The Securities and Exchange Commission has not necessarily reviewed the information in this filing and has not determined if it is accurate and complete.
The reader should not assume that the information is accurate and complete.

UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
Washington, D.C. 20549
FORM 13F

FORM 13F INFORMATION TABLE
OMB APPROVAL
OMB Number: 3235-0006
Estimated average burden
hours per response: 23.8
COLUMN 1 COLUMN 2 COLUMN 3 COLUMN 4 COLUMN 5 COLUMN 6 COLUMN 7 COLUMN 8
VALUE SHRS OR SH/ PUT/ INVESTMENT OTHER VOTING AUTHORITY
NAME OF ISSUER TITLE OF CLASS CUSIP (x$1000) PRN AMT PRN CALL DISCRETION MANAGER SOLE SHARED NONE
3M CO COM 88579Y101 569 3,229 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,229
ABBOTT LABS COM 002824100 511 12,092 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,092
ABBVIE INC COM 00287Y109 944 14,965 SH   SOLE   0 0 14,965
ADOBE SYS INC COM 00724F101 272 2,505 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,505
ALAMO GROUP INC COM 011311107 344 5,222 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,222
ALLEGION PUB LTD CO ORD SHS G0176J109 1,389 20,156 SH   SOLE   0 0 20,156
ALLSTATE CORP COM 020002101 902 13,039 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,039
ALPHABET INC CAP STK CL C 02079K107 251 323 SH   SOLE   0 0 323
ALPS ETF TR ALERIAN MLP 00162Q866 2,252 177,455 SH   SOLE   0 0 177,455
ALTRIA GROUP INC COM 02209S103 387 6,128 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,128
AMAZON COM INC COM 023135106 322 385 SH   SOLE   0 0 385
AMERICAN ELEC PWR INC COM 025537101 3,248 50,579 SH   SOLE   0 0 50,579
AMGEN INC COM 031162100 699 4,189 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,189
APPLE INC COM 037833100 3,365 29,767 SH   SOLE   0 0 29,767
AT&T INC COM 00206R102 3,354 82,582 SH   SOLE   0 0 82,582
AUTOMATIC DATA PROCESSING IN COM 053015103 1,259 14,279 SH   SOLE   0 0 14,279
BANK AMER CORP COM 060505104 592 37,835 SH   SOLE   0 0 37,835
BARCLAYS PLC ADR 06738E204 90 10,344 SH   SOLE   0 0 10,344
BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY INC DEL CL B NEW 084670702 987 6,835 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,835
BIOGEN INC COM 09062X103 334 1,066 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,066
BOB EVANS FARMS INC COM 096761101 208 5,436 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,436
BOEING CO COM 097023105 1,630 12,371 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,371
BP PLC SPONSORED ADR 055622104 373 10,601 SH   SOLE   0 0 10,601
BRISTOL MYERS SQUIBB CO COM 110122108 2,604 48,299 SH   SOLE   0 0 48,299
CATERPILLAR INC DEL COM 149123101 1,022 11,517 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,517
CHESAPEAKE ENERGY CORP COM 165167107 79 12,596 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,596
CHEVRON CORP NEW COM 166764100 1,943 18,878 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,878
CINCINNATI FINL CORP COM 172062101 455 6,032 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,032
CISCO SYS INC COM 17275R102 924 29,134 SH   SOLE   0 0 29,134
COCA COLA CO COM 191216100 2,128 50,291 SH   SOLE   0 0 50,291
COLGATE PALMOLIVE CO COM 194162103 876 11,809 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,809
COMCAST CORP NEW CL A 20030N101 553 8,334 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,334
COMPASS MINERALS INTL INC COM 20451N101 375 5,089 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,089
CONOCOPHILLIPS COM 20825C104 275 6,324 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,324
CONSOLIDATED EDISON INC COM 209115104 298 3,955 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,955
CORNING INC COM 219350105 280 11,826 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,826
CROWN CASTLE INTL CORP NEW COM 22822V101 812 8,624 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,624
CVS HEALTH CORP COM 126650100 294 3,305 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,305
DISNEY WALT CO COM DISNEY 254687106 1,884 20,288 SH   SOLE   0 0 20,288
DOMINION RES INC VA NEW COM 25746U109 955 12,862 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,862
DOW CHEM CO COM 260543103 1,610 31,069 SH   SOLE   0 0 31,069
DU PONT E I DE NEMOURS & CO COM 263534109 1,262 18,845 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,845
DUKE ENERGY CORP NEW COM NEW 26441C204 773 9,652 SH   SOLE   0 0 9,652
EATON CORP PLC SHS G29183103 238 3,624 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,624
EMERSON ELEC CO COM 291011104 578 10,595 SH   SOLE   0 0 10,595
ENERGY TRANSFER EQUITY L P COM UT LTD PTN 29273V100 228 13,584 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,584
ENTERPRISE PRODS PARTNERS L COM 293792107 308 11,145 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,145
EXXON MOBIL CORP COM 30231G102 3,586 41,085 SH   SOLE   0 0 41,085
FARMERS NATL BANC CORP COM 309627107 1,201 111,427 SH   SOLE   0 0 111,427
FIRSTENERGY CORP COM 337932107 273 8,240 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,240
FORD MTR CO DEL COM PAR $0.01 345370860 453 37,547 SH   SOLE   0 0 37,547
FRONTIER COMMUNICATIONS CORP COM 35906A108 50 12,130 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,130
GENERAL DYNAMICS CORP COM 369550108 205 1,322 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,322
GENERAL ELECTRIC CO COM 369604103 3,466 117,012 SH   SOLE   0 0 117,012
GENERAL MLS INC COM 370334104 270 4,233 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,233
GLAXOSMITHKLINE PLC SPONSORED ADR 37733W105 535 12,416 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,416
HALLIBURTON CO COM 406216101 320 7,137 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,137
HARRIS CORP DEL COM 413875105 444 4,845 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,845
HOME DEPOT INC COM 437076102 1,713 13,314 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,314
HONEYWELL INTL INC COM 438516106 279 2,389 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,389
HUNTINGTON BANCSHARES INC COM 446150104 1,980 200,785 SH   SOLE   0 0 200,785
ILLINOIS TOOL WKS INC COM 452308109 535 4,460 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,460
INGERSOLL-RAND PLC SHS G47791101 4,144 60,989 SH   SOLE   0 0 60,989
INTEL CORP COM 458140100 1,083 28,685 SH   SOLE   0 0 28,685
INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHS COM 459200101 1,861 11,713 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,713
ISHARES INC CORE MSCI EMKT 46434G103 1,624 35,600 SH   SOLE   0 0 35,600
ISHARES SILVER TRUST ISHARES 46428Q109 808 44,372 SH   SOLE   0 0 44,372
ISHARES TR 1-3 YR CR BD ETF 464288646 901 8,517 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,517
ISHARES TR CORE HIGH DV ETF 46429B663 1,041 12,811 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,811
ISHARES TR CORE S&P MCP ETF 464287507 2,959 19,127 SH   SOLE   0 0 19,127
ISHARES TR CORE S&P500 ETF 464287200 3,280 15,078 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,078
ISHARES TR INTERM CR BD ETF 464288638 3,414 30,658 SH   SOLE   0 0 30,658
ISHARES TR MIN VOL EAFE ETF 46429B689 355 5,244 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,244
ISHARES TR MIN VOL USA ETF 46429B697 742 16,332 SH   SOLE   0 0 16,332
ISHARES TR MSCI EAFE ETF 464287465 2,622 44,350 SH   SOLE   0 0 44,350
ISHARES TR RUS 1000 GRW ETF 464287614 2,010 19,300 SH   SOLE   0 0 19,300
ISHARES TR RUS 1000 VAL ETF 464287598 2,092 19,810 SH   SOLE   0 0 19,810
ISHARES TR RUS 2000 GRW ETF 464287648 1,390 9,333 SH   SOLE   0 0 9,333
ISHARES TR RUS 2000 VAL ETF 464287630 3,186 30,413 SH   SOLE   0 0 30,413
ISHARES TR RUS MD CP GR ETF 464287481 1,092 11,210 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,210
ISHARES TR RUS MDCP VAL ETF 464287473 2,027 26,398 SH   SOLE   0 0 26,398
ISHARES TR RUSSELL 2000 ETF 464287655 761 6,127 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,127
ISHARES TR S&P 500 GRWT ETF 464287309 1,568 12,887 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,887
ISHARES TR S&P 500 VAL ETF 464287408 1,627 17,136 SH   SOLE   0 0 17,136
ISHARES TR SELECT DIVID ETF 464287168 372 4,343 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,343
ISHARES TR U.S. ENERGY ETF 464287796 1,008 25,850 SH   SOLE   0 0 25,850
ISHARES TR U.S. PFD STK ETF 464288687 288 7,297 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,297
JOHNSON & JOHNSON COM 478160104 2,899 24,541 SH   SOLE   0 0 24,541
JPMORGAN CHASE & CO COM 46625H100 5,202 78,127 SH   SOLE   0 0 78,127
KEYCORP NEW COM 493267108 388 31,857 SH   SOLE   0 0 31,857
KIMBERLY CLARK CORP COM 494368103 420 3,334 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,334
KINDER MORGAN INC DEL COM 49456B101 537 23,221 SH   SOLE   0 0 23,221
KROGER CO COM 501044101 217 7,312 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,312
LILLY ELI & CO COM 532457108 947 11,796 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,796
LOCKHEED MARTIN CORP COM 539830109 1,060 4,422 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,422
MAGELLAN MIDSTREAM PRTNRS LP COM UNIT RP LP 559080106 379 5,355 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,355
MANITOWOC FOODSERVICE INC COM 563568104 247 15,200 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,200
MANITOWOC INC COM 563571108 73 15,200 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,200
MARATHON OIL CORP COM 565849106 437 27,671 SH   SOLE   0 0 27,671
MARATHON PETE CORP COM 56585A102 301 7,420 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,420
MCDONALDS CORP COM 580135101 443 3,839 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,839
MERCK & CO INC COM 58933Y105 1,955 31,322 SH   SOLE   0 0 31,322
MICROSOFT CORP COM 594918104 2,941 51,061 SH   SOLE   0 0 51,061
NEWELL BRANDS INC COM 651229106 287 5,457 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,457
NEXTERA ENERGY INC COM 65339F101 653 5,340 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,340
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORP COM 655844108 286 2,942 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,942
ORACLE CORP COM 68389X105 1,197 30,467 SH   SOLE   0 0 30,467
PEOPLES BANCORP INC COM 709789101 770 31,294 SH   SOLE   0 0 31,294
PEPSICO INC COM 713448108 1,814 16,679 SH   SOLE   0 0 16,679
PFIZER INC COM 717081103 2,603 76,859 SH   SOLE   0 0 76,859
PHILIP MORRIS INTL INC COM 718172109 437 4,490 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,490
PIMCO ETF TR 0-5 HIGH YIELD 72201R783 237 2,378 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,378
POWERSHARES DB CMDTY IDX TRA UNIT BEN INT 73935S105 404 26,916 SH   SOLE   0 0 26,916
POWERSHARES ETF TR II INTL DEV LOWVL 73937B688 374 12,209 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,209
POWERSHARES ETF TR II S&P500 LOW VOL 73937B779 983 23,682 SH   SOLE   0 0 23,682
POWERSHARES ETF TRUST BASIC MAT SECT 73935X427 353 6,084 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,084
POWERSHARES ETF TRUST CON STAPLE SEC 73935X393 347 6,153 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,153
POWERSHARES ETF TRUST DWA MOMENTUM PTF 73935X153 1,253 29,538 SH   SOLE   0 0 29,538
POWERSHARES ETF TRUST DYN UTIL PORTF 73935X591 355 13,733 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,733
POWERSHARES ETF TRUST TECH SECT PORT 73935X344 372 8,946 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,946
POWERSHARES QQQ TRUST UNIT SER 1 73935A104 662 5,578 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,578
POWERSHS DB MULTI SECT COMM PS DB AGRICUL FD 73936B408 1,158 57,950 SH   SOLE   0 0 57,950
PPG INDS INC COM 693506107 271 2,622 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,622
PROCTER AND GAMBLE CO COM 742718109 2,473 27,557 SH   SOLE   0 0 27,557
PROGRESSIVE CORP OHIO COM 743315103 426 13,522 SH   SOLE   0 0 13,522
PROSHARES TR PSHS ULTSH 20YRS 74347B201 266 8,405 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,405
PROSHARES TR ULTRA FNCLS NEW 74347X633 241 3,320 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,320
REALTY INCOME CORP COM 756109104 351 5,240 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,240
RPM INTL INC COM 749685103 487 9,075 SH   SOLE   0 0 9,075
RYDEX ETF TRUST GUG S&P500 EQ WT 78355W106 383 4,587 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,587
SCHLUMBERGER LTD COM 806857108 606 7,703 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,703
SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR SBI INT-ENERGY 81369Y506 510 7,224 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,224
SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR SBI INT-UTILS 81369Y886 3,761 76,766 SH   SOLE   0 0 76,766
SIRIUS XM HLDGS INC COM 82968B103 176 42,219 SH   SOLE   0 0 42,219
SMUCKER J M CO COM NEW 832696405 1,320 9,737 SH   SOLE   0 0 9,737
SOUTHERN CO COM 842587107 408 7,948 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,948
SPDR GOLD TRUST GOLD SHS 78463V107 257 2,048 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,048
SPDR INDEX SHS FDS DJ GLB RL ES ETF 78463X749 912 18,313 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,313
SPDR INDEX SHS FDS DJ INTL RL ETF 78463X863 222 5,320 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,320
SPDR S&P 500 ETF TR TR UNIT 78462F103 1,799 8,319 SH   SOLE   0 0 8,319
SPDR SER TR NUVN BRCLY MUNI 78468R721 293 5,846 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,846
SPDR SERIES TRUST BRC CNV SECS ETF 78464A359 239 5,154 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,154
SPDR SERIES TRUST BRCLY EM LOCL 78464A391 315 11,133 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,133
SPDR SERIES TRUST S&P DIVID ETF 78464A763 3,260 38,646 SH   SOLE   0 0 38,646
SPDR SERIES TRUST WELLS FG PFD ETF 78464A292 2,117 46,540 SH   SOLE   0 0 46,540
SPECTRA ENERGY CORP COM 847560109 510 11,937 SH   SOLE   0 0 11,937
STARBUCKS CORP COM 855244109 273 5,035 SH   SOLE   0 0 5,035
TEGNA INC COM 87901J105 212 9,706 SH   SOLE   0 0 9,706
TEXAS INSTRS INC COM 882508104 290 4,128 SH   SOLE   0 0 4,128
THERMO FISHER SCIENTIFIC INC COM 883556102 552 3,472 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,472
TIFFANY & CO NEW COM 886547108 232 3,200 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,200
TIMKEN CO COM 887389104 439 12,491 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,491
TIMKENSTEEL CORP COM 887399103 163 15,611 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,611
TORONTO DOMINION BK ONT COM NEW 891160509 287 6,465 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,465
TOYOTA MOTOR CORP SP ADR REP2COM 892331307 215 1,856 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,856
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE INC CL B 911312106 240 2,197 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,197
UNITED STATES OIL FUND LP UNITS 91232N108 631 57,718 SH   SOLE   0 0 57,718
UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORP COM 913017109 243 2,390 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,390
UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC COM 91324P102 217 1,553 SH   SOLE   0 0 1,553
US BANCORP DEL COM NEW 902973304 285 6,649 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,649
VANGUARD INDEX FDS REIT ETF 922908553 2,593 29,896 SH   SOLE   0 0 29,896
VANGUARD INTL EQUITY INDEX F FTSE EMR MKT ETF 922042858 1,227 32,597 SH   SOLE   0 0 32,597
VANGUARD INTL EQUITY INDEX F FTSE SMCAP ETF 922042718 607 6,103 SH   SOLE   0 0 6,103
VANGUARD SPECIALIZED PORTFOL DIV APP ETF 921908844 219 2,604 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,604
VANGUARD TAX MANAGED INTL FD FTSE DEV MKT ETF 921943858 2,149 57,454 SH   SOLE   0 0 57,454
VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC COM 92343V104 3,378 64,992 SH   SOLE   0 0 64,992
VISA INC COM CL A 92826C839 1,244 15,040 SH   SOLE   0 0 15,040
VODAFONE GROUP PLC NEW SPNSR ADR 92857W308 371 12,733 SH   SOLE   0 0 12,733
WAL-MART STORES INC COM 931142103 1,037 14,382 SH   SOLE   0 0 14,382
WEC ENERGY GROUP INC COM 92939U106 232 3,868 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,868
WELLS FARGO & CO NEW COM 949746101 337 7,611 SH   SOLE   0 0 7,611
WENDYS CO COM 95058W100 266 24,660 SH   SOLE   0 0 24,660
WORTHINGTON INDS INC COM 981811102 896 18,654 SH   SOLE   0 0 18,654
YUM BRANDS INC COM 988498101 331 3,643 SH   SOLE   0 0 3,643
ZIMMER BIOMET HLDGS INC COM 98956P102 281 2,164 SH   SOLE   0 0 2,164