EX-99.(A)(5)(D) 3 dex99a5d.htm VALUATION REPORT AS PER CVM INSTRUCTION 361 Valuation Report as per CVM Instruction 361

Exhibit (a)(5)(D)

LOGO


Contents

Important Note

 

I.    Executive Summary    7
II.    Appraiser Qualifications and Declarations    13
III.    Information from Telemig Celular    20
IV.    Valuation of Telemig preferred Shares    26
  

I.      Volume Weighted Average Share Price

  
  

II.     Equity Share Values

  
  

III.   Economic Value by Market Multiples

  
  

IV.   Premium Value of Similar Public Share Offers

  
V.    Conclusion    32
VI.    Annexes    34

 

LOGO   -2-


Important Notice

1. BES Investimento do Brasil S.A - Banco de Investimento (hereinafter “BESI” ) was engaged by Vivo Participações S.A. (hereinafter the “Company”) to draw up this economic and financial valuation Report (hereinafter the “valuation Report”), for a Voluntary Public Tender Offer for the Purchase of the preferred Shares issued by Telemig Celular Participações S.A. (hereinafter “Telemig Participações”) and Telemig Celular S.A. (hereinafter “Telemig Celular” and, jointly with Telemig Participações, “Telemig”) (hereinafter the “VTO” ), to be undertaken by the Company pursuant to Instruction 361 of the Brazilian Exchange Commission (hereinafter “CVM”), dated March 5, 2002, as altered (hereinafter “CVM Instruction 361”).

2. The Valuation Report is the intellectual property of BESI and was drawn up by BESI to comply with the provisions of Articles 8 and 31 of CVM Instruction 361.

3. The Valuation Report must not be used for any purposes other than those related to the VTO.

4. BESI has not made, and will not make, any recommendations nor express any explicit or implicit opinion to Telemig shareholders, it being the sole and exclusive decision of the latter to accept or not accept the VTO.

5. The Valuation Report does not represent a judgment, opinion or recommendation to the Company’s management, its shareholders or any third party (including, but without being limited to, investors who decide to participate in the VTO) as to the convenience and opportunity of undertaking the VTO, which shall remain at the exclusive discretion of the Company’s management, not does it intend to support any investment decision. BESI is not advising Telemig shareholders as to the VTO. All shareholders should conduct their own analyses of the VTO.

 

LOGO   -3-


Important Notice (continued)

 

6. The reference date used for the Valuation Report is August 2, 2007, date of the material fact of the announcement of acquisition of control of Telemig and, among other facts, of the VTO.

7. When preparing this Valuation Report, BESI considered, among others, the following Telemig information: (i) Telemig Audited Financial Statements for the fiscal year ended on December 31, 2007 (ii) historical record of market share prices of Telemig preferred shares. BESI considered further other information, financial studies, analyses and research, and financial, economic, monetary and market criteria regarded as relevant, as well as public information on Telemig’s sphere of operation and on macroeconomic parameters where Telemig is notably present.

8. This Valuation Report has not considered previous Telemig valuations or securities issued by these companies made public up to this date, within the context of past operations, offers and negotiations involving Telemig.

9. The drawing up of economic-financial valuations is a complex task involving subjective judgments and is not susceptible to a partial analysis or summarized description. BESI has not placed specific importance on any of the factors considered individually in the Valuation Report. On the contrary, it undertook a qualitative analysis on the importance and relevance of all factors considered herein. Thus, the Valuation Report should be analyzed as a whole, since an analysis of selected parts, summaries or specific aspects of the Valuation Report, without full knowledge and analysis of the Valuation Report in its totality, may result in an incomplete and incorrect understanding of the analysis undertaken by BESI, and of the conclusions contained in the Valuation Report. The results submitted herein envisage the compliance by the Company with the provisions of Articles 8 and 31 of CVM Instruction 361, within the scope of the VTO, not extending beyond any other issues or transactions, present or future, in relation to Telemig and the economic group of which these companies are part, or to their sphere of activity.

 

LOGO   -4-


Important Notice (continued)

 

10. BESI has assumed and relied, with the express consent of the Company and without any independent confirmation, on the content, exactness, veracity, integrity, consistency, sufficiency, completeness and precision of all financial, accounting, legal, and fiscal information and other information analyzed by BESI or discussed with BESI, made publicly available by Telemig. BESI has not undertaken (i) any valuation of Telemig assets and liabilities (contingent or not); (ii) review or audit of Telemig financial statements; (iii) technical audit of Telemig operations; (iv) valuation of the solvency or fair value of Telemig, in accordance with any law related to bankruptcy, insolvency or similar issues; or (v) any physical inspection of Telemig properties, facilities or assets. BESI does not assume any responsibility whatsoever in relation to the verification of the content, exactness, veracity, integrity, consistency, sufficiency, completeness and precision of such information.

11. BESI is not responsible for direct or indirect losses or loss of profits that may result from the use of the valuation Report.

12. Except when another date is expressly specified, the valuation Report reflects Telemig’s financial and accounting conditions, as per available information up to April 3, 2008, so that any alteration in such conditions and information after this date may alter the results presented herein. BESI is not obliged, at any time, to update, review, correct or reaffirm any information contained in the valuation Report, or to furnish any additional information related to the valuation Report. When preparing the valuation Report, BESI was not authorized by the Company or its Board of Directors to request, nor has it requested, information of interest to third parties regarding a total or partial acquisition of Telemig shares. Consequently, the results determined in the valuation Report are not necessarily, nor should they be inferred as, representative of effective Telemig sale prices to third parties, for which these companies may be negotiated now or at a future date.

 

LOGO   -5-


Important Note (continued)

 

13. Other company and sector valuations, also undertaken by BESI, may adopt different approaches on market assumptions than those adopted in the valuation Report, so that the BESI research department, and other departments and affiliated companies, may use in their analyses different Report and publications, estimates, projections and methodologies from those used in the valuation Report; any such analyses, reports and publications may contain different conclusions from those described in the valuation Report.

14. BESI was engaged by the Company and, independently of the VTO, will be remunerated for the services rendered.

15. BESI has provided, either directly or through affiliated companies, certain financial and investment banking services to the Company, as well as to its respective parent companies, for which it received remuneration, continues to provide them and may, at any time, provide them again. BESI, either directly or through affiliated companies is, or may become, a creditor of the Company, of Telemig, as well as of any of its respective parent companies in certain financial operations, and may also increase or decrease the volume of its financial operations with these corporations.

16. In the normal course of its activities, BESI may, either directly or through affiliated companies, negotiate securities of the Company or of Telemig, as well as of their respective parent companies, in its own name or in that of its clients and, consequently, may, at any time, be long or short of these securities.

17. BESI declares that there is no conflict of interests that would impair its impartiality of judgment, required for the performance of its duties in relation to the drawing up of the valuation Report.

18. The valuation Report was drawn up solely in Portuguese and, should it be translated into any other language, the Portuguese version shall always prevail.

 

/s/ Juliana Arruda

     

/s/Bruno Guapo Garção

Juliana Arruda       Bruno Guapo Garção
Vice-President       Associate

 

LOGO   -6-


LOGO


Object and Scope of the Analysis

 

 

On August 2, 2007, Vivo Participações S.A announced that it had signed, a stock purchase agreement with Telpart Participações S.A., to acquire control of Telemig.

 

 

In addition to the announcement for the acquisition of the controlling interest and of the subsequent mandatory public offerings of ordinary shares of Telemig, Vivo also announced, on the same date, their intention of making voluntary public tender offers of up to  1/3 of each class of preferred shares in circulation of Telemig Participações and Telemig Celular that it did not already own at a premium of 25% over the weighted average of the last 30 trading days, up to August 1, 2007. The price offered in Telemig Participações voluntary public offer is R$ 63,90 and in Telemig Celular voluntary public offer is R$ 654,72.

 

 

Following the above mentioned transaction, BESI was engaged by Vivo Participações S.A. to draw up this economic and financial valuation Report for the purpose of a Voluntary Public Tender Offer of preferred Shares Issued by Telemig Participações and Telemig Celular, to be effected by the Company.

 

 

Pursuant to CVM Instruction 361, BESI conducted the analyses of the following methodologies:

– Volume Weighted Average Share Price for the last twelve months prior to August 1, 2007;

– Net book value per share, calculated in accordance with Telemig Audited Financial Statements for the fiscal year ended on December 31, 2007 and reviewed by Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu;

– Economic value, based on market value multiples of comparable companies to those analyzed;

– Premium offered in similar transactions occurring since 2001, calculated through the mean and median premiums offered in public offerings of preferred shares on the weighted average price of the shares, considering 30 trading days prior to the announcement of the respective VTO;

 

 

Among the methodologies used, BESI concluded that the most adequate is that of the premium offered in comparable transactions, as it reflects the parameters used in the market to price the benefit to be extended by the controlling company to holders of preferred shares in similar voluntary tender offers.

 

LOGO   -8-


Object and Scope of the Analysis

 

 

Different methodologies have, among others, the following limitations that preclude their application in this offer up to  1/3 of the preferred shares in circulation not owned by the company:

– The methodology of weighted averages over the last 12 months tends to flatten the value of the company, not reflecting recent events, whether positive or negative, immediately before the offer and, in this way potentially omitting relevant developments.

– Book value per share is not a satisfactory indicator for this valuation Report, as the net equity value follows accounting rules that may not reflect the market value of shares, in the extent that it is tied to past events and performance of the companies, and does not embody expectations of future performances to be appraised.

– Economic value calculated through market multiples is not an adequate alternative, since the sample available in the Brazilian market is scarce. Only the shares of Vivo Participações S.A., TIM Participações S.A., Tele Norte Celular Participações and Amazônia Celular can be used for a market multiples analysis.

– The economic value obtained through discounted cash flow methodology is not applicable in the case of voluntary public offerings of preferred shares, as the value obtained through such method implies an effective control of the company, something that does not occur with holders of preferred shares who do not have voting rights and, as such, no control over the cash flows that are the object of the valuation Report.

 

LOGO   -9-


Methodology Applied

 

 

BESI appraised the preferred shares of the following companies: (i) Telemig Celular Participações S.A., and (ii) Telemig Celular S.A., applying the methodologies described in the table below.

 

 

In the case of Telemig Celular S.A., we used the preferred share with greater liquidity among the classes in circulation (see annex A Liquidity Analysis of preferred Shares).

 

 

The quantities considered in the analyses presented in this document were those existing after the date of the announcement of the VTO, August 2, 2007, and contemplate the reverse split that occurred later.

 

 

The respective sources of information, concepts used and detailing of the calculations of EBITDA and Net Debt used in the analysis are shown in the Annex. The same applies to the share price and volumes traded.

 

METHODOLOGY

 

DESCRIPTION

Volume Weighted Average Share Price  

•       The closing price of each share was weighted according to the daily financial volume traded over the period.

 

•       The period considered was 12 months prior to disclosure of the material fact regarding the VTO, i.e., from August 2, 2006 to August 2, 2007.

 
Book Value per share  

•       Obtained by dividing the respective company’s net equity, determined in the Financial Statements for the fiscal year ended on December 31, 2007, by the number of shares after the reverse split on August 14, 2007.

Market Multiples of Comparable Companies  

•       Comparable companies listed on the São Paulo Stock Exchange and components of the IBOVESPA Index (Vivo, Tim, Tele Norte Celular Participações and Amazônia Celular) were used to obtain the multiples.

 

•       We calculated the ratio between the Enterprise Value of these companies weighted solely by preferred shares based on an average market value of thirty working days prior to the announcement of the VTO (from June 20 to August 1, 2007) and their respective EBITDA’s 2007, and the net debt as per the Financial Statements for the fiscal year ended on December 31, 2007.

 

•       In the case of Telemig Participações, calculations of EBITDA and Net Debt are weighted according to its interest in Telemig Celular. Multiples obtained were applied to the Company under analysis for the establishment of the value.

 
Comparison with Voluntary Tender Offers.  

•       The comparable transactions considered were the public offerings for acquisition of preferred shares in Brazil, since 2001. The only offers considered were those in which the preferred shares showed relative liquidity prior to the respective public offerings. Because of sampling limitations, comparisons were based on offers for 100% of preferred shares and not only offers for  1/3 of the preferred float.

 

•       For each of the comparable transactions, the calculations were based on the premiums offered by buyers in relation to market share price considering an average of thirty trading days prior to the announcement of the respective public offerings.

 

•       The resulting premiums were applied to the Telemig preferred shares appraised herein, considering the average share price, weighted by volume, over the thirty trading days prior to the announcement.

 
 

 

LOGO   -10-


Selected Methodology

 

 

Premium offered in public offers of preferred shares

 

Date of

Announcement

  

Company¹

   Share Class    Premium Offered on Volume
Weighted Average Share Price²
 

31-ago-06

   Fertibras    PN    39,9 %

9-mai-06

   Embratel    PN    31,7 %

9-nov-04

   Cosipa    PN    25,5 %

8-nov-04

   Seara    PN    14,8 %

25-ago-04

   CRT Celular    PN    19,7 %
  

Tele Centro Oeste Celular Participações

   PN    20,2 %
  

Tele Leste Celular Participações

   PN    20,8 %
  

Tele Sudeste Celular Participações

   PN    19,7 %

29-abr-04

   Bunge    PN    10,6 %

16-mar-01

   Bompreço    PN    35,2 %
        

Mean

             23,80 %

Median

         20,50 %
                  

Notes

 

1. Voluntary offers and ‘going-private’ offers announced since 2001, excluding low-liquidity companies.
2. Prior period to the announcement of Public Offerings

 

LOGO

  -11-


Analysis Results - Telemig

 

 

For Telemig Participações preferred shares, the selected value range is from R$ 61.64 to R$ 63.32 per share that, converted to values prior to the reverse split on August 14, 2007, would be within the interval ranging from R$ 6.16 to R$ 6.33 per lot of one thousand shares.

 

 

For Telemig Celular preferred shares, the selected value range is from R$ 631.15 to R$ 648.43 per share.

LOGO

Note:

 

1– Number of shares contemplates reverse split which occurred after the announcement of the Voluntary Tender Offer.
2– The value of Telemig Celular obtained through the use of market multiples based on EBITDA 2007 is not significant as the four companies sample includes three holding companies which historically trade at a premium to the operating companies due to the low liquidity of the latter. Therefore, the use of the average multiple obtained through this sample overestimates the true value of Telemig Celular.

 

LOGO   -12-


LOGO

 


Appraiser Qualifications

BES Investimento do Brasil S.A - Banco de Investimento (hereinafter “BESI” ) is part of the Espírito Santo Group, one of the largest financial groups in Portugal, present in Europe, the Americas, Africa and Asia. In the financial segment, the Espírito Santo Group is involved in commercial and investment banking activities, leasing, consumer credit, real estate credit, shares brokerage, private equity, venture capital and fund management. In Brazil, the Espírito Santo Group started its activities in 1975 with total investments in the country already exceeding € 1.8 billion

BESI is an investment bank basically focused on services related to financial consultancy in (i) corporate finance in the following operations: mergers & acquisitions, privatizations, corporate valuations, restructuring, going private and going public from the structuring and economic/financial valuation through to the conclusion of the operation; and (ii) domestic and international capital markets in: issue and primary and secondary distribution of bonds and securities; syndicated loans and finance structuring, as well as other products and services inherent to investment banking activities.

BESI also has a wholly owned subsidiary (BES Securities do Brasil S.A. – Corretora de Câmbio e Valores Mobiliários) which operates in Stock Markets and Futures and Commodities Markets, and in the preparation of equity research reports.

BESI’s Corporate Finance area is responsible for drawing up this valuation Report. The Corporate Finance area comprises eight fully qualified professionals, with the support of its global Corporate Finance area through sectorial teams in Portugal, Spain and London.

 

LOGO   -14-


Appraiser Qualifications

The Corporate Finance area of BESI has recently undertaken valuations of major listed companies, among which

 

   

Banco Mercantil do Brasil in August 2005;

 

   

PrimeSys – Soluções Empresariais S/A in September 2005;

 

   

Tele Centro Oeste Celular Participações S.A. (valuation Report filed with CVM on August 11, 2003);

 

   

Prevê Prédios S.A. (valuation Report filed with CVM on August 20, 2002);

 

   

Banco Mercantil de São Paulo S.A. (valuation Report filed with CVM on August 20, 2002);

 

   

Telesp Celular Participações in November 1999.

Additionally, the Corporate Finance area of BESI conducted various operations over the last few years undertaking company valuations. Some of these processes are detailed in the next slide: “Recent selected transactions involving company valuations”

 

LOGO   -15-


Recent Selected Transactions involving companys valuations —

BES Investimento do Brasil

LOGO

 

LOGO   -16-


Selected International Transactions — Espirito Santo Investment

LOGO

 

LOGO   -17-


Appraisers Qualifications

 

Name

  

Position

  

Summary Relevant Experience

Juliana Arruda

   Vice President   

•        9 years of experience in the M&A area having advised Icatu and Grupo José de Mello in sale of their stakes in Med-Lar, Societé General and Banco Mais in their acquisition of Banco Pecúnia and the sale of Grupo Espírito Santo stake in Shopping Villa-Lobos.

Bruno Guapo Garção

   Associate   

•        7 years experience in the M&A area, having advised Nutasa, S.G.P.S., in the sale of its Animal Feed Business to Saprogal/ The Carlyle Group, Espírito Santo Concessões in the valuation of several Motorway concessions in Portugal and Fábrica Têxtil Riopele, S.A. in the valuation of the business plan of Intermarcas, the owner of the Chocolate and LAB brands

 

LOGO   -18-


Appraiser Declarations

 

 

BESI, either directly or through its parent companies, subsidiaries or related individuals, does not own no shares issued by Telemig, whether in its own name or under its discretionary management;

 

 

BESI, either directly or through affiliated companies, provided certain financial and investment banking services to the Company, its Subsidiaries and Affiliates, as well as to its parent companies, for which it was remunerated, continues to provide these services and may, at any time, provide them again. In the normal course of its activities, BESI may come to negotiate, either directly or through affiliated companies, securities belonging to the Company, its parent companies, subsidiaries, affiliates, as well as Telemig, in its own name or on behalf of its clients and, consequently, may, at any time, hold long or short positions in relation to the aforementioned securities. Notwithstanding the relationship heretofore described, and except for the information herein provided, BESI has no other commercial information of any nature whatsoever regarding Telemig that may affect the valuation Report.

 

 

BESI affirms that the Company, its controlling shareholders and directors, have not conducted, interfered, limited, hampered or practiced any action whatsoever that compromised the access, use or knowledge of information, assets, documents or work methodologies relevant to the conclusions presented herein, nor have they determined or restricted the capacity of BESI to establish the methodologies applied to reach the conclusions provided in the valuation Report, or restricted BESI’s capacity of determining the conclusions presented in the valuation Report.

 

 

BESI has no conflict of interest with the Company, its controlling shareholders and directors, that demeans its necessary independence for the performance of its duties, as well as for the preparation of this valuation Report.

 

 

For the services provided regarding the valuation Report, independently of the conclusion of the Offer, BESI will receive 150.000 thousand reais (R$ 150.000) from the Offering Party.

 

 

Pursuant to what is provided under Article 8o, §6, of CVM Instruction 361, BESI declares that during the twelve (12) months prior to the date of valuation Report, it received from the Company, its subsidiaries and affiliates, as well as from its parent companies, a total amount of US$ 1.000.000, by way of remuneration for advisory, valuation Report and similar services rendered for this transaction. BESI will receive in the future an additional remuneration of US$ 1.000.000 for the advisory, valuation Report and similar services rendered for this transaction.

 

 

BESI also declares that it has not received from Telemig, its subsidiaries and affiliates, as well as from its parent companies any fees for advisory, auditing and similar services during the twelve (12) months prior to the date of the valuation report.

 

 

This valuation Report has undergone internal review and has been approved by the Executive Directors of the Corporate Finance Department and the Legal Department of BESI.

 

LOGO   -19-


LOGO

 


Brief Description of the Sector

 

 

•       There are currently approximately 3.3 billion cell phones worldwide, according to Wireless Intelligence research. At the end of 2007, there were 121 million cell phones in operation in Brazil, a growth of 21.12% over the previous year.

 

•       In terms of subscribers, the cellular telephony sector in Brazil is the 5th largest in the world, after China, United States, Japan and Russia, according to data released by Anatel (the Brazilian telecommunications regulatory agency).

 

•       From January to December 2007, a further 20.9 million subscribers were added to the client base, i.e., an increase of 21% to the number of active cell phones in Brazil. According to Anatel, the number of cell phones in Brazil exceeds 120 million this year, and the mobile telephony coverage is now available to 90.4% of the population.

 

Installed Wireless Base – mm

LOGO

 

 

 

 

 

 

Source: www.anatel.gov.br

  

Market Share – Wireless Sector (January 2008)

 

LOGO

 

Share – Available Technologies

(December 2007)

 

LOGO

 

LOGO   -21-


I. Telemig

 

Brief Description

 

•       Telemig Celular Participações S.A. controls the cellular telephony provider Telemig Celular S.A, established after the restructuring of the Telebrás System. Subsequent to the sale of the shares of the holding companies to the private sector, the majority of the voting shares was acquired by Telpart Participações S.A.

 

•       Telemig is the leading services operator for the cellular mobile telephony in the State of Minas Gerais, serving 86% of the population in the concession area in 2007.

 

•       The Company holds concession rights to operate mobile telephony in Region I, being the company with the largest share of post-paid clients in its region.

 

•       According to Telemig’s latest quarterly statement, the Company held a 29.1% market share in its region in December 2007.

   LOGO

 

Source: www.telemigcelular.com.br

 

LOGO   -22-


I. Telemig (continued)

 

LOGO

Source: www.telemigcelular.com.br

 

LOGO   -23-


I. Telemig (continued)

 

ARPU - R$

LOGO

Source: www.telemigcelular.com.br

 

LOGO   -24-


I. Telemig (continued)

 

LOGO
Soure: www.telemigcelular.com.br  

*  Net debt values reported by the Company. For concept and detailed calculation of net debt used in the present laudo, see Annex “C”. Detailed calculation of EBITDA and Net Debt”.

 

LOGO   -25-


LOGO

 


I. Volume Weighted Average Share Price - Telemig

 

 

Evolution of Average Share Price 12 months prior to VTO announcement (Aug/02/2006 to Aug/01/2007)

LOGO

 

     TMCP4    TMGC7

Pre Announcement of the offer

   Av. Volume
Quantity
   Average Weighted Price
(R$ / share)
   Av. Volume
Quantity
   Average Weighted Price
(R$ / share)

Daily Weighted Average last 30 days

   74.117    51,15    12,5    523,78

Daily Weighted Average last 6 months

   91.762    44,95    19,4    508,57

Daily Weighted Average last 12 months

   86.471    41,97    34,2    443,20

Source: Bloomberg

 

LOGO   -27-


I. Volume Weighted Average Share Price - Telemig

 

 

Evolution of Share Average Price since the material fact announcing the transaction up to Apr/04/2008

LOGO

 

     TMCP4    TMGC7

Pre Announcement of the offer

   Av. Volume
Quantity
   Average Weighted Price
(R$ / share)
   Av. Volume
Quantity
   Average Weighted Price
(R$ / share)

Daily Weighted Average from 08/02/07 to 04/04/08

   83.235    52,10    63,0    638,08

Source: Bloomberg

 

LOGO   -28-


II. Book Value per Share - Telemig

Telemig Participações

 

Book Value - December 31, 2007

    

Equity Value of Telemig Celular Participações as of December 31, 2007 (in million R$)

   1.230

Number of Shares (millions)

   36,21

Equity Value of Telemig Celular Participações (R$ / share)

   33,97

LOGO

The Book Value per share of Telemig Celular Participações based on the Balance Sheet as of December 31,

2007 corresponds to R$ 33.97 per share.

Telemig Celular

 

Book Value - December 31, 2007

    

Equity Value of Telemig Celular as of December 31, 2007 (in million R$)

   1.071

Number of Shares (millions)

   2,372

Equity Value of Telemig Celular (R$ / share)

   451,31

LOGO

The Book Value per share of Telemig Celular based on the Balance Sheet as of December 31, 2007

corresponds to R$ 451.31 per share

Source: CVM

 

LOGO   -29-


III. Economic Value of the Company per Market Multiples - Telemig¹

 

 

The economic value of Telemig Participações preferred shares obtained through the use of EBITDA² multiples is R$ 52.18 per share.

 

 

The economic value of Telemig Celular preferred shares obtained through the use of EBITDA² multiples is R$ 810.17 per share.

 

     Multiples    Equity Value R$ mm³    Price per share R$
     EV / EBITDA    EV / EBITDA    EV / EBITDA

Telemig Participações

   3,94x    1.889    52,18

Telemig Celular

   3,94x    1.922    810,17

Notes:

 

1. See Annex “B. Calculation of multiples used in the valuation Report” for further details
2. EBITDA 2007 is explained in Annexes “C. Detailed calculation of EBITDA and Net Debt” and “D. Glossary”
3. The concept of Company Value and Equity Value is explained in Annex “D. Glossary”
* The value of Telemig Celular obtained through the use of market multiples based on EBITDA 2007 is not significant as the four companies sample includes three holding companies which historically trade at a premium to the operating companies due to the low liquidity of the latter. Therefore, the use of the average multiple obtained through this sample overestimates the true value of Telemig Celular.

Source: CVM - ITR and Bloomberg

 

LOGO   -30-


IV. Premium values of similar public offerings—Telemig

 

 

The median and mean of the premium offered for preferred shares in similar transactions that occurred since 2001 were 20.5% and 23.8%, respectively:

 

LOGO       LOGO   

•        Applying the mean and median of the premium, the value range of Telemig Participações preferred shares is R$ 61.64 to R$ 63.32 per share.

  

•        Applying the mean and median of the premium, the value range of Telemig Celular preferred shares is R$ 631.15 to R$ 648.43 per share.

Notes:

 

1. Premium applied on weighted average price between June 21, 2007 and August 1, 2007 (30 trading days after the announcement of the VTO)
Source: Economática and Bloomberg

 

LOGO   -31-


LOGO


Analysis Results—Telemig

 

 

For Telemig Participações preferred shares, the selected value range is from R$ 61.64 to R$ 63.32 per share that, converted to values prior to the reverse split on August 14, 2007, would be within the interval ranging from R$ 6.16 to R$ 6.33 per lot of one thousand shares.

 

 

For Telemig Celular preferred shares, the selected value range is from R$ 631.15 to R$ 648.43 per share.

LOGO

Note:

 

1 –   Number of shares contemplates reverse split which occurred after the announcement of the Voluntary Tender Offer.
2 –   The value of Telemig Celular obtained through the use of market multiples based on EBITDA 2007 is not significant as the four companies sample includes three holding companies which historically trade at a premium to the operating companies due to the low liquidity of the latter. Therefore, the use of the average multiple obtained through this sample overestimates the true value of Telemig Celular.

 

LOGO   -33-


LOGO


A. Liquidity Analysis of preferred Shares

 

 

In order to determine the most liquid class of preferred share of Telemig Celular, we analyzed the volume of business in terms of quantity of traded shares over the last 30 trading days, prior to the announcement of the VTO, i.e., from June 20, 2007 to August 1, 2007.

Telemig Celular

 

Telemig Celular

       Volume

    TMGC6

        0 

  TMGC7  

      125

    TMGC8  

        0 

    TMGC11

      49 

    TMGC12

        1 

    TMGC13

    105 

 

 

The most liquid share of Telemig Celular S.A during the period analyzed was TMGC7.

Source: Bloomberg

 

LOGO   -35-


B. Calculation of Multiples Used in the Valuation Report

 

 

In order to calculate the enterprise value of comparable companies, we calculated the respective average market values of preferred shares only, over the last 30 trading days prior to the date of announcement of the VTO (June 20, 2007 to August 1, 2007), adding the net debt as of December 31, 2007 to the value obtained. These enterprise values implied a range of EBITDA multiples.

 

 

To obtain the Equity Value of Telemig, we applied the average EBITDA multiple of the companies included in the sample to the Telemig EBITDA 2007 and deducted the net cash.

 

                          Múltiples

(R$ millions)

   Market Cap - Average last
30 trading days¹
   Net Debt
31/12/07²
   EV    EBITDA 07³     EV / EBITDA

Vivo Participações S.A.

   13.564    2.661    16.225    3.133     5,18x

TIM Participações S.A.

   15.799    1.213    17.012    2.870     5,93x

Tele Norte Celular Participações

   173    125    298    109     2,72x

Amazônia Celular

   108    172    280    146     1,92x
                         

Average

              3,94x
               
     Data of companies appraised      

(R$ millions)

   EBITDA 07³    EV / EBITDA    Implied EV    Net Debt
31/12/07²
    Implied Equity Value

Telemig Participações

   377    3,94x    1.486    (403 )   1.889

Telemig Celular

   453    3,94x    1.785    (136 )   1.922

Obs: During the period, instead of net debt, both Telemig Celular and Telemig Participações showed net cash, for which reason values are negative.

Notes:

 

1. Average Market Cap from the last 30 trading days from the announcement of the Material Fact (August, 02 - 2007). Calculated by multiplying the daily preferred share mid-price by the total amount of shares.
2. For concept and detailed calculation of net debt see Annex “C” . Detailed calculation of EBITDA and Net Debt”
3. EBITDA 2007 of Telemig Participações is proportional to its 83,25% participation held on the operational company.

Source: CVM – ITR and Bloomberg

 

LOGO   -36-


C. Detail Calculation of EBITDA and Net Debt

Net Debt Consolidated – 31/12/07 – R$ millions

 

    Vivo   TIM   Telemig
Participações
Consolidated
    Telemig
Participações
Alone
    Telemig
Celular
    Telemig
Participações
Proportional
    Tele Norte
Celular
Consolidated
  Tele Norte
Celular
Alone
    Amazônia   Tele Norte Part.
Proportional

(-) Cash, Cash Equivalents

  2.191   1.173   731     294     437     657     45   15     30   37

Cash, Cash Equivalents

  2.191   1.173   731     294     437     657     45   15     30   37
Debt   4.852   2.385   305     4     301     255     213   11     202   162

Short and Long Term Debt

  4.381   2.146   148     0     148     123     152   5     147   115

Hedge Operations

  448   0   92     0     92     76     53   3     51   41

Interest

  0   0   6     0     6     5     5   0     5   3

Dividends

  22   240   49     47     1     49     3   3     0   3

Interest on Capital

  0   0   11     (43 )   54     2     0   0     0   0
                                                 

Net Debt / (Net Cash)

  2.661   1.213   (426 )   (289 )   (136 )   (403 )   168   (4 )   172   125
                                                 

Obs: During the period, instead of net debt both Telemig Celular and Telemig Participações showed net cash, for which reason values are negative. Telemig’s Participações values result from its 83,25% participation held in the Telemig Celular. Tele Norte Participações values result from its 74,96% participation held in Amazonia Celular.

EBITDA 2007 – R$ milions

 

EBITDA

Vivo

   3.133

TIM

   2.870

Tele Norte Participações

   109

Amazônia Celular

   146

Telemig Participações

   377

Telemig Celular

   453

Obs: Telemig’s Participações values result from its 83,25% participation held in the Telemig Celular. Tele Norte Participações values result from its 74,96% participation held in Amazonia Celular.

Source: CVM – ITR

 

LOGO   -37-


D. Glossary

 

•        Net Debt

   Net Debt value was calculated by adding Loans and Financing, Debentures, Pension Fund Deficit, Net Balance of asset and liabilities operations with Derivatives, and deducting Cash and Banks

•        EBITDA

   “Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization” is the operating “cash” profit of the company.

•        VTO

   Voluntary Tender Offer

•        Company Value

   Company Value is calculated by adding market value (product between market price of shares and number of company shares) to net debt, or subtracting from net cash.

•        Equity Value

   Company value deducted from net debt

 

LOGO   -38-


E. Historical Prices and Volume Traded - TMCP4

 

TMCP4 BZ Equity

  

TMCP4 BZ Equity

  

TMCP4 BZ Equity

  

TMCP4 BZ Equity

Date

   Px Last    Px Volume   

Date

   Px Last    Px Volume   

Date

   Px Last    Px Volume   

Date

   Px Last    Px Volume

4/4/2007

   53,6    44.200    1/14/2008    50,74    24.100    10/18/2007    52,5    75.200    7/31/2007    54,9    113.910

4/3/2008

   53    79.600    1/11/2008    50,7    21.700    10/17/2007    53,5    489.600    7/30/2007    52,4    97.830

4/2/2008

   50,9    183.200    1/10/2008    51,68    27.500    10/16/2007    50,85    44.900    7/27/2007    48,4    90.690

4/1/2008

   51    345.400    1/9/2008    50,5    80.000    10/15/2007    51    88.300    7/26/2007    47,7    134.390

3/31/2008

   50,2    44.000    1/8/2008    48,5    52.800    10/11/2007    52,49    50.700    7/25/2007    49,6    129.690

3/28/2008

   51    38.000    1/7/2008    48,5    46.800    10/10/2007    52,54    21.700    7/24/2007    50,6    115.000

3/27/2008

   51,1    108.500    1/4/2008    49,1    53.300    10/9/2007    52,59    47.900    7/23/2007    51,9    47.420

3/26/2008

   50,7    25.700    1/3/2008    49,65    34.400    10/8/2007    52,57    21.400    7/20/2007    51,1    54.570

3/25/2008

   50,9    74.100    1/2/2008    50,1    43.200    10/5/2007    52,57    99.200    7/19/2007    52    68.410

3/24/2008

   51,6    32.500    12/28/2007    48,51    93.000    10/4/2007    52,5    60.800    7/18/2007    52,3    64.410

3/20/2008

   50,99    98.800    12/27/2007    50    47.000    10/3/2007    52,4    67.500    7/17/2007    52,6    60.720

3/19/2008

   51    48.900    12/26/2007    48,99    46.600    10/2/2007    52,5    91.400    7/16/2007    52,6    71.900

3/18/2008

   52,25    97.100    12/21/2007    49,49    77.600    10/1/2007    54    49.500    7/13/2007    53,1    61.090

3/17/2008

   51,52    40.800    12/20/2007    46,75    53.300    9/28/2007    53,66    22.400    7/12/2007    53,4    90.790

3/14/2008

   52,2    37.800    12/19/2007    47,12    127.500    9/27/2007    54    66.800    7/11/2007    53,3    117.140

3/13/2008

   52,8    199.500    12/18/2007    46,9    118.400    9/26/2007    54,14    26.900    7/10/2007    53,5    82.970

3/12/2008

   53    180.700    12/17/2007    47,01    96.800    9/25/2007    53,45    51.000    7/6/2007    53,1    88.820

3/11/2008

   52,8    39.800    12/14/2007    48,4    28.100    9/24/2007    54,57    32.200    7/5/2007    51,6    104.100

3/10/2008

   52,68    28.300    12/13/2007    48,5    87.900    9/21/2007    54,12    41.800    7/4/2007    49,9    26.470

3/7/2008

   52,2    62.000    12/12/2007    49,05    121.200    9/20/2007    54    94.600    7/3/2007    50,1    21.480

3/6/2008

   52,6    195.900    12/11/2007    49,28    98.700    9/19/2007    53,5    45.900    7/2/2007    50    33.260

3/5/2008

   53,53    54.000    12/10/2007    49,43    59.800    9/18/2007    53,5    98.800    6/29/2007    48,7    58.960

3/4/2008

   53,69    38.100    12/7/2007    48,91    133.600    9/17/2007    53    68.400    6/28/2007    49,3    36.500

3/3/2008

   53    233.900    12/6/2007    49,5    54.200    9/14/2007    55    26.900    6/27/2007    49,5    33.670

2/29/2008

   52,5    32.800    12/5/2007    49,56    39.400    9/13/2007    55,7    11.200    6/26/2007    48,8    30.270

2/28/2008

   53,15    43.300    12/4/2007    50,23    30.300    9/12/2007    55,19    38.500    6/25/2007    48    55.330

2/27/2008

   52,98    49.100    12/3/2007    49,75    37.800    9/11/2007    56,8    17.200    6/22/2007    48,7    48.050

2/26/2008

   52,95    73.100    11/30/2007    50    65.600    9/10/2007    55,8    21.300    6/21/2007    49,6    49.000

2/25/2008

   52,59    163.400    11/29/2007    49,54    152.900    9/6/2007    57    29.500    6/20/2007    49    118.940

2/22/2008

   51,8    36.200    11/28/2007    49,5    67.700    9/5/2007    57    149.800    6/19/2007    48,9    76.910

2/21/2008

   51,39    52.000    11/27/2007    49,98    25.100    9/4/2007    57,5    88.600    6/18/2007    49,7    63.330

2/20/2008

   51,2    54.500    11/26/2007    49    65.300    9/3/2007    57,9    27.600    6/15/2007    49,2    133.940

2/19/2008

   50,5    81.400    11/23/2007    50,9    41.500    8/31/2007    58    272.800    6/14/2007    49,7    44.020

2/18/2008

   52    12.900    11/22/2007    49,99    11.000    8/30/2007    56,22    129.600    6/13/2007    49,1    278.250

2/15/2008

   51    17.900    11/21/2007    49,75    57.200    8/29/2007    55,7    90.700    6/12/2007    46,7    100.710

2/14/2008

   52,22    40.100    11/19/2007    51,2    31.800    8/28/2007    55,5    159.600    6/11/2007    48,9    83.180

2/13/2008

   52,92    147.800    11/16/2007    50,8    77.000    8/27/2007    55,5    81.200    6/8/2007    48,1    104.360

2/12/2008

   50,6    71.300    11/14/2007    52    169.400    8/24/2007    55,25    61.900    6/6/2007    46,2    140.400

2/11/2008

   50,4    133.000    11/13/2007    49,88    61.200    8/23/2007    57,5    76.600    6/5/2007    46,8    73.930

2/8/2008

   49,8    45.700    11/12/2007    50,99    33.600    8/22/2007    54,9    114.900    6/4/2007    47,8    73.070

2/7/2008

   50,2    136.500    11/9/2007    50    94.000    8/21/2007    53,29    85.200    6/1/2007    48,5    280.180

2/6/2008

   50    125.900    11/8/2007    50,15    65.900    8/20/2007    51,5    62.600    5/31/2007    47,3    501.470

2/1/2008

   52,96    205.100    11/7/2007    53,3    47.800    8/17/2007    52,25    116.700    5/30/2007    48,8    208.650

1/31/2008

   51,01    26.800    11/6/2007    53,93    23.200    8/16/2007    52,1    171.000    5/29/2007    49,5    134.290

1/30/2008

   50,64    48.400    11/5/2007    53,1    69.000    8/15/2007    51,5    473.400    5/28/2007    49,6    31.740

1/29/2008

   49,8    34.600    11/1/2007    53,3    38.000    8/14/2007    50,2    102.200    5/25/2007    49    228.840

1/28/2008

   51    71.300    10/31/2007    53,4    45.200    8/13/2007    51,3    92.620    5/24/2007    47    134.980

1/24/2008

   48,7    54.300    10/30/2007    54,3    90.100    8/10/2007    52    127.650    5/23/2007    49    200.340

1/23/2008

   48,8    78.100    10/29/2007    53,5    40.700    8/9/2007    52,8    145.680    5/22/2007    47    83.310

1/22/2008

   49,89    84.800    10/26/2007    54    42.700    8/8/2007    54,5    191.710    5/21/2007    47    109.120

1/21/2008

   48,2    51.300    10/25/2007    54    104.300    8/7/2007    53,6    85.320    5/18/2007    46,2    41.550

1/18/2008

   49,5    68.600    10/24/2007    53,51    54.900    8/6/2007    54,4    174.460    5/17/2007    47    34.230

1/17/2008

   50,5    72.800    10/23/2007    53,3    219.900    8/3/2007    52,4    265.770    5/16/2007    47    80.110

1/16/2008

   50,85    93.900    10/22/2007    52,61    75.400    8/2/2007    53    150.700    5/15/2007    46,4    70.060

1/15/2008

   50,63    41.400    10/19/2007    52,78    66.200    8/1/2007    52,3    117.720    5/14/2007    46    48.490

TMCP4 BZ Equity

  

TMCP4 BZ Equity

  

TMCP4 BZ Equity

  

TMCP4 BZ Equity

Date

   Px Last    Px Volume   

Date

   Px Last    Px Volume   

Date

   Px Last    Px Volume   

Date

   Px Last    Px Volume

5/11/2007

   46,3    76.770    2/21/2007    42,4    121.350    11/28/2006    39,6    66.080    9/5/2006    37    58.870

5/10/2007

   45,2    96.010    2/16/2007    39,5    96.210    11/27/2006    39    113.220    9/4/2006    36,2    54.060

5/9/2007

   44,5    79.970    2/15/2007    39,6    71.920    11/24/2006    41    67.570    9/1/2006    36,8    100.070

5/8/2007

   44,6    25.750    2/14/2007    39,8    250.920    11/23/2006    40    82.860    8/31/2006    35,5    252.670

5/7/2007

   45,9    28.410    2/13/2007    38,9    48.250    11/22/2006    41    125.030    8/30/2006    36    101.020

5/4/2007

   46,3    30.840    2/12/2007    38,1    40.020    11/21/2006    42    67.130    8/29/2006    33,5    30.100

5/3/2007

   46,2    39.690    2/9/2007    38,4    48.300    11/17/2006    42    49.730    8/28/2006    33,6    102.970

5/2/2007

   46,1    65.490    2/8/2007    39    38.000    11/16/2006    42    82.690    8/25/2006    32    94.220

4/30/2007

   44,9    127.820    2/7/2007    38,8    71.030    11/14/2006    42    118.920    8/24/2006    32,1    96.410

4/27/2007

   44,5    59.610    2/6/2007    39,2    35.440    11/13/2006    40    114.520    8/23/2006    33,1    111.370

4/26/2007

   44,8    77.080    2/5/2007    39,9    16.920    11/10/2006    40    197.910    8/22/2006    34,3    67.610

4/25/2007

   46,7    126.940    2/2/2007    39,7    42.640    11/9/2006    39    254.650    8/21/2006    35    44.220

4/24/2007

   44,1    44.230    2/1/2007    39,4    41.380    11/8/2006    40    110.640    8/18/2006    35,9    46.020

4/23/2007

   44    46.390    1/31/2007    40,2    57.590    11/7/2006    40    156.300    8/17/2006    35,9    80.140

4/20/2007

   44,5    113.180    1/30/2007    39,2    69.190    11/6/2006    39    222.980    8/16/2006    36    304.320

4/19/2007

   43,5    91.840    1/29/2007    38,8    49.680    11/3/2006    38    223.920    8/15/2006    36    76.530

4/18/2007

   42,6    125.390    1/26/2007    39    35.230    11/1/2006    37    106.170    8/14/2006    35,1    47.310

4/17/2007

   42,8    76.790    1/24/2007    40,3    45.870    10/31/2006    37    111.230    8/11/2006    34,9    50.940

4/16/2007

   42,5    126.450    1/23/2007    40,3    49.450    10/30/2006    37    43.690    8/10/2006    36,5    21.340

4/13/2007

   41,8    129.710    1/22/2007    40    37.460    10/27/2006    37    45.160    8/9/2006    36,5    35.760

4/12/2007

   41,1    106.810    1/19/2007    40,1    40.340    10/26/2006    38    54.000    8/8/2006    36,6    39.300

4/11/2007

   40,8    92.580    1/18/2007    39,6    60.510    10/25/2006    38    57.050    8/7/2006    36,2    17.880

4/10/2007

   40,3    183.500    1/17/2007    38,7    24.040    10/24/2006    38    57.550    8/4/2006    36,7    30.010

4/9/2007

   39,9    61.300    1/16/2007    38,5    33.580    10/23/2006    39    78.840    8/3/2006    36    38.500

4/5/2007

   39,5    36.160    1/15/2007    39,2    32.240    10/20/2006    37    43.660    8/2/2006    35,2    67.070

4/4/2007

   39    38.250    1/12/2007    39,6    52.200    10/19/2006    38    69.500    8/1/2006    35,3    88.960

4/3/2007

   39,3    97.090    1/11/2007    39,3    83.740    10/18/2006    38    198.950         

4/2/2007

   38,3    36.420    1/10/2007    38,5    110.850    10/17/2006    39    69.820         

3/30/2007

   38,9    71.030    1/9/2007    36,6    71.760    10/16/2006    40    36.230         

3/29/2007

   38,3    68.110    1/8/2007    37    107.990    10/13/2006    39    68.040         

3/28/2007

   37,7    88.200    1/5/2007    37,1    156.860    10/11/2006    39    40.940         

3/27/2007

   38,2    48.020    1/4/2007    39,5    127.870    10/10/2006    40    128.210         

3/26/2007

   38,2    62.490    1/3/2007    39,4    98.800    10/9/2006    41    123.990         

3/23/2007

   39,2    27.180    1/2/2007    40,6    48.050    10/6/2006    40    61.060         

3/22/2007

   39,5    107.560    12/28/2006    40,5    50.600    10/5/2006    40    91.280         

3/21/2007

   40,2    148.940    12/27/2006    40,4    92.120    10/4/2006    40    119.650         

3/20/2007

   38,4    116.280    12/26/2006    39    38.410    10/3/2006    40    42.700         

3/19/2007

   38,2    77.620    12/22/2006    39    27.380    10/2/2006    40    122.400         

3/16/2007

   37,7    99.210    12/21/2006    39    45.550    9/29/2006    40    42.490         

3/15/2007

   37,4    114.230    12/20/2006    39,4    59.290    9/28/2006    41    28.580         

3/14/2007

   38,4    103.500    12/19/2006    39,8    60.810    9/27/2006    40    42.250         

3/13/2007

   38,6    146.710    12/18/2006    39,7    46.510    9/26/2006    41    54.650         

3/12/2007

   40    59.500    12/15/2006    40,4    84.630    9/25/2006    41    31.530         

3/9/2007

   39,3    46.700    12/14/2006    40,3    44.090    9/22/2006    41    75.750         

3/8/2007

   38,5    42.370    12/13/2006    40,1    223.230    9/21/2006    41    130.840         

3/7/2007

   37,6    68.790    12/12/2006    39,3    67.080    9/20/2006    40    97.380         

3/6/2007

   38,8    84.490    12/11/2006    39    53.820    9/19/2006    40    123.150         

3/5/2007

   37,3    64.780    12/8/2006    39,4    27.530    9/18/2006    40    35.420         

3/2/2007

   38,1    179.750    12/7/2006    39,6    58.580    9/15/2006    40    49.690         

3/1/2007

   39,2    127.380    12/6/2006    39,3    54.620    9/14/2006    40    125.240         

2/28/2007

   38,4    163.770    12/5/2006    39,6    85.420    9/13/2006    40    43.750         

2/27/2007

   38    191.240    12/4/2006    39,5    148.850    9/12/2006    40    50.910         

2/26/2007

   41,8    96.630    12/1/2006    39,3    69.500    9/11/2006    40    108.760         

2/23/2007

   41,7    54.950    11/30/2006    39,8    61.260    9/8/2006    41    152.580         

2/22/2007

   43,7    122.900    11/29/2006    40,5    86.090    9/6/2006    37    79.180         

 

LOGO   -39-


F. Historical Prices and Volume Traded - TMGC7

 

TMGC7 Equity

 

TMGC7 Equity

 

TMGC7 Equity

 

TMGC7 Equity

 

TMGC7 Equity

 

TMGC7 Equity

Date

  Px Last   Px Volume  

Date

  Px Last   Px Volume  

Date

  Px Last   Px Volume  

Date

  Px Last   Px Volume  

Date

  Px Last   Px Volume  

Date

  Px Last   Px Volume

4/2/2008

  600   1   6/27/2007   520,00   0,0   4/9/2007   500,01   0,0   1/16/2007   500,00   0,0   10/23/2006   350,10   0,0   8/3/2006   362,00   0,0

3/28/2008

  600   126   6/26/2007   520,00   20,0   4/5/2007   500,01   0,0   1/15/2007   500,00   0,0   10/20/2006   350,10   0,0   8/2/2006   362,00   111,0

3/4/2008

  600   2   6/25/2007   520,00   0,0   4/4/2007   500,01   0,0   1/12/2007   500,00   0,0   10/19/2006   350,10   0,0      

1/23/2008

  600   1   6/22/2007   520,00   77,0   4/3/2007   500,01   0,0   1/11/2007   500,00   0,0   10/18/2006   350,10   0,0      

1/21/2008

  600   28   6/21/2007   500,00   1,0   4/2/2007   500,01   0,0   1/10/2007   500,00   4,0   10/17/2006   350,10   0,0      

1/18/2008

  600   1   6/20/2007   500,00   1,0   3/30/2007   500,01   0,0   1/9/2007   500,00   0,0   10/16/2006   350,10   0,0      

1/17/2008

  600   104   6/19/2007   451,00   2,0   3/29/2007   500,01   0,0   1/8/2007   500,00   0,0   10/13/2006   350,10   0,0      

1/16/2008

  600   81   6/18/2007   520,00   0,0   3/28/2007   500,01   0,0   1/5/2007   500,00   0,0   10/11/2006   350,10   0,0      

1/3/2008

  600   4   6/15/2007   520,00   0,0   3/27/2007   500,01   0,0   1/4/2007   500,00   6,0   10/10/2006   350,10   1,0      

12/28/2007

  600   15   6/14/2007   520,00   0,0   3/26/2007   500,01   0,0   1/3/2007   500,00   55,0   10/9/2006   355,00   0,0      

12/26/2007

  600   23   6/13/2007   520,00   0,0   3/23/2007   500,01   6,0   1/2/2007   600,00   200,0   10/6/2006   355,00   0,0      

12/17/2007

  600   9   6/12/2007   520,00   0,0   3/22/2007   500,00   0,0   12/28/2006   550,00   0,0   10/5/2006   355,00   0,0      

12/13/2007

  600   2   6/11/2007   520,00   0,0   3/21/2007   500,00   0,0   12/27/2006   550,00   70,0   10/4/2006   355,00   0,0      

12/10/2007

  600   20   6/8/2007   520,00   0,0   3/20/2007   500,00   0,0   12/26/2006   499,98   15,0   10/3/2006   355,00   0,0      

12/3/2007

  610,01   1   6/6/2007   520,00   0,0   3/19/2007   500,00   0,0   12/22/2006   469,00   0,0   10/2/2006   355,00   0,0      

11/27/2007

  601   1   6/5/2007   520,00   0,0   3/16/2007   500,00   0,0   12/21/2006   469,00   0,0   9/29/2006   355,00   0,0      

11/22/2007

  610   1   6/4/2007   520,00   0,0   3/15/2007   500,00   0,0   12/20/2006   469,00   0,0   9/28/2006   355,00   0,0      

10/24/2007

  610   1   6/1/2007   520,00   0,0   3/14/2007   500,00   0,0   12/19/2006   469,00   1,0   9/27/2006   355,00   0,0      

10/19/2007

  602   1   5/31/2007   520,00   0,0   3/13/2007   500,00   0,0   12/18/2006   450,00   0,0   9/26/2006   355,00   0,0      

9/11/2007

  650   41   5/30/2007   520,00   0,0   3/12/2007   500,00   0,0   12/15/2006   450,00   0,0   9/25/2006   355,00   0,0      

9/5/2007

  650   30   5/29/2007   520,00   0,0   3/9/2007   500,00   0,0   12/14/2006   450,00   0,0   9/22/2006   355,00   0,0      

8/31/2007

  650   8   5/28/2007   520,00   0,0   3/8/2007   500,00   0,0   12/13/2006   450,00   0,0   9/21/2006   355,00   66,0      

8/27/2007

  650   1   5/25/2007   520,00   0,0   3/7/2007   500,00   0,0   12/12/2006   450,00   0,0   9/20/2006   355,00   0,0      

8/16/2007

  600   63   5/24/2007   520,00   0,0   3/6/2007   500,00   0,0   12/11/2006   450,00   0,0   9/19/2006   355,00   0,0      

8/13/2007

  670   10   5/23/2007   520,00   0,0   3/5/2007   500,00   0,0   12/8/2006   450,00   0,0   9/18/2006   355,00   0,0      

8/10/2007

  650   32   5/22/2007   520,00   0,0   3/2/2007   500,00   10,0   12/7/2006   450,00   0,0   9/15/2006   355,00   2,0      

8/9/2007

  650   150   5/21/2007   520,00   0,0   3/1/2007   500,00   10,0   12/6/2006   450,00   0,0   9/14/2006   360,00   470,0      

8/8/2007

  650   171   5/18/2007   520,00   43,0   2/28/2007   520,00   0,0   12/5/2006   450,00   0,0   9/13/2006   362,00   9,0      

8/7/2007

  650   100   5/17/2007   470,00   0,0   2/27/2007   520,00   0,0   12/4/2006   450,00   0,0   9/12/2006   350,00   0,0      

8/6/2007

  650   460   5/16/2007   470,00   0,0   2/26/2007   520,00   9,0   12/1/2006   450,00   0,0   9/11/2006   350,00   0,0      

8/3/2007

  650   527   5/15/2007   470,00   0,0   2/23/2007   520,00   0,0   11/30/2006   450,00   0,0   9/8/2006   350,00   0,0      

8/1/2007

  502,00   0,0   5/14/2007   470,00   0,0   2/22/2007   520,00   0,0   11/29/2006   450,00   2,0   9/6/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/31/2007

  502,00   0,0   5/11/2007   470,00   0,0   2/21/2007   520,00   0,0   11/28/2006   400,00   0,0   9/5/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/30/2007

  502,00   1,0   5/10/2007   470,00   0,0   2/16/2007   520,00   0,0   11/27/2006   400,00   1,0   9/4/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/27/2007

  550,00   0,0   5/9/2007   470,00   0,0   2/15/2007   520,00   0,0   11/24/2006   400,00   0,0   9/1/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/26/2007

  550,00   0,0   5/8/2007   470,00   3,0   2/14/2007   520,00   0,0   11/23/2006   400,00   0,0   8/31/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/25/2007

  550,00   0,0   5/7/2007   480,00   0,0   2/13/2007   520,00   0,0   11/22/2006   400,00   0,0   8/30/2006   350,00   66,0      

7/24/2007

  550,00   1,0   5/4/2007   480,00   2,0   2/12/2007   520,00   0,0   11/21/2006   400,00   0,0   8/29/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/23/2007

  570,00   0,0   5/3/2007   500,00   100,0   2/9/2007   520,00   0,0   11/17/2006   400,00   0,0   8/28/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/20/2007

  570,00   0,0   5/2/2007   500,00   1,0   2/8/2007   520,00   0,0   11/16/2006   400,00   0,0   8/25/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/19/2007

  570,00   0,0   4/30/2007   500,00   0,0   2/7/2007   520,00   0,0   11/14/2006   400,00   1,0   8/24/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/18/2007

  570,00   0,0   4/27/2007   500,00   0,0   2/6/2007   520,00   0,0   11/13/2006   350,00   0,0   8/23/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/17/2007

  570,00   0,0   4/26/2007   500,00   0,0   2/5/2007   520,00   2,0   11/10/2006   350,00   0,0   8/22/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/16/2007

  570,00   0,0   4/25/2007   500,00   0,0   2/2/2007   520,00   0,0   11/9/2006   350,00   0,0   8/21/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/13/2007

  570,00   0,0   4/24/2007   500,00   2,0   2/1/2007   520,00   0,0   11/8/2006   350,00   0,0   8/18/2006   350,00   0,0      

7/12/2007

  570,00   0,0   4/23/2007   500,00   0,0   1/31/2007   520,00   0,0   11/7/2006   350,00   0,0   8/17/2006   350,00   6,0      

7/11/2007

  570,00   0,0   4/20/2007   500,00   0,0   1/30/2007   520,00   4,0   11/6/2006   350,00   0,0   8/16/2006   360,00   0,0      

7/10/2007

  570,00   1,0   4/19/2007   500,00   0,0   1/29/2007   500,00   5,0   11/3/2006   350,00   0,0   8/15/2006   360,00   0,0      

7/6/2007

  570,00   0,0   4/18/2007   500,00   0,0   1/26/2007   500,00   0,0   11/1/2006   350,00   0,0   8/14/2006   360,00   0,0      

7/5/2007

  570,00   11,0   4/17/2007   500,00   0,0   1/24/2007   500,00   0,0   10/31/2006   350,00   2,0   8/11/2006   360,00   100,0      

7/4/2007

  520,00   0,0   4/16/2007   500,00   131,0   1/23/2007   500,00   1,0   10/30/2006   350,00   2,0   8/10/2006   362,00   0,0      

7/3/2007

  520,00   2,0   4/13/2007   500,01   0,0   1/22/2007   500,00   0,0   10/27/2006   350,00   1,0   8/9/2006   362,00   0,0      

7/2/2007

  510,00   0,0   4/12/2007   500,01   0,0   1/19/2007   500,00   0,0   10/26/2006   350,00   0,0   8/8/2006   362,00   0,0      

6/29/2007

  510,00   0,0   4/11/2007   500,01   0,0   1/18/2007   500,00   0,0   10/25/2006   350,00   0,0   8/7/2006   362,00   0,0      

6/28/2007

  510,00   10,0   4/10/2007   500,01   0,0   1/17/2007   500,00   0,0   10/24/2006   350,00   29,0   8/4/2006   362,00   0,0      

 

LOGO   -40-