20-F 1 u09128e20vf.htm 20-F e20vf
Table of Contents

UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
WASHINGTON, D.C. 20549
FORM 20-F
 
         
     o   REGISTRATION STATEMENT PURSUANT TO SECTION 12(b) OR (g)
OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
OR
     o   ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d)
OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
OR
     x   TRANSITION REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d)
OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
For the transition period from March 31, 2009 to December 31, 2009*
   
 *  The registrant has changed its financial year to end on December 31, 2009. This report relates to the nine month
financial period ended December 31, 2009.
OR
     o   SHELL COMPANY REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d)
OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934
Date of event requiring this shell company report . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
 
Commission file number:1-14452
 
THE GOVERNOR AND COMPANY OF
THE BANK OF IRELAND
(Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)
 
 
IRELAND
(Jurisdiction of incorporation or organization)
 
40 MESPIL ROAD, DUBLIN 4, IRELAND
(Address of principal executive offices)
 
The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland
Lower Baggot Street
Dublin 2, Ireland
Telephone no: +353 1 6615933
Facsimile no: +353 1 6615671
(Name, telephone number, facsimile number and address of company contact person)
 
Securities registered or to be registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:
 
     
Title of each class
 
Name of each exchange on which registered
− Ordinary stock (nominal value of €0.101 each)   The New York Stock Exchange**
− American Depositary Shares, each representing four units of
    Ordinary Stock (nominal value of €0.101 each)
  The New York Stock Exchange
 
**  Not for trading, but only in connection with the registration of American Depositary Shares representing such ordinary stock, pursuant to the requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission.
Securities registered or to be registered pursuant to Section 12(g) of the Act: None
Securities for which there is a reporting obligation pursuant to Section 15(d) of the Act: None
Indicate the number of outstanding shares of each of the Issuer’s classes of capital or common stock as of December 31, 20092:
Ordinary stock (nominal value of €0.64 per unit): 993,001,864
Preference stock (nominal value of €1.27 per unit): 3,026,598
    Preference stock (nominal value of €0.01 per unit): 3,500,000,000
Preference stock (nominal value of Stg£1 per unit): 1,876,090
Indicate by check mark if the registrant is a well-known seasoned issuer, as defined in Rule 405 of the Securities Act.
YES  [X]      NO  [  ] 
If this report is an annual or transition report, indicate by check mark if the registrant is not required to file reports pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
YES  [  ]      NO  [X] 
 
Note — checking the box above will not relieve any registrant required to file reports pursuant to Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 from their obligations under those Sections.
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports), and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days.
YES  [X]      NO  [  ] 
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has submitted electronically and posted on its corporate Web site, if any, every Interactive Data File required to be submitted and posted pursuant to Rule 405 of Regulation S-T during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to submit and post such files).*
YES  [X]      NO  [  ] 
* This requirement does not apply to the registrant until its fiscal year ended December 31, 2011.
 
Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, or a non-accelerated filer. See definition of “accelerated file and large accelerated file” in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act:
 
         
         
Large accelerated filer [X]
  Accelerated filer [  ]   Non-accelerated filer [  ]
 
Indicate by check mark which basis of accounting the registrant has used to prepare the financial statements included in this filing:
 
         
         
US GAAP  [  ] 
  International Financial Reporting   Other  [  ] 
    Standards as issued by the
International Accounting
Standards Board  [X] 
   
 
If “Other” has been checked in response to the previous question, indicate by check mark which financial statement item the registrant has elected to follow.
Item 17  [  ]      Item 18  [  ] 
 
If this is an annual report, indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act).
YES  [  ]      NO  [X] 
 
1.  Renominalised from €0.64 to €0.10 with effect from May 19, 2010
 
2.  See note 58(i) to the Consolidated Financial Statements for a description of additional stock issues after December 31, 2009.
 


Table of Contents

 
 
[THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
 
 


2


Table of Contents

The Governor and Company of The Bank of Ireland
 
 
ANNUAL REPORT ON FORM 20-F
 
Table of Contents
 
             
        Page
 
 Item
  Caption        
    Presentation of information     5  
    Forward looking information     5  
    Definitions     6  
    Reporting currency     6  
    Exchange rates     7  
             
             
           
    Part I        
  Identity of Directors, Senior Management & Advisors (not applicable)     8  
  Offer Statistics & Expected Timetable (not applicable)     8  
  Key Information     8  
    Selected financial data     8  
    Risk factors     12  
  Information on the Company     34  
    General     34  
    Business overview     34  
    Corporate structure     34  
    Principal capital expenditures and divestitures     37  
    Material subsidiaries     38  
    Description of property     38  
    Competition     39  
    Supervision and regulation     40  
    Economic conditions affecting the Group     54  
  Unresolved Staff Comments     55  
  Operating & Financial Review and Prospects     55  
    Overview     55  
    Critical accounting estimates and judgements     64  
    Market conditions     64  
    Liquidity and capital resources     64  
    Analysis of results of operations     73  
    Average balance sheet and interest rates     106  
    Description of assets & liabilities     109  
  Directors, Senior Management and Employees     129  
    Directors and senior management     129  
    Remuneration of Directors and Officers     132  
    Corporate governance statement     138  
    Court committees     142  
    Employees     145  
    Stock options     146  
  Major Stockholders and Related Party Transactions     147  
    Control of registrant     147  
    Related party transactions     147  
    Description of US stockholders     147  
  Financial Information     147  
    Dividend policy     148  
    Legal proceedings     149  
    Significant changes     149  
    Prospective accounting changes/Impact of new accounting policies     150  


3


Table of Contents

             
        Page
 
  The Offer and Listing     150  
    Nature of trading market     150  
  Additional Information     151  
    Charter and Bye-Laws     151  
    Exchange controls and other limitations affecting security holders     160  
    Taxation     160  
    Documents available through the SEC     163  
    Relations with stockholders     163  
  Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures about Market Risk     164  
  Description of Securities other than Equity Securities     173  
    175  
             
             
           
    Part II        
  Defaults, Dividend Arrearages & Delinquencies (not applicable)     179  
  Material Modifications to the Rights of Security Holders & Use of Proceeds     179  
  Controls and Procedures     179  
  A. Audit Committee Financial Expert     180  
    B. Code of Ethics     180  
    C. Principal Accountant Fees and Services     180  
    D. Exemptions from the Listing Standards for Audit Committees (not applicable)     180  
    E. Purchases of Equity Securities by the Issuer and Affiliated Purchasers     180  
    F. Change in Registrant’s Certifying Accountant (not applicable)     180  
    G. Corporate Governance     180  
             
             
           
    Part III        
  Financial Statements (not applicable)     181  
  Financial Statements     181  
  Exhibits     181  
 Exhibit 1.2
 EX 4.5
 EX 4.6
 Exhibit 12.1
 Exhibit 12.2
 Exhibit 13.1
 Exhibit 13.2

4


Table of Contents

 
PRESENTATION OF INFORMATION
 
As set out in note 1 to the Consolidated Financial Statements, the Group has changed its fiscal year end from March 31, to December 31, to align its financial calendar with that of its peer banks. Accordingly, the latest financial period presented is for the nine months ended December 31, 2009, which affects the comparison with prior financial periods with a fiscal year end of March 31. For a comparison of selected financial information for the nine month periods ended December 31, 2009 and 2008, see note 59 to the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
In this Annual Report on Form 20-F (“Annual Report” or “Form 20-F”), the term “Ordinary Stock” refers to units of ordinary stock of the Bank and the term “ADSs” refers to American Depositary Shares each representing the right to receive four units of ordinary stock and evidenced by American Depositary Receipts (“ADRs”). On May 19, 2010, the ordinary stock of the Bank was renominalised from €0.64 to €0.10 per unit. For further detail see note 58 of the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
The ADSs are listed on the New York Stock Exchange and are evidenced by ADRs issued by The Bank of New York Mellon as Depositary under a Deposit Agreement.
 
Unless a specific source is identified, all information regarding market and other operating and statistical data provided in this document is based on the Group’s own estimates. In making estimates, the Group relies on data produced internally and, where appropriate, external sources, including information made public by other market participants or associations.
 
Information found on any website address included in this Annual Report is not part of or incorporated into this Annual Report and the inclusion of such addresses is for the reader’s reference only.
 
Certain definitions are set out in the Appendix to Part I of this Form 20-F.
 
FORWARD LOOKING INFORMATION
 
This document contains certain forward looking statements within the meaning of Section 21E of the US Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Section 27A of the US Securities Act of 1933 with respect to certain of the Bank of Ireland Group’s (the “Group”) plans and its current goals and expectations relating to its future financial condition and performance and the markets in which it operates. These forward looking statements can be identified by the fact that they do not relate only to historical or current facts. Generally, but not always, words such as “may,” “could,” “should,” “will,” “expect,” “intend,” “estimate,” “anticipate,” “assume,” “believe,” “plan,” “seek,” “continue,” “target,” “goal,” “would”, or their negative variations or similar expressions identify forward looking statements. Examples of forward looking statements include among others, statements regarding the Group’s future financial position, income growth, business strategy, projected costs, projected impairment losses, capital ratios, margins, future payments of dividends, the outcome of the current review of the Group’s defined benefit pension schemes, estimates of capital expenditure, discussions with the Irish, European and other regulators and plans and objectives for future operations. Forward looking statements should not be read as a guarantee of future performance or results, and will not necessarily be accurate indications of the times at, or by which, such performance or results will be achieved. Rather, they are based on current views and assumptions and involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors, many of which are outside the control of the Group and are difficult to predict, that may cause the actual results, performance, achievements or developments of the Group or the businesses in which it operates to differ materially from any future results, performance, achievements or developments expressed or implied from the forward looking statements. A number of material factors could cause actual results to differ materially from those contemplated by the forward looking statements, including, among other factors, the following:
 
 
•  general economic conditions in Ireland, the United Kingdom and the other markets in which the Group operates;
 
•  declining property values in Ireland and the United Kingdom;
 
•  the potential exposure of the Group to various types of market risks, such as interest rate risk, foreign exchange rate risk, credit risk and commodity price risk;


5


Table of Contents

 
•  financial uncertainties in the EU and in member countries and the potential effects of those uncertainties on the Group;
 
•  the ability of the Group to access sufficient funding to meet its liquidity needs;
 
•  the outcome of the Group’s participation in the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme;
 
•  the terms of the final EU restructuring plan to be agreed with the European Commission and the Department of Finance and the implementation of the final EU restructuring plan;
 
•  changes in the Group’s credit ratings;
 
•  the effects of the Irish Government’s stockholding in the Group (through the NPRFC);
 
•  the outcome of the Group’s participation in NAMA;
 
•  changes in the Irish banking system;
 
•  the making of further contributions to the Group’s pension schemes;
 
•  changes in applicable laws, regulations and taxes in jurisdictions in which the Group operates;
 
•  the effects of competition and consolidation in the markets in which the Group operates; and
 
•  the success of the Group in managing the risks involved in the foregoing.
 
See Item 3 “Key Information — Risk Factors” and under Item 11 “Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures about Market Risk” in this document for more information on factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from those contemplated by the forward looking statements in this document.
 
Any forward looking statements speak only as at the date they are made. The Group does not undertake to release publicly any revision to these forward looking statements to reflect events, circumstances or unanticipated events occurring after the date hereof. The reader should however, consult any additional disclosures that the Group may make in documents that it may file or submit to the US Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”).
 
DEFINITIONS
 
For the purposes of this Annual Report, the term “Bank” means The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland and the terms “Group” and “Bank of Ireland Group” mean the Bank and its consolidated subsidiaries and, where the context permits, its interests in associated companies and joint ventures.
 
Certain financial and statistical information in this Annual Report is presented separately for domestic and foreign activities. Domestic activities include transactions recorded on the books of the Group branches and offices located in Ireland. Foreign activities include transactions recorded on the books of the Group branches and offices in the United Kingdom (“UK”), the United States of America (“US”) and elsewhere outside of Ireland.
 
Unless otherwise stated, for the purposes of this Annual Report, references to “Ireland” exclude Northern Ireland.
 
Further definitions are set out in the Appendix to Part I of this Form 20-F.
 
REPORTING CURRENCY
 
The Group publishes consolidated financial statements in euro (“€” or “EUR”). Each euro is made up of one hundred cents, each of which is represented by the symbol “c” in this Annual Report.
 
References to “dollars”, “US$”, “$” or “¢” are to US currency, and references to “Stg£”, “GBP£” and “pounds sterling” are to UK currency. Amounts in dollars, unless otherwise stated, for the current financial (fiscal) year have been translated from euro at the rate prevailing on December 31, 2009 as shown below under “Exchange Rates”. This rate should not be construed as a representation that the euro amounts actually denote such dollar amounts or have been, could have been, or could be converted into dollars at the rate indicated.


6


Table of Contents

 
EXCHANGE RATES
 
As a significant portion of the assets, liabilities, income and expenses of the Group is denominated in currencies other than euro, fluctuations in the value of the euro relative to other currencies have had an effect on the euro value of assets and liabilities denominated in such currencies as well as on the Group’s results of operations. The principal foreign currencies affecting the Group’s financial statements are sterling and the dollar. At June 4, 2010, the spot rate was US$1.1998 = €1.00.
 
The following table sets forth, for the dates or periods indicated, the spot or Noon Buying Rate in New York for cable transfers as certified for customs purposes by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (the “Noon Buying Rate”) and the rates used by the Group in the preparation of its consolidated financial statements, which are sourced from the European Central Bank (“ECB”):
 
                                         
    Period ended
               
    December 31,
  Year ended March 31,
    2009   2009   2008   2007   2006
    (dollars per €)
 
Euro/dollar rates:
                                       
End of period
    1.4332       1.3261       1.5805       1.3374       1.2139  
Average1
    1.4223       1.4103       1.4316       1.2943       1.2163  
High
    1.5100       1.6010       1.5805       1.3374       1.3093  
Low
    1.2903       1.2446       1.3295       1.2091       1.1667  
End of period rate used by the Group2
    1.4406       1.3308       1.5812       1.3318       1.2104  
Average rate used by the Group2
    1.4248       1.4321       1.4328       1.2912       1.2126  
 
The highest spot or noon buying rate for each of the last six months was: May 2010: 1.3183, April 2010: 1.3666, March 2010: 1.3758, February 2010: 1.3955, January 2010: 1.4536, December 2009: 1.5100.
 
The lowest spot or noon buying rate for each of the last six months was: May 2010: 1.2224, April 2010: 1.3130, March 2010: 1.3344, February 2010: 1.3476, January 2010: 1.3870, December 2009: 1.4243.
 
                                         
    Period ended
               
    December 31,
  Year ended March 31,
    2009   2009   2008   2007   2006
    (Stg£ per €)
 
Euro/sterling rates:
                                       
End of period rate used by the Group2
    0.8881       0.9308       0.7958       0.6798       0.6964  
Average rate used by the Group2
    0.8851       0.8333       0.7116       0.6783       0.6826  
 
 
1.  The average of the spot or Noon Buying Rates on the last day of each month during the Group’s financial year/period.
 
2.  The rates used by the Group in the preparation of its consolidated financial statements.


7


Table of Contents

 
PART 1
 
Item 1   IDENTITY OF DIRECTORS, SENIOR MANAGEMENT & ADVISORS
 
Not applicable.
 
Item 2   OFFER STATISTICS & EXPECTED TIMETABLE
 
Not applicable.
 
Item 3   KEY INFORMATION
 
SELECTED FINANCIAL DATA
 
The following tables present selected consolidated financial data which have been derived from the audited consolidated financial statements of the Group. Tables 1 and 2 detail financial data under International Financial Reporting Standards (“IFRS”) as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (“IASB”) for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and the years ended March 31, 2009, 2008, 2007 and 2006.
 
The consolidated financial statements of the Group have been prepared in accordance with IFRS as issued by the IASB for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and the years ended March 31, 2009, 2008, 2007 and 2006. The EU adopted version of IAS 39 currently relaxes some of the hedge accounting rules in IAS 39 ‘Financial Instruments — Recognition and Measurement’. The Group has not availed of this relaxation, hence these financial statements comply with both IFRS as adopted by the EU and IFRS as issued by the IASB.
 
The selected consolidated financial data should be read in conjunction with, and are qualified in their entirety by reference to, the consolidated financial statements of the Group and the notes thereto, which are included in this Annual Report. The financial results should not be construed as indicative of financial results for subsequent periods. See Item 5 “Operating & Financial Review and Prospects”.
 
As noted in the Presentation of Information the Group has changed its financial year (see note 1 to the Consolidated Financial Statements).


8


Table of Contents

SELECTED CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL DATA
 
Table 1
 
                                                 
    For the Financial Period Ended
            * Restated
  * Restated
       
    9 months
  9 months
  12 months
  12 months
  12 months
  12 months
    ended
  ended
  ended
  ended
  ended
  ended
    December 31,
  December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    20091   2009   2009   2008   2007   2006
    US$m   (in € millions, except per unit amounts and percentages)    
 
Income Statement Data
                                               
Interest income
    5,025       4,188       9,717       10,397       8,137       5,954  
Interest expense
    (2,410 )     (2,009 )     (6,047 )     (7,134 )     (5,380 )     (3,647 )
                                                 
Net interest income
    2,615       2,179       3,670       3,263       2,757       2,307  
Insurance net premium income
    798       665       1,069       1,940       2,188       1,298  
Fees and commissions income
    569       474       717       816       898       912  
Fees and commissions expense
    (306 )     (255 )     (232 )     (150 )     (160 )     (170 )
Net trading expense
    (34 )     (28 )     (307 )     (246 )     (70 )     30  
Life assurance investment income and (losses)/gains
    1,150       958       (1,570 )     (826 )     247       599  
Gain on repurchase of subordinated liabilities
    1,244       1,037                          
Other operating income
    37       31       73       238       199       116  
                                                 
Total Operating Income
    6,073       5,061       3,420       5,035       6,059       5,092  
Insurance contract liabilities and claims paid
    (1,754 )     (1,462 )     537       (798 )     (2,213 )     (1,666 )
                                                 
Total Operating Income, net of Insurance Claims
    4,319       3,599       3,957       4,237       3,846       3,426  
Other Operating expenses
    (1,657 )     (1,381 )     (2,121 )     (2,160 )     (2,159 )     (2,020 )
Impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets
    (7 )     (6 )     (304 )                  
                                                 
Operating profit before impairment charges on financial assets
    2,655       2,212       1,532       2,077       1,687       1,406  
Impairment charges on financial assets
    (4,868 )     (4,057 )     (1,513 )     (232 )     (103 )     (103 )
                                                 
Operating (loss)/profit
    (2,213 )     (1,845 )     19       1,845       1,584       1,303  
Share of (loss)/profit of associated undertakings and joint ventures (after tax)
    42       35       (42 )     46       44       45  
(Loss)/Profit on disposal of business activities
    (4 )     (3 )                 243       176  
Profit on sale of property
                      39       87        
                                                 
(Loss)/profit before taxation
    (2,176 )     (1,813 )     (23 )     1,930       1,958       1,524  
Taxation
    413       344       41       (229 )     (306 )     (303 )
                                                 
(Loss)/Profit for the period
    (1,763 )     (1,469 )     18       1,701       1,652       1,221  
                                                 
Attributable to minority interests
    (11 )     (9 )     (35 )     5       1       (9 )
                                                 
Attributable to stockholders
    (1,752 )     (1,460 )     53       1,696       1,651       1,230  
                                                 
(Loss)/Profit for the period
    (1,763 )     (1,469 )     18       1,701       1,652       1,221  
                                                 
Earnings per unit of €0.64 ordinary stock (cent)
    (202.3c )     (168.6c )     4.3c       174.3c       172.2c       128.5c  
                                                 
Diluted earnings per unit of €0.64 ordinary stock (cent)
    (202.3c )     (168.6c )     4.3c       173.6c       171.0c       127.6c  
                                                 
Dividends per unit of €0.64 ordinary stock (cent)2
                      63.6c       60.4c       52.5c  
                                                 
Number of shares used in EPS calculation (in millions)
    993       993       988       965       950       947  
                                                 
Number of shares used in diluted EPS calculation (in millions)
    993       993       988       969       957       954  
                                                 
 
 
 *  The prior years have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 


9


Table of Contents

                                                 
    December 31,
  December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    20091   2009   2009   2008   2007   2006
    US$m   (in € millions, except per unit amounts and percentages)
 
Balance Sheet Data
                                               
Amounts in accordance with IFRS:
                                               
Total assets
    217,291       181,106       194,116       197,434       188,813       162,212  
Loans and advances to customers (net of impairment for losses on loans and advances)
    143,303       119,439       133,740       135,738       125,048       101,246  
Loans held for sale to NAMA (net of impairment for losses on loans and advances)
    11,347       9,457                          
Loans and advances to banks
    6,036       5,031       7,886       9,409       7,210       12,188  
Allowance for impairment losses on loans and advances to customers
    (6,929 )     (5,775 )     (1,781 )     (596 )     (428 )     (359 )
Available for sale financial assets
    25,124       20,940       26,858       29,307       33,449       28,205  
Deposits from banks
    21,480       17,903       28,814       14,130       20,405       32,312  
Customer accounts
    101,757       84,812       83,119       86,234       72,277       61,710  
Debt securities in issue
    51,764       43,144       45,133       60,842       59,523       36,814  
Subordinated liabilities
    7,262       6,053       7,942       7,808       7,808       6,493  
Minority interests
    60       50       61       38       34       45  
Capital stock
    839       699       699       664       663       663  
Stock premium account
    4,910       4,092       4,092       775       771       767  
Retained earnings
    3,915       3,263       4,761       5,670       4,672       3,188  
Other reserves
    (1,896 )     (1,580 )     (2,610 )     (400 )     905       803  
Own shares held for the benefit of life assurance policyholders
    (104 )     (87 )     (90 )     (225 )     (287 )     (235 )
Stockholders’ equity
    7,663       6,387       6,852       6,484       6,724       5,186  

10


Table of Contents

Table 2
 
                                         
        * Restated
  * Restated
       
    9 months
  12 months
  12 months
  12 months
  12 months
    ended
  ended
  ended
  ended
  ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008   2007   2006
    (in Percentages %)
 
Other Financial Data***
                                       
Return on average total assets3
    (1.03 )     0.03       0.8       0.9       0.8  
Return on average stockholders’ equity4
    (25.3 )     0.9       24.4       26.9       25.7  
Net interest margin5
    1.7       2.1       1.9       1.8       1.8  
Cost/income ratio6
    38 **     62       50       51       55  
Impairment provisions on loans and advances to customers7
    2.5       1.3       0.4       0.3       0.4  
Ipairment provisions on loans held for sale to NAMA8
    22.7                          
Impairment charges to average total loans9
    3.9       1.0       0.2       0.1       0.1  
Stockholders’ equity to assets10
    3.5       3.3       3.3       3.6       3.2  
Dividend payout ratio11
                  36       32       37  
 
                                         
    December 31
  March 31
  March 31
  March 31
  March 31
    2009   2009   2008   2007   2006
    (in Percentages %)
 
Capital12
    Basel II       Basel II       Basel I       Basel I       Basel I  
Equity Tier 1 ratio
    5.3       6.2       5.7       5.3       4.9  
Tier 1 capital ratio
    9.8       12.0       8.1       7.6       7.9  
Total capital ratio
    13.4       15.2       11.1       10.5       11.5  
 
 
  The prior years have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
  **  Impacted by the gain of €1,037 million on the repurchase of subordinated liabilities.
 
  ***  Other financial data for 9 months ended December 31, 2009 is presented on an annualised basis.
 
  1.  Translated solely for convenience into dollars at €1.00 = US$1.1998, the Spot Rate on June 4, 2010.
 
  2.  See Item 8 “Financial Information – Dividend Policy” for details of dividends per unit of ordinary stock in dollars.
 
  3.  Return on average total assets represents profit attributable to the ordinary stockholders as a percentage of average total assets. The calculation of the average balances for all years includes daily, weekly or monthly averages for certain reporting units. See Item 5 “Operating & Financial Review and Prospects — Average Balance Sheet and Interest Rates”. The Group considers these average balances to be representative of the operations of the Group.
 
  4.  Return on average stockholders’ equity represents profit attributable to the ordinary stockholders as a percentage of average stockholders’ funds, excluding minority interests.
 
  5.  Net interest margin represents net interest income as a percentage of average interest earning assets.
 
  6.  The cost/income ratio is determined by dividing the total expenses including goodwill impairment of the Group by the total income (including gain on the re-purchase of subordinated liabilities) of the Group including income from associated undertakings and joint ventures.
 
  7.  Impairment provisions on loans and advances to customers is calculated by dividing the impairment provision on loans and advances to customers by total loans and advances to customers at the balance sheet date.
 
  8.  Impairment provisions on loans held for sale to NAMA is calculated by dividing the impairment provision on loans held for sale to NAMA by loans held for sale to NAMA at the balance sheet date.
 
  9.  Impairment charges to average total loans is calculated by dividing impairment losses for the financial period on loans and advances to customers by average loans and advances to customers.
 
  10.  Stockholders’ equity excludes minority interests.
 
  11.  Dividend payout ratio is calculated by dividing the annual equity dividends by profit attributable to ordinary stockholders.
 
  12.  With effect from July 2007 the Irish Financial Regulator issued a requirement that a Prudential Filter be applied to proposed dividends which results in these dividends being deducted from capital when calculating capital ratios. Capital ratios have been restated to reflect that requirement. This has no impact on the calculation of the ratios for the nine months ended December 31, 2009.


11


Table of Contents

 
RISK FACTORS
 
This section addresses those risks to the Group’s business that are considered material by the Directors. These risks should not be regarded as a complete and comprehensive statement of all potential risks and uncertainties: some risks are not yet known and some that are not currently considered material could later turn out to be material. All of these risks could materially adversely affect the Group, its income, operating profits, earnings, net assets, liquidity, funding and/or capital resources and its ability to meet any targets or objectives.
 
Ireland: The Group’s businesses are subject to risks arising from general and sector specific economic conditions in Ireland, which have materially adversely affected the Group’s earnings and are likely to continue to affect its results, financial condition and prospects.
 
As at December 31, 2009, 63% of the Group’s total assets were located in Ireland and during the 9 month period ended December 31, 2009, approximately 64% of its total income was generated in Ireland. Ireland is facing an extremely challenging economic period and is only recently emerging from recession. Unemployment has increased, with the consensus forecasting a rise to 13.6% by the end of 2010 (Source: Reuters Poll, March 2010). The property market has suffered a very significant decline, with average national house prices in Ireland falling by 18.5% in 2009 and 9.1% in 2008 (Source: Permanent TSB/ERSI House Price Index) and commercial property prices falling by 55.6% between September 2007 and December 2009 (Source: IPD Irish Commercial Property Index). Following heavy reliance on construction and property-related activity for economic growth, the Irish economy is currently experiencing a severe contraction. Irish GDP has contracted by 7.1% for the 2009 calendar year (Source: CSO, Quarterly National Accounts, Q4 2009). The Government finances show a significant deficit with a revised estimated General Government Balance (“GGB”) deficit of 11.7% of GDP in 2009 compared to a deficit of 7.2% of GDP in 2008 and a surplus of 0.3% of GDP in 2007 (Source: Department of Finance Monthly Economic Bulletin, April 2010). There has also been a significant fiscal adjustment in Ireland implemented by the Government equivalent to 7.5% of GDP in 2009 through a combination of increased taxes and a reduction in Government spending (Source: Department of Finance).
 
Negative macroeconomic conditions in Ireland are evident in a decline in demand for business products and services, weak business and consumer confidence, lower personal expenditure and consumption, increases in the debt service burden of consumers and businesses and limitations on the general availability of credit. These factors have significantly affected, and will continue to affect, the behaviour of the Group’s customers and, by extension, the demand for, and supply of, the Group’s products and services, which in turn will affect the Group’s financial condition and results.
 
In addition, higher unemployment, reduced corporate profitability, and increased corporate and personal insolvency rates have and will continue to reduce borrowers’ ability to repay loans. Due to the fall in Irish residential and commercial property prices, the value of collateral on many of the Group’s loans has reduced and write-downs and impairment charges have significantly increased.
 
These conditions have already materially adversely affected the Group, have exerted downward pressure on share prices, liquidity and availability of credit for financial institutions, including the Group, and other corporations and have left the Irish banking system facing serious structural and funding issues. If these economic conditions continue or worsen, or if the Irish economy recovers at a slower rate than anticipated, the Group may experience further reductions in business activity, increased funding costs, decreased asset values, additional write-downs and impairment charges with consequent adverse effects on profitability and financial condition.
 
Further downgrades to the Irish sovereign ratings or outlook could impair the Group’s access to funding, trigger additional collateral requirements and weaken its competitive position.
 
The sovereign rating of Ireland has a number of effects on the Irish banking sector as a whole. As at June 7, 2010, the last practicable date prior to the publication of this Form 20-F, the long-term (outlook) / short-term (outlook) sovereign credit ratings for Ireland were AA(negative outlook) / A-1+ from Standard & Poor’s, Aa1(negative outlook) / P-1 from Moody’s Investor Service, AA- (stable) / F1+ from Fitch Ratings and AA(negative) / A-1+ from Ratings and Investment Information Inc. (R+I). A downgrade would be likely to increase the cost of financing the Irish public debt, which could result in increased taxation, lower Government spending and consequently an adverse


12


Table of Contents

effect on Irish economic conditions. As the guarantor of certain liabilities of the Group under the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and under the ELG Scheme, a downgrade is also likely to impact adversely on the Group’s credit rating and cost of funding for certain securities guaranteed under these schemes and could result in the withdrawal of deposits from the Group.
 
In addition, as a Participating Institution in NAMA, the Group receives Government guaranteed bonds and non-guaranteed subordinated bonds issued by NAMA as consideration for the transfer of assets to NAMA. In the normal course of business, the Group also has holdings in Government bonds separate from those issued under NAMA. A downgrade or series of downgrades in the rating of the Government debt or the Government guaranteed bonds could adversely impact the extent to which the Group can use these bonds as collateral for the purposes of accessing the liquidity provision operations offered by Monetary Authorities or secured borrowing from wholesale markets, for example if these bonds ceased to meet the eligibility criteria set by Monetary Authorities (see the risk factor entitled “Constraints on liquidity, lack of availability of funding and increased cost of funding could materially adversely affect the Group’s business”). As such, a downgrade or series of downgrades in the sovereign rating of Ireland may have a systemic effect on the Irish banking sector, may have adverse effects for the Irish economy and may also affect the marketability of the Government guaranteed bonds held by the Group and the Group’s ability to sell them, or make it more difficult and/or more expensive for the Group to access private sources of capital and funding.
 
In addition to Ireland, the Group’s businesses are subject to inherent risks arising from general and sector specific economic conditions in other countries to which the Group has an exposure, particularly in the United Kingdom. Adverse developments, such as the recent deterioration in general economic conditions and in the global financial markets, have already materially adversely affected the Group’s earnings and are likely to continue to affect its results, financial condition and prospects.
 
The global financial system began to experience difficulties in mid-2007. This resulted in severe dislocation of financial markets around the world, significant declines in the values of nearly all asset classes and unprecedented levels of illiquidity in capital markets. Uncertainty surrounds the pace and scale of global economic recovery and conditions could deteriorate further as fiscal and monetary supports are withdrawn.
 
The financial crisis and the global recession have had a negative impact on general and sector specific conditions in other jurisdictions outside Ireland in which the Group operates, including the United Kingdom and the United States. As has occurred in Ireland, this has resulted in a decline in demand for business products and services, weak business and consumer confidence, lower personal expenditure and consumption, increases in the debt service burden of consumers and businesses and limitations on the general availability of credit. These factors have significantly affected, and will continue to affect, the Group’s customers and, by extension, the demand for, and supply of, the Group’s products and services and in turn the Group’s financial condition and results. In addition, higher unemployment, reduced corporate profitability and increased corporate and personal insolvency rates in other jurisdictions outside Ireland, may reduce borrowers’ ability to repay loans.
 
Specifically in relation to the United Kingdom, GDP contracted by 4.9% in 2009 (Source: Office for National Statistics, Output, Income And Expenditure, Quarter 4 2009) and grew by 0.2% on a quarter by quarter basis in the first quarter of 2010 (Source: Office for National Statistics, Statistical Bulletin, Q1 2010). The consensus view (Source: Reuters Consensus Forecast, March 2010) is that the UK economy will grow at a pace of 1.2% in 2010 and 2.3% in 2011, although uncertainty remains on the likely impact on the economy of the pace of fiscal tightening required to reduce the UK national budget deficit. In the UK property sector after peaking in October 2007, residential house prices fell steadily over the period to February 2009 with the cumulative decline over this period amounting to 19.5% (Source: Nationwide Index). The commercial property market experienced a 45% fall in capital values from the peak in quarter two of 2007 to trough in quarter two of 2009 (Source: IPD). While these markets have recovered somewhat and residential house prices started to rise in Spring 2009 with prices rising by an annualised 9.0% to March 2010 (Source: Nationwide Index), so that prices in March 2010 were 11.5% below their peak and growth in commercial property capital values of 8.1% were recorded in the final quarter of 2009, significant uncertainty remains around the pace and scale of recovery. This reduction in the value of residential and commercial property has reduced the value of collateral on many of the Group’s loans, leading to significantly increased write-downs and impairment charges.


13


Table of Contents

The precise nature of all the risks and uncertainties the Group faces as a result of the global economic outlook are difficult to predict in view of the severity of the global recession, uncertainty regarding the economic impact of the withdrawal, and the timing of such withdrawal, of the various governmental fiscal and monetary supports by Government agencies and Monetary Authorities and the fact that many of these risks are outside the Group’s control.
 
If these levels of market disruption and volatility worsen, the Group may experience further reductions in business activity, increased funding costs, decreased asset values, additional write-downs and impairment charges with consequent adverse effects on profitability and financial condition. Moreover the worsening of the global economic environment could impact on one or more countries that are significant to the Group’s business and could further adversely affect the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Decreases in the credit quality of the Group’s borrowers and counterparties, as well as increased difficulties in relation to the recoverability of loans and other amounts due from such borrowers and counterparties, have resulted in increases, and could result in further significant increases, in the Group’s impaired loans and impairment charges.
 
Credit risk is the risk that a borrower or counterparty will be unable or unwilling to meet a commitment that it has entered into or that any pledged collateral does not fully cover the lender’s claims. Risks arising from changes in credit quality and the recoverability of both secured and unsecured loans and amounts due from counterparties are inherent in a wide range of the Group’s businesses. The outlook for the global economy remains uncertain. In particular, Ireland’s recent significant reliance on the construction and property industry has exacerbated the impact of Ireland’s economic recession. The consensus expectation is that any recovery in the Irish economy will take longer than that of the European Union as a whole. Adverse changes in the credit quality or behaviour of the Group’s borrowers, counterparties and their guarantors, including sovereign counterparties, or adverse changes arising from a general deterioration in global economic conditions or systemic risks in the financial systems, have reduced, and are expected to continue to reduce, the recoverability and value of the Group’s assets. These circumstances have caused a significant increase in, and could cause further significant increases in, impaired loans and impairment charges.
 
The Group’s primary markets are Ireland and the United Kingdom. At December 31, 2009, 47% of the Group’s loans and advances to customers (including loans held for sale to NAMA) were in Ireland, 45% were in the United Kingdom and 8% were in other jurisdictions (Source: unaudited internal management information). Exposures originated and managed in Ireland and the United Kingdom represent a material concentration of credit risk. The Group has exposures to residential mortgages and to a range of corporate customers in different sectors, in particular exposures to investors in commercial property and residential property. Developers of commercial and residential property, particularly in Ireland, are facing especially challenging market conditions and commercial property prices have shown significant declines over the past two and a half years (see further details below under the risk factor “The Group is exposed to declining property values and a deterioration in the performance of the residential and commercial property markets, particularly in Ireland and the United Kingdom”). Beyond this sector, economic and financial conditions have deteriorated more broadly. Interest rates may rise in the Group’s main markets, which may lead to, amongst other things, further declines in values of collateral and investments, increasing unemployment, weakening consumer and corporate spending, declining corporate profitability, declining equity markets and bond markets and an increase in corporate insolvencies. As further detailed below (see the risk factor “The Group is exposed to declining property values and a deterioration in the performance of the residential and commercial property markets, particularly in Ireland and the United Kingdom”), residential property prices continue to be under severe pressure in Ireland.
 
Many borrowers in Ireland and the United Kingdom borrow on short-term fixed or discounted floating rates and when such rates expire the continued reduced supply and stricter terms of lending together with the potential for higher borrowing rates has led, and may continue to lead, to higher loan default rates. In spite of the United Kingdom economy’s recent improvement, unemployment rates could still increase and lead to higher loan default rates in the United Kingdom in the future. According to Central Statistics Office data, the standardised unemployment rate in March 2010 in Ireland was 13.4% (Source: CSO Live Register, March 2010). In Ireland, the consensus expectation is that the unemployment rate will peak at approximately 13.6% (Source: Reuters Poll, March 2010). Increased


14


Table of Contents

unemployment would also be likely to result in higher loan default rates. These developments could materially adversely impact the Group’s ability to recover on these loans or lead to significant write-downs of investments.
 
The Group has also been exposed to increased counterparty risk as a result of financial institution and corporate failures and nationalisations and will continue to be exposed to the risk of loss if counterparty financial institutions or other corporate borrowers fail or are otherwise unable to meet their obligations.
 
Increased volatility in financial markets has resulted in, and may continue to result in, reduced asset valuations which could further adversely affect the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Significant falls in perceived or actual asset values have resulted from previous market events. Increased volatility and further dislocation affecting certain financial markets and asset classes could further impact the Group’s financial condition, results of operations and prospects. In the future these factors could have an impact on the mark-to-market valuations of assets in the Group’s available for sale (“AFS”), trading portfolios and assets and liabilities designated at fair value through profit and loss. In addition, any further deterioration in the performance of the assets in Bank of Ireland’s AFS portfolio could lead to additional impairment losses. The AFS portfolio accounted for 12% of total Group assets as at December 31, 2009.
 
The Group is exposed to declining property values and a deterioration in the performance of the residential and commercial property markets, particularly in Ireland and the United Kingdom.
 
As at December 31, 2009, total loans and advances to customers (pre-impairment provisions and excluding assets held for sale to NAMA) were approximately €122.4 billion and included €61 billion of residential mortgages (of which €29 billion were in Ireland and €32 billion in the United Kingdom) and €24 billion of property and construction lending (of which €12 billion was in Ireland, €10 billion in the United Kingdom and €2 billion in the rest of the world). In respect of the property and construction lending, €21 billion was investment property lending with the remaining €3 billion being exposure to landbank and development lending.
 
Declining residential and commercial property prices have led to a significant slowdown in the construction sector in Ireland and the United Kingdom. Economic and other factors, including general deterioration in the economy and dislocation of the financial system, may lead to further contraction in the residential mortgage and commercial lending market and further decreases in residential and commercial property prices.
 
The Group has a material exposure to residential mortgages. 32% of the mortgages provided by the Group are to buy-to-let investors in Ireland and the United Kingdom (40% in Ireland and 60% in the United Kingdom). An excess supply of rental property or falls in rental demand could impact buy-to-let borrowers’ income and ability to service the loans. Borrowers for residential and buy-to-let properties may also have increased difficulties in servicing loans as a result of lower rental demand because capital growth will not be available to borrowers to offset any income losses. 8% of the total mortgage book of the Group was self- certified loans in the United Kingdom. The information submitted by borrowers in respect of these self-certified loans may have been incomplete or inaccurate and, as such, the Group may have incorrectly assessed the credit quality, willingness or ability of borrowers to repay these loans, which could result in higher than anticipated rates of arrears. Income verification on these self-certified loans depends on disclosures by borrowers of their income and may be subject to higher rates of arrears as a result of income expectations which are no longer achievable, reflecting the economic downturn which, when combined with reduced property values, may result in higher loan loss levels than for other mortgage types. These effects could be exacerbated if there is an increase in the rates of interest that are payable by borrowers generally.
 
The Group has exposure to a range of corporate customers in different sectors, in particular exposures to investors in the commercial and residential property sectors. Economic conditions have deteriorated and interest rates may rise in the Group’s main markets which may lead to, amongst other things, further declines in values of collateral and investments, increasing unemployment, weakening consumer and corporate spending, declining corporate profitability and an increase in corporate insolvencies. These developments could materially adversely impact the Group’s ability to recover the loans and interest in respect of these commercial property and residential lending portfolios or lead to significant write-downs of investments.


15


Table of Contents

The announcement of the establishment of NAMA has had an impact on the liquidity of property assets in Ireland. The volume of commercial property transactions, in particular, is currently at very low levels as market participants await further clarity as to what effects NAMA’s operations will have on the property market. The transfer of assets to NAMA could have further adverse consequences for the liquidity and value of property assets in Ireland, as NAMA is ultimately expected to control a significant quantum of property assets or property loans giving it a significant market presence. The discount on assets transferred to NAMA may have a material adverse impact on the values and liquidity of property generally, thereby reducing the value of collateral on many of the Group’s loans and thereby significantly increasing the rate of write-downs and/or impairment charges.
 
Developers of commercial and residential property, particularly in Ireland, are facing especially challenging market conditions. As discussed in the risk factor “Ireland: The Group’s businesses are subject to risks arising from general and sector specific economic conditions in Ireland, which have materially adversely affected the Group’s earnings and are likely to continue to affect its results, financial condition and prospects” the property market has suffered a very significant decline, with average house prices in Ireland falling by 18.5% in 2009 and 9.1% in 2008 (Source: Permanent TSB/ERSI House Price Index) and commercial property prices falling by 55.6% between September 2007 and December 2009 (Source: IPD Irish Commercial Property Index).
 
Residential property supply and demand has fallen sharply. Approximately 12,000 private new houses were completed in Ireland in the first half of 2009, from over 88,000 at the peak in 2006 (Source: Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government) and the number of new mortgages has fallen from over 110,000 in 2006 to approximately 25,000 in 2009 (Source: Irish Banking Federation/PwC Mortgage Market Profile).
 
Development loans, in particular, become more difficult to service in times of negative economic growth because the success of development investment is closely linked to an increase in overall demand for property in the economy and to positive economic growth. The overhang of unsold stock of completed residential units has caused an increase in, and may cause further increases in, the number of impaired development loans and in impairment charges. It has been, and may continue to be, uneconomic to develop land purchased and intended to be developed, which has the effect of reducing the value of collateral on many of the Group’s landbank and development loans and significantly increasing the rate of write-downs and impairment charges.
 
If the current economic downturn in Ireland continues, with further falls in house prices and increases in unemployment, the Group’s commercial property and residential mortgage lending portfolios may be exposed to further substantial increases in impairment charges, which could materially affect the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects. The effects of declining property values and any increases to interest rates payable by borrowers in the wider economy may also contribute to higher default rates and impairment losses on non-property commercial and consumer loans, which could materially adversely affect the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Market risks, including interest rate risk, foreign exchange risk, bond and equity price risk and other market risks, could materially adversely affect the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Market risk is the potential adverse change in the Group’s earnings or the value of its net assets arising principally from movements in, and increased volatility of, interest rates, bond and equity prices, exchange rates and other market prices. The Group’s average one day interest rate Trading Book Value at Risk (“VaR”) in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was €2.1 million. The major part of the Group’s proprietary risk is interest rate risk in the euro, Sterling and US dollar markets. Changes in interest rate or bond price levels in these or other markets where the Group holds proprietary risk positions may impact the value of assets, the value of liabilities or the margin received by the Group. The terms of existing loan commitments or facilities may mean that the Group is restricted in its ability to increase interest rates charged to customers in response to changes in interest rates that affect the costs of wholesale borrowing.
 
The Group is exposed to structural interest rate and structural foreign exchange risk. Structural interest rate risk arises from the existence of non-interest bearing assets and liabilities on the Group’s balance sheet. These consist mainly of non-interest bearing current accounts plus equity less fixed assets. Due to this structural risk exposure, changes in interest rates and the volatility of such changes may affect the net assets and earnings reported by the Group. Structural foreign exchange risk is defined as an entity’s non-trading net asset position in an entity’s non-


16


Table of Contents

euro currencies. Structural foreign exchange risk arises substantially from the Group’s net investment in its subsidiaries which report in Sterling. The Group’s Sterling net assets account for 59% of the total Group net assets. Changes in foreign exchange rates affect the euro value of assets and liabilities denominated in other currencies. Such changes and the degree of volatility of such changes may affect the net assets and earnings reported by the Group. A 10% appreciation of the euro against Sterling and the US Dollar at December 31, 2009 would have resulted in a loss in reserves of €399 million.
 
The Group is also exposed to the effect of changes in exchange rates on the translation value of its non-euro earnings, particularly its Sterling and US Dollar earnings. Substantial changes in interest or foreign exchange rates could have a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
While the Group has no significant direct exposure to equity markets (due to the fact that it does not hold proprietary equity investment or trading portfolios), it is indirectly exposed to equity markets through its asset management, custody, fund administration, private banking and life assurance businesses and its pension funds. In these business areas, equity investment is held on behalf of, or backs liabilities to, customers of the Group but revenue from these business areas is dependent on amongst other things, the market value of held equity investments. Changes in equity prices and the degree of volatility with respect thereto may affect the net assets and earnings reported by the Group.
 
Constraints on liquidity, lack of availability of funding and increased cost of funding could materially adversely affect the Group’s business.
 
Liquidity risk is the risk that a bank will be unable to meet its obligations, including funding commitments and deposit withdrawals, as they fall due. This risk is inherent in banking operations and can be heightened by an over-reliance on a particular source of funding (including, for example, short-term and overnight funding, securitisations and covered bonds), changes in credit ratings or market-wide phenomena such as disruption in the functioning of markets and major events or disasters of global significance. From mid-2007, credit markets worldwide experienced a severe reduction in liquidity and term funding. During this time, perception of counterparty risk between banks and the perception of the impact of sovereign credit risk on banks has also increased significantly. This increase in perceived counterparty risk led to reductions in inter-bank lending, and hence, in common with many other banking groups, the Group’s access to traditional sources of liquidity has been restricted. The availability of sources of liquidity on terms acceptable to the Group has been adversely impacted. The disruption in the functioning of funding markets led to the introduction of a range of government guarantee and liquidity assistance schemes in a number of countries, including Ireland.
 
Despite recent improvements in liquidity conditions and wholesale markets, the perception of counterparty and country risk has remained at elevated levels. Furthermore, despite the introduction of the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme, the terms on which such funding is available are more onerous and expensive than was the case prior to mid-2007. Should the global economy and the global financial system deteriorate further, the Group’s cost of funding may rise and access to liquidity may be further constrained.
 
The Group qualifies for access to the liquidity operations offered by Monetary Authorities for so long as it meets certain eligibility criteria relating to collateral which it can provide to Monetary Authorities. The Group holds a significant pool of contingent liquidity collateral, comprised of debt securities and other eligible collateral which is capable of being pledged against borrowings from Monetary Authorities. If the quality of the Group’s collateral fundamentally deteriorates, or if Monetary Authorities materially change eligibility criteria, the Group’s ability to access Monetary Authorities’ liquidity operations may become less flexible which could adversely affect the Group. The quality of the Group’s collateral may also be influenced by the sovereign rating of Ireland (see the risk factor “Further downgrades to the Irish sovereign ratings or outlook could impair the Group’s access to funding, trigger additional collateral requirements and weaken its competitive position” for further information).


17


Table of Contents

The Group relies on customer deposits to fund a considerable portion of its loan portfolio, the ongoing availability of which is sensitive to factors outside the Group’s control. Loss of consumer confidence in the Group’s business or in banking businesses generally, among other things, could result in unexpectedly high levels of customer deposit withdrawals, which could have a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and liquidity prospects.
 
The Group’s largest single source of funding is customer deposits, which represented approximately 50% of total Group funding at December 31, 2009. Medium-term growth in the Group’s lending activities will depend, in part, on the availability of customer deposits on appropriate terms, for which there is increasing competition. The Group has sought to increase its reliance on customer deposits in the recent past given the challenges in accessing wholesale funding. Increases in the cost of customer deposits will affect the Group’s margins and profit, while a lack of availability of such deposit funding could affect the Group’s future growth.
 
The ongoing availability of these deposits to fund the Group’s loan portfolio is subject to potential changes in certain factors outside the Group’s control, such as a loss of confidence of depositors in either the economy in general, the financial services industry or the Group specifically, ratings downgrades, significant further deterioration in economic conditions and the availability and extent of deposit guarantees (including as a result of regulatory changes to deposit guarantee schemes and/or changes to the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and/or the ELG Scheme). These factors could lead to a reduction in the Group’s ability to access customer deposit funding on appropriate terms in the future and to sustained deposit outflows, both of which would impact on the Group’s ability to fund its operations and meet its minimum liquidity requirements. In such circumstances, if the current challenges in the wholesale funding markets were not resolved or Monetary Authority lending to financial institutions is withdrawn or curtailed, it is likely that wholesale funding would prove more difficult and costly to obtain.
 
Any loss in consumer confidence in the Group’s banking businesses or in banking businesses generally, could significantly increase the amount of retail deposit withdrawals in a short space of time. Should the Group experience an unusually high level of withdrawals, this may have an adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects and could, in extreme circumstances, prevent the Group from funding its operations and meeting its minimum liquidity requirements. In such extreme circumstances the Group may not be in a position to continue to operate without additional funding support, which it may be unable to access.
 
The termination of, or changes to the operation of, or the participation by the Group in, the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme or changes in the terms of the Group’s participation in such schemes could have an adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
The ELG Scheme facilitates participating institutions, including the Group, in issuing debt securities and taking deposits which are due to mature after the expiry of the CIFS Guarantee Scheme on September 29, 2010. The ELG Scheme was approved by the European Commission under State aid rules on November 20, 2009 and by the Houses of the Oireachtas (parliament of Ireland) on December 3, 2009 and commenced on December 9, 2009. The Bank became a participating institution in the ELG Scheme on January 11, 2010.
 
The CIFS Guarantee Scheme and ELG Scheme are currently scheduled to expire on September 29, 2010 (bonds and deposits issued under the ELG Scheme before September 29, 2010 will be covered up to maturity, subject to a maximum maturity of five years). The ELG Scheme’s current approval by the European Commission under EU State aid rules is subject to review by the end of June 2010. Arising from this review, the European Commission could require the amendment or cessation of the ELG Scheme.
 
On March 30, 2010 the Minister for Finance announced that he would be seeking European Commission approval for an extension of a modified ELG Scheme consistent with its phasing out over a realistic period of time. The next review of this scheme is due for completion by the end of June 2010. Notwithstanding this announcement, the nature of the proposed extension is subject to approval by the European Commission and this could be influenced by a range of factors including EU policy. In addition, on November 9, 2009, the ECB highlighted that guarantees of short term bank debt (maturity profile of less than three months) and interbank deposits should be avoided to the extent possible and, as such, there is a risk that in its review of the ELG Scheme to be completed by the end of June 2010, the European Commission could require that the ELG Scheme, which currently covers short term bank debt and interbank deposits, be amended so as to limit the guarantee coverage of these forms of liability in the future.


18


Table of Contents

The cancellation or material amendment of the ELG Scheme prior to the scheduled expiry date of the Issuance Window on September 29, 2010 following the review by the European Commission by the end of June 2010 could introduce systemic weakness to the Irish banking sector and remove an important element of liquidity support for the sector as a whole. As such, the cancellation or material amendment of the ELG Scheme, or the removal of the Group from the ELG Scheme prior to its planned expiry could adversely affect the terms on which the Group would be able to access funding. The Group’s financial position may also be impacted by material changes to the costs of participating in the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and/or the ELG Scheme, which may be changed at the discretion of Minister for Finance and the European Commission.
 
While a key focus for the Group is to reduce its reliance on the Government Guarantee Schemes, should the ELG Scheme be extended, the Group could, in order to meet market expectations, continue to participate in the ELG Scheme and the on-going cost of the ELG Scheme could adversely affect the Group’s financial performance and delay it from achieving its financial targets.
 
Furthermore, should the expiry of the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme on September 29, 2010 lead to unanticipated adverse impacts on the Group’s funding markets, the Group may suffer constraints on liquidity that could materially adversely affect the Group’s business.
 
The Irish banking system may restructure and change significantly which could have a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
The banking system in Ireland was impacted by the systemic issues facing the financial sector globally caused by factors such as the collapse of sub-prime mortgage lending in the US, the failure of a number of high profile financial institutions, such as Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns, the global credit crisis and rapidly deteriorating economic conditions, particularly in Ireland. Arising from these events, there have been a number of Government and market responses impacting or potentially impacting on the structure of the Irish banking sector, including:
 
•  The Government has taken or has announced that it is likely to take steps to support or recapitalise substantially certain of the domestic major Irish banks and building societies and in doing so has taken, or has announced that it is likely to take, significant equity positions in certain of the major domestic Irish banks and building societies, in some cases amounting to majority voting control or nationalisation.
 
•  On January 19, 2010 the Government announced a framework for an investigation into the factors which contributed to the Irish banking crisis within the context of the international economic and financial environment at that time (for further information see page 29).
 
•  The Government also announced on March 30, 2010, the introduction of proposed new legislation that will amend the manner in which Irish financial institutions are regulated.
 
•  There is the possibility that the Government may support initiatives to develop a “third force” in Irish banking, created by the possible merger of several smaller financial institutions.
 
The Directors believe it is possible that, arising from these responses to the banking crisis in Ireland, a restructuring of the Irish banking system may occur in addition to the changes that have happened to date. It is unclear what form any such restructuring might take or over what timeframe it might occur.
 
It is also unclear whether such restructuring might take place on a market driven basis or whether other factors such as the involvement of the European Commission or the Government would have an impact. As a material part of the Group’s business and activities are in Ireland, the competitive position of the Group in the Irish banking system may be materially adversely affected by any such restructuring.
 
The NPRFC Investment, the Government Transaction and NAMA are the subject of a review by the European Commission under EU State aid rules, the outcome of which is uncertain and may involve the prohibition of some or all elements of the State aid provided to the Group by the Government, the requirement for the Group to repay the State aid, or the imposition of conditions on the Group that may be materially adverse to its interests.
 
The NPRFC Investment, the Government Transaction (which comprises the NPRFC Placing, Warrant Cancellation, the NPRFC Rights Issue Undertaking, the amendment of the rights attaching to the 2009 Preference Stock and the


19


Table of Contents

other transactions, rights and obligations set out in the Government Transaction Agreement as more particularly described on page 22 and the Group’s participation in NAMA are the subject of an ongoing review by the European Commission under EU State aid rules. As a consequence of the State aid provided to the Group under these measures, an EU Restructuring Plan for the Group was required to be prepared by the Group and submitted by the Department of Finance to the European Commission for approval under EU State aid rules. As part of this process, discussions are ongoing between the European Commission, the Group and the Department of Finance in relation to the draft EU Restructuring Plan. Although the EU Restructuring Plan has not been finalised, the European Commission has communicated that it will require the Group to effect certain structural (through divestments and wind-downs) and behavioural measures. Furthermore, the Irish Government is proposing to introduce a set of measures for the Irish banking sector which would complement the specific measures agreed as part of the individual European Commission restructuring plans for Irish banks that are subject to Restructuring under EU State aid rules (among which includes the EU Restructuring Plan) (“Irish Government Measures”). The exact scope and extent of the Irish Government Measures as at the date of this Form 20-F is not known to the Group. Based on the status of these negotiations, details of those elements which the Group considers likely to form part of the final EU Restructuring Plan are set out in note 58 to the Consolidated financial statements.
 
The decision regarding the approval of the Irish Government Measures, including the terms of the final EU Restructuring Plan, will be taken by the European Commission. As at the date of this Form 20-F, there can be no certainty as to the outcome of the State aid proceedings and the content of the final EU Restructuring Plan (including in relation to the Irish Government Measures). In particular, the final EU Restructuring Plan may differ from the Group’s expectations set out in note 58 to the Consolidated financial statements.
 
If the European Commission does not approve the EU Restructuring Plan in substantially the form prepared by the Group in consultation with the Department of Finance (as amended in discussions with the European Commission), the European Commission would instead likely open a formal investigation into State aid given to the Group. At the conclusion of this investigation, the European Commission could impose conditions that are more disadvantageous, potentially materially so, to the Group than those in the proposed EU Restructuring Plan. In particular, the Group could be required to dispose of a significantly larger proportion of its assets and/or agree to a significantly more stringent divestment timetable or more onerous behavioural restrictions than those contemplated in the proposed EU Restructuring Plan. Any more extensive remedies could have a greater and materially more negative impact on the Group’s business, operations and competitive position than would be the case if the Group implemented the proposed EU Restructuring Plan. In such circumstances, unless, during the course of the formal investigation, a revised EU Restructuring Plan was submitted that was acceptable to the European Commission, the European Commission may, instead of imposing more disadvantageous conditions as described above, require the Irish Government to recover the State aid from the Group. At any stage of the process, the Group could challenge any European Commission decision adverse to the interests of the Group in the EU courts. However, should the Group ultimately be unsuccessful in any such challenge, the Group would be required to comply with the Commission’s decision and therefore, the consequences for the Group could, as described above, be significantly adverse to the Group’s interests.
 
In addition, it is possible that even if the European Commission does approve the EU Restructuring Plan in substantially the form prepared by the Group in consultation with the Department of Finance (as amended in discussions with the European Commission), a third party may challenge that decision in the EU courts. If such a challenge were to emerge and succeed, the European Commission would need to reconsider its decision, which may result in any of the adverse outcomes described above.
 
The Group could be subject to a variety of risks as a result of implementing the EU Restructuring Plan in the form prepared by the Group in consultation with the Department of Finance in relation to the divestment and wind-down measures. There is no assurance that the price that the Group receives for any assets sold pursuant to the final EU Restructuring Plan will be at a level the Group considers adequate or which it could obtain in circumstances in which the Group was not required to sell such assets in order to implement the EU Restructuring Plan or if such sale were not subject to the restrictions contained in the terms thereof. In particular, should the Group fail to complete the divestments required by the EU Restructuring Plan, namely, New Ireland Assurance Company plc, Bank of Ireland Asset Management Limited, ICS Building Society, Foreign Currency Exchange Corporation and its stakes in Paul Capital Investments LLC and the Irish Credit Bureau Limited, within the relevant time periods set out in the


20


Table of Contents

EU Restructuring Plan, a divestiture trustee(s) could be appointed by the European Commission to conduct the sale, with a mandate to complete the disposal with no minimum price (including at a negative price). Furthermore, if by a certain time, the Group has failed to implement its commitment to run-off its UK intermediary mortgage portfolio to a certain level under the EU Restructuring Plan, then Bank of Ireland will be required to ensure that within a certain period, on a consolidated basis, its consolidated loans to customers will at least be matched by consolidated customer deposits plus wholesale funding greater than one year (i.e., the ratio of Bank of Ireland customer loans to Bank of Ireland customer deposits plus wholesale funding greater than one year will not be more than 100%). In implementing the final EU Restructuring Plan, the Group will lose existing customers, deposits and other assets through the sale of businesses and potentially suffer damage to the rest of the Group’s business arising from implementing the final EU Restructuring Plan regarding the divestment measures, and the potential for realising additional associated revenues and margins that it otherwise might have achieved in the absence of such disposals may be inhibited. Such implementation may also result in disruption to the retained business impacting on customers, and could result in separation costs which could potentially be substantial.
 
The Group will also be subject to a variety of other risks as a result of implementing the EU Restructuring Plan in the form prepared by the Group in consultation with the Department of Finance in relation to the expected behavioural measures. The implementation of these behavioural measures by the Group may lead to the emergence of new competitors in the Irish market and the emergence of stronger current competitors in the Irish market which could have a material adverse impact on the performance of the Group. In implementing the behavioural measures, the Group may be required to provide access to its customers for the benefit of new and current competitors. This, and other potential consequences of implementing the behavioural measures, will mean that the Group could lose some existing customers and deposits and, through damage to the Group’s business arising from implementing such measures, damage the potential for the Group to gain customers and realise additional associated revenues and margins that it otherwise might have achieved in the absence of such behavioural measures. Such implementation may also result in disruption to the Group’s business, which may impact adversely on its customers and could result in operational costs which could potentially be substantial. A monitoring trustee(s) (and possibly a divestment trustee(s)) will be appointed in respect of the EU Restructuring Plan and the actions of the monitoring trustee(s) (and any divestment trustee(s)) may further adversely impact on the Group and its performance.
 
In addition, the Group could be subject to a variety of risks as a result of the implementation of the Irish Government Measures, the exact scope and extent of which is not known to the Group at the date of this Form 20-F. The implementation of these Irish Government Measures may lead, for example, to the emergence of new competitors in the Irish market and the emergence of stronger current competitors in the Irish market which could have a material adverse affect on of the performance of the Group. These, and other potential consequences of the implementation of the Irish Government Measures, will mean that the Group could lose existing business, and potentially, adversely affect the Group’s business, as well as adversely affect the potential for the Group to gain customers and realise additional associated revenues and margins that it otherwise might have achieved in the absence of such Irish Government Measures.
 
The effect of implementing the final EU Restructuring Plan and the Irish Government Measures may be the emergence of one or more new competitors and/or a material strengthening of one or more of the Group’s existing competitors in the Irish banking market. There can be no assurance that the Group will be able to continue to compete as effectively (whether against existing or new or strengthened competitors) and maintain or improve its revenues and margins in the resulting competitive environment, which could adversely affect the Group’s results, operations and financial condition and its business generally.
 
On February 26, 2010, the European Commission approved the establishment of NAMA under EU State aid rules. The European Commission will assess the compatibility of the transferred assets under EU State aid rules as they are separately notified by the Government (in particular in relation to the transfer price). As a result, the transfer of assets by the Bank to NAMA will be subject to assessment by the European Commission to ensure the ongoing compatibility of the implementation of NAMA under the EU State aid rules. As at the date of this Form 20-F, there can be no certainty as to the outcome of such an assessment by the European Commission and such an assessment could adversely affect the Group’s results, operations and financial condition and its business generally.


21


Table of Contents

If any or all of the risks described in this paragraph materialise or have a greater impact than expected or any other currently unforeseen risks materialise, there could be a negative impact which could be material on the Group’s business, operations and competitive position.
 
The Group’s participation in the CIFS Guarantee Scheme, the ELG Scheme, the NPRFC Investment, NAMA and the Government Transaction could require the Group to implement operational policies that could materially adversely affect the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
The terms and conditions of the CIFS Guarantee Scheme, the ELG Scheme, the NPRFC Investment, NAMA and the Government Transaction place certain restrictions on, and require the Group to submit to a degree of governmental regulation in relation to, the operation of the Group’s business.
 
Under the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme, the Minister for Finance may impose restrictions on the expansion of capital and lending activity of the Group as a covered institution, the declaration and payment of dividends and the implementation of buy-backs or share redemptions. No covered institution, including the Bank, may acquire shares in any other credit institution or financial institution, establish subsidiaries or enter into or acquire new business(es) where such activities would increase the liability of the covered institution under the CIFS Guarantee Scheme. In addition, the NTMA may issue directions to covered institutions to comply with some or all of the provisions of conduct, transparency and reporting requirements applicable to covered institutions under the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme.
 
In connection with the NPRFC Investment and pursuant to the terms of the Subscription Agreement, the Bank provided warranties in respect of certain matters relating to the financial position and commercial activities of the Bank and is required to consult with the Minister for Finance in respect of matters reasonably expected to have a public interest dimension. The Bank must also use all reasonable efforts to comply with the customer package set out in Appendix I to the announcement issued by the Department of Finance on February 11, 2009, which includes, among other things, increasing lending capacity to SMEs and providing additional mortgage lending capacity for first time buyers, compliance with the Code of Conduct for Business Lending to Small and Medium Enterprises and compliance with the Code of Conduct for Mortgage Arrears.
 
Under the Government Transaction Agreement the Bank has committed to promote the availability of credit and the development of the Irish economy, including the commitment to use all reasonable efforts to meet a lending target of €3 billion per annum for new or increased credit facilities to SMEs in Ireland in each of the twelve month periods starting on April 1, 2010 and April 1, 2011.
 
Under the terms of the Credit Review Guidelines, issued pursuant to the NAMA Act, Participating Institutions’ decisions to refuse credit facilities to SMEs, sole traders and farming enterprises for sums of between €1,000 and €250,000 are subject to review, if requested by the applicant, by the Credit Reviewer on the grounds of the viability and repayment capacity of the applicant. While the Credit Reviewer does not have the power to override the lending decision of the Participating Institution, if a Participating Institution does not comply with a recommendation of the Credit Reviewer, it is required to provide an explanation for this refusal.
 
The implementation of some or all of these measures could entail the Group effecting policies that it might not otherwise implement on purely commercial grounds. In particular, implementing these policies could result in a concentration of lending by the Group to SMEs in Ireland. As such, these measures could have an adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Further details on the Group’s relationship with the Government through its participation in NAMA, the NPRFC Investment, the CIFS Guarantee Scheme, the ELG Scheme and the Government Transaction are set out in note 55 in the notes to the Consolidated financial statements.
 
Participation in NAMA may subject the Group to directions from the Financial Regulator, NAMA, the Minister for Finance or the European Commission which could have a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
By virtue of the Group’s participation in NAMA, the Group could be subject to additional directions from the Financial Regulator and/or the Minister for Finance as to the conduct of its business in addition to the restrictions


22


Table of Contents

and potential restrictions arising out of the NPRFC Investment and the Group’s participation in the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and ELG Scheme and the law and regulation applicable to credit institutions. See risk factor entitled “The Group’s participation in the CIFS Guarantee Scheme, the ELG Scheme, the NPRFC Investment, NAMA and the Government Transaction could require the Group to implement operational policies that could materially adversely affect the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects”.
 
In addition, as a condition of the Group’s participation in NAMA, the Group will not have control over which of the Group’s loans are transferred to NAMA. The NAMA Act provides that the Group shall not, without the prior written approval of NAMA, deal with Bank of Ireland Eligible Bank Assets other than in the ordinary course of its business, in any way which may impair NAMA’s interests, compromise any claim or vary any contract. These restrictions apply before any transfer to NAMA, and also apply in respect of assets eligible for transfer which do not actually transfer.
 
The Financial Regulator may direct the Group to provide any report that the Financial Regulator considers necessary to monitor the Group’s compliance with the obligations under or by virtue of the NAMA Act. The Financial Regulator could also exercise its power under the NAMA Act to require the consolidation or merger of Participating Institutions, including Bank of Ireland. Under the NAMA Act, the Group may also be required to provide such services as NAMA may direct and to comply with such monitoring of lending and balance sheet management as the Minister for Finance or the Financial Regulator may direct. A Participating Institution may also be directed by the Minister for Finance to draw up, or amend, a restructuring or business plan; and, if the Minister for Finance approves such plan, the Participating Institution is obliged to take all reasonable steps to implement it. The European Commission will assess the compatibility (and, in particular, the actual transfer price) of the transferred assets when they are notified by the Government and this includes a claw-back mechanism in the case of excess payments. Such an assessment could have an adverse effect on the Group.
 
These directions could restrict the Group’s balance sheet growth, limit the Group’s ability to make acquisitions or require the Group to dispose of assets, including its loan portfolios. Any such directions may adversely affect the Group’s profitability, financial condition and prospects.
 
Further details on the Group’s relationship with the Government through its participation in NAMA, the NPRFC Investment, the CIFS Guarantee Scheme, the ELG Scheme and the Government Transaction are set out in note 55 to the Consolidated financial statements.
 
The NPRFC could exercise its voting rights in a manner which is not aligned with the interests of the Group or its other stockholders.
 
The Government (through the NPRFC) is currently the largest holder of Ordinary Stock, holding approximately 36% from June 14, 2010. The NPRFC also holds all of the 2009 Preference Stock. Under the terms of the 2009 Preference Stock, if the Bank does not pay the cash dividend otherwise due on the 2009 Preference Stock, payable annually on February 20, it is required to issue units of Ordinary Stock to the NPRFC in lieu of the relevant cash dividend. This could arise if the Bank was precluded from paying dividends by virtue of the terms of a “dividend stopper” provision or by having inadequate distributable reserves at the relevant dividend declaration date. As further described in the risk factor “The Group is currently precluded from paying dividends or distributions on certain instruments affected by the terms of a “dividend stopper”, including its 2009 Preference Stock and the ACSM Hybrids for a period of one calendar year from and including February 1, 2010. In the event that the Group remains, or subsequently becomes, precluded from paying, or elects not to pay, such dividend on the 2009 Preference Stock and/or the ACSM Hybrids, it will be required to issue units of Ordinary Stock to the holders of the 2009 Preference Stock (being the NPRFC) and/or to a trustee on behalf of the holders of the ACSM Hybrids, as the case may be. Consequently, the proportionate ownership and voting interests of Existing Stockholders will be diluted”, on Monday February 22, 2010, the Bank issued the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock to the NPRFC in lieu of a cash dividend on the 2009 Preference Stock, which was otherwise due on February 20, 2010. If the Bank is precluded from paying, or elects not to pay, any future annual dividend on the 2009 Preference Stock, this will result in the issue of further units of Ordinary Stock to the NPRFC. This could ultimately result in the Government holding a significantly larger stake in the Bank.


23


Table of Contents

Through the NPRFC’s stockholding of approximately 36% (as of June 14, 2010) in the Bank and other relationships with the Group, the Government is in a position to exert significant influence over the Group and its business. As the holder of the 2009 Preference Stock the NPRFC has the right to directly appoint 25% of the directors of the Group (such 25% to include any directors nominated by the Minister for Finance pursuant to the CIFS Guarantee Scheme). The tabling of any resolution at a General Court of the Bank to alter the capital structure of the Group requires the prior approval in writing of the Minister for Finance. These rights apply in full for so long as the NPRFC holds any units of 2009 Preference Stock and they are not reduced in line with any reduction in the number of units of 2009 Preference Stock held. In addition, as the holder of the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock, the NPRFC is entitled to exercise the voting rights attaching to these units of Ordinary Stock.
 
As a result, the Government, through the NPRFC, is in a position to exert an influence over the Group’s business and there is a risk that the Government could exercise its voting rights in a manner which may not always be aligned with the interests of the Group’s other Stockholders.
 
A change in Government policy or the Irish Government could have a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition, liquidity and prospects.
 
Irish Government policy in respect of the banking sector, including its supervision, regulation, recapitalisation and structure, has and will continue to have a major impact on the Group. The Irish Government can implement its policy by utilising its extensive powers under existing legislation, the introduction of new or amended legislation or, in the Group’s case, the exercise of its stockholder and other rights pursuant to the NPRFC’s stockholding in the Bank. There can be no guarantee that the current policies of the Irish Government will be continued and the introduction of new Government policies or the amendment of existing policies could have a significant impact on the Group’s results, financial condition, liquidity and prospects. Such policies could be introduced by either the current Government or a new Government constituted by different members or parties from the currently elected Oireachtas (Irish Parliament) or appointed following a general election, which may be called by the current Government at any time before the end of the term of the current Government in July 2012.
 
The discount on disposal of Bank of Ireland Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA may exceed the Group’s estimate of €4.4 billion (arrived at using the methods and assumptions outlined on page 57) (including impairment provisions of €2.8 billion at December 31, 2009), and if it did it would adversely impact the Group’s capital and results of operations. Even after the transfer of assets to NAMA, the Group is exposed to some of NAMA’s losses in the event that NAMA has an underlying loss at the conclusion of its operations.
 
As stated by the Minister for Finance on March 30, 2010, NAMA is now operational and the Group has since transferred Tranche 1 NAMA Assets of €1.9 billion (before impairment provisions) for which it received consideration of €1.2 billion in Government guaranteed bonds and non-guaranteed subordinated bonds.
 
A number of uncertainties remain as to the specific quantum and mix of subsequent Bank of Ireland Eligible Bank Assets which may transfer to NAMA, the timing of those transfers, the price that NAMA would pay for those loans, the fees that the Group would be paid for any work undertaken in relation to such loans and the “fair value” of the consideration to be received. Therefore, a number of uncertainties remain as to the final discount to book value on the total amount of Bank of Ireland Eligible Bank Assets transferred to NAMA and there can be no assurance that the actual discount applied to Bank of Ireland Eligible Bank Assets transferring to NAMA will not be greater than that estimated by the Directors.
 
If the incremental loss which the Group is required to recognise as a result of the transfer of assets to NAMA is significantly greater than the Directors expect, this may result in a further diminution of the capital base of the Group and may result in the need for additional capital.
 
In addition, the application of a discount to the Bank of Ireland Eligible Bank Assets that is significantly greater than currently anticipated could result in the Group being subject to downgrades in its credit ratings. See the risk factor “A series of further downgrades to the Group’s credit ratings or credit outlook could impair the Group’s access to funding, either by borrowing or through access to capital markets, trigger additional collateral requirements and/or weaken its competitive position”.


24


Table of Contents

If NAMA makes a loss the shortfall up to the value of the non-guaranteed subordinated bonds issued by NAMA will be shared by the Participating Institutions, including the Group, up to the amount of the non-guaranteed subordinated bonds issued in proportion to each institution’s share of the total non-guaranteed subordinated bonds issued by NAMA. Such a shortfall could occur if the ultimate sales proceeds and income generated on the Eligible Bank Assets transferred to NAMA fail to cover the initial consideration paid and interest costs and expenses incurred by NAMA. As such, in the event that NAMA makes a loss on its operations, these subordinated securities could ultimately prove to be of little or no value to the Group, which could have an adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Further, if after the sharing of losses up to the value of the non-guaranteed subordinated bonds with the Participating Institutions NAMA makes an underlying loss at the conclusion of its operations calculated by reference to the Eligible Bank Assets it acquires from all the Participating Institutions (not just Bank of Ireland), the Group may be required to pay a tax surcharge to the Government which, depending on the quantum of underlying loss, may be significant and which could have an adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects. The tax surcharge payable to the Government will be apportioned to each Participating Institution on the basis of the book value of the Eligible Bank Assets acquired by NAMA from each Participating Institution concerned as a proportion of the total book value of the Eligible Bank Assets acquired by NAMA from all of the Participating Institutions.
 
A series of further downgrades to the Group’s credit ratings or credit outlook could impair the Group’s access to funding, either by borrowing or through access to capital markets, trigger additional collateral requirements and/or weaken its competitive position
 
As at June 7, 2010, the last practicable date prior to publication of this Form 20-F, the long-term (outlook) / short-term (outlook) credit ratings for the Group are A-(stable) / A-2 (stable) from Standard & Poor’s, A1(stable) / P-1(stable) from Moody’s Investor Service, A-(stable) / F1(stable) from Fitch Ratings and AA(Outlook Negative)/R-1 (Middle) (Outlook Stable) from DBRS. These credit ratings reflect the most recent action by Standard & Poor’s on January 26, 2010 to lower the credit ratings of the Group from A(negative watch) / A-1(negative watch) to A-(stable) / A-2(stable) as part of a general downgrade of Irish financial institutions, which led to an outflow of some ratings sensitive international deposits. While the Group believes that the probability of a material credit rating downgrade occurring in the next 12 months is relatively low, there can be no guarantee that the Group will not be subject to further downgrades and any further downgrades in the credit ratings of the Group could have a materially negative impact on the volume and pricing of its funding and its financial position, limit the Group’s access to the capital and funding markets, trigger material collateral requirements in derivative contracts or other secured-funding arrangements and weaken the Group’s competitive position in certain markets. In addition, the availability of deposits is often dependent on credit ratings and a series of further downgrades would be likely to lead to significant withdrawals of corporate or retail deposits which would result in a material deterioration in the Group’s funding and liquidity position and may have systemic implications for the Irish banking system.
 
See the risk factors “Constraints on liquidity, lack of availability of funding and increased cost of funding could materially adversely affect the Group’s business” and “Further downgrades to the Irish sovereign ratings or outlook could impair the Group’s access to funding, trigger additional collateral requirements and weaken its competitive position” above for further information.
 
The Group operates in competitive markets (subject to some price regulation) which are subject to significant change and uncertainty which could have a material adverse effect on its results, financial condition and prospects.
 
The Group is subject to significant competition in the markets in which it operates and some of its competitors are larger and have greater financial resources than the Group. The markets for financial services within which the Group operates are highly competitive. It is anticipated that such competition may intensify in response to regulatory actions, competitor behaviour, consumer demand, technological changes, the impact of consolidation, new market entrants and other factors. In the event that financial markets remain unstable, competitor and market consolidation may accelerate.
 
In particular, competitive pricing pressures may limit the Group’s ability to normalise its deposit rates and increase rates on customer loans which would prevent the Group restoring its net interest margin to target average levels


25


Table of Contents

which is a key driver of future profitability. In addition, the Group could also encounter difficulties in increasing interest rates to borrowers, particularly in respect of residential mortgages, due to the reputational impact such increases could have on the Group in the Irish market, and the political and/or legislative consequences that such an impact could have for the Group. Any of these events could have an adverse impact on net interest margins, and consequently on the results and financial condition of the Group.
 
Intervention by Monetary Authorities in the banking sector may impact the competitive position of the Group relative to its international competitors who may be subject to intervention of a different quantum and nature, potentially putting the Group at a competitive disadvantage in certain markets. Competition may increase in some or all of the Group’s principal markets and may have an adverse effect on its results, financial condition and prospects.
 
The Group is subject to extensive regulation and oversight. Failure to comply with its regulatory obligations and to manage the associated risks properly could have a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
The Group is subject to a wide variety of banking, insurance and financial services laws and regulations together with a large number of regulatory and enforcement authorities in each of the jurisdictions in which it operates. All of these are subject to change, particularly in the current market environment, where there have been unprecedented levels of government intervention and changes to the regulations governing financial institutions, including nationalisations of financial institutions in Ireland, the United Kingdom, the United States and other European countries. In the wake of the current difficult economic conditions and ongoing concerns regarding the regulation of the financial sector, new regulatory provisions may be introduced to which Bank of Ireland could be subject either at national, EU or international level. As a result of these and other ongoing and possible future changes in the financial services regulatory landscape (including requirements imposed by virtue of the Group’s participation in any government or regulator-led initiatives), the Group expects to face greater regulation in Ireland, the United Kingdom, the United States (at a federal and state level) and other European countries in which it operates. Compliance with such regulations may increase the Group’s capital requirements and costs, could materially adversely affect its business, the products and services it offers and the value of its assets or require the Group to change certain of its business practices. As a result, the Group is exposed to regulatory and other risks, including:
 
•  the monetary, interest rate, capital adequacy and other policies of central banks and regulatory authorities;
 
•  general changes in government or regulatory policy or changes in regulatory regimes that may significantly influence investor decisions, in particular in markets in which the Group operates or may increase the costs of doing business in those markets;
 
•  measures required by the European Commission under the EU Restructuring plan;
 
•  changes to the financial reporting environment and/or standards;
 
•  changes in taxation legislation and its interpretation;
 
•  changes to the type, amount or proportion of assets that the Group is required to hold in order to account for liquidity risk or changes to the way in which the Group is required to fund its operations;
 
•  potential requirements to develop and maintain a wind-down plan, also known as a “living will”, in respect of the Group, which would set out a proposed strategy should the Group fail, in order to limit the cost to creditors, public funds and other disruption and which may require changes to the Group’s structure and operations;
 
•  changes to the amount and quality of regulatory capital that the Group’s life assurance business is required to hold;
 
•  other general changes in regulatory requirements, such as prudential rules relating to the capital adequacy framework and the imposition of onerous compliance obligations, restrictions on activities or business growth or pricing and requirements to operate in a way that prioritises objectives other than stockholder value creation;
 
•  changes in competition and pricing environments;


26


Table of Contents

 
•  changes in the market for banking sector assets, caused by widespread divestment of assets by financial institutions across the European Union in order to comply with State aid requirements;
 
•  changes to competition regulation and/or the regulation of the postal sector in the United Kingdom which may affect the joint ventures between the Group and Post Office Limited;
 
•  the application of new, or additional, regulatory regimes arising from a restructuring of the Group’s business such as to bring it within the jurisdiction of new or additional regulators;
 
•  differentiation amongst financial institutions by governments with respect to the extension of guarantees to bank customer deposits and the terms attaching to such guarantees, including requirements for the Group to accept exposure to the risk of any individual member of the Group, or even third party participants in guarantee schemes, failing;
 
•  implementation of, or costs related to, local customer or depositor compensation, guarantee or reimbursement schemes, including in the event a bank becomes unable to meet its obligations to customers, or changes to the funding or compensation limits of such schemes (including potential EU-wide harmonisation of the funding or compensation limits of deposit guarantee schemes as a result of the European Commission’s review of EC Directive 94/19/EC relating to such schemes);
 
•  expropriation, nationalisation and confiscation of assets and changes in legislation relating to foreign ownership; and
 
•  other unfavourable political, military or diplomatic developments producing social instability or legal uncertainty which, in turn, may affect demand for the Group’s products and services.
 
The Group is subject to extensive regulation and supervision in relation to the levels of capital in its business. The minimum regulatory capital requirements, as well as the manner in which existing regulatory capital is calculated, could change in the future, which could materially adversely affect the Group’s results, financial conditions and prospects.
 
As a result of the current environment and market events, the minimum regulatory requirements imposed on the Group, the manner in which the existing regulatory capital is calculated, the instruments that qualify as regulatory capital and the capital tier to which those instruments are allocated, could be subject to change in the future. A number of regulatory initiatives have recently been proposed, which would significantly alter the Group’s capital requirements. These proposed initiatives include:
 
•  EU Directive 2009/111/EC (“CRD II”): CRD II is due to be implemented by December 31, 2010. In particular it will make changes to the criteria for assessing hybrid capital eligible to be included in Tier 1 Capital and may require the Group to replace, over a staged grandfathering period, existing capital instruments that do not fall within these revised eligibility criteria. Whilst it has been adopted into law, there is still significant uncertainty around the interpretation and the implementation of the Directive as it relates to the Bank.
 
•  The EU Capital Requirements Directive III (“CRD III”): CRD III is currently subject to consultation and implementation of the rules is expected by January 1, 2011. It will introduce a number of changes in response to the recent and current market conditions, which may:
 
  •  Increase the capital requirements for trading books to ensure that a firm’s assessment of the risks connected with its trading book better reflects the potential losses from adverse market movements in stressed conditions;
 
  •  Limit investments in re-securitisations and impose higher capital requirements for re-securitisations to make sure that firms take proper account of the risks of investing in such complex financial products; and
 
  •  Increase disclosure standards.
 
•  On December 16, 2009, the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, a forum for regular co-operation on banking supervisory matters, published a consultation paper entitled “Strengthening the resilience of the banking sector”. The consultation paper contains proposals to strengthen the global capital framework by,


27


Table of Contents

among other things, raising the quality of the Core Tier 1 Capital base in a harmonised manner (including through changes to the items which give rise to adjustments to that capital base), strengthening the risk coverage of the capital framework, promoting the build up of capital buffers and introducing a global minimum liquidity standard for the banking sector. The consultation paper was open for consultation until April 16, 2010 and any changes are not expected to be implemented until after 2012.
 
•  On February 26, 2010, the European Commission issued a public consultation document on further possible changes to the Capital Requirements Directive IV (“CRD IV”) which is closely aligned with the proposals of December 16, 2009 from the Basel Committee.
 
•  The Solvency II Directive (Directive 2009/138/EC), adopted by the European Parliament on April 22, 2009 and endorsed by the Council of Ministers on May 5, 2009, is a fundamental review of the capital adequacy regime for the European insurance industry. When implemented (required by October 31, 2012) the capital structure and overall governance of the Group’s life assurance business will alter significantly and this may have an impact on the capital structure of the Group.
 
Significant uncertainty remains around the final requirements and implementation of these proposed initiatives. If certain of these measures were implemented as currently proposed, in particular the changes proposed by the Basel Committee and the CRD IV consultation document relating to the definition of and instruments that are eligible to be included within the Core Tier 1 Capital base, they would be expected to have a significant impact on the capital and asset and liability management of the Group, which in turn would be expected to have an adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
If the Group proceeds to transfer part of its UK business to a newly-incorporated, wholly owned subsidiary, any such subsidiary could be subject to special resolution regime powers under the UK Banking Act 2009.
 
The Group has been actively considering transferring part of its UK business into a newly-incorporated, wholly owned subsidiary. The subsidiary would be likely to involve the Group’s Post Office joint ventures, its branch business in Northern Ireland and other parts of its UK business banking operations.
 
If this transfer were to take place, the newly-incorporated, wholly owned subsidiary would be regulated by the FSA, as a UK authorised bank, and be subject to the special resolution regime under the UK Banking Act 2009. If the subsidiary was in the future, in a position in which it was considered, in the opinion of the FSA, to be failing, or likely to fail, to meet the threshold authorisation conditions in the FSMA, it could become subject to the exercise of the special resolution regime powers granted to HM Treasury, the Bank of England and the FSA under the UK Banking Act 2009. These powers are: (a) to transfer all or part of the business of the subsidiary or the shares of the subsidiary to a private sector purchaser, (b) transfer all or part of the business of the subsidiary to a “bridge bank” wholly owned by the Bank of England, or (c) take the subsidiary into temporary UK Government ownership, with the corresponding risk of the loss of the Group’s UK business within its UK wholly owned subsidiary.
 
If the Group is required to hold higher levels of capital than anticipated by the market, this could have a material adverse impact on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Credit institutions, including the Group, are required to hold adequate capital at levels determined by regulatory requirements and market expectations. Due to the ongoing uncertainty in financial markets, market expectations may require international banks to hold Equity Tier 1 Capital, Core Tier 1 Capital, and Tier 1 Capital at levels higher than currently expected or the definitions of these capital tiers may be subject to change. As a consequence, this could require the Group to hold higher levels of capital than the minimum 7% Equity Tier 1 Capital and 8% Core Tier 1 Capital targets set by the Financial Regulator in its Prudential Capital Assessment Review announced on March 30, 2010. These higher expectations in turn could adversely impact the Group’s operational flexibility and reduce earnings growth and restrain the Bank’s ability to pay dividends.


28


Table of Contents

The Group may be subject to litigation proceedings and regulatory investigations which could have a material adverse impact on its results, financial condition and prospects.
 
The Group may be subject to significant litigation and regulatory investigation risks. As a result, the Group may become involved in various disputes and legal proceedings in Ireland, the United Kingdom, the United States and other jurisdictions, including litigation and regulatory investigations. For instance, in the United Kingdom, the FSA has the power to revoke the Group’s UK permissions if the FSA considers it necessary to do so in order to protect customers. Disputes and legal proceedings, if they occur, are subject to many uncertainties, and their outcomes are often difficult to predict, particularly in the earlier stages of a case or investigation. Adverse regulatory action or adverse judgments in litigation could result in restrictions or limitations on the Group’s operations or result in an adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
In addition, the outcome of current litigation and inquiries, including the outcome of appeals initiated by the Bank, disclosed in page 149 could be worse than expected and could have a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
If a court of law were to determine that the Bank is under a binding legal obligation to pay dividends on the 1992 Preference Stock, except in certain specified circumstances, the Bank could be required to compensate holders or former holders of the 1992 Preference Stock and could potentially be subject to claims by holders or former holders of Hybrid/Preferred Securities.
 
The Bank has received correspondence from certain holders of the 1992 Preference Stock asserting that the Bank is under a binding legal obligation to pay dividends on the 1992 Preference Stock except in certain specified circumstances. The Bank’s view, based on external legal advice, has been, and remains, that the payment of dividends on the 1992 Preference Stock is a matter for the discretion of the Bank. Accordingly, because “dividend stopper’ provisions applicable to the Bank precluded it from paying any dividends unless under a binding legal obligation to do so, no dividends were paid by the Bank on the 1992 Preference Stock in February 2010. If such dividends had been declared and paid, the total amounts payable to holders of the 1992 Preference Stock would have been €4.64 million and £2.4 million.
 
If court proceedings were initiated by any holders or former holders of the 1992 Preference Stock and a court ruled that the Bank is under a binding legal obligation to pay dividends on the 1992 Preference Stock except in certain specified circumstances and was, therefore, in breach of the terms of the 1992 Preference Stock by not paying a dividend to holders or former holders of the 1992 Preference Stock in February 2010, the Bank could be required to compensate such holders of the 1992 Preference Stock.
 
In relation to the Hybrid/Preferred Securities, no payments were made in February, March or April 2010 in respect of coupons which might otherwise have been paid on the Hybrid/Preferred Securities. The total amount of such payments would have been €12.4 million, £2.4 million and US$34.5 million, respectively. Due to the provisions of the Hybrid/Preferred Securities preventing payment of dividends on the 1992 Preference Stock for a period of one year following the non payment of coupons on the Hybrid/Preferred Securities, any determination by a court of law that the Bank is under a binding legal obligation to pay dividends on the 1992 Preference Stock except in certain specified circumstances could potentially result in claims by holders or former holders of the Hybrid/Preferred Securities.
 
The investigation into the factors which contributed to the Irish banking crisis announced by the Irish Government, may result in the Group incurring costs in facilitating and engaging with the investigation and may result, depending on the findings of the investigation, in reputational damage to the Group or further investigations into the Group’s conduct.
 
Investigation into the banking system
 
On January 19, 2010, the Minister for Finance announced a framework for an investigation into the factors which contributed to the Irish banking crisis within the context of the international economic and financial environment at that time.


29


Table of Contents

As part of the first stage of the investigation into the banking system, the Government commissioned two preliminary investigatory reports. A report on the functions of the CBFSAI over the period from the establishment of the Financial Regulator in May 2003 to the end of September 2008 has been prepared by the recently appointed Governor of the CBFSAI. A second report, dealing with an investigation into the specific factors within the Irish banking sector which exacerbated the impact of the international financial crisis for Ireland, has been prepared by independent experts appointed by the Minister. This preliminary report involved inquiry into the conduct, management and corporate governance of individual financial institutions, including the Bank.
 
Both preliminary reports have been submitted to the Minister and have been published. Their findings are expected to form the basis of the terms of reference of a formal statutory investigation (the “Statutory Commission of Investigation”) which will be established by the Government pursuant to the Commissions of Investigation Act, 2004. At the second stage of the investigation into the banking system, it is expected that the Statutory Commission of Investigation will examine the performance of individual banks and bank directors, the performance of regulatory authorities, the response of Government and Government agencies and the structure of the banking system in Ireland generally.
 
The Government anticipates that the Statutory Commission of Investigation will be established by June 30, 2010 and complete its work by the end of 2010, at which point its findings will be laid before the Finance and Public Service Oireachtas Committee for its consideration. Further inquiry may result from the findings of the Statutory Commission of Investigation, including the possibility of public hearings.
 
Further information including the preliminary reports are available on www. bankinginquiry.gov.ie.
 
Bank of Ireland may incur significant costs, including legal and financial adviser costs, in facilitating and/or engaging with these investigations, and any ancillary investigations that may arise following the initial investigations. The results of these investigations could also result in ancillary investigations that may result in sanctions or other actions being taken against the Group. In addition, the reports or findings (including preliminary findings) or submissions given in public or otherwise released in respect of these investigations could have an adverse effect on the Group’s reputation.
 
The Group may not succeed in implementing or fully implementing its plan to reduce the deficits in the defined benefit pension schemes it sponsors by a combination of benefit restructuring and additional employer contributions. In the event that these deficits result in the schemes becoming unable to meet their liabilities, the Group could elect to, or be required to, make additional, potentially significant, contributions to the schemes which could have a materially negative impact on the Group’s financial condition and trading performance. In addition, and notwithstanding the implementation of these plans to reduce the deficits, the Group may if appropriate, elect to, or may be required to, make further contributions to its pension schemes if the value of pension fund assets is not sufficient to cover potential obligations.
 
The Group sponsors a number of defined benefit pension schemes for past and current employees. As at December 31, 2009, these pension schemes had a deficit of €1.6 billion (calculated on the basis of IAS 19). As is set out in more detail in note 58 to the Consolidated financial statements, the Group has had extensive discussions with staff representative bodies in order to address this deficit by a combination of benefits restructuring and additional employer contributions over a period of time. If fully implemented, the benefits restructuring aspect of this proposed approach is estimated to deliver a reduction of approximately 50% in the total deficit across all schemes relative to the December 31, 2009 IAS 19 deficit position.
 
While this approach has been agreed (following its recommendation by an independent third party chairman) with the members, in respect of the main pension scheme (which accounts for approximately 85% of the total deficit across all schemes), there is no guarantee that the finalised proposals will be approved by all of the members.
 
As such, there is a risk that the proposed approach will not be fully implemented with all of the scheme members and that the deficit will not be reduced by the amount anticipated by the Group. In the event that the proposed approach fails to reduce these deficits, there is a risk that the pension schemes could fail to meet their liabilities. This could have a significant reputational impact on the Group. In these circumstances, the Group could choose to make additional contributions to the relevant schemes or could be obliged to make additional contributions to the


30


Table of Contents

schemes. Such contributions could be significant and may have a materially negative impact on the Group’s financial condition and trading performance.
 
In addition, and notwithstanding the implementation of the proposals to reduce the current pension scheme deficits outlined above, the pension funds are subject to market fluctuations and changes in the value of underlying securities, as well as interest rate risk and changes to actuarial assumptions. These fluctuations could impact on the value of the schemes’ asset portfolios and result in returns on the pension funds being less than expected and/or result in there being a greater than expected increase in the estimated value of the schemes’ liabilities. As a result, new or additional deficits in the schemes may arise which could result in the Group choosing or being obliged to make additional contributions to the schemes in the event those schemes became unable to meet their liabilities. Such contributions could be significant and may have a materially negative impact on the Group’s financial condition and trading performance.
 
Weaknesses or failures in the Group’s internal processes and procedures including IT or equipment failures and other operational risks could have a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects and could result in reputational damage.
 
The Group’s businesses are dependent on their ability to process and report, accurately and efficiently, a high volume of complex transactions across numerous and diverse products and services, in different currencies and subject to a number of different legal and regulatory regimes. Operational risks are inherently present in the Group’s businesses, including, as a result of potentially inadequate or failed internal processes (including financial reporting and risk monitoring processes), IT or equipment failures or the failure of external systems and controls including those of the Group’s suppliers or counterparties (supplier and counterparty systems, controls, and processes being entirely outside the control of the Group) or from people-related or external events, such as the risk of fraud and other criminal acts carried out against the Group.
 
The Group has obligations as a non-US registrant under US securities laws and regulations, including the requirement to comply, where applicable, with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (“SOx”). The Group has put in place a comprehensive framework to document and test its internal control structures and procedures in line with the requirements of Section 404 of SOx, which requires, among other things, certification by management regarding the effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting. There can, however, be no assurance that the risk-controls or loss-mitigation actions implemented will be effective in controlling each of the operational risks faced by the Group. Any weakness in these controls or actions could result in a material adverse impact on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects, as well as reputational damage which could exacerbate such adverse impact.
 
The Group’s life assurance business is subject to inherent risks involving claims, as well as market conditions generally.
 
Life assurance risk is the potential volatility in the amount and timing of claims caused by unexpected changes in mortality, longevity and morbidity. Mortality risk is the risk of deviations in timing and amounts of cash flows paid to policy holders (premiums and benefits) due to the incidence or non-incidence of death. Longevity risk is the risk of such deviations due to increasing life expectancy trends among policy holders and pensioners, resulting in payout ratios higher than those the Group originally accounted for. Morbidity risk is the risk of deviations in timing and amount of cash flows to policy holders (such as claims) due to the incidence or non-incidence of disability and sickness. A material change in relation to any of these risks could materially and adversely affect the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects. In addition, the Group’s life assurance business is subject to risks relating to the volatility in the value of the underlying assets held to meet its liabilities.
 
In Ireland and the Isle of Man, the Group is responsible for contributing to compensation schemes in respect of banks and other authorised financial services firms that may be unable to meet their obligations to customers.
 
The Group is obliged to contribute to investor compensation schemes in Ireland and the Isle of Man, (“Compensation Schemes”) which are designed to compensate (up to defined limits) certain classes of customers of authorised financial services firms where a firm is unable, or deemed likely to be unable, to pay claims against it. The Compensation Schemes are funded by levies on firms authorised by the respective financial regulators. In the event


31


Table of Contents

that one or more Compensation Scheme significantly increases the levies to be paid by firms or changes the coverage or funding levels, the associated costs to the Group may have a material impact on its results, operations and financial condition.
 
If the Group becomes subject to employment disputes or industrial action, this could adversely affect its business.
 
A significant number of the Group’s employees are members of trade unions. The Group currently consults with its employees and their representatives regarding pay, pensions, work practices and conditions of employment. The Group recognises that challenges may arise in relation to pay, pensions and terms and conditions of employment which may need to be resolved through established industrial relations fora. In the event that the Group becomes subject to industrial action or other labour conflicts, including strikes or other forms of industrial actions, this may result in a disruption to the Group’s business, financial condition and prospects.
 
The Group may not be able to recruit, retain and develop appropriate senior management and skilled personnel.
 
The Group’s success depends in part on the availability of skilled management and the continued service of key members of its management team. The Group depends on the availability of skilled management both at its head office and at each of its business units. Failure by the Group to staff its operations appropriately, or the loss of one or more key senior executives, and failure to replace them in a satisfactory and timely manner, may have a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
In addition, if the Group fails to attract and appropriately train, motivate and retain highly skilled and qualified personnel, its business may also be negatively affected. Restrictions imposed on remuneration by Government or regulatory authorities or other factors outside of the Group’s control in relation to the retention and recruitment of key executives may also adversely impact on the Group’s ability to attract and retain appropriately skilled personnel.
 
If the Central Bank Reform Bill 2010 is enacted as currently drafted, the Group would also be required to submit for review and approval, proposed new appointments to some senior management positions. This could have a material adverse effect on the Group if the approval process resulted in delays in filling key positions or impacted the Group’s ability to attract suitable candidates.
 
The Group’s operations have inherent reputational risk, meaning the risk to earnings and capital from negative public opinion.
 
Reputational risk is inherent in the Group’s business. Negative public or industry opinion can result from the actual or perceived manner in which the Group conducts its business activities or from actual or perceived practices in the banking industry, such as money laundering or mis-selling of financial products. Negative public or industry opinion may adversely affect the Group’s ability to keep and attract customers and, in particular, corporate and retail depositors the loss of which would in each case adversely affect the Group’s business, financial condition and prospects.
 
The effect of the realisation of country risk in respect of other sovereign issuers could spread to Irish financial institutions and could result in a material adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Country risk is the risk that a counterparty is unable to meet its contractual obligations as a result of adverse economic conditions or actions taken by the government in the relevant country. This includes the risk that:
 
•  a sovereign borrower may be unable or unwilling to fulfil contractual obligations; and/or
 
•  a non-sovereign counterparty may be unable to fulfil its contractual obligations as a result of currency shortage due to adverse economic conditions or actions taken by the government of the country.
 
Country risk in a sovereign issuer other than Ireland, especially a European sovereign issuer, could have an impact on capital markets in general, in particular on the market perception of the risks associated with lending to peripheral European sovereign issuers, such as Ireland, and financial institutions in those countries, such as the Bank. As such, country risk could have a significant adverse effect on the Group’s access to funding, results, financial condition and prospects.


32


Table of Contents

The value of certain financial instruments recorded at fair value is determined using financial models incorporating assumptions, judgements and estimates that may change over time or may ultimately not turn out to be accurate.
 
In establishing the fair value of certain financial instruments, the Group relies on quoted market prices or, where the market for a financial instrument is not sufficiently active, internal valuation models that utilise observable financial market data. In certain circumstances, the data for individual financial instruments or classes of financial instruments utilised by such valuation models may not be available or may become unavailable due to changes in financial market conditions. In such circumstances, the Group’s internal valuation models require the Group to make assumptions, judgements and estimates to establish fair value. In common with other financial institutions, these internal valuation models are complex, and the assumptions, judgements and estimates the Group is required to make often relate to matters that are inherently uncertain, such as expected cash flows, the ability of borrowers to service debt, residential and commercial property price appreciation and depreciation, and relative levels of defaults and deficiencies. Such assumptions, judgements and estimates may need to be updated to reflect changing facts, trends and market conditions. The resulting change in the fair values of the financial instruments could have a material adverse effect on the Group’s earnings and financial condition. Also, recent market volatility and illiquidity has challenged the factual bases of certain underlying assumptions and has made it difficult to value certain of the Group’s financial instruments. Valuations in future periods, reflecting prevailing market conditions, may result in changes in the fair values of these instruments, which could have an adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Change of control may lead to adverse consequences for the Group.
 
Bank of Ireland and its subsidiaries are parties to joint ventures, contracts and other agreements containing change of control provisions that may be triggered in the event of a change of control of the relevant Group entity for example as a result of a major stockholder, such as the NPRFC, obtaining a majority stake in the Bank. These include the joint ventures between the Bank and Post Office Limited (“POL”) which operates the Post Office network in the United Kingdom — one in relation to foreign exchange (First Rate) and one in relation to Post Office branded retail financial services products. Agreements with change of control provisions typically provide for, or permit, the termination of the agreement upon the occurrence of a change of control of one of the parties or if the new controlling party does not satisfy certain criteria. The crystalisation of change of control provisions could also result in the loss of contractual rights and benefits, as well as the termination of joint venture agreements. On a change of control of the relevant Group entity, the exercise of such rights or the decision by a counterparty not to waive or vary its rights on a change of control could have a material effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Changes in taxation rates, legislation or practice may lead to adverse consequences for the Group.
 
The Group is subject to various tax rates in various jurisdictions computed in accordance with local legislation and practice. There is a risk that such tax rates, legislation and practice may change, which could adversely affect the results, financial condition and prospects of the Group.
 
In accordance with applicable accounting rules, the Group has recognised deferred tax assets on losses available to relieve future profits to the extent that it is probable that such losses will be utilised. The assets are quantified on the basis of current tax legislation and are subject to change in respect of the tax rate or the rules for computing taxable profits and allowable losses. A failure to generate sufficient future taxable profits or changes in tax legislation may reduce the recoverable amount of the deferred tax assets currently recognised in the financial statements.
 
The Group’s results of operations and the markets in which it operates may be adversely affected by terrorist, geopolitical, pandemic and natural disaster risks.
 
Terrorist acts, other acts of war or hostility, geopolitical, natural disaster, pandemic or other such events and responses to those acts/events may also create economic and political uncertainties, which could have a negative impact on Irish, United Kingdom, United States, European Union and international economic conditions generally,


33


Table of Contents

and in ways that cannot necessarily be predicted. These events could have an adverse effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.
 
Item 4   INFORMATION ON THE COMPANY
 
GENERAL
 
The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland was established as a chartered corporation by an Act of the Irish Parliament of 1781/2 and by a Royal Charter of King George III in 1783. The Bank of Ireland Group is one of the largest financial services groups in Ireland with total assets of €181 billion at December 31, 2009. The address of the principal executive offices is 40 Mespil Road, Dublin 4 Ireland. (Telephone +35316615933).
 
The Group provides an extensive range of banking and other financial services. All of these services are provided by the Group in Ireland, with selected services being offered in the UK and internationally. The Group has a network of retail branches in Ireland and joint ventures in the UK engaged in the provision of consumer financial services. Corporate Banking and Global Markets conduct the Group’s international business with centres in Dublin, London and the US, as well as branches in Paris and Frankfurt, and offices in New York and Chicago.
 
The Group provides fund management services through its Asset Management business. Other subsidiaries include Bank of Ireland Life Holdings plc, a life assurance and pensions company in Ireland, ICS Building Society (“ICS”), a home mortgage business in Ireland, and Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank (“BoIMB”).
 
As set out in note 58(h) to the Consolidated financial statements, the Group is finalising its negotiations with the European Commission in relation to the terms of its EU Restructuring Plan and it expects to dispose of a number of subsidiaries as part of this plan.
 
BUSINESS OVERVIEW
 
The Group provides a broad range of financial services in Ireland to all major sectors of the Irish economy. These include checking and deposit services, overdrafts, term loans, mortgages, business and corporate lending, international asset financing, leasing, instalment credit, debt factoring, foreign exchange facilities, interest and exchange rate hedging instruments, executor, trustee, life assurance and pension and investment fund management, fund administration and custodial services and financial advisory services, including mergers and acquisitions and underwriting. The Group provides services in euro and other currencies. The Group markets and sells its products on a domestic basis through its extensive nationwide distribution network in Ireland, which consists of approximately 250 full time service branches and approximately 1,300 ATMs, its direct telephone banking service, direct sales forces and its online services.
 
The UK Financial Services (“UKFS”) division incorporates Business Banking in Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the branch network in Northern Ireland, the discontinued intermediary sourced mortgage business operating under Bristol & West and Bank of Ireland brands and the joint ventures with the UK Post Office, namely Post Office Financial and Travel Services. In addition, the Bank provides corporate lending and treasury products and services to corporate customers in Northern Ireland, England, Scotland and Wales through its Corporate Banking and Global Markets businesses which have offices in Belfast, Bristol and London.
 
Operations in the rest of the world are undertaken by:
 
•  Corporate Banking, which is engaged in international lending, with offices located in France, Germany, and the US;
 
•  Global Markets, which delivers a comprehensive range of risk management products to the Group’s customer base.
 
CORPORATE STRUCTURE
 
As at December 31, 2009 the Group organised its businesses into Retail Republic of Ireland, Bank of Ireland Life, Capital Markets, UK Financial Services and Group Centre. The Group’s operations extend geographically throughout Ireland, the UK, Europe and the US. The segmental analysis note, shown in note 2 to the consolidated


34


Table of Contents

financial statements includes an analysis of profit contributions by both geographic segments and by business classes. See also Item 5 “Operating & Financial Review and Prospects” and note 58(h) to the Consolidated financial statements for further information in relation to EU Restructuring Plan and planned disposals.
 
Retail Republic of Ireland
 
Retail Republic of Ireland includes all the Group’s branch operations in the Republic of Ireland. The branches offer a wide range of financial products and services in addition to the deposit, lending, checking account and other money transmission services traditionally offered by banks. It also includes BoIMB, ICS, Private Banking, instalment credit and leasing business, credit card operations, commercial finance/factoring businesses, foreign exchange operations and a direct telephone and online banking unit.
 
As at December 31, 2009 Branch banking in the Republic of Ireland operated approximately 250 full service branches. A full range of banking services is provided to all major sectors of the Irish economy, including small and medium sized commercial and industrial companies. Branches provide checking accounts, demand and term deposit accounts, overdrafts, term loans and home loans as well as money transmission and foreign exchange services. Also available through branches are credit cards, life assurance, pension and investment products, as well as loan and deposit products of other Group businesses. Customers also have access to online and telephone banking services.
 
BoIMB’s principal activities are the issuance of Irish residential mortgages together with the issuance of mortgage covered securities in accordance with the Asset Covered Securities Act, 2001 to 2007 to provide funding to the Group. As at December 31, 2009, the total amount outstanding in respect of mortgage covered securities issued was €9 billion. As at the same date, the total value of the mortgage covered pool, including mortgage assets and cash, securing the mortgage covered securities was €12.7 billion.
 
ICS Building Society is involved in mortgage lending secured by residential properties and the collection of deposits. Its mortgage business is generated principally by referrals from intermediaries. ICS Building Society deposits are generated by referrals from the Bank’s branches. In addition, ICS Building Society currently operates a mortgage servicing centre which processes the Group’s Irish mortgage portfolio. For information on ICS Building Society and on the EU Restructuring Plan, see note 58(h) to the Consolidated financial statements in the notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
Bank of Ireland Private Banking provides wealth management solutions to high net worth individuals in Ireland. It offers a complete private banking service utilising an extensive range of investment, fiduciary and banking products.
 
Bank of Ireland Finance provides instalment credit and leasing facilities. Its products are marketed to the personal, commercial and agricultural sectors by a direct sales force, through the Bank’s branches and by intermediaries such as dealers, retailers and professionals with whom it has established relationships. Its products include secured instalment credit, leasing and insurance premium finance. Bank of Ireland Commercial Finance also provides current asset financing through invoice discounting, factoring and stocking facilities.
 
First Rate Enterprises Limited specialises in the provision of foreign exchange services. In Ireland, it currently operates through Bank of Ireland branches and a network of outlets located in hotels, shops, airports and tourist sites.
 
Bank of Ireland Life
 
The Group operates in the life and pensions market in Ireland through New Ireland Assurance Company plc trading as Bank of Ireland Life. New Ireland is a manufacturer of pension, life assurance and related products for individuals and SME’s. Bank of Ireland Life offers life assurance, protection, pensions and investment products to the Group customers in Ireland through the branch network. The Group also operates in the independent intermediary market under the New Ireland brand and through a direct sales force. For further information on the EU Restructuring Plan, see note 58(h) to the Consolidated financial statements.


35


Table of Contents

Capital Markets
 
The principal constituents of the Capital Markets division are Corporate Banking, Global Markets, Asset Management Services and IBI Corporate Finance.
 
Corporate Banking provides integrated relationship banking services to a significant number of the major Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland corporations, financial institutions and multi national corporations operating in or out of the island of Ireland. The range of lending products provided includes, but is not limited to, overdraft and short term loan facilities, term loans, project finance and structured finance. Corporate Banking is also engaged in international lending, with offices located in London, Paris, Frankfurt and the United States. Its international lending business includes, but is not limited to, acquisition finance, project finance, term lending, and asset based financing, principally in the United Kingdom, Continental Europe and the US.
 
Global Markets is responsible for managing the Group’s interest rate and foreign exchange risks, while also responsible for executing the Group’s liquidity and funding requirements. Global Markets trades in a range of market instruments on behalf of the Group itself and the Group’s customers. The trading activities include, but are not limited to, dealing in foreign exchange spot and forward contracts, options, inter bank deposits and loans, financial futures, bonds, swaps and forward rate agreements and equity tracker products. Global Markets also operates in the United Kingdom and the US.
 
Bank of Ireland Asset Management Services provides comprehensive investment management, custody and administration services to investors globally. It is comprised of Bank of Ireland Asset Management, Bank of Ireland Securities Services, and the Group’s stake in Paul Capital Investments LLC. Pursuant to the EU Restructuring Plan, the Bank will be required to dispose of Bank of Ireland Asset Management Services and the Group’s stake in Paul Capital Investments LLC (for further information see note 58(h) to the Consolidated financial statements).
 
IBI Corporate Finance provides independent financial advice to public and private companies on takeovers, mergers and acquisitions, disposals and restructurings, in addition to fund raisings, public flotations and stock exchange listings.
 
UK Financial Services
 
UK Financial Services brings together the Group’s retail activities in the sterling area.
 
Until recently, Personal Lending UK provided standard and non-standard (buy-to-let and self-certified) residential mortgages and motor finance products, operating through broker and intermediary channels. The Bank announced in January 2009 that it was exiting its intermediary-originated residential mortgage business. Since then, the mortgage operation has been closed to new business from the intermediary channel. The Group will also attempt to accelerate the wind down of the UK intermediary mortgage book by way of sale, but will not have an obligation to sell this book at less than book value
 
Business Banking UK operates solely as a business bank in Great Britain and as both a retail and business bank in Northern Ireland.
 
The retail business in Northern Ireland has a network of 44 branches and offers deposit products, lending, current account and other money transmission services typically offered by retail banks. The business banking unit mainly provides loan facilities to medium to large corporate clients while also providing international banking, treasury, current asset financing, leasing and electronic banking services. Offshore deposit taking services are offered through the Isle of Man operations.
 
Post Office Financial Services (“POFS”) sells banking and insurance products directly and through the UK post office branch network. The banking products offered include savings accounts, credit cards and mortgages. The principal insurance products are car, home and life insurance.
 
First Rate Exchange Services Limited provides personal foreign exchange services through the UK post office branch network and online channel. The Group also has a contract to provide an ATM infrastructure (over 2,000 ATMs) and related services in various Post Office locations.


36


Table of Contents

The Group has been actively considering transferring part of its UK business into a newly-incorporated, wholly-owned subsidiary. The establishment of a UK subsidiary, directly regulated by the FSA, would enable the Group to offer products in the UK market that are directly comparable with existing UK mainstream providers from a risk and protection standpoint. The subsidiary would be likely to involve the Group’s Post Office joint ventures, its branch business in Northern Ireland and other parts of its UK business banking operations. The transfer will have no material impact on the Group’s capital over the period of the transfer; however, it will be required to hold liquid assets specifically aligned to the UK subsidiary.
 
Group Centre
 
In the Group organisation structure, Group Centre comprises the central support functions for the Group including Finance, Group Credit and Market Risk, Group Governance Risk and Human Resources. In the Group’s financial statements, Group Centre also reflects the costs associated with capital management activities, unallocated support costs and the cost of the Government Guarantee Scheme.
 
PRINCIPAL CAPITAL EXPENDITURES AND DIVESTITURES
 
Acquisitions
 
There were no principal acquisitions in the three financial periods to December 31, 2009.
 
Divestitures
 
The principal capital divestitures in the three financial periods to December 31, 2009 consist of the following:
 
Iridian Asset Management LLC
 
During the nine months ended December 31, 2009 the Group disposed of its interest in Iridian Asset Management LLC (Iridian). Iridian was a 100% subsidiary of BIAM US Inc and acted as an Institutional Asset Manager in the US market within the Capital Markets division of the Group. In the Annual Report for the year ended March 31, 2009 the impact of a fall in assets under management in the latter part of that year was highlighted and it was noted that the Group was reviewing its strategic options for this business. The disposal was concluded on June 30, 2009 with a resulting loss on disposal of €10 million.
 
In the year ended March 31, 2009 an impairment charge of €201 million on goodwill relating to Iridian was recognised in the income statement.
 
Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC
 
At March 31 2009, the Group held a 71.5% interest in Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC (“Guggenheim” ). During the nine months ended December 31, 2009, the Group disposed of a 49.5% interest in Guggenheim with the intention of disposing of the remaining interest (22%) in the following year. Guggenheim acted as a US based fund of hedge funds manager within the Capital Markets division of the Group. Similar to Iridian, the significant drop in assets under management in the latter part of the last financial year following the turmoil in global markets prompted the Group to consider its strategic options for this business. The disposal of the 49.5% stake was concluded on August 31, 2009 with a resulting profit on disposal of €7 million. The remaining 22% interest is of negligible value with minimal control or influence.
 
In the year ended March 31, 2009 an impairment charge of €103 million on goodwill and other intangibles relating to Guggenheim was recognised in the income statement.


37


Table of Contents

 
MATERIAL SUBSIDIARIES
 
The principal group undertakings at December 31, 2009 were:
 
             
        Country of
  Statutory
Name
  Principal activity   incorporation   year end
 
Bank of Ireland International Finance Limited*ˆ
  International asset financing   Ireland   March 31
Bank of Ireland (IOM) Limitedˆ
  Retail banking   Isle of Man   March 31
Bank of Ireland Life Holdings plc*ˆ
  Life assurance and pensions   Ireland   December 31
Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank*
  Mortgage lending and issuance of mortgage covered securities   Ireland   March 31
First Rate Enterprise (UK) Limited(1)ˆ
  Foreign exchange   England   March 31
Midasgrange Limited (t/a Post Office Financial Services)(2)ˆ
  Retail financial services   England   March 31
ICS Building Society*
  Mortgage lending and deposit gathering   Ireland   December 31
 
 
* Direct subsidiary of The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland.
 
ˆ Not a significant subsidiary as defined in the SEC Regulation S-X.
 
(1)  This entity is a joint venture with the UK Post Office, with each party owning 50% of the equity of the business.
 
(2)  This is a venture with Post Office Limited in which the Group holds 50.1% of the equity of the business.
 
All the Group undertakings are included in the consolidated accounts. Except as otherwise indicated, the Group owns 100% of the equity of the principal group undertakings and 100% of the voting shares of all these undertakings and in the case of ICS Building Society, 100% of the investment shares.
 
DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY
 
At December 31, 2009, the Group operated 294 full time retail bank branches of which 250 were in Ireland and 44 in Northern Ireland. There are no full service retail bank branches in Britain.
 
Operations in the rest of the world are undertaken by Corporate Banking through offices located in the UK, France, Germany, Australia and the US and by Global Markets through offices located in the UK and the US. These premises are owned directly by the Group or held under commercial leases. The premises are subject to continuous maintenance and upgrading and are considered suitable and adequate for the Group’s current and anticipated operations. Full details of acquisitions and disposals during the year are given in note 32 to the consolidated financial statements under the heading “Property, Plant and Equipment”.
 
The Bank of Ireland Group’s former headquarters, located at Lower Baggot Street, Dublin 2, Ireland, comprise a complex of three buildings constructed in the 1970’s having approximately 20,439 square metres (220,000 square feet) of net floor space, which the Bank leases on commercial terms. The Group also occupies approximately 48,321 square metres (520,000 square feet) of net floor space for central functions in Dublin, of which 682 square metres (7,000 square feet) is sublet, in addition to the offices and administrative buildings of Bank of Ireland Life and the multi occupied property at 40 Mespil Road referred to below.
 
The property at 40 Mespil Road, Dublin 4 became the Group’s Head Office with effect from April 12, 2010. Lower Baggot Street will continue to be the registered office of the Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland until July 1, 2010 when it will be changed to Mespil Road.
 
The Bank’s UK Financial Services division occupies approximately 40,055 square metres (431,000 square feet) of net floor space in the UK for business centres and administrative support functions. The majority of these premises are held on individual leases with different expiry dates. As a result of changes in the UK Financial Services division there are a number of leased premises that are no longer used in support of business operations. These properties are


38


Table of Contents

either sub-let or vacant and on the market. There are no new major projects in progress which will have a significant bearing on occupied floor space but opportunities to exit leases and consolidate space are being reviewed or taken as and when they arise.
 
The head office of Bank of Ireland Life is located at 9/12 Dawson Street, Dublin, Ireland. The head office and administrative buildings occupy approximately 5,388 square metres (58,000 square feet) of net floor space. Bank of Ireland Life also has a network of 11 operational branches operating through New Ireland Assurance Company plc.
 
Bank of Ireland Asset Management along with other Group units including Bank of Ireland Private Banking, Bank of Ireland Business Banking, Bank of Ireland Group Legal Services, Group Credit Operations and IBI Corporate Finance occupy approximately 11,133 square metres (120,000 square feet) of net floor space in 40 Mespil Road, Dublin 4, Ireland, held on a commercial lease, which expires in June 2028.
 
Following the sale and leaseback of 36 branches in October 2006, and a further 30 properties in September 2007, the group now leases back these properties under operating leases which give rise to a total annual rental commitment of €12 million.
 
COMPETITION
 
The Bank of Ireland Group faces strong competition in all of its major markets. Other financial services groups, including local banks and domestic and foreign financial services companies, compete for business in these markets.
 
Ireland and Northern Ireland
 
The Group provides a full range of banking services in Ireland and Northern Ireland and is subject to strong competition from various types of institutions in the financial services sector. The Group’s main competitors across the full range of banking activities are other banks, in particular Allied Irish Banks plc, Ulster Bank Limited and Lloyds Banking Group plc (in both Ireland and Northern Ireland), National Irish Bank Limited (in Ireland), Northern Bank Limited (in Northern Ireland), Irish Life and Permanent plc (in Ireland), and Anglo Irish Bank Corporation plc (in Ireland).
 
Allied Irish Banks plc (which trades as First Trust Bank in Northern Ireland) and Irish Life and Permanent plc have their head offices in Dublin. Ulster Bank Limited is a subsidiary of The Royal Bank of Scotland Group plc and Northern Bank Limited and National Irish Bank Limited are subsidiaries of Danske Bank A/S.
 
The Group also competes in the corporate and investment banking services areas with a range of other domestic and foreign banks. There is also competition from the building societies, the Irish Post Office, credit unions and national savings organisations in both Ireland and Northern Ireland.
 
The general competitive environment in Ireland is subject to the operation of the Competition Act, 2002 (as amended), and in the UK (including Northern Ireland) the Competition Act 1998, both of which are modelled closely on Articles 81 and 82 of the EC Treaty, and EC Directive 89/646 of December 15, 1989 (as amended, known as the “Second Banking Co-ordination Directive”), which permits in Ireland and the UK (including Northern Ireland) the establishment of branches and the provision of cross border services by banks headquartered elsewhere in the European Union.
 
United Kingdom
 
The Bank of Ireland Group’s operations in the UK focus on specific business niches, in particular business banking, mortgage lending and retail financial services (the latter through a joint venture with the UK Post Office).
 
The UK has a competitive and sophisticated financial market with over 500 licensed banking institutions with extensive retail networks. The Group’s principal competitors include other providers of personal and commercial financial services, such as banks, building societies and insurance companies many of which have extensive branch networks throughout the UK.


39


Table of Contents

International
 
In those markets where the Group’s strategy is to create niche businesses internationally the range and number of competitors is even more extensive. In addition, certain businesses based in Ireland, such as corporate finance or asset management, face competition on an international rather than a national basis.
 
Inquiries
 
In the UK the Competition Commission published its Final Report on Payment Protection Insurance in January 2009. The Commission’s package of remedies was partially quashed by the Competition Appeals Tribunal in November 2009 and remitted to the Commission for further consideration. The Commission published provisional conclusions in May 2010 and its final decision is awaited, following consultation. The main point under consideration is whether there should be a prohibition on the selling of Payment Protection Insurance at the same time as or immediately after the sale of credit (a ‘Point of Sale Prohibition’).
 
The Office of Fair Trading (the “OFT”) investigates issues in the UK from competition, consumer protection and other perspectives. In April 2007, the OFT launched an investigation into the fairness of personal current account unarranged overdraft charges under the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations. The investigation was discontinued in December 2009 following a test case considered by the Supreme Court. In March 2010 the OFT welcomed commitments from the UK banking industry to develop minimum standards for opting out of unarranged overdrafts and other measures.
 
Also in March 2010 the OFT announced “...a short piece of work during 2010 looking at barriers to entry...” to the UK personal current account market “...to consider whether there are any obstacles to entrants providing a competitive stimulus.”
 
SUPERVISION AND REGULATION
 
IRELAND
 
General regulation and supervision
 
Recent measures by the Government to support the Irish financial sector have resulted in closer supervision of financial institutions as well as additional regulatory requirements relating to the specific measures implemented, such as the CIFS Guarantee Scheme, the NPRFC Investment, the ELG Scheme and NAMA.
 
Banking activities in Ireland are regulated and supervised by the Financial Regulator. The Irish banking law regulations consist primarily of the Central Bank Acts, the Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland Act, 2003, the Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland Act, 2004, the 1992 Consolidated Supervision Regulations, the 1992 Licensing Regulations, regulations made by the Minister for Finance under the European Communities Act, 1972, and regulatory notices issued by the Financial Regulator. These ministerial regulations and regulatory notices implement EU directives relating to banking regulation, including the First Banking Co-ordination Directive, the Second Banking Co-ordination Directive, the Solvency Ratio Directive, the Own Funds Directive, the Large Exposures Directive, the Deposit Guarantee Scheme Directive, the Capital Adequacy Directive and the Capital Requirements Directive. To the extent that areas of banking activity are the subject of EU directives, the provisions of Irish banking law reflect the requirements of those directives.
 
In Ireland, the Financial Regulator sets the requirements for liquidity for Irish licensed banks. The Group operates under the regulatory liquidity regime introduced by the Financial Regulator in July 2007. This regime requires that banks have sufficient payment resources (cash inflows and marketable assets) to cover 100% of expected cash outflows in the 0 to 8 day time horizon and 90% of expected cash outflows in the 8 day to 30 day time horizon.
 
The Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland Act, 2003 brings under one supervisory umbrella all of the financial services activities in Ireland. The Financial Regulator is a constituent part of the CBFSAI and is entrusted with the supervisory activities of the former Central Bank of Ireland. Two particular features of the Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland Act, 2003 should be noted. First, it established as a separate function the Office of the Consumer Director with particular responsibility for the administration of the Consumer Credit Act, 1995 and the consumer protection provisions of other supervisory enactments. The


40


Table of Contents

Consumer Credit Act had been administered by a separate office, the Director of Consumer Affairs, since its implementation on May 13, 1996. Second, it established the Irish Financial Services Appeal Tribunal, which hears and determines appeals under any of the designated enactments or statutory instruments referred to above that have the effect of imposing a sanction or liability on any person. The provisions relating to the Irish Financial Services Appeal Tribunal became effective on August 1, 2004. The CBFSAI has responsibility for contributing to the stability of the financial system, promoting the efficient and effective operating of payment and settlement systems, for holding and managing the foreign reserves of Ireland, promoting the efficient and effective operations of settlement systems and for the performance of functions imposed on the CBFSAI under the Rome Treaty or the European System of Central Banks Statute (the sole responsibility of the Governor of the CBFSAI).
 
On March 30, 2010, the Minister for Finance published the Central Bank Reform Bill, 2010. The purpose of that bill is to create a single, fully integrated, Central Bank with a unitary board, “the Central Bank Commission”, chaired by the Governor of the Central Bank. Assuming the bill becomes law, the Financial Regulator would be dissolved and most of its existing functions would be merged into the new structure. The Central Bank would be responsible and accountable for the prudential supervision of individual financial firms, the conduct of business, including protection of customer interests and the stability of the financial system overall.
 
All Irish licensed banks are obliged to draw up and publish their annual accounts in accordance with the European Communities (Credit Institutions: Accounts) Regulations, 1992 (as amended by the European Community (Credit Institutions) (Fair Value Accountancy) Regulations, 2004). As a listed entity Bank of Ireland is required to prepare its financial statements in accordance with IFRS and with those parts of the Companies Acts applicable to companies reporting under IFRS and Article 4 of the EU Council Regulation 1606/2002 of July 19, 2002.
 
Subject to the provisions of the 1992 Licensing Regulations relating to mutual recognition of credit institutions authorised elsewhere in the EU, the Central Bank Act, 1971 (as amended) (the “1971 Act”) restricts the carrying on of banking business in Ireland to holders of licences granted under the 1971 Act. The 1971 Act stipulates that licence holders must maintain a minimum deposit with the CBFSAI. The Financial Regulator has a qualified discretion to grant or refuse a licence and may attach conditions to any licences granted. Bank of Ireland holds a licence granted under the 1971 Act with one condition attached — that Bank of Ireland must notify the Financial Regulator of its intention to close any branch in Ireland. The Financial Regulator, after consultation with the Minister for Finance, may revoke a licence under certain circumstances specified in the 1971 Act.
 
The Financial Regulator has statutory power to carry out inspections of the books and records of licence holders and to obtain information from licence holders about their banking and bank related business. Pursuant to this power, the Financial Regulator carries out regular review meetings and periodically inspects licensed banks. The Financial Regulator is also empowered by law to obtain information from licence holders about their banking and bank related business.
 
The Financial Regulator may also prescribe ratios to be maintained between, and requirements as to the composition of, the assets and liabilities of licensed banks and to make regulations for the prudent and orderly conduct of banking business of such banks. The Financial Regulator has completed a Prudential Capital Assessment Review for the Bank and further information on this review is set out in the section below (Financial Regulator — Prudential Capital Assessment Review).
 
The Group is also subject to EU Directives relating to capital adequacy, and in the area of monitoring and control of large exposures, which are implemented in Ireland by way of the Banking Consolidation Directive. The capital framework as set out in the Capital Requirements Directive has been transposed into Irish law via European Communities (Capital Adequacy of Investment Firms) Regulations 2006 (S.I. No. 660 of 2006), European Communities (Capital Adequacy of Credit Institutions) Regulations 2006 (S.I. No. 661 of 2006) and by way of administrative notice. These regulations set forth minimum start up and ongoing capital requirements for banks licensed by the Financial Regulator and require applicants for a licence to notify the Financial Regulator of the identity of certain shareholders and the size of their holdings in the applicant. The Financial Regulator also sets requirements and standards from time to time for the assessment of applications for licenses. The most recent requirements and standards, published initially in the “Quarterly Review of the Central Bank of Ireland, Winter 1995”, have been updated regularly and are non-statutory requirements which are applied by the Financial


41


Table of Contents

Regulator to credit institutions as a supplement to the statutory requirements referred to generally in this paragraph but do not purport to interpret or refer comprehensively to the statutory provisions applicable to credit institutions.
 
The Group is subject to extensive regulation and regulatory supervision in relation to the levels of capital in its business. As a result of the current environment and market events, the minimum regulatory requirements imposed on the Group, as well as the manner in which the existing regulatory capital is calculated could change in the future.
 
Capital Requirements Directive II is a package of measures adopted by the European Parliament and Council on September 16, 2009. The effective date of changes to be implemented under CRD II is December 31, 2010, the most important of which are as follows:
 
•  Technical changes to the capital requirements for the trading book, including credit risk mitigation (“CRM”) for counterparty credit risk;
 
•  Rules and regulations to strengthen the co-operation between supervisors in crisis situation and to strengthen the powers of (host) supervisors to collect information about systemically relevant branches of supervised financial institutions;
 
•  Improving the quality of firms’ capital by establishing clear EU-wide criteria for assessing the eligibility of hybrid capital to be counted as part of a firm’s overall capital. The Proposals specify the features that hybrid capital must have regarding permanence, flexibility of payments and loss absorbency to be eligible as Tier 1 Capital;
 
•  Enhancing the management of large exposures by restricting a firm’s lending beyond a certain limit to any one party;
 
•  Further elaboration of the rules on liquidity risk management and
 
•  Improving the risk management of securitisation, including a requirement to ensure that a firm does not invest in a securitisation unless the originator retains an economic interest.
 
Capital Requirements Directive III would amend Directive 2009/111/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of September 16, 2009 amending Directives 2006/48/EC, 2006/49/EC and 2007/64/EC. CRD III is currently subject to consultation and implementation of the rules is expected by January 1, 2011. It introduces a number of changes in response to the recent and current market conditions, including:
 
•  Strengthening the capital requirements for the trading book to ensure that a firm’s assessment of the risks connected with its trading book better reflects the potential losses from adverse market movements in stressed conditions;
 
•  Limiting investment in re-securitisations and imposing higher capital requirements for re-securitisations to make sure that firms take proper account of the risks of investing in such complex financial products; and
 
•  Upgrading disclosure standards to increase market confidence.
 
There is still significant uncertainty around the final requirements and the implementation by the Financial Regulator of both CRD II and CRD III as it relates to the Group. If implemented as currently proposed both CRD II and CRD III will have a significant impact on the capital and asset and liability management (“ALM”) of the Group which in turn could have a material effect on the Group results, financial condition and prospects.
 
On December 16, 2009 the Basel Committee, a forum for regular co-operation on banking supervisory matters, published a consultation paper entitled “Strengthening the resilience of the banking sector”. This consultation paper contains proposals to strengthen the global capital framework by, among other things, raising the quality of the equity and Tier 1 Capital base in a harmonised manner, with more emphasis on common equity and more adjustments to common equity, strengthening the risk coverage of the capital framework, promoting the build up of capital buffers and introducing a global minimum liquidity standard for the banking sector. The consultation paper was open for consultation until April 16, 2010 and any changes are not expected to be implemented until after 2012. If the draft changes were implemented as currently proposed, they could have a significant impact on the capital and asset and liability management of the Group, which in turn could have a material effect on the Group’s results, financial condition and prospects.


42


Table of Contents

The Group’s operations in overseas locations are subject to the regulations and reporting requirements of the regulatory and supervisory authorities in the overseas locations with the Financial Regulator having overall responsibility for their regulation and supervision. The Financial Regulator is required to supervise the Group on a consolidated basis, i.e. taking account of the entire Group activities and relationships.
 
Licensed banks must notify their existing fees and charges and related terms and conditions, and any changes therein from time to time to the Consumer Director of the Financial Regulator, who can direct that no fees, charges or increases or changes therein be made without his or her approval.
 
All credit institutions are obliged to take the necessary measures to counteract money laundering effectively in accordance with the Criminal Justice Act, 1994 (as amended) and the Guidance Notes for Credit Institutions, which were issued with the approval of the Money Laundering Steering Committee which was set up in 1994 under the chairmanship of the Department of Finance. Revised guidance notes were issued in 2003.
 
The Third Money Laundering Directive was transposed into Irish law on May 5, 2010 under the Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010.
 
Under the European Communities (Deposit Guarantee Schemes) Regulations, 1995 (as amended) the Financial Regulator also operates a statutory depositor protection scheme (the “Deposit Guarantee Scheme”) to which both licensed banks (including Bank of Ireland) and building societies (including ICS Building Society) are required to make contributions amounting to 0.2 per cent of their total deposits. The Deposit Guarantee Scheme provides compensation in respect of current accounts, demand deposit accounts, term deposit accounts, share accounts and deposit accounts with building societies and credit unions. The maximum level of compensation payable to any one depositor was increased in 2008 to €100,000 per depositor per institution. Previously it was 90 per cent of the aggregate deposits held by that depositor subject to a maximum compensation of €20,000. The Deposit Guarantee Scheme does not have an end date. The CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme apply in addition to the Deposit Guarantee Scheme. The first €100,000 of a depositor’s funds at an institution are covered by the Deposit Guarantee Scheme and any excess is covered by either the CIFS Guarantee Scheme or the ELG Scheme.
 
Under the Deposit Protection Scheme, the compensation payment process is initiated by either the CBFSAI determining that a credit institution is unable to repay deposits due to its financial condition, or a court making a ruling, for reasons directly related to a credit institution’s financial circumstances, that suspends depositors’ ability to make claims against that institution. The CBFSAI is expected to pay compensation to depositors within three months of a determination that deposits are unavailable, or of a ruling by the court (subject to the terms and conditions set out in the regulations). This timeframe will be reduced to 20 working days after December 30, 2010.
 
In 1997, the EU Investor Compensation Directive laid down basic requirements for investor compensation schemes. This was done to provide a harmonised minimum level of investor protection across the EU. In Ireland, this Directive was transposed into Irish law pursuant to the Investor Compensation Act, 1998 under which the Investor Compensation Company Limited (“ICCL”) was established. The main purpose of the scheme is to provide adequate funds out of which eligible investors (private clients) of failed investment firms are compensated for financial losses arising. The funds are generated solely from contributions from investment firms. The current contribution rate varies depending on the nature of the investment services provided and in certain situations, on the number of clients being provided with services by the firm. In the Group, Bank of Ireland Insurance and Investments Limited and Bank of Ireland Private Banking contribute to this fund.
 
This scheme covers certain investment products i.e. non-deposit based products where the investment intermediary is unable, due to its financial circumstances, to return client money or investment instruments owed or belonging to a private client. The amount recoverable from the ICCL is currently 90% of the customer’s net loss from the investment product, or €20,000, whichever is the smaller. The ICCL can only begin the process of making compensation payments to eligible investors once it has been advised by the Financial Regulator that an authorised investment firm has either: (1) been the subject of a court ruling which prevents the firm returning money or investment instruments to clients; (2) or been the subject of a determination by the Financial Regulator that the firm is unable to meet its obligations arising from claims by clients.
 
The Financial Regulator has implemented Consumer Protection Code and Minimum Competency Requirements. The Consumer Protection Code, fully effective from July 2007, applies to banks and building societies, insurance


43


Table of Contents

undertakings, investment business firms, mortgage intermediaries and credit unions. The Consumer Protection Code requires regulated entities to know their customers and their suitability for products or services, to prepare terms of business and minimum levels of information for customers, including disclosure requirements and customer record obligations, to identify all charges, fees or other rewards connected with the supply of a service and to establish processes to deal with errors, complaints and conflicts of interest. There are also detailed rules on the fairness of advertising, and specific sectoral rules on banking products, loans, insurance services and investment products. The Minimum Competency Requirements, effective from January 2007, requires employees of regulated entities who provide advice on or sell retail financial products to acquire the competencies set out therein and to engage in continuing professional development on an ongoing basis.
 
A financial services ombudsman’s bureau and a financial services ombudsman council have been established under the Central Bank and Financial Services Authority Act of 2004. This also sets out the functions and powers of that council and bureau, respectively, and establishes consultative panels to advise the Financial Regulator on matters relating to its statutory functions.
 
Financial Regulator — Prudential Capital Assessment Review
 
The Financial Regulator announced on March 30, 2010 that the Central Bank and the Financial Regulator had carried out an exercise to determine the forward looking prudential capital requirements of certain Irish credit institutions, including the Bank, covered by Government Guarantee Schemes. The Prudential Capital Assessment Review (“PCAR”) assessed the capital requirements arising for expected base and potential stressed loan losses, and other financial developments, over the three year period 2010-2012. It involved the Central Bank and the Financial Regulator making an assessment of the recapitalisation requirements of the credit institutions in order to satisfy both a base case and stressed target capital requirement.
 
The PCAR was undertaken to determine the recapitalisation requirements of certain Irish credit institutions with reference to both:
 
•  Base case:  A target level of 8% Core Tier 1 Capital after taking account of the realisation of future expected losses and other financial developments under a base case scenario. This test is designed to ensure the credit institutions are capitalised to a level which reflects prudential requirements and current market expectations, after taking into account forecasted loan losses through to 2012. As a further prudential requirement, the capital used to meet the base case target must be principally in the form of equity, the highest quality form of capital, with 7% equity as the target level.
 
•  Stressed scenario:  A target level of 4% Core Tier 1 Capital that should be maintained to meet a stress scenario or a portfolio level sensitivity analysis. This capital test, which is similar to that employed by US and UK supervisory authorities, is designed to ensure that the credit institutions have a sufficient capital buffer to withstand losses under an adverse scenario significantly worse than that currently anticipated.
 
The Financial Regulator stated that recapitalisation to the target requirements specified in the PCAR will provide market participants with confidence that the credit institutions have a strong capital base after realising forecasted expected losses and that a prudent capital buffer is in place to withstand additional losses in adverse stress conditions.
 
Methodology
 
The PCAR involved the Central Bank and the Financial Regulator making an assessment of the recapitalisation requirements of the credit institutions involved in the exercise in order to satisfy both a base case and stressed target capital requirement.
 
A team of prudential supervisors, credit specialists and treasury specialists in the Financial Regulator, supported by Central Bank economists and financial stability specialists, conducted the PCAR by:
 
•  Assessing the provisioning estimates of each relevant credit institution, their Basel capital model outputs, expected loss forecasts, funding costs and projected operating income;


44


Table of Contents

 
•  Reviewing independent third party estimates of provisions and expected losses conducted on specific credit institutions’ portfolios;
 
•  Reviewing likely and stressed scenario loan loss projections for portfolio categories by credit rating agencies and other sources including regulatory agencies;
 
•  Reviewing the outcome of modelled base and stress macro-economic scenarios that the Financial Regulator specified and mandated each credit institution to calculate;
 
•  Using information received from NAMA in respect of the discounts on the first tranche of Bank of Ireland Eligible Bank Assets as the basis for estimating the NAMA loan losses;
 
•  Applying prudent buffers to estimates of expected loan losses;
 
•  Applying prudent adjustments to base case and stress scenario funding costs and treasury asset losses;
 
•  Applying knowledge of the quality of loan portfolios gained through the Financial Regulator’s more intensive supervisory interaction with the various credit institutions, including observation of the Bank’s credit committee deliberations; and
 
•  Benchmarking the Financial Regulator’s analysis to the approaches taken by other leading international financial supervisors.
 
The PCAR required the assessment to take account of changes to EU prudential banking capital requirements that have been formally adopted, even if they have yet to be implemented. This does not include the “Basel II plus” changes that are still at consultation stage, although the potential changes were noted as part of the Financial Regulator’s overall assessment of target capital levels.
 
Stress Test
 
In stress test, the capital requirement of 4% Core Tier 1 Capital is designed to ensure that the relevant credit institutions will be adequately capitalised even after experiencing a hypothetical adverse macroeconomic scenario or unexpected severe losses on particular loan portfolios. This capital level is equivalent to that established by the FSA and similar to that established by the US Federal Reserve, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation and Office of the Comptroller of the Currency.
 
The stress test requirement is based on a severe scenario of hypothetical adverse macroeconomic conditions and therefore involves an element of judgment. The stress test inputs do not represent a forecast of likely economic developments by the Central Bank and the Financial Regulator, instead they are much more adverse than what is considered likely.
 
The Central Bank and the Financial Regulator required credit institutions to stress test their portfolios to the higher of:
 
•  The institutions’ estimated loan losses in a stress scenario based on a delayed macroeconomic recovery scenario prescribed by the Central Bank and the Financial Regulator;* and
 
•  Application of severe sensitivity shocks to the loan book at a portfolio specific level. This included loan loss rates of 5% for mortgages in Ireland and non-NAMA development property loan losses of 60% in Ireland and 35% in the United Kingdom.
 
The Financial Regulator emphasised that these were not forecast or expected loss levels, and are disclosed to show the extent of the stress that has been applied in the stress test and that these loss rates are not based on any macroeconomic scenario and therefore should not be interpreted in that manner. The Financial Regulator also noted that it is the losses established under the portfolio level sensitivity approach that have provided the binding stress case capital requirements, rather than the macroeconomic scenario and that the use of stress testing to benchmark
 
 
The Financial Regulator provided a specified macroeconomic scenario based on a hypothetical delayed economic recovery involving negligible GDP growth in 2011 and 2012, unemployment increasing to 14.7% in 2012, a further cumulative house price decline of 24.8% in the years 2010 to 2012 beyond the decline reported and other parameters.


45


Table of Contents

prudential capital requirements will become a part of the regulatory framework operated by the Central Bank and the Financial Regulator.
 
Recapitalisation Plans
 
The Financial Regulator required the credit institutions that have completed the exercise to prepare recapitalisation plans in light of the PCAR results. The amount of capital set by the PCAR process must be in place by the end of 2010 to a level calculated by reference to the base capital target, after taking into account projected expected losses, including institution-specific and other adjustments.
 
The Financial Regulator also requires credit institutions to set out their plans to ensure that capital is in place by the end of 2010 to a level calculated with reference to the stress capital target, taking account of stressed losses and other adjustments.
 
In the case of Bank of Ireland, based on the Financial Regulator’s assessment of the estimated impact of NAMA, a detailed review of the Bank’s loan book and capital position and the results of a range of stress testing scenarios, the Financial Regulator concluded that the Bank requires an additional €2.66 billion of Equity Tier 1 Capital, to be in place by the end of the 2010 calendar year in order to meet the base case and stress targets.
 
The Bank believes that raising this level of capital would result in its Equity Tier 1 Capital Ratio and Core Tier 1 Capital Ratio, as at December 31, 2010, being greater than the 7% and 8% levels respectively targeted by the Financial Regulator, the NAMA process having been completed by that date. The Bank stated that it believed that a capital raising of this size would ensure that its trough Equity Tier 1 Capital Ratio through the cycle would not fall below 7%. This level of capital would permit the Bank to pass the higher of the stress scenarios based on a delayed macroeconomic recovery and the severe sensitivity shock test set by the Financial Regulator at the 4% Core Tier 1 level. The Bank has confirmed to the Financial Regulator that it would maintain an Equity Tier 1 Capital Ratio in excess of 4% in the case of the delayed macroeconomic recovery stress scenario.
 
For details of the Group’s capital raising, which subsequently took place in April to June 2010, see page 58 and note 58(i) to the consolidated financial statements.
 
Government Guarantee Schemes
 
Under the CIFS Guarantee Scheme the covered liabilities of Bank of Ireland, ICS Building Society, Bank of Ireland Mortgages and Bank of Ireland (IOM) Limited (“the covered institutions”) for the period September 30, 2008 to September 29, 2010 inclusive are guaranteed under the laws of Ireland by the Minister for Finance. Covered liabilities are all retail and corporate deposits (to the extent not covered by existing deposit protection schemes in Ireland or any other jurisdiction and excluding those liabilities which are now covered by the ELG Scheme), interbank deposits, senior unsecured debt, covered bonds (including asset covered securities) (issued prior to the commencement of the ELG Scheme) and dated subordinated debt (Lower Tier 2 (issued prior to the commencement of the ELG Scheme)). In the event of a default in respect of a covered liability, the Minister for Finance will pay to the relevant creditor, on demand, an amount equal to the unpaid covered liabilities. The guarantee is unconditional and irrevocable. Should any of the covered institutions be removed from the CIFS Guarantee Scheme, all of its fixed term covered liabilities outstanding at that time will continue to have the full benefit of the guarantee to September 29, 2010 or their maturity, whichever is earlier. All covered liabilities, including on-demand deposits, will be protected by notice of at least 90 days prior to any covered institution being removed from the CIFS Guarantee Scheme. No call can be made under the guarantee after September 29, 2010. Further information on the CIFS Guarantee Scheme is outlined in note 55 to the consolidated financial statements.
 
On December 9, 2009, the Minister for Finance commenced the ELG Scheme which is intended to facilitate participating institutions issuing debt securities and taking deposits with a maturity of up to five years on either a guaranteed or unguaranteed basis, provided the relevant liabilities are acquired during an Issuance Window which expires on September 29, 2010. The Bank joined the scheme on January 11, 2010. The ELG Scheme is subject to European Commission review by the end of June, 2010, under which the European Commission could require the amendment or cessation of the ELG Scheme. All liabilities guaranteed under the existing CIFS Guarantee Scheme as at January 11, 2010 will remain guaranteed under and in accordance with the terms of the CIFS Guarantee


46


Table of Contents

Scheme unless guaranteed by the ELG Scheme. The costs of participating in the ELG Scheme may be changed at the Minister for Finance’s discretion.
 
The Minister for Finance announced on March 30, 2010 that he would be seeking European Commission approval for an extension of a modified ELG Scheme consistent with its phasing out over a realistic period of time. The Minister noted that the ELG Scheme is due to be reviewed by the EU Commission by the end of June 2010 and that an announcement about the future of the ELG Scheme would be made in advance of that date. However, in order to bring the review date in line with other European Guarantee Schemes, the EU Commission have approved a continuation of the scheme under existing terms to end June 2010 and that the formal review of the scheme by the Commission will now be completed prior to June 30, 2010.
 
Under the terms of the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme, the Minister for Finance may regulate the competitive behaviour and commercial conduct of a covered institution, having regard to capital ratios, market share and balance sheet growth, including imposing restrictions on the expansion of capital and lending activity, the declaration and payment of dividends and the implementation of buy-backs or share redemptions. Under the terms of the CIFS Guarantee Scheme, covered institutions may not acquire shares in any other credit institution or financial institution, establish subsidiaries or enter into or acquire new business(es) where such activities would increase the liability of the institution under the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme. The Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Financial Regulator, may require a covered institution to draw up and implement a restructuring plan to ensure compliance with the objectives of the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme. A covered institution is required to comply with any targets on assets and liabilities to be set by the Financial Regulator, after consultation with the Minister for Finance. The Minister for Finance may issue directions to Participating Institutions to comply with some or all of the provisions of conduct, transparency and reporting requirements applicable to covered institutions under the CIFS Guarantee Scheme and the ELG Scheme.
 
NAMA
 
In April 2009, the Minister for Finance announced that NAMA would be established with the purpose of strengthening the Irish financial sector and the NAMA legislation was enacted into law in November 2009.
 
The participation of Bank of Ireland in the NAMA programme was recommended by the Court of Directors in the Circular of December 18, 2009. It was approved by the stockholders at an Extraordinary General Court on January 12, 2010. Bank of Ireland’s application as a participating institution was approved by the Minister for Finance on February 12, 2010.
 
NAMA has the power to acquire from Participating Institutions, Eligible Bank Assets, that is, land and development loans and certain associated loans (which are expected to comprise non-land and non-development related loans to borrowers of land and development related loans, or loans to certain associated entities of borrowers who had provided security in respect of the land or development related loans). The geographic distribution of the loans relates to exposures both within and outside Ireland. The Eligible Bank Assets will also include interest rate derivative contracts sold to borrowers by Participating Institutions that relate to hedging the interest rate exposure on the loans to be acquired.
 
The Eligible Bank Assets are being acquired on a phased basis from April 2010, with the largest systemic exposures to the Irish banking system acquired first. Details of each tranche of assets to be acquired will be set out in the form of an acquisition schedule issued by NAMA prior to each acquisition date. It is expected that all Eligible Assets will have been transferred by December 31, 2010.
 
In acquiring such assets, NAMA will apply a valuation methodology which will take account of the current market value and the long term economic value on a loan by loan basis. As loan quality, geographic distribution and type of loans vary from institution to institution, each loan will be valued individually. As a result the aggregate discount applied to gross loan values in determining the consideration to be paid by NAMA will vary from institution to institution. Participating Institutions are required to accept the valuations set by NAMA, subject only to certain limited rights of objection.
 
As consideration for Eligible Bank Assets transferred, NAMA will issue to financial institutions a combination of Government guaranteed bonds, issued by NAMA (not less than 95% of the consideration) and subordinated bonds


47


Table of Contents

(not more than 5% of the consideration). These Government guaranteed bonds will be marketable instruments that are capable of being pledged as funding collateral to debt market investors and to monetary authorities such as the ECB.
 
Payments on the subordinated bonds are subject to the requirement that NAMA has sufficient funds, both annually (in respect of coupon payments) and in order to repay the Government guaranteed bonds and subordinated bonds, based on a measure of financial performance of NAMA in totality (rather than on the financial performance of the Eligible Bank Assets acquired from any particular Participating Institution). The subordinated bonds are not guaranteed by the Irish Government and they are not expected to be marketable, they could have a value less than their nominal face value and the payment of interest and repayment of capital is dependent on the performance of NAMA.
 
At December 31, 2009, the Group considered that the estimated Eligible Bank Assets which were expected to be transferred to NAMA met the criteria for classification as assets held for sale. Thus, the relevant loans and advances to customers, derivatives and accrued interest have been reclassified to assets held for sale as at December 31, 2009. The assets classified as assets held for sale to NAMA continue to be measured on the same basis as prior to their classification as assets held for sale. In particular, loans and advances to customers continue to be measured at amortised cost less any incurred impairment losses. In accordance with accounting standards, de-recognition of these assets held for sale will occur when substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership have been transferred to NAMA. This will only occur on a phased basis as ownership of each tranche is legally transferred to NAMA.
 
Based on the Eligible Asset Regulations (as contained within the NAMA regulations), internal review work to identify all loans falling within the eligibility criteria and ongoing interaction with NAMA, the Group expects to transfer total land and development and associated loans of approximately €12.2 billion gross together with related derivatives and accrued interest of €0.2 billion. Net of impairment provisions of €2.8 billion which are held against these loans at December 31, 2009, this estimate would imply a net transfer of €9.6 billion of Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA.
 
         
    As at
    December 31, 2009
    €m
 
Assets held for sale to NAMA
       
Land and development loans
    8,522  
Associated loans
    3,713  
         
      12,235  
Impairment provisions
    (2,778 )
         
      9,457  
Derivatives
    93  
Accrued interest
    31  
         
Total assets held for sale to NAMA
    9,581  
         
Analysed by operating segment
       
Retail Republic of Ireland
    2,470  
UK Financial Services
    2,765  
Capital Markets
    4,346  
         
Total assets held for sale to NAMA
    9,581  
         


48


Table of Contents

The fair values and notional amounts of derivative instruments held for sale to NAMA are set out in the table below:
 
                         
    Contract/
       
    notional
  Fair Values
December 31, 2009
  amount   Assets   Liabilities
    €m   €m   €m
 
Derivatives held for trading
                       
Interest rate derivatives
                       
Interest rate swaps
    2,001       88        
Over the counter interest rate options
    348       5       1  
                         
Total derivatives held for trading
    2,349       93       1  
                         
 
As interactions with NAMA and the internal review work are ongoing and the possibility that loans that are expected to transfer may be repaid or refinanced with other banks, there is uncertainty as to the final amount of eligible assets that will transfer.
 
The Group expects to incur a loss on disposal of the Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA arising from the difference between the fair value of the consideration to be received and the carrying value of the Eligible Bank Assets to be disposed of together with the costs of disposal and any provision that may be required under accounting standards due to the ongoing cost of servicing these assets on behalf of NAMA.
 
The principal determinant of the expected loss on disposal is the difference between the discount applied to the original gross Eligible Bank Asset value in arriving at NAMA’s valuation and the impairment provisions recorded against the Eligible Bank Assets under Accounting Standards. This discount or “haircut” to original asset value is calculated on a different basis and using a different methodology to the determination of impairment provisions under accounting standards.
 
In accordance with Accounting Standards, the loss on disposal will only be recognised on the actual transfer of each tranche of assets to NAMA. At the same time as recognition of such losses, the Bank will benefit from a reduction in its risk weighted assets for regulatory capital purposes.
 
The loss on disposal of Eligible Bank Assets will be tax deductible. However, the use of such tax losses in future years will be restricted as set out in part 10 of Schedule 3 of the National Asset Management Agency Act 2009 (the “Act”). This inserts a new section 396C into the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 which limits the utilisation of tax losses carried forward by an institution participating in NAMA. It lengthens the period over which the deferred tax asset created will reverse by restricting the amount of profits against which trading losses can be utilised. The balance is available for indefinite carry forward. There is no time limit on the utilisation of these losses.
 
In addition, the Act provides that, on the later of ten years after the passing of the Act or the dissolution, restructuring or material alteration of NAMA, in the event that the accounts of NAMA disclose an underlying loss, the Minister for Finance may bring forward legislation to impose a special tax by way of surcharge on Participating Institutions to recover such loss.
 
The first tranche of assets transferred from the Group to NAMA on April 2, 2010. This tranche comprised €1.9 billion of assets (before impairment provision) for which consideration of €1.2 billion in Government guaranteed bonds and subordinated bonds was received. This resulted in a discount to gross loan value of approximately 36%.
 
These loans (including accrued interest) comprised land and development loans of €0.9 billion and associated loans of €1.0 billion. As at December 31, 2009, the Group held impairment provisions of €0.3 billion against these loans. In addition, the transfer included associated derivatives with a fair value of €15 million.
 
The nominal consideration receivable for these Eligible Bank Assets amounted to €1.2 billion and a loss of €0.4 billion (before the impact of any adjustment required to record the subordinated debt at fair value and any provision that may be required for ongoing servicing costs) will be recognised in the Group’s income statement for the year ending December 31, 2010.
 
The limited number and nature of loans involved in this first tranche mean that it may not be a representative sample of the total portfolio of assets held for sale to NAMA and consequently the loss on sale is not necessarily indicative


49


Table of Contents

of the loss that the entire portfolio of Eligible Bank Assets that may ultimately transfer. The loss on sale that is expected to ultimately arise for the Group is a function of the quantum of assets to be transferred, the mix of those assets as between land, development and associated loans and the discount that is applied to the assets transferring on a loan by loan basis. Accordingly the Group is currently unable to accurately quantify the ultimate expected loss on transfer of all of the Bank’s Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA.
 
As a Participating Institution in NAMA, the Bank is subject to additional directions from the Financial Regulator and/or the Minister for Finance as to the conduct of its business. Under section 206 of the NAMA Act, the Financial Regulator may, with the approval of the Minister for Finance, give a direction to a Participating Institution in order to achieve the purposes of the NAMA Act. A direction under this section may restrict balance sheet growth, restrict the institution’s ability to take over other credit institutions, require balance sheet reductions, or restrict or require consolidation and merger of Participating Institutions. Under section 207 of the NAMA Act the Financial Regulator may also direct a Participating Institution in writing to make any report that the Financial Regulator considers necessary to monitor the Participating Institution’s compliance with the obligations under or by virtue of the NAMA Act. Pursuant to section 208 of the NAMA Act, a Participating Institution may also be directed by the Minister for Finance to draw up, or amend, a restructuring or business plan and take reasonable steps to ensure than any draft business plan submitted to the Minister for Finance accurately contains all relevant information. If the Minister for Finance approves a draft business plan, the Participating Institution is obliged to take reasonable steps to implement that plan.
 
Credit Review Guidelines under the NAMA Act
 
On March 30, 2010 the Minister for Finance brought into force the Credit Review Guidelines regarding lending practices and procedures relating to the review of decisions of Participating Institutions, including the Bank, to refuse credit. The guidelines set out the procedures to be operated by the Credit Reviewer. The Credit Reviewer has the power to review a Participating Institution’s decision to refuse a credit application for between €1,000 and €250,000 by an SME, a sole trader or a farming enterprise. Where the Credit Reviewer makes a recommendation that, considering the viability and repayment capacity of the applicant, the credit facilities should have been granted, the Participating Institution is required to either comply with the recommendation or issue an explanation as to why compliance with the recommendation is not appropriate. The guidelines do not grant the Credit Reviewer the power to override the lending decision of the Participating Institution.
 
In addition to the power to review individual applications, the Credit Reviewer also has a general power to review the lending policies (including from the perspective of a particular sector) of each Participating Institution and to issue reports to the Minister for Finance following such a review.
 
NPRFC Investment
 
See item 10 Charter and Bye-Laws.
 
Proposed new legislation impacting the regulation and supervision of the banking sector
 
On March 30, 2010 the Government published the draft Central Bank Reform Bill 2010. The draft bill contains a number of provisions which will, if enacted, impact on the regulation of the Bank, including:
 
•  the requirement for the Central Bank of Ireland (as the CBSFAI will be known once reconstituted under the bill) to approve, prior to their appointment, key office-holders in financial service providers (the types of office-holder to which this obligation will apply will be prescribed by secondary legislation or by orders issued by the Central Bank of Ireland, which as at the date of this Form 20-F have not been published);
 
•  the power of the Central Bank of Ireland to suspend or remove a director, chief executive or other senior executive prescribed in secondary legislation from his or her position in a financial services provider;
 
•  the power of the Central Bank of Ireland to impose levies for the purposes of funding regulation of financial service providers.


50


Table of Contents

 
The draft bill proposes the removal of the promotion of financial services as one of the functions of the Central Bank of Ireland. The draft bill also provides for the transfer of some of the consumer information and education functions from the Central Bank of Ireland to the National Consumer Agency, with the National Consumer Agency being granted the power to impose levies on financial service providers, including the Bank, for the purposes of funding its performance of these functions.
 
The draft bill is subject to amendment in the legislative process and might not be enacted or might be enacted with material amendments to the current draft.
 
The Minister for Finance announced on March 30, 2010 that a second bill will be introduced in the autumn of 2010 which will contain additional new and enhanced regulatory powers and functions for the Central Bank of Ireland, and that a third bill would be subsequently proposed for the purposes of consolidating the current legislation on banking regulation.
 
As part of the EU Restructuring Plan, the Irish Government is proposing to enact legislation to enhance competition in the Irish banking sector.
 
Investigation into the banking system
 
On January 19, 2010, the Minister for Finance announced a framework for an investigation into the factors which contributed to the Irish banking crisis within the context of the international economic and financial environment at that time.
 
As part of the first stage of the investigation into the banking system, the Government commissioned two preliminary investigatory reports. A report on the functions of the CBFSAI over the period from the establishment of the Financial Regulator in May 2003 to the end of September 2008 has been prepared by the recently appointed Governor of the CBFSAI. A second report, dealing with an investigation into the specific factors within the Irish banking sector which exacerbated the impact of the international financial crisis for Ireland, has been prepared by independent experts appointed by the Minister. This preliminary report involved inquiry into the conduct, management and corporate governance of individual financial institutions, including the Bank.
 
Both preliminary reports have been submitted to the Minister and have been published. Their findings are expected to form the basis of the terms of reference of a formal statutory investigation (the “Statutory Commission of Investigation”) which will be established by the Government pursuant to the Commissions of Investigation Act, 2004. At the second stage of the investigation into the banking system, it is expected that the Statutory Commission of Investigation will examine the performance of individual banks and bank directors, the performance of regulatory authorities, the response of Government and Government agencies and the structure of the banking system in Ireland generally.
 
The Government anticipates that the Statutory Commission of Investigation will be established by June 30, 2010 and complete its work by the end of 2010, at which point its findings will be laid before the Finance and Public Service Oireachtas Committee for its consideration. Further inquiry may result from the findings of the Statutory Commission of Investigation, including the possibility of public hearings.
 
Further information including the preliminary reports are available on www. bankinginquiry.gov.ie.
 
UNITED KINGDOM
 
In respect of its banking operations in the United Kingdom, Bank of Ireland has the status of “credit institution” under the Banking Consolidation Directive. Pursuant to the Banking Consolidation Directive, Bank of Ireland has the right to provide banking services on a cross-border basis, or through the establishment of a branch, to clients located in other EEA member states (known as “host” member states) on the basis of its “home” (Irish) authorisation, without the need for separate authorisation by the competent authorities of those “host” member states. This is known as “passporting”, and Bank of Ireland has exercised its EU “passport” rights to provide banking services in the United Kingdom through the establishment of branches and also the provision of services on a cross-border basis.


51


Table of Contents

The powers of the FSA in relation to EEA credit institutions are less extensive than those in relation to United Kingdom credit institutions because, pursuant to the principle of “home country” control incorporated in the Banking Consolidation Directive, the competent authority of the “home country” (in Ireland, the Financial Regulator) has primary responsibility for the supervision of credit institutions incorporated in another EEA state. The FSA, however, retains specific responsibility, in conjunction with the Financial Regulator, for supervising the liquidity of branches of EEA credit institutions which operate in the United Kingdom. The FSA also has the right to carry out on-the-spot verifications of supervisory information relating to branches and for ensuring that EEA credit institutions carrying on activities listed in the Banking Consolidation Directive in the United Kingdom take sufficient steps to cover risks arising from their open positions on financial markets in the United Kingdom. The FSA is also able to apply conduct of business rules to credit institutions providing banking services in the United Kingdom. For example, in relation to deposit taking, it has made rules about conduct of business, approval of advertisements, the handling of complaints and the avoidance of money laundering.
 
Under the Banking Consolidation Directive as implemented in the United Kingdom, the FSA is empowered in specified circumstances to impose a prohibition on, or to restrict the listed activities of, an EEA credit institution providing services into the United Kingdom. Consistent with the allocation of supervisory responsibilities in the Banking Consolidation Directive, the FSA would usually exercise its power only after consulting the relevant home state authority which, as “consolidated supervisor” under the Banking Consolidation Directive, amongst other things, coordinates the gathering and dissemination of information amongst any relevant supervisory authorities. The home state authority also provides for the exchange of information and the planning and co-ordination of supervisory activities in crisis situations and in cases where the authorities become aware of contraventions of the law by institutions covered by the Banking Consolidation Directive operating in their territory. The FSA can also enforce its conduct of business rules and has certain other enforcement powers under UK legislation.
 
Because Bank of Ireland has established a place of business in England, it is subject to the provisions of the United Kingdom Companies Act 2006 which affect overseas companies.
 
In respect of its banking operations in Northern Ireland, Bank of Ireland is empowered under the Bank of Ireland Act, 1821 to issue bank notes as local currency, and is subject to the provisions of the Bankers (Northern Ireland) Act, 1928, the Bank of Ireland and Subsidiaries Act, 1969 and the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, as amended (“FSMA”) in respect thereof.
 
Since December 1, 2001, the FSA’s power and responsibilities derive from the FSMA. The scope of the FSMA was extended in 2004 to include the sale and administration of retail mortgages and long-term care insurance, and in 2005 for general insurance intermediation. It was further extended in 2009 to include the provision of certain banking services that were previously covered by the Banking Code. In January 2005, Post Office Limited became an appointed representative of Bristol & West plc (a wholly owned subsidiary of the Group), which was regulated by the FSA, in respect of its activities in relation to the POFS joint venture with the Group and remained such a representative until September 30, 2007. With effect from October 1, 2007, Post Office Limited became an appointed representative of Bank of Ireland.
 
The FSA’s basic method of supervising banks involves the regular reporting of statistical information and a regular set of returns giving balance sheet and consolidated statement of income data, material on the maturity structure of assets and liabilities, sectoral analysis of business and details of concentration of risk in assets and deposits. Review meetings are held by the FSA with the management of regulated firms. Under the risk based approach introduced in 2001, the FSA’s supervision of banks is based on a systematic analysis of the risk profile of each bank. The FSA also publishes requirements it expects banks to meet on matters such as capital adequacy, limits on large exposures to individual entities and groups of closely connected entities and liquidity.
 
In order to maintain authorisation under the FSMA, regulated firms must be able to demonstrate that they meet, (and will continue to meet) a number of “threshold conditions” set out in the FSMA. For example, authorised firms must have adequate financial resources, not have “close links” of a nature that would impede the FSA’s supervision of the firm and generally satisfy the FSA that they are a “fit and proper” person. In addition, firms are subject to the rules set out in the FSA Handbook, which also provides guidance on the application and interpretation of these rules. The FSA Handbook contains rules governing senior management arrangements, systems and controls, conduct of business, training and competence, money laundering and complaints handling. Any person within an FSA-


52


Table of Contents

regulated firm performing a “controlled function” will also need to be personally approved by the FSA under its “Approved Persons” regime. Approved persons are individually regulated by the FSA, and personally accountable to it, and must meet ongoing standards of conduct and fitness and propriety.
 
The FSA has the power to take a wide range of disciplinary actions against regulated firms and any FSA approved persons, including private warnings, public censure, the imposition of fines, the variation, suspension or termination of the firm’s authorisation or the removal of approved status from individuals.
 
In the United Kingdom, persons carrying on consumer credit business, consumer hire business or an ancillary credit business need a consumer credit licence from the UK Office of Fair Trading under the UK Consumer Credit Act 1974.
 
The licences cover only the activities listed in the licence and business carried out in the names specified in the licence. Various members of the Group hold such licences in relation to regulated consumer credit lending and mortgage broking. The Director General of Fair Trading has certain powers in relation to these licences and these activities. The Office of Fair Trading from time to time issues general or sector-specific guidance on what it expects of fit persons who hold licences, and breaches of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 may be taken into account by the Office of Fair Trading in determining whether a person is fit to hold a licence.
 
The Isle of Man operates the Depositors Compensation Scheme (the “DCS”), in which Bank of Ireland IOM Limited participates. The DCS compensates people with money in current and deposit accounts in financial institutions in the Isle of Man (including in the Bank) with up to £50,000 of net deposits (loans may be netted off against any deposits held with the same deposit taker) per individual depositor or £20,000 for most other categories of depositor. Cover is calculated per depositor, per deposit taker, if a bank fails. Participants in the DCS may be directed, by written notice, to make contribution levies in respect of the DCS compensation fund. These levies may, in any one financial year, equate to the greater of £35,000 and a sum representing 0.125% of the average deposits of the participant as determined by the manager of the scheme, up to a maximum of £350,000. In addition, participants in the DCS may be directed to provide security in respect of any present or future levy contributions.
 
The Group announced in April 2010 that it has been actively considering transferring part of its UK business into a newly incorporated, wholly-owned subsidiary. The establishment of a UK subsidiary, which would be directly regulated by the FSA, would enable the Group to offer products in the UK market that are directly comparable with existing UK mainstream providers from a risk and protection standpoint. The subsidiary would be likely to involve the Group’s Post Office joint ventures, its branch business in Northern Ireland and other parts of its UK business banking operations.
 
UNITED STATES
 
In the United States, Bank of Ireland, its Connecticut branch, its representative offices and certain US subsidiaries are subject to a comprehensive regulatory structure involving numerous statutes, rules and regulations.
 
Bank of Ireland operates a branch in Connecticut from which it conducts a wholesale banking business. The branch is licensed by and is subject to regulation and examination by the Connecticut Department of Banking. Bank of Ireland has representative offices in the States of New York and Illinois. These representative offices are licensed by their respective states and are subject to the laws and regulations of those states. In addition, the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System exercises examination and regulatory authority over the branch and the representative offices. The regulation of the Connecticut branch imposes restrictions on its activities, as well as prudential restrictions, such as limits on extensions of credit to a single borrower. The branch does not accept retail deposits and its deposits and obligations are not insured by the US Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation or any other United States government agency. All covered liabilities of the branch are guaranteed by the CIFS Guarantee Scheme.
 
The Connecticut Department of Banking has the authority to take possession of the business and property of the Group located in Connecticut in certain circumstances relating to the branch. Such circumstances generally include violation of law, unsafe business practices and insolvency.


53


Table of Contents

By operating a branch in the United States, Bank of Ireland and its subsidiaries are subject to regulation by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System under various laws, including the International Banking Act of 1978 and the Bank Holding Company Act of 1956. In this regard, Bank of Ireland has elected to become a “financial holding company” under the Bank Holding Company Act of 1956. Financial holding companies may engage in a broader spectrum of activities, including underwriting and dealing in securities and merchant banking activities, than are permitted to banking organisations that are not financial holding companies. To maintain its financial holding company status, Bank of Ireland is required to meet or exceed certain capital ratios and its branch is required to meet or exceed certain examinations ratings. The failure to maintain financial holding company status could limit the activities of Bank of Ireland and its subsidiaries in the US and have other adverse consequences.
 
A major focus of US governmental policy relating to financial institutions in recent years has been combating money laundering and terrorist financing and enforcing compliance with US economic sanctions issued by the Office of Foreign Assets Control. Regulations applicable to the US operations of Bank of Ireland and its subsidiaries impose obligations to maintain appropriate policies, procedures and controls to detect, prevent and report money laundering and terrorist financing and to ensure compliance with US economic sanctions against designated foreign countries, nationals and others. Failure of a financial institution to maintain and implement adequate programmes to combat money laundering and terrorist financing or to ensure economic sanction compliance could have serious legal, monetary and reputational consequences for the institution.
 
Bank of Ireland’s subsidiaries in the United States are also subject to regulation by applicable federal and state regulations with regard to their activities in the asset based lending, currency exchange, asset management and investment advisory businesses.
 
ECONOMIC CONDITIONS AFFECTING THE GROUP
 
The majority of the Group’s business activities are in Ireland and the UK.
 
The Irish economy has experienced a steep and prolonged recession; annual GDP contracted by 3% in 2008, according to the Irish Central statistics Office (CSO), and by a further 7.1% in 2009. The construction sector was a significant factor behind the slowdown; house building fell by 34% in 2008 and 48% in 2009 while non-residential construction also declined last year, bringing the total fall in real construction spending in 2009 to 34%. The corporate sector also reduced spending on machinery and equipment and as a result total capital formation declined by 30% in 2009 following a 16% fall in the previous year. Consumer spending, which accounts for about half of GDP, fell by over 7% in volume terms in 2009, reflecting falling household disposable income and a rise in the savings ratio, the latter affected by uncertainty about the path of future income in the face of a sharp deterioration in the labour market; the unemployment rate rose from under 5% in 2007 to 13.4% in the first quarter of 2010. Household disposable income appears set to decline again this year, reflecting a further fall in employment, minimal wage growth, if any, a higher tax burden and falling rental income. Interest rates are now at historically low levels, however, which will offer some respite to households with debt, and consumer prices have fallen, so supporting real incomes; retail sales rose on an annual basis in the first quarter of the year, implying stabilization in consumer spending. The external sector provided the only major stimulus to the economy in the downturn and the consensus GDP forecast for 2010, as revealed in a Reuter’s poll, expects this trend to continue, offsetting a further decline in domestic demand to give a broadly flat GDP growth figure for the year as a whole.
 
The Irish housing market has also slowed appreciably since a cyclical peak in early 2007 and prices to March 2010 had fallen by over 34% from the high, according to the Permanent TSB index (a leading Irish housing price indicator). Mortgage lending fell in 2009, reflecting tighter credit standards, a change in price expectations and the impact of the ‘credit crunch’. The cost to banks of funding in the wholesale money markets has risen substantially, as has the cost of term funding, putting a premium on customer deposits. Rents have also declined and are 25% below the peak according to the CSO. Commercial property in Ireland has fallen sharply in value (by over 55% from the peak to end-March 2010 according to IPD) but investment returns on commercial property were positive in the first quarter of 2010 for the first time in two years, implying a possible bottom in that market.
 
The fall in economic activity and the decline in asset prices badly affected the Government’s finances; the General Government deficit exceeded 14% of GDP in 2009 and the Department of Finance expects the deficit to exceed 11%


54


Table of Contents

of GDP in 2010. The Government has responded by raising taxes and cutting expenditure. S&P has reduced Ireland’s sovereign debt rating from AAA to AA.
 
The UK economy also experienced a recession (GDP fell by 4.9% in 2009) but activity has picked up again with GDP recording positive growth in the final quarter of 2009 and the first quarter of 2010. The consensus forecast is for GDP growth of 1.3% in 2010 and over 2% next year. The Bank of England responded to the downturn by cutting interest rates to an historic low of 0.5% and embarked on more unconventional policies, including the purchase of £200bn in bonds (mostly Gilts), funded by the creation of bank money in an effort to boost credit creation and stimulate economic activity. Mortgage lending has begun to pick up, albeit modestly, and house prices have also risen from the lows, according to the Nationwide index. Commercial property values also fell substantially in the recession but are also rising again according to the IPD index.
 
In a broader international context the global economy is recovering from an unusual severe downturn, with the developing economies leading the upturn. There has also been a pronounced policy response from the major economies, involving expansionary fiscal and monetary policy and more direct intervention to support the banking sector. The path of the recovery remains uncertain, however, and many banks are seeking to boost capital and reduce risk weighted assets, adding to a difficult business environment for the banking sector.
 
Item 4A   UNRESOLVED STAFF COMMENTS
 
None.
 
Item 5   OPERATING & FINANCIAL REVIEW AND PROSPECTS
 
Overview
 
In February 2010, the Group announced that it was changing its financial year from March 31 to December 31, (see note 1 to the Consolidated Financial Statements). The nine month trading period ended December 31, 2009, was very difficult for both our customers and our business and this has been reflected in the substantial increase in credit losses.
 
Delivering Group Stability
 
The operating environment was very difficult in the nine months to December 31, 2009 with a further contraction in the level of economic activity across our core markets in Ireland and the UK and difficult economic conditions globally. Towards the end of the period the economic environment showed some signs of stabilisation with the pace of decline in key metrics beginning to slow.
 
With hindsight, it is clear that the Bank’s growth ambitions in previous years had been framed against an overly optimistic view of the outlook for the Irish economy and it was too exposed to the property sector and too reliant on wholesale funding. Consequently the Group was particularly affected by the severe economic downturn of the last two years in the Irish market compounded by the worst turmoil global financial markets had experienced since the 1930s.
 
The Irish Government acted decisively in support of the Irish banks during this time to underpin their systemic contribution to economic recovery. The priority was to enhance the availability of liquidity and ensure the continued access to funding for the Irish banking system. In common with initiatives introduced by other governments to protect their financial systems and economies, a number of key initiatives were implemented by the Irish Government. These included: in September 2008 the introduction of the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Scheme 2008 which guarantees deposits and certain liabilities for participating banks until September 2010; in March 2009 the National Pension Reserve Fund Commission made a €3.5 billion investment in Bank of Ireland via 8% coupon preference stock (with warrants); in December 2009 the introduction of the Credit Institutions (Eligible Liabilities Guarantee) Scheme 2009 (the ‘ELG Scheme’), which provides participating banks with the option to issue (before September 2010) guaranteed or un-guaranteed debt securities and deposits with a maturity of up to five years; and in December 2009 the establishment of NAMA which is acquiring performing and non-performing land and development and associated loans (primarily investment property loans) from participating banks.


55


Table of Contents

Bank of Ireland also implemented a strategy during this time to stabilise the Group, strengthen our capital position, enhance our funding, reduce our costs, while continuing to support our customers.
 
With respect to capital and funding:
 
•  In November 2008 we cancelled dividends on ordinary stock to preserve capital;
 
•  In January 2009 we announced our withdrawal from the intermediary sourced mortgage market in the UK and we commenced the process of winding down a series of non-core international lending portfolios in Capital Markets which we expect will reduce the size of our balance sheet over time (as at December 31, 2009 loan assets in these activities totalled approximately €34 billion). This reduction of assets, which will be managed for value, will reduce the quantum of wholesale funding we require, will lower our risk-weighted assets and, as a result, will strengthen our capital ratios;
 
•  In June 2009 we completed a debt re-purchase programme of a nominal value of €1.7 billion Euro, Sterling and US Dollar denominated Tier 1 securities. The gain generated from the re-purchase increased Equity tier 1 capital by €1 billion;
 
•  In February 2010 we completed a debt-for-debt exchange whereby we exchanged certain Lower tier 2 securities for a new series of longer dated Lower tier 2 securities. This resulted in a gain to Equity tier 1 capital of €405 million whilst leaving our total capital position unchanged;
 
•  In February 2010 we issued 184 million units of Ordinary Stock to the NPRFC in lieu of the €250 million cash dividend otherwise due on the 2009 Preference Stock;
 
•  Between January 2009 and March 2010 we raised approximately €14 billion of term funding (wholesale funding with a maturity of one year or greater) in total across a series of benchmark deals and private placements;
 
•  On April 26, 2010, the Group announced its Proposals to further strengthen capital (subject to shareholder approval);
 
•  On May 19, 2010 at the Extraordinary General Court (EGC) of Bank of Ireland, the shareholders passed all the resolutions to enable the completion of the proposed capital raise; and
 
•  On June 9, 2010 the Group announced the completion of its capital raising Proposals which generated additional equity tier 1 capital of €2.9 billion, with the transaction setting on June 14, 2010.
 
NAMA
 
In January 2010 at our Extraordinary General Court, our stockholders voted in favour of Bank of Ireland’s application to participate in NAMA, and in February 2010, the Minister for Finance confirmed our designation as a participating member. Performing and nonperforming land and development loans, together with associated loans (primarily investment property loans), collectively defined as Eligible Bank Assets, are expected to be acquired by NAMA on a phased basis from early April 2010, with the largest systemic exposures to the Irish banking system being acquired first.
 
Our original estimates of assets transferring to NAMA were based upon the disclosure made by the Minister for Finance in his speech of September 16, 2009 where the Minister indicated that circa €16 billion of both performing and non-performing assets would transfer to the Agency from Bank of Ireland. Since that date, and taking into account the impact of the EU approval of NAMA on February 29, 2010, we have had ongoing interaction with NAMA and have conducted a comprehensive internal review to identify all loans falling within the eligibility criteria based on the Eligible Asset Regulations formulated by NAMA.
 
Largely as a result of this review, we expect to retain loans of circa €3 billion from the original estimate of €16 billion on the Bank’s balance sheet and transfer loans of circa €12.2 billion to NAMA.
 
Of the circa €3 billion of loans which we expect to retain, approximately one third are land and development loans and two thirds are associated loans. The estimates of impairment losses on the non-NAMA bound loans and


56


Table of Contents

advances to customers of €4.7 billion to March 31, 2011 includes estimates of impairment losses on these assets which are now no longer expected to transfer to NAMA.
 
The loans we now expect to transfer to NAMA of circa €12.2 billion have impairment provisions of €2.8 billion at December 31, 2009 and, together with related derivatives of €0.2 billion, will give rise to a net transfer of €9.6 billion of Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA. The loans are expected to comprise €8.5 billion of land and development loans and €3.7 billion of associated loans.
 
The Group has completed the transfer of the first tranche of loans of gross €1.9 billion to NAMA in early April 2010 comprising of €0.9 billion of land and development loans and €1.0 billion of associated loans. The consideration for these assets will amounted to €1.2 billion.
 
While the limited number and nature of loans involved in this first tranche may not be representative of the total portfolio, applying this level of discount to the total portfolio would result in a loss of €4.4 billion (before taking account of impairment provisions of €2.8 billion at December 31, 2009). We have developed a model which we believe replicates the NAMA valuation methodology and have put through that model a sample of €6 billion — approximately 50% — of the loans we expect to go to NAMA, including the first tranche. This model indicates that, on this sample, the level of discount would be similar to that pertaining to the first tranche. We believe, therefore, that the value of the discount on the total portfolio transferring to NAMA will be within the guidance we provided at our Extraordinary General Court meeting in January 2010. However the actual loss will be known only on completion of the relevant due diligence and valuation exercises on a loan by loan basis.
 
Impairment — non-NAMA assets
 
The Group have conducted an extensive internal review of our impairment estimates on our non-NAMA bound loans and advances to customers. The outcome of this review is to confirm that the outlook for impairments on our non-NAMA bound loans remains as expected and we confirm our previous guidance of an impairment charge for these loans of €4.7 billion over the 3 years ending March 31, 2011. The Group believe that the impairment charge on our non-NAMA loans and advances to customers has peaked in 2009 and will reduce progressively in each of 2010, 2011 and 2012.
 
Funding
 
We have made good progress in improving our funding profile and our core loan portfolio, which excludes those loans in run-off or transferring to NAMA, is now substantially matched by an equivalent amount of customer deposits. A key focus of the Group is to reduce its reliance on the Government Guarantee Schemes which are currently due to expire on September 29, 2010 and we are positioning ourselves to disengage from these schemes in a prudent and safe manner. We prioritised the gathering of customer deposits in the nine months ended December 31, 2009 which have increased by 2% to €85 billion since March 31, 2009. In addition we have reduced the quantum of our wholesale funding to €61 billion at December 31, 2009, down from €74 billion at March 31, 2009. We also extended the maturity profile of this wholesale funding with 32%, at December 31, 2009, having a maturity profile of one year or greater compared to 27%, at March 31, 2009. Taking account of the deleveraging initiatives outlined above, the Bank is targeting a Group loan / deposit ratio of less than 130% by December 2012.
 
Capital
 
We continued to supplement the Group’s capital which is a key priority for us. Liability management initiatives, outlined above, generated circa €1.4 billion of additional Equity tier 1 capital. However the losses recorded in the period, largely as a result of the sharp increase in impairment charges, resulted in an overall reduction in our capital ratios. On a proforma basis at December 31, 2009, reflecting the February 2010 Lower tier 2 exchange, our Equity tier 1, Core tier 1, Tier 1 and Total capital ratios were 5.8%, 9.3%, 10.2% and 13.4% respectively which compares to 6.2%, 9.5%, 12.0% and 15.2% respectively at March 2009.
 
On March 30, 2010, the Financial Regulator publicly advised the market of the outcome of the Prudential Capital Assessment Review for Bank of Ireland and he determined that the Group needed to raise an additional €2.66 billion of equity capital by December 31, 2010. This outcome was aligned with our previously held views. To support the Group’s capital needs, the State committed to converting part of its €3.5 billion 2009 Preference Stock into ordinary equity.


57


Table of Contents

On April 26, 2010 the Group announced its Proposals to further strengthen capital with a proposal to raise not less than €2.8 billion of capital through the implementation of an Institutional Placing, NPRFC Placing, Rights Issue (including the NPRFC Rights Issue Undertaking), and Debt for Equity Offers.
 
The Group has completed all elements of these Proposals which included;
 
•  a firm placing to Private Investors of c. 327 million units of ordinary stock at a price of €1.53 per unit for €0.5 billion (which represented a 15% discount on the closing price of €1.80 per unit of ordinary stock on April 23, 2010);
 
•  a firm Placing to the NPRFC that involved the conversion of 1,038 million units of the 2009 Preference Stock at a subscription price of €1 each into ordinary stock at the closing price on April 23, 2010 (€1.80 per unit of ordinary stock);
 
•  under the Debt for Equity Offers, existing holders of eligible debt securities got the opportunity to exchange those securities for a) cash proceeds raised from the allotment of ordinary stock on behalf of these bond holders in the rights issue or b) allotment instruments of up to €200 million (which automatically convert into ordinary stock on the conversion day). Participation in the offer was 57% resulting in a total gain of circa €233 million (this was in addition to the €1.4 billion additional equity tier 1 Capital arising from the earlier liability management initiatives) of which €100 million was applied to reduce the rights issue;
 
•  the NPRFC committing to take up its full rights in respect of its holdings and the consideration was the conversion of units of the 2009 Preference Stock at a subscription price of €1.00 each into ordinary stock at the rights issue price;
 
•  the warrants held by the NPRFC to subscribe for 334,737,148 units of ordinary stock were cancelled on May 19, 2010 in return for the payment of €491 million in cash by the Bank to the NPRFC; and
 
•  the estimated aggregate costs associated with the Proposals above are €130 million (inclusive of VAT).
 
•  Ordinary stockholders were invited to subscribe for rights issue stock at a price of €0.55 per new unit of ordinary stock on the basis of 3 new units of ordinary stock for every 2 existing units of ordinary stock held. This price represented a discount of 41.7% to the theoretical ex-rights price (TERP). Stockholders participation in the Rights Issue was fully underwritten by international investment banks and sub-underwriters and the results were announced on June 9, 2010, with the transaction settling on June 14, 2010. Valid acceptances of 94.63% was received from the 3,136,446,163 units of ordinary stock issued. The balance of the rights issue stock was placed with investors on June 9, 2010 at a price of €0.75. The Bank also announced the results of the US Debt for Equity offer in relation to late tenders received of $1.25 million.
 
These capital proposals completed on June 8, 2010 and settled on June 14, 2010.
 
The net impact of the above Proposals is to increase the Group’s equity tier 1 capital by €2.9 billion as follows:
 
         
    € m
 
Placing*
    1,536  
Rights Issue
    1,725  
Debt for Equity
    295  
         
      3,556  
Warrant Cancellation
    (491 )
Costs and Fees
    (130 )
         
Net Increase
    2,935  
         
 
 
Institutional placing and NPRFC Placing.
 
European Commission
 
As part of the European Commission’s State aid review, we submitted our restructuring plan to the European Commission on September 30, 2009. Over the last number of months, the Department of Finance and Bank of Ireland have been involved in detailed discussions with the European Commission in relation to the terms of our restructuring plan.


58


Table of Contents

The Group expects that the decision regarding the approval of the proposed measures, including the final binding terms of the EU Restructuring Plan, will be taken by the European Commission, by mid-2010. Therefore, at the date of the Form 20-F, there can be no certainty as to the outcome of the State aid proceedings and the content of the final EU Restructuring Plan. The Group expects, however, based on the current status of its negotiations through the Department of Finance with the European Commission that the final EU Restructuring Plan is likely to consist of the key elements set out in note 58(h) in the notes to the consolidated financial statements.
 
A Strengthened Platform for Sustainable Growth
 
Bank of Ireland is emerging from this crisis a changed and more focused bank. We are now directing our capital and resources to our core business portfolios where we have clear competitive strengths and capabilities, and strong positions in markets with attractive growth opportunities.
 
Core portfolio
 
•  In Ireland, our objective is to be the number one retail and commercial bank. We believe that Ireland is an attractive banking marketplace with favourable demographics, a pro-business environment, and a changing competitive landscape. We have leading positions in our main business segments holding the number one or two market positions for our principal product and market segments across each of our business units.
 
•  In the UK, we continue to grow our consumer banking franchise through our partnership with the UK Post Office. This franchise has in excess of two million customers accessing our comprehensive range of products through over 11,500 Post Office branches. In addition to our consumer banking activities in England, Scotland and Wales we will maximise the opportunities offered by our network of branches in Northern Ireland and continue to develop our Business Banking, Corporate Banking and Treasury activities focused on specific customer segments in the UK.
 
•  Internationally, we remain fully committed to developing further in the US and continental Europe those activities where we believe we have clear competitive strengths and capabilities, namely: our corporate banking specialist lending businesses in the areas of global project finance, mid-market leveraged acquisition finance, comprehensive asset based lending, together with our treasury management services.
 
Non-core portfolio
 
In line with our continuing objective to de-lever our balance sheet we are reducing the assets in our non-core portfolios through a disciplined process of run-off and / or disposals as market opportunities allow. This reduction of assets will continue to be managed for value. For example we will reduce our wholesale funding requirements in tandem with the realisation of proceeds from the run-down of our UK intermediary distributed mortgage portfolio of approximately €30 billion, our international capital markets lending portfolios of approximately €4 billion and the net proceeds from the transfer of circa €12.2 billion property loans to NAMA.
 
Net interest margin
 
Interest rates at historically low levels, together with intense competition, have resulted in an unsustainable mismatch in the pricing of our assets and liabilities. In the year ahead, as we position ourselves to achieve the financial stability which would allow us to cease our reliance on the Government guarantees, we plan to extend the maturity profile of our wholesale funding, which will reduce our net interest margin in the short term. Re-pricing of loan assets and deposits is a management priority, and while some progress has been made thus far, further steps are necessary in order for us to achieve a more appropriate net interest margin.
 
Costs
 
Costs remain a key strategic focus for the Group and our objective remains to reduce our cost base to align it better to meet the needs of the Group for the future. In this regard we are targeting to achieve a cost income ratio of below 50% in our 2013 financial year.
 
In the nine months to December 31, 2009 we reduced our costs by 11% compared to the nine months ended December 31, 2008, largely due to a further reduction in staff numbers together with continued rigorous management of all cost categories across the Group. Since March 2008, staff numbers are down by approximately


59


Table of Contents

2,200, representing a reduction of 13%. While our overall costs have reduced, our pension costs have increased. The deficit on the Group’s pension schemes at December 31, 2009 was €1.6 billion (as calculated under IAS 19), primarily due to increased longevity of pensioners, lower interest rates, high wage inflation historically, and subdued investment returns. There is recognition between the Bank and all relevant parties that this situation is not sustainable and that we must agree a shared solution to address the issue. We are making good progress in this matter and further details are set out in note 58 on page F-49 in the notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
Outlook
 
Trading conditions in our core markets in Ireland and the UK in the first quarter of our 2010 financial year remained challenging though economic conditions have recently shown some signs of stabilisation after the substantial fall in economic output from early in 2008.
 
Net interest income is being impacted by a number of factors:
 
•  the low interest rate environment, together with the impact of continuing competition on deposit pricing, placing pressure on deposit margins;
 
•  the higher cost of wholesale funding as we continue to increase the quantum of term funding (wholesale funding with a maturity of one year or greater) in pursuit of our strategy to disengage in a prudent manner from the Government Guarantee Schemes; and
 
•  while lending margins on new business remain strong, low levels of new business activity mutes the impact of this.
 
As a result, we continue to anticipate some downward pressure on our net interest margin in 2010. Ongoing strong cost discipline across the Group and the benefits of business disposals and other initiatives implemented in the prior financial year continue to deliver cost savings as anticipated. The challenging economic conditions, unemployment and weak consumer sentiment continue to impact the loan impairment charge as expected. We continue to believe that loan losses on our non-NAMA-bound loan portfolios have peaked with the impairment charge progressively reducing as previously guided. Loan losses on these portfolios for the three year period to March 31, 2011 remain within the loan loss guidance of €4.7 billion.
 
The quantum of customer lending, including loans held for sale to NAMA, remains broadly unchanged at March 31, 2010 when compared to December 31, 2009 on a constant currency basis. The demand for new loans is muted. Competition for customer deposits remains intense and our customer deposits at March 31, 2010 are marginally lower compared to December 31, 2009 on a constant currency basis. In January 2010, the Group’s long term and short term credit ratings were downgraded by Standard & Poor’s to A- / A-2 with a stable outlook. This downgrade led to an initial outflow of some ratings sensitive international deposits. In the quarter ended March 31, 2010, the Group has raised approximately €4.5 billion in term funding (funding with a maturity greater than one year at date of issue). In line with the Group’s stated goals, the maturity profile of its wholesale funding has been extended with over 37% of its overall wholesale funding having a maturity of greater than one year at March 31, 2010 compared to 32% at December 31, 2009.
 
Performance Overview
 
Group loss before tax of €1,813 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compares to a loss before tax (LBT) of €23 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009, with basic loss per share (LPS) of 168.6 cent for the nine month period, compared to earnings per share of 4.3 cent for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Even allowing for the shorter reporting period this significant reduction is driven primarily by a reduction in total income (net of insurance claims) and a substantial increase in the impairment charge on loans and advances to customers, partly offset by a material reduction in total operating expenses.
 
The Group loss before tax for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 included a gain of €1,037 million on the repurchase of tier 1 debt securities in June 2009 and a gain of €67 million as a result of an adjustment under effective interest rate (EIR) method of recognizing interest expense on subordinated liabilities arising from the restriction imposed by the EU Commission on the Group’s ability to make coupon payments on certain subordinated liabilities unless under a binding obligation to do so.


60


Table of Contents

The twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 included an impairment charge of €304 million related to the Group’s US based asset management businesses, Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC (Guggenheim) and Iridian Asset Management LLC (Iridian), which had been severely impacted by the downturn in the global asset management sector. During the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 the Group disposed of its interest in Guggenheim and Iridian resulting in a net loss of €3 million.
 
Total income (net of insurance claims and including gain on repurchase of subordinated liabilities) of €3,599 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is lower than the total income (net of insurance claims) of €3,957 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The increased cost of deposits in highly competitive markets, higher cost of term funding in wholesale markets, lower fees and other income as a result of reduced business activities and asset disposals, the higher cost of the Government Guarantee Scheme and impairment on investment properties partly offset by the gain on repurchase of tier 1 debt securities in June 2009 are the principal factors underlying the reduction in total income.
 
Operating expenses of €1,381 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 are €740 million lower than the operating expenses of €2,121 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Even allowing for the shorter reporting period the costs are lower due to reductions in staff numbers, a restructuring provision of €83 million in the prior period together with rigorous management of all costs. This focus on rigorous cost management will continue as further action is taken to align costs to an environment of lower levels of activity and revenues. As a result, the cost/income ratio for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was 38% compared to 62% for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
The impairment charge on loans and advances to customers including loans held for sale to NAMA for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of €4,055 million is a substantial increase over the impairment charge of €1,435 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase reflects the very challenging economic conditions, higher unemployment, weaker consumer sentiment and, in particular, a dramatic slowdown in the property and construction sector in Ireland and, to a lesser extent, in the UK.
 
Of the €4,055 million impairment charge for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, €2,231 million or 55% relates to loans held for sale to NAMA and €1,824 million or 45% relates to loans and advances to customers.
 
The Group’s share of results from associates and joint ventures of €35 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compares to a loss of €42 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The profit after tax of €35 million is primarily attributable to the Group’s share of First Rate Exchange Services (FRES), a joint venture with the UK Post Office, which reported a profit after tax of €27 million (Stg£23 million) for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009. The loss of €42 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 was significantly impacted by an impairment charge of €63 million arising from the Group’s stake in a property unit trust that holds an investment in a UK retail property.
 
Loss after tax for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of €1,469 million compares to a profit after tax of €18 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The taxation credit for the Group was €344 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a taxation credit of €41 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 primarily due to losses in the nine month period.
 
Divisional Performance
 
Retail Republic of Ireland delivered LBT of €1,514 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a PBT of €11 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Financial performance has been impacted by the significant contraction in the Irish economy. The sharp decline in the property and construction sectors with continuing low levels of transactions in both the commercial and residential property markets has led to a substantially higher impairment charge of €1,836 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €708 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Intense competition for deposits and the low interest rate environment resulted in significant reductions in deposit margins. The economic outlook together with poor consumer sentiment has resulted in subdued demand for financial services products. Operating expenses were lower reflecting reduced staff numbers and tight control of costs.


61


Table of Contents

Bank of Ireland Life delivered PBT of €133 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, versus a LBT of €107 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The results for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 include a positive investment valuation variance of €23 million. The performance of investment markets since April 2009 has resulted in a positive investment valuation variance, this compares to an underperformance of investment markets in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009, which gave rise to the negative investment valuation variance of €117 million. The nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is also directly impacted by a gain relating to the gross-up of policyholder tax in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of €64 million compared to a charge of €76 million in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Consistent with long term bond yields, the discount rate applied to future cash flows decreased from 9.0% to 8.25%, and the unit growth assumption was reduced from 7.25% to 6.5%, resulting in a gain of €3 million in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, compared to a loss of €16 million in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
The UK Financial Services division delivered a LBT of £720 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, compared to a LBT of £46 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Net interest income of £411 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is £216 million lower than the twelve month period ended March 31 2009 due to the shorter reporting period, intense competition impacting liability spreads together with the low interest rate environment. The negative impacts were partly offset by higher pricing on both the Residential Mortgage and Business Banking loan books. The results in the Business Banking and Residential Mortgage businesses were significantly impacted by higher impairment charges of £948 million primarily in the land and development element of the Property and construction portfolio which has been significantly impacted by the sharp declines in asset values, higher unemployment and lower levels of economic activity. Operating expenses for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of £267 million were £180 million lower than the operating expenses of £447 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction is driven by the shorter reporting period together with savings from the restructuring of both the UK Residential mortgage and Business Banking operations. Investment has continued in the joint ventures with the UK Post Office. The prior twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 included a restructuring provision of £56 million.
 
The Capital Markets division delivered a LBT of €603 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a PBT of €161 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This significant reduction is driven primarily by significant impairment charges €1,157 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €305 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The results for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009, included a charge of €304 million relating to the write-off of goodwill and other intangible assets in relation to the Group’s US based asset management businesses. During the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 the Group disposed of its interest in Guggenheim and Iridian resulting in a net loss of €3 million. Corporate Banking delivered a LBT of €749 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a PBT of €247 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 driven primarily by higher impairment charges. Global Markets delivered a PBT of €128 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a PBT of €246 million for the twelve month period ended march 31, 2009. This reduction is due to the shorter reporting period, the higher cost of funding, gains in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 arising as a result of good positioning in a falling interest rate environment and lower levels of third party customer business in the current reporting period as a result of the reduced level of economic activity.
 
Economic Environment
 
Domestic demand in Ireland has been very weak, driven initially by a significant contraction in construction output and a decline in business spending, followed by a substantial fall in consumer spending, which fell by an estimated 7.0% in 2009. The weakness in domestic demand is also reflected in the number of company insolvencies, which rose by 82% in 2009 on the previous year. Irish employment fell by 166,900 or 8.1% in the twelve months to December 31, 2009. The unemployment rate rose rapidly, from under 5% in early 2008 to 13.2% by the end of 2009 and was 13.4% in each of the three months January to March 2010. The ESRI forecasts a savings ratio of 10.25% in 2010 which is a decline from its figure of 10.6% for 2009 but a significant increase from the 2007 ratio of 2.3%.
 
The Irish economy has however shown some signs of stabilization after the unprecedented fall in output from early 2008 — GDP contracted by 7.4% in the six months to March 31, 2009 but by only 0.3% in the six months to September 30, 2009. GDP has contracted by 7.1% for the 2009 calendar year. Expectations for the near-term


62


Table of Contents

outlook have improved, with an expected return to growth in the second half of 2010 leading to a fall in GDP of 0.5% for the 2010 calendar year. The consensus expectation for 2011 is for a 3% growth in GDP.
 
While the markets perception of Irish sovereign risk stabilized in the first quarter of 2010 there are still concerns over increases in the cost of borrowings which Ireland may face. The recent volatility in market sentiment, as the euro fell in value against the US dollar and sterling, was due to the significant concerns about the Greek sovereign debt position but the recent rating agencies downgrade of Greece, Spain and Portugal has increased the risks throughout the Eurozone.
 
Exports are a primary driver of economic activity in Ireland, with the value of merchandise exports falling by just 3% in 2009 against a 22% decline in imports. The general view amongst forecasters is that exports should start to grow again this year, given the global recovery and in response to a fall in wages in Ireland, which is expected to boost competitiveness. The EU forecasts a fall in Irish unit labour costs in 2010 in absolute terms and relative to other EU member states.
 
The recession in Ireland has been deeper than the average across the European Union and this, together with the euro appreciation against Sterling (30% of Irish imports are from the United Kingdom) has resulted in a fall in Irish consumer prices; inflation averaged -1.7% in 2009 on the basis of the standardised European measure of inflation (“HICP”), or -4.5% on the Irish Consumer Price Index (“CPI”), which, unlike the HICP, includes mortgage interest. Inflation is expected to return to positive territory by the end of 2010, although average inflation for the year is likely to remain negative, at -1.1% on the CPI measure.
 
The quantum of bank lending has contracted in Ireland, falling by over 3% in 2009, excluding write-downs and valuation effects. Mortgage lending in Ireland fell by 0.3% and Irish households have reduced credit card debt by €3 billion in outstanding balances at the end of 2009, a decline of 0.7% over 2008.
 
The Government has set out a framework to reduce the general Government balance deficit to 3% of GDP by 2014. A fiscal correction of 5% of GDP in 2009 was implemented between July 2008 and April 2009. The measures included the introduction of an income tax levy, reducing the public sector pay bill through the implementation of a pension levy, and containing public expenditure across Government departments. The Government budget for 2010, presented in December 2009, delivered a further fiscal correction amounting to 2.5% of GDP. This focused on reducing public expenditure through a further reduction in the public sector pay bill and a reduction in social welfare spending.
 
The Irish property market has yet to show clear signs of stabilization. House prices fell 18.5% in 2009 and as at December 31, 2009 are 32% below the peak reached in February 2007 according to the Permanent-tsb / ESRI index. Commercial property prices have also fallen very significantly, with capital values down over 56% from their peak, according to the IPD index. The pace of decline in the value of commercial property has slowed, however, with a 4.9% decline in the fourth quarter of 2009, against 8.5% in the third quarter of 2009 and 17.7% in the fourth quarter of 2008.
 
GDP in the UK economy contracted by 4.95% but returned to growth in the final quarter of 2009, with GDP rising by 0.4%. GDP grew by 0.2% in the first quarter of 2010. The consensus view is that the economy will grow at a slow pace, 1.2% in 2010 and 2.3% in 2011, although uncertainty remains on the likely impact on the economy of the pace of fiscal tightening required to reduce the UK national budget deficit.
 
The UK housing market has not exhibited the excess levels of supply to the extent exhibited in Ireland and as a result prices started to rise in the Spring of 2009 as demand stabilized. In the period October 2007 to February 2009, residential house prices in the UK fell steadily with the cumulative decline over this period amounting to 19.5%. In the 12 month period to March 2010, prices have risen by an annual 9% (Nationwide Index) and lending to the household sector has begun to rise, albeit at a slow pace. The commercial property market also appears to be recovering, having bottomed in mid-2009 according to the IPD Irish Commercial Property Index, with a 45% fall in capital values from peak in the second quarter of 2007 to trough in the second quarter of 2009. Capital values grew strongly in the final quarter of 2009, at 8.1%. Employment has fallen by less than some had predicted, in part reflecting much weaker wage growth than in previous recessions. The unemployment rate has stabilized at 7.8% in each of the three months to January 2010.
 
See item 4 “Information on the Company — Economic conditions affecting the Group”.


63


Table of Contents

 
CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES AND JUDGEMENTS
 
The Group makes estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities within the next financial year. Estimates and judgments are continually evaluated and are based on historical experience and other factors, including expectations of future events that are believed to be reasonable under the circumstances. Details of these critical accounting estimates and judgements are set out on pages F-36 to F-39 of this document.
 
MARKET CONDITIONS
 
Trading conditions for the Group were very difficult in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 with a reduction in the overall level of economic activity and a further deterioration in the credit environment across our main markets.
 
Valuation of Financial Instruments
 
Where possible, the Group calculates fair value using observable market prices. Where market prices are not available or unreliable, fair values are determined using valuation techniques which may include discounted cash flow models or comparisons to instruments with characteristics either identical or similar to those of the instruments held by the Group. More detail on the methods and assumptions used in the valuation of financial instruments is set out in notes 46 and 47 to the consolidated financial statements.
 
LIQUIDITY AND CAPITAL RESOURCES
 
The Group’s overall liquidity policy and control is the responsibility of the Group Asset and Liability Committee (“ALCO”) and is managed on behalf of ALCO by Group Treasury to ensure that the Group can meet its current and future re-financing needs at all times and at acceptable costs. See Item 11 “Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures about Market Risk” for further details about our risk management policies. (See also note 56 in the F pages of this document.)
 
Capital Management Objectives and Policies
 
The objectives of the Group’s capital management policy are to at all times comply with regulatory capital requirements and to ensure that the Group has sufficient capital to cover the risks of its business and support its future development.
 
The capital adequacy requirements set by the Financial Regulator in Ireland which reflects the requirements as set out in the EU Capital Requirements Directive and its preceding directives are used by the Group as the basis for its capital management. These requirements set a floor under which capital levels must not fall. The Group seeks to maintain sufficient capital to ensure that even under stressed conditions these requirements are not breached.
 
The Group also looks at other methodologies of capital measurement including the capital definitions set out by rating agencies. It also calculates economic capital based on its own internal models.
 
The Group meets its objectives in terms of capital management through the maintenance of capital ratios above the minimum levels set by the Financial Regulator and relative to market expectations for banks with its business profile. Market expectations regarding capital ratios for banks have risen following the rise in loss expectations across the international banking industry, driven by exposures to assets vulnerable to the downturn in residential and commercial real estate prices and the deteriorating economic climate. These increased expectations have led to substantial private and government led recapitalization schemes internationally.
 
On March 30, 2010, the Financial Regulator announced the outcome of a Prudential Capital Assessment Review (“PCAR”) for the Group and it was determined that the Group needed to raise an additional €2.7 billion of equity capital by December 31, 2009. Further details are set out on page 44.


64


Table of Contents

The following table sets out the Group’s capital resources (stockholders’ equity and subordinated liabilities):
 
                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    (in € millions)
 
Stockholders’ funds
                       
Equity (including other equity reserves)
    6,345       6,810       6,477  
Non-cumulative preference stock
    42       42       7  
                         
Total Stockholder’s Equity
    6,387       6,852       6,484  
Minority interests’ equity
    50       61       38  
Undated loan capital
    1,521       3,385       3,209  
Dated loan capital
    4,532       4,557       4,599  
                         
Total capital resources
    12,490       14,855       14,330  
                         
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
In the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 the Group’s total capital resources reduced by €2,365 million to €12,490 million. The movement of €2,365 million includes a decrease of €465 million relating to Stockholders’ equity (including other equity reserves) and a decrease of €1,864 million relating to undated loan capital. The movement of €465 million in Stockholders’ funds was mainly driven by an after tax loss of €1,460 million which included the €1,037 million gain arising from the June 2009 repurchase of tier 1 debt securities, a net actuarial loss on pension funds of €74 million and an increase in other reserves (Available for sale reserves of €924 million and cash flow hedging reserve of €82 million) together with a positive movement in foreign exchange reserves of €117 million primarily due to the strengthening of Sterling against euro. Other items gave rise to a negative movement of €54 million. The movement of €1,864 million in undated loan capital primarily relates to the tier 1 repurchase in June 2009 together with fair value movements on the remaining securities.
 
Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
In the year ended March 31, 2009, total Group capital resources increased by €525 million to €14,855 million primarily following the recapitalisation of the bank by the Irish Government through its investment of €3,500 million in preference stock (€3,462 million net of costs), offset by negative retentions for the period of €328 million, other net negative movements in equity of €2,766 million including changes in the cash flow hedge reserve (€540) million, the available for sale (AFS) reserve (€1,113) million, foreign exchange adjustments (€528) million, the movement in the defined benefit pension schemes (€544) million, the issue or reissue of capital stock (€83) million and other movements of €42 million. Other movements in the year to March 31, 2009 include a €176 million increase in relation to undated loan capital, a €42 million decrease in relation to dated loan capital while minority interests increased by €23 million.


65


Table of Contents

                         
        Restated*
  Restated*
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
Movements on Stockholders’ Equity   2009   2009   2008
    (in € millions)
 
Stockholders’ Equity at beginning of period
    6,852       6,484       6,724  
Movements:
                       
(Loss)/Profit attributable to stockholders(a)
    (1,460 )     53       1,696  
Equity dividends
          (387 )     (611 )
Preference share capital and warrants(f)
          3,462        
Reissue of stock/treasury stock
    (7 )     (83 )     194  
Foreign exchange adjustments(b)(g)
    117       (528 )     (712 )
Available for Sale (AFS) reserve movement(c)(h)
    924       (1,113 )     (386 )
Cash flow hedge reserve movement(d)(i)
    82       (540 )     (247 )
Pension fund obligations(e)(j)
    (74 )     (544 )     (209 )
Other movements
    (47 )     48       35  
                         
Closing Stockholder’s Equity
    6,387       6,852       6,484  
                         
 
 
* The prior years have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
An explanation of the movements in stockholders equity during the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, is as follows:
 
(a) The loss attributable to stockholders of €1,460 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 shows a significant decrease compared to the profit attributable to stockholders of €53 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This is primarily due to the substantial increase in the impairment charge on Total loans.
 
(b) Foreign exchange adjustments reflect the impact of any euro related movements on the translation of sterling and US dollar denominated net investments in foreign operations.
 
(c) The AFS reserve movement in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is driven by the impact of tighter credit spreads and interest rate changes on the value of the AFS book. The AFS reserve is expected to continue to reverse as the underlying financial assets mature
 
(d) The cash flow hedge reserve movement reflects the impact of changes in interest rates on the mark to market value of cash flow hedge accounted derivatives. Over time, the reserve will flow through the income statement in line with the underlying hedged instruments, with no net income statement impact.
 
(e) The movement in pension fund obligations is primarily as a result of changes in key assumptions, including the inflation rate and the discount rate used in the calculation of the schemes’ liabilities, together with the positive impact of the recovery in global equity and bond markets on the valuation of pension fund assets at December 31, 2009.
 
An explanation of the movements in stockholders equity during the year ended March 31, 2009, is as follows:
 
(f) On March 31, 2009, the National Pension Reserve Fund Commission (NPRFC) invested €3.5 billion in new preference stock (€3,462 million net of costs) and warrants (to subscribe for up to 25% of the enlarged ordinary stock in the Bank of Ireland). This stock with a coupon of 8% (which increased to 10.25% under the Proposals) is redeemable at par until the fifth anniversary of its issue and thereafter at 125% of par. The preference stock qualifies as core Tier 1 capital.
 
(g) foreign exchange adjustments reflect the impact of the strength of the euro on the translation of Sterling and US dollar denominated net investment in foreign subsidiaries.


66


Table of Contents

 
(h) the AFS reserve movement is driven by the net impact of interest rate changes and the widening of credit spreads on the value of our AFS book (€26.9 billion) at March 31, 2009. This reserve is expected to reverse as the underlying financial assets mature.
 
(i) the cash flow hedge reserve movement reflects the impact of changes in interest rates on the mark to market of cash flow hedge accounted derivatives. Over time this balance will flow through the income statement in line with the underlying hedged instruments with no net income statement impact.
 
(j) movement in pension fund obligations is primarily as a result of changes in key assumptions including discount rate and mortality together with the impact of the weakness in global financial markets on the valuation of pension fund assets at March 31, 2009.
 
As at December 31, 2009, the Group had €1,521 million of Undated Loan Capital and €4,532 million of Dated Loan Capital (including fair value adjustments), a total of €6,053 million in aggregate of subordinated liabilities. Of the Dated Loan capital €3,778 million is repayable in five or more years. The cost and availability of subordinated debt are influenced by credit ratings. A reduction in the ratings assigned to the Group’s securities could increase financing costs and reduce market access. The long term credit ratings of the Group as at June 7, 2010 are as follows:
 
     
    Senior Debt
Moodys
  A1
Standard & Poors
  A−
Fitch
  A−
DBRS
  AA (low)
 
Depending on the degree of subordination the ratings assigned to Loan Capital may be one or more notches below the level for senior debt. Credit ratings are not a recommendation to buy, hold or sell any security and each rating should be evaluated independently of every other rating. These ratings are based on current information furnished to the rating agencies by Bank of Ireland and information obtained by the rating agencies from other sources. The ratings are accurate only as of June 7, 2010 and may be changed, superseded or withdrawn as a result of changes in, or unavailability, of such information.
 
As at March 31, 2009, Bank of Ireland Group had €3,385 million of Undated Loan Capital and €4,557 million of Dated Loan Capital (including fair value adjustments), a total of €7,942 million in aggregate of subordinated liabilities. Of the Dated Loan Capital €3,782 million as of such date was repayable in five or more years.
 
Capital Adequacy Requirements
 
The Group’s capital management policy has been developed within the supervisory requirements of the Irish Financial Regulator.
 
The EU Capital Requirements Directive (CRD) which came into force from January 1, 2007 introduced significant amendments to the existing capital adequacy framework. The implementation of the CRD results in a more risk sensitive approach to the derivation of a bank’s capital requirements.
 
The CRD is divided into three sections commonly referred to as Pillars. Pillar 1 introduced the Internal Ratings Based Approach (IRBA) which permits banks to use their own internal rating systems to calculate their capital requirements for credit risk.
 
Use of the IRBA is subject to regulatory approval. Where credit portfolios are not subject to IRBA, the calculation of the minimum capital requirements is subject to the Standardised Approach, which is a more granular approach to the calculation of risk weightings than under Basel I.
 
Under Pillar 2 of the CRD (Supervisory Review) banks undertake an Internal Capital Adequacy Assessment Process (ICAAP) which is then subject to supervisory review.
 
Pillar 3 of the CRD (Market Discipline) involves the disclosure of a range of qualitative and quantitative information relating to capital and risk. The Group most recently disclosed this information on July 31, 2009.
 
The CRD also introduced a requirement to calculate capital requirements, and to set capital aside, with respect to operational risk. The Group is also required to set capital aside for market risk.
 
Information on PCAR is outlined on page 44.


67


Table of Contents

The following table shows the components and basis of calculation of the Group’s Tier 1 and Total Capital ratios under Basel II for December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2009.
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
    Basel II   Basel II
    €m   €m
 
Capital base
               
Share capital and reserves
    6,437       6,913  
Regulatory retirement benefit obligation adjustments
    1,632       1,478  
Available for sale reserve and cash flow hedge reserve
    1,118       2,124  
Goodwill and other intangible assets
    (488 )     (511)  
Preference stock
    (3,521 )     (3,520)  
Other adjustments
    80       22  
                 
Equity Tier 1 capital
    5,258       6,506  
Preference stock
    59       58  
2009 Preference stock and warrants
    3,462       3,462  
                 
Core Tier 1 Capital
    8,779       10,026  
Innovative hybrid debt
    752       1,197  
Non-innovative hybrid debt
    574       1,798  
Supervisory deductions
    (454 )     (372)  
                 
Total Tier 1 capital
    9,651       12,649  
                 
Tier 2
               
Undated loan capital
    225       229  
Date loan capital
    3,716       3,827  
IBNR provisions
    772       307  
Revaluations reserves
    40       80  
Supervisory deductions
    (454 )     (372)  
Other adjustments
    11        
                 
Total Tier 2 capital
    4,310       4,071  
                 
Total capital before supervisory deductions
    13,961       16,720  
Supervisory deductions
               
Life and pension business
    (797 )     (749)  
                 
Total capital
    13,164       15,971  
                 
Risk weighted assets
               
Credit risk
    89,785       96,395  
Market risk
    2,133       2,509  
Operational risk
    6,415       6,473  
                 
Total risk weighted assets
    98,333       105,377  
                 
Risk asset ratios including dividends
               
Equity Tier 1 (Core Tier 1 less preference stock)
    5.3%       6.2%  
Core Tier 1
    8.9%       9.5%  
Tier 1
    9.8%       12.0%  
Total capital
    13.4%       15.2%  
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
Total tier 1 capital decreased by €2,998 million at December 2009, reflecting the loss for the period of €1,469 million in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 (which includes the benefit of the gain generated from the debt repurchased of €1,037 million) and the reduction of €1,670 million associated with the tier 1 debt repurchase.
 
At December 31, 2009 the tier 2 capital increased by 6% or €239 million to €4,310 million. The movement was driven by an increase in IBNR provisions of €465 million offset by a decrease in dated loan capital of €111 million.


68


Table of Contents

Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
In the year to March 31, 2009 the Tier 1 Capital Ratio increased from 8.1% to 12.0% and the Core Tier 1 ratio improved from 5.7% to 9.5% with both ratios reflecting the capital initiatives by the Group. The Total Capital Ratio increased from 11.1% to 15.2%.
 
In the year ended March 31, 2009 a range of initiatives were implemented which have increased the Group’s capital and reduced risk weighted assets resulting in an improvement in each of the key capital ratios.
 
Of most significance was the Government supported recapitalisation of the Group. On March 31, 2009, the National Pensions Reserve Fund Commission (NPRFC) completed the investment of €3.5 billion in new preference stock. This stock with a coupon of 8% is redeemable at par until the fifth anniversary of its issue and thereafter at 125% of par. The NPRFC also received warrants to subscribe for up to 25% of the enlarged ordinary stock of the Group. The preference stock qualifies as core Tier 1 capital. In January 2009, the Group announced its intention to cease mortgage lending through the intermediary channel in the UK and also to exit from some non-core Corporate Banking international lending niches.
 
In August 2008 the Group issued Stg£450 million of lower Tier 2 capital and in December 2008 redeemed €600 million of lower Tier 2 capital.
 
Funding
 
The Group is reverting to a more traditional banking model where it will substantially fund its core loan portfolios through customer deposits. Asset growth in the future will be more dependent on the Group’s ability to attract deposits. In this regard, the Group will leverage the potential of its extensive retail distribution platforms, both in the Republic of Ireland through its branch network and internationally through its joint venture with the UK Post Office, its Business and Corporate Banking relationship management teams and its network of treasury offices in Dublin, the UK and the US.
 
The Group performs stress testing and scenario analysis to evaluate the impact of stresses on its liquidity position. These stress tests are at both a Group specific and systemic risk level. The stress tests are run at three levels of moderate, serious and severe. The results of the tests are compared to the strategic actions which the Group can take in such circumstances to correct a potential liquidity shortfall and bring it back in order. Such actions range from selling assets, switching from unsecured to secured funding and adjusting the price the Group would pay for liabilities. The result of the stress testing is reported at regular intervals to the Group Risk Policy Committee (GRPC) and the Court.
 
A significant part of the liquidity of the banking businesses in Ireland and the UK arises from their ability to generate customer deposits. A substantial proportion of the customer deposit base is made up of current and savings accounts, which, although repayable on demand, have traditionally, provided a stable source of funding. These customer deposits are supplemented by the issue of subordinated loan capital and wholesale funding sources in the capital markets, as well as from direct customer contracts. Wholesale funding sources include deposits taken on the inter-bank market, certificates of deposit, sale and repurchase agreements, commercial paper programmes, a euro medium term note programme and the mortgage covered securities programme.
 
The monitoring and reporting of liquidity takes the form of cash flow measurement and projections for future periods, with the 0-8 days and 8 days to 1 month periods as two of the key periods of measurement for liquidity management. The Group also operates a contingency liquidity plan for periods of liquidity stress.
 
The ability to sell assets quickly is also an important source of liquidity to the Group’s banking business. The Group holds sizeable balances of marketable treasury and other eligible bills and debt securities which could be disposed of to provide additional funding should the need arise.
 
The Group has developed significant pools of eligible collateral from its balance sheet which are capable of being pledged in the secondary market and through the normal market operations of the Monetary Authorities to provide access to secured funding. At December 31, 2009, the net drawings, primarily from Monetary Authorities, were €8 billion.


69


Table of Contents

The following table sets out the amounts and maturities of the Group’s contractual cash obligations at December 31, 2009.
 
                                         
        Between
  Between
       
    Within
  one and
  two and
  Over five
   
    one year   two years   five years   years   Total
        (in € millions)    
 
Subordinated liabilities — dated
          754       229       3,549       4,532  
Debt securities in issue
    24,646       3,200       6,130       9,168       43,144  
Operating leases
    65       68       151       442       726  
Capital commitments
    4                          
 
In addition, the Group takes deposits and other liabilities in the normal course of its banking business. The maturity of deposits by banks, customer accounts and debt securities in issue is given in note 56 to our consolidated financial statements.
 
                         
    % Growth December 2009 over March 2009
    Risk
  Loans and advances
  Customer
    Weighted Assets   to customers   Deposits
 
Retail Republic of Ireland
    (3 %)     (4 %)     4 %
Capital Markets
    (11 %)     (10 %)     (1 %)
UK Financial Services
    (4 %)           3 %
(euro equivalent)
                       
Group
    (7 %)     (4 %)     2 %
 
Total assets decreased by 7% from €194 billion at March 31, 2009 to €181 billion at December 31, 2009. Loans and advances to customers (including loans held for sale to NAMA) decreased by 4% during the nine months to December 31, 2009. Customer deposits increased by 2% in a difficult environment.
 
The Group funds its operations through a combination of customer accounts and wholesale funding sourced from the debt markets.
 
•  Customer accounts comprise demand deposits, current accounts and term deposits. At December 31, 2009 customer accounts were €85 billion or 50% of the Group balance sheet (excluding BoI Life policyholder assets).
 
•  Debt capital markets provide short term and longer term facilities in the form of either secured or unsecured funding. Total wholesale funding decreased 17% from €74 billion at March 31, 2009 to €61 billion at December 31, 2009 and represented 34% of the Group’s balance sheet at that date.
 
The funding environment has been subject to a number of significant shocks and volatility during the Group’s nine month reporting period from April 1, 2009 through December 31, 2009.
 
Customer Accounts (deposits)
 
Customer deposits comprise demand, notice and term deposits as well as credit balances on current accounts.
 
Despite intense market competition for retail deposits in Ireland and the UK and pressure on international deposits caused by rating downgrades earlier in 2009, the Group’s deposit base at December 31, 2009 of €85 billion is €2 billion or 2% higher than at March 31, 2009. This increase is principally due to the increase in deposits in Retail Republic of Ireland and through the Group’s joint venture with the UK Post Office.
 


70


Table of Contents

                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
   
Customer deposits
  2009   2009   Change
    € billion   € billion   %
 
Retail Republic of Ireland
    35       33       4 %
                         
Deposits
    24       23       4 %
Current account credit balances
    11       10       6 %
                         
UK Financial Services
    21       21       3 %
                         
UK Financial Services (Stg£ equivalent)
    19       19       (2 %)
POFS
    9       8       9 %
Business Banking
    10       11       (9 %)
                         
Capital Markets
    29       29       (1 %)
                         
Total customer deposits
    85       83       2 %
                         
 
The Loans to Deposits ratio, based on Total loans and advances to customers — including loans held for sale to NAMA, of 152% at December 31, 2009 has improved from 161% at March 31, 2009. This improvement is due to both the increase in the level of customer deposits and the reduction in loans and advances to customers since March 31, 2009. The Loans to Deposits ratio excluding loans held for sale to NAMA was 141% at December 31, 2009.
 
In January 2010, the Group’s long term and short term credit ratings were downgraded by Standard & Poors to A- / A-2 with a stable outlook. This downgrade has led to an outflow of some ratings sensitive international deposits.
 
Wholesale Funding
 
The Group’s wholesale funding programmes are diversified across geographies, investor types and maturities. In addition, the Group has invested in recent years to build a strong technical capability which has allowed it to maximize the funding capability of its balance sheet in terms of contingent liquidity collateral.
 
Wholesale funding reduced to €61 billion at December 31, 2009 as compared to €74 billion at March 31, 2009. This was principally due to an increase in customer deposits of €2 billion and a reduction of €7 billion in the level of liquid assets. At December 31, 2009, 32% of wholesale funding had a term to maturity of greater than one year compared to 27% at March 31, 2009.
 
International wholesale funding markets stabilised in the latter half of 2009, with improved investor sentiment towards Ireland and Irish financial institutions. This is evidenced by the reduction in the market cost of credit default protection in respect of such institutions. This has resulted in enhanced access to funding markets, facilitating debt issuance at lower prices and long maturities.
 
While the markets perception of Irish sovereign risk remained in the first quarter of 2010 there are still concerns over increases in the cost of borrowings which Ireland may face. The recent volatility in market sentiment, as the euro fell in value against the US dollar and sterling, was due to the significant concerns about the Greek sovereign debt position but the recent rating agencies downgrade of Greece, Spain and Portugal has increased the risks throughout the Eurozone.
 
Bank of Ireland operates under the Liquidity Regime introduced by the Irish Financial Regulator in July 2007. This regime requires that banks have sufficient payment resources (cash inflows and marketable assets) to cover 100% of expected cash outflows in the 0 to 8 day time horizon and 90% of expected cash outflows in the over 8 day to one month time horizon. The Group continues to maintain a significant liquidity buffer in excess of these requirements.

71


Table of Contents

Overall, Bank of Ireland’s established and diversified funding strategy continues to support growth across our businesses.
 
                                                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
Balance Sheet Funding
  € billion   %   € billion   %   € billion   %
 
Deposits by banks
    18       11       29       16       14       8  
CP/CD’s
    10       6       14       7       27       15  
Securitisations
    6       3       6       3       8       4  
Senior Debt/ACS
    27       16       25       14       26       14  
                                                 
Total Wholesale Funding
    61       36       74       40       75       41  
Customer Deposits
    85       50       83       45       86       47  
Capital/Subordinated Debt
    12       8       15       8       14       8  
Other
    11       6       12       7       10       4  
                                                 
Total
    169       100       184       100       185       100  
                                                 
 
The above table excludes liabilities to policyholders in the life assurance business.
 
In late December 2009, international funding markets became increasingly concerned about the fiscal position of some Eurozone countries whose credit spreads widened. Irish sovereign debt outperformed those countries during this time, as investors differentiated between Ireland and some Eurozone countries based on the timely actions taken by the Irish Government to tackle its budgetary and fiscal position.
 
In the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 the Group issued €9.1 billion of term funding (funding with a maturity of 1 year or greater at time of issue). The average maturity of this funding was 2.4 years with an average spread of 1.8% over 3 month Euribor.
 
The Group continues to benefit from a robust and diversified contingent liquidity strategy. At December 31, 2009, the Group had a pool of contingent liquidity collateral with a funding value of €42 billion. Drawings from Monetary Authorities at December 31, 2009 were €8 billion net, down from €17 billion net at March 31, 2009.
 
On January 11, 2010, the Group was accepted as a participating institution in the Irish Governments Eligible Liabilities Guarantee Scheme (the ELG Scheme). This scheme provides flexibility to issue some deposits and debt securities in both un-guaranteed and guaranteed form (up to a maximum maturity of 5 years). The Group is further increasing the percentage of wholesale funding with a maturity of greater than 1 year. To this end, since January 2010, the Group has, under the ELG scheme, issued a €2.5 billion 5 year senior unsecured Government Guaranteed fixed rate security at mid swaps +145 basis points and a US$1 billion 2 year senior unsecured Government Guaranteed security at US dollar mid swaps +175 basis points (both before the cost of the ELG scheme).
 
A key focus of the Group is to reduce its reliance on the Government Guarantee Schemes which are currently due to expire on September 29, 2010.
 
Off Balance Sheet Arrangements
 
                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
Contingent Liabilities   (in € millions)
 
Acceptances and endorsements
    27       19       47  
Guarantees and irrevocable letters of credit
    1,599       1,879       2,199  
Other contingent liabilities
    799       670       669  
                         
      2,425       2,568       2,915  
Lending commitments
    25,031       26,919       36,881  
                         
Total contingent liabilities and commitments
    27,456       29,487       39,796  
                         


72


Table of Contents

Lending commitments are agreements to lend to customers in accordance with contractual provisions; these are either for a specified period or, as in the case of credit cards and overdrafts, represent a revolving credit facility which can be drawn down at any time, provided that the agreement has not been terminated. The total amounts of unused commitments do not necessarily represent future cash requirements, in that commitments often expire without being drawn upon.
 
The Group has a number of Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) where it does not own more than half of the voting power in the company but which are consolidated. Details of these subsidiaries are available in note 52 to the Consolidated financial statements.
 
ANALYSIS OF RESULTS OF OPERATIONS
 
Basis of Preparation and Presentation
 
The consolidated financial statements of the Group are prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee (IFRIC) interpretations as adopted by the European Union (EU) and with those parts of the Companies Act, 1963 to 2006 applicable to companies reporting under IFRS with the European Communities (Credit Institutions: Accounts) Regulations, 1992 and with the Asset Covered Securities Act, 2001 to 2007. These financial statements comply with both IFRS as adopted by the EU and IFRS as issued by the IASB.
 
Review of Group Performance
 
Group Income Statement
 
                         
        Restated*
  Restated*
    9 months
  12 months
  12 months
    ended
  ended
  ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    € millions
 
Net interest income
    2,179       3,670       3,263  
Other income (net of insurance claims)
    1,420       287       974  
                         
Total operating income (net of insurance claims)
    3,599       3,957       4,237  
Other operating expenses
    (1,381)       (2,121 )     (2,160 )
Impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets
    (6)       (304 )      
Impairment charge on financial assets
    (4,057)       (1,513 )     (232 )
Share of associated undertakings and joint ventures (post tax)
    35       (42 )     46  
Loss on disposal of business activities
    (3)              
Profit on disposal of property
                39  
                         
Total (loss)/profit before tax
    (1,813)       (23 )     1,930  
Taxation
    344       41       (229 )
                         
(Loss)/profit
    (1,469)       18       1,701  
                         
Attributable to minority interests
    (9)       (35 )     5  
Attributable to stock holders
    (1,460)       53       1,696  
                         
(Loss)/profit
    (1,469)       34       1,701  
                         
Basic (LPS)/EPS c per share
    (168.6)c       4.3c       174.3c  
                         
Diluted (LPS)/EPS c per share
    (168.6)c       4.3c       173.6c  
                         
 
 
 *  The prior years have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
Income
 
Net interest income and ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ are affected by a number of IFRS income classifications. Under IFRS, certain assets and liabilities can be designated at fair value through profit or loss. Where assets or liabilities have been designated at fair value through profit or loss, the total fair value movements on


73


Table of Contents

these items, including net interest income, are reported in ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’. However, the costs of funding the assets and the interest income on investment of the liabilities are reported in ‘net interest income’’. In addition, debt is raised in a variety of currencies and the resulting foreign exchange and interest rate risk is managed using derivative instruments — the cost of which is reported in ‘other income’’.
 
Net Interest Income
 
The following table shows net interest income for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 and for the two reporting periods ending March 31, 2009 and March 31, 2008.
 
                         
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    (in € millions)
 
Net interest income
    2,179       3,670       3,263  
                         
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
Net interest income of €2,179 million decreased by €1,491 million in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 from €3,670 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
Net interest income is affected by the classification of certain income between interest expense and other income (net of insurance claims) under IFRS which relates to the designation of certain financial instruments under the fair value option. This treatment resulted in additional net interest income of €71 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 and additional income of €578 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009, offset by a similar reduction in ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ in both reporting periods. As a result of the impact of the IFRS classifications, the Group’s net interest income decreased by €984 million in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009.
 
The reduction in net interest income was also due to margin attrition on deposits as a result of intense competition and the low interest rate environment, higher costs of funding in the wholesale markets, and lower treasury income. These reductions were partly offset by higher asset pricing, particularly in Corporate Banking, UK Business Banking and the UK Residential Mortgage Business, lower cost of market dislocation, earnings on the proceeds from the issue of the €3.5 billion 2009 Preference stock before taking account of the 8% coupon payable on the investment and lower interest costs following the repurchase of tier 1 debt securities in June 2009.
 
In January 2010, following indications from the European Commision that the Group should not make coupon payments on its tier 1 and upper tier 2 capital instruments unless under a binding legal obligation to do so, the Group announced that the non-cumulative distribution on certain upper tier 2 Capital instruments, which would otherwise have been payable on 1 February and 4 February 2010, would not be paid. The effect of this decision by the Group was to trigger the “dividend stopper” provisions of these instruments. The gain as a result of the restriction imposed by the EU Commission on the Group’s ability to make coupon payments increased net interest income by €58 million and income (net of insurance claims) by €9 million (interest expense on subordinated liabilities is recognised using the effective interest rate (EIR) method).
 
Financial Year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
Net interest income increased by 12% or €407 million, from €3,263 million to €3,670 million for the year to March 31, 2009.
 
As outlined above, net interest income is affected by the classification of certain income between interest expense and other income (net of insurance claims) under IFRS which relates to the designation of certain financial instruments under the fair value option. This treatment resulted in additional net interest income of €578 million for the year ended March 31, 2009 and €346 million for the year ended March 31, 2008, offset by a similar reduction in ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ in both years. As a result of the impact of the IFRS classifications, the Group’s net interest income increased by €175 million or 6% in the year ended March 31, 2009.


74


Table of Contents

Growth in net interest income was driven by improved lending margins primarily in Corporate Banking and UK mortgage lending which are repricing for risk and higher cost of funds, together with improved treasury margins due to being well positioned in a declining interest rate environment.
 
Group Net Interest Margin (Group Net Yield)
 
The following table sets forth the Group’s net interest margin for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 and for the two twelve month reporting periods ending March 31, 2009 and March 31, 2008.
 
                         
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
 
Average interest earning assets (€ billion)
    172       177       175  
                         
Group net interest margin — annualised (group net yield) (%)
    1.69       2.07       1.86  
                         
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
The Group net interest margin (annualised) for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 declined by 38 basis points to 1.69% as compared to a net interest margin of 2.07% for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. 27 basis points of the decrease is due to classification of certain income under IFRS as mentioned above in the net interest income section.
 
Excluding the impact of this classification, the other key drivers of the margin decrease of 11 basis points (annualised) were as follows:
 
•  26 basis points reduction due to margin attrition on deposits as a result of intense competition and the low interest rate environment,
 
•  7 basis points lower due to higher costs of funding in the wholesale markets, and
 
•  3 basis points lower due to lower treasury income.
 
Partly offset by:
 
•  11 basis points due to higher asset pricing, particularly in Corporate Banking, UK Business Banking and the UK Residential Mortgage Business,
 
•  5 basis points increase due to lower cost of market dislocation,
 
•  4 basis points higher due to earnings on the proceeds from the issue of the €3.5 billion 2009 Preference stock before taking account of the 8% coupon payable on the investment,
 
•  4 basis points higher as a result of the non-payment of the coupons on the tier 1 and upper tier 2 capital instruments unless under a legal binding obligation to do so, following indications from the European Commission; and
 
•  1 basis point higher due to lower interest costs following the repurchase of tier 1 debt securities in June 2009.
 
Financial Year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
The Group net interest margin increased by 21bps to 2.07% for the year ended March 31, 2009 from 1.86% for the year ended March 31, 2008. 13bps of the increase is due to the classification of certain items under IFRS, as mentioned above in the ‘net interest income’ section.
 
Excluding the impact of this classification, net interest margin increased by 8 bps for the year to March 31, 2009 and the key drivers of margin growth were:
 
•  Improved product pricing contributed 8bps, particularly in Corporate Banking and the UK mortgage business which are repricing for risk and cost of funds


75


Table of Contents

 
•  balance sheet structure where average deposit growth exceeded average lending growth, and improved asset mix which increased margins by 6bps
 
•  improved treasury margin due to the sharp decline in interest rates contributed 5bps
 
Offset by
 
•  increased competition for deposits together with the impact of narrowing margins due to falling interest rates which reduced the net interest margin by 7bps
 
•  higher funding costs arising from market dislocation which was only a feature of the second half of the prior year, decreased margins by 4bps.
 
The following table shows interest rates in effect at December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2009 and 2008.
 
Interest Rates — Ireland, UK and US
                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31
    2009   2009   2008
    (percentages)
    %   %   %
 
Ireland
                       
European interbank offered rate:
                       
One month Euribor
    0.45 %     1.12 %     4.36 %
Three month Euribor
    0.70 %     1.51 %     4.73 %
United Kingdom
                       
London interbank offered rate:
                       
One month
    0.52 %     1.03 %     5.79 %
Three month
    0.61 %     1.65 %     6.01 %
United States
                       
Prime Rate
    3.25 %     3.25 %     5.25 %
 
Other Income (net of insurance claims)
 
The following table shows other income (net of insurance claims) for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 and for the two twelve month reporting periods ending March 31, 2009 and March 31, 2008.
 
                         
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
        (in € millions)    
 
Net insurance premium income
    665       1,069       1,940  
Fee and commission income
    474       717       816  
Fee and commission expense
    (255 )     (232 )     (150 )
Net trading expense
    (28 )     (307 )     (246 )
Life assurance investment income and losses
    958       (1,570 )     (826 )
Gain on repurchase of subordinated liabilities
    1,037              
Insurance contract liabilities and claims paid
    (1,462 )     537       (798 )
Other operating income
    31       73       238  
                         
Other Income (net of insurance claims)
    1,420       287       974  
                         
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
‘Other income (net of insurance claims)’of €1,420 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 increased by €1,133 million compared to €287 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 and compared to €974 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2008. IFRS income classifications, as mentioned above have also impacted ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ (a debit of €71 million in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 versus a debit of €578 million in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 and a debit of €346 million in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2008).


76


Table of Contents

In June 2009, the Group successfully completed a debt re-purchase programme of a nominal value of €1.7 billion euro, sterling and US dollar denominated tier 1 securities. The debt repurchase involved a cash tender offer for six tier 1 securities at an average discount of 59% to their nominal value. The gain generated from the repurchase increased ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ by €1,037 million.
 
Grossing up for policyholders tax in our Life business was a €64 million credit in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a €76 million charge in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The non recognition of the investment return on treasury shares held for the benefit of policyholders in Bank of Ireland Life decreased ‘other income (net of insurance claims) by €6 million compared to increasing ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ by €131 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
The results for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 include a positive investment valuation variance of €23 million. The performance of investment markets since April 2009 has resulted in a positive investment valuation variance, this compares to an underperformance of investment markets in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009, which gave rise to the negative investment valuation variance of €117 million.
 
During the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, the Group disposed of its interest in Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC (Guggenheim) and Iridian Asset Management LLC (Iridian) resulting in a net loss of €3 million.
 
In the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 there was a loss of €3 million on hedge ineffectiveness on transition to IFRS compared to €7 million loss in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
The principal other items within ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ and after the impact of IFRS income classifications which contribute to the drop in ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 include;
 
•  the shorter reporting period,
 
•  lower fee and other income of €266 million in the Banking and Capital Markets businesses as a result of lower levels of new business activity, and
 
•  reduced income of €71 million in the Life business primarily due to lower volumes of new business as a result of affordability issues for policyholders arising from lower levels of disposable income
 
•  additional charge associated with the Irish Government Guarantee of certain liabilities of €39 million (the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 includes a charge for six months from September 29, 2008 compared to a nine month charge to December 31, 2009)
 
•  a positive movement on the investment valuation variance of €140 million in Bank of Ireland Life due to improved valuations as world equity and investment markets have shown some recovery from last year’s sharp falls,
 
•  increased impairment of €25 million on the value of some investment properties arising from continuing low levels of transactions in the commercial property markets,
 
•  lower fees arising from the disposal of Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC (Guggenheim) in June 2009 and Iridian Asset Management LLC (Iridian) in August 2009 of €33 million,
 
•  a movement of €70 million arising from the change in credit spreads on the Group’s issued notes and subordinated debt designated at ‘fair value through profit or loss’. This is a partial reversal of gains recognised in prior periods,
 
•  a charge in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of €74 million arising from an unfavourable court ruling in connection with a European property investment,
 
•  a charge of €39 million in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 arising from the collapse of Lehmans in September 2008, and
 
•  a gain of €24 million reflecting a distribution by Visa International following its initial public offering, included in the results for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.


77


Table of Contents

 
Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
‘Other income (net of insurance claims)’ reduced by 71% to €287 million in the year to March 31, 2009 compared to the prior year ended March 31, 2008. IFRS income classifications, as mentioned above have also impacted ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ (debit of €578 million in the year to March 31, 2009, versus a debit of €346 million in the prior year).
 
Grossing up for policyholders tax in our Life business was a €76 million charge in the twelve months to March 31, 2009 compared to €60 million charge in the previous year. The non recognition of the investment return on treasury shares held for the benefit of policyholders in Bank of Ireland Life increased ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ by €131 million for the year ended March 31, 2009 compared to a benefit of €189 million for the year to March 31, 2008.
 
In the year ended March 31, 2009 there was a loss of €7 million on hedge ineffectiveness on transition to IFRS compared to €6 million in the prior year.
 
Also, there was a significant negative investment valuation variance of €117 million in Bank of Ireland Life due to weaker global equity markets in the year to March 31, 2009, versus a negative investment valuation variance of €50 million in the prior year.
 
Other contributing factors to the drop in ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’ include;
 
•  lower fees in the Business and Corporate Banking businesses;
 
•  impairment of investment properties (€46 million);
 
•  lower management and performance fees in the asset management businesses and the cost to unwind customer risk positions following the Lehmans collapse in mid September 2008 (€39 million);
 
•  the cost of the government guarantee in the year ended March 31, 2009, was €66 million and is charged to ‘other income (net of insurance claims)’.
 
These charges are partly offset by a gain of €64 million on the widening of credit spreads relating to the Group’s issued notes designated at fair value through profit or loss.
 
Other operating expenses
 
The following table sets out the Group’s other operating expenses for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 and for the two twelve month reporting periods ending March 31, 2009 and March 31, 2008.
 
Other operating expenses
 
                         
        Restated*
  Restated*
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
        (in € millions)    
 
Staff costs (excl pension costs)
    640       1,017       1,104  
Pension costs
    149       180       134  
Non staff costs
    592       924       922  
                         
Other operating expenses
    1,381       2,121       2,160  
                         
 
 
* The prior years have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
Operating expenses of €1,381 million decreased by €740 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to operating expenses of €2,121 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Even


78


Table of Contents

allowing for the shorter reporting period, costs are lower due to lower staff numbers and rigorous cost management across all costs.
 
Staff costs (excluding pension costs) of €640 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 were €377 million lower compared to €1,017 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The staff costs are lower as a result of the Group’s continuing pay and recruitment freeze and the non-replacement of departing staff. In addition, staff costs are lower due to reduced staff numbers arising from the Group’s actions to close to new business and put into run-down our intermediary sourced mortgage business in the UK and some of our international lending businesses in Corporate Banking as well as from the sale and downsizing of our asset management businesses. Staff numbers (including contract and agency staff) of 14,647 full time equivalents at December 31, 2009 were 7% lower compared to 15,786 full time equivalents at March 31, 2009.
 
Pension costs of €149 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 were €31 million lower when compared to the pension costs for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. After adjusting for the shorter reporting period, pension costs have increased as a result of the escalating costs to the Group of providing the pension scheme benefits together with the reduction in returns on scheme assets following their fall in values over the last two years in particular.
 
In the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, continued tight control of all other costs remained a key focus. In the year ended March 31, 2009, non staff costs included costs associated with a number of downsizing initiatives (€83 million).
 
Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
Other operating expenses decreased by 2% in the year ended March 31, 2009, which includes costs associated with a number of downsizing initiatives (€83 million).
 
The downsizing initiatives relate to the Group’s goal of aligning its structure and cost base to an environment of lower levels of new business and activity. These initiatives include the cessation of mortgage lending through the intermediary channel in the UK and downsizing of some activities within Capital Markets and in the UK business banking operations. Total costs for the prior year to March 31, 2008 also included €17 million in restructuring charges.
 
The Group tightly managed its headcount during the year. Staff numbers (full time equivalents) were 5% lower at March 31, 2009, at 15,487 compared with March 31, 2008. Variable compensation across the Group has been reduced significantly such that, notwithstanding higher pension costs, staff costs overall are down by 4% when compared with the prior year. The challenging economic environment, reduced levels of new business and increased impairment levels have brought a renewed focus on our cost infrastructure. Significant progress has been made since the launch of the Strategic Transformation Programme (STP) in March 2005, but the new environment in which the Group finds itself has led to a renewed focus on costs. Tight cost management remains an imperative. We reiterate our commitment to rigorous cost management.
 
Impairment of Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets
 
                         
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    ( in € millions)
 
Impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets
    (6 )     (304 )      
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
Impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets included a charge of €304 million in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. See below for more detail.


79


Table of Contents

Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
The Group carried out an impairment review of all goodwill and other intangible assets on the Group balance sheet at March 31, 2009. The carrying value of the US based asset management businesses, Guggenheim and Iridian, were severely impacted by the downturn in the global asset management sector, falling assets under management and client redemptions. Consequently a decision was made to write down the carrying value of the businesses to their recoverable amounts, which was fair value less costs to sell. As a result the Group recorded an impairment charge of €304 million in the year ended March 31, 2009. This impairment had no cash impact nor did it impact the Group’s capital ratios. The Group has now disposed of these businesses.
 
Summary Group Balance Sheet
 
                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
   
    2009   2009   Change
    €bn   €bn   %
 
Summary Consolidated Balance Sheet
                       
Loans and advances to customers (net of impairment provisions)
    119       134        
Assets held for sale to NAMA (net of impairment provisions)
    10              
                         
Total loans (net of impairment provisions)
    129       134       (4% )
Liquid assets
    31       38       (20% )
Other assets
    21       22       (2% )
                         
Total assets
    181       194       (7% )
                         
Customer deposits
    85       83       2%  
Wholesale funding
    61       74       (17% )
Subordinated liabilities
    6       8       (24% )
Other liabilities
    23       22       2%  
                         
Total liabilities
    175       187       (7% )
Stockholders’ equity
    6       7        
                         
Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity
    181       194       (7% )
                         
Key Balance Sheet metrics
                       
Loans and advances to customers — incl. assets held for sale to NAMA/customer deposits
    152%       161%          
Loans and advances to customers — excl. assets held for sale to NAMA/customer deposits
    141%                
Equity tier 1 ratio (core tier 1 less preference stock)
    5.3%       6.2%          
Core tier 1 ratio
    8.9%       9.5%          
Tier 1 ratio
    9.8%       12.0%          
Total capital ratio
    13.4%       15.2%          
Total Risk Weighted Assets
  €98bn     105bn          
 
Loans and Advances to Customers
 
Total loans, net of impairment provisions, at December 31, 2009 of €129 billion reflects a decrease of 4% from €134 billion at March 31, 2009. This reduction is due to lower levels of economic activity and a consequent reduced demand for loans and other credit facilities, together with higher impairment provisions at December 31, 2009.
 
In January 2009 the Group announced its withdrawal from the intermediary sourced mortgage market in the UK and commenced the process of winding down a series of non-core international lending portfolios in Capital Markets. At December 31, 2009, loan assets in these activities totaled approximately €34 billion or 25% of the Total loans (before impairment provisions). Over time this will reduce the size of the Group’s balance sheet which will have the benefit of reducing the Group’s wholesale funding requirements, will lower the Group’s risk weighted assets and will strengthen the Group’s capital ratios. The de-leveraging of the UK residential mortgage portfolio is progressing, albeit at a slower pace than originally expected. This is due to lower levels of re-mortgage activity in the UK market.


80


Table of Contents

At December 31, 2009, the Group classified those loans and advances to customers expected to transfer to NAMA as assets held for sale to NAMA. For ease of comparative purposes, the tables and commentary below, presents the loans and advances to customers, net of impairment provisions, of €119 billion and assets held for sale to NAMA, net of impairment provisions, of €10 billion together as Total loans.
 
Loans and Advances to Customers — book composition
 
The following table analyses the loan book by portfolio:
 
                                 
    Gross Loans and Advances to Customers
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
Portfolio   €bn   %   €bn   %
Residential mortgages
    61       45       59       44  
Non property Small & Medium Enterprise (SME)/Corporate (non property)
    34       25       37       27  
Property and Construction:
    36       27       34       25  
                                 
— Investment
    25             22        
— Landbank & Development
    11             12        
                                 
Consumer — unsecured
    4       3       6       4  
                                 
Total Loans and Advances to Customers Before Allowance for Impairment Charges
    135       100       136       100  
Impairment provisions
    (6 )           (2 )      
                                 
Total Loans and Advances to Customers After Allowance for Impairment Charges
    129             134        
                                 
 
Residential mortgages comprise 45% of the Group’s loan book at December 31, 2009, up from 44% at March 31, 2009 due predominantly to new lending to first time buyers in Ireland and new lending originating through the joint venture with the UK Post Office. At December 31, 2009, 47% of residential mortgages were in Ireland and 53% of residential mortgages were in the UK.
 
Non-property SME and corporate loans account for 25% of the Group’s loan book at December 31, 2009 compared to 27% of the Group’s loan book at March 31, 2009. This decrease in the loan book is primarily as a result of repayments and a slow down in demand for loans and other credit facilities. This portfolio is well diversified across industries and geographies.
 
The Property and construction loan book accounts for 27% of the Group’s loan book at December 31, 2009 compared to 25% of the Group’s loan book at March 31, 2009. This book includes both investment loans and land and development loans. This increase since March 31, 2009 is due to additional loan draw-downs of committed facilities and the impact of movements in exchange rates.
 
Consumer loans amount to €4 billion at December 31, 2009 which is €2 billion lower than at March 31, 2009. This decrease is primarily as a result of repayments as customers seek to reduce their levels of indebtedness and a slowdown in demand for loans and other credit facilities.
 
The stock of impairment provisions of €5.8 billion at December 31, 2009 has increased by €4.0 billion compared to €1.8 billion at March 31, 2009. This reflects the substantial impairment charges in the nine month period ended December 31,2009 as a result of the very significant and challenging economic conditions, higher unemployment, weaker consumer sentiment and in particular a sharp decline in the property and construction sectors in Ireland and to a lesser extent in the UK.


81


Table of Contents

The following table analyses the loans and advances to customers and associated impairment provisions between those loans expected to transfer to NAMA and those assets expected to be retained by the Group.
 
                         
        Impairment
  Carrying
Analysis at December 31, 2009
  Total loans   provisions   value
    €m   €m   €m
 
Loans and advances to customers
                       
Mortgages
    60,402       359       60,043  
Non-property SME & Corporate
    34,140       1,134       33,006  
Property & Construction
    23,554       1,124       22,430  
- Investment
    20,758       362       20,396  
- Landbank/Development
    2,796       762       2,034  
Consumer
    4,340       380       3,960  
                         
Total loans and advances to customers
    122,436       2,997       119,439  
                         
Loans held for sale to NAMA
                       
Landbank & Development
    8,522       2,552       5,970  
Associated
    3,713       226       3,487  
                         
Total loans held for sale to NAMA
    12,235       2,778       9,457  
                         
Total loans
    134,671       5,775       128,896  
                         
 
                         
        Impairment
  Carrying
Loans held for sale to NAMA
  Total loans   provisions   value
    €m   €m   €m
 
Composition by division
                       
Retail Republic of Ireland
    3,525       1,063       2,462  
UK Financial Services
    3,573       817       2,756  
Capital Markets
    5,137       898       4,239  
                         
Total loans held for sale to NAMA
    12,235       2,778       9,457  
                         
 
The impairment provision on loans held for sale to NAMA of €2,778 million at December 31, 2009 is made up of €1,063 million or 38% from Retail Republic of Ireland, €817 million or 29% from UK Financial Services and €898 million or 33% from the Capital Markets division. The ratio of impairment provisions to loans held for sale to NAMA is 23%. This ratio differs across the divisions. Retail Republic of Ireland has a ratio of 30% reflecting the impact of the sharp deterioration in the property and construction sector in Ireland. The ratio in UK Financial Services is 23% and the ratio in Capital Markets is 17% reflecting the diversification of property assets across different geographic and less stressed areas with Capital Markets having a higher proportion of assets in the investment element of property assets.
 
Loans and Advances to Customers — asset quality
 
The Group classifies loans as ‘financial assets neither past due nor impaired’, ‘financial assets past due but not impaired’ and ‘impaired financial assets’ in line with the requirements of IFRS7. Loans and advances to customers within ‘financial assets neither past due nor impaired’ are assigned an internal credit grade by the Group based on an assessment of the credit quality of the borrower and these ratings are summarised below:
 
•  high quality ratings apply to highly rated financial obligors, strong corporate and business counterparties and consumer banking borrowers (including residential mortgages) with whom the Group has an excellent repayment experience. High quality ratings are derived from grades 1 to 4 on the thirteen point grade scale, grades 1 and 2 on the seven point grade scale and ratings equivalent to AAA, AA+, AA, AA−, A+, A, A−, BBB+ and BBB for the external major rating agencies,
 
•  satisfactory quality ratings apply to good quality financial assets that are performing as expected, including loans and advances to small and medium sized enterprises, leveraged entities and more recently established businesses. Satisfactory quality ratings also include some element of the Group’s retail portfolios. Satisfactory


82


Table of Contents

quality ratings are derived from grades 5 to 7 on the thirteen point grade scale, grade 3 on the seven point grade scale and external ratings equivalent to BBB−, BB+, BB and BB−,
 
•  acceptable quality ratings apply to customers with increased risk profiles that are subject to closer monitoring and scrutiny by lenders with the objective of managing risk and moving accounts to an improved rating category. Acceptable quality ratings are derived from grades 8 and 9 on the thirteen point grade scale, grade 4 outstandings within the seven point scale and external ratings equivalent to B+, and
 
•  the lower quality but not past due nor impaired rating applies to those financial assets that are neither in arrears nor impaired but where the Group requires a work down or work out of the relationship unless an early reduction in risk is achievable. Lower quality ratings are derived from outstandings within rating grades 10 and 11 on the thirteen point grade scale and grade 5 on the seven point grade scale and external ratings equivalent to B or below.’
 
‘Past due but not impaired loans’ are defined as follows:
 
•  Loans where repayment of interest and/or principal are overdue by at least one day but are not impaired.
 
‘Impaired loans’ are defined as follows:
 
•  Loans with a specific impairment provision attaching to them together with loans (excluding residential mortgages) which are more than 90 days in arrears.
 
•  All assets in grades 12 and 13 on the thirteen point grade scale and grades 6 and 7 on the seven point grade scale are impaired.
 
                                                 
        Loans held
   
    Gross loans and
  for sale to
   
December 31, 2009
  advances to customers   NAMA   Total Loans
    €m   %   €m   %   €m   %
 
Asset Quality
                                               
High Quality
    68,654       56.1%       561       4.6%       69,215       51.4%  
Satisfactory Quality
    27,665       22.6%       2,014       16.5%       29,679       22.1%  
Acceptable Quality
    11,380       9.3%       2,266       18.5%       13,646       10.1%  
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
    2,773       2.3%       575       4.7%       3,348       2.5%  
                                                 
Neither past due nor impaired
    110,472       90.3%       5,416       44.3%       115,888       86.1%  
Past due but not impaired
    5,177       4.2%       255       2.1%       5,432       4.0%  
Impaired
    6,787       5.5%       6,564       53.6%       13,351       9.9%  
                                                 
Total loans and advances to customers
    122,436       100.0%       12,235       100.0%       134,671       100.0%  
                                                 
 
                                                 
        Loans held
   
    Gross loans and
  for sale to
   
March 31, 2009
  advances to customers   NAMA   Total Loans
    €m   %   €m   %   €m   %
 
Asset Quality
                                               
High Quality
    72,465       53.5%            —            —       72,465       53.5%  
Satisfactory Quality
    37,087       27.3%                   37,087       27.3%  
Acceptable Quality
    12,556       9.3%                   12,556       9.3%  
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
    2,330       1.7%                   2,330       1.7%  
                                                 
Neither past due nor impaired
    124,438       91.8%                   124,438       91.8%  
Past due but not impaired
    5,761       4.3%                   5,761       4.3%  
Impaired
    5,322       3.9%                   5,322       3.9%  
                                                 
Total loans and advances to customers
    135,521       100.0%                   135,521       100.0%  
                                                 
 
On December 31, 2009, the Group classified those loans and advances to customers expected to transfer to NAMA as loans held for sale to NAMA. For ease of comparative purposes the tables and commentary presents the loans and advances to customers of €122 billion and loans held for sale to NAMA of circa. €12 billion, together these are referred to as Total loans.


83


Table of Contents

Asset quality continues to deteriorate on a declining loan book. Total loans classified as ‘neither past due nor impaired’ have declined in both volume and percentage terms, with a significant rise in impaired loans in the period from €5.3 billion at March 31, 2009 to €13.4 billion at December 31, 2009. Of the impaired loans at December 31, 2009, 49% or €6.6 billion are expected to transfer to NAMA.
 
Total loans classified as ‘neither past due nor impaired’ accounted for 86.1% of the Group loan book at December 31, 2009 compared to 91.8% at March 31, 2009. The movement is due primarily to the deterioration in the global and Irish economic environments, resulting in continuing low levels of economic activity across our main markets, impacting upon credit quality.
 
In the ‘past due but not impaired’ category, both the quantum and percentage of the Total loans are down from €5.8 billion or 4.3% at March 31, 2009 to €5.4 billion or 4.0% at December 31, 2009. This reduction is mainly due to the movement of exposures into the ‘impaired’ category during the period.
 
‘Impaired’ loans increased from €5.3 billion at March 31, 2009 to €13.4 billion at December 31, 2009, an increase of 151%. This increase in impaired loans reflects the severe deterioration in general economic conditions, weaker consumer sentiment and a sharp slowdown in the Property and construction sector, particularly in the land and development sub-sector. Property and construction accounts for 72% of all impaired loans.
 
The Group currently expects that approximately €12.2 billion of loans may transfer to NAMA (classified as loans held for sale to NAMA). As of December 31, 2009, of these assets of approximately €12.2 billion 44% or €5.4 billion are classified as ‘neither past due nor impaired’, 2% or €0.3 billion are classified as ‘past due but not impaired’ and 54% or €6.6 billion are classified as impaired. Of the €6.6 billion impaired loans, €6.5 billion or 98% relates to the Property and construction portfolio with €5.2 billion or 80% of this relating to land and development.
 
Challenged Loans
 
The Group’s ‘challenged’ loans were €26.3 billion at December 31, 2009 compared to €15.7 billion at March 31, 2009. These ‘challenged’ loans include ‘impaired loans’, together with ‘past due but not impaired loans’, ‘lower quality but not past due nor impaired’ and loans at the lower end of ‘acceptable quality’ which are subject to increased credit scrutiny. The change since March 31, 2009 of €10.6 billion is due to the continued impact of the weaker economic conditions on arrears and continued downward grade migration across the portfolio particularly in Property and construction. Analysed by portfolio at December 31, 2009, Property and construction exposures continued to dominate and represent 58% of all challenged loans. The Non-property SME and corporate loan book accounts for 29% of challenged loans, Residential mortgages accounts for 8% and Consumer loans accounts for 5% of challenged loans at December 31, 2009.
 
                                         
                    Provisions as
            Impaired
      % of
        Impaired
  loans as a %
  Impairment
  impaired
December 31, 2009
  Advances   loans   of advances   Provision   loans
    €m   €m   %   €m   %
 
Total loans: Composition and Impairment
                                       
                                         
Residential mortgages
    60,470       471       0.8%       359       76%  
Non-property SME and corporate
    34,351       2,806       89.2%       1,152       41%  
Property and construction
    35,510       9,648       27.2%       3,884       40%  
Consumer
    4,340       426       9.8%       380       89%  
                                         
Total loans and advances to customers
    134,671       13,351       9.9%       5,775       43%  
                                         
 


84


Table of Contents

                                         
                    Provisions as
            Impaired
      % of
        Impaired
  loans as a %
  Impairment
  impaired
March 31, 2009
  Advances   loans   of advances   Provision   loans
    €m   €m   %   €m   %
 
Total loans: Composition and Impairment
                                       
                                         
Residential mortgages
    58,888       229       0.4%       144       63%  
Non-property SME and corporate
    37,041       1,187       3.2%       480       40%  
Property and construction
    33,955       3,538       10.4%       856       24%  
Consumer
    5,637       368       6.5%       301       82%  
                                         
Total loans and advances to customers
    135,521       5,322       3.9%       1,781       33%  
                                         
 
Impaired loans increased from €5.3 billion or 3.9% of Total loans at March 31, 2009 to €13.4 billion or 9.9% of Total loans at December 31, 2009. Of the €13.4 billion impaired loans, €11.8 billion have been assessed for impairment on an individual basis with the remaining €1.6 billion assessed collectively. Specific provisions on loans assessed on an individual basis amount to €4 billion. The increase in impaired loans primarily reflects the sharp deterioration in the Property and construction sector, particularly in Ireland, together with a deterioration in general economic conditions and weak consumer sentiment.
 
By portfolio, Residential mortgages accounts for 4% of impaired loans, Non-property SME and corporate accounts for 21% of impaired loans, Property and construction accounts for 72% of impaired loans and Consumer accounts for 3% of impaired loans.
 
The ratio of impaired loans to Total loans in the Residential mortgage portfolio is 0.8%, Non-property SME and corporate is 8.2%, Property and construction is 27.2% and Consumer is 9.8% at December 31, 2009. This ratio has increased for all portfolios since March 31, 2009 with the most significant deterioration in the Property and construction portfolio.
 
Total balance sheet provisions against loans and advances to customers were €5.8 billion at December 31, 2009, a significant increase compared to €1.8 billion at March 31, 2009. The Property and construction portfolio accounts for 76% of the increase in provisions during the period, with the Non-property SME and corporate portfolio and the Residential mortgage portfolio generating most of the balance. The increase in impairment provisions in the Consumer portfolio on a declining loan book was relatively modest. Of the €5.8 billion impairment provisions at December 31, 2009, €2.8 billion relates to assets expected to transfer to NAMA.
 
The increase in provisions reflects the impact of the continued deterioration in general economic conditions, consequent loan grade degradation and continued weakening in the Property and construction sectors, in the Republic of Ireland and to a lesser extent in the UK. Impairment provisions as a percentage of impaired loans (coverage ratio) increased to 43% at December 31,2009 from 33% at March 31, 2009. Coverage ratios, which vary considerably by portfolio, are influenced by the nature of the loan assets and the extent and quality of underlying collateral held by the Group in support of the loan.
 
The coverage ratio on Residential mortgages increased from 63% at March 31, 2009 to 76% at December 31, 2009. In line with existing market practice, coverage ratios for Residential mortgages are computed on a different basis to other portfolios (i.e Residential mortgages that are 90 days past due are excluded from impaired loans). If Residential mortgages that are 90 days past due were included in impaired loans, the coverage ratio for Residential mortgages would be 20% at December 31,2009 (up from 12% at March 31, 2009). The Non-property SME and corporate coverage ratio of 41% at December 31, 2009 compares to 40% at March 31, 2009. The coverage ratio for Property and construction of 40% at December 31, 2009 has increased from 24% at March 31, 2009, reflecting a significant increase in the impairment provision at December 31, 2009. Consumer lending at December 31, 2009 has 89% coverage, up from 82% at March 31, 2009. Of the approximately €12.2 billion of loans held for sale to NAMA, €6.6 billion or 54% were impaired. The impairment provision at December 31, 2009 amounted to €2.8 billion which represents 42% of impaired loans.

85


Table of Contents

Loan Impairment Charge
 
The Group impairment charge for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 amounted to €4,055 million or 3.96% when expressed as an annualised percentage of average loans and advances to customers including loans held for sale to NAMA. The charge of €4,055 million is €2,620 million higher than the charge of €1,435 million for the twelve month period ended March 2009. This higher charge reflects, in particular, the impact of the sharp deterioration in the property and construction sector particularly in Ireland, with continued weakening in non-property sectors
 
                                                 
    9 months ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
Total loan impairment charge
  €m   %   €m   %   €m   %
 
Specific impairment (net of provision write backs)
    3,467       3.39%       1,058       0.76%       210       0.16%  
Incurred but not reported (IBNR)
    591       0.58%       385       0.27%       30       0.02%  
Recoveries
    (3 )     (0.01%)       (8 )     (0.01%)       (13 )     (0.01%)  
                                                 
Total loan impairment charge
    4,055       3.96%       1,435       1.02%       227       0.17%  
                                                 
 
The split of the Group impairment charge for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 and the year ended March 31, 2009 and March  31, 2008 by portfolio is as follows:
 
                                                 
    9 months ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
Group loan impairment charge
  €m   %   €m   %   €m   %
 
Residential mortgages
    237        0.52%       127         0.20%       5           0.01 %
Non-property SME & Corporate
    659       2.50%       344       0.94%       83       0.25 %
Property and Construction
    2,993       11.25%       766       2.11%       60       0.17 %
Consumer
    166       4.21%       198       3.08%       79       1.10 %
                                                 
Total loan impairment charge
    4,055       3.96%       1,435       1.02%       227       1.70 %
                                                 
Analysed as follows:
                                               
Loans held for sale to NAMA
    2,231       24.31%                          
Loans and advances to customers
    1,824       1.96%       1,435       1.02%       227       1.70 %
                                                 
Total loan impairment charge
    4,055       3.96%       1,435       1.02%       227       1.70 %
                                                 
 
The impairment charge on Residential mortgages was €237 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €127 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase is due to the impact on the level of arrears from rising unemployment and lower disposable income together with further declining property prices.
 
The impairment charge on Non-property SME and corporate was €659 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €344 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase is due to the impact on customers of the slowdown in economic activity and poor consumer sentiment together with the level of business insolvencies.
 
The impairment charge on Property and construction was €2,993 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €766 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The land and development element within the Property and construction portfolio is most significantly impacted by falling property prices, more negative views of asset values, over supply of residential stock in Ireland and the general weak economic conditions, particularly in Ireland and to a lesser extent in the UK.
 
The impairment charge on Consumer loans was €166 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €198 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The charge on Consumer loans remains significant due to higher unemployment, high levels of personal indebtedness and lower disposable income.


86


Table of Contents

Of the €4,055 million impairment charge on loans and advances to customers for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, €2,231 million or 55% relates to loans held for sale to NAMA. The impairment charge of €1,824 million on loans and advances to customers represents 45% of the total charge of €4,055 million for the nine months ended December 31, 2009; it represents 1.96% on an annualised basis, on the average loans and advances to customers excluding loans held for sale to NAMA.
 
The asset quality of the mortgage portfolio has shown some deterioration with an impairment charge of 20bps in the year to March 31, 2009 compared to 1bp in the prior year. Unemployment is a key risk driver of impairment in the mortgage portfolio and this higher charge reflects the general deterioration in the economy and increase pace of unemployment.
 
The asset quality of our non-property SME and corporate lending is diversified across a range of business sectors and has been impacted by the general downward trend in levels of economic activity.
 
The property and construction portfolio represents 25% of the Group’s loan book. The impairment charge of 211bps in the year to March 31, 2009 compares to 17bps in the prior year. The recession in both the Irish and UK economics together with lack of liquidity and falling asset values, have significantly impacted the asset quality in this portfolio.
 
The impairment charge on the consumer portfolio has increased from 110bps in the year ended March 31, 2008 to 308bps in the year ended March 31, 2009, reflecting a significant deterioration in the asset quality of this book.
 
Financial assets renegotiated that would otherwise be past due or impaired
 
Renegotiated loans are those facilities at 31 December 2009 which if not renegotiated during the nine month period ended 31 December 2009 would have been classified as ‘impaired’ loans or as ‘past due but not impaired’ loans. The carrying value of these loans at 31 December 2009 is €6,390 million (March 31, 2009: €5,950 million) and represents borrowers whose loan terms and conditions have been amended in recognition of a change in the borrowers’ circumstances. Renegotiated loans are primarily included in the ‘Acceptable quality’ and lower quality but not ‘past due nor impaired’ classifications and are not deemed to represent a risk of loss at the reporting date.
 
Loans that have their terms amended but do not meet the requirements for financial assets that are ‘neither past due nor impaired’, continue to be reported as ‘past due but not impaired’ or as ‘impaired’.
 
Repossessed collateral
 
During the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, the Group took possession of collateral held as security, as follows:
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Ireland
    6       1  
UK & Other
    66       73  
                 
      72       74  
Other properties
    12       0  
                 
      84       74  
                 
 
Repossessed properties are sold as soon as practicable, with the proceeds applied against outstanding indebtedness.
 
Asset quality: Other Financial Instruments
 
Other financial instruments include available for sale financial assets, derivative financial instruments, loans and advances to banks, interest receivable and the reinsurance assets. The table below analyses the Group’s exposure to other financial instruments based on the gross amount before provisions for impairment.
 


87


Table of Contents

                                 
    December 31,
  March 31
    2009   2009
Other financial instruments
  €m   %   €m   %
 
High quality
    33,633       93%       41,747       89%  
Satisfactory quality
    2,097       6%       4,895       11%  
Acceptable quality
    286       1%       99        
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
    113             30        
                                 
Neither past due nor impaired
    36,129       100%       46,771       100%  
Impaired
    12             79        
                                 
Total
    36,141       100%       46,850       100%  
                                 
 
The total volume of other financial instruments at December 31, 2009 amounted to €36.1 billion, a reduction of €10.8 billion from the volume of other financial instruments (€46.9 billion at March 31, 2009). This reduction primarily reflects the lower levels of available for sale financial assets, derivative financial instruments and loans and advances to banks. Virtually all of the Group’s exposures to other financial instruments were classified as ‘neither past due nor impaired’.
 
Available for sale assets
 
Substantially all of the Group’s liquid assets are accounted for in the Group’s Available for Sale financial assets portfolio. The following table quantifies the Group’s exposure to each asset class and the impact of market dislocation on valuations at December 31, 2009 with comparisons at March 31, 2009.
 
                               
                              Fair Value
                              expressed as a % of
Portfolio     Market Value     Asset Type     Profile     Key Movements     Underlying Nominal
Liquid Asset
Portfolio
    €19.4 billion
(March 31, 2009,
€25.2 billion)
    €18.3 billion
bank debt
(March 31, 2009,
€22.7 billion)
    Average rating AA-
(March 31, 2009
Average rating AA-)
    Negative mark to market adjustment to reserves of €0.3 billion, a positive movement in the period of €0.7 billion
(March 31, 2009, €1.0 billion negative)
    100.4%
(March 31, 2009,
96.6)%
                        No impairments were recognised in the current period
(March 31, 2009, €61 million)
     
                               
            €1.1 billion
Government bonds
(March 31, 2009,
€2.5 billion)
    100% AA rated
(March 31, 2009
95% AAA rated)
    Positive mark to market adjustment to reserves of €21 million, a negative movement in the period of €46 million
(March 31, 2009, €67 million positive)
No impairments were recognised in the current or prior periods
    104.2%
(March 31, 2009,
102)%
                               

88


Table of Contents

                               
                              Fair Value
                              expressed as a % of
Portfolio     Market Value     Asset Type     Profile     Key Movements     Underlying Nominal
Asset backed
Securities
Portfolio
    €1.5 billion
(March 31, 2009,
€1.7 billion)
    €0.5 billion RMBS
(March 31, 2009, €0.5 billion),
    79% rated
AAA/AA
(March 31, 2009 95)%
    Total negative mark to market adjustment to reserves of €0.4 billion a positive movement in the period of €0.2 billion
(March 31, 2009, €0.6 billion negative)
Impairments of €1.6 million were recognised in the current period
(March 31, 2009 €15 million)
    87%
(March 31, 2009
81)%
                               
            €0.4 billion CMBS
(March 31, 2009,
€0.4 billion)
    75% rated
AAA/AA
(March 31, 2009
100)%
           
                               
           
€0.6 billion
including loans in
syndication, CDO’s
and financials

(March 31, 2009,
€0.8 billion)
                 
                               
 
At December 31, 2009, the Liquid Asset Portfolio comprises €19.4 billion of the total AFS financial assets; €1.1 billion in government bonds and €18.3 billion in bank debt. The other AFS assets of €1.5 billion are Asset Backed Securities (ABS) comprising Commercial Mortgage Backed Securities (CMBS) of €0.4 billion, Residential Mortgage Backed Securities (RMBS) of €0.5 billion, and loans in syndication, Collateralised Debt Obligations (CDOs) and loans to financials totalling of €0.6 billion.
 
The receivership of Washington Mutual resulted in an impairment of €36 million in the AFS portfolio and this has been charged through the income statement in the year ended March 31, 2009. In addition the nationalisation and subsequent receivership of certain Icelandic banks led to a €25 million impairment charge in the year to March 31, 2009.
 
Trading securities
 
The Group holds a portfolio of bonds for trading purposes typically taking positions in financial and corporate risk with ratings between investment grade AAA and BBB (average rating A). The value of the portfolio at December 31, 2009 was €403 million (March 31, 2009: €125 million).
 
Share of associated undertakings and joint ventures
 
Profit after tax from associated undertakings and joint ventures has increased from a loss of €42 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 to a profit of €35 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009.
 
First Rate Exchange Services (FRES) a joint venture with the UK Post Office generated profit after tax of £23 million (€27 million) in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 down from £31 million (€39 million) in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2008. This reduction is primarily due to the shorter reporting period and lower fee income due to the contraction in the overseas travel market.
 
The Group has a stake in a property unit trust that holds an investment in a UK retail property. This interest, initially acquired by the Group to sell onto private investors, remains on the Group’s balance sheet. The decline in the property market led to a fall in the value of this interest of €70 million which was reflected in the income statement

89


Table of Contents

for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The share of results for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was €8 million.
 
Profit on disposal of business activities /property
 
In the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 the Group disposed of its interest in Guggenheim and Iridian resulting in a €3 million net loss.
 
Taxes
 
The following table sets out a reconciliation of taxes chargeable at the statutory Irish corporation tax rate and the Group’s effective tax rate for the nine months ended December 31, 2009, and the two years ended March 31, 2009. The effective tax rate is obtained by dividing the tax charge by profit before tax.
 
                         
        * Restated
  * Restated
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    (in € millions, except percentages)
 
Average statutory corporation tax rate
    12.5 %     12.5 %     12.5 %
                         
Loss/(profit) before tax multiplied by the standard rate of Corporate tax in Ireland
    227       1       (242 )
Effects of:
                       
Foreign earnings subject to different rates of tax
    70       81       (86 )
Bank of Ireland Life — different basis of taxation
    (55 )     58       53  
Income arising on repurchase of subordinated liabilities
    121              
Elimination of investment return on treasury stock held for the benefit of policyholders
    (1 )     16       24  
Tax exempted profits and income at a reduced Irish tax rate
          (4 )     (2 )
Non-deductible goodwill impairment
    (1 )     (110 )        
Non-deductible expenses
    (9 )     (19 )     (7 )
Prior year adjustments
    4       7       1  
Share of profit of associates and joint ventures shown post tax in income statement
    3       5       6  
Other adjustments for income tax purposes
    (15 )     6       24  
                         
Income tax credit/(charge)
    344       41       (229 )
                         
*     The prior years have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
The taxation credit for the Group was €344 million for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 compared to a taxation credit of €41 million for the year ended March 31, 2009 primarily due to losses in the period. The effective tax rate for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 was a credit of 19% compared to a credit of 178% for the year ended March 31, 2009.
 
Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
The taxation credit for the Group was €41 million for year ended March 31, 2009 compared to a taxation charge of €229 million in the year ended March 31, 2008. The tax credit arises primarily due to a reduction in earnings across the Group and the life policyholder tax gross-up. The effective tax rate was a credit of 178% for the year ended March 31, 2009, compared to a charge of 11.8% for the year ended March 31, 2008.


90


Table of Contents

Divisional Performance: (Loss)/profit before tax
 
                         
        Restated*
  Restated*
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
    (in € millions)
 
Retail Republic of Ireland
    (1,514 )     11       749  
Bank of Ireland Life
    133       (107 )     48  
UK Financial Services
    (805 )     (26 )     463  
Capital Markets
    (603 )     161       651  
Group Centre
    976       (62 )     19  
                         
(Loss)/profit before tax
    (1,813 )     (23 )     1,930  
                         
*     The prior years have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
Retail Republic of Ireland
 
Retail Republic of Ireland incorporates the Branch Network, Mortgage Business, Consumer Banking, Business Banking and Private Banking activities in the Republic of Ireland. Together with Bank of Ireland Life, it is the leading bancassurance franchise in Ireland built on a broad distribution platform, a comprehensive suite of retail, business products and services, a commitment to service excellence and a strong focus on operating efficiency.
 
Retail Republic of Ireland: Income statement
 
                         
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
    (in € millions)
 
Net interest income
    888       1,452       1,429  
Other income
    112       277       450  
                         
Total operating income
    1,000       1,729       1,879  
Other operating expenses
    (680 )     (940 )     (983 )
Impairment losses on intangible assets
    (6 )            
                         
Operating income before impairment on financial assets
    314       789       896  
Impairment losses on loans and advances
    (1,836 )     (708 )     (146 )
Share of profit/(loss) of associates and joint ventures
    8       (70 )     (1 )
                         
(Loss)/profit before tax
    (1,514 )     11       749  
                         
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
The nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was particularly difficult for the Retail businesses in Ireland which continued to be adversely impacted by the significant contraction in the Irish economy. The sharp decline in the property and construction sectors led to substantially higher impairment charges. Intense competition for deposits and the low interest rate environment resulted in significant reductions in deposit margins. The economic outlook together with poor consumer sentiment has resulted in subdued demand for financial services products.
 
Retail Republic of Ireland reported a loss before tax of €1,514 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a profit before tax of €11 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
The operating profit of €314 million before impairment charges on financial assets for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 reduced by €475 million compared to the operating profit of €789 million before impairment charges on financial assets for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
Net interest income of €888 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was €564 million lower than the net interest income of €1,452 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction is a


91


Table of Contents

result of the shorter reporting period together with significant narrowing of liability spreads due to intense competition for customer deposits and the low interest rate environment.
 
Net other income of €112 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was €165 million lower than Net other income of €277 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction arises primarily as a result of the shorter reporting period, a charge of €74 million arising from an unfavourable court ruling in connection with a European property investment, further impairment of €15 million on the value of some investment properties arising from continuing low levels of transactions in the commercial property market and lower fees and other income in Business Banking, Private Banking and Credit Cards due to lower levels of new business activity. Net other income for the 12 month period ended March 31, 2009 included a €24 million gain from a distribution by VISA International following its initial public offering.
 
Operating expenses of €680 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 have decreased compared to €940 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This is largely due to the shorter reporting period, reduced staff numbers and tight control of costs.
 
Share of results of associates and joint ventures of €8 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compares to a loss of €70 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The loss of €70 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 is primarily attributable to an impairment charge of €63 million relating to the Group’s investment in a property unit trust that holds an investment in a UK retail property.
 
At December 31, 2009, the Group classified those loans and advances to customers expected to transfer to NAMA as loans held for sale to NAMA. For ease of comparative purposes, the following commentary presents loans and advances to customers and loans held for sale to NAMA together as Total loans.
 
The impairment charge on Total loans of €1,836 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was a substantial increase on the impairment charge of €708 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 due principally to the significant contraction in economic activity, with continuing low levels of transactions in both the commercial and residential property markets.
 
The impairment charge on the Residential mortgages was €165 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €60 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase is due to the impact on the level of arrears from rising unemployment and lower disposable income, together with the further decline in property prices. At December 31, 2009, 3 month arrears in the Residential mortgage portfolio were 3.46% compared to 1.92% at March 31, 2009.
 
The impairment charge on Non-property SME and corporate loans was €343 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €157 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase is due to the impact on customers of the slowdown in economic activity and poor consumer sentiment, together with the level of business insolvencies.
 
The impairment charge on Property and construction loans was €1,187 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €330 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The land and development element within the Property and construction portfolio is most significantly impacted by the sharp contraction in the level of economic activity, leading to falling asset values, exacerbated by the over supply of residential and commercial property in Ireland.
 
The impairment charge on Consumer loans was €141 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €161 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The charge on Consumer loans remains significant, due to higher unemployment, high levels of personal indebtedness and lower disposable income.
 
Resources and Advances
 
At December 31, 2009 total customer deposits were €35 billion, an increase of 4% over March 31, 2009. Deposits have increased from €23 billion at March 31, 2009 to €24 billion at December 31, 2009, an increase of 4%. Current account credit balances have increased from €10 billion at March 31, 2009 to €11 billion at December 31, 2009, an increase of 6%. The strength of our distribution platform particularly through our Branch Network and Business


92


Table of Contents

Banking relationships, the increase in the savings ratio and the development of products that are attractive to retail customers have been the key enablers of the strong deposit inflows from both new and existing customers.
 
As a consequence of the weak economic environment, demand for new loans and other credit facilities in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was considerably lower than previous periods. Total loans, before impairment provisions, were €54 billion at December 31, 2009 compared to €55 billion at March 31, 2009, a reduction of 1% (a decline of 4% net of impairment provisions) reflecting the impact of customers reducing personal indebtedness and businesses not taking on new financial commitments in the current difficult economic environment.
 
The Residential mortgage book at December 31, 2009 grew 2% compared to the Residential mortgage book at March 31, 2009 reflecting the Group’s focus on the First Time Buyer segment. This growth in the mortgage book is more than offset by a decline in other retail loan books. In particular, the Consumer loan book has declined by 14% due to scheduled repayments and redemptions as customers have sought to reduce levels of personal indebtedness.
 
Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
The year ended March 31, 2009, was challenging for the Retail businesses which were adversely impacted by the rapid and severe contraction in the Irish economy, the downturn in residential and commercial property markets, the effect of stock market weakness on the sale of investment products and the continued dislocation in financial markets.
 
Retail Republic of Ireland delivered profit before tax of €11 million in the year ended March 31, 2009, compared with €749 million in the year ended March 31, 2008.
 
The divisional performance for the year ended March 31, 2009, is not directly comparable to the prior year as the current year to March 31, 2009, includes costs associated with the costs of the downsizing initiatives of €9 million. In addition, the prior year numbers to March 31, 2008, include €33 million of a gain in relation to disposal of property compared to nil in the current year.
 
Net interest income increased by 1% in the year to March 31, 2009, to €1,452 million. However the year on year percentages for net interest income and ‘other income’ are impacted by IFRS income classifications between net interest income and ‘other income’. Excluding the impact of both of these income classifications, net interest income decreased by 1% and ‘other income’ decreased by 4%.
 
The net interest income reduction primarily reflects higher funding costs associated with market dislocation, tighter liability spreads due to competition and balance sheet mix.
 
‘Other income’ was lower by 38% in the year ended March 31, 2009, compared to the prior year. This reduction primarily results from lower general insurance sales and higher claims costs, together with the impairment of investment properties and lower sales and commissions.
 
A strong cost performance was achieved with operating expenses reduced by 5% in the year ended March 31, 2009, compared to the prior year. Staff numbers were reduced significantly (down 6%) and all cost categories were managed very tightly through the year.
 
Reflecting the sharply disimproved economic environment, rising unemployment and severe weakness in the property and construction sector, the impairment charge for the year ended March 31, 2009 was €708 million or 129bps compared with €146 million or 28bps in the year ended March 31, 2008. Of the year on year increase of €562 million in the impairment charge, 10% relates to residential mortgages, 12% relates to consumer lending with the balance of 78% largely relating to the property and construction component of the business lending portfolio. The impairment charge on the mortgage portfolio was 23bps for the year ended March 31, 2009 compared with 1bp in the year ended March 31, 2008 and this increase largely reflects the impact of higher levels of unemployment and lower property prices. At March 31, 2009, 3 month arrears in the mortgage portfolio were 192bps at March 31, 2009 compared to 70bps at March 31, 2008. The impairment charge on consumer lending was 416bps for the year ended March 31, 2009 compared to 195bps in the prior year. Loan impairment on other lending, primarily property and construction was 210bps for the year ended March 31, 2009 compared to 33bps for the year ended March 31, 2008.


93


Table of Contents

Share of associated undertakings and joint ventures represents the Group’s stake in a property unit trust which holds an investment in a UK retail property.
 
Resources and Advances
 
Deposit growth of 1% was achieved through competitive products, brand strength and distribution capability. In line with overall market trends, book growth of 5% in mortgages, 1% in business lending and a reduction of 7% in consumer lending resulted in the loan book at March 31, 2009, remaining unchanged compared to March 31, 2008.
 
Bank of Ireland Life
 
The Group operates in the life and pensions market in Ireland through New Ireland Assurance Company plc trading as Bank of Ireland Life. New Ireland is a manufacturer of pension, life assurance and related products for individuals and SME’s. Bank of Ireland Life offers life assurance, protection, pensions and investment products to the Group customers in Ireland through the branch network. The Group also operates in the independent intermediary market under the New Ireland brand and through a direct sales force.
 
                         
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    (in € millions)
 
Profit/(loss) before tax
    133       (107 )     48  
                         
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
Profit before tax of €133 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 has increased by €240 million from a loss before tax of €107 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase is due primarily to the movement in the investment valuation variance partly offset by lower operating profit.
 
Annual Premium Equivalent (APE) sales for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 were 23% lower (on an annualised basis) than the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
Operating profit of €43 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is lower than the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 as a result of;
 
•  lower volumes of new business, notably of savings and regular premium pensions,
 
•  the shorter reporting period
 
•  policy lapses due to lower disposable income, and
 
•  lower average funds under management, reflecting the sharp fall in investment markets in the second half of the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
Operating expenses of €82 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is lower by €26 million compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction is due to the shorter reporting period and the continued focus on cost reduction by Bank of Ireland Life. Included in operating expenses of €82 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is an impairment charge of €3 million relating to the revaluation of Bank of Ireland Life owned properties.
 
In the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, consistent with long term bond yields, the discount rate applied to future cashflows decreased from 9.0% to 8.25%, and the unit growth assumption was reduced from 7.25% to 6.5%, resulting in a profit of €3 million compared to a loss of €16 million in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
The performance of investment markets in excess of this growth assumption since April 2009 has resulted in a positive investment valuation variance of €23 million. This compares to an underperformance of investment markets in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009, which gave rise to a negative investment valuation variance of €117 million.


94


Table of Contents

An increase of €140 million due to a credit of €64 million relating to the gross up of policyholder tax in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a charge of €76 million in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
Profit before tax fell from €48 million in the year to March 31, 2008 to a loss of €107 million for the year ended March 31, 2009.
 
The reduction in profit before tax of €155 million was attributable to the following factors:
 
•  A reduction of €62 million due to the impact of adverse trading conditions. As Bank of Ireland Life predominately writes unit-linked business, movements in premiums, claims and life assurance investment income and losses are not directly reflective of profit. Rather, profit is impacted more by new business sales, funds under management and charges levied on policyholders. New business sales, particularly lump sum investments, as measured by Annual Premium Equivalent (APE), were 44% lower in the current year compared to the prior year. Funds under management were lower due to weaknesses in investment markets. Also higher policy lapses as investors are increasingly diverting their portfolios from equities to cash have led to the reduction in profit. Bank of Ireland Life has maintained a tight focus on cost management with operating expenses down 1% year on year.
 
•  A reduction of €67 million due to a negative investment valuation variance of €117 million arising from the weakness in global equity markets, compared to a €50 million charge for the year ended March 31, 2008.
 
•  A reduction of €16 million due to the charge relating to the gross up of policyholder tax in the current year to March 31, 2009 of €76 million compared to a charge of €60 million in the prior year.
 
•  A reduction of €10 million due to change in the discount rate and other rate changes. Consistent with long term bond yields, the discount rate applied to future cash flows was increased from 8.0% to 9.0% in the year ended March 31, 2009, (the prior year reflects the impact of an increase in the discount rate to 8.0% from 7.5%).
 
UK Financial Services (UKFS)
(£ Sterling)
 
The UK Financial Services (UKFS) Division incorporates Business Banking in Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the branch network in Northern Ireland, the UK Residential mortgage business and the joint ventures with the UK Post Office, namely Post Office Financial and Travel Services (POFTS).
 
UK Financial Services: Income Statement
 
                         
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008*
    (in £ millions)
 
Net interest income
    411       627       579  
Other income
    61       115       119  
                         
Total operating income
    472       742       698  
Total operating expenses
    (267 )     (447 )     (379 )
                         
Operating profit before impairment losses
    205       295       319  
Impairment losses on loans and advances
    (948 )     (372 )     (23 )
Share of profit of associates and joint ventures
    23       31       34  
                         
(Loss)/profit before tax
    (720 )     (46 )     330  
                         
(Loss)/profit before tax (euro equivalent)
    (805 )     (26 )     463  
                         
 
 
Divisional PBT performance of UK Financial Services (UKFS) and Group Centre are restated to reflect the corporate restructuring of Bristol & West plc undertaken to obtain the optimum capital and funding treatment for the Group under Basel II. For the year ended March 31, 2008, this restatement reduces the UKFS PBT to £330 million from £353 million and it reduces Group Centre’s loss by an equivalent amount.


95


Table of Contents

 
The average exchange rate applied by the Group in converting the above Sterling amounts to euro for the purposes of preparing the consolidated financial statements was 0.8851 to December 31, 2009, (0.8333 to March 31, 2009 and 0.7116 to March 31, 2008).
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
The UKFS loss before tax of £720 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, compares to a loss before tax of £46 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The Divisional performance for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is not directly comparable with the year ended March 31, 2009 as the prior financial period included costs associated with the downsizing initiatives of £56 million.
 
Net interest income of £411 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is £216 million lower than the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 due to the shorter reporting period, intense competition impacting liability spreads together with the low interest rate environment. The negative impacts were partly offset by higher pricing on both the Residential mortgage and Business Banking loan books.
 
In January 2009, the Group announced its withdrawal from the intermediary sourced mortgage market in the UK and the wind down of a range of international lending portfolios in Capital Markets (together the “Non-core loan portfolios”). At December 31, 2009 the Non-core loan portfolios amounted to €34 billion.
 
Up to September 30, 2009, the Group allocated its total cost of funds (which includes the cost over libor / euribor on wholesale funding, customer deposits and securitisations) based on the net asset or liability position of each division. With effect from October 1, 2009, the Group has decided to change the basis of allocation of its cost of funds. From this date, the Group has allocated the marginal cost of wholesale funding to the Non-core loan portfolios. For the remaining loan portfolios (together the “Core loan portfolios”) the Group’s residual cost of funds is allocated based on the net asset or liability position of each division.
 
The impact of this decision, made on October 1, 2009, on UK Financial Services was to decrease its Net interest income in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 by €17 million (Stg£15 million). As a consequence, the impact of this decision was to increase the Net interest income in Retail Republic of Ireland by €9 million and to increase the Net interest income in Capital Markets by €8 million.
 
It is estimated that the impact of this decision, on an annualised basis, would be to decrease the Net interest income in UK Financial Services by €68 million (Stg£60 million), to increase the Net interest income in Retail Republic of Ireland by €36 million and to increase the Net interest income in Capital Markets by €32 million.
 
Net other income of £61 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 reduced by £54 million when compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction reflects the shorter reporting period, reduced fee income as a result of lower new business lending activity and seasonality in the Consumer Financial Services businesses, together with the impact of interest rate changes on the fair value of economic hedging instruments.
 
Operating expenses for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of £267 million were £180 million lower than the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction is driven by the shorter reporting period together with savings from the restructuring of both the UK Residential mortgage and Business Banking operations, also the prior twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 included a restructuring provision of £56 million. Investment has continued in the joint ventures with the UK Post Office.


96


Table of Contents

At December 31, 2009, the Group classified those loans and advances to customers expected to transfer to NAMA as loans held for sale to NAMA. For ease of comparative purposes the following tables and commentary presents loans and advances to customers and loans held for sale to NAMA together as Total loans.
 
                 
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
Loan impairment charge by portfolio
  December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    £m   £m
 
Residential mortgages
    64       58  
Non-property SME and corporate
    43       48  
Property and construction
    820       245  
Consumer
    21       21  
                 
Total impairment charge on total loans
    948       372  
                 
 
Financial period ended December 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2009
 
The impairment charge on Total loans of £948 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was a substantial increase on the impairment charge of £372 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The increased impairment charge arises primarily in the land and development element of the Property and construction portfolio, which has been most significantly impacted by sharp declines in asset values, higher unemployment and lower levels of economic activity. The increase in the Residential mortgage impairment charge is driven by higher unemployment, house price deflation and the weak economy, which have led to higher arrears and repossessions.
 
The Share of results of associates and joint ventures relates to the Group’s share of First Rate Exchange Services (FRES), a joint venture with the UK Post Office, which generated profit after tax of £23 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, compared to £31 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction is primarily due to the shorter reporting period and lower fee income due to the contraction in the overseas travel market.
 
As outlined above, the impact of the Group’s decision to change the basis of allocation of its cost of funds with effect from October 1, 2009 was to decrease the Net interest income in UK Financial Services by €17 million (Stg£15 million). Within UK Financial Services, the impact of this decision was to decrease the Net interest income for Residential mortgages by €26 million (Stg£23 million) and to increase the Net interest income for Business Banking by €9 million (Stg£8 million).
 
It is estimated that the impact of this decision on an annualised basis would be to decrease the Net interest income for Residential mortgages by €103 million (Stg£91 million) and to increase the Net interest income in Business Banking by €35 million (Stg£31 million).
 
The profit before tax in the Residential Mortgage Business for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of £39 million has decreased from a profit before tax of £55 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Operating profit of £108 million before impairment charges for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 has decreased by £12 million when compared to the operating profit before impairment charges for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This decrease is due to the shorter reporting period, the change in the basis of allocation of the cost of funds, as previously outlined, partly offset by improved product margins and a reduction in the operating costs resulting from the closure of the intermediary channel to new business in January 2009. The operating expenses for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 included £37 million in relation to costs associated with a restructuring provision. Residential mortgage impairment charges for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of £64 million increased from £58 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 driven by higher unemployment, house price deflation and the weak economy which have led to higher arrears and repossessions.
 
While arrears have risen sharply from a low base, the residential mortgage portfolio continues to outperform industry averages. At December 31, 2009, overall residential mortgage portfolio arrears greater than three months were 171 basis points compared to average industry arrears of 238 basis points as per CML (“Council of Mortgage Lenders”) data.


97


Table of Contents

The Business Banking loss before tax for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of £729 million shows a significant deterioration when compared to the loss before tax for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 of £100 million. This deterioration reflects a substantial increase in impairment charges to £860 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to £292 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase in the impairment charge arises substantially in the land and development element of the Property and construction portfolio and is driven primarily by a sharp decline in asset values, higher unemployment and lower levels of economic activity. Operating profit before impairment charges of £131 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 decreased by £61 million compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 of £192 million. This is due to the shorter reporting period, lower net interest income due to intense competition for deposits, a lower interest rate environment and reduced deposit volumes, higher wholesale funding costs partly offset by asset re-pricing and the impact of the change in the basis of allocation of the cost of funds as outlined above. The operating expenses for the 12 month period ended March 31, 2009 included £19 million in relation to costs associated with the restructuring provision.
 
Consumer Financial Services which is comprised of a number of business activities with the UK Post Office (POFTS, Credit Cards and ATMs) delivered a profit before tax of £20 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 which is £28 million lower than the profit before tax for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction is primarily attributable to the shorter reporting period, seasonality in the Consumer Financial Services businesses and lower fee income due to the contraction in the overseas travel market together with deposit margin attrition.
 
The loss before tax in Division Centre increased to £50 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 from £49 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 due mainly to the continued investment in deposit gathering initiatives and the impact of interest rate changes on fair value of economic hedging instruments.
 
Resources and Advances
 
Business Banking deposits declined by 9% in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 reflecting continued intense competition. Deposits sourced through the Group’s joint venture with the UK Post Office have grown by 9% since March 31, 2009 to £8.5 billion at December 31, 2009, reflecting the Group’s investment in this important source of customer deposits.
 
Total loans, before impairment provisions of £47 billion is a reduction of 2% (a decline of 4% net of impairment provisions) at December 31, 2009 compared to £48 billion at March 31, 2009.
 
The de-leverage of the UK residential mortgage book has been slower than originally expected as a result of lower re-mortgage activity in the UK market. This, coupled with mortgage lending through the UK Post Office channel, has resulted in the UK mortgage book being 2% lower at December 31, 2009 compared to March 31, 2009.
 
The Business Banking loan book at December 31, 2009 is lower by 3% since March 31, 2009 reflecting weakened demand for loans and other credit facilities.
 
Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
The UKFS loss before tax of £46 million for the year ended March 31, 2009, compares to profit before tax of £330 million in the prior year. The Divisional performance for the year ended March 31, 2009 is not directly comparable with the year ended March 31, 2008 as the current year numbers include costs associated with a restructuring provision of £56 million.
 
Total operating income grew by 6% to £742 million in the year ended March 31, 2009. Net interest income grew by 8% due to improved pricing and volume growth in the lending businesses partly offset by the higher funding costs caused by the continuing market dislocation and the margin attrition suffered on deposits due to falling interest rates and severe competition.
 
Operating expenses increased by 18% to £447 million for the year ended March 31, 2009. This includes costs related to the downsizing initiatives of £56 million. Excluding these costs, operating expenses increased by 3% driven by costs associated with deposit gathering initiatives.


98


Table of Contents

The impairment charge increased to £372 million (78bps) in the year ended March 31, 2009 from £23 million (6bps) in the year ended March 31, 2008. The increased impairment charge arises primarily in the landbank and property development component of the business banking portfolio.
 
The Residential Mortgage business PBT reduced significantly in the year ended March 31, 2009 compared to the prior period. The PBT is after a charge of £37 million in relation to the costs associated with the downsizing initiatives. Operating profit before impairment charges in the Mortgage business in the year ended March 31, 2009, is 15% higher than in the year ended March 31, 2009. This increase in operating profit is driven by higher loan volumes and improved product margins outweighing the impact of higher funding costs and lower redemption income.
 
Mortgage impairment charges increased from 1bp in the year ended March 31, 2008 to 20bps in the year ended March 31, 2009 driven by the economic downturn which has led to higher arrears and repossessions, and material house price deflation. While arrears have risen sharply during the year from a low base, the mortgage portfolio continues to significantly outperform industry averages. At March 31, 2009, total mortgage portfolio 3 month arrears were 148bps (March 31, 2008: 63bps), which compare favourably to data released by the Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML) on May 15, 2009, which indicated total mortgage portfolio 3 month arrears of 239bps for the overall market. 3 month arrears across standard mortgages were 80bps (March 31, 2008: 49bps). 3 month arrears in relation to buy to let (BTL) mortgages were 173bps (March 31, 2008: 57bps), which compares to CML buy to let data of 309bps. 3 month arrears in relation to self certified mortgages were 366bps (March 2008: 139bps).
 
Business Banking recorded a loss before tax in the year ended March 31, 2009 compared to a profit before tax in the prior period. The loss includes a charge of £19 million in relation to the costs associated with the downsizing initiatives. Operating profit before impairment charges grew by 6% driven by strong cost management in the period. However higher loan impairment losses in the year ended March 31, 2009, compared to the prior year reflect falls in property values and limited availability of liquidity due to both the recession and deleveraging by many banks. These factors have been particularly severe in the landbank and residential development sectors of the portfolio which account for 84% of the total impairment charge.
 
Consumer Financial Services which is comprised of a number of business activities with the UK Post Office (largely Post Office Financial Services (POFS), First Rate Exchange Services (FRES) and ATMs) together with some smaller retail businesses, delivered a slightly higher profit for the year ended March 31, 2009, compared to the year ended March 31, 2008. POFS now has in excess of 2 million customers. FRES, the foreign exchange joint venture, had a more challenging year, with the travel market reflecting the effect of the recession and sterling weakness impacting foreign travel.
 
Division Centre’s loss increased in the year ended March 31, 2009 due mainly to significant investment in deposit gathering together with increased property costs including a fair value loss on owned premises.
 
Resource and Advances
 
Loans and advances to customers (net of impairment provisions) increased by 7% from £45 billion at March 31, 2008 to £48 billion at March 31, 2009. Residential mortgages and business loans grew by 7% and 8% respectively and this largely reflects the momentum resulting from the very strong pipeline developed in the second half of the prior financial year ended March 31, 2008 and carried into the first half of the current financial year ended March 31, 2009. Lending balances were held flat in the 6 months to March 31, 2009 and are expected to reduce going forward following the decision to close the intermediary mortgage channel in the UK, as announced in January 2009.
 
Customer accounts grew by 15% from £17 billion to £19 billion driven by strong growth in deposits from the UK Post Office network. Business Banking deposits declined over the final few months of the financial year ended March 31, 2009, as depositor sentiment towards Irish financials was negatively impacted by a number of factors including credit rating agency actions and the nationalisation of Anglo Irish Bank.


99


Table of Contents

Capital Markets
 
Our Capital Markets Division comprises Corporate Banking, Global Markets, Asset Management and IBI Corporate Finance.
 
Capital Markets: Income statement
 
                         
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
    (in € millions)
 
Net interest income
    705       1,482       1,030  
Other income
    83       (237 )     90  
                         
Operating income
    788       1,245       1,120  
Operating expenses
    (230 )     (386 )     (416 )
Impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets
          304        
                         
Operating profit before impairment loss on financial assets
    558       555       704  
Impairment losses on loans and advances to customers (incl. loans held for sale to NAMA)
    (1,157 )     (305 )     (48 )
Impairment losses on loans and advances to banks
          (2 )      
Impairment losses on AFS financial assets
    (2 )     (76 )     (5 )
Loss on disposal of business activities
    (3 )            
Share of results of associates and joint ventures
    1       (11 )      
                         
(Loss)/profit before tax
    (603 )     161       651  
                         
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
Capital Markets reported a loss before tax of €603 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a profit before tax of €161 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
Operating profit of €558 million before impairment charges on financial assets for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compares to an operating profit of €555 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
The year on year change in net interest income and other income is impacted by IFRS income classifications, as explained on page 74.
 
Net interest income decreased by 52% in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended 31 March 2009. After the impact of the IFRS income classifications, ‘Net interest income’ decreased by 34% in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 primarily reflecting the shorter reporting period and the higher cost of funding.
 
Other income/(expense) increased by 135% in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31,2009. After the impact of IFRS classifications, ‘Net other income’ for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 reduced by 47% when compared to the twelve month period ended March 31 2009, this decrease primarily reflects:
 
•  the shorter reporting period,
 
•  reduced fees in the asset management businesses of €67 million arising from the disposal of Iridian Asset Management LLC (Iridian) in June 2009 and Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC (Guggenheim) in August 2009, together with lower fee income in Bank of Ireland Asset Management and Bank of Ireland Securities Services,
 
•  lower other income in Corporate Banking of €39 million primarily due to reduced fee income driven by a lack of demand for credit facilities and the recognition of impairment charges on investment properties (€10 million),


100


Table of Contents

 
•  lower levels of other income in Global Markets of €64 million primarily as a result of decreased levels of third party customer business, partly offset by;
 
•  a charge of €39 million in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 related to the collapse of Lehmans in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009.
 
Operating expenses of €230 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 are €156 million lower than the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction is primarily due to the shorter reporting period, the disposal of Iridian and Guggenheim together with tight management of all costs.
 
There was no impairment of goodwill in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009. The year ended March 31, 2009 included an impairment charge of €304 million in respect of goodwill and other intangible assets in the asset management business.
 
At December 31, 2009, the Group classified those loans and advances to customers expected to transfer to NAMA as loans held for sale to NAMA. For ease of comparative purposes the following tables and commentary presents loans and advances to customers and loans held for sale together as Total loans.
 
                 
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
Loan impairment charge by portfolio
  December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    €m   €m
 
Non-property SME and corporate
    270       137  
Property and construction
    887       168  
                 
Total impairment charge on Total loans
    1,157       305  
                 
 
The impairment charge on Total loans of €1,157 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 increased from €305 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase was largely attributable to the Property and construction portfolio and in particular the land and development element which is substantially expected to transfer to NAMA.
 
The impairment charge on the Non property SME and corporate portfolio was €270 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €137 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 which reflects the challenging conditions for certain mid-tier Irish corporate customers and some specific debt restructuring activity in the leveraged acquisition finance business.
 
The impairment charge on the Property and construction portfolio of €887 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €168 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The land and development element within the Property and construction portfolio is most significantly impacted by the sharp decline in the level of economic activity leading to falling asset values exacerbated by the over supply of residential and commercial property in Ireland.
 
An impairment charge on Available for sale financial assets of €2 million (€1 million each in Corporate Banking and Global Markets) was incurred in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, compared to a €76 million charge for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This charge of €76 million included €36 million on the receivership of Washington Mutual, €25 million on the nationalisation and subsequent receivership of some Icelandic banks together with a €15 million charge relating to a leveraged exposure to a fund of rated financial institution debt securities.
 
During the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, the Group disposed of its interest in Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC (Guggenheim) and Iridian Asset Management LLC (Iridian) resulting in a net loss of €3 million.
 
The loss before tax of €749 million in Corporate Banking for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compares to a profit before tax of €247 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Even allowing for the shorter reporting period, this sharp deterioration in profit was due to a substantial increase in the impairment charge to €1,157 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €305 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Total operating income was lower by €195 million in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 driven by the shorter


101


Table of Contents

reporting period, the higher funding costs, recognition of impairment on investment properties (€10 million) and lower fee income due to lower levels of new business activity.
 
Global Markets profit before tax of €128 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compares to €246 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. Total income for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is lower by €207 million compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction is primarily due to the shorter reporting period, the higher cost of funding, gains in the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 as a result of good positioning in a falling interest rate environment and lower levels of third party customer business in the current reporting period as a result of the reduced level of economic activity. An impairment charge of €1 million has been incurred in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, compared to €63 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 due primarily to the impairment charges incurred in the prior period on the receivership of Washington Mutual and on the nationalisation and subsequent receivership of some Icelandic banks.
 
The profit before tax of €20 million in Asset Management Services for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to a loss before tax of €326 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 included a charge of €304 million relating to the impairment of goodwill and intangible assets, together with a loss of €32 million associated with the collapse of Lehmans in September 2008. Bank of Ireland Asset Management and Bank of Ireland Securities Services reported lower levels of income in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 due to the shorter reporting period, lower assets under management and lower fee income. Iridian and Guggenheim, the US asset management businesses, were disposed of during the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 resulting in a net loss of €3 million.
 
Division Centre includes central management costs and IBI Corporate Finance.
 
Resources and Advances
 
Capital Markets customer deposits at December 31, 2009 were €29 billion, broadly in line with that reported at March 31, 2009 in an intensely competitive environment for deposits in Ireland and internationally.
 
In January 2010, the Group’s long term and short term credit ratings were downgraded by Standard & Poors to A- / A-2 with a stable outlook. This downgrade has led to an outflow of some ratings sensitive international deposits.
 
Loans and advances to customers, before impairment provisions, were €28 billion at December 31, 2009 as compared to €29 billion at March 31, 2009, a reduction of 6% (a decline of 10% net of impairment provisions) reflecting lower lending demand due to reduced levels of economic activity.
 
Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
Capital Markets’ profit before tax of €161 million for the year ended March 31, 2009, reduced by 75% over the comparable prior period. The Divisional performance for the year ended March 31, 2009 is not directly comparable with the year ended March 31, 2008 as the year ended March 31, 2009 included a charge for goodwill impairment of €304 million, relating to an impairment review of all goodwill and other intangible assets on the Group balance sheet. The carrying value of the US based asset management businesses, Guggenheim and Iridian, were severely impacted by the downturn in the global asset management sector, falling assets under management and client redemptions. As a result the Group has recorded an impairment charge of €304 million in the year ended March 31, 2009.
 
In addition, costs associated with the downsizing initiatives of €9 million are included in the current year numbers to March 31, 2009.
 
Net interest income grew by 44% while ‘other income’ fell by 363%. However the year on year percentages for net interest income and ‘other income’ are impacted by IFRS income classifications between net interest income and ‘other income’. Excluding the impact of both of these income classifications, net interest income increased by 34% and ‘other income’ fell by 29%.


102


Table of Contents

Operating income at €1,245 million for the year ended March 31, 2009 is 11% higher than the prior year due to strong net interest income growth in Corporate Banking coupled with a strong performance in Global Markets. This growth is partly offset by lower ‘other income’ particularly in the Asset Management Services business. The focus on cost management resulted in costs (before impairment of goodwill and other intangibles and costs related to the downsizing initiatives) of €377 million in the year ended March 31, 2009 which were 10% lower than the comparable prior period, mainly driven by a scale back in operations in asset management activities, tighter discretionary spend and lower variable compensation. The divisional cost/income ratio is 56% compared to 37% for the prior period.
 
Asset quality deteriorated with an impairment charge on loans and advances to customers for the year ended March 31, 2009, of €305 million (108bps) up from €48 million (19bps) for the year ended March 31, 2008. Of the increased impairment charge over the prior period, over 60% relates to some specific provisions together with grade degradation in the property lending portfolio.
 
In addition, within the AFS financial assets portfolio, an impairment charge of €76 million was incurred in the year ended March 31, 2009, including €36 million on the receivership of Washington Mutual and €25 million on the nationalisation and subsequent receivership of some Icelandic banks.
 
Corporate Banking delivered €565 million in operating profit before impairment charge in the year ended March 31, 2009, compared to €428 million in the prior year. This is driven by strong interest income growth of 30% reflecting volume growth and higher margins. Excluding costs associated with the downsizing initiatives, other operating expenses are 7% lower year on year, due to lower variable compensation and lower discretionary spend. Corporate Banking’s profit before tax is €247 million for the year ended March 31, 2009, compared to €375 million in the prior year. The impairment charge, year on year, has increased from €48 million to €305 million in the year ended March 31, 2009, reflecting the current challenging economic conditions relative to the benign credit experience of the prior year. Over 60% of the increase relates to property, with the balance spread across the remaining portfolios
 
Global Markets, which delivers a comprehensive range of risk management products to the Group and its customer base, delivered operating profits before impairment charges of €309 million in the year ended March 31, 2009, which represents a 40% increase on the prior year. This profit growth was driven by growth in third party customer business, together with good positioning in a falling interest rate environment. Profit before tax after impairments of €246 million in the year to March 31, 2009, compares to €221 million in the prior year. The impairment charge of €63 million primarily relates to Washington Mutual (€36 million) and Icelandic banks (€25 million).
 
Asset Management Services reported a loss before tax of €326 million in the year ended March 31, 2009, compared to a profit of €66 million in the comparable prior period. The loss for the year to March 31, 2009, includes an impairment of goodwill and other intangibles assets charge of €304 million and costs related to the downsizing initiatives of €8 million. Lower income was due to reduced assets under management caused by weakness in global investment markets and some mandate losses, together with losses of €32 million associated with the collapse of Lehmans in September 2008.
 
Resources and Advances
 
Lending growth of 10% for the year ended March 31, 2009, reflects strong volume growth in the 6 months to September 30, 2008 whilst volumes at March 31, 2009, are broadly in line with the September 30, 2008 level. The first half volume growth resulted from the very strong pipeline developed in the second half of the prior financial year. Slowdown in new lending activity in the 6 months to March 31, 2009, reflects a selective approach to new business lending together with the impact of slower economic growth.
 
Through the Group’s treasury offices in Dublin, London, Belfast and Bristol together with branches in Paris, Frankfurt and the US a significant pool of high quality corporate and institutional deposits was accessed, many arising from the Group’s broader lending and treasury management relationships. Notwithstanding this distribution capability, deposits were down 10% year on year. Following the introduction of the Irish Government Guarantee, higher than usual deposit flows were experienced in the quarter to December 31, 2008. These inflows were


103


Table of Contents

unwound in January and February 2009 as a result of negative sentiment towards Ireland following rating agency actions and the nationalisation of Anglo Irish Bank.
 
Group Centre
 
Group Centre comprises capital management activities and unallocated support costs.
 
                         
        * Restated
  * Restated
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
  12 months ended
Group Centre Income Statement
  December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008**
    €m   €m   €m
 
Net interest income/(expenses)
    123       (8 )     (3 )
Net other income
    938       100       140  
                         
Operating profit
    1,061       92       137  
Operating expenses
    (85 )     (154 )     (118 )
                         
Profit/(loss) before tax
    976       (62 )     19  
                         
 
 
The prior years have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
**  Divisional PBT performance of UK Financial Services (UKFS) and Group Centre are restated to reflect the corporate restructuring of Bristol & West plc undertaken to obtain the optimum capital and funding treatment for the Group under Basel II. For the year ended March 31, 2008, this restatement reduces the UKFS PBT to £330 million from £353 million and changes Group Centre’s loss of €13 million to a profit of €19 million.
 
Nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009
 
Group Centre reported a profit before tax of €976 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, compared to a loss before tax of €62 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The increase was principally due to a gain of €1,037 million on the repurchase of tier 1 debt securities.
 
Net interest income of €123 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 includes the interest earned on cash received as consideration for the issuance of €3.5 billion of preference stock on March 31, 2009 and reflects lower funding costs following the repurchase of tier 1 debt securities in June 2009. It also includes the impact of a reduction of €58 million in interest expense in relation to the restriction imposed by the EU Commission on the Group’s ability to make coupon payments on certain subordinated liabilities unless under a binding legal obligation to do so (interest expense on subordinated liabilities is recognised using the effective interest rate method (EIR)).
 
Net other income for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 includes the gain of €1,037 million on the repurchase of tier 1 debt securities completed in June 2009. It also includes the impact of the cost of the Government liability guarantee of €105 million. This is an increase of €39 million as the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 included a charge of €66 million for the six month period from September 29, 2008 compared to the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 which includes the charge for nine months. An increase of €9 million in net other income arises from the impact of the restriction imposed by the EU Commission on the Group’s ability to make coupon payments on certain subordinated liabilities as described above.
 
In addition, the movement in net other income includes a movement of €70 million arising from the change in credit spreads on the Group’s issued notes and subordinated debt designated at ‘fair value through profit or loss’. This is a partial reversal of gains recognised in prior periods.
 
Operating expenses of €85 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compares to €154 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This reduction is due principally to the shorter reporting period and lower staff and other costs partly offset by higher costs in relation to the NAMA Scheme. The twelve month period ended March 31, 2009 included accelerated software depreciation and the restatement of €16 million under IFRS 2 for share based payments.


104


Table of Contents

Financial year ended March 31, 2009 compared to financial year ended March 31, 2008
 
Group Centre, which comprises earnings on surplus capital, unallocated support costs and some smaller business units, had a net loss of €62 million in the year ended March 31, 2009, compared to a profit of €19 million in the year ended March 31, 2008. The key drivers behind the net loss were costs related to the Government guarantee (€66 million), higher funding costs, and accelerated software depreciation partly offset by the gain associated with the impact of the widening credit spread on the element of the banks own issued debt which is carried at fair value.
 
Year on year comparison is directly affected by the following items:
 
Derecognition on consolidation of investment return on treasury shares held by BoI Life for policyholders (2009: €131 million credit, 2008: €189 million credit), hedge ineffectiveness on transition to IFRS (2009: €7 million charge, 2008: €6 million charge), and costs associated with downsizing initiatives (2009: €4 million charge, 2008: €17 million charge).
 
Adjusted for these items, the net loss for Group Centre increased by €22 million to €163 million in the year to March 31, 2009.


105


Table of Contents

 
AVERAGE BALANCE SHEET AND INTEREST RATES
 
The following tables show the average balances and interest rates of interest earning assets and interest bearing liabilities for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and each of the two years ended March 31, 2009 and March 31, 2008. The calculations of average balances are based on daily, weekly or monthly averages, depending on the reporting unit. The average balances used are considered to be representative of the operations of the Group. The explanation of the underlying business trends in the Group’s net interest margin, after adjusting for the impact of IFRS income classifications is explained on page 74. Rates for the 9 month period are annualised.
 
                                                                         
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
    Average
          Average
          Average
       
    Balance   Interest   Rate   Balance   Interest   Rate   Balance   Interest   Rate
    (in € millions)   %   (in € millions)   %   (in € millions)   %
 
ASSETS                                                                        
Loans and advances to banks
                                                                       
Domestic offices
    5,619       39       0.9       5,912       201       3.4       5,936       230       3.9  
Foreign offices
    3,284       9       0.4       1,399       45       3.2       1,360       93       6.8  
Loans and advances to customers(1)
                                                                       
Domestic offices
    78,956       2,293       3.9       78,251       4,681       6.0       75,090       4,668       6.2  
Foreign offices
    59,440       1,349       3.0       62,654       3,452       5.5       59,179       3,796       6.4  
Central government and other eligible bills
                                                                       
Domestic offices
                                        10             3.9  
Foreign offices
                                                     
Available for sale financial assets
                                                                       
Domestic offices
    23,037       490       2.8       27,748       1,307       4.7       32,932       1,579       4.8  
Foreign offices
    919       8       1.2       899       28       3.1       424       25       5.9  
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
                                                                       
Domestic offices
    53                   235                   24              
Foreign offices
    202                   81                   228              
Other
                            3                   6        
                                                                         
Total interest-earning assets
    171,510       4,188       3.3       177,179       9,717       5.5       175,183       10,397       5.9  
                                                                         
Domestic offices
    107,665       2,822       3.5       112,146       6,189       5.5       113,992       6,477       5.7  
Foreign offices
    63,845       1,366       2.9       65,033       3,528       5.4       61,191       3,914       6.4  
Other
                                              6        
                                                                         
      171,510       4,188       3.3       177,179       9,717       5.5       175,183       10,397       5.9  
Allowance for impairment losses
    (3,103 )                 (936 )                 (498 )            
Non interest earning assets
    20,398                   25,389                   24,726              
                                                                         
Total assets
    188,805       4,188       3.0       201,632       9,717       4.8       199,411       10,397       5.2  
                                                                         
Percentage of assets applicable to foreign activities
    31.4%                       31.8%                       30.6%                  


106


Table of Contents

AVERAGE BALANCE SHEET AND INTEREST RATES (continued)
 
                                                                         
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
    Average
          Average
          Average
       
    Balance   Interest   Rate   Balance   Interest   Rate   Balance   Interest   Rate
    (in € millions)   %   (in € millions)   %   (in € millions)   %
 
LIABILITIES AND STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY                                                                        
Deposits from banks
                                                                       
Domestic offices
    24,531       192       1.0       16,111       521       3.2       7,995       263       3.3  
Foreign offices
    1,803       6       0.4       989       33       3.3       10,761       577       5.4  
Customer accounts
                                                                       
Domestic offices
    42,297       372       1.2       42,254       1,221       2.9       33,601       1,229       3.7  
Foreign offices
    31,166       623       2.7       35,686       1,552       4.3       30,287       1,579       5.2  
Debt securities in issue
                                                                       
Domestic offices
    31,444       568       2.4       41,029       1,625       4.0       49,627       2,351       4.7  
Foreign offices
    9,116       86       1.3       16,567       672       4.1       11,586       697       6.0  
Subordinated liabilities
                                                                       
Domestic offices
    3,146       97       4.2       4,665       196       4.2       4,472       226       5.1  
Foreign offices
    3,373       65       2.6       3,424       227       6.6       3,515       229       6.5  
Other
                                              (17 )      
                                                                         
Total interest bearing liabilities
    146,876       2,009       1.8       160,725       6,047       3.8       151,844       7,134       4.7  
                                                                         
Domestic offices
    101,418       1,229       1.6       104,059       3,563       3.4       95,695       4,069       4.3  
Foreign offices
    45,458       780       2.3       56,666       2,484       4.4       56,149       3,082       5.5  
Other
                                              (17 )      
                                                                         
      146,876       2,009       1.8       160,725       6,047       3.8       151,844       7,134       4.7  
                                                                         
Current accounts
    9,332                   10,137                   12,533              
Other non interest bearing liabilities
    24,855                   24,772                   28,084              
Stockholders’ equity
    7,742                   5,998                   6,950              
                                                                         
Total liabilities and stockholders’ equity
    188,805       2,009       1.4       201,632       6,047       3.0       199,411       7,134       3.6  
                                                                         
Percentage of liabilities applicable to foreign activities
    26.0%                       31.1%                       28.2%                  
 
Certain lines above have been adjusted to correct for inter-jurisdictional funding items that arise through normal business activities, to give a more meaningful picture of the Group’s domestic and foreign activities.
 
The balance sheets of the life assurance companies have been consolidated and are reflected under ‘non interest earning assets’ and ‘other non interest bearing liabilities’.

107


Table of Contents

Change in Net Interest Income — Volume and Rate Analysis
 
The following table allocates changes in net interest income between volume and rate for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 compared to the year ended March 31, 2009 and the year ended March 31, 2008 compared to the year ended March 31, 2008. Volume and rate variances have been calculated based on movements in average balances over the period and changes in average interest-earning assets and average interest-bearing liabilities. Changes due to a combination of volume and rate are allocated rateably to volume and rate.
 
                                                 
    9 months ended
  Year ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    Increase/(Decrease) due to change in
    Average
  Average
  Net
  Average
  Average
  Net
    Volume   Rate   Change   Volume   Rate   Change
    (in € millions)
 
INTEREST EARNING ASSETS
                                               
Loans to and advances to banks
                                               
Domestic offices
    (9 )     (153 )     (162 )     (1 )     (28 )     (29 )
Foreign offices
    28       (64 )     (36 )     3       (51 )     (48 )
Loans and advances to customers
                                               
Domestic offices
    42       (2,430 )     (2,388 )     193       (180 )     13  
Foreign offices
    (169 )     (1,934 )     (2,103 )     214       (558 )     (344 )
Available for sale financial assets
                                               
Domestic offices
    (193 )     (624 )     (817 )     (245 )     (27 )     (272 )
Foreign offices
    1       (21 )     (20 )     19       (16 )     3  
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
                                               
Domestic offices
                                   
Foreign offices
                                   
Other
          (3 )     (3 )           (3 )     (3 )
                                                 
Total interest income
    (300 )     (5,229 )     (5,529 )     183       (863 )     (680 )
                                                 
INTEREST BEARING LIABILITIES
                                               
Deposits from banks
                                               
Domestic offices
    188       (517 )     (329 )     263       (5 )     258  
Foreign offices
    16       (43 )     (27 )     (384 )     (160 )     (544 )
Customer accounts
                                               
Domestic offices
    1       (850 )     (849 )     280       (288 )     (8 )
Foreign offices
    (176 )     (753 )     (929 )     257       (284 )     (27 )
Debt securities in issue
                                               
Domestic offices
    (318 )     (739 )     (1,057 )     (373 )     (353 )     (726 )
Foreign offices
    (216 )     (370 )     (586 )     244       (269 )     (25 )
Subordinated liabilities
                                               
Domestic offices
    (55 )     (44 )     (99 )     9       (39 )     (30 )
Foreign offices
    (3 )     (159 )     (162 )     (6 )     4       (2 )
Other
                            17       17  
                                                 
Total interest expense
    (563 )     (3,475 )     (4,038 )     290       (1,377 )     (1,087 )
                                                 
Total change in net interest income
    263       (1,754 )     (1,491 )     (107 )     514       407  
                                                 


108


Table of Contents

 
DESCRIPTION OF ASSETS AND LIABILITIES
 
The following sections provide information relating to the assets and liabilities of the Bank of Ireland Group.
 
Assets
 
Loan Portfolio
 
At December 31 2009, the Group considered that the estimated Eligible Bank Assets, that is, land and development loans and certain associated loans which were expected to be transferred to NAMA, met the criteria for classification as assets held for sale. Thus, the relevant loans and advances to customers, derivatives and accrued interest have been reclassified to assets held for sale as at December 31, 2009. The assets classified as assets held for sale to NAMA continue to be measured on the same basis as prior to their classification as assets held for sale. In particular, loans and advances to customers continue to be measured at amortised cost less any incurred impairment losses. In accordance with accounting standards, de-recognition of these assets held for sale will occur when substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership have been transferred to NAMA. This will only occur on a phased basis as ownership of each tranche is legally transferred to NAMA. Further information is outlined in the Supervision and Regulation section on pages 47 to 51.
 
Loan Composition — Loans and advances to customers & loans held for sale to NAMA (Total loans)
 
The tables and analysis below summarise the Group’s Total loans over the following categories: ‘neither past due nor impaired’, ‘past due but not impaired’ and ‘impaired’. Exposures are based on the gross amount before provisions for impairment.
 
                                         
        Non-
           
        Property
  Property
       
    Residential
  SME and
  and
       
December 31, 2009
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Loans and advances to customers
                                       
Financial assets neither past due nor impaired
    56,600       30,821       19,390       3,661       110,472  
Financial assets past due but not impaired
    3,331       625       968       253       5,177  
Impaired financial assets
    471       2,694       3,196       426       6,787  
                                         
Total
    60,402       34,140       23,554       4,340       122,436  
                                         
 
                                         
        Non-
           
        Property
  Property
       
    Residential
  SME and
  and
       
December 31, 2009
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Loans held for sale to NAMA
                                       
Financial assets neither past due nor impaired
    30       97       5,289             5,416  
Financial assets past due but not impaired
    38       2       215             255  
Impaired financial assets
          112       6,452             6,564  
                                         
Total
    68       211       11,956             12,235  
                                         
 
                                         
        Non-
           
        Property
  Property
       
    Residential
  SME and
  and
       
December 31, 2009
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Total loans
                                       
Financial assets neither past due nor impaired
    56,630       30,918       24,679       3,661       115,888  
Financial assets past due but not impaired
    3,369       627       1,183       253       5,432  
Impaired financial assets
    471       2,806       9,648       426       13,351  
                                         
Total
    60,470       34,351       35,510       4,340       134,671  
                                         
 


109


Table of Contents

                                         
        Non-
           
        Property
  Property
       
    Residential
  SME and
  and
       
March 31, 2009
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Total loans
                                       
Financial assets neither past due nor impaired
    55,877       35,081       28,525       4,955       124,438  
Financial assets past due but not impaired
    2,782       773       1,892       314       5,761  
Impaired financial assets
    229       1,187       3,538       368       5,322  
                                         
Total
    58,888       37,041       33,955       5,637       135,521  
                                         
 
The Bank of Ireland Group’s loan portfolio comprises of loans to customers (including overdrafts) and instalment credit and finance lease receivables.
 
The Group provides mortgage loans for house purchases as well as home improvement loans and secured personal loans to existing mortgage customers. The Group has a wide range of home mortgage loan products including amortising, interest only and endowment loans. Interest on mortgage loans is typically at a floating rate but the Group also makes some fixed rate loans.
 
The Group’s residential mortgage portfolio at December 31, 2009 is widely diversified by individual borrower and amounts to 45% (March 31, 2009: 44%) of loans and advances to customers (pre impairment provisions).
 
The Group loan book comprises exposure of 27% or €36 billion (March 31, 2009: 25% / €34 billion) to property and construction lending. The Group’s businesses and other services portfolio is diversifed between Ireland 77% (March 31, 2009: 64%) and UK and other 23% (March 31, 2009: 36%).
 
With the exception of residential mortgages, property and construction and business and other services, the Group’s exposure to credit risk from its lending activities in any individual sector or industry does not exceed 10% of loans and advances to customers.

110


Table of Contents

Total loans and advances to customers
 
The following tables set forth the Bank of Ireland Group’s total loans and advances to customers at December 31, 2009 and March 31 for each of the four years ended March 31, 2009, using data prepared in accordance with IFRS.
 
Where necessary, comparative figures have been adjusted to conform to changes in presentation in the current year.
 
                                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
  2008
  2007
  2006
    IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS
 
Ireland
                                       
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    28,196       27,647       26,696       24,634       19,827  
— other lending
    2,906       3,406       6,589       6,146       5,212  
Property and construction
    19,472       19,358       20,313       16,305       10,726  
Business and other services
    11,983       10,782       9,032       6,284       6,043  
Manufacturing
    4,511       6,049       5,727       5,446       4,749  
Distribution
    4,463       3,343       3,726       3,305       2,979  
Transport
    778       935       1,860       1,829       1,168  
Financial
    1,088       1,919       1,720       2,381       1,675  
Agriculture
    1,726       1,954       1,379       1,300       1,160  
Energy
    1,438       2,555       1,131       889       485  
                                         
Total Ireland
    76,561       77,948       78,173       68,519       54,024  
                                         
United Kingdom & Other
                                       
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    32,274       31,241       34,065       35,055       31,171  
— other lending
    1,434       2,231       2,820       2,808       2,352  
Property and construction
    16,038       14,597       15,283       13,390       9,652  
Business and other services
    3,627       6,032       3,016       2,956       2,269  
Manufacturing
    1,744       1,740       1,362       1,229       943  
Distribution
    525       795       572       520       295  
Transport
    618       319       379       319       292  
Financial
    1,354       349       439       492       490  
Agriculture
    388       57       113       105       69  
Energy
    108       212       112       83       48  
                                         
Total United Kingdom & Other
    58,110       57,573       58,161       56,957       47,581  
                                         
Gross loans and advances to customers
    134,671       135,521       136,334       125,476       101,605  
Allowance for loan losses
    (5,775 )     (1,781 )     (596 )     (428 )     (359 )
                                         
Total including loans held for sale to NAMA
    128,896       133,740       135,738       125,048       101,246  
                                         


111


Table of Contents

Total loans to customers (%)
 
The following table sets forth the percentage of total loans to customers represented by each category of loan at December 31, 2009 and March 31 for each of the four years ended March 31, 2009, using data prepared in accordance with IFRS.
 
                                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
  2008
  2007
  2006
    IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS
 
Ireland
                                       
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    20.9%       20.4%       19.6%       19.6%       19.5%  
— other lending
    2.2%       2.5%       4.8%       4.9%       5.1%  
Property and construction
    14.5%       14.3%       14.9%       13.0%       10.6%  
Business and other services
    8.9%       8.0%       6.6%       5.0%       5.9%  
Manufacturing
    3.3%       4.5%       4.2%       4.3%       4.7%  
Distribution
    3.3%       2.5%       2.7%       2.6%       2.9%  
Transport
    0.6%       0.7%       1.4%       1.5%       1.1%  
Financial
    0.8%       1.4%       1.3%       1.9%       1.6%  
Agriculture
    1.3%       1.4%       1.0%       1.0%       1.1%  
Energy
    1.1%       1.8%       0.8%       0.7%       0.5%  
                                         
Total Ireland
    56.9%       57.5%       57.3%       54.6%       53.2%  
                                         
United Kingdom & Other
                                       
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    24.0%       23.1%       25.0%       27.9%       30.7%  
— other lending
    1.1%       1.6%       2.1%       2.2%       2.3%  
Property and construction
    11.9%       10.8%       11.2%       10.7%       9.5%  
Business and other services
    2.7%       4.5%       2.2%       2.4%       2.2%  
Manufacturing
    1.3%       1.2%       1.0%       1.0%       0.9%  
Distribution
    0.4%       0.6%       0.4%       0.4%       0.3%  
Transport
    0.5%       0.2%       0.3%       0.3%       0.3%  
Financial
    1.0%       0.3%       0.3%       0.4%       0.5%  
Agriculture
    0.3%       0.0%       0.1%       0.1%       0.1%  
Energy
    0.1%       0.2%       0.1%       0.1%       0.0%  
                                         
Total United Kingdom & Other
    43.1%       42.5%       42.7%       45.4%       46.8%  
                                         
Group total loan portfolio
    100.0%       100.0%       100.0%       100.0%       100.0%  
                                         


112


Table of Contents

Analysis of Loans to Customers by Maturity and Interest Rate Sensitivity
 
The following tables analyse loans by maturity and interest rate sensitivity. Overdrafts, which represent a significant proportion of the portfolio, are classified as repayable within one year. Approximately 15% of the Bank of Ireland Group’s loan portfolio at December 31, 2009 was provided on a fixed rate basis. Fixed-rate loans are defined as those loans for which the interest rate is fixed for the full life of the loan. Variable-rate loans include some loans for which the interest rate is fixed for an initial period (e.g., some residential mortgages) but not for the full life of the loan. The interest rate exposure is managed by Global Markets within agreed policy parameters. See Item 11 “Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures about Market Risk”.
 
                                 
    As at December 31, 2009
        After 1 year
       
    Within
  but within
  After 5
   
    1 year   5 years   years   Total
    (in € millions)
 
Ireland
    15,330       21,114       40,117       76,561  
United Kingdom & Other
    11,943       18,586       27,581       58,110  
                                 
Total loans by maturity
    27,273       39,700       67,698       134,671  
                                 
                                 
Fixed rate
    8,790       7,406       4,371       20,567  
Variable rate
    18,483       32,294       63,327       114,104  
                                 
Total loans by maturity
    27,273       39,700       67,698       134,671  
                                 


113


Table of Contents

The following table sets forth an analysis of loans by maturity within each classification as at December 31, 2009.
 
                                 
    As at December 31, 2009
        After 1 year
       
    Within
  but within
  After 5
   
    1 year   5 years   years   Total
    (in € millions)
 
Ireland
                               
Personal
                               
— residential mortgages
    977       4,053       23,166       28,196  
— other lending
    1,590       808       508       2,906  
Property and construction
    7,856       5,325       6,291       19,472  
Business and other services
    2,415       4,545       5,023       11,983  
Manufacturing
    546       2,703       1,262       4,511  
Distribution
    914       1,895       1,654       4,463  
Transport
    68       90       620       778  
Financial
    347       655       86       1,088  
Agriculture
    488       581       657       1,726  
Energy
    129       459       850       1,438  
                                 
Total Ireland
    15,330       21,114       40,117       76,561  
                                 
United Kingdom & Other
                               
Personal
                               
— residential mortgages
    2,140       7,912       22,222       32,274  
— other lending
    846       587       1       1,434  
Property and construction
    6,880       6,104       3,054       16,038  
Business and other services
    1,118       1,170       1,339       3,627  
Manufacturing
    525       1,032       187       1,744  
Distribution
    116       332       77       525  
Transport
    51       528       39       618  
Financial
    74       637       643       1,354  
Agriculture
    150       224       14       388  
Energy
    43       60       5       108  
                                 
Total UK & Other
    11,943       18,586       27,581       58,110  
                                 
Group total loan portfolio
    27,273       39,700       67,698       134,671  
                                 
 
Movement in the Allowance for Loan Losses
 
Loan Loss Provisioning Methodology
 
Through its ongoing credit review processes, the Group seeks to identify deteriorating loans early with a view to taking corrective action to prevent the loan becoming impaired. Typically, loans that are at risk of impairment are managed by dedicated specialist units/debt collection teams focused on “working out” loans.
 
The identification of loans for assessment as impaired is driven by the Group’s credit risk rating systems. It is the Group’s policy to provide for impairment promptly and consistently across the loan book. For those loans that become impaired, the focus is to minimise the loss that the Group will incur from the impairment. This may involve entering into restructuring arrangements or action to enforce security or legal pursuit of individuals who are personally liable for the loan.
 
All credit exposures, either individually or collectively, are regularly reviewed for objective evidence of impairment; where such evidence of impairment exists, the exposure is measured for an impairment provision. The criteria used to determine that there is objective evidence of impairment include:


114


Table of Contents

•  delinquency in contractual payments of principal or interest;
 
•  cash flow difficulties;
 
•  breach of loan covenants or conditions;
 
•  deterioration of the borrower’s competitive position;
 
•  deterioration in the value of collateral;
 
•  external rating downgrade below an acceptable level; and
 
•  initiation of bankruptcy proceedings.
 
Where objective evidence of impairment exists, as a result of one or more past events, the Group is required to estimate the recoverable amount of the exposure or group of exposures.
 
For financial reporting purposes, loans on the Balance Sheet that become impaired are written down to their estimated recoverable amount. The amount of this write down is taken as an impairment charge to the income statement.
 
The Group’s impairment provisioning methodologies are compliant with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). International Accounting Standard (IAS) 39 requires that there is objective evidence of impairment and that the loss has been incurred. The standard does not permit the recognition of expected losses, no matter how likely these expected losses may appear.
 
All exposures are assessed for impairment either individually or collectively.
 
Methodology for Individually Assessing Impairment
 
An individual impairment assessment is performed for any exposure for which there is objective evidence of impairment, and where the exposure is above an agreed minimum threshold. The carrying amount of the exposure net of the estimated recoverable amount (and thus the specific provision required) is calculated using a discounted cashflow analysis. This calculates the estimated recoverable amount as the present value of the estimated future cash flows, discounted at the exposure’s original effective interest rate (or the current effective interest rate for variable rate exposures). The estimated future cashflows include forecasted principal and interest payments (not necessarily contractual amounts due) including cash flows, if any, from the realisation of collateral/security held, less realisation costs.
 
In the context of the Group’s impaired land and development property assets, where recovery and/or repayment is likely to be generated from asset sales and/or realisation of the property collateral, estimated cashflows are based on valuations from one or more different methods, in light of the restricted market liquidity that currently exists. These valuation methods include valuations from independent external professionals, estimates based on verbal consultations with external valuers, local market knowledge provided by relevant bank management, and residual value methodologies. The appropriate methodological application depends on the particular circumstances of the loan and underlying collateral, e.g. the degree of liquidity and recent transactional evidence in the relevant market segment, the type, size and location of the property asset and its development potential and marketability.
 
Given the absence of sufficient transactional evidence and market liquidity, up to date, independent and professional valuations in writing are sought in certain circumstances. Whilst less formal than written valuations, verbal consultations with external valuers can help benchmark asset values and provide general information on market developments and trends. The application of local market knowledge occurs typically where the loan and underlying property asset are relatively small and relevant bank management has in-depth knowledge of both the property asset and local market conditions, which may be illiquid. In such cases, estimated valuations of undeveloped sites may be expressed on a ‘per plot’ basis if there is suitable zoning/planning in place, whereas unzoned rural land may be assumed to have only agricultural value. Residual value methodologies are used to estimate the current value of a site or part-completed development based on a detailed appraisal that assesses the costs (building, funding and other costs) and receipts (forecast sales and/or lettings) associated with bringing a


115


Table of Contents

Methodology for Individually Assessing Impairment (continued)
 
development to completion. This valuation methodology may be applied when a property asset is considered to have realistic development potential given current or anticipated planning status, projected marketability etc.
 
After applying one or more of the above methodologies, the resulting valuations show a wide range of discounts (typically between 40% and 90%) to estimated peak market values for the underlying property collateral assets. Key influencing factors as to the level of discount include the type of property asset (with undeveloped land incurring a relatively high discount), the status of zoning and planning, and the location in terms of both jurisdiction/region and proximate environment, e.g. whether city centre, suburban, provincial town or rural.
 
Methodology for Collectively Assessing Impairment
 
Where exposures fall below the threshold for individual assessment of impairment, such exposures with similar credit risk characteristics (e.g. portfolio of consumer personal loans) are pooled and are collectively assessed for impairment. A provision is then calculated by estimating the future cash flows of a group of exposures that are collectively evaluated for impairment. This estimation considers the expected contractual cash flows of the exposures in a portfolio and the historical loss experience for exposures with credit risk characteristics similar to those in the portfolio being assessed. Assumptions and parameters used to create the portfolio provision, which are based on historical experience (i.e. amount and timing of cashflows/loss given default), are regularly compared against current experience in the loan book and current market conditions.
 
Where there is objective evidence of impairment on a collective basis, this is reported as a specific provision in line with individually assessed loans.
 
Methodology for establishing Incurred but not reported (IBNR) provisions
 
Impairment provisions are also recognised for losses not specifically identified but which, experience and observable data indicate, are present in the portfolio at the date of assessment. These are described as incurred but not reported provisions. Statistical models are used to determine the appropriate level of IBNR provisions. These models estimate latent losses taking into account three observed and/or estimated factors:
 
•  loss emergence rates (based on historic grade migration experience or probability of default),
 
•  the emergence period (historic experience, adjusted to reflect the current conditions and the credit management model),
 
•  loss given default rates (loss and recovery rates using historical loan loss experience, adjusted where appropriate to reflect current observable data).
 
Account performance is reviewed periodically to confirm that the credit grade or probability of default assigned remains appropriate and to determine if impairment has arisen. For consumer and smaller ticket commercial exposures, the review is largely based on account behaviour and is highly automated. Where there are loan arrears, excesses, dormancy, etc. the account is downgraded to reflect the higher underlying risk. For larger commercial loans, the relationship manager re-assesses the risk at least annually (more frequently if circumstances or grade require) and re-affirms or amends the grade (credit and Probability of Default (“PD”) grade) in light of new information or changes (e.g. up to date financials or changed market outlook). Grade migration and adjusted PD grades are analysed for inclusion in the loss model. Recent data sets are used in order to capture current trends, rather than averaging over a period which might include earlier and less stressed points in the credit cycle.
 
Emergence period is calculated using historical loan loss experience, adjusted to reflect the more intensive credit management model in place, where all vulnerable portfolios are reviewed on a shortened cycle. The range of emergence periods is typically three to nine months.
 
Loss given default is calculated using historical loan loss experience, adjusted where appropriate to apply management’s credit expertise to reflect current observable data (including assessment of the deterioration in the property sector, discounted collateral values, rising unemployment and reduced repayment prospects, etc).
 
An analysis of the Group’s impairment provisions at December 31, 2009 is set out on page F-72.


116


Table of Contents

Methodology for establishing Incurred but not reported (IBNR) provisions (continued)
 
Other factors taken into consideration in estimating provisions include local and international economic climates, changes in credit management processes and policies, changes in portfolio risk profile and the effect of any external factors such as legal or competition requirements.
 
Whilst provisioning is an ongoing process, all business units formally review and confirm the appropriateness of their provisioning methodologies and the adequacy of their impairment provisions on a half yearly basis. Their conclusions are reviewed by the Credit and Market Risk function and the GRPC.
 
The Group’s provisioning methodology is approved by the GRPC on a half yearly basis. The quantum of the Group’s loan loss charge, impaired loans balances and provisions is also reviewed by the GRPC semi annually, in advance of providing a recommendation to the Group Audit Committee.
 
Impaired loans increased from €5,322 million at March 31, 2009 to €13,351 million at December 31, 2009, or from 393bps to 991bps of total loans. The increase in impaired loans reflects the rapid slowdown in the property and construction sectors both in Ireland and the UK together with a deterioration in general economic conditions and weaker consumer sentiment.
 
Total balance sheet provisions against loans and advances to customers were €5,775 million at December 31, 2009 compared to €1,781 million at March 31, 2009. Impairment provisions as a percentage of total loans were 429bps, the ratio being 59bps for the Group mortgage book and 730bps for non-mortgage lending.
 
Impairment provisions as a percentage of impaired loans (the coverage ratio) is 43% at December 31, 2009, which compares to 33% at March 31, 2009. This year on year reduction reflects a higher proportion of impaired collateralised loans at December 31, 2009 compared to March 31, 2009. These loans, due to their collateralised nature, require lower provisioning and impact the coverage ratio accordingly.


117


Table of Contents

Methodology for establishing Incurred but not reported (IBNR) provisions (continued)
 
The following table presents information regarding the movement in the allowance for loan losses for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and for each of the four years ended March 31, 2009 using data prepared in accordance with IFRS.
 
                                         
    9 months to
  Year ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
  2008
  2007
  2006
    IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS
    Impairment   Impairment   Impairment   Impairment   Impairment
    (in € millions)
 
Allowance at beginning of period
    1,781.0       596.1       428.1       359.0       318.7  
Total allowance
    1,781.0       596.1       428.1       359.0       318.7  
Exchange and other adjustments
    47.7       4.4       (29.1 )     (0.6 )     0.6  
Other Movements
    33.4       (18.5 )                  
Recovery of amounts previously charged off:
                                       
Ireland
    0.9       3.4       10.1       16.8       19.6  
United Kingdom
    2.3       4.9       3.2       2.2       1.7  
                                         
Total recovery of amounts previously charged off
    3.2       8.3       13.3       19.0       21.3  
                                         
Amounts charged off:
                                       
Ireland
    (54.9 )     (197.4 )     (30.0 )     (27.5 )     (71.9 )
United Kingdom
    (90.3 )     (47.3 )     (12.7 )     (25.2 )     (13.1 )
                                         
Total amounts charged off
    (145.2 )     (244.7 )     (42.7 )     (52.7 )     (85.0 )
                                         
Provision for impairment losses charged to income:
                                       
Ireland
    2,986.5       1,050.5       171.3       77.4       73.5  
United Kingdom
    1,068.4       384.9       55.2       26.0       29.9  
                                         
      4,054.9       1,435.4       226.5       103.4       103.4  
Impairment loss write back
                             
                               
                                         
Allowance at end of period
    5,775.0       1,781.0       596.1       428.1       359.0  
                                         
Total allowance
    5,775.0       1,781.0       596.1       428.1       359.0  
                                         
The total allowance at December 31, 2009 is split as follows:-
                                       
Loans and advances to customers
    2,997.0                          
Loans held for sale to NAMA
    2,778.0                          
                                         
Total allowance
    5,775.0                          
                                         


118


Table of Contents

Provisions and allowances for loan losses (%)
 
The following table presents additional information regarding provisions and allowances for loan losses for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and for each of the four years ended March 31, 2009 using data prepared in accordance with IFRS.
 
                                         
    9 months to
  Year ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
  2008
  2007
  2006
    IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS
    (in € millions, except percentages)
    %   %   %   %   %
 
Allowance at end of year as a percentage of total loans to customers at end of year:
                                       
Ireland
    5.61       1.69       0.64       0.50       0.53  
United Kingdom
    2.55       0.80       0.15       0.14       0.15  
                                         
Total
    4.29       1.31       0.44       0.34       0.35  
                                         
Specific
    3.42       0.90       0.32       0.23       0.23  
IBNR
    0.86       0.41       0.12       0.11       0.12  
                                         
Total
    4.29       1.31       0.44       0.34       0.35  
                                         
Allowance at end of year as a percentage of impaired loans at end of year(1)
                                       
Ireland
    42.17       31.84       63.72       63.56       61.65  
United Kingdom
    46.76       39.15       32.65       60.53       94.03  
                                         
Total
    43.26       33.45       56.16       62.97       66.12  
                                         
Average loans to customers(2)
    136,359       140,905       134,269       115,717       93,075  
                                         
Provisions charged to income as a percentage of average loans to customers:
                                       
Specific
    3.34       0.75       0.14       0.09       0.10  
IBNR
    0.57       0.27       0.03             0.01  
                                         
Total
    3.91       1.02       0.17       0.09       0.11  
                                         
Net loans charged off as a percentage of average loans to customers
    0.14       0.17       0.02       0.03       0.07  
 
 
(1)  Prior to the implementation of IFRS accruing loans which were contractually past due 90 days or more as to principal or interest payments and loans which were ‘troubled debt restructurings’ as defined in SFAS No. 15 ‘Accounting by Debtors and Creditors for Troubled Debt Restructuring’ were not included. The December 2009 calculation (43.26%) which is based on impaired loans does include non-home mortgage loans which are contractually past due 90 days or more as to principal or interest payments. The comparable figure for March 2009 is 33.45%.
 
(2)  Average loans include average interest earning and non-interest earning loans.


119


Table of Contents

 
Loans charged off
 
The following table provides information regarding loans charged off for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and for each of the four years ended March 31, 2009 using data prepared in accordance with IFRS.
 
                                         
    9 months to
  Year ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
  2008
  2007
  2006
    IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS
    (in € million)
 
Ireland
                                       
Agriculture
    0.1       2.1       0.9       1.3       2.0  
Energy
                             
Manufacturing
    0.4       2.8       2.4       1.5       1.2  
Property and construction
    0.7       0.8       2.4       0.9       1.8  
Distribution
    7.1       1.3       1.1       0.7       2.9  
Transport
                             
Financial
                             
Business and Other Services
    5.0       113.1       14.0       6.6       20.7  
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
          0.1       0.1              
— other lending
    41.6       77.2       9.1       16.5       43.3  
                                         
      54.9       197.4       30.0       27.5       71.9  
                                         
United Kingdom
                                       
Agriculture
          0.1       0.1             0.1  
Manufacturing
    0.3       3.3       0.5       1.0       0.4  
Property and construction
          14.3       1.0       0.3       0.2  
Distribution
    6.5       2.7       0.2       0.2       0.4  
Transport
                             
Financial
                             
Business and Other Services
    19.6       8.5       1.1       8.9       0.6  
Commercial mortgages
                            0.4  
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    29.4       9.6       2.9       2.2        
— other lending
    34.5       8.8       6.9       12.6       11.0  
                                         
      90.3       47.3       12.7       25.2       13.1  
                                         
Group total
    145.2       244.7       42.7       52.7       85.0  
                                         


120


Table of Contents

Recoveries of loans previously charged off
 
The following table presents an analysis of the Group’s recoveries of loans previously charged off for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and for each of the four years ended March 31, 2009 using data prepared in accordance with IFRS.
 
                                         
    9 months to
  Year ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
  2008
  2007
  2006
    IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS
    (in € millions)
 
Ireland
                                       
Agriculture
                0.4       0.8       0.5  
Manufacturing
                      0.3       0.2  
Property and construction
                      0.5       0.3  
Distribution
                0.1       0.7       0.3  
Transport
                             
Financial
                             
Business and Other Services
    0.7       1.4       4.9       2.6       8.2  
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
                             
— other lending
    0.2       2.0       4.7       11.9       10.1  
                                         
      0.9       3.4       10.1       16.8       19.6  
                                         
United Kingdom
                                       
Agriculture
                            0.1  
Manufacturing
                            0.3  
Property and construction
          0.9                   0.1  
Distribution
                            0.1  
Transport
                             
Financial
                             
Business and Other Services
    0.4                         0.2  
Commercial mortgages
                            0.1  
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    0.3       4.0       2.2       0.9        
— other lending
    1.6             1.0       1.3       0.8  
                                         
      2.3       4.9       3.2       2.2       1.7  
                                         
Group total
    3.2       8.3       13.3       19.0       21.3  
                                         


121


Table of Contents

Analysis of allowances for loan losses by sector
 
The following table present an analysis of allowances for loan losses at December 31, 2009 and at March 31, 2009, 2008, 2007 and 2006, using data prepared in accordance with IFRS.
 
                                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
  2008
  2007
  2006
    IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS
    (in € millions)
 
Ireland
                                       
Agriculture
    29.8       14.0       10.6       11.0       10.4  
Energy
    10.3       10.7       0.2             0.1  
Manufacturing
    247.7       52.5       20.5       32.0       5.3  
Property and construction
    2,207.5       371.0       46.0       11.5       8.5  
Distribution
    163.9       30.0       20.4       16.2       9.1  
Transport
                             
Financial
                             
Business and Other Services
    452.6       174.0       125.0       86.9       95.0  
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    133.2       49.3       0.0       0.3       1.6  
— other lending
    271.7       195.0       136.0       82.6       52.9  
                                         
      3,516.7       896.5       358.7       240.5       182.9  
                                         
United Kingdom
                                       
Agriculture
    0.1       0.6       0.3       0.4       0.6  
Manufacturing
    1.8       1.5       2.2       1.4       0.9  
Property and construction
    969.9       221.9       16.5       13.0       1.2  
Distribution
    14.7       13.9       11.2       3.7       0.4  
Transport
                             
Financial
                             
Business and Other Services
    40.7       16.5       11.3       4.2       13.8  
Commercial mortgages
                            0.3  
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    34.1       26.2       5.5       8.1       4.8  
— other lending
    33.9       40.7       20.6       14.6       18.4  
                                         
      1,095.2       321.3       67.6       45.4       40.4  
                                         
Total specific allowance
    4,611.9       1,217.8       426.3       285.9       223.3  
                                         
Total IBNR allowance
    1,163.1       563.2       169.8       142.2       135.7  
                                         
Total group allowance
    5,775.0       1,781.0       596.1       428.1       359.0  
                                         


122


Table of Contents

Loan losses as a percentage of total loans
 
The following table presents an analysis of allowances for loan losses as a percentage of total loans at December 31, 2009 and at March 31, 2009, 2008, 2007 and 2006 using data prepared in accordance with IFRS.
 
                                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
  2008
  2007
  2006
    IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS
    (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)
 
Ireland
                                       
Agriculture
    1.73       0.73       0.77       0.85       0.90  
Energy
    0.72       0.42       0.02             0.02  
Manufacturing
    5.49       0.87       0.35       0.58       0.11  
Property and construction
    11.34       1.92       0.23       0.07       0.08  
Distribution
    3.67       0.90       0.55       0.49       0.30  
Transport
                             
Financial
                             
Business and other services
    3.78       1.61       1.37       1.37       1.57  
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    0.47       0.18             0.03       0.01  
— other lending
    9.35       5.73       2.06       1.34       1.05  
                                         
      4.59       1.15       0.46       0.36       0.35  
                                         
United Kingdom
                                       
Agriculture
    0.04       1.05       0.27       0.38       0.87  
Energy
          0.05                    
Manufacturing
    0.10       0.09             0.12       0.11  
Property and construction
    6.05       1.52       0.18       0.13       0.02  
Distribution
    2.80       1.75       0.11       0.71       0.14  
Transport
                1.98              
Financial
                             
Business and Other Services
    1.12       0.27             0.14       0.63  
Commercial mortgages
                0.39             0.01  
Personal
                                       
— residential mortgages
    0.11       0.08       0.02       0.02       0.02  
— other lending
    2.37       1.82       0.73       0.50       0.76  
                                         
      1.88       0.56       0.12       0.08       0.09  
                                         
Total specific allowance
    3.42       0.90       0.31       0.23       0.23  
                                         
Total IBNR allowance
    0.87       0.41       0.12       0.11       0.12  
                                         
Total group allowance
    4.29       1.31       0.44       0.34       0.35  
                                         
 
Risk elements in lending
 
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) requires potential credit risk elements in lending to be analysed as (i) loans accounted for on a non-accrual basis; (ii) accruing loans which are contractually past due 90 days or more as to principal or interest payments; (iii) loans not included in (i) or (ii) which are “troubled debt restructurings” as defined in Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 15 “Accounting by Debtors and Creditors for Troubled Debt Restructurings”, and (iv) potential problem loans not included in (i), (ii) or (iii).
 
These categories reflect US financial reporting practices which differ from those used by the Bank of Ireland Group. See Item 11 “Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures about Market Risk — Loan Loss Provisioning”.
 
The amount of loans set out below do not give effect to available security and are before the deduction of specific provisions, which would have been so reported had the Commission’s classifications been employed. The category


123


Table of Contents

of non-accrual loans includes those loans on which interest continues to be accrued but against which specific provisions have been made.
 
The table below details the information using data prepared in accordance with IFRS for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and for each of the four years ended March 31, 2009, 2008, 2007 and 2006.
 
                                         
    9 Months
  Year
  Year
  Year
  Year
    ended
  ended
  ended
  ended
  ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
  2008
  2007
  2006
    IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS   IFRS
 
Loans accounted for on a non-accrual basis
                                       
Ireland(1)
    8,490       2,984       549       402       284  
United Kingdom(1)
    2,446       838       133       89       57  
                                         
Total
    10,936       3,822       682       491       341  
                                         
Accruing loans which are contractually past due 90 days or more as to principal or interest(2)
                                       
Ireland
    1,692       1,159       255       144       184  
United Kingdom
    722       341       125       44       20  
                                         
Total
    2,414       1,500       380       188       204  
                                         
Home Mortgage Loans — Accruing loans which are contractually past due 90 days or more as to principal or interest(3)
                                       
Ireland
    699       430       198       136       97  
United Kingdom
    661       516       194       153       154  
Total
    1,360       946       392       289       251  
                                         
Total risk elements in lending
    14,710       6,268       1,454       968       796  
                                         
Restructured loans not included above
    189       71                    
                                         
 
 
(1)  Includes loans in Ireland and the UK where interest is accrued but provision has been made. The loans on which no interest is accrued amounted to €3,342 million at December 31, 2009 (March 31, 2009: €1,194 million) and the provisions thereon amounted to €1,299 million at December 31, 2009 (March 31, 2009: €369 million).
 
(2)  Overdrafts generally have no fixed repayment schedule and are not included in this category.
 
(3)  Includes Home Mortgage Loans in Ireland and the UK (December 31, 2009: €699 million in Ireland and €661 million in the UK) which are secured and, typically in the UK, where the original loan to value ratio exceeds 75%, benefit from mortgage indemnity insurance.
 
The Bank of Ireland Group generally expects that loans, where known information about possible credit problems of borrowers causes management to have serious doubts as to the ability of such borrowers to comply with loan repayment terms, would be included under its definition of non-accrual loans and would therefore have been reported in the above table.
 
It is not normal practice for banks in Ireland or the UK to take property onto their books in settlement of problem loans or to classify them as Other Real Estate Owned. Where formal insolvency procedures are entered into, the property charged to the Group is sold by the receiver, administrator or liquidator, with the proceeds received by the Group. Loans subject to insolvency proceedings are included within non-performing loans in the table above, to the extent that they are not written off. This treatment is also followed for loans in Ireland and the UK which would be classified as “In-Substance Foreclosure” under US reporting practices.


124


Table of Contents

Cross-Border Outstandings
 
Cross-border outstandings are those outstandings that create claims outside a reporting center’s country unless loaned in and funded or hedged in the local currency of the borrower. They comprise loans, acceptances, interest-bearing deposits with other banks, other interest-bearing investments, leases and any other monetary assets, but exclude finance provided within the Bank of Ireland Group. The geographical and sectoral breakdown is based on the country and sector of the borrower or of the guarantor of ultimate risk.
 
Cross-border outstandings exceeding 1% of total assets are set forth in the following table.
 
                                         
    Banks and
      Commercial
      As
    other
  Government
  and industrial
      percentage
    financial
  and official
  and other
      of total
    institutions   institutions   private sector   Total   assets1
    (in € millions, except percentages)
 
IFRS
                                       
As at December 31, 2009, United Kingdom
    1,593             1,104       2,697       1.49 %
IFRS
                                       
As at March 31, 2009, United Kingdom
    2,032             1,675       3,708       1.91 %
IFRS
                                       
As at March 31, 2008, United Kingdom
    2,706             1,318       4,024       2.04 %
IFRS
                                       
As at March 31, 2007, United Kingdom
    2,818             1,195       4,013       2.12 %
 
 
Assets, consisting of total assets as reported in the consolidated balance sheet plus acceptances were €181.1 billion at December 31, 2009 (€194.1 billion at March 31, 2009, €197.4 billion at March 31, 2008.).
 
Cross-border outstandings to borrowers in countries in which such outstandings amounted to between 0.75% and 1.0% of total assets in aggregate were nil at December 31, 2009, €1,508 million at March 31, 2009 and €1,482 million at March 31, 2008. In December 2009 there were no such cross border outstandings (March 2009: Sweden: 2008: Australia).
 
Debt Securities
 
The following table shows the book value of Bank of Ireland Group’s debt securities at December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2009 and 2008.
 
                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    (in € millions)
 
Irish Government
    1,026       1,795       467  
Other European government
    29       2,368       3,430  
US Treasury and US government agencies
          11        
Mortgage backed obligations
                392  
Collateralised Mortgage Obligations
    530       846       1,317  
Corporate bonds
    18,741       24,262       25,290  
Other securities
    558       1,029       985  
                         
      20,884       30,311       31,881  
                         
 
The market value of Bank of Ireland Group’s Irish Government securities (the book value of which exceeded 10% of stockholders’ equity) at December 31, 2009 was €1.0 billion (March 31, 2009: €1.8 billion and March 31, 2008: €0.5 billion).


125


Table of Contents

The following table categorises the Group’s available for sale debt securities assets by maturity and weighted average yield at December 31, 2009.
 
                                                                 
    At December 31, 2009
        More than 1 year
  More than 5 Years
   
    Less than 1 year   less than 5 years   less than 10 years   After 10 years
        Weighted
      Weighted
      Weighted
      Weighted
        Average
      Average
      Average
      Average
    Market
  Percent
  Market
  Percent
  Market
  Percent
  Market
  Percent
    Value   Yield   Value   Yield   Value   Yield   Value   Yield
    (in € millions, except percentages)
 
Irish government
                842       4.0 %     184       5.9 %            
Other European government
                            29       4.8 %            
US Treasury & US government agencies
                                               
Mortgage backed obligations
                                               
Collateralised mortgage obligations
    81       1.9 %     301       1.5 %     98       1.4 %     50       1.7 %
Corporate bonds
    5,343       1.7 %     10,977       2.3 %     2,087       3.8 %     334       4.2 %
Other
    116       0.9 %     279       1.1 %     163       0.5 %            
                                                                 
Total market value
    5,540               12,399               2,561               384          
                                                                 
 
Maturity is remaining contractual maturity except for mortgage-backed securities where maturity has been calculated on an expected duration basis. The weighted average yield for each range of maturities is calculated by dividing the annual interest income prevailing at the balance sheet date by the book value of securities held at that date.
 
The figures included in the table above are net of impairment charges of €2 million in the nine months ended December 31, 2009 (March 31, 2009: €76 million)
 
Loans and Advances to Banks
 
The Group places funds with other banks for a number of reasons, including liquidity management, the facilitation of international money transfers and the conduct of documentary credit business with correspondent banks.
 
Limits on the aggregate amount of placings that may be made with individual institutions are established in accordance with Group credit policy.
 
The following table analyses placings with banks, based on the branches from which the placing is made for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and each of the two years ended March 31, 2009. Placings with banks are included in Loans and Advances to Banks in the financial statements.
 
                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    (in € millions)
 
Placings with banks repayable within 30 days:
                       
Domestic
    4,021       5,978       6,822  
Foreign
    39       1,031       2,362  
                         
Total
    4,060       7,009       9,184  
                         
Placings with banks repayable beyond 30 days:
                       
Domestic
    923       867       179  
Foreign
    48       10       46  
                         
Total
    971       877       225  
                         
Total
    5,031       7,886       9,409  
                         


126


Table of Contents

LIABILITIES
 
Deposits
 
The following table analyses average deposits by customers based on the location of the branches in which the deposits are recorded for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and each of the two years ended March 31, 2009.
 
                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    (in € millions)
 
Branches in Ireland
    51,612       51,245       44,913  
Branches outside Ireland
    31,183       36,832       31,508  
                         
Total
    82,795       88,077       76,421  
                         
 
                                                 
    Average
      Average
      Average
   
    Interest Rate
      Interest Rate
      Interest Rate
   
    during 9 months
  9 months
  during Year
      during Year
   
    ended
  ended
  ended
  Year ended
  ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2009   2009   2008   2008
    %   (in € millions)   %   (in € millions)   %   (in € millions)
 
Branches in Ireland
                                               
Current accounts:
                                               
Interest bearing
    0.2       864       3.2       1,603       3.1       1,965  
Non-interest bearing
          9,315             8,991             11,312  
Deposit accounts:
                                               
Demand
    0.3       18,253       1.8       16,020       1.9       17,616  
Time
    1.9       23,180       3.5       24,631       5.9       13,366  
Other deposits
                            5.5       654  
                                                 
              51,612               51,245               44,913  
                                                 
Branches outside Ireland
                                               
Current accounts:
                                               
Interest bearing
    0.5       2,387       4.3       2,050       5.0       2,736  
Non-interest bearing
          17             1,146             1,221  
Deposit accounts:
                                               
Demand
    0.7       13,908       4.0       14,488       4.8       10,174  
Time
    4.9       14,871       4.5       19,148       5.4       17,108  
Other Deposits
                            6.0       269  
              31,183               36,832               31,508  
                                                 
Total
            82,795               88,077               76,421  
                                                 
 
Rates for the nine month period are annualized.
 
Current accounts are checking accounts raised through the Group’s branch network and in Ireland are primarily non-interest bearing.
 
Demand deposits bear interest at rates which vary from time to time in line with movements in market rates and according to size criteria. Such accounts are not subject to withdrawal by check or similar instrument and have no fixed maturity dates.
 
Time deposits are generally larger and bear higher rates of interest than demand deposits but have predetermined maturity dates.


127


Table of Contents

The following table shows details of the Group’s large time deposits and certificates of deposit (US$100,000 and over or the equivalent in other currencies) by time remaining until maturity.
 
                                 
    At December 31, 2009
    0-3
  3-6
  6-12
  Over 12
    months   months   months   months
    (in € millions)
 
Time deposits
                               
Domestic branches
    13,280       2,062       1,447       1,429  
Foreign branches
    3,810       1,747       2,672       832  
Certificates of deposit
                               
Domestic branches
    3,908       137       21       14  
Foreign branches
    5,504       98       273       6  
                                 
      26,502       4,044       4,413       2,281  
                                 
 
Non-resident deposits held in domestic branches at December 31, 2009 accounted for approximately 11.6% of total deposits.
 
Return on Equity and Assets
 
Please see Table 2 in “Selected Consolidated Financial Data” on page 11 for further details.
 
Short-Term Borrowings
 
The following table shows details of short term borrowings of the Group for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 and the year ended March 31, 2009 and March 31, 2008.
 
                         
    9 months
  Year
  Year
    ended
  ended
  ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    (in € millions, except percentages)
 
Debt securities in issue
                       
End of year outstandings
    43,144       45,133       60,842  
Highest month-end balance
    43,144       64,276       66,018  
Average balance
    40,560       57,596       61,213  
Average rate of interest
                       
At year end
    1.6%       2.0%       4.6%  
During year
    1.5%       3.8%       5.0%  
Deposits by banks
                       
End of year outstandings
    4,909       9,305       12,381  
Highest month end balance
    10,199       14,821       17,510  
Average balance
    8,354       11,160       13,636  
Average rate of interest
                       
At year end
    0.73%       1.6%       4.3%  
During year
    0.80%       3.2%       4.0%  
Repurchase agreements
                       
End of year outstandings
    12,994       19,509       1,749  
Highest month end balance
    27,144       19,509       7,457  
Average balance
    17,980       5,940       5,454  
Average rate of interest
                       
At year end
    0.91%       1.3%       4.5%  
During year
    0.78%       3.4%       5.7%  
 
Average interest rates during the year are computed by dividing total interest expense by the average amount borrowed. Average interest rates at year end are average rates for a single day and as such may reflect one-day market distortion, which may not be indicative of generally prevailing rates.


128


Table of Contents

Item 6   DIRECTORS, SENIOR MANAGEMENT AND EMPLOYEES
 
DIRECTORS AND SENIOR MANAGEMENT
 
The strategic direction of the Group is provided by the Court of Directors (the “Court”) which comprises executive and non-executive Directors. Management is delegated to certain officers and committees of the Court. The table below details the roles held by members of the Court of Directors, the years in which they were appointed a Director and, in the case of Executive Directors, the year of their appointment to their present position in square brackets. This information is correct as at May 24, 2010.
 
                     
Name
 
Age
 
Position held
 
Year appointed a Director
 
Directors
                   
Patrick Molloy
    72     Governor     2009  
Dennis Holt
    61     Deputy Governor     2006  
Richie Boucher [2009]
    51     Group Chief Executive     2006  
Des Crowley [2006]
    50     Chief Executive Officer — Retail (Ireland and UK)     2006  
Denis Donovan [2006]
    56     Chief Executive, Capital Markets     2006  
John O’Donovan [2001]
    58     Group Chief Financial Officer     2002  
Paul Haran
    52     Non-Executive Director     2005  
Heather Ann McSharry
    48     Non-Executive Director     2007  
Rose Hynes
    52     Non-Executive Director     2007  
Jerome Kennedy
    61     Non-Executive Director     2007  
Tom Considine
    65     Non-Executive Director     2009  
Joe Walsh
    67     Non-Executive Director     2009  
Patrick O’Sullivan
    61     Non-Executive Director     2009  
Executive Officers
                   
Kevin O’Reilly
    55     Interim Head of Group HR        
Helen Nolan
    52     Group Secretary        
Ronan Murphy
    57     Chief Governance Risk Officer        
Liam McLoughlin
    46     Head of Group Manufacturing        
Vincent Mulvey
    49     Chief Credit and Market Risk Officer        
 
At the Annual General Court (AGC), on May 19, 2010, both Declan McCourt and Terry Neill retired having completed their two terms in office.
 
Non-Executive Officers
 
Patrick Molloy
Governor
 
Appointed to the Court in June 2009 and Governor in July 2009. He was Group CEO of Bank of Ireland from 1991-1998 and subsequently served as a Non Executive Director from 1998-2001. He has served as a Non Executive Director on the Boards of CRH plc (1997-2007); Eircom plc (1999-2001) and Waterford Wedgwood plc (2002-2009). He was Chairman of Enterprise Ireland (1998-2008) and CRH plc (2000-2007). His current Directorships are Blackrock Hospital Ltd (Chairman), Dublin Adult Learning Centre and Hugh Lane Gallery Trust (Chairman).
 
(Age 72)
 
Dennis Holt BA, ACIB
Deputy Governor and Senior Independent Director
 
Appointed to the Court in 2006. Chairman of Group Audit Committee from October 2008 to August 2009 when he was appointed Deputy Governor and Senior Independent Director. 39 years experience in Financial Services,


129


Table of Contents

including Retail Banking Executive Director on the Main Board of Lloyds TSB (2000-2001) and CEO of global insurer AXA’s UK and Ireland businesses (2001-2006). Chairman of Liverpool Victoria Friendly Society Ltd.
 
(Age 61)
 
Executive Directors
 
Richie Boucher
Group Chief Executive
 
Appointed to the Court in October 2006 and appointed Group Chief Executive in February 2009. Joined Bank of Ireland Group as Chief Executive, Corporate Banking in December 2003 from Royal Bank of Scotland. He was appointed Chief Executive, Retail Financial Services Ireland in January 2006. He is a past President of the Institute of Bankers in Ireland (2008) and of the Irish Banking Federation (2006).
 
(Age 51)
 
Des Crowley BA(Mod) Econ, FCMA
Chief Executive Officer — Retail (Ireland & UK)
 
Appointed to the Court in 2006. Joined Bank of Ireland in 1988 from Arthur Andersen & Co. Appointed Chief Executive, Retail Banking and Distribution and joined the Group Executive Committee in 2000. In 2004 he was appointed Chief Executive, Retail Financial Services, Chief Executive, UK Financial Services in 2006 and Chief Executive Officer — Retail (Ireland & UK) in May 2009. He is a Director of Post Office Financial Services and First Rate Exchange Services, our joint ventures with the UK Post Office and a Director of New Ireland Assurance plc.
 
(Age 50)
 
Denis Donovan B Comm, MBA
Chief Executive, Capital Markets
 
Appointed to the Court in 2006. Joined Bank of Ireland in 1985 from the Central Bank of Ireland. Appointed Chief Executive of the Group’s Capital Markets Division in 2006, having held the position of Chief Executive, Wholesale Financial Services Division since 2003. He was CEO of Global Markets from 1999-2003 and Chief Operating Officer — International, with Bank of Ireland Asset Management from 1993-1999.
 
(Age 56)
 
John O’Donovan B Comm, FCA
Group Chief Financial Officer
 
Joined the Group in 2001 as Group Chief Financial Officer. Appointed to the Court in 2002. Formerly Group Finance Director/Company Secretary of Aer Lingus plc.
 
(Age 58)
 
Non-Executive Directors
 
Tom Considine BA, F.C.C.A.
 
Appointed to the Court in January 2009. Appointed Chairman of the Court Risk Committee in August 2009. President of the Institute of Public Administration and a member of the Forum of the Economic & Social Research Institute. Former Secretary General of the Department of Finance. Former Board member of the Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland and former member of the Council of the Economic & Social Research Institute.
 
(Age 65)


130


Table of Contents

Paul Haran M.Sc, B.Sc
 
Appointed to the Court in 2005. Spent his career in public service and was Secretary General of the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment (1997-2004) during a period of significant economic and social transformation. In that period he was also a member of the National Economic and Social Council (1997-2004) and the Board of Forfas (1997-2004). He is Chairman of the National Qualifications Authority of Ireland, of Edward Dillon & Company and of the UCD Michael Smurfit Graduate Business School and the UCD College of Business & Law. A member of the Forum of the Economic and Social Research Institute and the Road Safety Authority, he is also a Director of Glanbia plc, the Mater Private Hospital and Drury Communications. He serves on the councils of Camerata Ireland, the Irish Taxation Institute and the Irish Insurance Federation.
 
(Age 52)
 
Rose Hynes BCL, AITI, Solr
 
Appointed to the Court in 2007. A Solicitor by profession. Previously held senior management positions in GPA Group plc, including General Counsel and Head of Commercial. Appointed Chairman of Bord Gáis in 2009. Director of Total Produce plc, where she is its Senior Independent Director and chairs the Compensation Committee. Also a Director of a number of other companies. Former Director of Fyffes plc, Shannon Airport Authority plc, and Aer Lingus Group plc.
 
(Age 52)
 
Jerome Kennedy F.C.A
 
Appointed to the Court in 2007. Appointed Chairman of Group Audit Committee in August 2009. Spent 24 years (1980-2004) as a Partner in KPMG providing audit and advisory services to a range of Irish companies and Irish subsidiaries of multinational groups from 1980-1995. Managing Partner of KPMG Ireland and a Board member of KPMG Europe from 1995-2004. Director of Bank of Ireland Life Holdings plc, New Ireland Assurance Company plc and Total Produce plc where he chairs the Audit Committees. Also Chairman of Caulfield McCarthy Group Retail and is on the Irish Board of the UCD Michael Smurfit Graduate Business School.
 
(Age 61)
 
Heather Ann McSharry B.Comm, MBS
 
Appointed to the Court in 2007. Director of IDA Ireland and Council member of the Institute of Directors. Previously Managing Director of Reckitt Benckiser and Boots Healthcare in Ireland. Former Director of Enterprise Ireland and the Irish Pharmaceutical Healthcare Association, and a fomer member of Governing Authority of University College Dublin.
 
(Age 48)
 
Patrick O’Sullivan BBS MsC F.C.A.
 
Appointed to the Court in July 2009. Previously Vice Chairman, Chief Growth Officer and Group Finance Director of Zurich Financial Services; Chief Executive Officer, Eagle Star Insurance (London); Chief Operating Officer, Barclays De Zoete Wedd Holdings (London); Managing Director, Financial Guaranty Insurance Co. (part of GE Capital) (London & New York); Executive Director, Goldman Sachs International (London) and General Manager, Bank of America Futures (London). He is currently Non Executive Director of Man Group plc, Cofra Holdings AGC and Chairman of Old Mutual plc.
 
(Age 61)


131


Table of Contents

Joe Walsh
 
Appointed to the Court in January 2009. Served as Minister for Agriculture from 1992-2004, having previously served as Minister for Food from 1987. He retired from the Cabinet in 2004. Director of Cork Racecourse (Mallow) Ltd. Horse Sport Ireland, and Irish Hunger Task Force.
 
(Age 67)
 
Senior Independent Director
Dennis Holt
 
Group Audit Committee (GAC)
Jerome Kennedy (Chairman)
Tom Considine
Paul Haran
Rose Hynes
Heather Ann McSharry
Patrick O’Sullivan
 
Group Remuneration Committee (REM COM)
Rose Hynes (Chairman)
Patrick Molloy
Joe Walsh
 
Group Nomination and Governance Committee (N&G)
Patrick Molloy (Chairman)
Dennis Holt
Heather Ann McSharry
Joe Walsh
 
Court Risk Committee
Tom Considine (Chairman)
Rose Hynes
Jerome Kennedy
Patrick O’Sullivan
 
Trustees of the Bank Staff Pension Fund
Paul Haran (Chairman)
Dennis Holt
Heather Ann McSharry
 
Terms of Office of the Directors
 
In accordance with the Bye-Laws of the Bank, each Director, if eligible, must submit himself/herself for re-election by the stockholders every three years. The normal retirement age for Directors is 68.
 
REMUNERATION OF DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS
 
The Group Remuneration Committee holds delegated responsibility for setting policy on the remuneration of the Governor and senior management (including Executive Directors) and approves specific remuneration packages for the Governor, each of the Executive Directors, the Group Secretary and those senior executives who report directly to the Group Chief Executive (Group Executive Committee).
 
The Subscription Agreement with the Irish Government and the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Scheme 2008 contain certain requirements in terms of executive remuneration and have affected key remuneration decisions during the period. These requirements were in effect for the nine month period ending December 31, 2009 and the Group is in compliance with all such remuneration requirements.


132


Table of Contents

The remuneration of Non-Executive Directors is determined and approved by the Court. Neither the Governor nor any Director participates in decisions relating to their own remuneration.
 
The Group Remuneration Committee’s role is to ensure that members of senior management are incentivised appropriately for their contribution to business performance and the achievement of strategic objectives.
 
During 2009 the committee received independent remuneration advice on executive remuneration from Deloitte LLP.
 
Statement on Remuneration
 
The current global economic downturn, coupled with continued disruption in capital markets, has resulted in another exceptionally challenging year in financial services. Reflecting the external environment, the performance of the Group and the Group’s obligations in relation to remuneration as set out under the Subscription Agreement and the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Scheme 2008, the Group Remuneration Committee took the following key decisions in relation to remuneration for the Group’s Directors during the period ended December 31, 2009:
 
Executive Directors
 
The remuneration packages for the Executive Directors were renegotiated and the changes took effect from May 1, 2009.
 
Changes were made to the remuneration package of the Group Chief Executive. He has agreed to a cessation of his Pension Cash Allowance, and has waived receipt of a portion of his salary. As a result, his total cash remuneration on an annualised basis has reduced by 20.6% when compared with the role he held prior to being appointed Group Chief Executive. His contractual arrangements were amended to include an option to retire at age 55 on a pension of approximately 59% of salary. This option was waived by him in April 2010. His accrued pension entitlement as at December 31, 2009, before taking account of the waiver of his early retirement option, was €276,690 as set out on page F-133.
 
The remaining Executive Directors have agreed to waive receipt of a minimum of 10% of their salary for one year with effect from May 1, 2009. Total cash remuneration payable to all Executive Directors, as set out in the table below, has reduced by 23.8% when compared with a comparable period for 2008 / 09.
 
Changes have been made to the contractual arrangements governing the taxable non-pensionable cash allowance in lieu of pension benefit foregone. The amounts payable to each Executive Director have been reduced as shown in the table below. Further detail regarding the nature of these allowances is set out in the Retirement Benefits section on pages 136 and 137.
 
Executive Directors will not receive any annual performance bonus in respect of 2009.
 
Awards made under the 2006 Long Term Incentive Plan lapsed resulting in the cancellation of the conditional grant of units of stock. The Group did not make any awards under the Long Term Incentive Plan in 2009.
 
The Group did not make any awards under the Executive Stock Option Scheme in June 2009. Awards made under the 2006 Executive Stock Option Scheme lapsed in 2009, resulting in the cancellation of options under this grant, as the performance conditions were not achieved.


133


Table of Contents

The table below shows the current structure of the Executive Directors’ cash remuneration (on an annualised basis), compared to that in effect for the year ended March 31, 2009. Cash remuneration includes all amounts payable to the Executive Directors. The difference between the amounts shown in the table below and the table on page F-126 is that amounts have been annualised, and the table below excludes pension contributions paid directly to pension funds.
 
                                                                 
Current structure-
          Gross
                  Reduction
annualised package
      Gross
  salary
          Pension
      (annualised
in effect from May 1,
  Gross
  salary
  after
      Car
  cash
  Total cash
  versus
2009
  salary   waived(1)   waiver   Bonus   allowance   allowance   remuneration   prior year)
    €000   €000   €000   €000   €000   €000   €000   %
 
R Boucher
    690       (67 )     623             34             657       20.6 %
D Crowley(2)
    570       (72 )     498             28       72       598       22.9 %
D Donovan
    660       (66 )     594             28       245       867       23.8 %
J O’Donovan
    550       (55 )     495             28       152       675       27.4 %
                                                                 
      2,470       (260 )     2,210             118       469       2,797       23.8 %
                                                                 
 
                                                         
Previous structure-
          Gross
               
annualised package
      Gross
  salary
          Pension
   
for the year ended
  Gross
  salary
  after
      Car
  cash
  Total cash
March 31, 2009
  salary   waived(1)   waiver   Bonus   allowance   allowance   remuneration
    €000   €000   €000   €000   €000   €000   €000
 
R Boucher(3)
    580             580             28       220       828  
D Crowley
    478             478             18       280       776  
D Donovan
    660             660             28       451       1,139  
J O’Donovan
    550             550             28       352       930  
                                                         
      2,268             2,268             102       1,303       3,673  
                                                         
 
 
(1) Details on the amount waived in the nine month period ended 31 December 2009 are shown on page F-126.
 
(2) When Des Crowley returned from the UK to an expanded role his salary was £440,000. It had been agreed that his salary on a return to Ireland would be €662,500. On his return to Ireland his salary was actually set at €570,000, 13% less than had been guaranteed, and he accepted this reduction. He also agreed to a waiver of €72,000 (12%) so that his salary after waiver is now €498,000. Compared to his original contractual position this represents a total reduction of 24%. In addition, his pension cash allowance was reduced as set out above.
 
(3) The amounts shown are in respect of Richie Boucher’s previous role.
 
Non-Executive Directors
 
In February 2009, the Governor, Deputy Governor and all Non-Executive Directors agreed to reduce their salary (in the case of the Governor and Deputy Governor) and their fees (in the case of all other Non-Executive Directors) by 25%. These reductions applied throughout the period ended December 31, 2009.
 
In addition, any fees payable in respect of Committee membership also reduced by 25%. These reductions also applied throughout the nine month period ended December 31, 2009.
 
Remuneration strategy
 
As described previously the Group is currently governed by obligations in relation to remuneration as contained in the Subscription Agreement and the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Scheme 2008. In addition, and taking account of the new regulatory environment, a review has commenced to ensure that our remuneration strategy, principles and frameworks continue to reflect new regulatory principles and recommendations (for example, UK Walker review recommendations) and external best practice.
 
The Bank of Ireland Group’s remuneration strategy is to stimulate the behaviours which drive the achievement of the Group’s business goals and strategy through providing a suite of remuneration tools directly related to:
 
•  Sustainable short and long term financial and business performance goals
 
•  Risk measures, which ensure that remuneration levels are risk adjusted and appropriately reflect risk timeframes


134


Table of Contents

 
•  Capital and liquidity measures
 
•  Non-financial measures of Group wide behaviours on leadership and employee engagement
 
Remuneration principles
 
A number of remuneration principles support this Group Remuneration Strategy:
 
•  Remuneration is aligned with the objective of maximising stockholder value over the medium to long term
 
•  Performance Driven — individual levels of remuneration are determined by individual performance versus a range of goals (see section on Performance Management) and also by Group performance
 
•  Market competitive — remuneration structures and pay levels are aligned with market practice in the relevant jurisdiction and/or segment and reflect the Group’s position within a relevant given market
 
•  Structured appropriately — remuneration structures and pay levels target, motivate and retain key skills and talent
 
•  Risk adjusted — remuneration is linked to appropriate risk measures and risk timeframes
 
•  Fairness and equity — Executive Directors are treated in a fair and equitable manner
 
•  Discretionary — all remuneration decisions (base pay increases, annual bonus, long term incentive grants) are subject to Group Remuneration Committee discretion and are dependent on individual and business performance
 
•  Regularly reviewed — reviewed at least annually to ensure appropriateness
 
•  Benchmarked appropriately — all benchmark analysis is conducted by external independent remuneration consultants
 
Performance Management
 
A robust performance management system and process remains critical in the current challenging environment.
 
The performance management approach allows the Group to align individual, business unit and divisional performance to the Group’s strategic objectives through an ongoing dialogue between managers and their direct team members. In addition, it supports an executive’s career development and professional growth.
 
The Balanced Scorecard & Key Result Areas (“KRAs”)
 
A Balanced Scorecard is a key document in the Performance Planning & Review process. This Balanced Scorecard approach is consistent with the emerging regulatory recommendations and principles. It ensures that:
 
•  All key deliverables and accountabilities of a role are taken into account when performance is assessed. For example, financial results, impact on customers, how an executive leads and develops his / her people, risk, regulatory and compliance requirements
 
•  A broad view of an individual’s performance is taken, rather than focusing on one or two key areas to the detriment of others
 
•  Organisational performance is continually enhanced by measuring both results and behaviours.
 
The Balanced Scorecard currently contains four Key Result Areas (KRAs), each with a minimum weighting of 10%, that apply to all executive roles in Bank of Ireland:
 
KRA 1 Financial/Revenue/Cost/Efficiency
KRA 2 Customer
KRA 3 Leadership & PeopleDevelopment
KRA 4 Credit, Regulatory & Operational Risk.


135


Table of Contents

The KRAs are agreed between the executive and his / her line manager at the beginning of the performance cycle. A formal interim review is conducted with regular informal reviews taking place at other times during the year. A formal end of year review occurs at the end of the financial year.
 
Remuneration package for Executive Directors
 
The total remuneration package is reviewed by the Group Remuneration Committee on an annual basis with assistance from external remuneration consultants who provide independent remuneration advice and analysis to the Committee. Remuneration levels are benchmarked versus similar level roles in Ireland and the UK.
 
For the period ended December 31, 2009 the remuneration packages for Executive Directors are governed by obligations contained in the Subscription Agreement.
 
The key elements of the remuneration package for the period ended December 31, 2009 were as follows:
 
Salary — Is payable monthly and is set at a level as approved under the Subscription Agreement. Salaries are reviewed annually by the Group Remuneration Committee.
 
Performance-related bonus scheme — The level earned by each Executive Director is based on the Remuneration Committee’s assessment of that Director’s performance against pre-determined financial goals and required leadership behaviours.
 
A decision was taken by the Group Remuneration Committee during the year ended March 31, 2009 that no performance related bonuses would be paid for the financial year ended March 31, 2009 and the year ended March 31, 2010.
 
Long Term Incentive Plan — Since 2004, the Group has operated a Long Term Incentive Plan (“LTIP”) for key senior executives, with stockholder approval, to align the interests of those executives with the interests of stockholders. Under the LTIP, which is described in more detail in note 45 on page F-101, conditional awards had been made to the Executive Directors as set out in the table on pages F-131 and F-132.
 
As set out previously the Committee decided that it was not appropriate to make a conditional award under this plan in June 2009. It is also likely that any conditional grants which have been made but which have not vested to date will lapse.
 
Stock Options — In 2004, the Group updated the Executive Stock Option Scheme (“ESOS”), with stockholder approval. The stock option scheme is designed to strongly align the interests of Executive Directors and Senior Executives with the interests of stockholders through having a significant element of their remuneration based on stock price performance.
 
As set out previously the Committee decided that it was not appropriate to make a grant of stock options under this scheme in June 2009. It is also likely that grants made in 2007 and 2008 will lapse confirming the strong link between Executive Director remuneration and stock performance. All ESOS grants made in respect of the financial years 2003/04 to 2007/08 inclusive currently have no value.
 
Employee Stock Issue Scheme — The Bank operates an Employee Stock Issue Scheme under which the Court of Directors may set aside an element of Group profit before taxation for allocation to the trustees of the scheme to enable them to acquire units of ordinary stock on behalf of the scheme participants. The amount set aside is related to overall Group performance (see also note 45 on page F-99 of the Consolidated Financial Statements). Executive Directors participate on the same basis as staff. As the performance conditions were not achieved, there was no issue under the employee stock scheme in 2009.
 
Sharesave Scheme — In 1999, the Group established a Sharesave Scheme (“SAYE scheme”) for all eligible employees. Under the SAYE scheme the Executive Directors who participated were granted options over units of ordinary stock as set out in the table on page F-131 (see also note 45 on page F-99). There was no SAYE scheme launched during 2009.
 
Retirement Benefits — The Executive Directors, with the exception of Denis Donovan, are members of the Bank Staff Pensions Fund, which is a contributory scheme at the rate of 2.5% of salary. Denis Donovan is a member of the


136


Table of Contents

Bank of Ireland Asset Management Pension Scheme, which is currently a non-contributory scheme. Both the Bank Staff Pensions Fund and the Bank of Ireland Asset Management Pension Scheme are defined benefit plans. Richie Boucher’s contract on appointment as Group Chief Executive Officer provided for an option, exercisable by the Group or by him, allowing him to retire at age 55, on a pension of approximately 59% of his salary. He waived this option in April 2010.
 
The Finance Act 2006 introduced a substantial tax charge on pension assets in excess of €5 million or the value of individual prospective pension entitlements as at December 7, 2005 (each to be indexed annually). Having reviewed market responses to this development and having taken actuarial advice, in May 2006 the committee agreed that Executive Directors be offered an option (a) to continue with unchanged pension funding arrangements or (b) to elect for a revised arrangement whereby their prospective pension fund would be limited to the value of the standard pension cap (or their personal fund threshold, if applicable) together with a taxable, non pensionable, cash allowance in lieu of the pension benefit foregone. All the Executive Directors originally opted for the revised arrangement, the income statement impact of which is broadly similar to that of continuing to fund these pensions under the earlier pre-2006 arrangements. There have been further (downward) revisions to this arrangement, which apply from May 1, 2009. The changes in the allowances are set out in the table on page F-133. Pension cash allowances in respect of Richie Boucher ceased from May 1, 2009. His prospective pension fund is therefore no longer limited to the value of the standard pension cap, and the value of the fund in excess of the cap will be subject to the additional taxation prescribed by the Finance Act 2006.
 
Service contracts — No service contract exists between the Bank and any Director which provides for a notice period from the Group of greater than one year.
 
The aggregate remuneration paid by the Group to key management personnel (26 persons) then in office, for the nine months ended December 31, 2009, was €8 million, including amounts paid under bonus and/or profit sharing plans. The aggregate amount, included in the above figure, set aside by the Group in the nine months ended December 31, 2009 to provide pension benefits for these Directors and Executive Officers amounted to €2 million. Included in these amounts is a payment to the Bank Staff Pensions Fund to cover the contractual option allowing the Chief Executive to retire at age 55 on a pension of approximately 59% of salary. This option was waived in April 2010 and the financial impact of the waiver will be included in the next financial statements. None of the Directors or Executive Officers beneficially holds more than 1% of the share capital on an individual basis. Additional information regarding remuneration of Directors is set out in note 54 to the consolidated financial statements.
 
Group Pension Plans
 
The Group operates a number of pension plans in Ireland and overseas. The plans are funded and are primarily of the defined benefit type and the assets of the plans are held in separate trustee administered funds. Payments to these defined benefit funds are determined on an actuarial basis, designed to build up reserves during the working life of fulltime employees to pay the employees, or their dependants, a pension after retirement. A formal actuarial valuation is undertaken at least triennially to determine the payments to each of these defined benefit funds. At each valuation the funds’ actuaries assess whether the liabilities of each fund, based on current salary levels, are fully funded on a discontinuance basis.
 
The total pension cost for the Group in respect of the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was €149 million of which €119 million related to the main scheme.
 
Interest of Management in Certain Transactions
 
No transaction material to the Group has been entered into in the last three fiscal years to which the Group or any of its subsidiaries was a party in which any Director or officer of the Group, any significant shareholder or any relative or spouse thereof had a direct or indirect material interest, and to the knowledge of the Group, no such transactions are presently proposed. Further details of Related Party Transactions with the Directors are outlined in note 50 to the consolidated financial statements. For information about material transactions with the NPRFC, which as a result of the recapitalisation described in note 58(i), now holds approximately 36% of the outstanding units of Ordinary Stock, see note 55 and note 58 to the Consolidated Financial Statements.


137


Table of Contents

Indebtedness of Directors and Executive Officers
 
The aggregate amount of indebtedness of key management personnel (20 persons) and their connected persons, on normal commercial/staff terms, to the Bank of Ireland Group amounted to €10.5 million at December 31, 2009. The interest rates payable thereon and other terms were at prevailing market rates and terms and reflect ordinary commercial/staff transactions and do not involve more than the normal risk of collectibility or present other unfavourable features. The aggregate amount of indebtedness of key management personnel of the Group included in the above figure, on terms similar to those on which loans are made to members of staff generally, which are at interest rates more favourable than prevailing market rates, was €1.881 million at December 31, 2009. These staff loans were made in accordance with the US Sarbanes-Oxley Act and the rules thereunder, which permits these loans if the loans are made on the same basis as, and on terms no more favourable than, loans made available to employees generally. For further information refer to note 50, of the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE STATEMENT
 
The Court of Directors is accountable to stockholders for the overall direction and control of the Group. It is committed to high standards of governance designed to protect the interests of stockholders and all other stakeholders while promoting the highest standards of integrity, transparency and accountability.
 
The Court’s role is to provide leadership of the Group within a framework of prudent and effective controls which enable risk to be assessed and managed. The Court sets the Group’s strategic aims, ensuring that the necessary financial and human resources are in place for the Group to meet its objectives and review management performance.
 
In response to the stressed position in which the Group now finds itself, the Court initiated a fundamental review of risk governance within the Group in early 2009. All of the recommendations of the review group have either been implemented, or are in the process of implementation. Increased Court oversight of risk has been enabled through the establishment of the Court Risk Committee, whose membership is drawn exclusively from non-executive Directors, to monitor risks arising in the Group. The Court Risk Committee also assists the Court in discharging its responsibilities of ensuring that risks are properly identified, reported and assessed, properly controlled, and that strategy is informed by and aligned with the Group’s risk appetite.
 
A key objective of the Group’s governance framework is to ensure compliance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements and the Combined Code on Corporate Governance (the “Combined Code”), a copy of which is available on www.frc.org.uk. The Directors believe that the Group meets this objective and expect it to continue to do so. Specifically, the Group has complied with the provisions of the Combined Code throughout the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, except in the case of Tom Considine’s membership of the Group Audit Committee and Joe Walsh’s membership of the Group Remuneration Committee — see comments on independence on page 139.
 
The Court of Directors
 
At December 31, 2009, the Court consisted of 15 Directors, 11 of whom were Non-Executive Directors. It held 8 scheduled and 7 unscheduled meetings during the nine month period ended December 31, 2009. Agendas and papers are circulated prior to each meeting to provide the Directors with relevant information to enable them to discharge fully their duties. The Group Secretary provides dedicated support for Directors on any matter relevant to the business on which they require advice separately from or additional to that available in the normal Court process.
 
The Court has the following schedule of matters specifically reserved for its decision:
 
•  the determination of strategy;
 
•  overseeing the management of the business, including control systems and risk management;
 
•  approving material acquisitions, disposals and investment decisions;
 
•  overseeing corporate governance and succession planning;


138


Table of Contents

 
•  approving guarantees entered into by the Group, other than in the normal course of business; and
 
•  approving changes in Group pension schemes.
 
Management is responsible for the execution of agreed strategy and for all operational matters.
 
Details of the number of scheduled meetings of the Court and its Committees and attendance by individual Directors are set out on page 144. The terms of reference of the Committees are reviewed annually by the relevant Committees and by the Court and are available on the Bank’s website (www.bankofireland.com) or by request to the Group Secretary. The Non-Executive Directors meet at least once annually without the Executive Directors present.
 
The Bank has in place Directors’ and Officers’ liability insurance in respect of legal actions against its Directors; however this insurance cover does not extend to fraudulent or dishonest behaviour.
 
See under “Election/Re-election of Director’s” below for recent changes to the composition of the Court of Directors.
 
Governor and Group Chief Executive
 
The respective roles of the Governor, who is Chairman of the Court, and the Group Chief Executive are set out in writing and have been agreed by the Court.
 
The Governor oversees the operation and effectiveness of the Court of Directors. He also ensures that there is effective communication with stockholders and promotes compliance with the highest standards of corporate governance. The Governor commits a substantial amount of time to the Group and his role has priority over any other business commitment.
 
The Group Chief Executive is responsible for execution of agreed strategy and holds delegated authority from the Court for the day to day management of the business.
 
Board Balance and Independence
 
The Court has considered the principles relating to independence contained in the Combined Code. The Court has determined that the Governor, Deputy Governor and each current Non-Executive Director, with the exception of Tom Considine and Joe Walsh, is independent within the meaning of the Combined Code. Tom Considine and Joe Walsh were nominated by the Minister for Finance under the terms of the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Scheme, 2008 and are not required to stand for election or regular re-election by stockholders. They are not, therefore, considered independent by reference to the terms of the Combined Code. The Court values and has benefited from their judgement and the quality of their contribution to the deliberations of the Court and its Committees. Each of the Governor, Deputy Governor and all of the Non-Executive Directors bring independent challenge and judgement to the deliberations of the Court through their character, objectivity and integrity and all are considered independent of management in accordance with the criteria set out in the NYSE Corporate Governance Standards.
 
Appointments to the Court
 
The Group Nomination and Governance Committee is chaired by the Governor and its composition is fully compliant with the Combined Code. The Committee is responsible for leading the process for succession to the position of Group Chief Executive and for Court and overseeing the selection process for key subsidiary Board non-executive appointments and renewals.
 
The Committee regularly reviews succession plans for the Court in the context of the Group’s strategy and the skills, knowledge and experience of current Directors and makes appropriate recommendations to the Court. Prior to the appointment of any Director, the Committee approves a job specification, assesses the time commitment involved and identifies the skills and experience required for the role. The recruitment process for Non Executive Directors is supported by an experienced third party professional search firm which develops an appropriate pool of candidates and provides a level of independent assessment to the process. The Group then works with that firm to shortlist candidates, conduct interviews/meetings and complete comprehensive due diligence.


139


Table of Contents

All newly appointed Directors are provided with a comprehensive letter of appointment detailing their responsibilities as Directors, the terms of their appointments and the expected time commitment for the role. A copy of the standard terms and conditions of appointment of Non-Executive Directors can be inspected during normal business hours by contacting the Group Secretary.
 
In addition, the Committee, with the support of the Group Secretary, monitors developments in corporate governance, assesses the implications of such developments for the Group and advises the Court accordingly. It is also charged with overseeing the Group’s Corporate Responsibility Programme.
 
Information and Professional Development
 
On appointment, all Non-Executive Directors receive comprehensive briefing documents designed to familiarise them with the Group’s operations, management and governance structures; these include the functioning of the Court and the role of the key committees. In addition, new Directors undertake an induction programme, including visits to Group businesses and briefings with senior management. On an ongoing basis, briefings appropriate to the business of the Group are provided to all Non-Executive Directors.
 
The Directors have access to the advice and services of the Group Secretary, who is responsible for advising the Court on all governance issues and for ensuring that the Directors are provided with relevant information on a timely basis to enable them to consider issues for decision and to discharge their oversight responsibilities. The Directors also have access to the advice of the Group Legal Adviser and to independent professional advice, at the Group’s expense, if and when required. Committees of the Court have similar access and are provided with sufficient resources to undertake their duties.
 
Performance Evaluation
 
Each Committee of the Court reviews its performance and discusses its conclusions with the Court. The Court evaluates its own performance annually and also reviews the conclusions of the Group Nomination and Governance Committee in relation to the performance of individual Directors standing for election or re-election. The objective of all these evaluations is to identify any scope for improvement and, in the case of the individual evaluations, to determine whether each Director continues to contribute effectively and to demonstrate commitment to the role.
 
The Court and individual Director performance evaluation process involves completion of questionnaires by Directors, one to one discussions between the Governor and each Director and presentation of the overall findings to the Court for its consideration and action as required.
 
As part of the overall performance evaluation process, the Senior Independent Director meets annually with each of the Directors, without the Governor being present, to appraise the Governor’s performance. They may also meet on such other occasions as are deemed appropriate.
 
Election/Re-Election of Directors
 
Patrick J Molloy was co-opted to the Court of Directors on June 10, 2009 and elected to the Court at the Annual General Court held on May 19, 2010.
 
Tom Considine and Joe Walsh were co-opted as non-executive Directors, with effect from January 1, 2009, under the terms of the Government Guarantee Scheme.
 
Patrick O’Sullivan was elected to the Court at the Annual General Court on July 3, 2009. All of the other Directors who stood for re-election were re-elected at the Annual General Court.
 
At the Annual General Court held on May 19, 2010, all Directors with the exception of Tom Considine and Joe Walsh retired. Declan McCourt and Terry Neill, who had each completed two terms in 2010, retired at the end of the AGC. Other than the four Directors mentioned above, all Directors offered themselves for re-election (or, in the case of the Governor election) and all were re-elected (or in the case of the Governor, elected). Following formal performance evaluation, the Court has concluded that each Director makes a valued contribution and continued to demonstrate commitment to the role. The Court recommended that stockholders vote in favour of their (re-)election in each case at the Annual General Court.


140


Table of Contents

Non-Executive Directors are normally appointed for an initial three year term, with an expectation of a further term of three years assuming satisfactory performance. A Non Executive Director is not normally expected to serve any longer than two terms, except where a clear benefit is expected to accrue to the Group, as determined following a particularly rigorous assessment of the skills and experience available to the Court. In the unlikely event that a Non-Executive Director is invited to serve longer than nine years, he/she is then subject to annual re-election by stockholders. In the case of Tom Considine and Joe Walsh, the requirement to stand for election and regular re-election is dispensed with for as long as the Government’s Preference Share investment in the Bank remains in place.
 
Remuneration
 
Information on the remuneration of Directors, is set out in note 54 to the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
A statement confirming that remuneration consultants appointed by the Group Remuneration Committee have no other remuneration consultancy connections with the Group is available on the Group’s website (www.bankofireland.com) or by request to the Group Secretary. During the financial period the remuneration consultants provided corporate recovery services, regulatory and risk focused advisory services and IT consulting services. The Group’s long term incentive schemes have been approved by stockholders.
 
Directors’ Loans
 
The amount of outstanding loans to Directors is set out on pages F-117 to F-119. A formal process is in place for approval and reporting of loans to Directors and their connected persons. The process is designed to ensure that no departure from existing group credit policy occurs without the Chairman of the Group Audit Committee being informed.
 
Accountability and Audit
 
The Statement of Directors Responsibility, including a going concern statement, is set out on page F-2.
 
Internal Controls
 
The Directors acknowledge their overall responsibility for the Group’s systems of internal control and for reviewing their effectiveness.
 
Such systems are designed to control, rather than eliminate, the risk of failure to achieve business objectives and can provide reasonable, but not absolute, assurance against material misstatement or loss. Such losses could arise because of the nature of the Group’s business in undertaking a wide range of financial services that inherently involve varying degrees of risk.
 
The Court has obligations as a non-US registrant under US securities laws and regulations, including the requirement to comply, where applicable, with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOx). The Group has put in place a comprehensive framework to document and test its internal control structures and procedures in line with the requirements of Section 404 of SOx, which requires, among other things, certification by management regarding the effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting. The Group’s overall control systems include:
 
•  a clearly defined organisation structure with defined authority limits and reporting mechanisms to higher levels of management and to the Court, which support the maintenance of a strong control environment;
 
•  Court and Management Committees with responsibility for core policy areas;
 
•  a comprehensive set of policies and procedures relating to financial controls, asset and liability management (including interest rate, foreign currency and liquidity risk), operational risk and credit risk management (further details are given in note 56 to the Consolidated Financial Statements).
 
•  a Code of Conduct setting out the standards of behaviour expected of all Directors, officers and employees. This covers arrangements, should the need arise, for the independent investigation and follow up of any concerns raised by staff regarding matters of financial and non-financial reporting; and


141


Table of Contents

 
•  monthly reporting by business units which enables progress against business objectives to be monitored, trends to be evaluated and variances to be acted upon.
 
These controls, which are embedded within the operations of the Group, are reviewed by Group Internal Audit. In these reviews, emphasis is focused on areas of greater risk as identified by risk analysis.
 
The Directors confirm that the Court, through its Committees, has reviewed the effectiveness of the Group’s systems of internal control for the nine months ending December 31, 2009. This review involved consideration of the reports of internal audit and the risk management functions, (including operational risk, regulatory risk and compliance) and establishing that appropriate action is being taken by management to address issues highlighted. In addition, the reports of the external auditors, which contain details of any material control issues identified arising from their work, are reviewed by the Group Audit Committee. After each meeting of the Group Audit Committee, its Chairman reports to the Court on all significant issues considered by the Committee and the minutes of meetings are circulated to all members of the Court.
 
Following the end of the nine month financial period to December 31, 2009, the Court reviewed the Group Audit Committee’s conclusions in relation to the Group’s systems of internal control and the appropriateness of the structures in place to manage and monitor them. This process involved a confirmation that a system of internal control in accordance with the Financial Reporting Council Revised Guidance on Internal Control was in place throughout the period and up to the date of the signing of these financial statements. It also involved an assessment of the ongoing process for the identification, evaluation and management of individual risks and of the role of the various Committees and Group risk management functions and the extent to which various significant challenges facing the Group are understood and are being addressed.
 
COURT COMMITTEES
 
Group Audit Committee
 
The Group Audit Committee (“GAC”) comprises six Non-Executive Directors. The Court has determined that the Committee members’ collective skills and recent and relevant financial experience enable them to discharge their responsibilities. In close liaison with the Court Risk Committee, which advises the Court in establishing the Group’s risk appetite and setting standards for the Group’s risk control framework, the Group Audit Committee reviews the appropriateness and completeness of the system of internal control, reviews the manner and framework in which management ensures and monitors the adequacy of the nature, extent and effectiveness of internal control systems, including accounting control systems, and thereby maintains an effective system of internal control.
 
The GAC has responsibility for:
 
•  monitoring the integrity of the financial statements;
 
•  assisting the Court in meeting obligations under relevant Stock Exchange listing rules and other applicable laws and regulations including the Sarbanes-Oxley Act in the United States;
 
•  overseeing all matters relating to the relationship between the Group and the External Auditors;
 
•  discharging the statutory responsibility of the Bank under Section 42 of The Companies (Auditing and Accounting) Act, 2003 and other statutes or regulations;
 
•  overseeing compliance with the requirements of the Irish Government associated with their support for the Bank of Ireland Group.
 
It conducts an annual review of the procedures and processes by which non-audit services are provided by the external auditors in order to ensure, among other things, that auditor objectivity and independence are not compromised. In this regard, a key procedural control requires that any engagement of the external auditors to provide non-audit services must be pre-approved by the Committee, which also receives reports on the performance of such services.


142


Table of Contents

Court Risk Committee
 
The Court Risk Committee (‘CRC’) is comprised of non-executive Directors and was established in response to a recommendation from a Court-sponsored review of risk governance. Under its Terms of Reference the CRC is required to monitor risk governance and assist the Court in discharging its responsibilities in ensuring that risks are properly identified, reported, and assessed; that risks are properly controlled; and that strategy is informed by and aligned with the Group’s risk appetite. To ensure co-ordination with the work of the GAC, the chairman of GAC is a member of the CRC and the chairman of the CRC is a member of the GAC. Membership is reviewed annually by the Group Nomination and Governance Committee. The CRC meets at least quarterly; it met four times in 2009, and is scheduled to meet six times in 2010.
 
The Court Risk Report is produced by the Chief Credit and Market Risk Officer and covers material Risk Types to which the Group has exposure. The Court Risk Report is presented quarterly to GRPC, the CRC and the Court of Directors. In addition, monthly updates on credit, liquidity and capital risks are submitted to the GRPC and the Court of Directors. The Group’s material risk types and group risk reporting are outlined on pages 166 to 172, respectively.
 
The primary responsibilities of the CRC are to assist the Court in discharging its responsibilities on overseeing risk management in the Group. To that end the CRC develops views on the key risks facing the Group, including determining if they are appropriately identified, reported, assessed and controlled. In discharging these responsibilities the CRC reviews the recommendations of the GRPC to the Court on key risk documents including, the Group Risk Framework, Risk Appetite, Risk Strategy and key documents on liquidity, credit, capital and funding.
 
On an annual basis, the CRC reviews the Group’s Risk Management Framework which is approved by the Court. The Group’s Risk Management Framework defines risk management processes for material risk types on the basis of, among other things, a comprehensive risk identification and assessment process. Where this exercise highlights risks or areas not effectively covered by existing risk management and governance processes, appropriate changes are proposed to the Court.
 
The CRC also discusses results of the Group’s stress testing programme. These results are used to inform Risk Appetite as well as capital targets and buffers as part of the Group’s Internal Capital Adequacy Assessment Process (ICAAP). The Group’s Stress Testing Process is described on page F-166.


143


Table of Contents

 
Attendance at scheduled meetings of the Court during the period ended December 31, 2009
 
                                                                                                                                                                 
                    Group
  Group
  Group
  Group
       
            Group Audit
  Group Audit
  Nomination &
  Nomination &
  Remuneration
  Remuneration
  Court Risk
  Court Risk
    Court
  Court
  Committee
  Committee
  Governance Committee
  Governance Committee
  Committee
  Committee
  Committee
  Committee
    Scheduled   Unscheduled   Scheduled   Scheduled   Scheduled   Unscheduled   Scheduled   Unscheduled   Scheduled   Unscheduled
Name
  A   B   A   B   A   B   A   B   A   B   A   B   A   B   A   B   A   B   A   B
 
Richie Boucher
    8       8       7       7                                                                                                  
Richard Burrows (Retired on 7/3/09)
    3       3       1       1                               1       1       2       2       1       1       2       2                          
Tom Considine (Appointed to CRC 8/25/09)
    8       8       7       7       5       5       4       4                                                       4       4              
Des Crowley
    8       7       7       7                                                                                                  
David Dilger (Retired on 7/3/09)
    3       3       1       1       1       1       2       2                               1       1       2       2                          
Denis Donovan
    8       7       7       7                                                                                                  
Paul Haran
    8       8       7       6       5       5       4       4                                                                          
Dennis Holt (Appointed Deputy Governor and Senior Independent Director 8/25/09. Appointed to N&G 8/25/09. Retired from GAC 8/25/09. Retired from Rem Com 8/25/09)
    8       8       7       6       3       3       1       1       1       1                   1       1       2       2                          
Rose Hynes (Appointed to CRC 8/25/09)
    8       8       7       7       5       5       4       3                               2       2       2       2       4       4              
Jerome Kennedy (Appointed to CRC 8/25/09)
    8       8       7       6       5       5       4       4                                                       4       4              
George Magan (Retired on 7/3/09)
    3       2       1       1                               1       1       2       1       1       1       2                                
Patrick Molloy (Appointed on 6/10/09. Appointed Governor 7/3/09. Appointed to N&G 7/3/09. Appointed to Rem Com 8/25/09)
    6       6       6       6                               1       1       2       2       1       1                                      
Declan McCourt (Appointed to Rem Com 8/25/09)
    8       8       7       7                               2       2       4       4       1       1                                      
Heather Ann McSharry
    8       8       7       7       5       5       4       4       2       2       4       4                                                  
Terry Neill (Appointed to Rem Com 8/25/09. Appointed to CRC 8/25/09)
    8       8       7       7                               2       2       4       3       1       1                   4       4              
John O’Donovan
    8       8       7       7                                                                                                  
Patrick O’Sullivan (Appointed on 7/3/09. Appointed to GAC 8/25/09. Appointed to CRC 8/25/09)
    5       5       6       4       2       1       3       3                                                       4       3              
Joe Walsh
    8       8       7       5                               2       2       4       4       2       2       1       1                          
 
Column A: Indicates the number of meetings held during the period the Director was a member of the Court and I or the Committee and was eligible to attend.
 
Column B: Indicates the number of meetings attended.
 


144


Table of Contents

 
Speak Up Policy
 
The Group has a Speak Up policy in place for all staff, which is in accordance with international best practice for whistleblowing arrangements and is compliant with the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. The policy encourages staff to raise concerns openly and locally. Where this is not possible or the problem has not been resolved effectively at that level, there are clear alternative senior contacts within the Group to whom the concern may be addressed. Confidential advice is available from Public Concern at Work, an independent, not-for-profit organisation, through a freephone number and a dedicated email address. In the case of concerns regarding financial reporting, fraudulent accounting or irregularities in audit work, these can be passed directly to the Chairman of the Group Audit Committee, whose contact details are available from Public Concern at Work. The Chairman of the Group Audit Committee is a non-executive Director.
 
Court Appointed Executive Committees
 
Group Risk Policy Committee (GRPC) — Within the parameters of Court approved high level policies, frameworks and principles, the GRPC approves risk policies and actions and makes recommendations to the Court on risk issues where the Court has reserved authority. In addition the committee ensures that risks are properly identified and assessed; that risks are properly controlled and managed; and that strategy is informed by and aligned with the Group’s risk appetite.
 
Group Investment Committee — The Group Investment Committee is responsible for evaluating all material investment/divestment/capital expenditure proposals, determining those within its authority and recommending those outside its authority to the Court for its approval. It is also responsible for monitoring the implementation of such proposals and ensuring satisfactory delivery of expected benefits.
 
Membership of the above committees at December 31, 2009 was as follows:
 
     
Group Risk Policy Committee
 
Group Investment Committee
 
Vincent Mulvey (Chairman)
  Richie Boucher* (Chairman)
Richie Boucher*
  Christine Brennan
Sean Casey
  Des Crowley*
Des Crowley*
  Denis Donovan*
Denis Donovan*
  Liam McLoughlin
Liam McLoughlin
  Vincent Mulvey
Ronan Murphy
  Ronan Murphy
Declan Murray
  Helen Nolan
Helen Nolan
  John O’Donovan*
John O’ Donovan*
   
Mick Sweeney
   
 
 
* Court member
 
New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) Corporate Governance Requirements
 
As a company formed by Charter in Ireland listed on the Irish and London Stock Exchanges and with an ADR listing on the NYSE, the Group’s corporate governance practices reflect Irish law, the Listing Rules of the Irish Stock Exchange and the UK Listing Authority and the Combined Code. The Group believes there are no significant differences between its corporate governance practices and the requirements of the NYSE
 
EMPLOYEES
 
For the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 the Group employed 14,755 staff on an average full-time equivalent basis (see note 12 to the consolidated financial statements). The decrease in staff over the previous year’s figure (15,868) is due to the impact of downsizing initiatives in the UK and US operations, together with normal staffing level fluctuations. The Group employed 16,026 staff on average in the year ended March 31, 2008.
 
The Group continues to operate an Employee Stock Issue scheme under which Group employees may be granted allocation of shares depending on Group performance.


145


Table of Contents

 
STOCK OPTIONS
 
Under the terms of the senior Executive Stock Option Scheme approved by the stockholders, options may be granted, at the discretion of the Directors, enabling senior executives to subscribe for specified numbers of units of Ordinary Stock.
 
As at May 24, 2010 options were outstanding over 7,533,045 units of stock representing 0.36% of the total ordinary stock then in issue.
 
Such options are exercisable as follows:
 
             
    Number
   
    Outstanding at
   
Exercise price (€ cent)
  May 24, 2010*   Exercise Period
 
9.15
    101,650     Nov 2003 – Nov 2013
11.05
    329,000     May 2004 – May 2014
12.50
    487,000     June 2005 – June 2015
10.65
    10,000     December 2005 – December 2015
10.77
    824,499     June 2006 – June 2016
10.54
    60,000     December 2006 – December 2016
10.76
    1,241,000     July 2007 – July 2017
12.85
    968,000     June 2008 – June 2018
13.68
    47,514     January 2009 – January 2019
15.45
    962,350     June 2007 – June 2017
9.75
    51,282     November 2007 – November 2017
8.10
    2,033,500     June 2008 – June 2018
1.215
    417,250     November 2008 – November 2018
 
As at May 24, 2010, executive Directors and Executive Officers as a group held options under the above scheme over a total of 1,285,300 units, representing 0.06% of the total ordinary stock in issue.
 
In addition to their interests in ordinary stock through their holding of stock options and the conditional awards of stock they have received under the LTPSP and LTIP, as set out in note 54 to the Consolidated Financial Statements, the interests of the Directors and Group Secretary in office at May 24, 2010, and of their spouses and minor children, in the stocks issued by the Group are set out below:
 
         
    UNITS OF €0.10
    OF ORDINARY STOCK
    As at May 24, 2010
    Beneficial*
 
DIRECTORS
       
Patrick J Molloy
    1,167,333  
Dennis Holt
    16,284  
Richie Boucher
    33,127  
Des Crowley
    133,724  
Denis Donovan
    187,951  
John O’Donovan
    91,126  
Paul Haran
    8,443  
Heather Ann McSharry
    11,354  
Rose Hynes
    25,000  
Jerome Kennedy
    8,062  
Tom Considine
    5,000  
Joe Walsh
    10,733  
Patrick O’Sullivan
    10,000  
         
SECRETARY
       
Helen Nolan
    21,883  
 
 
 *  Information is shown as at May 24, 2010 and before any changes which may be required as a consequence of the rights issue.


146


Table of Contents

 
As at May 24, 2010, Directors and Executive Officers of the Bank as a group beneficially held 0.09% (1,834,500 units) of the Group’s issued ordinary stock.
 
Limitations on Stock Issue and Stock Option Plans
 
All of the employee stock issue and stock option schemes are subject to a range of flow rate controls approved by the stockholders and which conform to institutional investor guidelines.
 
Item 7   MAJOR STOCKHOLDERS AND RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
 
CONTROL OF REGISTRANT
 
As at June 8, 2010 the Bank had received notification of the following substantial interests in its issued ordinary stock:
 
                 
NAME
  Units held   %
 
Capital Research and Management Company*
    65,994,690       3.14  
NPRFC
    763,789,210       36.36 **
 
 
* This stockholding is not beneficially owned but is held on behalf of a range of clients, none of whom hold, so far as the Directors have been notified, more than 3% of the issued ordinary stock. So far as the Directors have been notified, there were no other holdings of 3% or more of the issued ordinary stock of the Bank.
 
** The NPRFC has acquired voting rights equivalent to 36.36% of all votes capable of being cast by stockholders on a poll at a General Court of the Bank on any resolution proposed at a General Court of the Bank involving the appointment and removal of Directors. Such voting rights are also exercisable in relation to certain matters concerning a proposed change of control of the Bank (being a change in the holding of more than 50% of the voting stock of the Bank or of substantially all of the Bank’s business and assets).
 
Following completion of the Proposals, the NPRFC is expected to have a holding of approximately 36%.
 
RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
 
Refer to note 50 of the consolidated financial statements. Also see “Interest of Management in Certain Transactions” and “Indebtedness of Directors and Executive Officers” on pages 137 and 138.
 
DESCRIPTION OF US STOCKHOLDERS
 
At December 31, 2009, 823,051 units of Ordinary Stock were held by 445 stockholders with registered addresses in the United States and 13,430,623 ADSs were held by 244 registered holders with addresses in the United States. The combined shareholdings of these holders comprise approximately 5.43% of the total number of units of Ordinary Stock in issue at December 31, 2009 (being 1,004,216,989 units). These figures do not include either the number of units of ordinary stock held by stockholders with registered addresses outside the United States in which United States residents have an interest or the number of such US residents.
 
Item 8   FINANCIAL INFORMATION
 
See pages F-4 through F-183.


147


Table of Contents

 
DIVIDEND POLICY
 
The table below provides a summary of dividends per unit of ordinary stock paid in respect of the past five financial years.
 
                 
    Dividends
  Translated into
    per unit of
  US cents
    Ordinary Stock
  per Unit of
Dividend Payment Date
  (in euro cents)   Ordinary Stock(1)
 
Nine month Financial Period ended December 31, 2009
    Nil       Nil  
Financial Year ended March 31, 2009
    Nil       Nil  
Financial Year ended March 31, 2008
               
July 23, 2008
    39.4       61.85  
January 15, 2007
    24.2       36.06  
Financial Year ended March 31, 2007
               
July 27, 2007
    39.40       53.27  
January 16, 2007
    21.00       27.13  
Financial Year ended March 31, 2006
               
July 28, 2006
    34.30       43.73  
January 11, 2006
    18.20       22.09  
 
 
(1) Translated at the Spot Rate on the dates of payment.
 
On January 19, 2010, and following communications from the European Commission that the Bank should not make coupon payments on its Tier 1 Securities and Upper Tier 2 Securities unless under a binding legal obligation to do so, the Group announced that the non-cumulative distributions on the LP21 Securities and the LP3 Securities2, which would otherwise have been payable on February 1, 2010 and February 4, 2010 respectively, would not be paid. The effect of this decision by the Bank was to trigger the “dividend stopper” provisions of the LP2 Securities. While this “dividend stopper” remains in force, the Group is precluded for a period of one calendar year from and including February 1, 2010 from declaring and making any distribution or dividend payment on its Ordinary Stock, non-cumulative euro and Sterling Preference Stock, the 2009 Preference Stock3, Hybrid/Preferred Securities4 and the ACSM Hybrids5.
 
On that basis, (and also under the commitments to be made under the EU Restructuring Plan), the Group is therefore prevented from making discretionary dividend payments on its capital stock for a period of one calendar year from and including February 1, 2010. As a consequence of the dividend stopper, the Bank issued the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock6 to the NPRFC on Monday, February 22, 2010 in lieu of the cash dividend due to the holders of the 2009 Preference Stock on February 20, 2010.
 
In addition, under the terms of the CIFS Guarantee Scheme, the Bank is precluded from paying dividends on the Ordinary Stock without the prior approval of the Minister for Finance until the expiry of the CIFS Guarantee
 
 
1 Bank of Ireland Capital Funding (No. 2) LP US$800 million Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-Voting Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities.
2 Bank of Ireland Capital Funding (No. 3) LP Fixed Rate/Floating Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities;
3 8% (now increased to 10.25%) non-cumulative preference stock of 0.01 each issued to the NPRFC.
4 Bank of Ireland Capital Funding (No. 1) LP Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities, the LP2 Securities, the LP3 Securities and Bank of Ireland Capital Funding (No. 4) LP Fixed Rate/Floating Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities.
5 Bank of Ireland UK Holdings plc 7.4% Guaranteed Step-up Callable Perpetual Preferred Securities and Bank of Ireland UK Holdings plc 6.25% Guaranteed Callable Perpetual Preferred Securities.
6 184,394,378 units of Ordinary Stock issued to the NPRFC on Monday 22 February 2010 in lieu of the cash dividend otherwise due on the 2009 Preference Stock.


148


Table of Contents

Scheme which is scheduled to take place on September 29, 2010. The prohibition can be extended under the ELG Scheme.
 
Under the EU Restructuring Plan, the Group will commit not to make discretionary payments of coupons or to exercise voluntary call options on hybrid capital securities on or before January 31, 2011. Thereafter, any conditions imposed by the European Commission in respect of hybrid capital securities are expected to fall away.
 
Also under the EU Restructuring Plan, the Bank will commit not to pay dividends on its Ordinary Stock until the earlier of (i) September 30, 2012; and (ii) such date that the 2009 Preference Stock is redeemed or no longer owned by the State through the NPRFC or otherwise.
 
The Directors intend to resume paying dividends on Ordinary Stock after the above conditions have been satisfied and the Group has demonstrated that it can maintain appropriate capital ratios and sustainable profits.
 
LEGAL PROCEEDINGS
 
Save as disclosed in the paragraph below, there are no governmental, legal or arbitrational proceedings (including any such proceedings which are pending or threatened of which the Group is aware) which may have, or have had in the recent past, significant effects on the financial position or profitability of the Group taken as a whole.
 
Procom litigation
 
In May 2007, the Bank, through Bank of Ireland Private Banking, entered into an agreement with Procom Desarollos Urbanos, SA and Cecosa Hipermercados S.L.U (the “Plaintiff”) to purchase the entire issued share capital of Procom Desarrollo Comercial de Zaragoza, SA which is a Spanish incorporated company involved in the development of a shopping centre and retail park in Zaragoza, Spain. The agreement contained a number of pre-conditions. The Bank contends that one of the pre-conditions was not satisfied and accordingly did not proceed to purchase Procom Desarrollo Comercial de Zaragoza, SA. In February 2009, the Plaintiff initiated legal proceedings against Bank of Ireland Private Banking and the Bank (the “Defendant”) for specific performance or, failing this, damages in relation to the terminated agreement claiming €142 million in damages. On February 10, 2010, the Madrid Court of First Instance ruled in favour of Plaintiff and awarded damages of €90.87 million. An appeal has been lodged by both the Bank and the Plaintiff. The Bank is advised that the appeal process will take between six and eighteen months. Either party may then ultimately appeal this matter to the Supreme Court in Spain, which is likely to take a further two years.
 
SIGNIFICANT CHANGES
 
There have been a number of announcements since December 31, 2009, in relation to the items noted below. Further information on these is outlined in note 58 Post balance sheet events on page F-177.
 
(a)  Discretionary Coupon Payments
 
(b)  Exchange of Lower Tier 2 Securities
 
(c)  Issue of Ordinary Stock to the NPRFC
 
(d)  Credit Institutions (Eligible Liabilities Guarantee) Scheme — (ELG)
 
(e)  National Asset Management Agency (NAMA)
 
(f)  National Asset Management Agency Investment Limited (NAMAIL)
 
(g)  Pensions Review
 
(h)  EU Restructuring Plan
 
(i)  Placing of Ordinary Stock, debt for equity offers and rights issue, April — June 2010
 
(j)  Renominalisation of Ordinary Stock


149


Table of Contents

 
PROSPECTIVE ACCOUNTING CHANGES/IMPACT OF NEW ACCOUNTING POLICIES
 
Refer to pages F-33 to F-35 for details.
 
Item 9   THE OFFER AND LISTING
 
NATURE OF THE TRADING MARKET
 
As at May 24, 2010 the authorised capital stock of the Group was made up of €3,480,000,000 divided into 24,000,000,000 units of ordinary stock of €0.10 each, US$200,000,000 divided into 8,000,000 units of non- cumulative preference stock of US$25 each, STG£100,000,000 divided into 100,000,000 units of non-cumulative preference stock of STG£1 each, €162,000,000 divided into 100,000,000 units of non-cumulative preference stock of €1.27 each, €35,000,000 divided into 3,500,000,000 units of non-cumulative preference stock of €0.01 each, 100,000,000 undesignated Dollar preference stock of US$0.25 each, 100,000,000 undesignated sterling preference stock of Stg£0.25 each, and 2,000,000,000 of Deferred Stock of €0.54 each.
 
As at May 24, 2010, there were 2,090,976,199 units of ordinary stock of €0.10 each issued and outstanding. As at May 24, 2010 2,464,000,000 units of non-cumulative preference stock of €0.01 each were in issue. 1,876,090 units of Sterling preference stock and 3,026,598 units of euro preference stock were in issue and 1,188,611,367 units of Deferred Stock of €0.54 each were in issue. See also note 58 for details of the rights issue which concluded on June 8, 2010.
 
For further information on the renominalisation of the Ordinary Stock refer to note 58 in the notes to the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
The principal trading markets for the Ordinary Stock are the Irish Stock Exchange and the London Stock Exchange.
 
At May 24, 2010, 65 companies were quoted on the Irish Stock Exchange. These companies had a combined market capitalisation of more than €125.15 billion at that date. The 10 companies with the largest market capitalisations accounted for over 87.5% of the Exchange’s total market capitalisation.
 
The Group’s American Depository Shares (ADSs) are listed on the New York Stock Exchange. Each ADS, evidenced by one American Depository Receipt (ADR), represents four units of ordinary stock. Depository Receipts are negotiable securities that are used to represent, among other things, a non-US company’s publicly traded ordinary share capital.
 
ADRs are traded and dividends distributed in US dollars just like any US security, alleviating certain obstacles associated with investing directly in the home markets of non-US companies. The Bank of New York Mellon is the Depository Bank for the Bank of Ireland’s ADR programme.
 
The following table sets forth, for the periods indicated, the reported highest and lowest closing price for one unit of Ordinary Stock on the Irish Stock Exchange, as derived from the Daily Official List of the Irish Stock Exchange


150


Table of Contents

quoted in euro and the highest and lowest sales prices for the ADSs as reported on the New York Stock Exchange Composite tape.
 
                                 
    Ordinary Stock   ADSs
    High   Low   High   Low
    (in euro)   (in dollars)
 
Financial Year Ended
                               
March 31, 2006
    15.50       11.65       76.00       60.10  
March 31, 2007
    18.65       13.10       97.98       66.38  
March 31, 2008
    16.85       8.61       91.00       54.51  
March 31, 2009
    10.00       0.13       63.47       0.66  
Nine months ended December 31, 2009
    3.42       0.58       20.18       2.78  
Financial year 2007/2008
                               
First quarter
    16.85       14.78       91.00       80.46  
Second quarter
    15.43       11.25       83.96       63.54  
Third quarter
    13.93       8.90       79.27       55.50  
Fourth quarter
    10.48       8.61       63.72       54.51  
Financial year 2008/2009
                               
First quarter
    10.00       5.52       63.47       34.30  
Second quarter
    6.31       3.27       40.00       19.55  
Third quarter
    4.85       0.68       26.42       3.97  
Fourth quarter
    0.95       0.13       5.23       0.66  
Nine months ended December 31, 2009
                               
First quarter
    2.23       0.58       12.98       2.78  
Second quarter
    3.42       1.24       20.18       6.85  
Third quarter
    3.25       1.18       20.06       6.58  
Month ended
                               
December 2009
    1.70       1.18       10.77       6.58  
January 2010
    1.71       1.29       10.03       7.24  
February 2010
    1.32       1.00       7.98       5.48  
March 2010
    1.60       0.98       8.97       5.23  
April 2010
    1.91       1.60       10.57       8.35  
May 2010
    1.68       0.67       9.19       4.30  
 
Fluctuations in the exchange rate between the euro and the dollar will affect the dollar equivalent of the price of the ordinary stock on the Irish Stock Exchange and as a result may affect the market price of the ADSs on the New York Stock Exchange. See “Exchange Rates”.
 
Item 10   ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
 
CHARTER AND BYE-LAWS
 
1.  Objects and Registration Details
 
The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland (the “Bank”) is registered in Ireland with the Companies Office under No. C-1. The corporation was established pursuant to a Charter granted by King George III on foot of an Act of the Irish Parliament passed in 1781/82. The Charter was granted in 1783.
 
The corporation’s objects and purposes were set out originally in the Charter and have been amended by legislation (in 1872 and 1929) and by resolutions passed by the stockholders meeting in General Court in 1972 and 1995. The principal objects of the corporation are to carry on the business of banking and to undertake all types of financial services.


151


Table of Contents

2.  Recapitalisation of the Bank
 
(a)  Initial investment by the Government of Ireland in Preference Stock
 
On March 27, 2009 the Stockholders of the Bank approved resolutions enabling the subscription by the National Pensions Reserve Fund (the “NPRFC”) for 2009 Preference Stock at an aggregate issue price of €3.5 billion, pursuant to an agreement between the Minister for Finance of Ireland, the NRPFC and the Bank. The investment by the NRPFC was on foot of the Government’s commitment to recapitalise the Bank, announced on December 21, 2008 and as part of the investment the Bank issued to the NPRFC Warrants to subscribe for new units of Ordinary Stock equivalent to 25% of the existing Ordinary Stock (see the “Warrants” below).
 
The 2009 Preference Stock, comprising units of 8 per cent. non-cumulative preference stock of €0.01 each in the capital of the Bank, ranks pari passu with the Ordinary Stock of the Bank on a repayment of capital on a winding-up of the Bank, and ranks ahead of the Ordinary stock as regards the payment of dividends. The 2009 Preference Stock ranks pari passu as regards dividends with other stock or securities which constitute core Tier I capital of the Bank (other than Ordinary Stock and other than dividends to Minority Interests). The 2009 Preference Stock entitles the holder to receive a non-cumulative dividend at a fixed rate of rate 8% of the issue price per annum, payable annually at the discretion of the Bank. If the dividend on the 2009 Preference Stock is not paid in any year the Bank is precluded from paying a dividend on the Ordinary Stock until the payment of the dividend on the 2009 Preference Stock has resumed.
 
If a cash dividend is not paid by the Bank, the Bank shall issue units of Ordinary Stock to the NPRFC. The number of units of ordinary stock that the Bank would be required to issue to the NPRFC (in the event of non-payment of a dividend) will be calculated by dividing the amount of the unpaid dividend by the Thirty Day Average Price. If units of ordinary stock are issued in the event of non-payment of dividends, these units will be settled on a day determined by the Bank, in its sole discretion, provided that this must occur no later than the day on which the Bank subsequently redeems or repurchases or pays a dividend on the 2009 preference stock or any class of capital stock. The issue of units of ordinary stock in the event of non-payment of dividends will result in the dilution of existing ordinary stockholders’ proportionate ownership and voting interests in the Bank.
 
If the dividend on the 2009 preference stock is not paid in any particular year, then the Bank is precluded from paying any dividend on any ordinary stock until the Bank resumes the payment of dividends on the 2009 preference stock in cash. The Bank will also be precluded from paying any dividend on any ordinary stock where the payment of such dividend would reduce the distributable reserves of the Bank to such an extent that the Bank would be unable to pay the next dividend due for payment on the 2009 preference stock.
 
The 2009 preference stock may be repurchased at the option of the Bank, in whole or in part, at a price per unit equal to the issue price of €1.00 per unit of the 2009 preference stock within the first five years from the date of issue and thereafter at a price per unit of €1.25, provided in either case that the consent of the Financial Regulator to the repurchase of the 2009 preference stock is obtained. The 2009 preference stock will not be capable of being repurchased if it would breach or cause a breach of Irish banking capital adequacy requirements from time to time applicable to the Bank. The 2009 preference stock may be repurchased from profits available for distribution or from the proceeds of any issue of stock or securities that constitute core tier 1 capital.
 
While the 2009 Preference Stock is held by a Government Entity, the Minister for Finance has the right to directly appoint 25 per cent. of the directors of the Bank (such 25 per cent. to include any directors nominated by the Minister for Finance pursuant to the Government Guarantee Scheme). Two directors were appointed as directors by the Court pursuant to the nominations of the Minister for Finance under the Government Guarantee Scheme. The 2009 Preference Stock carried voting rights equivalent to 25% of the total voting rights on any resolution proposed at a General Court of the Bank in relation to the appointment or removal of a Director of the Bank. The 2009 Preference Stock also carried 25% of the total voting rights in relation to any resolution proposing a change of control of the Bank. For as long as the NPRFC or an acceptable Government Entity holds the 2009 Preference Stock the tabling of any resolution at a General Court of the Bank to alter the capital structure of the Bank requires the prior approval in writing of the Minister for Finance.


152


Table of Contents

The Warrants
 
The Bank issued, on March 31, 2009, 334,737,148 warrants to the NPRFC. Under the terms of the warrants, the NPRFC were entitled to subscribe for units of Ordinary Stock on the basis of one unit of Ordinary Stock for each individual warrant.
 
Under the terms of the Warrant Cancellation (see below at (b)), the warrants have been cancelled.
 
The warrants, if exercised in full, would have entitled the NPRFC to acquire 334,737,148 units of Ordinary Stock, equivalent to 25 per cent of the Existing Stock as enlarged by the Ordinary Stock issuable on exercise of the warrants and to exercise no more than 50 per cent of the voting rights attaching to any units of Ordinary Stock issued as a result of the exercise of the warrants.
 
The warrants were exercisable on the earlier of (i) at any time between the fifth and tenth anniversary of the date of issue of the 2009 preference stock (issued March 31, 2009); and (ii) any offer (within the meaning of the Takeover Panel Act 1997) for the Bank or other change of Control event in respect of the Bank.
 
The exercise price per unit of Ordinary Stock issued pursuant to the warrants was €0.52 for 177,213,784 units of Ordinary Stock and €0.20 for 157,523,364 units of Ordinary Stock. Any difference between the exercise price and the nominal value of the Ordinary Stock (being €0.64) would have been paid up from the Bank’s undistributable reserves (including the Stock Premium Account) or (subject to there being no contravention of the rights of other stockholders) from the Bank’s distributable reserves.
 
The number of units of ordinary stock which could have been acquired pursuant to the exercise of the warrants were subject to anti-dilution protection in line with market norms for warrants.
 
(b)  Placing of Ordinary Stock, debt for equity offers and rights issue, April — June 2010
 
In April 2010, the Bank announced Proposals to increase Equity Tier 1 Capital by not less than €2.8 billion by way of an Institutional Placing, a NPRFC Placing, a Rights Issue and Debt for Equity Offers. The proceeds of the Institutional Placing and the Rights Issue were underwritten by Underwriters pursuant to the Underwriting Agreement. In addition, the Warrants held by the NPRFC were cancelled in return for the payment of €491 million in cash under the Warrant Cancellation. The Proposals approved by Stockholders on May 19, 2010 consisted of:
 
•  Placing:  The Placing, comprising the Institutional Placing and the NPRFC Placing, raised €1,536 million in Equity Tier 1 Capital in May 2010. The proceeds of the Institutional Placing were underwritten pursuant to the Underwriting Agreement, subject to conditions, including Admission of the Placing Stock and the approval of the Resolutions at the EGC. The Underwriters agreed to use reasonable endeavours to procure Placees for an aggregate of 326,797,386 units of Placing Stock at a price of €1.53 per unit of Placing Stock issued in the Institutional Placing pursuant to the Underwriting Agreement. The price at which the Placing Stock was issued to Placees represented a 15.0% discount to the Closing Price of €1.80 of the Existing Stock on April 23, 2010 (being the last practicable date prior to announcement of the Proposals). Placees were considered Qualifying Stockholders for the purposes of the Rights Issue in respect of their Placing Stock. Pursuant to the NPRFC Placing, the NPRFC agreed to subscribe for 575,555,556 units of Ordinary Stock at a price of €1.80 per unit of Ordinary Stock (being the Closing Price on April 23, 2010). The consideration for the NPRFC’s subscription was the conversion of 1,036,000,000 units of 2009 Preference Stock (at their subscription price of €1.00 per unit of 2009 Preference Stock) to units of Ordinary Stock. In consideration for the NPRFC Placing, the Bank paid to the NPRFC a fee equal to 1% of the subscription price for all units of 2009 Preference Stock converted pursuant to the NPRFC Placing (the NPRFC Placing Fee). In addition, the Bank paid a Transaction Fee of €22 million at the closing of the NPRFC Placing in May 2010. The Ordinary Stock issued pursuant to the NPRFC Placing was eligible for participation in the Rights Issue as if such Ordinary Stock was held on the Record Date;
 
•  Rights Issue:  A Rights Issue which raised €1,725 million in Equity Tier 1 Capital (a portion of the cash proceeds of which were paid directly to noteholders electing for Ordinary Stock allotted in the Rights Issue on their behalf pursuant to the Debt for Equity Offers). The proceeds of the Rights Issue of up to €1.2 billion were underwritten pursuant to the Underwriting Agreement, subject to conditions, including, amongst other things, Admission of the Rights Issue Stock (nil paid) and the approval of the Resolutions at an Extraordinary General


153


Table of Contents

  Court (‘EGC’). The Rights Issue size and Rights Issue Price at which Qualifying Stockholders were invited to subscribe for Rights Issue Stock were determined by the Bank and the Joint Bookrunners in advance of the EGC. Pursuant to the NPRFC Rights Issue Undertaking, the NPRFC agreed, subject to certain terms and conditions, to take up its entitlement of Rights Issue Stock in the Rights Issue in respect of its holding of the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock and its holding of Ordinary Stock issued as a result of the NPRFC Placing (but excluding its other investment holdings in the Bank). The consideration for the take up of its Rights in respect of the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock and its holding of Ordinary Stock as a result of the NPRFC Placing was the conversion of units of 2009 Preference Stock at their subscription price of €1.00 each to Ordinary Stock at the Rights Issue Price of €0.55 per unit of ordinary stock. The number of units of ordinary stock owned by the NPRFC following the conversion is 1,139,924,901 units.
 
•  Debt for Equity Offers:  Under the Debt for Equity Offers, holders of certain of the Group’s Tier 1 Securities and Upper Tier 2 Securities were given the opportunity to exchange these securities for (a) Allotment Instruments (which automatically converted into Conversion Ordinary Stock on the Conversion Date); or (b) through a settlement procedure, cash proceeds from the allotment of Ordinary Stock in the Rights Issue on behalf of such holders or; (c) a combination thereof. The tender prices represented a discount of up to 42.0% to the nominal value of the existing Tier 1 Securities and Upper Tier 2 Securities exchanged by these security holders and resulted in a capital gain, which increased the Group’s Equity Tier 1 Capital. The increase in Equity Tier 1 Capital resulting from the combination of the Rights Issue and the Debt for Equity Offers amounted to €2,020 million. The actual size of the Rights Issue (including the NPRFC Rights Issue Undertaking) was reduced by the capital gain arising on the Debt for Equity Offers.
 
•  Warrant Cancellation:  The Warrants held by the NPRFC were, simultaneously with the NPRFC Placing, cancelled in return for the payment of €491 million in cash by the Bank to the NPRFC. This reflected the market value of the Warrants, being the difference between the exercise price of the Warrants and the Closing Price of the Ordinary Stock on April 23, 2010, plus a fee of €12 million. Following approval of the Proposals, the NPRFC ceased to hold the Warrants and the subscription rights for Ordinary Stock pursuant to the Warrants.
 
Following the implementation of the Proposals, the NPRFC increased its holding of Ordinary Stock, but had its Warrants cancelled and its holding of 2009 Preference Stock reduced. This resulted in the NPRFC holding up to a maximum of 36% of the Bank’s enlarged capital stock following the implementation of the Proposals (with the NPRFC subscribing fully for its rights in relation to the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock and the Ordinary Stock issued pursuant to the NPRFC Placing), and the full take up of its Rights in respect of the units of its other Existing Stock (i.e. the Ordinary Stock held pursuant to its other investment activities in addition to the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock) with no right to purchase additional Ordinary Stock pursuant to the Warrants. The implementation of the Proposals resulted in the NPRFC’s holding of 2009 Preference Stock falling from the 3,500 million units held at April 26, 2010 to a 1,837,041,304 units.
 
The implementation of the Proposals resulted in Ordinary Stockholders’ proportionate holding in the Bank being diluted. This was because the issue of the Placing Stock, the Ordinary Stock issued under the NPRFC Placing and the Ordinary Stock issued pursuant to the Debt for Equity Offers were not offered to Existing Stockholders. The degree of dilution increased depending on a number of variables, the main ones being whether or not Stockholders take up their Rights to subscribe for Ordinary Stock under the Rights Issue and the level of participation by noteholders in the Debt for Equity Offers.
 
Renominalisation of Ordinary Stock
 
Because the Bye-Laws of the Bank precluded the issue units of Ordinary Stock at a discount to their nominal value, the Bank’s ordinary stock was renominalised by Stockholders at the Extraordinary General Court held on May 19, 2010. This resulted in the nominal value of each unit of ordinary stock being reduced from €0.64 per unit to €0.10 per unit. Each existing unit of ordinary stock in existence at the date of renominalisation was subdivided into one unit of Ordinary Stock of €0.10 (“€0.10 Ordinary Stock”) and one unit of deferred stock of €0.54 in the capital of Bank of Ireland (“Deferred Stock”). The purpose of the issue of Deferred Stock is to ensure that the reduction in the nominal value of the Ordinary Stock does not result in a reduction in the capital of Bank of Ireland. The units of deferred stock have no economic value.


154


Table of Contents

Each Ordinary Stockholder’s proportionate interest in the issued Ordinary Stock of Bank of Ireland remained unchanged as a result of the Renominalisation. Aside from the change in nominal value, the rights attaching to €0.10 Ordinary Stock (including voting and dividend rights and rights on a return of capital) are identical in all respects to those of the previous Ordinary Stock.
 
The Deferred Stock created on the Renominalisation has no voting or dividend rights and, on a return of capital on a winding up of Bank of Ireland, will have the right to receive the amount paid up thereon only after Stockholders have received, in aggregate, any amounts paid up thereon plus €10 million per unit of Ordinary Stock, the purpose of which is to ensure that the units of Deferred Stock have no economic value. No stock certificates or documents of title will be issued in respect of the Deferred Stock, nor will CREST accounts of Stockholders be credited in respect of any entitlement to Deferred Stock, nor will they be admitted to the Official Lists or to trading on the Irish Stock Exchange, the London Stock Exchange or any other investment exchange. The Deferred Stock shall not be transferable at any time, other than with the prior written consent of the Directors. At the appropriate time, the Bank may redeem or repurchase the Deferred Stock, make an application to the High Court of Ireland for the Deferred Stock to be cancelled, or acquire or cancel or seek the surrender of the Deferred Stock (in each case for no consideration) using such other lawful means as the Directors may determine.
 
Capital stock immediately following the completion of the Proposals
 
The authorised, issued and fully paid capital stock of the Bank immediately following completion of the Proposals is as follows:
 
                                 
    Authorised   Issued and fully paid
    Number
  Amount
  Number
  Amount
    Million   € million   Million   € million
 
Maximum Potential Enlarged Capital Stock units of €0.10 each
    24,000     2,400       21,672     2,167  
Deferred Stock of €0.54 each
    2,000     1,080       1,189     642  
2009 Preference Stock of €0.01 each
    3,500     35       1,779     18  
Non-cumulative 1992 Preference Stock of €1.27 each
    100     127       3     4  
Undesignated 1992 Preference Stock of €0.25 each
    100     25              
Non-cumulative 1992 Preference Stock of Stg£1 each
    100     £ 100       1.9     3  
Undesignated non-cumulative 1992 Preference Stock of Stg£0.25 each
    100     £ 25              
Non-cumulative 1992 Preference Stock of US$25 each
    8     US$ 200              
Undesignated non-cumulative 1992 Preference Stock of US$0.25 each
    100     US$ 25              
 
Amendment of the NPRFC’s dividend and voting rights
 
As part of the Government’s participation in the recapitalisation of the Bank, the rights attaching to the 2009 Preference Stock were amended to increase the non-cumulative dividend to a fixed rate of 10.25% (from 8% previously) of the issue price per annum, payable annually in arrears at the discretion of the Bank. In addition the Warrants held by the NPRFC to subscribe for 334,737,148 units of Ordinary Stock were cancelled in return for payment of €491 million in cash by the Bank to the NPRFC.
 
As the holder of the 2009 Preference Stock, the NPRFC had the right to directly appoint 25% of the directors of the Group (such 25% to include any directors nominated by the Minister for Finance pursuant to the CIFS Guarantee Scheme) and could exercise voting rights equivalent to 25% of the total voting rights on any resolution proposed at a General Court of the Bank in relation to the appointment or removal of a Director of the Group. The 2009 Preference Stock also carried 25% of the total voting rights in relation to any Control Resolution (exclusive of any voting rights that the NPRFC or any Government Body may have through any holding of Ordinary Stock). The tabling of any resolution at a General Court of the Bank to alter the capital structure of the Group requires the prior approval in writing of the Minister for Finance. These rights applied in full for so long as the NPRFC held any units of 2009 Preference Stock.


155


Table of Contents

In addition, the NPRFC and other Government Bodies were restricted from exercising more than 25% of the total voting rights at a General Court of the Bank in respect of the voting rights attaching to, amongst other securities, the 2009 Preference Stock and any Ordinary Stock issued in lieu of cash dividends or issued upon the exercise of the Warrants, on a resolution to appoint, re-elect or remove a director. This restriction did not apply to other Ordinary Stock held by the NPRFC (for example Ordinary Stock held pursuant to its other investment activities).
 
Following the implementation of the Proposals, the NPRFC’s voting rights were altered. The NPRFC are no longer subject to the restriction on exercising more than 25% of the total voting capital on resolutions for the appointment, re-election or removal of directors: as such, the NPRFC would be entitled to exercise the full ordinary voting rights attaching to its Ordinary Stock (including the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock and the Ordinary Stock issued pursuant to the NPRFC Placing and the NPRFC Rights Issue Undertaking). However, the 2009 Preference Stock no longer carries a block vote of 25% of the total voting rights in respect of resolutions relating to directors and Control Resolutions; instead, the 2009 Preference Stock will carry the right to ’top-up’ the NPRFC’s total voting rights to 25% of the total voting rights on directors and Control Resolutions where the NPRFC’s ordinary voting rights through its holding of Ordinary Stock (or other securities issued in future) falls below this level.
 
The other rights attaching to the 2009 Preference Stock or granted to the Minister for Finance under the Bank’s Bye-Laws remain unchanged following the implementation of the Proposals.
 
3.  Directors
 
Any Director interested in a contract must declare his/her interest at a meeting of the Directors at which the question of entering into such contract first arises. The Bye-Laws also require that a Director may not vote in respect of any proposal in which he or any person connected with him has a material interest of making this determination. Interests in stock, shares, debenture or other securities of the Group are disregarded for the purpose. A Director cannot be counted in a quorum of the Court of Directors or of the meeting of a committee in relation to any resolution on which he is debarred from voting. The prohibition on voting in respect of contracts in which Directors are interested is disapplied in respect of proposals:
 
(a)  where a Director is given security or indemnified in respect of money lent or obligations incurred by him for the benefit of the Group;
 
(b)  giving security or indemnifying a third party in respect of a debt or obligation of the Group;
 
(c)  relating to an offer of debentures or securities of the Group in which a Director is interested as an underwriter;
 
(d)  regarding any proposal concerning any other company in which a Director is interested, directly or indirectly, provided that the director does not hold or is not beneficially interested in more than 1% of any class of share capital of that company;
 
(e)  regarding any pension or retirement fund or stock option scheme from which a Director might benefit and which has been approved by the Revenue Commissioners; and
 
(f)  regarding any proposal to purchase and maintain insurance against any liability incurred by Directors and Officers of the Group.
 
The remuneration of Directors is fixed from time to time by the stockholders in General Court. Such remuneration is divided among them as the Directors determine. Such remuneration shall be independent of any remuneration to which a Director may be entitled in respect of any other office or appointment within the Group. In the absence of an independent quorum, the Directors are not competent to vote compensation to themselves or any members of their body. The Governor and Deputy Governor, elected from time to time by the Directors, are office holders and are remunerated on terms established by the Directors.
 
Directors may exercise all the borrowing powers of the Group and may give security in connection therewith. These borrowing powers may be amended or restricted only by the stockholders in General Court.
 
There is no age limit requirement in the Bye-Laws that specifies when a Director must retire. However the Directors have adopted as a guideline that the normal retirement age for non-executive directors is age 68.


156


Table of Contents

All Directors (with the exception of Directors appointed by the Government (“Government Appointees”) must hold at least 1,000 units of Ordinary Stock.
 
In accordance with “The Combined Code on Corporate Governance”, adopted by the Irish Stock Exchange and the London Stock Exchange, all Directors retire by rotation every three years and, if eligible, may offer themselves for re-election subject to satisfactory performance evaluation. The appointment, removal and retirement of Government Appointees is subject to different arrangements that are set out in Bye-Law 100 of the Bye-Laws.
 
4.  Rights and Restrictions Attaching to stock
 
(a)  Ordinary stock
 
Dividend Rights
 
Under Irish law, and under the Bye-Laws of the Group, dividends are payable on the ordinary stock of the Bank only out of profits available for distribution. Holders of the ordinary stock of the Bank are entitled to receive such dividends as may be declared by the stockholders General Court, provided that the dividend cannot exceed the amount recommended by the Directors. The Bank may pay stockholders such interim dividends as appear to the Directors to be justified by the profits of the Bank. Any dividend which has remained unclaimed for 12 years from the date of its declaration may be forfeited and cease to remain owing by the Bank.
 
Voting Rights
 
Voting at any General Court is by a show of hands unless a poll is properly demanded. On a show of hands, every stockholder who is present in person or by proxy has one vote regardless of the number of units of stock held by him. On a poll, every stockholder who is present in person or by proxy has one vote for every unit of ordinary stock of €0.10 each except for the voting rights of the Minister for Finance which are more restricted. A poll may be demanded by the chairman of the meeting or by at least nine members of the Group present in person or by proxy and entitled to vote on a poll. The necessary quorum for a General Court is 10 persons present in person or by proxy and entitled to vote.
 
All business is considered to be special business if it is transacted at an Extraordinary General Court as is all business transacted at an Annual General Court other than the declaration of a dividend, the consideration of the accounts, the balance sheet and reports of the Directors and Auditors, the election of Directors in the place of those retiring, the re-appointment of the retiring Auditors, and the determination of the remuneration of the Auditors, all of which is deemed ordinary business. Special business is dealt with by way of a special resolution, which must be passed by not less than three fourths of the votes cast by such members as being entitled so to do, vote in person or, where proxies are allowed, by proxy at a General Court at which not less than 21 days’ notice specifying the intention to propose a resolution as a special resolution has been duly given. Ordinary business is dealt with by way of an ordinary resolution which requires a simple majority of the votes cast by the members voting in person or by proxy at a General Court. Where an equal number of votes has been cast on any resolution the chairman of the meeting is entitled to a second or casting vote. The special voting rights of the 2009 Preference Stockholder are referred to at paragraph 2(a) above.
 
Liquidation Rights
 
In the event of any surplus arising on the occasion of the liquidation of the Bank the Ordinary Stockholders would be entitled to a share in that surplus pro rata to their holdings of Ordinary Stock.
 
(b)  Preference stock
 
The capital of the Bank is divided into ordinary stock and non-cumulative dollar preference stock, non-cumulative sterling preference stock and non-cumulative euro preference stock. At May 24, 2010 there were in issue 1,876,090 units of non-cumulative sterling preference stock and 3,026,598 units of non-cumulative euro preference stock. The holders of non-cumulative sterling and euro preference stock are entitled to a fixed annual dividend in accordance with the terms and conditions relating to the issue of the preference stock. Any dividend which has


157


Table of Contents

remained unclaimed for 12 years from the date of its declaration may be forfeited and cease to remain owing by the Bank.
 
The non-cumulative sterling preference stock and the non-cumulative euro preference stock rank pari passu inter se and the right to a fixed dividend is in priority to the dividend rights of ordinary stock in the capital of the Bank. On a winding up or other return of capital by the Bank, the non-cumulative sterling preference stockholders and the non-cumulative euro preference stockholders are entitled to receive, out of the surplus assets available for distribution to the Bank’s members, an amount equal to the amount paid up on their preference stock including any preference dividend outstanding at the date of the commencement of the winding-up or other return of capital. Otherwise the preference stockholders are not entitled to any further or other right of participation in the assets of the Bank.
 
Bye-Law 7 enables the Directors to issue and allot new preference stock (the “2005 preference stock”) which can be either redeemable or non-redeemable, and can be denominated in US dollars, in euro or in sterling. Any preference stock issued under Bye-Law 7 will rank equivalently to the existing euro and sterling preference stock as regards entitlements to dividends. Bye-Law 7 permits the substitution of all of the outstanding preferred securities in the event of the occurrence of a “Trigger Event”. A trigger event will occur when the capital adequacy requirements of the Financial Regulator have been, or are expected to be, breached.
 
The ranking and dividend entitlements of the 2009 Preference Stock are referred to in paragraph 2 above.
 
5.  Variation of Class Rights
 
The rights attached to the ordinary stock of the Bank may be varied or abrogated, either while the Bank is a going concern or during or in contemplation of a winding-up, with the sanction of a resolution passed at a class meeting of the holders of the ordinary stock. Similarly, the rights, privileges, limitations or restrictions attached to the preference stock may be varied, altered or abrogated, either while the Bank is a going concern or during or in contemplation of a winding-up, with the written consent of the holders of not less than 75% of such class of stock or with the sanction of a resolution passed at a class meeting at which the holders of 75% in nominal value of those in attendance vote in favour of the resolution.
 
6.  Convening of General Courts
 
Annual General Courts and a Court called for the passing of a special resolution must be called by 21 days notice in writing at the least. The notice must specify the place and date of the meeting and, in the case of special business, must give the general nature of that business. Admission to General Courts is limited to members of the Bank and validly appointed proxies.
 
7.  Limitation on the Rights to Own Securities
 
Neither the Charter nor the Bye-Laws impose restrictions on the right of non-resident or foreign shareholders to own securities in the Group. See, however, “Exchange Control and Other Limitations Affecting Security Holders” on page 160 for restrictions imposed in the context of EU and UN sanctions.
 
8.  Further Capital Calls
 
Bye-Laws 17 to 22 deal with the mechanisms that enable the Directors to make calls upon members in respect of any moneys unpaid on their stock. All of the issued ordinary and preference stock is fully paid up.
 
9.  Limitation on a Change of Control
 
The voting rights of the 2009 Preference Stockholder concerning a change in control of the Bank are referred to at paragraph 2(a) above.
 
10.  Disclosure of Stock Ownership
 
Under Irish company law where a person acquires an interest in shares in a public limited company (and the Bank is considered to be a public limited company for these purposes) or ceases to be interested in such shares, he has an


158


Table of Contents

obligation to notify the company of the interests he has, or had, in its shares. As recently modified by the Transparency Regulations of 2007 (implementing the EU Transparency Directive), shareholders must now notify both the Financial Regulator and the company if the percentage of voting rights held by the shareholder exceeds, or falls below, a threshold of 3% and each 1% thereafter up to 100% as a result of an acquisition or disposal of voting rights in shares.
 
Under the Bye-Laws of the Group any member may be requested to declare by statutory declaration whether he is beneficially entitled to ordinary stock of which he is the registered owner and, if not, to disclose the person or persons for whom he holds such ordinary stock in trust. Such a declaration must be made within 14 days of service of the notice. Failure to respond to the notice in the prescribed period entitles the Directors to serve a disenfranchisement notice on such member with the consequence that the member may not attend or vote, either personally or by proxy, at any General Court of the Bank or exercise any other rights conferred by membership in respect of his holding ordinary stock (the “Default Stock”). In addition, where the default stock amounts to more than 5% of the ordinary stock then in issue of the Bank then the disenfranchement notice can state that no dividend will be payable on the default stock, and that no transfer of the default stock will be registered by, or on behalf of, the Bank. A disenfranchisement notice may continue in effect for as long as the default in respect of which it was issued continues.
 
11.  Employee Share Schemes, Long Term Incentive Plan and Executive Stock Option Schemes
 
Stockholders of the Bank have from time to time approved (and renewed) executive stock option schemes and more broadly based employee profit participation plans.
 
The Group Sharesave Scheme (1999), established under similar enabling legislation in both Ireland and the UK, enables participating employees, who enter into a savings related contract, to be granted an option to acquire units of ordinary stock on completion of that contract at a price related to the market price which prevailed at the time of the granting of the option. Eligible employees, whose remuneration is subject to Irish or UK income tax, may be awarded options over stock the exercise price of which may be set at a discount of up to 25% of the prevailing stock market price (20% in the UK). Participants must take out an approved savings contract and may contribute from €12 to €320 per month.
 
The Long Term Incentive Plan (2004) is restricted to senior executive officers and focuses on the Group’s Total Shareholder Return (TSR) relative to a group of leading European financial services businesses. The TSR takes into account both the Group’s stock price performance and dividend payments to stockholders. The Long Term Incentive Plan is median based and competitive relative to other leading financial services businesses in Europe, and provides incentives for eligible management that are aligned with stockholders’ interests, and is designed to ensure that the Group continues to recruit, retain and motivate high quality executives. Under the Plan, senior executives may receive conditional awards of stock worth up to one time’s salary each year (or up to 1.5 times salary in the case of the Group Chief Executive) but these awards will vest in full only if the Group’s total shareholder return over three years is ranked first or second relative to a group of leading European financial services businesses. No awards will vest if the Group’s total shareholder return is below the median relative to those companies or if the average Return on Equity (“ROE”) is less than 20% per annum.
 
The Group Executive Stock Option Scheme (2004) focuses on underlying earnings per share (“underlying EPS”) growth. The scheme, which is median based and competitive in relation to other leading financial services businesses in Europe, also provides incentives for eligible management that are aligned with stockholders’ interests and is designed to ensure that the Group can continue to recruit, retain and motivate high quality executives. Under the scheme, executives may be granted options to purchase stock up to one time’s salary each year. Options granted between 2004 and 2007 will only be exercisable if the Group’s underlying EPS growth over three years exceeds the increase in the Consumer Price Index by at least 5% per annum compound. For options granted in 2008, 25% will become capable of exercise if the Group’s underlying EPS growth is 3% per annum compounded. 100% of options granted in 2008 will become capable of exercise if the Group’s underlying EPS growth is 6% per annum compounded. A scaled level of vesting will occur between these two targets, with options lapsing if the minimum target of underlying EPS of 3% per annum compounded is not achieved.


159


Table of Contents

The Group Staff Stock Issue Scheme (2006) was established under profit sharing legislation and approved by the Revenue Commissioners in Ireland. All Irish resident employees (including executive directors of the Bank and of participating companies) are eligible to participate in the scheme. As presently implemented the scheme allows the Group to make an award of free stock up to a maximum of 6% of the salary of eligible employees in any one year, up to a ceiling of €12,700. Subject to being held in trust for a period of three years, the stock is passed to the employee tax free and is thereby a very tax efficient mechanism for creating employee stock ownership. The amount of stock allocated by the directors reflects the Group’s performance but cannot exceed 5% of the consolidated profits of the Group in any year. The Stock Incentive Plan (2003) approved by the Inland Revenue of the UK, makes similar provisions for employees of the Group or any participating company resident in the UK.
 
All of the above stock issue and stock option schemes are subject to a range of flow rate controls approved by the stockholders and which conform to current institutional investor guidelines.
 
12.  Directors’ and Officers’ Liability Insurance
 
Irish company law permits companies to purchase and maintain insurance against directors’ and officers’ liability. The Bye-Laws of the Group enable the Group to purchase such liability insurance and make it clear that directors are entitled to vote and be counted in the quorum in respect of any resolution concerning the purchase of such insurance.
 
13.  Material Contracts
 
See note 55 to the Consolidated Financial Statements for details of material transactions with the Irish Government.
 
EXCHANGE CONTROLS AND OTHER LIMITATIONS AFFECTING SECURITY HOLDERS
 
There are no restrictions under the Bye-Laws of the Group, presently in force, that limit the right of non-resident or foreign owners, as such, to hold securities of the Group freely or, when entitled, to vote such securities freely. There are currently no Irish foreign exchange controls or laws restricting the import or export of capital, although the Council of the European Union does have the power, under Articles 58 to 60 of the Treaty establishing the European Community, to impose restrictions on capital movements to and from third countries. There are currently no restrictions under Irish law affecting the remittance of dividends, interest or other payments to non-resident holders of securities of the Group, except in respect entities and/or individuals detailed in relevant European Union and United Nations sanctions listings received from the Financial Regulator from time to time, for example members of the Taliban and Al-Qaeda networks. The Group also complies with applicable requirements arising in respect of non-cooperative countries and territories (“NCCT”), pursuant to the NCCT initiative of the Financial Action Task Force.
 
TAXATION
 
The following summary of certain consequences to US holders (as defined below), or as in the case of Irish taxation, to eligible US holders (also as defined below) of the purchase, ownership and disposition of ADSs or ordinary stock deals only with US holders that hold ADSs or units of ordinary stock as capital assets for Irish and US Federal income tax purposes and does not deal with special classes of holders, such as dealers in securities, traders in securities that elect to use a mark to market method of accounting for their securities holdings, tax-exempt organisations, life assurance companies, persons liable for alternative minimum tax, persons that actually or constructively own 10% or more of the voting stock of the Bank, persons that hold units of ordinary stock or ADSs as part of a straddle or a hedging or conversion transaction, or US holders or eligible US holders whose functional currency is not the US dollar. While the summary discussion relates to material matters relevant to the tax laws of the US and Ireland, all holders should consult their own tax advisors as to the Irish, US or any other tax consequences of the purchase, ownership and disposition of ordinary stock or ADSs including the effect of any foreign state or local tax laws as they apply to their particular circumstances.
 
This summary is based (i) on the income tax treaty between Ireland and the US (the “Tax Treaty”), tax laws, regulations, administrative rulings and court decisions of Ireland and the US, all as currently in effect and all subject to change at any time, perhaps with retroactive effect, and (ii) in part, on representations of the Depositary, and


160


Table of Contents

assumes that each obligation in the Deposit Agreement and any related agreement will be performed in accordance with its terms.
 
If a partnership holds the ordinary stock or ADSs, the US federal income tax treatment of a partner will generally depend on the status of the partner and the activities of the partnership. A partner in a partnership holding ordinary stock or ADSs should consult its tax advisor with regard to the US federal income tax treatment of an investment in the ordinary stock or ADSs.
 
For purposes of this discussion, a “US holder” is a beneficial owner of ADSs or ordinary stock that is, for US federal income tax purposes, (i) a citizen or resident of the US, (ii) a US domestic corporation or an entity taxable as a corporation, (iii) an estate whose income is subject to US federal income tax regardless of its source, (iv) a trust if a US court can exercise primary supervision over the trust’s administration and one or more US persons are authorised to control all substantial decisions of the trust.
 
For purposes of this discussion, an “eligible US holder” is a US holder that is (i) not a resident of Ireland for purposes of Irish taxes, (ii) not engaged in a trade or business in Ireland through a permanent establishment and (iii) otherwise eligible for benefits under the Tax Treaty with respect to income and gain from ordinary stock or ADSs.
 
For purposes of the Tax Treaty and the US Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the ’Code’), US holders will be treated as the beneficial owners of the ordinary stock underlying the ADSs represented by the ADRs.
 
Irish Taxation
 
Dividends:  Dividends paid by an Irish resident company do not carry a tax credit and are generally subject to Dividend Withholding Tax (“DWT”) at the standard rate of income tax, currently 20%. This could include dividends paid by the Group with respect to ordinary stock or ADSs. There are a number of exemptions available from DWT including: (i) for ordinary stock, where the recipient is an eligible US holder who completes a relevant declaration and submits same to the Bank’s Registration Department prior to the due date of payment of the relevant dividend; and (ii) in relation to dividends paid with respect to ADSs as evidenced by an ADR, where the beneficial holder’s address on the register of depositary receipts is located in the US and is held by the Bank of New York or other ‘qualifying intermediary’ as defined in section 172E Irish Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 (or see list at http://www.revenue.ie/en/tax/dwt/authorised-qualifying-intermediaries.html) or by any intervening ‘specified intermediary’ as defined in section 172F Irish Taxes Consolidation Act 1997.
 
An eligible US holder that receives a dividend which has been subjected to DWT may, in certain circumstances, claim repayment of the DWT by making an application to the Irish Tax Authorities in accordance with provisions of Irish law. Under the provisions of Irish law an eligible US holder, who is not under the control (direct or indirect) of a person or persons who are Irish resident, is exempt from Irish tax on dividends paid by the Group. Where entitlement to a full repayment under these provisions cannot be established, the procedures outlined in the immediately following paragraphs will apply.
 
The Tax Treaty limits the Irish tax liability of an eligible US holder (that is unable to claim repayment of the full DWT under provisions of Irish law) in respect of a dividend paid by the Bank to 15% of the gross amount. Consequently such holder may claim repayment from the Irish Tax Authorities, in accordance with the Tax Treaty, of the amount of DWT in excess of 15% of the sum of the cash dividend and the related DWT.
 
Gain on Disposition:  A gain realised on the disposition of ADSs or ordinary stock by a US holder who is not resident or ordinarily resident in Ireland for Irish tax purposes is not subject to Irish Capital Gains Tax unless such ADSs or units of ordinary stock are held in connection with a trade or business carried on by such holder in Ireland through a branch or agency.
 
Irish Stamp Duty:  Section 90 of the Irish Stamp Duties Consolidation Act 1999 exempts from Irish stamp duty transfers of ADRs where the ADRs (or the underlying securities they represent) are dealt in and quoted on a recognised stock exchange in the US. The ordinary stock that is listed and traded on the New York Stock Exchange in the form of ADSs, evidenced by ADRs, falls within this exemption.


161


Table of Contents

Irish stamp duty will be charged at a rate of 1% rounded down to the nearest euro of the consideration on any conveyance or transfer on the sale of the ordinary stock or the value of that stock if higher. If less than one euro, stamp duty is rounded up to one euro.
 
Stamp duty (which would be applicable at the rate of 1% rounded down to the nearest euro of the price paid or, if higher, the value of the ordinary stock) may apply to conversions of ordinary stock into ADSs and of ADSs to ordinary stock. This would include a deposit of ordinary stock with the depository in exchange for ADSs and withdrawals of ordinary stock if the deposit withdrawal is done as a conveyance on sale or in contemplation of sale.
 
US Federal Income Taxation
 
Dividends:  Under the Code and subject to the PFIC rules discussed below, the gross amount of any dividend (including any related applicable DWT) paid by the Bank to a US holder out of its current or accumulated earnings and profits (as determined for US Federal income tax purposes) is subject to US Federal income taxation. Dividends paid to a non-corporate US holder in taxable years beginning before January 1, 2011 that constitute qualified dividend income will be taxable to the holder at a maximum federal tax rate of 15% provided that the ADSs or ordinary stock are held for more than 60 days during the 121-day period beginning 60 days before the ex-dividend date and the holder meets other holding period requirements. Dividends paid by the Bank with respect to its ADSs or units of ordinary stock generally will be qualified dividend income. The dividend will not be eligible for the dividends received deduction generally allowed to corporations. The amount of any dividend will be the US dollar value of the euro payment (determined at the spot US dollar/euro exchange rate) on the date of actual or constructive receipt by the US holder, in the case of ordinary stock, or by the Depositary in the case of ADSs, regardless of whether the payment is converted into dollars. Gain or loss, if any resulting from currency exchange fluctuations during the periods from the date or US holder includes the dividend payment on income to the date such US holder converts the payment into US dollars, generally will be ordinary income or loss and will not be eligible for the special tax rate applicable to qualified dividend income and generally will be income or loss from sources within the US for foreign tax credit limitation purposes. Distributions in excess of current and accumulated earnings and profits, as determined for US Federal income tax purposes, will be treated as a non-taxable return of capital to the extent of the US holder’s basis in the ADSs or units of ordinary stock and thereafter as capital gain.
 
Subject to certain limitations, any Irish tax (including DWT) withheld and paid over to Ireland will be creditable against the US holder’s US Federal income tax liability. Special rules apply in determining the foreign tax credit limitation with respect to dividends that are subject to the maximum 15% federal tax rate. To the extent a refund of the tax withheld is available to a US holder under Irish law or the Tax Treaty, the amount of tax withheld that is refundable will not be eligible for credit against a US holder’s US Federal income tax liability.
 
Dividends paid by the Bank with respect to ADSs or ordinary stock ‘will be income from sources out side the US and will depending on a US holders circumstances, generally be passive’ income or ‘general’ income. For purposes of computing the foreign tax credit affordable to the holder US holders should consult their own tax advisors concerning the implications of US foreign tax credit rules in light of their particular circumstances.
 
Gain on Disposition:  Subject to the PFIC rules discussed below, upon the sale, exchange or other disposition of ADSs or ordinary stock, a US holder will recognise gain or loss, if any, equal to the difference between the US dollar amount realised upon the sale, exchange, or other disposition and the US holder’s tax basis in the ADSs or ordinary stock. Capital gain of a non-corporate US holder is generally taxed at preferential rates where the US holder has a holding period greater than one year. The deductibility of capital losses is subject to limitations. The gain or loss will generally be income or loss from sources within the US for foreign tax credit limitation purposes.
 
PFIC Rules:  The Bank believes that ADSs and ordinary stock should not be treated as stock of a Passive Foreign Investment Company (“PFIC”) for US federal income tax purposes, but this conclusion is a factual determination that is made annually and thus may be subject to change. If, contrary to the Bank’s belief, the Bank were to be treated as a PFIC, gain realised on the sale or other disposition of a US holder’s ADSs or ordinary stock would in general not be treated as a capital gain. Instead, a US holder would be treated as if it had realised such gain and certain “excess distributions” ratably over its holding period for the ADSs or ordinary stock and would be taxed at the highest tax rate in effect for each such year to which the gain was allocated, together with an interest charge in respect of the tax attributable to each such year. With certain exceptions, a US holder’s ADSs or ordinary stock will


162


Table of Contents

be treated as stock in a PFIC if the Group Bank were a PFIC at any time during such US holder’s holding period in its ADSs or ordinary stock. Dividends received by a US holder from the Group Bank will not be eligible for the special tax rates applicable to qualified dividend income if the Group Bank is treated as a PFIC with respect to such US holder either in the taxable year of the distribution or the preceding taxable year, but instead will be taxable at rates applicable to ordinary income.
 
DOCUMENTS AVAILABLE THROUGH THE SEC
 
It is possible to read and copy documents referred to in this annual report on Form 20-F that have been filed with the SEC at the SEC’s public reference room located at 100 F Street, N.E., Washington, D.C. 20549. Please call the SEC at 1-800-SEC-0330 for further information on the public reference room and its copy charges. Documents filed with the SEC on or after November 4, 2002 are available on the website maintained by the SEC (www.sec.gov).
 
RELATIONS WITH STOCKHOLDERS
 
Communication with stockholders is given high priority. The Group seeks to provide through its Annual Report a balanced, clear assessment of the Group’s performance and prospects. It also uses its website, (www.bankofireland.com) to provide investors with the full text of the Annual Report and Interim Statement, the Form 20-F (which is filed annually with the US Securities and Exchange Commission) and with copies of presentations to analysts and investors as they are made, so that information is available to all stockholders. Annual and interim results presentations are webcast live so that all stockholders can receive the same information at the same time.
 
Additionally, the Investor Relations section on the Group’s website is updated with all Stock Exchange releases as they are made by the Group. The outcome of every General Meeting of the Group, including detailed voting results, is published on the Group’s website as well as being released to all Stock Exchanges on which the Group’s securities are traded. The Group has an active and well developed Investor Relations programme, which involves regular meetings by the Group Chief Executive, members of his senior executive team and the Head of Group Investor Relations with the Group’s principal institutional stockholders and with financial analysts and brokers. The Directors are kept informed on investor issues through regular reports from Group Investor Relations on the outcome of these meetings. All meetings with stockholders are conducted in such a way so as to ensure that price sensitive information is not divulged. In addition, all Directors are encouraged and facilitated to hear the views of investors and analysts at first hand through their participation in conference calls following major announcements. The Court concluded that the objective of keeping Directors fully informed on stockholder views was achieved in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009.
 
The Governor and/or the Senior Independent Director are available to stockholders if they have concerns that cannot be resolved through the normal channels.
 
The Group’s policy is to make constructive use of the Annual General Court and all stockholders are encouraged to participate. Stockholders are given the opportunity to ask questions at the Annual General Court. The notice of the Annual General Court is normally issued at least 20 working days before the meeting in line with the requirements of the Combined Code. However, 21 calendar days’ notice of the Annual General Court, held on May 19, 2010, was given to stockholders, due to the need to align the timing of the Annual General Court with that of the Extraordinary General Court held on the same day. Following the implementation in Ireland of the EU Shareholders’ Rights Directive, the Bye-Laws have been amended to allow an Extraordinary General Court, other than an Extraordinary General Court called for the passing of a special resolution, to be convened by giving 14 days’ notice of the meeting. At the Annual General Court, separate resolutions are proposed on each substantially separate issue and voting is conducted by way of poll. The votes for, against and abstaining, on each resolution, including proxies, are posted on the Group’s website as soon as possible afterwards and released to the Stock Exchange. It is usual for all Directors to attend all General Courts and to be available to meet stockholders and for the Chairs of the Group Audit, Nomination and Governance and Remuneration Committees to be available to answer relevant questions. In addition a ‘Help Desk’ facility is available at all General Courts to assist stockholders to resolve any specific queries that they may have.


163


Table of Contents

Item 11   QUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE DISCLOSURES ABOUT MARKET RISK
 
Risks are unexpected future events that could influence the achievement of the Group’s strategic, financial, capital or other objectives. One of the Group’s core business objectives is to engage in calculated, profitable risk taking, applying strong risk management skill to ensure risk diversification and the achievement of targeted returns. Proactive identification and management of risk is therefore central to delivery of the Group’s strategy and underpins operations throughout the Group.
 
Risk Management Approach
 
The Group follows an integrated approach to risk management to ensure that all material classes of risk are taken into account and that its risk management and capital management strategies are aligned with its overall business strategy. This integrated approach is set out in the Group Risk Framework, which is approved by the Court of Directors. It describes the Group’s formal governance process around risk and the approach to risk identification, assessment, analysis and reporting.
 
Risk Management Structure & Organisation
 
Risk Governance
 
The Group completed a review of its risk governance framework in May 2009 taking account of the impact of the financial crisis on the Group and on the financial services sector. The outcome of the review has resulted in several recommendations that have been or are currently being implemented. These include:
 
•  establishment of a new non-executive board level committee — the Court Risk Committee — with specific responsibility for advising the Court on all risk issues,
 
•  the terms of reference and membership of key risk committees have been refined and updated for emerging best practice recommendations,
 
•  the content of risk reporting has been enhanced and the frequency of reporting to senior management and the Court has increased,
 
•  an internal reorganisation has been implemented, which includes a split of the role of the Chief Risk Officer into two functions — Chief Credit & Market Risk Officer (CCMRO) and Chief Governance Risk Officer (CGRO) — both of whom are members of the Group Executive, reporting directly to the Group Chief Executive Officer. The restructure was designed to enhance the status of risk at executive level and give greater line of sight on accountability and responsibility for risk;
 
•  the responsibilities of the CCMRO include the management of credit and market risk and overall integrated risk reporting to the Group Executive team, the CRC and the Court;
 
•  The CGRO has responsibility for the management of the Group Regulatory, Compliance and Operational Risk function, Group Internal Audit, Group Legal Services and the Group Secretariat.
 
Responsibilities for risk management extend throughout the organisation.
 
•  The Court of Directors is responsible for approving high level policy and strategic direction in relation to the nature and scale of risk that the Group is prepared to assume to achieve its corporate objectives. The Court ensures that an appropriate system of internal control is maintained and reviews its effectiveness. It regularly reviews reports on the size and composition of key risks facing the Group as well as the proceedings of key committees;
 
•  The CRC was established following internal and external reviews of risk governance in 2009. The committee comprises non-executive Directors of the Court and its primary responsibilities are to assist the Court in discharging its responsibilities in overseeing risk management in the Group. To that end it forms a view on the key risks facing the Group, on the quality and effectiveness of risk identification, assessment, control and reporting, reviews the extent to which strategy is informed by and aligned with the Group’s risk appetite and


164


Table of Contents

reports its findings to the Court. It meets at least six times annually and more often if required. The committee met four times in the latter half of 2009.
 
•  The GAC assists the Court in fulfilling its responsibilities in relation to risk management by, inter alia, reviewing and evaluating the Group’s procedures for fraud prevention and detection; all regulatory contact in all jurisdictions, such as inspections, disciplinary matters and emerging developments; whether management is setting the appropriate “control culture” through communication and example and the timely implementation of recommendations; and a formal annual report of the effectiveness of the Group’s system of internal controls, covering all material controls, including financial, operational and compliance controls and risk management systems (“Annual Controls Review”).
 
•  The GRPC is the senior management risk committee of the Group. It is appointed by and reports directly to the Court. It is chaired by the Chief Credit & Market Risk Officer (CCMRO). The GRPC exercises authority delegated by the Court to approve business initiatives that have material implications for the level or composition of risk, and which are consistent with high level policy approved by the Court. The CRC and the Court oversee the decisions of the GRPC through a review of the GRPC minutes. The GRPC delegates specific responsibility for oversight of the major classes of risk (credit, market, liquidity, operational, regulatory) to specific committees that are accountable to it.
 
The Group’s approach to risk management is based on three lines of defence.
 
1.  Primary responsibility and accountability for risk management lies with line management in individual businesses. Every business unit is responsible for the identification and management of risk at business unit level including the implementation of appropriate controls and reporting to the Group in respect of all major risk events. Business units are the owners of the risks arising in their businesses, are accountable for them and are the first line of defence for the Group in managing them.
 
2.  Central risk management functions are responsible for establishing a risk control framework, formulating risk policy and strategy, and providing independent oversight and analysis and centralised reporting of key risks. This includes divisional credit functions (reporting to the CCMRO) responsible for independent oversight and analysis of credit risk within their respective divisions.
 
3.  Group Internal Audit is responsible for providing control assurance to the Court, Group Audit Committee and senior management and other interested parties such as the regulators and external auditors. This includes Group Credit Review (GCR) who are responsible for the review of the quality and management of credit risk assets across the Group. Independence is assured through direct access to the chair of the Group Audit Committee.
 
The organisational structure for risk management is designed to facilitate reporting and escalation of risk concerns from business units and risk functions upwards to the GRPC, the CRC and the Court of Directors, and the conveying of approved risk management policies and decisions from the Court and the GRPC to business units. In addition, Group Treasury (formerly Asset and Liability Management) is responsible for capital planning & management, liquidity planning and management, transfer pricing, balance sheet management and contingent liquidity programmes. The Group Treasurer heads the function and reports directly to the Group Chief Financial Officer. Risk Strategy, Analysis and Reporting, in conjunction with Group Treasury assess the impact of the most material risks on the Group’s capital ratios
 
RISK STRATEGY AND APPETITE
 
The Group’s risk strategy and risk appetite is set by the Court of Directors and reviewed on an ongoing basis by the GRPC, the CRC and the Court
 
Risk Strategy
 
The Group’s core business objective is to engage in calculated and profitable risk taking to ensure adequate returns after taking risk into account. There are also risks that the Group wishes to avoid which, in addition to financial


165


Table of Contents

impacts, would lead to reputational damage in the perception of the Group by its customers, investors, suppliers, employees, regulators or the wider public.
 
The objectives of risk strategy are
 
•  to ensure that all material risks are correctly identified, measured and adequately controlled
 
•  to allocate clear roles, responsibilities and accountabilities for the control of risk within the Group, and
 
•  to raise awareness of and commitment to the principles of risk management.
 
Risk Appetite
 
Risk appetite, which is approved by the Court, defines the amount and nature of risk the Group is prepared to accept in pursuit of its financial objectives. Given the unprecedented deterioration in economic conditions and the resulting strain on the Group’s asset quality, capital and funding metrics, the Group is following a strategy designed to reduce its overall risk profile through increased capital ratios and decreased reliance on wholesale funding. Together these measures look to significantly reduce risk levels for stockholders and bondholders. This strategy also calls for the Group to exit from some lending portfolios. This strategy sets the Group’s risk appetite by targeting the level of exposure to individual asset classes, the quantum and sources of funding and capital levels.
 
As economic conditions improve and as capital and funding levels strengthen, the Group’s risk appetite will reflect its aims to deliver sustainable growth through the pursuit of business strategies which are aligned with the Group’s risk principles. These principles stipulate that for significant risks that the Group assumes, it must have the ability to assess the risk and have appropriate resources and skills to manage them. The principles also stipulate that the Group must have appropriate governance processes in place, and must ensure that the risk does not cause any undue concentrations.
 
Risk Appetite guides the Group in its risk taking and related business activities. The Group’s Risk Appetite Statement is derived having regard to the maintenance of financial stability, solvency and the protection of the Group’s core franchises and growth platforms in the context of earning an appropriate return. The Group has defined measures to track its risk profile against the most significant risks that it assumes. Each of these measures has a defined target level or limit, as appropriate, and actuals are tracked against these targets and limits. All measures are reported to the GRPC, the CRC and to the Court through the Court Risk Report. The Group’s risk appetite and risk profile must be aligned. Where the Group has a risk profile that is in excess of its risk appetite, it will take action to realign the risk profile through increased risk mitigation activities and risk reduction.
 
RISK IDENTIFICATION PROCESS
 
Risks facing the Group are identified and assessed at least annually through the Group’s Risk Identification Process.
 
Risks that are deemed material are included in the Group Risk Framework, owners identified, appropriate policies put in place and a formalised measurement and management process defined and implemented.
 
The Group has identified ten risk types that it believes could have a material impact on earnings, capital adequacy and on its ability to trade in the future. These ten risks have been assigned owners who report on and/or actively manage the risk within formalised measurement and management processes. The ten risk types are:
 
Credit risk is defined as the risk of loss resulting from a counterparty being unable to meet its contractual obligations to the Group in respect of loans or other financial transactions. This risk includes concentration risk and country risk.
 
Liquidity risk is the risk that the Group will experience difficulty in financing its assets and/or meeting its contractual payment obligations as they fall due, or will only be able to do so at substantially above the prevailing market cost of funds. Factors that may increase the Group’s cost of funds would be rating downgrades or other factors which change the market’s willingness to supply funding to the Group.
 
Business risk is the risk of loss due to uncertainty in profits or earnings volatility that damage the franchise or operational economics of a business. The uncertainty in profits or earnings volatility may be caused by changes in


166


Table of Contents

the competitive environment such as volume, margin or cost changes due to new entrants to the market, the introduction of new products, or a sudden shift in customer behaviour or demand, or by an inflexible cost structure that does not respond to a fall in earnings. Business risk also includes the risk of loss due to the inability to recruit, train, develop, motivate and/or retain appropriate numbers and/or calibre of staff and specifically the risk of loss of key personnel impacting the operation of one or more of the Group’s businesses.
 
Market risk is the risk of loss due to an adverse change in the Group’s income or net worth, arising from movements in interest rates, exchange rates or other market prices.
 
Pension risk is the risk that the assets of the schemes fail to generate returns that are sufficient to meet fully the liabilities of the schemes. This risk crystallises when a deficit emerges of a size which implies a material probability that the liabilities will not be fully met.
 
Operational risk is defined as the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, people related events and systems, or from external events and outsourcing arrangements. It includes legal and contractual risk which is the risk of loss due to litigation arising from errors, omissions, and acts by the Group in the conduct of its business.
 
Regulatory risk is the risk arising from a breach of regulatory and compliance deadlines and requirements. Regulatory risk arises from a failure to comply with the laws, regulations or codes applicable to the financial services industry in the jurisdictions within which the Group operates. Regulatory risk also includes tax compliance risk, which is the risk of loss due to non-compliance with tax legislation and the Group’s tax policy.
 
Life insurance risk is defined as the volatility in the amount and timing of claims caused by unexpected changes in mortality, morbidity and longevity.
 
Model risk is the risk that the Group’s suite of risk models inaccurately measures a risk to some exposures, resulting in it holding inadequate capital (economic or regulatory) or being subject to economic, regulatory and/or market censure.
 
Reputation risk is the risk to earnings arising from adverse perception of the Group’s image on the part of customers, suppliers, counterparties, stockholders, investors or regulators.
 
While business units remain responsible for the identification and management of risk in their businesses, risk management functions are responsible for establishing a risk control framework.
 
As discussed earlier, many of these risks are impacted by unfavourable changes in economic conditions.
 
The Group’s Capital Management function assesses the impact of the most material risks on the Group’s capital ratios.
 
In addition to, and separate from, the Group’s Risk Identification Process, the top five risks facing the Group are identified on a half yearly basis whereby members of the Group Executive and the GRPC identify and rank the top five macro risks facing the Group for consideration by the CRC and the Court. The following criteria are used to identify and assess the top risks:
 
•  the severity of the risk in terms of materiality and the length of time it would take the Group to recover,
 
•  the likelihood of the risk occurring; and
 
•  the impact of the risk, taking mitigants and likelihood into account.
 
RISK MEASUREMENT
 
Risk management systems are in place to facilitate measurement, monitoring and analysis of risk. These systems are in line with good practice and ensure compliance with regulatory requirements. In addition to the assessment of individual risks on a case-by-case basis, the Group also measures its exposure to risk at an aggregate level using, among other techniques, economic capital estimates and stress testing.


167


Table of Contents

Economic capital
 
The Group uses Economic Capital (Ecap) as a metric by which risk is assessed, risk based budgets and strategic plans are articulated and an internal risk based capital framework is applied. Ecap is used internally for capital planning as well as for the calculation of risk adjusted returns. The common measure of return on risk used by the Group is Risk Adjusted Return on Economic Capital (RAROC).
 
Stress testing and scenario analysis
 
The Group conducts stress tests in order to assess the impact of adverse scenarios on the Group’s loan impairment charges, profits, capital requirements and funding. Learning from the severity of recent events affecting the global economy and financial markets will inform the manner in which stress tests are utilised as a risk management and capital planning tool. For example, stress test results can be used to inform limits and other risk mitigating actions such as de-leveraging and to inform the amount and quality of capital required.
 
The results of stress tests are used to assess the Group’s resilience to adverse scenarios and to aid the identification of potential areas of vulnerability or risk concentration. The tests are applied to the current risk exposures of the Group and also consider new business volumes as projected in the Group’s business plan and strategy. Macroeconomic scenarios of different levels of severity are combined with assumptions on volume growth and margin development. Impacts are measured in terms of potential loan losses, profits and regulatory and economic capital requirements.
 
In addition to stress tests based on deteriorating macroeconomic conditions, the Group also carries out and analyses specific scenario-based stresses. These capture and quantify
 
•  the potential exposure to specific risks such as concentrations to particular sectors, counterparties or geographies, and
 
•  vulnerabilities to operational and environmental events.
 
The Group also performs other stress tests such as on individual credit models and market risk exposures, for the management and limit-setting of individual risks.
 
RISK REPORTING
 
On a quarterly basis, material risks identified under the Group’s Risk Identification Process are assessed and their status is reported by the CCMRO in the Court Risk Report in the first instance to the GRPC. This report is also submitted to the CRC and the Court. The format of this report is approved by the CRC. The content of the quarterly report includes analysis of and commentary on all material risk types as set out in pages 166 and 167. It also addresses governance and control issues and the Group’s capital position.
 
In addition to the quarterly report, the GRPC, the CRC and the Court consider more frequent formal updates on the key areas of credit and liquidity risk and capital management. The reports also provide data on the external economic environment and management’s view of the implications of this environment on the Group’s risk profile.
 
The CRC and the Court also receive risk information through their review of the GRPC minutes and also carry out investigations into specific risk matters in greater depth.
 
LIQUIDITY RISK
 
See note 56 to the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
CREDIT RISK
 
See note 56 to the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
MARKET RISK
 
See note 56 to the Consolidated Financial Statements.


168


Table of Contents

REGULATORY, COMPLIANCE & OPERATIONAL RISK
 
Regulatory, compliance and operational risk has increased over the course of the calendar year in light of industry developments and increased regulatory supervision.
 
Under the CIFS Scheme, the Governor and Group Chief Executive sign a quarterly compliance certificate, The Group is also required to obtain a Compliance Certificate on the Quarterly Compliance Certificate from its auditors,--PricewaterhouseCoopers.
 
The Minister of Finance also has significantly increased powers as part of this Scheme, including the power to appoint non-executive Directors.
 
The Group, in common with other covered institutions, is subject to close supervision by the Financial Regulator. The Financial Regulator has also appointed observers to attend the Court, Group Risk Policy Committee (GRPC), ALCO, Group Liquidity Committee, Group Regulatory, Compliance and Operational Risk Committee, Group Credit Committee, Group Audit Committee and the Court Risk Committee (CRC).
 
The Court oversees regulatory compliance with the extensive supervisory and regulatory regimes to which the Group is subject, principally in Ireland, the UK and the US, and the Group’s operational risks, through
 
•  the Group Audit Committee (GAC) and the Court Risk Committee — to both of whom the Head of Group Regulatory, Compliance and Operational Risk reports semi annually,
 
•  the Group Regulatory, Compliance and Operational Risk Committee (GRCORC), a committee appointed by the GRPC. The minutes of GRCORC meetings are provided to the GRPC and the Head of Group Regulatory, Compliance and Operational Risk reports to the GRPC semi annually, and
 
•  a Regulatory, Compliance and Operational Risk status update is included in the Court Risk Report presented to the GRPC, the CRC and the Court on a quarterly basis.
 
The GRCORC discharges its responsibilities principally through its meetings at which a comprehensive report on Regulatory, Compliance and Operational Risk is presented by the Group Regulatory, Compliance and Operational Risk function (GRCOR). In addition, the Committee receives presentations from Business and Support Units concerning their particular operations and addressing the management of those risks as they arise within them. In addition the Committee determines the Top 6 Risks (of a Regulatory, Compliance and Operational Risk nature) facing the Group.
 
The GRCOR function supports the GRCORC and manages the Group’s risks associated with operations, legal compliance, data privacy, business continuity, and compliance with legislation including anti money laundering. It also reviews upstream risks in relation to regulatory, compliance and operational developments.
 
The Head of the GRCOR function is responsible for formulating and communicating the risk control framework for the management of regulatory, compliance and operational risks and for monitoring the implementation of the framework by business management across the Group. Regulatory, compliance and operational risk policies are implemented by business units, subject to monitoring and support from the GRCOR function. The GRCORC also promotes awareness of regulatory, compliance and operational risks throughout the Group.
 
Key internal developments in the past year
 
The Group has amended its organisational structure for the management of regulatory, compliance and operational risk. Staff continue to operate in business units supporting the business, but now report to Divisional Risk Partner teams who are supported by specialist GRCOR function Centres of Expertise teams providing policy and advice. Regulated entities continue to have appointed compliance officers who also report to local management. This is in line with best practice internationally and aligns regulatory, compliance and operational risk with other support functions in the Group.


169


Table of Contents

REGULATORY AND COMPLIANCE RISK
 
Definition
 
Regulatory and compliance risk is the risk arising from a breach of regulatory or compliance deadlines and requirements. It arises from a failure to comply with the laws, regulations or codes applicable to the financial services industry in the jurisdictions within which the Group operates. Non-compliance has adverse reputational implications and may lead to fines, public reprimands, enforced suspension of operations or, in extreme cases, withdrawal of authorisation to operate.
 
Management of Regulatory and Compliance Risk
 
The Group manages regulatory and compliance risk under an overall framework, which is implemented by accountable executives, monitored by the GRPC, the GAC, the CRC and the GRCORC, and supported by the GRCOR function. The effective management of regulatory and compliance risk is primarily the responsibility of business management.
 
The Group’s regulatory and compliance practices are governed by policy formulated by the GRCORC and approved by the GRPC, on behalf of the Court. This requires the conduct of business in accordance with applicable regulations and with an awareness of regulatory and compliance risk by all employees.
 
The Group has established a formal approach to the management of regulatory and compliance risk and the objective is the identification, assessment, monitoring and management of regulatory and compliance risks.
 
Business units, divisions, and the GRCOR function undertake risk based regulatory and compliance monitoring, and annual monitoring plans are reviewed to reflect changes or emerging risks. Regulatory compliance reports from business units are analysed and reviewed by the GRCOR function and by the GRCORC.
 
OPERATIONAL RISK
 
Definition
 
Operational risks are present in the Group’s business, through inadequate or failed internal processes (including financial reporting and risk monitoring processes), Information Technology (IT) or equipment failures or the failure of external systems and controls including those of the Group’s suppliers or counterparties (supplier and counterparty systems, controls and processes) being entirely outside the control of the Group or from people related or external events, including the risk of fraud and other criminal acts carried out against the Group. In the case of legal and contractual risk, this includes the risk of loss due to litigation arising from errors, omissions, and acts by the Group in the conduct of its business.
 
Management of Operational Risk
 
The Group has established a formal approach to the management of operational risk in the form of the “Operational Risk Management Framework” to identify, assess, monitor and manage operational risks which may impact the achievement of the Group’s business objectives. It consists of:
 
•  formulation and dissemination of the Group Operational Risk policy,
 
•  establishment of organisational structures for the oversight, monitoring and management of operational risk throughout the Group,
 
•  embedding the operational risk management process in business and support units throughout the Group, and
 
•  maintenance of awareness and training of relevant staff in the operational risk management process.
 
The Group’s exposure to operational risk is governed by policy formulated by the GRCORC and approved by the GRPC, on behalf of the Court. Policies for management of specific aspects of operational risk are approved and monitored by GRCORC.


170


Table of Contents

Business units are responsible for effective implementation of the operational risk policy, and the head of each business unit provides the GRCOR function with a certificate of compliance with the requirements of the policy semi annually. In addition, the GRCOR function monitors compliance through review of management reports provided by the business units; through periodic visits to business and support functions to inspect practices and compliance with policies; and through monitoring of the nature, scale and frequency of loss events.
 
Risk Mitigation
 
The Group implements specific policies and risk mitigation measures for key risks, including financial crime, data protection and privacy and business contingency planning risks. This strategy is further supported by risk transfer mechanisms such as the Group’s insurance programme, whereby selected risks are reinsured externally.
 
Risk Reporting
 
The Head of the GRCOR function reports to the GRCORC on the status of operational risk in the Group, including status of these key risks across the Group and progress of risk mitigation initiatives, significant loss events and the nature, scale and frequency of overall losses.
 
BUSINESS RISK
 
Definition
 
Business risk is the risk of loss due to uncertainty in profits or earnings volatility that damage the franchise or operational economics of the Group’s business. This uncertainty may be caused by changes in the competitive environment, a collapse in economic conditions affecting prices, volumes and exchange rates, an inflexible cost structure that does not respond to a changed environment, the possibility of severe industrial relations disputes disrupting operations or the curtailment of strategically important investments leading to an inability to sustain future requirements. The Group faces business risk as a direct or indirect consequence of its business activities.
 
Risk management, measurement and reporting
 
The Group reviews business risk as part of the annual risk identification process. The risk is managed on a divisional basis, and measured quarterly, with a scorecard addressing moves in key indicators around income diversification, margin trends, customer advocacy, direct and indirect costs and staff turnover and engagement. Input from the Group’s divisions is collated by Risk Strategy Analysis & Reporting, who liaise with Group Finance to provide an overall group context and assess the impact of changes in the environment on the 5 year plan. An update is provided quarterly in the Court Risk Report.
 
Risk mitigation
 
The Group’s main mitigants for business risk include the diversification of income streams across products, segments, business sectors and locations and good employee relations. Flexibility in cost base also helps mitigate business risk. The Group depends in part on the continued service of key members of its management team. The ability to continue to attract, train, motivate and retain highly qualified professionals is a key element of the Group’s strategy.
 
PENSION RISK
 
Definition
 
Pension risk is the risk that the assets of the schemes fail to generate returns that are sufficient to meet fully the liabilities of the schemes. This risk crystallises when a deficit emerges of a size which implies a material probability that the liabilities will not be fully met.


171


Table of Contents

Risk management, measurement and reporting
 
The Group maintains a number of defined benefit pension schemes for past and current employees. In the past year, the rise in equity markets has increased the value of scheme assets but the decline in long-term yields and, for this purpose, long-term corporate bond yields which determine the discount rate under the IAS 19 accounting standard, has more than offset these gains. The Group’s IAS 19 pension deficit at December 31, 2009 was €1.6 billion (March 31, 2009: €1.5 billion).
 
The investment policy pursued to meet the Scheme’s estimated future liabilities is a matter for the Trustees and the Scheme’s Investment Committee. The Group, as sponsor, is afforded an opportunity to communicate its views on investment strategy to the Trustees and receives regular updates including scenario analysis of pension risk.
 
The GRPC reviews pension risk and the Court is informed quarterly of the GRPC’s risk deliberations through a review of the GRPC proceedings and through the Court Risk Report.
 
Risk mitigation
 
In order to mitigate pension risk, a new scheme was introduced in 2006 for all new entrants which has adjusted terms for new members (see note 43 to the Consolidated Financial Statements). In January 2010, the Group announced a comprehensive review of all aspects of its pension provision. This included an assessment of the appropriate level of pension risk that the schemes should entail for the sponsor. Under the review, the Group and other stakeholders have been considering a range of measures to reduce the current deficit. To the extent that the Group has to contribute to the deficit, such contributions could be significant and may have a negative impact on the Group’s financial condition and prospects. For further information on the current status of this review, please refer to note 58 of the Consolidated Financial Statements.
 
REPUTATION RISK
 
Definition
 
Reputation risk is defined as the risk of loss/volatility of earnings arising from adverse perception of the Group’s image on part of the customers, suppliers, counterparties, stockholders, investors and regulators. This risk typically materialises through a loss of business in the areas affected.
 
The Group uses business and management processes rather than capital in its mitigation.
 
Risk management, measurement and reporting
 
Group Communications is the primary function responsible for managing reputation risk. It includes all external and internal communications, public affairs and corporate responsibility, helping to reinforce the Group’s reputation with its employees, customers, government, general public and the wider community.
 
The Group Government Relations function, which is part of Group Communications, was established in July 2009 against the backdrop of the increased need for ongoing communication both formal and informal with government, political and public sector processes in all markets. The function helps to ensure that reputation risk is minimised through proactive engagement with governments.
 
Reputation risk indicators are tracked on an ongoing basis. These indicators include external market conditions and risk events which may have the potential to impact reputation and surveys measuring customer sentiment.
 
The Group reviews reputation risk as part of the annual risk identification process. Quarterly updates are reported to the GRPC, the CRC and the Court as part of the Court Risk Report.
 
Risk mitigation
 
A wide range of processes and structures are used to identify, assess and mitigate the potential risk to the Group’s reputation. Managing the Group in a manner that ensures that the potential impact on the Group’s reputation is taken into account in decision making is paramount in mitigating against reputation risk.


172


Table of Contents

 
CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
 
In June 2009 the Group announced the successful completion of a debt re-purchase programme of €1.7 billion of euro, sterling and US dollar denominated non core tier 1 securities. This initiative increased the Group’s equity tier 1 by €1 billion. The Group’s equity tier 1, core tier 1, tier 1 and total capital ratios at December 31, 2009 were 5.3%, 8.9%, 9.8% and 13.4% respectively.
 
In February 2010, the Group successfully completed an exchange of €1.6 billion of dated (lower tier 2) subordinated notes, yielding a gain to equity and core tier 1 capital of €405 million whilst leaving the total capital position unchanged.
 
The Financial Regulator has completed a Prudential Capital Assessment Review (“PCAR”) for Bank of Ireland in order to assess its capital requirements. This review has taken into account both expected base and potential stressed loan losses, together with other financial developments, over a 3 year time horizon to December 31, 2012.
 
The PCAR has been undertaken with reference to:
 
•  a target core tier 1 ratio level of 8% in the base case. As a further prudent requirement, the capital to meet the base case target must be principally in the form of equity to meet a targeted equity tier 1 ratio of 7%.
 
•  a target level of 4% core tier 1 capital should be maintained in a stress scenario.
 
As announced on March 30, 2010, the outcome of this review was that the Financial Regulator determined that the Group needed to raise an additional €2.7 billion of equity capital by December 31, 2010 to comply with the PCAR.
 
This outcome was aligned with the Group’s previously held views. As set out in more detail in note 58(i) to the Financial Statements, the Group announced Proposals in April 2010 to increase its tier 1 capital by not less than €2.8 billion and this capital raising initiative was completed on June 8, 2010.
 
See also note 57 of the consolidated financial statements for more information on Capital Management.
 
Item 12   DESCRIPTION OF SECURITIES OTHER THAN EQUITY SECURITIES
 
American Depositary Shares
 
The Bank of New York Mellon as, Depositary collects fees for delivery and surrender of ADSs directly from investors depositing shares or surrendering ADSs for the purpose of withdrawal, or from intermediaries acting for them. The Depositary collects fees for making distributions to investors by deducting those fees from the amounts distributed or by selling a portion of distributable property to pay the fees. The Depositary may generally refuse to provide fee-attracting services until its fees for those services are paid.
 
         
Persons depositing or withdrawing shares must pay:
  For:
 
$5.00 (or less) per 100 ADSs (or portion of 100 ADSs)     Issuance of ADSs, including issuances resulting from a distribution of shares or rights or other property
      Cancellation of ADSs for the purpose of withdrawal, including if the deposit agreement terminates
$5.00 (or less) per 100 ADSs (or portion of 100 ADSs) (A fee equivalent to the fee that would be payable if securities distributed had been shares and the shares had been deposited for issuance in ADSs)     Distribution of deposited securities by the Depositary to registered ADS holders
Applicable Registration or transfer fee     Transfer and registration of shares on our share register to or from the name of the Depositary or its agent when the holder deposits or withdraws shares
Applicable Expenses of the Depositary     Cable, telex and facsimile transmissions
Applicable Taxes and other governmental charges the Depositary or the custodian have to pay on any ADS or share underlying an ADS, for example, stock transfer taxes, stamp duty or withholding taxes     As necessary


173


Table of Contents

 
Fees and direct and indirect payments made by the Depositary to the Group
 
The Depositary has agreed to reimburse certain Group expenses related to the Group’s ADS programme and incurred by the Group in connection with the ADS programme. For the period ended December 31, 2009, the Depositary reimbursed to the Group, or paid amounts on its behalf to third parties, a total sum of €72,010.
 
The table below sets forth the categories of expense that the Depositary has agreed to reimburse the Group and the amounts reimbursed for the period ended December 31, 2009.
 
         
    Amount reimbursed
    for the
    9 months
    ended December
Category of expense reimbursed to the Group   31, 2009
 
    $  
NYSE listing fees
     
Investor Relations programme support*
    125,000  
Total
    125,000  
 
 
The reimbursement of $125,000 includes $38,000 NYSE annual fee for listing ADS which Bank of Ireland paid directly to NYSE.
 
The table below sets forth the types of expense that the Depositary has paid to third parties and the amounts reimbursed for the period ended December 31, 2009:
 
         
    Amount reimbursed
    for the
    9 months
    ended December
Category of expense waived or paid directly to third parties   31, 2009
 
    $    
NYSE listing fees
     
Printing, distribution and administration costs paid directly to third parties in connection with US shareholder communications and AGC related expenses in connection with the ADS program
    72,010  
Total
    72,010  
 
The Depositary has also agreed to waive fees for standard costs associated with the administration of the ADS program and has paid certain expenses directly to third parties on behalf of the Group.


174


Table of Contents

 
APPENDIX TO PART I — DEFINITIONS
 
€0.10 Ordinary Stock the units of Ordinary Stock following Renominalisation;
 
ACSM Hybrids the Bank UK Holdings plc €600 million (of which €476 million is outstanding) 7.4% Guaranteed Step-up Callable Perpetual Preferred Securities and the Bank UK Holdings plc £350 million (of which £46.432 million is outstanding) 6.25% Guaranteed Callable Perpetual Preferred Securities;
 
Admission the admission of units of stock to the Official Lists becoming effective in accordance with the Listing Rules and the admission of such stock to trading on the Irish Stock Exchange’s and London Stock Exchange’s markets for listed securities becoming effective in accordance with the Admission to Trading Rules of the Irish Stock Exchange and the Admission and Disclosure Standards of the London Stock Exchange respectively;
 
AFS available for sale;
 
Allotment Instruments each instrument delivered to holders thereof pursuant to the Debt for Equity Offers and issued with the benefit of the Allotment Instrument Deed Poll convertible into Conversion Ordinary Stock, the nominal value of which will not exceed €200,000,000;
 
Annual General Court or AGC an annual general meeting of stockholders of the Bank;
 
Bank of Ireland Eligible Bank Assets those assets of the Group that are designated as Eligible Bank Assets;
 
CBFSAI Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland;
 
Central Bank the Central Bank of Ireland;
 
Central Bank Acts the Central Bank Acts, 1942 to 1998 (as amended);
 
CIFS Guarantee Scheme the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Scheme 2008 (S.I. No 411 of 2008);
 
Closing Price the closing middle-market quotation of a unit of Ordinary Stock as derived from the Daily Official List;
 
Combined Code the Combined Code on Corporate Governance issued by the UK Financial Reporting Council;
 
Consumer Protection Code code issued by the Financial Regulator in August 2006 which applies to entities regulated by the Financial Regulator;
 
Control Resolution a resolution of those Stockholders who are entitled to so vote for the approval of any agreement or transaction (including a merger) whereby, or in consequence of which, Control of the Group, or substantially all of the Group’s business, is or may be acquired by any person or persons (excluding any government concert party) acting in concert and which for the avoidance of doubt shall include any resolution to approve a scheme of arrangement pursuant to section 201 of the Companies Act 1963 pursuant to which a takeover of the Group (within the meaning of the Irish Takeover Panel Act 1997 Takeover Rules (as amended, replaced or substituted from time to time)) would be effected or approved or a merger or division of The Bank pursuant to the European Communities (Mergers and Divisions of Companies) Regulations, 1987 (Statutory Instrument 137 of 1987) or a merger of The Bank pursuant to the European Communities (Cross-Border Mergers) Regulations 2008 (Statutory Instrument 157 of 2008);


175


Table of Contents

 
Conversion Ordinary Stock up to a maximum of €200 million of new Ordinary Stock to be allocated and issued by the Bank upon conversion of the Allotment Instruments (on or around the Conversion Date);
 
Debt for Equity Offers each of the US Debt for Equity Offers and the Non-US Debt for Equity Offers;
 
Default Stock units of Ordinary Stock belonging to a member who fails to disclose the person or persons for whom he/she holds such Ordinary Stock in trust with the result that the Directors serve a disenfranchisement notice on such member with the consequence that the member may not attend or vote, either personally or by proxy, at any General Court of the Bank or exercise any other rights conferred by membership in respect of his or her holding of Ordinary Stock;
 
Deferred Stock units of deferred stock in the capital of the Bank created pursuant to the Renominalisation;
 
Department of Finance Department of Finance of Ireland;
 
DWT dividend withholding tax;
 
Eligible Bank Assets those classes of assets prescribed as eligible bank assets by the Minister for Finance, in accordance with section 69 of the NAMA Act;
 
ESOS the executive stock option scheme as described in the Remuneration of Directors ;
 
ESRI the Economic and Social Research Institute;
 
EU Restructuring Plan the EU restructuring plan for the Group to be approved by the European Commission following negotiations based on the draft plan prepared by the Bank and submitted by the Department of Finance on 30 September 2009;
 
Existing Stock the units of Ordinary Stock in issue as at April 26, 2009;
 
Extraordinary General Court or EGC an extraordinary general meeting of stockholders of the Bank;
 
Financial Regulator the Irish Financial Services Regulatory Authority;
 
Fully Paid Rights rights which are provisionally allotted to Qualifying Stockholders pursuant to the Rights Issue and which are recorded in the register of the Bank as having been paid at the Rights Issue Price;
 
Government Appointee a director appointed by a Government Preference Stockholder or the Minister for Finance pursuant to the CIFS Guarantee Scheme;
 
Government Transaction the NPRFC Placing, the Warrant Cancellation, the NPRFC Rights Issue Undertaking, the amendment of the rights attaching to the 2009 Preference Stock and the other transactions, rights and obligations set out in the Government Transaction Agreement;
 
Government Transaction Agreement the transaction agreement between the Bank, the NPRFC and the Minister for Finance entered into in connection with the Government Transaction;
 
Hybrid/Preferred Securities Bank of Ireland Capital Funding (No. 1) LP, €600,000,000 Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities, the LP2 Securities, the LP3 Securities and Bank of Ireland Capital Funding (No. 4) LP £500,000,000 Fixed Rate/Floating Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities;


176


Table of Contents

 
Institutional Placing the placing of Ordinary Stock with institutional investors (but excluding the NPRFC);
 
Irish Government Measures the Irish Government is proposing to introduce a set of measures for the Irish banking sector which would complement the specific measures agreed as part of the individual European Commission restructuring plans for Irish banks that are subject to restructuring under EU State aid rules (among which includes the EU Restructuring Plan);
 
Joint Bookrunners or joint bookrunners Citi, Credit Suisse, Davy, Deutsche Bank and UBS;
 
Minister for Finance or Minister the Minister for Finance of Ireland;
 
NAMA the National Asset Management Agency and, where the context permits, other members of NAMA’s group including subsidiaries and associated companies. For further information refer to www.nama.ie;
 
NAMAIL National Asset Management Agency Investment Limited;
 
National Pensions Reserve Fund the fund established by the National Pensions Reserve Fund Act, 2000 to meet (insofar as possible) the costs of Ireland’s social welfare and public service pensions from 2025 onwards;
 
Nil Paid Rights rights to acquire Rights Issue Stock, where the amount payable on acceptance of the offer of Rights Issue Stock has not been paid;
 
NPRFC the National Pensions Reserve Fund Commission, established by the National Pensions Reserve Fund Act 2000 to, inter alia, control, manage and invest the assets of the National Pensions Reserve Fund. References herein to the NPRFC mean the NPRFC acting in its capacity as controller and manager of the National Pensions Reserve Fund;
 
NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock 184,394,378 units of Ordinary Stock issued to the NPRFC on Monday 22 February 2010 in lieu of the cash dividend otherwise due on the 2009 Preference Stock;
 
NPRFC Investment the subscription by the NPRFC for €3.5 billion of 2009 Preference Stock in the Bank and the issue of the Warrants completed on 31 March 2009;
 
NPRFC Placing the proposed conversion by the NPRFC of units of 2009 Preference Stock to units of Ordinary Stock as part of the Placing;
 
NPRFC Placing Fee a fee payable to the NPRFC equal to 1% of the subscription price for all units of 2009 Preference Stock converted pursuant to the NPRFC Placing;
 
NPRFC Placing Price €1.80 per unit of Ordinary Stock issued under the NPRFC Placing;
 
Participating Institution a credit institution designated by the Minister for Finance as a participating institution in accordance with the provisions of section 67 of the NAMA Act;
 
Placees persons with whom Placing Stock is to be placed, including, in the case of the NPRFC Placing and where the context so permits, the NPRFC;
 
Placing Stock the 326,797,386 units of Ordinary Stock to be issued by the Bank pursuant to the Institutional Placing;
 
Preference Stock means the 2009 Preference Stock and the 1992 Preference Stock;


177


Table of Contents

 
Proposals the Institutional Placing, the Rights Issue, the Debt for Equity Offers and the Government Transaction;
 
Qualifying Stockholders holders of Ordinary Stock on the register of members of the Bank at the Record Date and Placees (excluding the NPRFC in respect of the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock);
 
Record Date 5.00 p.m. on May 17, 2010;
 
Record Date Stock units of Ordinary Stock in issue as at the Record Date;
 
Renominalisation the reduction of the nominal value of units of Ordinary Stock from €0.64 each to €0.10 each and creation of Deferred Stock;
 
Resolutions the resolutions proposed at the Extraordinary General Court of May 19, 2010, excluding the resolution to reduce the stock premium of the Bank;
 
Rights rights to acquire Rights Issue Stock in the Rights Issue;
 
Rights Issue the offer by way of rights to Qualifying Stockholders to acquire Rights Issue Stock.
 
Thirty Day Average Price (i) 100% of the average daily closing price of the Ordinary Stock on the Irish Stock Exchange over the 30 dealing days immediately preceding the original scheduled dividend declaration date, (in the event that the Ordinary Stock issued in the event of non-payment of dividends on the 2009 Preference Stock is settled on the dividend payment date to which it relates); or
 
(ii) 95% of the average daily closing price of the Ordinary Stock on the Irish Stock Exchange over the 30 dealing days immediately preceding the original scheduled dividend declaration date (in the event that the Ordinary Stock, issued in the event of non-payment of dividends on the 2009 Preference Stock, is settled after the dividend payment date to which it relates);
 
Tranche 1 NAMA Assets the first tranche of Bank of Ireland Eligible Bank Assets which transferred to NAMA on April 2, 2010;
 
Transaction Fee the transaction fee of €22 million payable to the NPRFC at the closing of the NPRFC Placing;
 
Underwriters the Joint Bookrunners;
 
Underwriting Agreement the underwriting and sponsors’ agreement dated April 26, 2010 between the Bank and the Underwriters relating to the Institutional Placing and the Rights Issue;
 
Warrant Cancellation the cancellation of the Warrants in return for the payment of €491 million by the Bank to the NPRFC;


178


Table of Contents

 
PART II
 
Item 13   DEFAULTS, DIVIDEND ARREARAGES & DELINQUENCIES
 
None.
 
Item 14   MATERIAL MODIFICATIONS TO THE RIGHTS OF SECURITY HOLDERS & USE OF PROCEEDS
 
See Item 8 and note 58(i) of the Consolidated financial statements for a discussion of changes to preferential shares relevant to holders of ordinary shares.
 
Item 15   CONTROLS AND PROCEDURES
 
(a)  Evaluation of Disclosure Controls and Procedures
 
An evaluation has been completed under the supervision and with the participation of the Group’s management, including the Group Chief Executive and the Group Chief Financial Officer, of the effectiveness of the design and operation of the Group’s disclosure controls and procedures as of the end of the period covered by this report. Disclosure controls and procedures are defined in Exchange Act Rule 13a-15(e) and generally refer to those controls and procedures designed to ensure that information required to be disclosed in reports filed under the US Securities Exchange Act of 1934 is recorded, processed, summarised and reported within specific time periods. As of the date of the evaluation, the Group’s management, including the Group Chief Executive and Group Chief Financial Officer, concluded that the design and operation of these disclosure controls and procedures were effective.
 
(b)  Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting
 
The management of the Group is responsible for establishing and maintaining adequate internal control over financial reporting. The Group’s internal control over financial reporting is a process designed under the supervision of the Group Chief Executive and the Group Chief Financial Officer to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for external reporting purposes in accordance with IFRS as adopted by the European Union and the IASB.
 
Management assessed the effectiveness of the Group’s internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2009 based on the criteria set forth by the Committee of Sponsoring Organisations of the Treadway Commission (“COSO”) in Internal Control-Integrated Framework. Based on this assessment, management has concluded that, as of December 31, 2009 the Group’s internal control over financial reporting was effective.
 
Internal control systems, no matter how well designed, have inherent limitations and may not prevent or detect misstatements. Also, projections of any evaluation of effectiveness to future periods are subject to the risk that internal controls may become inadequate because of changes in conditions, or that the degree of compliance with the policies or procedures may deteriorate. See page 141 (“Internal Controls”) for additional information.
 
PricewaterhouseCoopers, an independent registered public accounting firm, audited the consolidated financial statements of the Group for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, and has issued an audit report on the effectiveness of Group’s internal controls over financial reporting as of December 31, 2009.
 
(c)  Report of Registered Public Accounting Firm
 
The attestation report of Pricewaterhouse Coopers regarding management’s assessment of the effectiveness of the Group’s internal controls on financial reporting is included herein on page F-3.
 
(d)  Changes in Internal Control over Financial Reporting
 
There were no changes in our internal control over financial reporting during the period covered by this report that have materially affected, or are reasonably likely to materially affect, our internal control over financial reporting.


179


Table of Contents

 
Item 16
 
Item 16A   Audit Committee Financial Expert
 
The Group Audit Committee comprises only independent non-executive Directors as described in the NYSE guidelines. The Court has determined that the Committee members’ collective skills together with their recent and relevant financial experience enable the Committee to discharge its responsibilities.
 
Item 16B   Code of Ethics
 
A written code of ethics has been adopted applicable to all staff including the Group Chief Executive, Group Chief Financial Officer and persons performing the functions of the principal accounting officer or controller. The code is available to any person without charge upon request to the Group Secretary. Requests should be submitted in writing to Bank of Ireland, 40 Mespil Road, Dublin 4, Ireland, Attention: Group Secretary.
 
Item 16C   Principal Accountant Fees and Services
 
During the year, the audit committee operated a comprehensive policy on the provision of non-audit services by the principal accountant to the Group. This policy provides for the pre-approval of all non-audit services as well as the prohibition on the provision of certain other named services by the Group’s auditor, PricewaterhouseCoopers. Management seeks annual pre-approval for certain categories of services which may be rendered by PricewaterhouseCoopers, along with budgets attaching to each category, which cannot be exceeded without the prior approval of the Committee. Any assignment outside of the approved categories or which would cause fees to exceed the agreed budget must be pre-approved by any one member of the Audit Committee and notified to the Audit Committee for ratification at its next meeting. Management periodically reports to the Audit Committee the amount of fees committed in respect of each category of service. It is Group policy to subject all major consultancy assignments to a competitive tender process (see note 13 of the consolidated financial statements).
 
Item 16D   Exemptions from the Listing Standards for Audit Committees
 
Not applicable.
 
Item 16E   Purchases of Equity Securities by the Issuer and Affiliated Purchasers
 
As at March 31, 2009, 10,104,443 units of ordinary stock held by the Group’s life assurance company were categorised as ‘own shares’. 1,110,682 units of ordinary stock were acquired by the life assurance company during the nine month period ended December 31, 2009. No other share purchases or disposals were made during the year. At December 31, 2009 the Group’s life assurance company held 11,215,125 units of ordinary stock as ‘own shares’.
 
Item 16F   Changes in Registrant’s Certifying Accountants
 
Not applicable.
 
Item 16G   Corporate Governance
 
As noted on page 145, there are no significant differences between the Group’s corporate governance practices and the requirements of the NYSE applicable to US companies.
 


180


Table of Contents

 
PART III
 
Item 17   FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
Not applicable
 
Item 18   FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
Financial Statements on F-1 to F-183
 
Item 19   EXHIBITS
 
         
1.1
    Charter & Acts (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 1.1 of the annual report on Form 20-F of The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland for the financial year ended March 31, 2001, File No. 1-14452).
1.2
    Bye-Laws.
4.1
    Rules of the Bank of Ireland Group Stock Options Scheme — 2004 (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 4 of the annual report on Form 20-F of The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland for the financial year ended March 31, 2001, File No. 1-14452).
4.2
    Rules of the Bank of Ireland Group Long Term Performance Stock Plan (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 4 of the annual report on Form 20-F of The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland for the financial year ended March 31, 2001, File No. 1-14452).
4.3
    Rules of the Bank of Ireland Group Long Term Incentive Plan 2004 and Executive Stock Option Scheme 2004 (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 4 of the annual report on Form 20-F of The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland for the financial year ended March 31, 2006, File No. 1-14452).
4.4
    Rules of the Bank of Ireland Group Staff Stock Issue 2006 (incorporated by reference to Exhibit 4 of the annual report on Form 20-F of The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland for the financial year ended March 31, 2006, File No. 1-14452).
4.5
    Transaction Agreement between The Minister for Finance, The National Pensions Reserve Fund Commission and The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland, dated April 26, 2010.
4.6
    Placing and Rights Issue Underwriting and Sponsors’ Agreement, dated April 26, 2010.
8
    List of significant subsidiaries — incorporated by reference to page 19 of this Form 20-F.
12.1
    Certification by the Chief Executive Officer as required by Section 302 of Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
12.2
    Certification by the Chief Financial Officer as required by Section 302 of Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
13.1
    Certification by the Chief Executive Officer as required by Section 906 of Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.
13.2
    Certification by the Chief Financial Officer as required by Section 906 of Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002.


181


 

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
INDEX TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
 
Nine Months Ended December 31, 2009
 
         
    Page
 
    F-2  
    F-3  
    F-4  
    F-5  
    F-6  
    F-7  
    F-9  
    F-11  
Critical accounting estimates and judgements
    F-36  
    F-40  


F-1


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
 
The Directors are responsible for preparing the Annual Report and the financial statements in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee (IFRIC) interpretations adopted by the European Union (EU) and with those parts of the Companies Acts, 1963 to 2009 applicable to companies reporting under IFRS and Article 4 of the IAS Regulation and the European Communities (Credit Institutions: Accounts) Regulations, 1992. In preparing these financial statements, the Directors have also elected to comply with IFRS issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB).
 
Irish company law requires the Directors to prepare financial statements which give a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the Bank and the Group and of the profit or loss of the Group. In preparing these financial statements for the nine month period to December 31, 2009, the Directors are required to:
 
•   select suitable accounting policies and then apply them consistently;
 
•   make judgements and estimates that are reasonable and prudent;
 
•   state that the financial statements comply with IFRS adopted by the EU and IFRS issued by the IASB; and
 
•   prepare the financial statements on the going concern basis unless it is inappropriate to presume that the Group will continue in business.
 
The Directors are responsible for keeping proper books of account that disclose with reasonable accuracy at any time the financial position of the Bank and enable them to ensure that the financial statements are prepared in accordance with IFRS and IFRIC interpretations endorsed by the European Union (EU) and with those parts of the Companies Acts, 1963 to 2009 applicable to companies reporting under IFRS and Article 4 of the IAS Regulation and the European Communities (Credit Institutions: Accounts) Regulations, 1992. They are also responsible for safeguarding the assets of the Bank and the Group and hence for taking reasonable steps for the prevention and detection of fraud and other irregularities.
 
The Directors are also required by the Transparency (Directive 2004 / 109 / EC) Regulations 2007 and the Transparency Rules of the Financial Regulator to include a management report containing a fair review of the business and a description of the principal risks and uncertainties facing the Group.
 
The Directors are responsible for the maintenance and integrity of the corporate and financial information included on the Bank’s website.
 
Legislation in Ireland governing the preparation and dissemination of financial statements may differ from legislation in other jurisdictions.
 
The Directors confirm that, to the best of each Director’s knowledge and belief:
 
•   they have complied with the above requirements in preparing the financial statements;
 
•   the financial statements, prepared in accordance with IFRS as adopted by the European Union (EU) and with IFRS as issued by the IASB, give a true and fair view of the assets, liabilities, financial position of the Group and the Bank and of the loss of the Group; and
 
•   the management report contained in the Business Review includes a fair review of the development and performance of the business and the position of the Group and Bank, together with a description of the principal risks and uncertainties that they face.


F-2


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
REPORT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM
 
To the Court of Directors and members of The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland
 
In our opinion, the accompanying consolidated balance sheets and the related consolidated income statements, consolidated statements of other comprehensive income, consolidated statements of cash flows and consolidated statements of changes in equity present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland (the ‘Group’) and its subsidiaries at December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2009 and the results of their operations and cash flows for the year ended March 31, 2008, the year ended March 31, 2009 and the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, in conformity with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs) as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board. Also, in our opinion the Group maintained, in all material respects, effective internal control over financial reporting as of December 31, 2009, based on criteria established in Internal Control — Integrated Framework issued by the Committee of Sponsoring Organisations of the Treadway Commission (COSO). The Group’s management are responsible for these financial statements, for maintaining effective internal control over financial reporting and for its assessment of the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting, included in “Management’s Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting” appearing under item 15(b) of this Form 20-F . Our responsibility is to express opinions on these financial statements and on the Group’s internal control over financial reporting based on our integrated audits. We conducted our audits in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States). Those standards require that we plan and perform the audits to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements are free of material misstatement and whether effective internal control over financial reporting was maintained in all material respects. Our audits of the financial statements included examining, on a test basis, evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements, assessing the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by management, and evaluating the overall financial statement presentation. Our audit of internal control over financial reporting included obtaining an understanding of internal control over financial reporting, assessing the risk that a material weakness exists, and testing and evaluating the design and operating effectiveness of internal control based on the assessed risk. Our audits also included performing such other procedures as we considered necessary in the circumstances. We believe that our audits provide a reasonable basis for our opinions.
 
A company’s internal control over financial reporting is a process designed to provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial reporting and the preparation of financial statements for external purposes in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. A company’s internal control over financial reporting includes those policies and procedures that (i) pertain to the maintenance of records that, in reasonable detail, accurately and fairly reflect the transactions and dispositions of the assets of the company; (ii) provide reasonable assurance that transactions are recorded as necessary to permit preparation of financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles, and that receipts and expenditures of the company are being made only in accordance with authorizations of management and directors of the company; and (iii) provide reasonable assurance regarding prevention or timely detection of unauthorised acquisition, use, or disposition of the company’s assets that could have a material effect on the financial statements.
 
Because of its inherent limitations, internal control over financial reporting may not prevent or detect misstatements. Also, projections of any evaluation of effectiveness to future periods are subject to the risk that controls may become inadequate because of changes in conditions, or that the degree of compliance with the policies or procedures may deteriorate.
 
PricewaterhouseCoopers
Chartered Accountants and Registered Auditors
Dublin
Ireland
June 14, 2010


F-3


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
CONSOLIDATED INCOME STATEMENT
 
                                 
            Restated*
  Restated*
        9 Months Ended
  Year Ended
  Year Ended
    Notes   December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
        €m   €m   €m
 
Interest income
    3       4,188       9,717       10,397  
Interest expense
    4       (2,009 )     (6,047 )     (7,134 )
                                 
Net interest income
            2,179       3,670       3,263  
Net insurance premium income
    5       665       1,069       1,940  
Fee and commission income
    6       474       717       816  
Fee and commission expense
    6       (255 )     (232 )     (150 )
Net trading expense
    7       (28 )     (307 )     (246 )
Life assurance investment income and losses
    8       958       (1,570 )     (826 )
Gain on repurchase of subordinated liabilities
    9       1,037              
Other operating income
    10       31       73       238  
                                 
Total operating income
            5,061       3,420       5,035  
Insurance contract liabilities and claims paid
    11       (1,462 )     537       (798 )
                                 
Total operating income, net of insurance claims
            3,599       3,957       4,237  
Other operating expenses
    12       (1,381 )     (2,121 )     (2,160 )
Impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets
    30       (6 )     (304 )      
                                 
Operating profit before impairment charges on financial assets
            2,212       1,532       2,077  
Impairment charges on financial assets
    14       (4,057 )     (1,513 )     (232 )
                                 
Operating (loss)/profit
    15       (1,845 )     19       1,845  
Share of results of associates and joint ventures (after tax)
    16       35       (42 )     46  
Loss on disposal of business activities
    17       (3 )            
Profit on disposal of property
                        39  
                                 
(Loss)/profit before taxation
            (1,813 )     (23 )     1,930  
Taxation
    18       344       41       (229 )
                                 
(Loss)/profit for the period
            (1,469 )     18       1,701  
                                 
Attributable to minority interests
            (9 )     (35 )     5  
Attributable to stockholders
            (1,460 )     53       1,696  
                                 
(Loss)/profit for the period
            (1,469 )     18       1,701  
                                 
Earnings per unit of €0.64 ordinary stock (cent)
    19       (168.6c )     4.3c       174.3c  
                                 
Diluted earnings per unit of €0.64 ordinary stock (cent)
    19       (168.6c )     4.3c       173.6c  
                                 
 
 
* The prior year has been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13
 
The notes on pages F-42 to F-183
form an integral part of these consolidated financial statements


F-4


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF OTHER COMPREHENSIVE INCOME
 
                         
        Restated*
  Restated*
    9 Months Ended
  Year Ended
  Year Ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
(Loss)/Profit for the period
    (1,469 )     18       1,701  
Other comprehensive income, net of tax:
                       
                         
Net change in revaluation reserve
    (53 )     (96 )     (70 )
                         
Cash flow hedge reserve
                       
Changes in fair value
    (419 )     19       100  
Transfer to income statement
    501       (559 )     (347 )
                         
Net change in cash flow hedge reserve
    82       (540 )     (247 )
                         
Available for sale reserve
                       
Changes in fair value
    973       (1,108 )     (356 )
Transfer to income statement on asset disposal
    (49 )     (5 )     (30 )
                         
Net change in available for sale reserve
    924       (1,113 )     (386 )
                         
Net actuarial loss on defined benefit pension funds
    (74 )     (544 )     (209 )
Foreign exchange translation gains/(losses)
    117       (528 )     (712 )
                         
Other comprehensive income for the period net of tax
    996       (2,821 )     (1,624 )
                         
Total comprehensive income
    (473 )     (2,803 )     77  
                         
Total comprehensive income attributable to equity stockholders
    (464 )     (2,768 )     72  
Total comprehensive income attributable to minority interests
    (9 )     (35 )     5  
                         
Total comprehensive income
    (473 )     (2,803 )     77  
                         
 
The effect of tax on these items is shown in note 18
 
 
* The prior year has been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.


F-5


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEET
 
                         
        At
  At
        December 31,
  March 31,
    Notes   2009   2009
        €m   €m
 
ASSETS
Cash and balances at central banks
            4,241       3,224  
Items in the course of collection from other banks
            400       515  
Trading securities
    20       403       125  
Derivative financial instruments
    21       5,824       8,397  
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
    22       9,679       7,604  
Loans and advances to banks
    23       5,031       7,886  
Available for sale financial assets
    24       20,940       26,858  
Loans and advances to customers
    25       119,439       133,740  
Assets held for sale to NAMA
    26       9,581        
Other assets classified as held for sale
    34             24  
Interest in associates
    28       23       22  
Interest in joint ventures
    29       194       151  
Intangible assets — goodwill
    30       48       47  
Intangible assets — other
    30       459       485  
Investment properties
    31       1,265       1,413  
Property, plant and equipment
    32       404       492  
Deferred tax assets
    42       865       560  
Other assets
    33       2,304       2,566  
Retirement benefit asset
    43       6       7  
                         
Total assets
            181,106       194,116  
                         
EQUITY AND LIABILITIES
                       
Deposits from banks
    35       17,903       28,814  
Customer accounts
    36       84,812       83,119  
Items in the course of transmission to other banks
            198       238  
Derivative financial instruments
    21       6,037       7,554  
Debt securities in issue
    37       43,144       45,133  
Liabilities to customers under investment contracts
    38       5,050       4,084  
Insurance contract liabilities
    38       6,658       5,634  
Other liabilities
    40       2,899       3,049  
Provisions
    41       142       87  
Deferred tax liabilities
    42       134       50  
Retirement benefit obligations
    43       1,638       1,485  
Subordinated liabilities
    39       6,053       7,942  
Other liabilities classified as held for sale
    34             14  
Liabilities held for sale to NAMA
    26       1        
                         
Total liabilities
            174,669       187,203  
                         
Equity
                       
Capital stock
    45       699       699  
Stock premium account
            4,092       4,092  
Retained earnings
            3,263       4,761  
Other reserves
            (1,580 )     (2,610 )
Own stock held for the benefit of life assurance policyholders
            (87 )     (90 )
                         
Stockholders’ equity
            6,387       6,852  
Minority interests
            50       61  
                         
Total equity
            6,437       6,913  
                         
Total equity and liabilities
            181,106       194,116  
                         
 
The notes on pages F-42 to F-183
form an integral part of these consolidated financial statements


F-6


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY
 
                 
        Restated*
    9 Months Ended
  Year Ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    €m   €m
 
Capital stock
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    699       664  
Issue of 2009 preference stock
          35  
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    699       699  
                 
Stock premium account
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    4,092       775  
Premium on issue of 2009 preference stock
          3,317  
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    4,092       4,092  
                 
Retained earnings
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    4,761       5,670  
(Loss)/Profit for the period attributable to stockholders
    (1,460 )     53  
Equity dividends
          (387 )
Dividends on other equity interests
    (4 )     (10 )
Transfer from capital reserve
    29       39  
Loss retained
    (1,435 )     (305 )
Reissue of treasury stock
    (7 )     (83 )
Transfer from revaluation reserve
          4  
Transfer from share based payment reserve
    11       19  
Net actuarial loss on pension funds
    (74 )     (544 )
Other movements
    7        
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    3,263       4,761  
                 
Other Reserves:
               
Available for sale reserve
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    (1,532 )     (419 )
Changes in fair value
    1,110       (1,270 )
Deferred tax on fair value changes
    (131 )     162  
Transfer to income statement on asset disposal
    (55 )     (5 )
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    (608 )     (1,532 )
                 
Cash flow hedge reserve
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    (592 )     (52 )
Changes in fair value
    (555 )     121  
Transferred to income statement
               
- Net interest income (note 3)
    351       (93 )
- Net trading expense (foreign exchange)
    325       (672 )
Deferred tax on reserve movements
    (39 )     104  
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    (510 )     (592 )
                 
Foreign exchange reserve
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    (1,316 )     (788 )
Exchange adjustments during the period
    117       (528 )
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    (1,199 )     (1,316 )
                 
 
 
* The prior year has been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
The notes on pages F-42 to F-183
form an integral part of these consolidated financial statements


F-7


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
 
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN EQUITY  (Continued)
 
                 
        Restated*
    9 Months Ended
  Year Ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    €m   €m
 
Capital reserve
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    491       530  
Transfer to retained earnings
    (29 )     (39 )
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    462       491  
                 
Share based payment reserve
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    33       33  
Charge to the income statement
          19  
Transfer to retained earnings
    (11 )     (19 )
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    22       33  
                 
Revaluation reserve
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    82       182  
Transfer to retained earnings on sale of property
          (4 )
Revaluation of property
    (60 )     (113 )
Deferred tax on revaluation of property
    7       17  
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    29       82  
                 
Other equity reserves
               
US$150 million capital note1
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    114       114  
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    114       114  
                 
Core and secondary tranche warrants
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    110        
Issue of warrants
          110  
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    110       110  
                 
Total other reserves
    (1,580 )     (2,610 )
                 
Own stock held for the benefit of life assurance policyholders
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    (90 )     (225 )
Changes in value and amount of stock held
    3       135  
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    (87 )     (90 )
                 
Total stockholders’ equity excluding minority interests
    6,387       6,852  
                 
Minority interests
               
Balance at the beginning of the period
    61       38  
Acquisition
          61  
Revaluation
    (2 )      
Share of net loss
    (9 )     (35 )
Dividends paid to minority interest
          (3 )
                 
Balance at the end of the period
    50       61  
                 
Total equity
    6,437       6,913  
                 
 
 
* The prior year has been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
1 On April 26, 2010, the Group announced a debt for equity swap on the above security.
 
The notes on pages F-42 to F-183
form an integral part of these consolidated financial statements


F-8


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
CONSOLIDATED CASH FLOW STATEMENT
 
                         
        Restated*
  Restated*
    9 Months Ended
  Year Ended
  Year Ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Cash flows from operating activities
                       
(Loss)/profit before taxation
    (1,813 )     (23 )     1,930  
Share of results of associates undertakings and joint ventures
    (35 )     42       (46 )
Loss on disposal of business activities
    3              
Profit on disposal of property
                (39 )
Depreciation and amortisation
    107       178       137  
Impairment of financial assets
    4,057       1,513       232  
Other impairments
          17        
Impairment of goodwill and other intangibles
    6       287        
Decline in value of property below cost
    6              
Net change in prepayments and interest receivable
    175       270       (12 )
Net change in accruals and interest payable
    (154 )     (120 )     114  
Loans and advances written off net of recoveries
    (142 )     (236 )     (29 )
Revaluation of investment property
    98       512       149  
Interest expense on subordinated liabilities and other capital instruments
    163       435       450  
Profit on disposal of available for sale financial assets
    (55 )     (5 )     (34 )
Charge for share based payments
          19       16  
Charge for provisions
    88       70        
Charge for retirement benefit obligation
    149       180       134  
Gain on repurchase of subordinated liabilities
    (1,037 )            
Amortisation of premiums and discounts
    (12 )     (57 )     (94 )
Amortisation of debt issue expenses
    8       14       18  
                         
Cash flows from operating activities before changes in operating assets and liabilities
    1,612       3,096       2,926  
                         
Net change in deposits from banks
    (10,813 )     14,759       (6,024 )
Net change in customer accounts
    566       2,279       19,333  
Net change in loans and advances to customers
    3,474       (8,226 )     (20,309 )
Net change in loans and advances to banks
    3,901       (1,754 )     857  
Net change in trading securities
    (278 )     (6 )     400  
Net change in derivative financial instruments
    1,106       (954 )     (558 )
Net change in assets at fair value through profit or loss
    (2,062 )     3,248       1,830  
Net change in items in the course of collection
    78       146       114  
Net change in debt securities in issue
    (1,493 )     (17,464 )     3,061  
Net change in insurance contract liabilities
    1,024       (1,506 )     (50 )
Net change in other assets
    81       31       64  
Net change in liabilities to customers under investment contracts
    966       (1,578 )     (1,074 )
Net change in other liabilities
    (214 )     (400 )     (518 )
Effect of exchange translation and other adjustments
    (1,823 )     4,715       2,979  
                         
Net cash flow from operating assets and liabilities
    (5,487 )     (6,710 )     105  
                         
Net cash flow from operating activities before taxation
    (3,875 )     (3,614 )     3,031  
Taxation refunded/(paid)
    45       (215 )     (276 )
                         
Net cash flow from operating activities
    (3,830 )     (3,829 )     2,755  
Investing activities (section a)
    6,778       870       1,279  
Financing activities (section b)
    (838 )     2,525       (466 )
                         
Net change in cash and cash equivalents
    2,110       (434 )     3,568  
Opening cash and cash equivalents
    7,259       7,647       4,297  
Effect of exchange translation adjustments
    (182 )     46       (218 )
                         
Closing cash and cash equivalents (see note 48)
    9,187       7,259       7,647  
                         
 
 
* The prior periods have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 
The notes on pages F-42 to F-183
form an integral part of these consolidated financial statements


F-9


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
CONSOLIDATED CASH FLOW STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
                         
        Restated*
  Restated*
    9 Months Ended
  Year Ended
  Year Ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009   March 31, 2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
(a)  Investing activities
                       
Additions to available for sale financial assets
    (8,587 )     (27,267 )      
Disposal of available for sale financial assets
    15,389       28,324       2,006  
Additions to property, plant and equipment
    (11 )     (75 )     (54 )
Disposal of property, plant and equipment
    4       4       10  
Additions to intangible assets
    (47 )     (119 )     (98 )
Disposal of intangible assets
          7        
Purchase of investment property
          (36 )     (529 )
Disposal of investment property
    33             11  
Purchase of assets held for sale
                (211 )
Disposal of assets held for sale
                113  
Dividends received from joint ventures
          34       34  
Net change in interest in associates
    (3 )     (2 )     (3 )
                         
Cash flows from investing activities
    6,778       870       1,279  
                         
                         
(b)  Financing activities
                       
Reissue of treasury stock
    (7 )     (83 )     194  
Issue of new subordinated liabilities
          565       439  
Reduction of subordinated liabilities
    (683 )     (600 )     (22 )
Interest paid on subordinated liabilities
    (144 )     (419 )     (450 )
Equity dividends paid
          (387 )     (611 )
Dividends on other equity interests
    (4 )     (10 )     (14 )
Dividends paid to minority interests
          (3 )     (2 )
Issue of 2009 preference stock and warrants
          3,462        
                         
Cash flows from financing activities
    (838 )     2,525       (466 )
                         
 
 
* The prior periods have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13
 
The notes on pages F-42 to F-183
form an integral part of these consolidated financial statements


F-10


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES
 
 
         
    Page
    F-12  
    F-12  
    F-13  
    F-14  
    F-14  
    F-16  
    F-17  
    F-17  
    F-18  
    F-18  
    F-20  
    F-20  
    F-21  
    F-21  
    F-21  
    F-22  
    F-24  
    F-25  
    F-25  
    F-26  
    F-26  
    F-27  
    F-27  
    F-28  
    F-29  
    F-29  
    F-30  
    F-31  
    F-31  
    F-31  
    F-32  
    F-32  
    F-33  


F-11


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES
 
The following are Bank of Ireland Group’s principal accounting policies.
 
Basis of preparation
 
The financial statements comprise the Consolidated income statement, the Consolidated statement of other comprehensive income, the Consolidated balance sheet, the Consolidated statement of changes in equity, the Consolidated cash flow statement and the Group accounting policies and the notes to the Consolidated financial statements.
 
The consolidated financial statements of the Group are prepared in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and International Financial Reporting Interpretations Committee (IFRIC) interpretations as adopted by the European Union (EU) and with those parts of the Companies Act, 1963 to 2009 applicable to companies reporting under IFRS, with the European Communities (Credit Institutions: Accounts) Regulations, 1992 and with the Asset Covered Securities Acts, 2001 to 2007. The EU adopted version of IAS 39 currently relaxes some of the hedge accounting rules in IAS 39 ’Financial Instruments — Recognition and Measurement’. The Group has not availed of this, hence these financial statements comply with both IFRS as adopted by the EU and IFRS as issued by the IASB.
 
The financial statements have been prepared under the historical cost convention as modified to include the fair valuation of certain financial instruments and land and buildings.
 
The preparation of the financial statements in conformity with IFRS requires the use of estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities at the date of the financial statements and the reported amounts of revenues and expenses during the reporting period. Although these estimates are based on management’s best knowledge of the amount, event or actions, actual results ultimately may differ from those estimates. A description of the critical estimates and judgements is set out on pages F-36 to F-39.
 
Going concern
 
The information in the financial statements has been prepared on the going concern basis. A number of risk factors including credit, liquidity, market, insurance, pension, operational, legal and regulatory risk impact on the Group’s activities. The continuing global financial difficulties and the significantly deteriorated economic environments in which we operate have increased the pressure on the Group as to how these risk factors are managed. In preparing these financial statements the Directors have reviewed these risk factors and all relevant information to assess the Group’s ability to continue as a going concern. This review included consideration of the impact of the current economic factors affecting the Group and the industry, the liquidity position, the ability to access funds in the wholesale money markets (including the ability to use assets as collateral to raise funds) and the Group’s participation in NAMA. The Directors have reviewed the Group’s business plan for 2010 and 2011 which incorporates its funding plan and the remedies expected under the EU Restructuring Plan as set out in note 58 (h) and considered the critical assumptions underpinning this plan and tested them under stressed conditions. Following completion of a Prudential Capital Assessment Review in March 2010, the Financial Regulator determined that the Group is required to raise €2.7 billion in capital by December 31, 2010. This is consistent with the Group’s previously held views. As set out in note 58 (i) on April 26, 2010, the Group announced details of a capital raising of not less than €2.8 billion by way of an Institutional Placing, a NPRFC Placing, a Rights Issue and Debt for Equity offers. The capital raising was completed on June 8, 2010 and the Group has increased its Equity Tier 1 Capital by €2.9 billion. See note 58 (i) for further information.
 
The Directors have also taken into account measures introduced by the Irish Government to improve liquidity, including the enhanced customer deposit protection scheme, the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) scheme (“CIFS”), introduced by the Irish Government in September 2008, and the Credit Institutions Eligible Liabilities Guarantee Scheme (the “ELG Scheme”) introduced by the Government in December 2009. In concluding on the going concern basis the Directors took into account the CIFS scheme, the ELG Scheme, the Irish Government’s €3.5 billion investment in Bank of Ireland Preference Stock, the Group’s ability to use assets as collateral to access


F-12


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
Monetary Authority Liquidity Support Schemes, the impact of the Group’s participation in NAMA and the Government’s acknowledgment of the Group’s systemic importance to the economy as a whole and its continued support. As part of the Group’s capital raising announced on April 26, 2010, the State has converted 1,036,000,000 units of 2009 preference stock into ordinary equity. Please refer to note 58 (i) for further information.
 
Based on the factors above the Directors are satisfied that the Group will have access to adequate resources, both capital and funding, to continue in business for the foreseeable future. Accordingly, the Directors consider it appropriate to adopt the going concern basis in preparing the financial statements at December 31, 2009.
 
Adoption of new accounting standards
 
The following standards and amendments to standards have been adopted by the Group during the nine month period ended December 31, 2009:
 
IFRS 8 — ‘Operating Segments’
 
IFRS 8 replaces IAS 14 ‘Segment reporting’, and sets out the requirements for disclosure of financial and descriptive information about an entity’s operating segments and also about the entity’s products and services, the economic environments in which it operates and its major customers. The new standard requires a ‘management approach’, under which segment information is presented on the same basis as that used for internal reporting purposes. The introduction of this standard has not had a significant impact on the financial statements.
 
IAS 1 (Revised) — ‘Presentation of financial statements’
 
The revised standard amends the requirements for the presentation, structure and content of the financial statements. In accordance with the revised standard the Group has decided to present all items of income and expense in two separate statements, a consolidated income statement and a consolidated statement of other comprehensive income. The revised standard requires that all changes in equity arising from transactions with owners in their capacity as owners be presented separately from non-owner changes in equity, in the consolidated statement of changes in equity. The adoption of the revised standard does not change the recognition, measurement or disclosure of specific transactions and events required by other standards.
 
IFRS 2 — ‘Share-based payment: Vesting Conditions and Cancellations’ (amendment)
 
This amendment clarifies the accounting treatment of cancellations and vesting conditions of share-based payment schemes. It clarifies that vesting conditions are service conditions and performance conditions only. Other features of a share-based payment are not vesting conditions. These features need to be included in the grant date fair value for transactions with employees and others providing similar services, that is, these features would not impact the number of awards expected to vest or valuation thereof subsequent to grant date. The amendment also clarifies that all cancellations, whether by the entity or by other parties, should receive the same accounting treatment.
 
The main impact of this amendment for the Group arises from cancellations by employees of contributions to the Group’s Save-As-You-Earn (SAYE) schemes. Previously such cancellations would have resulted in the SAYE scheme expense recognised in prior periods, in respect of the relevant employees, being reversed. Under the amendment, in the event of a cancellation the Group recognises immediately the amount of the expense that would have otherwise been recognised over the remainder of the vesting period. The adoption of the amendment has resulted in an increase of €3.5 million in the Group’s operating expenses for the nine months ended December 31, 2009.
 
The amendment is applied retrospectively and has resulted in a restatement of the comparative figures. The comparative income statement for the year ended March 31, 2009 has been adjusted to increase operating expenses


F-13


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
and reduce profit before tax by €16 million (year ended March 31, 2008: €3 million). The adoption of the amendment has not impacted the balance sheet for either March 31, 2009 or March 31,2008.
 
IAS 23 (Revised) — ‘Borrowing costs’
 
The amendment requires an entity to capitalise borrowing costs directly attributable to the acquisition, construction or production of a qualifying asset (one that takes a substantial period of time to get ready for use or sale) as part of the cost of that asset. The option of immediately expensing such borrowing costs has been removed. This amendment has not had a material impact on the financial statements.
 
IAS 32 (Amendment) — ‘Financial instruments: Presentation’, and IAS 1 (Amendment), ‘Presentation of financial statements — Puttable financial instruments and obligations arising on liquidation’
 
The amended standards require the Group to classify puttable financial instruments and instruments, or components of instruments that impose on the Group an obligation to deliver to another party a pro rata share of the net assets of the Group only on liquidation as equity, provided the financial instruments have particular features and meet specific conditions. This amendment has not had any impact on the financial statements.
 
IFRS 7 (Amendment), ‘Financial Instruments: Disclosure’
 
The amendment requires enhanced disclosures about fair value measurement and liquidity risk. In particular the amendment requires classification of the fair value of those financial instruments which are measured on the balance sheet at fair value using a three-level fair value hierarchy.
 
These additional disclosures are set out in note 46 — Fair values of financial assets and liabilities and in note 56 — Risk Management.
 
IFRIC 14 — ‘The Limit on a Defined Benefit Asset, Minimum Funding Requirements and their Interaction’
 
This interpretation deals with accounting for refunds in contributions and minimum funding requirements. This IFRIC has not had a material impact on the financial statements.
 
Details of those IFRS pronouncements which will be relevant to the Group but which were not effective at December 31, 2009 and which have not yet been adopted by the Group are set out on pages F-33 to F-35.
 
Comparatives
 
Comparative figures have been adjusted where necessary, to conform with changes in presentation or where additional analysis has been provided in the current period.
 
Group accounts
 
(1)   Subsidiaries
 
Subsidiaries, which are those companies and other entities (including Special Purpose Entities (SPE’s)) in which the Group, directly or indirectly, has power to govern the financial and operating policies, generally accompanying a shareholding of more than half of its voting rights, are consolidated.
 
Assets, liabilities and results of all group undertakings have been included in the Group financial statements on the basis of financial statements made up to the end of the financial period.
 
The existence and effect of potential voting rights that are presently exercisable or presently convertible are considered when assessing whether the Group controls another entity.


F-14


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
Subsidiaries are consolidated from the date on which control is transferred to the Group and are no longer consolidated from the date that control ceases. The purchase method of accounting is used to account for the acquisition of subsidiaries. The cost of an acquisition is measured at the fair value of the assets given up, equity instruments issued or liabilities undertaken at the date of acquisition, plus costs directly attributable to the acquisition. The excess of the cost of acquisition over the fair value of the Group’s share of the identifiable net assets of the subsidiary acquired is recorded as goodwill. If the cost of acquisition is less than the fair value of the net assets of the subsidiary acquired, the difference is recognised directly in the income statement (see ‘Intangible Assets’ for the accounting policy on goodwill).
 
Intercompany transactions, balances and unrealised gains on transactions between group companies are eliminated. Unrealised losses are also eliminated unless the transaction provides evidence of impairment of the asset transferred. In addition foreign exchange gains and losses which arise on the retranslation to functional currency of intercompany monetary assets and liabilities are not eliminated.
 
Even if there is no shareholder relationship, SPE’s are consolidated in accordance with SIC12, if the Group controls them from an economic perspective. SPE’s are consolidated when the substance of the relationship between the Group and that entity indicates control. Potential indicators of control include, amongst others, an assessment of the Group’s exposure to the risks and benefits of the SPE. Whenever there is a change in the substance of the relationship between the Group and the SPE, the Group performs a reassessment of consolidation. Indicators for a reassessment of consolidation can include changes in ownership of the SPE, changes in contractual arrangements and changes in the financing structure.
 
Accounting policies of subsidiaries have been changed, where necessary, to ensure consistency with the policies adopted by the Group.
 
Upon adoption of IFRS, the Group availed of the exemption not to restate the Group financial statements for any acquisitions or business combinations that took place prior to April 1, 2004.
 
(2)   Associates and Joint Ventures
 
Associates are all entities over which the Group has significant influence but not control, generally accompanying a shareholding of between 20% and 50% of the voting rights.
 
Joint ventures are contractual arrangements whereby the Group and another party undertake an economic activity that is subject to joint control.
 
Investments in associates and joint ventures are accounted for by the equity method of accounting and are initially recognised at cost. Under this method, the Group’s share of the post acquisition profits or losses in associates and joint ventures is recognised in the income statement, and its share of post acquisition movements in reserves is recognised in reserves. The cumulative post acquisition movements are adjusted against the carrying amount of the investment.
 
When the Group’s share of losses in an associate or joint venture equals or exceeds its interest in the associate or joint venture the Group does not recognise further losses unless it has incurred obligations or made payments on behalf of the associate or joint venture.
 
Unrealised gains on transactions between the Group and its associates or joint ventures are eliminated to the extent of the Group’s interest in the associate / joint venture; unrealised losses are also eliminated unless the transaction provides evidence of an impairment of the asset transferred. The Group’s investment in associates and joint ventures includes goodwill (net of any accumulated impairment losses) on acquisition.
 
Accounting policies of associates and joint ventures have been changed, where necessary, to ensure consistency with the policies adopted by the Group.


F-15


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
(3)   Minority Interests
 
Transactions with minorities where the Group has control over the entity are accounted for using the “Economic entity model”. This accounting model requires that any surplus or deficit that arises on any transaction(s) with minorities to dispose of or to acquire additional interests in the entity are settled through equity.
 
(4)   Securitisations
 
Certain Group undertakings have entered into securitisation transactions in order to finance specific loans and advances to customers.
 
All financial assets continue to be held on the Group balance sheet, and a liability recognised for the proceeds of the funding transaction, unless:
 
•   the rights to the cash flows have expired or been transferred;
 
•   substantially all the risks and rewards associated with the financial instruments have been transferred outside the Group, in which case the assets are derecognised in full; or
 
•   a significant portion, but not all, of the risks and rewards have been transferred outside the Group. In this case the asset is derecognised entirely if the transferee has the ability to sell the financial asset, otherwise the asset continues to be recognised only to the extent of the Group’s continuing involvement.
 
Where the above conditions apply to a fully proportionate share of all or specifically identified cash flows, the relevant accounting treatment is applied to that proportion of the asset.
 
Foreign currency translation
 
Items included in the financial statements of each entity of the Group are measured using the currency of the primary economic environment in which the entity operates (the functional currency). The consolidated financial statements are presented in euro, which is the functional and presentation currency of the parent.
 
Foreign currency transactions are translated into functional currency at the exchange rates prevailing at the dates of the transactions. Foreign exchange gains and losses resulting from the settlement of such transactions and from the translation at year end exchange rates of monetary assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currencies, are recognised in the income statement, except when deferred in equity as qualifying cash flow hedges. Translation differences on non-monetary items, such as equities held at fair value through profit or loss, are reported as part of the fair value gain or loss. Translation differences on non-monetary items such as equities, classified as available for sale, are recognised in other comprehensive income and exchange differences arising on translation to presentation currency and on consolidation of overseas net investments, are recognised in other comprehensive income.
 
The results and financial position of all the group entities that have a functional currency different from the presentation currency have been translated into the presentation currency as follows:
 
•   assets and liabilities for each balance sheet presented are translated at the closing rate at the date of that balance sheet;
 
•   income and expenses for each income statement are translated at average exchange rates (unless this average is not a reasonable approximation of the cumulative effect of the rates prevailing on the transaction dates, in which case income and expenses are translated at the date of the transactions); and
 
•   all resulting exchange differences are recognised in other comprehensive income.
 
The Group availed of the exemption to deem all accumulated balances arising from translation of foreign subsidiaries to be nil on transition to IFRS on April 1, 2004.


F-16


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
On consolidation, exchange differences arising from the translation of the net investment in foreign entities and of borrowings and other currency instruments designated as hedges of such investments, are recognised in other comprehensive income. When a foreign operation is sold, such exchange differences are reclassified from equity to the income statement as part of the gain or loss on disposal.
 
Goodwill and fair value adjustments arising on the acquisition of a foreign entity are treated as assets and liabilities of the foreign entity and translated at the closing rate.
 
The principal rates of exchange used in the preparation of the financial statements are as follows:
 
                                 
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    Average   Closing   Average   Closing
 
€/US$
    1.4248       1.4406       1.4321       1.3308  
€/Stg£
    0.8851       0.8881       0.8333       0.9308  
 
Interest income and expense
 
Interest income and expense are recognised in the income statement for all instruments measured at amortised cost using the effective interest method.
 
The effective interest method is a method of calculating the amortised cost of a financial asset or a financial liability and of allocating the interest income or interest expense over the relevant period. The effective interest rate is the rate that exactly discounts estimated future cash payments or receipts through the expected life of the financial instrument or, when appropriate, a shorter period to the net carrying amount of the financial asset or liability. When calculating the effective interest rate, the Group estimates cash flows considering all contractual terms of the financial instrument (for example, prepayment options) but does not consider future credit losses. The calculation includes all fees and points paid or received between parties to the contract that are an integral part of the effective interest rate, transaction costs and all other premiums or discounts.
 
Once a financial asset or group of similar financial assets has been written down as a result of an impairment loss, interest income is recognised using the rate of interest used to discount the future cash flows for the purposes of measuring the impairment loss.
 
Where the Group revises its estimates of payments or receipts on a financial instrument measured at amortised cost, the carrying amount of the financial instrument (or group of financial instruments) is adjusted to reflect actual and revised estimated cash flows. The Group recalculates the carrying amount by computing the present value of estimated future cash flows at the financial instrument’s original effective interest rate. The adjustment is recognised in profit or loss as income or expense.
 
Fee and commission income
 
Fees and commissions which are not an integral part of the effective interest rate of a financial instrument are generally recognised on an accrual basis when the service has been provided. Commissions and fees arising from negotiating, or participating in the negotiation of a transaction for a third party, such as the acquisition of loans, shares or other securities or the purchase or sale of businesses, are recognised on completion of the underlying transaction. Portfolio and other management advisory and service fees are recognised based on the applicable service contracts usually on a time apportioned basis. Asset management fees related to investment funds are recognised rateably over the period the service is provided. The same principle is applied for wealth management, financial planning and custody services that are continuously provided over an extended period of time. Loan commitment fees for loans that are likely to be drawn down, are deferred (together with related direct costs) and recognised as an adjustment to the effective interest rate on the loan once drawn.


F-17


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
 
Leases
 
(1)   A Group company is the lessee
 
The total payments made under operating leases are charged to the income statement on a straight line basis over the period of the lease.
 
When an operating lease is terminated before the lease period has expired, any payment required to be made to the lessor by way of penalty is recognised as an expense in the period in which termination takes place.
 
Leases of property, plant and equipment where the Group has substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership are classified as finance leases. Finance leases are capitalised at the lease’s inception at the lower of the fair value of the leased property and the present value of the minimum lease payments.
 
The corresponding rental obligations, net of finance charges, are included in long term payables. The interest element of the finance costs is charged to the income statement over the lease period so as to produce a constant periodic rate of interest on the remaining balance of the liability for each period.
 
(2)   A Group company is the lessor
 
When assets are held under a finance lease, the present value of the lease payments is recognised as a receivable. The difference between the gross receivable and the present value of the receivable is recognised as unearned finance income. Lease income is included within net interest income and is recognised over the term of the lease reflecting a constant periodic rate of return on the net investment in the lease.
 
Financial assets
 
(1)   Classification, Recognition and Measurement
 
The Group classifies its financial assets in the following categories: financial assets at fair value through profit or loss; loans and receivables; held to maturity investments; and available for sale financial assets. The Group determines the classification of its financial assets at initial recognition.
 
Financial assets that the Group expects will be transferred to NAMA during 2010, have been classified as assets held for sale to NAMA (refer to accounting policy on page F-26).
 
(a)   Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
 
Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss can either be held for trading, if acquired principally for the purpose of selling in the short term, or designated at fair value through profit or loss at inception.
 
A financial asset may be designated at fair value through profit or loss only when:
 
i.  it eliminates or significantly reduces a measurement or recognition inconsistency, (“an accounting mismatch”), that would otherwise arise from measuring assets or liabilities or recognising the gains and losses on them on a different basis; or
 
ii.  a group of financial assets, financial liabilities or both is managed and its performance is evaluated on a fair value basis in accordance with documented risk management or investment strategy; or
 
iii.  a contract contains one or more embedded derivatives that significantly changes the cash flows of the contract and the separation of the embedded derivative(s) is not prohibited.
 
The principal category of assets designated at fair value through profit or loss are those held by the Group’s life assurance business, which are managed on a fair value basis.


F-18


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
Regular way purchases and sales of financial assets at fair value through profit or loss are recognised on trade date: the date on which the Group commits to purchase or sell the asset. Thereafter they are carried on the balance sheet at fair value, with all changes in fair value included in the income statement.
 
Financial assets may not be transferred out of this category, except for non-derivative financial assets held for trading, which may be transferred out of this category where:
 
i.  in rare circumstances, they are no longer held for the purpose of selling or repurchasing in the short term; or
 
ii.  they are no longer held for trading, they meet the definition of loans and receivables at the date of reclassification and the Group has the intention and ability to hold the assets for the foreseeable future or until maturity.
 
(b)   Loans and receivables
 
Loans and receivables are non-derivative financial assets with fixed or determinable payments that are not quoted in an active market. They arise when the Group provides money, goods or services directly to a debtor with no intention of trading the receivable.
 
Loans are recorded at fair value plus transaction costs when cash is advanced to the borrowers. They are subsequently accounted for at amortised cost using the effective interest method.
 
(c)   Held to maturity
 
Held to maturity investments are non-derivative financial assets with fixed or determinable payments and fixed maturities that the Group’s management has the positive intention and ability to hold to maturity. Were the Group to sell other than an insignificant amount of held to maturity assets, the entire category would be tainted and would need to be reclassified as available for sale.
 
Purchases and sales of held to maturity investments are recorded on trade date. They are initially recognised at fair value plus transaction costs and are subsequently accounted for at amortised cost using the effective interest method.
 
(d)   Available for sale
 
Available for sale financial assets are those intended to be held for an indefinite period of time, which may be sold in response to needs for liquidity or changes in interest rates, exchange rates or equity prices.
 
Purchases and sales of available for sale financial assets are recognised on trade date. They are initially recognised at fair value plus transaction costs. Movements are recognised in other comprehensive income. Interest is calculated using the effective interest method and is recognised in the income statement.
 
If an available for sale financial asset is derecognised or impaired the cumulative gain or loss previously recognised in other comprehensive income is reclassified to the income statement.
 
Dividends on available for sale equity instruments are recognised in the income statement when the Group’s right to receive payment is established.
 
Available for sale financial assets that would have met the definition of loans and receivables may be reclassified to loans and receivables if the Group has the intention and ability to hold the asset for the foreseeable future or until maturity.
 
(2)   Derecognition
 
Financial assets are derecognised when the rights to receive cash flows from the financial assets have expired or where the Group has transferred substantially all risks and rewards of ownership.


F-19


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
(3)   Shares in Group Entities
 
The Bank’s investments in its subsidiaries are stated at cost less any impairment.
 
Financial liabilities
 
The Group has two categories of financial liabilities: those that are carried at amortised cost and those that are carried at fair value through profit or loss. Financial liabilities are initially recognised at fair value, (normally the issue proceeds i.e. the fair value of consideration received) less, in the case of financial liabilities subsequently carried at amortised cost, transaction costs. For liabilities carried at amortised cost, any difference between the proceeds, net of transaction costs, and the redemption value is recognised in the income statement using the effective interest method.
 
Preference shares which carry a mandatory coupon are classified as financial liabilities. The dividends on these preference shares are recognised in the income statement as interest expense using the effective interest method.
 
A liability may be designated as at fair value through profit or loss only when:
 
i.  it eliminates or significantly reduces a measurement or recognition inconsistency, (“an accounting mismatch”), that would otherwise arise from measuring assets or liabilities or recognising the gains and losses on them on a different basis; or
 
ii.  a group of financial assets, financial liabilities or both is managed and its performance is evaluated on a fair value basis in accordance with documented risk management or investment strategy; or
 
iii.  a contract contains one or more embedded derivatives that significantly changes the cash flows of the contract and the separation of the embedded derivative(s) is not prohibited.
 
The Group designates certain financial liabilities at fair value through profit or loss as set out in note 46 to the financial statements.
 
Financial liabilities are derecognised when they are extinguished, that is when the obligation is discharged, cancelled or expires.
 
Valuation of financial instruments
 
The Group recognises trading securities, other financial assets and liabilities designated at fair value through profit or loss, derivatives and available-for-sale financial assets at fair value in the balance sheet. Fair value is the amount for which an asset could be exchanged or a liability settled between knowledgeable, willing parties in an arm’s length transaction.
 
The fair values of financial assets and liabilities traded in active markets are based on unadjusted bid and offer prices respectively. If an active market does not exist, the Group establishes fair value using valuation techniques. These include the use of recent arm’s length transactions, discounted cash flow analysis, option pricing models and other valuation techniques commonly used by market participants. To the extent possible, these valuation techniques use observable market data. Where observable data does not exist, the Group uses estimates based on the best information available.
 
The best evidence of the fair value of a financial instrument at initial recognition is the transaction price unless the fair value of that instrument is evidenced by comparison with other observable current market transactions in the same instrument (i.e. without modification or repackaging) or based on a valuation technique which primarily uses observable market inputs. When such evidence exists, the initial valuation of the instrument may result in the Group recognising a profit on initial recognition. In the absence of such evidence, the instrument is initially valued at the transaction price.


F-20


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
For liabilities designated at fair value through profit or loss, the fair values reflect changes in the Group’s own credit spread.
 
The fair values of the Group’s financial assets and liabilities are disclosed within note 46 together with a description of the valuation technique used for each asset or liability category. For assets or liabilities recognised at fair value on the balance sheet, a description is given of any inputs into valuation models that have the potential to significantly impact the fair value, together with an estimate of the impact of using reasonably possible alternative assumptions.
 
Sale and repurchase agreements and lending of securities
 
Securities sold subject to repurchase agreements (“repos”) are retained on the balance sheet and reclassified as pledged assets when the transferee has the right by contract or custom to sell or repledge the collateral; the counterparty liability is included in deposits by banks or customer accounts, as appropriate. Securities purchased under agreements to resell (“reverse repos”) are treated as collateralised loans and recorded as loans and advances to banks or customers, as appropriate. The difference between sale and repurchase price is treated as interest and recognised in the income statement over the life of the agreement using the effective interest method. Securities lent to counterparties are also retained on the balance sheet.
 
Securities borrowed are not recognised in the financial statements, unless these are sold to third parties, in which case the purchase and sale are recorded with the gain or loss included in trading income. The obligation to return the securities is recorded at fair value as a trading liability.
 
Issued debt and equity securities
 
The classification of instruments as a financial liability or an equity instrument is dependent upon the substance of the contractual arrangement. Instruments which carry a contractual obligation to deliver cash or another financial asset to another entity are classified as financial liabilities. The coupons on these instruments are recognised in the income statement as interest expense using the effective interest method. Where the Group has absolute discretion in relation to the payment of coupons and repayment of principal, the instrument is classified as equity and any coupon payments are classified as distributions in the period in which they are made.
 
If the Group purchases its own debt, it is removed from the balance sheet and the difference between the carrying amount of the liability and the consideration paid is included in net trading income.
 
Due to the materiality of the gain on the repurchase of subordinated liabilities, in June 2009 (detailed in note 9), that gain has been disclosed as a separate line item within the Group’s Consolidated Income Statement, rather than included within net trading income.
 
Derivative financial instruments and hedge accounting
 
Derivatives are initially recognised at fair value on the date on which the contract is entered into and are subsequently remeasured at their fair value at each balance sheet date. All derivatives are carried as assets when their fair value is positive and as liabilities when their fair value is negative.
 
Certain derivatives embedded in other financial instruments are separated from the host contract and accounted for as derivatives, when their economic characteristics and risks are not closely related to those of the host contract and the host contract is not carried at fair value through profit or loss.
 
Fair value gains or losses on derivatives are normally recognised in the income statement. However where they are designated as hedging instruments, the treatment of the fair value gains and losses depends on the nature of the hedging relationship.


F-21


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
The Group designates certain derivatives as either:
 
i.  hedges of the exposure to changes in the fair value of recognised assets or liabilities that is attributable to a particular risk (fair value hedge); or
 
ii.  hedges of highly probable future cash flows attributable to a recognised asset or liability, or a forecast transaction (cash flow hedge).
 
Hedge accounting is applied to these derivatives provided certain criteria are met. The Group documents, at the inception of the transaction, the relationship between hedging instruments and hedged items, as well as its risk management objective and strategy for undertaking various hedge transactions. The Group also documents its assessment, both at hedge inception and on an ongoing basis, of whether the derivatives that are used in hedging transactions are highly effective in offsetting changes in fair values or cash flows of hedged items.
 
(a)   Fair value hedge
 
Changes in the fair value of derivatives that are designated and qualify as fair value hedges are recorded in the income statement, together with any changes in the fair value of the hedged asset or liability that are attributable to the hedged risk.
 
If the criteria for hedge accounting cease to be met, no further adjustments are made to the hedged item for fair value changes attributable to the hedged risk. The cumulative adjustment to the carrying amount of a hedged item is amortised to profit or loss over the period to maturity using the effective interest method.
 
(b)   Cash flow hedge
 
The effective portion of changes in the fair value of derivatives that are designated and qualify as cash flow hedges are recognised in other comprehensive income. The gain or loss relating to the ineffective portion is recognised immediately in the income statement. Amounts accumulated in other comprehensive income are reclassified to the income statement in the periods in which the hedged item affects profit or loss.
 
When a hedging instrument expires or is sold, or when a hedge no longer meets the criteria for hedge accounting, any cumulative gain or loss existing in other comprehensive income at that time remains in other comprehensive income and is recognised in the income statement when the forecast transaction occurs. When a forecast transaction is no longer expected to occur, the cumulative gain or loss that was reported in other comprehensive income is immediately reclassified to the income statement.
 
Impairment of financial assets
 
Assets carried at amortised cost
 
The Group assesses at each balance sheet date whether there is objective evidence that a financial asset or group of financial assets is impaired. A financial asset or a group of financial assets is impaired and impairment losses are incurred if, and only if, there is objective evidence of impairment as a result of one or more events that occurred after the initial recognition of the asset (a ‘loss event’) and that loss event (or events) has an impact on the estimated future cash flows of the financial asset or group of financial assets that can be reliably estimated.
 
Objective evidence that a financial asset or group of assets is impaired includes observable data that comes to the attention of the Group about the following loss events:
 
i.  significant financial difficulty of the issuer or obligor;
 
ii.  a breach of contract, such as a default or delinquency in interest or principal payments;


F-22


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
 
iii.  the Group granting to the borrower, for economic or legal reasons relating to the borrower’s financial difficulty, a concession that the lender would not otherwise consider;
 
iv.  it becoming probable that the borrower will enter bankruptcy or other financial reorganisation;
 
v.  the disappearance of an active market for that financial asset because of financial difficulties; or
 
vi.  observable data indicating that there is a measurable decrease in the estimated future cash flows from a group of financial assets since the initial recognition of those assets, although the decrease cannot yet be identified with the individual financial assets in the group, including:
 
  •   adverse changes in the payment status of borrowers in the group; or
 
  •   national or local economic conditions that correlate with defaults on the assets in the group.
 
The Group first assesses whether objective evidence of impairment exists individually for financial assets that are individually significant, and individually or collectively for financial assets that are not individually significant. If the Group determines that no objective evidence of impairment exists for an individually assessed financial asset, whether significant or not, it includes the asset in a group of financial assets with similar credit risk characteristics and collectively assesses them for impairment. Assets that are individually assessed for impairment and for which an impairment loss is or continues to be recognised are not included in a collective assessment of impairment.
 
If there is objective evidence that an impairment loss on loans and advances or held to maturity investments carried at amortised cost has been incurred, the amount of the loss is measured as the difference between the asset’s carrying amount and the present value of estimated future cash flows (excluding future credit losses that have not been incurred) discounted at the financial asset’s original effective interest rate. The carrying amount of the asset is reduced through the use of an allowance account and the amount of the loss is recognised in the income statement. If a loan or held to maturity investment has a variable interest rate, the discount rate for measuring any impairment loss is the current effective interest rate determined under the contract. As a practical expedient, the Group may measure impairment on the basis of an instrument’s fair value using an observable market price.
 
The calculation of the present value of the estimated future cash flows of a collateralised financial asset reflects the cash flows that may result from foreclosure less costs for obtaining and selling the collateral, whether or not foreclosure is probable.
 
For the purposes of a collective evaluation of impairment, financial assets are grouped on the basis of similar credit risk characteristics (i.e. on the basis of the Group’s grading process that considers asset type, industry, geographical location, collateral type, past due status and other relevant factors). Those characteristics are relevant to the estimation of future cash flows for groups of such assets by being indicative of the debtors’ ability to pay all amounts due according to the contractual terms of the assets being evaluated.
 
Future cash flows in a group of financial assets that are collectively evaluated for impairment are estimated on the basis of the contractual cash flows of the assets in the group and historical loss experience for assets with credit risk characteristics similar to those in the group. Historical loss experience is adjusted on the basis of current observable data to reflect the effects of current conditions that did not affect the period on which the historical loss experience is based and to remove the effects of conditions in the historical period that do not exist currently. The methodology and assumptions used for estimating future cash flows are reviewed regularly by the Group to reduce any differences between loss estimates and actual loss experience.
 
If, in a subsequent period, the amount of the impairment loss decreases and the decrease can be related objectively to an event occurring after the impairment was recognised (such as an improvement in the debtor’s credit rating), the previously recognised impairment loss is reversed by adjusting the allowance account. The amount of the reversal is recognised in the income statement.


F-23


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
When a loan is uncollectible, it is written off against the related provision for loan impairment. Such loans are written off after all the necessary procedures have been completed and the amount of the loss has been determined. Subsequent recoveries of amounts previously written off decrease the amount of the charge for loan impairment in the income statement.
 
The Risk Management note on pages F-141 to F-175 contains further detail on loan loss provisioning methodology.
 
Available for sale financial assets
 
The Group assesses at each balance sheet date whether there is objective evidence that an available for sale financial asset is impaired. In addition to the factors set out above, a significant or prolonged decline in the fair value of an investment in an available for sale equity instrument below its cost is considered in determining whether an impairment loss has been incurred. If an impairment loss has been incurred, the cumulative loss that had been recognised in other comprehensive income is removed from equity and recognised in the income statement. If, in a subsequent period, the fair value of a debt instrument classified as available for sale increases and the increase can be objectively related to an event occurring after the impairment loss was recognised, the impairment loss is reversed through the income statement. Impairment losses recognised in the income statement on equity instruments are not reversed through the income statement.
 
Property, plant and equipment
 
Freehold land and buildings are initially recognised at cost, and subsequently are revalued annually to open market value by independent external valuers. Revaluations are made with sufficient regularity to ensure that the carrying amount does not differ materially from the open market value at the balance sheet date.
 
All other property, plant and equipment, including freehold and leasehold adaptations, are stated at historical cost less accumulated depreciation. Cost includes expenditure that is directly attributable to the acquisition of the items. Subsequent costs are included in the asset’s carrying amount or are recognised as a separate asset, as appropriate, only when it is probable that future economic benefits associated with the item will flow to the Group and the cost of the item can be measured reliably. All other repairs and maintenance are charged to the income statement during the financial period in which they are incurred.
 
Increases in the carrying amount arising on the revaluation of land and buildings are recognised in other comprehensive income. Decreases that offset previous increases on the same asset are recognised in other comprehensive income: all other decreases are charged to the income statement.
 
The Directors consider that residual values of freehold and long leasehold property based on prices prevailing at the time of acquisition or subsequent valuation are such that depreciation is not material.
 
Depreciation is calculated on the straight line method to write down the carrying value of other items of property, plant and equipment to their residual values over their estimated useful lives as follows:
 
     
Adaptation works on freehold and leasehold property Computer and other equipment   15 years, or the remaining period of the lease Maximum of 10 years
 
The assets’ residual values and useful lives are reviewed, and adjusted if appropriate, at each balance sheet date. Property, plant and equipment are reviewed for impairment whenever events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying amount may not be recoverable. An asset’s carrying amount is written down immediately to its recoverable amount if its carrying amount is greater than its estimated recoverable amount. The estimated recoverable amount is the higher of the asset’s fair value less costs to sell or its value in use.
 
Gains and losses on the disposal of property, plant and equipment are determined by reference to their carrying amount and are taken into account in determining profit before tax. If the asset being disposed of had previously


F-24


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
been revalued then any amount in other comprehensive income relating to that asset is reclassified to retained earnings on disposal.
 
Investment property
 
Property held for long term rental yields and capital appreciation is classified as investment property. Investment property comprises freehold and long leasehold land and buildings. It is carried at fair value in the balance sheet based on annual revaluations at open market value and is not depreciated. Changes in fair values are recorded in the income statement. Rental income from investment properties is recognised as it becomes receivable over the term of the lease.
 
Intangible assets
 
(a)   Goodwill
 
Goodwill represents the excess of the cost of an acquisition over the fair value of the Group’s share of the net identifiable assets of the acquired subsidiary, associate or joint venture at the date of acquisition. Goodwill on acquisition of subsidiaries is included in intangible assets. Goodwill on acquisitions of associates or joint ventures is included in ‘investments in associates’ and ‘investments in joint ventures’ as appropriate. The carrying amount of goodwill in the Irish GAAP balance sheet as at March 31, 2004 has been brought forward without adjustment on transition to IFRS.
 
Goodwill is tested annually for impairment, or more frequently if there is any indication that it may be impaired, and carried at cost less accumulated impairment losses. Goodwill is allocated to cash generating units (“CGU”) for the purpose of impairment testing. The CGU is considered to be the smallest identifiable group of assets that generates cash inflows that are largely independent of the cash inflows from other assets or group of assets. The Group impairment model compares the recoverable amount of the CGU with the carrying value at the review date. An impairment loss arises if the carrying value of the CGU exceeds the recoverable amount. The recoverable amount of a CGU is the higher of its fair value less costs to sell and its value in use, where the value in use is the present value of the future cash flows expected to be derived from the CGU.
 
Gains and losses on the disposal of an entity include the carrying amount of goodwill relating to the entity sold.
 
(b)   Computer software
 
Acquired computer software licenses are capitalised on the basis of the costs incurred to acquire and bring to use the specific software. These costs are amortised on the basis of the expected useful lives, which is normally five years.
 
Costs associated with developing or maintaining computer software programmes are recognised as an expense as incurred. Costs that are directly associated with the production of identifiable and unique software products controlled by the Group and which will probably generate economic benefits exceeding costs beyond one year, are recognised as intangible assets. Direct costs include software development, employee costs and an appropriate portion of relevant overheads.
 
Computer software development costs recognised as assets are amortised using the straight line method over their useful lives, which is normally five years.
 
Computer software is reviewed for impairment whenever events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying amount may not be recoverable. An asset’s carrying amount is written down immediately to its recoverable amount if its carrying amount is greater than its estimated recoverable amount. The estimated recoverable amount is the higher of the asset’s fair value less costs to sell and its value in use.


F-25


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
(c)   Other intangible assets
 
Other intangible assets are amortised on a straight line basis over their useful lives which range from 16 years to 20 years and reviewed for impairment whenever events or changes in circumstances indicate that the carrying amount may not be recoverable. An asset’s carrying amount is written down immediately to its recoverable amount if its carrying amount is greater than its estimated recoverable amount. The estimated recoverable amount is the higher of the asset’s fair value less costs to sell or its value in use.
 
Assets and liabilities classified as held for sale
 
An asset or a disposal group is classified as held for sale if the following conditions are met:
 
•   its carrying amount will be recovered principally through sale rather than continuing use;
 
•   it is available for immediate sale; and
 
•   the sale is highly probable within the next twelve months.
 
When an asset (or disposal group), other than a financial asset or financial liability, is initially classified as held for sale, it is measured at the lower of its carrying amount or fair value less costs to sell at the date of reclassification. Impairment losses subsequent to classification of such assets as held for sale are recognised in the income statement. Increases in fair value less costs to sell of such assets that have been classified as held for sale are recognised in the income statement to the extent that the increase is not in excess of any cumulative impairment loss previously recognised in respect of the asset.
 
The measurement of financial assets or financial liabilities which are classified as held for sale is not impacted by that classification, and they continue to be measured in accordance with the Group’s accounting policies for measurement of financial assets and financial liabilities respectively, set out on pages F-18 to F-20.
 
When an asset (or disposal group) is classified as held for sale, prior period amounts are not reclassified.
 
Where the criteria for the classification of an asset (or disposal group) as held for sale cease to be met, the asset (or disposal group) is reclassified out of held for sale and included in the appropriate balance sheet headings.
 
Assets and liabilities held for sale to NAMA
 
Assets and liabilities that the Group expects will be transferred to NAMA during 2010, all of which are financial assets and liabilities, are classified as assets and liabilities held for sale to NAMA.
 
These assets and liabilities continue to be measured in accordance with the Group’s accounting policies for measurement of financial assets and financial liabilities respectively, set out on pages F-18 to F-20. Loans and advances held for sale to NAMA are measured at amortised cost less any incurred impairment losses, which continue to be calculated in accordance with the Group’s accounting policy on impairment of financial assets, set out on pages F-18 to F-20.
 
The assets and liabilities will be derecognised when substantially all of the risks and rewards have transferred to NAMA, which will be the date when ownership of or the beneficial interest in the assets is legally transferred to NAMA. This is expected to occur on a phased basis as ownership of each tranche is transferred. Until the date of derecognition, interest income on the assets continues to be recognised using the effective interest method.
 
Derivatives held for sale to NAMA continue to be measured at fair value through profit or loss.
 
On the derecognition date, a gain or loss will be recognised, measured as the difference between the fair value of the consideration received and the balance sheet value of the assets transferred, less transaction costs and any provision for the ongoing cost of servicing these assets on behalf of NAMA. The consideration received will be measured at fair value at initial recognition.


F-26


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
 
Provisions
 
Provisions are recognised when the Group has a present legal or constructive obligation as a result of past events, it is probable that an outflow of resources embodying economic benefits will be required to settle the obligation, and a reliable estimate of the amount of the obligation can be made.
 
Provision is made for the anticipated costs of restructuring, including related redundancy costs, when an obligation exists. An obligation exists when the Group has a detailed formal plan for restructuring a business and has raised valid expectations in those affected by the restructuring by starting to implement the plan or announcing its main features.
 
Contingent liabilities are possible obligations whose existence will be confirmed only by uncertain future events or present obligations where the transfer of economic benefit is uncertain or cannot be reliably measured. Contingent liabilities are not recognised but are disclosed unless the probability of their occurrence is remote.
 
Employee benefits
 
(a)   Pension obligations
 
The Group companies operate various pension schemes. The schemes are funded and the assets of the schemes are held in separate trustee administered funds. The Group has both defined contribution and defined benefit plans. A defined benefit plan is a pension plan that defines an amount of pension benefit to be provided, usually as a function of one or more factors such as age, years of service or compensation. A defined contribution plan is a pension plan under which the Group pays fixed contributions into a separate entity (a fund) and will have no legal or constructive obligations to pay further contributions if the fund does not hold sufficient assets to pay all employees benefits relating to employee service in the current and prior periods.
 
The asset or liability recognised in the balance sheet in respect of defined benefit pension plans is the present value of the defined benefit obligation at the balance sheet date minus the fair value of plan assets, together with adjustments for unrecognised past service cost. The defined benefit obligation is calculated annually by independent actuaries using the projected unit credit method. The present value of the defined benefit obligation is determined by discounting the estimated future cash outflows using interest rates on high quality corporate bonds that are denominated in the currency in which the benefits will be paid, and that have terms to maturity approximating the terms of the related pension liability.
 
Actuarial gains and losses arising from experience adjustments and changes in actuarial assumptions are charged or credited directly to reserves through the consolidated statement of other comprehensive income. Past service costs are recognised immediately in income, unless the changes to the pension plan are conditional on the employees remaining in service for a specified period of time (the vesting period). In this case, the past service costs are amortised on a straight line basis over the vesting period.
 
For defined contribution plans, once the contributions have been paid, the company has no further payment obligations. The contributions are recognised as employee benefit expense when they are due. Prepaid contributions are recognised as an asset to the extent that a cash refund or a reduction in the future payments is available.
 
(b)   Equity compensation benefits
 
The Group has a number of equity settled share based payment schemes. The fair value at the date of grant of the employee services received in exchange for the grant of the options or shares is recognised as an expense. The total amount to be expensed over the vesting period is determined on the date the options or shares are granted by reference to their fair value, excluding the impact of any non-market vesting conditions (for example, growth in EPS). Non-market vesting conditions are included in assumptions about the number of options or shares that are expected to vest. At each balance sheet date, the Group revises its estimate of the number of options or shares that


F-27


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
are expected to vest. It recognises the impact of the revision of the original estimates, if any, in the income statement, and a corresponding adjustment to equity over the remaining vesting period.
 
Where an option is cancelled, the Group immediately recognises, as an expense, the amount of the expense that would have otherwise been recognised over the remainder of the vesting period.
 
Where new shares are issued, the proceeds received net of any directly attributable transaction costs are credited to share capital (at nominal value) and to share premium, when the options are exercised.
 
The fair value of the options granted is determined using option pricing models, which take into account the exercise price of the option, the current share price, the risk free interest rate, the expected volatility of the share price over the life of the option and other relevant factors.
 
Upon transition to IFRS, the Group availed of the exemption only to apply IFRS 2 to share based payments which were granted on or after November 7, 2002 that had not yet vested by January 1, 2005.
 
(c)   Short term employee benefit
 
Short term employee benefits, such as salaries and other benefits, are accounted for on an accruals basis over the period in which the employees’ service is rendered. Bonuses are recognised where the Group has a legal or constructive obligation to employees that can be reliably measured.
 
(d)   Termination payments
 
Termination payments are recognised as an expense when the Group is demonstrably committed to a formal plan to terminate employment before the normal retirement date. Termination payments for voluntary redundancies are recognised where an offer has been made by the Group, it is probable that the offer will be accepted and the number of acceptances can be reliably estimated.
 
Income taxes
 
(a)   Current income tax
 
Income tax payable on profits, based on the applicable tax law in each jurisdiction, is recognised as an expense in the period in which profits arise. The tax effects of income tax losses available for carry forward are recognised as an asset when it is probable that future taxable profits will be available against which these losses are utilised.
 
(b)   Deferred income tax
 
Deferred income tax is provided in full, using the liability method, on temporary differences arising between the tax bases of assets and liabilities and their carrying amounts in the financial statements. Deferred income tax is determined using tax rates (and tax laws) that have been enacted or substantially enacted by the balance sheet date and are expected to apply when the related deferred income tax asset is realised or the deferred income tax liability is settled.
 
The rates enacted or substantively enacted at the balance sheet date are used to determine deferred income tax. However, the deferred income tax is not accounted for if it arises from initial recognition of an asset or liability in a transaction other than a business combination that at the time of the transaction affects neither accounting nor taxable profit or loss.
 
Deferred tax assets are recognised to the extent that it is probable that future taxable profit will be available against which the temporary differences can be utilised.


F-28


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
Deferred income tax is provided on temporary differences arising from investments in subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures, except where the timing of the reversal of the temporary difference is controlled by the Group and it is probable that the difference will not reverse in the foreseeable future.
 
Deferred tax on items taken to other comprehensive income is also recognised in other comprehensive income and is subsequently reclassified to the income statement together with the deferred gain or loss.
 
Cash and cash equivalents
 
For the purposes of the cash flow statement, cash and cash equivalents comprise cash in hand and balances with central banks and post office banks which can be withdrawn on demand. It also comprises balances with an original maturity of less than three months.
 
Capital stock and reserves
 
(1)   Stock issue costs
 
Incremental external costs directly attributable to the issue of new equity stock or options are shown in equity as a deduction, net of tax, from the proceeds.
 
(2)   Dividends on ordinary stock
 
Dividends on ordinary stock are recognised in equity in the period in which they are approved by the Bank’s stockholders.
 
(3)   Treasury stock
 
Where the Bank or its subsidiaries purchases the Bank’s equity capital stock, the consideration paid is deducted from total stockholders’ equity as treasury stock until they are cancelled. Where such stock is subsequently sold or reissued, any consideration received is included in stockholders’ equity. Any changes in the value of treasury stock held are recognised in equity at the time of the disposal and dividends are not recognised as income or distributions.
 
This is particularly relevant in respect of Bank of Ireland stock held by Bank of Ireland Life for the benefit of policyholders.
 
(4)   Capital Reserve
 
The capital reserve represents transfers from retained earnings and other reserves in accordance with relevant legislation. The capital reserve is not distributable.
 
(5)   Foreign exchange reserve
 
The foreign exchange reserve represents the cumulative gains and losses on the translation of the Group’s net investment in its foreign operations since April 1, 2004.
 
(6)   Revaluation reserve
 
The revaluation reserve represents the cumulative gains and losses on the revaluation of property occupied by Group businesses, included within property, plant and equipment and non-financial assets classified as held for sale.
 
(7)   Available for sale reserve
 
The available for sale reserve represents the cumulative change in fair value of available for sale financial assets together with the impact of any fair value hedge accounting adjustments.


F-29


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
(8)   Cash flow hedge reserve
 
The cash flow hedge reserve represents the cumulative changes in fair value, excluding any ineffectiveness, of cash flow hedging derivatives. This will be transferred to the income statement when the hedged transactions impact the Group’s profit or loss.
 
Life assurance operations
 
In accordance with IFRS 4, the Group classifies all life assurance products as either insurance or investment contracts for accounting purposes.
 
Insurance contracts are those contracts that transfer significant insurance risk. These contracts are accounted for using an embedded value basis.
 
Investment contracts are accounted for in accordance with IAS 39. All of the Group’s investment contracts are unit linked in nature. These contracts are accounted for as financial liabilities whose value is contractually linked to the fair value of the financial assets within the policyholders’ unit linked funds. The value of the unit linked financial liabilities is determined using current unit prices multiplied by the number of units attributed to the contract holders at the balance sheet date. Their value is never less than the amount payable on surrender, discounted for the required notice period where applicable.
 
Non unit linked insurance liabilities are calculated using either a gross premium or net premium method of valuation. The assumptions are also set in accordance with the guidelines in the Insurance Regulations and contain a margin for adverse development. The key assumptions used in the valuation of insurance contract liabilities are:
 
     
Interest rate
  The interest rates are derived in accordance with the guidelines in the Insurance Regulations. Margins for risk are allowed for in the derived interest rates.
Mortality and morbidity
  The mortality and morbidity assumptions, which include an allowance for improvements in longevity for annuitants, are set with regard to the Group’s actual experience and / or relevant industry data.
Maintenance expenses
  Allowance is made for future policy costs and expense inflation explicitly.
 
The Group recognises an asset for deferred acquisition costs relating to investment contracts. Up front fees received for investment management services are deferred. These amounts are amortised over the period of the contract.
 
The Group recognises the value of in force life assurance business asset as the present value of future profits expected to arise from contracts classified as insurance contracts under IFRS 4. The asset has been calculated in accordance with the embedded value achieved profits methodology in the Statement of Recommended Practice issued by the Association of British Insurers which came into force in 2002. The asset is determined by projecting the future statutory surpluses attributable to stockholders estimated to arise from insurance contracts. The surpluses are projected using appropriate assumptions as to future investment returns, persistency, mortality and expense levels and include consideration of guarantees and options. These surpluses are then discounted at a risk adjusted rate. Thus, the use of best estimate assumptions in the valuation of the value of in force asset ensures that the net carrying amount of insurance liabilities less the value of in force assets is adequate.
 
The value of in force asset in the consolidated balance sheet and movements in the asset in the income statement are presented on a gross of tax basis. The tax charge comprises both current and deferred tax expense and includes tax attributable to both stockholders and policyholders for the period.


F-30


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
Premiums and claims
 
Premiums receivable in respect of non unit linked insurance contracts are recognised as revenue when due from policyholders. Premiums received in respect of unit linked insurance contracts are recognised in the same period in which the related policyholder liabilities are created. Claims are recorded as an expense when they are incurred.
 
Reinsurance
 
Contracts entered into by the Group with reinsurers under which the Group is compensated for losses on one or more contracts issued by the Group are dealt with as insurance contracts, subject to meeting the significant insurance risk test in IFRS 4. Outward reinsurance premiums are accounted for in accordance with the contract terms when due for payment.
 
Offsetting financial instruments
 
Financial assets and liabilities are offset and the net amount reported in the balance sheet when there is a legally enforceable right of set off and there is an intention to settle on a net basis, or realise the asset and settle the liability simultaneously.
 
Collateral
 
The Group enters into master agreements with counterparties, to ensure that if an event of default occurs, all amounts outstanding with those counterparties will be settled on a net basis.
 
The Group obtains collateral in respect of customer liabilities where this is considered appropriate. The collateral normally takes the form of a lien over the customer’s assets and gives the Group a claim on these assets for both existing and future liabilities. The collateral is, in general, not recorded on the Group balance sheet.
 
The Group also receives collateral in the form of cash or securities in respect of other credit instruments, such as stock borrowing contracts and derivative contracts, in order to reduce credit risk. Collateral received in the form of securities is not recorded on the balance sheet. Collateral received in the form of cash is recorded on the balance sheet, with a corresponding liability recognised within deposits from banks or deposits from customers. Any interest payable arising is recorded as interest expense.
 
In certain circumstances, the Group pledges collateral in respect of liabilities or borrowings. Collateral pledged in the form of securities or loans and advances continues to be recorded on the balance sheet. Collateral placed in the form of cash is recorded in loans and advances to banks or customers. Any interest receivable arising is recorded as interest income.
 
Financial guarantees
 
Financial guarantees are given to banks, financial institutions and other bodies on behalf of customers to secure loans, overdrafts and other banking facilities (‘facility guarantees’), and to other parties in connection with the performance of customers under obligations related to contracts, advance payments made by other parties, tenders, retentions and the payment of import duties. Financial guarantees are initially recognised in the financial statements at fair value on the date that the guarantee is given. Subsequent to initial recognition, the Group’s liabilities under such guarantees are measured at the higher of the initial measurement, less amortisation calculated to recognise in the income statement the fee income earned over the period, and the best estimate of the expenditure required to settle any financial obligation arising as a result of the guarantees at the balance sheet date.
 
Any increase in the liability relating to guarantees is taken to the income statement and recognised on the balance sheet within provisions for undrawn contractually committed facilities and guarantees.


F-31


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
 
Operating segments
 
The segment analysis of the Group’s results and financial position is set out in note 2. The Group has identified five reportable operating segments, which are as follows: Retail Republic of Ireland, Bank of Ireland Life, UK Financial Services, Capital Markets and Group Centre.
 
These segments have been identified on the basis that the chief operating decision-maker uses information based on these segments to make decisions about assessing performance and allocating resources. The analysis of results by operating segment is based on management accounts information.
 
Transactions between the operating segments are on normal commercial terms and conditions. Internal charges and transfer pricing adjustments have been reflected in the performance of each segment. Revenue sharing agreements are used to allocate external customer revenues to operating segments on a reasonable basis.
 
Materiality
 
In its assessment of materiality, the Group considers the impact of any misstatements based on both:
 
•   the amount of the misstatement originating in the current year income statement; and
 
•   the effects of correcting the misstatement existing in the balance sheet at the end of the current year irrespective of the year in which the misstatement occurred.


F-32


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
 
Impact of new accounting standards
 
The following standards, interpretations and amendments to standards will be relevant to the Group but were not effective at December 31, 2009 and have not been applied in preparing these financial statements. The Group’s initial view of the impact of these accounting changes is outlined below.
 
New standards, interpretations and amendments to standards effective for the year ended December 31, 2010:
 
             
Pronouncement
  Nature of change   Effective date   Impact
 
IAS 39 (Amendment) — Eligible Hedged Items, ‘Financial Instruments: Recognition and Measurement’   This amendment to IAS 39 clarifies how the principles that determine whether a hedged risk or portions of cash flows is eligible for designation as a hedged item or items should be applied.   Annual periods beginning on or after July 1, 2009   Not significant
             
IAS 27 (Revised) — ‘Consolidated and separate financial statements’   The revised standard requires the effects of all transactions with non-controlling interests to be recorded in equity if there is no change in control. These transactions will no longer result in goodwill on acquisitions from non-controlling interests or gains and losses on disposals to non-controlling interests. The standard also specifies the accounting when control is lost. Any remaining interest in the entity is remeasured to fair value, and a gain or loss is recognised in profit or loss. The Group will apply IAS 27 (Revised) prospectively to transactions with non-controlling interests from January 1, 2010.   Financial periods beginning on or after July 1, 2009   Not significant
             
IAS 27 (Amendment) ‘Cost of an investment in a subsidiary, jointly-controlled entity or associate’   The amendment removes the definition of the cost method from IAS 27 and requires an entity to present dividends from investment in subsidiaries, jointly controlled entities and associates as income in the separate financial statements of the investors.   Financial periods beginning on or after July 1, 2009   Not significant
             
IFRS 3 (Revised) — ‘Business combinations’   The revised standard continues to apply the acquisition method to business combinations, with some significant changes. For example, all payments to purchase a business are to be recorded at fair value at the acquisition date, with contingent payments classified as debt subsequently re-measured through the income statement. There is a choice on an acquisition-by-acquisition basis to measure the non-controlling interest in the acquiree either at fair value or at the non-controlling interest’s proportionate share of the acquiree’s net assets. All acquisition-related costs should be expensed. The group will apply IFRS 3 (Revised) prospectively to all business combinations from January 1, 2010.   Financial periods beginning on or after January 1, 2010   The impact on the Group will be dependent on the nature of any future acquisition.
 


F-33


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
             
Pronouncement
  Nature of change   Effective date   Impact
 
IFRS 2 (Amendment) — ‘Group Cash-settled share-based payment transactions’   The amendment clarifies the scope and the accounting for group cash-settled share-based payment transactions in the separate financial statements of the entity receiving the goods or services when that entity has no obligation to settle the share-based payment transactions. The amendment also incorporates the guidance contained in IFRIC 8 and IFRIC 11. As a result the IFRIC 8 and IFRIC 11 have been withdrawn. This amendment is still subject to EU endorsement.   Financial periods beginning on or after January 1, 2010   Not significant
             
Improvements to IFRSs 2009   The ‘Improvements to IFRSs 2009’ standard amends 10 standards, basis of conclusions and guidance, and 2 interpretations. The improvements include changes in presentation, recognition and measurement plus terminology and editorial changes. The Improvements are subject to EU endorsement.   Financial periods ranging from periods beginning on or after July 1, 2009 to periods beginning on or after January 1, 2010   Not significant
             
IFRIC 17 — ‘Distribution of non-cash to owners’   IFRIC 17 addresses how non-cash dividends distributed to shareholders should be measured. A dividend obligation is recognised when the dividend was authorised by the appropriate entity and is no longer at the discretion of the entity. The dividend obligation should be recognised at fair value of the net assets distributed. The difference between the dividend paid and the amount carried forward of the net assets distributed should be recognised in profit and loss. Additional disclosures are to be made if the net assets being held for distribution to owners meet the definition of a discontinued operation.   Financial periods beginning on or after July 1, 2009   Not significant
             
IFRS 9 — ‘Financial instruments’   The new standard addresses classification and measurement of financial assets. IFRS 9 replaces the multiple classification models in IAS 39 with a model that has two classification categories: amortised cost and fair value. Classification under IFRS 9 is driven by the entity’s business model for managing financial assets and the contractual characteristics of the financial assets. IFRS 9 removes the requirement to separate embedded derivatives from financial asset hosts and the cost exemption for unquoted equities. IFRS 9 is subject to EU endorsement, the timing of which is uncertain.   Financial periods beginning on or after January 1, 2013   The impact of IFRS 9 may change as a consequence of further developments resulting from the IASB’s financial instruments project. As a result, it is impracticable to quantify the impact of IFRS 9 as at the date of publication of these financial statements.
 

F-34


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
ACCOUNTING POLICIES  (Continued)
 
             
Pronouncement
  Nature of change   Effective date   Impact
 
Amendment to IAS 32 — ‘Classification of Rights Issues’   The amendment addresses the accounting for rights issues (rights, options or warrants) that are denominated in a currency other than the functional currency of the issuer. Previously such rights issues were accounted for as derivative liabilities. However, the amendment requires that, provided certain conditions are met, such rights are classified as equity regardless of the currency in which the exercise price is denominated.   Annual periods beginning on or after February 1, 2010   Not significant
             
Amendment to IAS 24 — ‘Related Party Disclosures’   The amendment simplifies the definition of a related party and provides a partial exemption from the disclosure requirements for government-related entities. This amendment is still subject to EU endorsement.   Annual periods beginning on or after January 1, 2011   The amendment may impact the level of detail which the Group is required to disclose in relation to transactions with the Irish Government
             
Amendment to IFRIC 14 — ‘Prepayments of a Minimum Funding Requirement’   The amendment removes an unintended consequence of IFRIC 14 related to voluntary pension prepayments when there is a minimum funding requirement. This amendment is still subject to EU endorsement.   Financial periods beginning on or after January 1, 2011   Not significant
             
IFRIC 19 — ‘Extinguishing Financial Liabilities with Equity Instruments’   IFRIC 19 requires a gain or loss to be recognised in profit or loss when a liability is settled through the issuance of the entity’s own equity instruments. The interpretation is still subject to EU endorsement.   Financial periods beginning on or after July 1, 2010   The impact on the Group will be dependent on any such transactions occurring.

F-35


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES AND JUDGEMENTS
 
In preparing the financial statements, the Group makes estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets, liabilities, revenues and expenses. Estimates and judgements are continually evaluated and are based on historical experience and other factors, including expectations of future events that are believed to be reasonable under the circumstances. As management judgement involves an estimate of the likelihood of future events, actual results could differ from those estimates, which could affect the future reported amounts of assets and liabilities. The estimates and judgements that have had the most significant effect on the amounts recognised in the Group’s financial statements are set out below.
 
(a)   Impairment charges on financial assets
 
The Group reviews its loan portfolios at least on a quarterly basis to assess impairment. The Group first assesses whether objective evidence of impairment exists individually for financial assets that are individually significant, and individually or collectively for financial assets that are not individually significant. Impairment provisions are also recognised for losses not specifically identified but which, experience and observable data indicate, are present in the portfolio at the date of assessment.
 
Management uses estimates based on historical loss experience for assets with credit risk characteristics and objective evidence of impairment similar to those in the portfolio, when scheduling its future cash flows. The methodology and assumptions used for estimating both the amount and timing of future cash flows are reviewed regularly to reduce any differences between loss estimates and actual loss experience. The use of historical loss experience is supplemented with significant management judgment to assess whether current economic and credit conditions are such that the actual level of inherent losses is likely to differ from that suggested by historical experience. In normal circumstances, historical experience provides objective and relevant information from which to assess inherent loss within each portfolio. In other circumstances, historical loss experience provides less relevant information about the inherent loss in a given portfolio at the balance sheet date, for example, where there have been changes in economic conditions such that the most recent trends in risk factors are not fully reflected in the historical information. In these circumstances, such risk factors are taken into account when calculating the appropriate levels of impairment allowances, by adjusting the impairment loss derived solely from historical loss experience.
 
The detailed methodologies, areas of estimation and judgement applied in the calculation of the Group’s impairment charge on financial assets are set out in the Risk Management note on pages F-141 to F-175.
 
The most critical judgemental area is in relation to impairment of property and construction loans and advances. This loan portfolio has been significantly affected in the current economic climate, as values of security have significantly reduced and, particularly in Ireland, there are very low levels of activity in the sector. Gross property and construction loans at December 31, 2009, including those held for sale to NAMA, amounted to €35.6 billion (March 31, 2009: €34 billion), against which were held provisions for impairment of €3.9 billion, (March 31, 2009: €0.9 billion).
 
The estimation of impairment losses is subject to uncertainty, which has increased in the current economic environment, and is highly sensitive to factors such as the level of economic activity, unemployment rates, bankruptcy trends, property price trends, and interest rates. The assumptions underlying this judgement are highly subjective. The methodology and the assumptions used in calculating impairment losses are reviewed regularly in the light of differences between loss estimates and actual loss experience. See note 27 for more information.
 
(b)   Assets held for sale to NAMA
 
Assets that the Group expects will be transferred to NAMA, all of which are financial assets, are classified as assets held for sale to NAMA. In the preparation of the financial statements at December 31, 2009, there are two key areas of judgement in relation to these assets.


F-36


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES AND JUDGEMENTS  (Continued)
 
The first of these is the identification of the quantity of assets which are expected to transfer. Based on the Eligible Asset Regulations (as contained within the NAMA regulations), internal review work to identify all loans falling within the eligibility criteria and ongoing interaction with NAMA, the Group expects to transfer total gross land and development and associated loans of approximately €12.2 billion, together with related derivatives and accrued interest of €0.2 billion. Net of impairment provisions of €2.8 billion which are held against these loans at December 31, 2009, this estimate would imply a net transfer of €9.6 billion of Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA.
 
As interactions with NAMA and the internal review work are ongoing and the possibility exists that loans that are expected to transfer may be repaid or refinanced with other banks, there is uncertainty as to the final amount of eligible assets that will transfer.
 
Secondly, significant judgement is required in relation to the level of impairment incurred on these assets, the vast majority of which are property and construction loans. As set out in the Group’s accounting policy for assets held for sale to NAMA on page F-26, impairment on these assets continues to be calculated on the same basis as prior to their classification as held for sale. The areas of judgement and estimation involved are set out in the above section on impairment of financial assets, together with the level of impairment provisions held against property and construction loans at December 31, 2009, including these assets.
 
Further information on the expected transfer of assets to NAMA is set out in notes 26 and 58.
 
(c)   Fair value of financial instruments
 
The Group measures certain of its financial instruments at fair value in the balance sheet. This includes trading securities, other financial assets and liabilities at fair value through profit or loss, all derivatives and available for sale financial assets. The fair values of financial instruments are determined by reference to observable market prices where available and an active market exists. Where market prices are not available or are unreliable, fair values are determined using valuation techniques including discounted cash flow models which, to the extent possible, use observable market inputs.
 
Where valuation techniques are used they are validated and periodically reviewed by qualified personnel independent of the area that created them. All models are calibrated to ensure that outputs reflect actual data and comparable market prices. Using valuation techniques may necessitate the estimation of certain pricing inputs, assumptions or model characteristics such as credit risk, volatilities and correlations and changes in these assumptions could affect reported fair values.
 
The fair value movement on assets and liabilities held at fair value through profit or loss, including those held for trading, are included in net trading income. Fair values in respect of financial assets and liabilities are disclosed in note 46.
 
The most significant area of judgement is in relation to financial liabilities classified within level 3 of the 3-level fair value hierarchy. These comprise debt securities in issue and subordinated liabilities with a fair value of €701 million (March 31, 2009: €795 million) which are measured at fair value through profit or loss, and the fair value of which is based on valuation techniques incorporating significant unobservable market data. The key judgement relates to the Group’s credit spread, the estimation of which has become more judgemental in current market circumstances. The Group estimates this spread by reference to recent transactions in the same instrument or in similar instruments issued by the Group. The effect of changing the estimated credit spreads to a range of reasonably possible alternatives would decrease the fair value of the liabilities by up to €35 million or increase their fair value by up to €6 million, with a corresponding impact on the income statement.
 
(d)   Retirement benefits
 
The Group operates a number of defined benefit pension schemes. In determining the actual pension cost, the actuarial values of the liabilities of the schemes are calculated. This involves modelling their future growth and


F-37


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES AND JUDGEMENTS  (Continued)
 
requires management to make assumptions as to price inflation, dividend growth, salary and pensions increases, return on investments and employee mortality. There are acceptable ranges in which these estimates can validly fall. The impact on the results for the period and financial position could be materially different if alternative assumptions were used. An analysis of the sensitivity of the defined benefit pension liability to changes in the key assumptions is set out in note 43 on retirement benefit obligations.
 
(e)   Life assurance operations
 
The Group accounts for the value of the stockholders’ interest in long term assurance business using the embedded value basis of accounting. Embedded value is comprised of the net tangible assets of Bank of Ireland Life and the present value of its in force business. The value of in force business is calculated by projecting future surpluses and other net cash flows attributable to the shareholder arising from business written up to the balance sheet date and discounting the result at a rate which reflects the shareholder’s overall risk premium, before provision has been made for taxation.
 
Future surpluses will depend on experience in a number of areas such as investment returns, lapse rates, mortality and investment expenses. Surpluses are projected by making assumptions about future experience, having regards to both actual experience and forecast long term economic trends. Changes to these assumptions may cause the present value of future surpluses to differ from those assumed at the balance sheet date and could significantly affect the value attributed to the in force business. The value of in force business could also be affected by changes in the amounts and timing of other net cash flows (principally annual management charges and other fees levied upon the policyholders) or the rate at which the future surpluses and cash flows are discounted. In addition, the extent to which actual experience is different from that assumed will be recognised in the income statement for the period. An analysis of the sensitivity of profit after tax and stockholders’ equity to changes in the key life assurance assumptions is set out in note 53 on the life assurance business.
 
(f)   Taxation
 
The taxation charge accounts for amounts due to fiscal authorities in the various territories in which the Group operates and includes estimates based on a judgement of the application of law and practice in certain cases to determine the quantification of any liabilities arising. In arriving at such estimates, management assesses the relative merits and risks of tax treatments assumed, taking into account statutory, judicial and regulatory guidance and, where appropriate, external advice.
 
At December 31, 2009 the Group had a net deferred tax asset of €731 million (March 31, 2009: €510 million), of which €475 million (March 31, 2009: nil) related to incurred trading losses.
 
A deferred tax asset is recognised to the extent that it is probable that future taxable profits will be available against which deductible temporary differences and unutilised tax losses can be utilised. The recognition of a deferred tax asset relies on management’s judgements surrounding the probability and sufficiency of future taxable profits, and the future reversals of existing taxable temporary differences.
 
To the extent that the recognition of a deferred tax asset is dependent on sufficient future profitability, a degree of estimation and the use of assumptions is required. The Group’s judgement takes into consideration the impact of both positive and negative evidence, including historical financial performance, projections of future taxable income, the impact of tax legislation and future reversals of existing taxable temporary differences.
 
The most significant judgement relates to the Group’s assessment of the recoverability of the portion of the deferred tax asset relating to trading losses. Under current Irish and UK tax legislation, there is no time restriction on the utilisation of these losses. Based on its projection of future taxable income, the Group has concluded that it is probable that sufficient taxable profits will be generated to recover this deferred tax asset, and it has been recognised in full.


F-38


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
CRITICAL ACCOUNTING ESTIMATES AND JUDGEMENTS  (Continued)
 
(g)   Goodwill
 
The Group capitalises goodwill arising on the acquisition of businesses, as disclosed in the accounting policies. The carrying value of goodwill as at December 31, 2009 was €48 million (March 31, 2009: €47 million). Goodwill is tested for impairment annually or more frequently if events or changes in circumstances indicate that it might be impaired.
 
For the purposes of impairment testing, goodwill acquired in a business combination is allocated to each of the Group’s cash generating units expected to benefit from the combination. Goodwill impairment testing involves the comparison of the carrying value of a cash generating unit with its recoverable amount. The recoverable amount is the higher of the unit’s fair value or its value in use.
 
Value in use is the present value of expected future cash flows from the cash generating unit. Fair value is the amount obtainable for the sale of the cash generating unit in an arm’s length transaction between knowledgeable, willing parties.
 
Impairment testing inherently involves a number of judgemental areas: the preparation of cash flow forecasts for periods that are beyond the normal requirements of management reporting; the assessment of the discount rate appropriate to the business; estimation of the fair value of cash generating units; and the valuation of the separable assets of each business whose goodwill is being reviewed. The use of reasonably possible alternative assumptions would not impact the carrying value of the Group’s goodwill. See note 30 for further information.
 
(h)   Provisions
 
The Group has recognised provisions in relation to restructuring costs, onerous contracts and litigation. Such provisions are sensitive to a variety of factors, which vary depending on their nature. The estimation of the amounts of such provisions is judgemental because the relevant payments are due in the future and the quantity and probability of such payments is uncertain.
 
The methodology and the assumptions used in the calculation of provisions are reviewed regularly and, at a minimum, at each reporting date. Details of the Group’s provisions are set out in note 41.


F-39


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT
 
Index to the notes to the consolidated financial statements
 
             
        Page
 
1
  Comparative period     F-42  
2
  Operating segments     F-42  
3
  Interest income     F-49  
4
  Interest expense     F-49  
5
  Net insurance premium income     F-49  
6
  Fees and commission income and expense     F-50  
7
  Net trading expense     F-50  
8
  Life assurance investment income and gains/(losses)     F-51  
9
  Gain on repurchase of subordinated liabilities     F-52  
10
  Other operating income     F-53  
11
  Insurance contract liabilities and claims paid     F-53  
12
  Other operating expenses     F-54  
13
  Auditors’ remuneration     F-55  
14
  Impairment charges on financial assets     F-56  
15
  Operating (loss)/profit     F-56  
16
  Results of associates and joint ventures (after tax)     F-56  
17
  Loss on disposal of business activities     F-56  
18
  Taxation     F-57  
19
  Earnings per share     F-60  
20
  Trading securities     F-62  
21
  Derivative financial instruments     F-62  
22
  Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss     F-65  
23
  Loans and advances to banks     F-65  
24
  Available for sale financial assets     F-66  
25
  Loans and advances to customers     F-67  
26
  Assets and liabilities held for sale to NAMA     F-69  
27
  Impairment provisions     F-72  
28
  Interest in associates     F-72  
29
  Interest in joint ventures     F-73  
30
  Intangible assets     F-73  
31
  Investment properties     F-76  
32
  Property, plant and equipment     F-77  
33
  Other assets     F-80  
34
  Other assets and liabilities classified as held for sale     F-80  
35
  Deposits from banks     F-81  
36
  Customer accounts     F-81  
37
  Debt securities in issue     F-81  
38
  Liabilities to customer unders investment and insurance contracts     F-82  
39
  Subordinated liabilities     F-84  
40
  Other liabilities     F-87  


F-40


Table of Contents

 
BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
             
        Page
 
41
  Provisions     F-88  
42
  Deferred tax     F-89  
43
  Retirement benefit obligations     F-90  
44
  Contingent liabilities and commitments     F-95  
45
  Capital stock     F-97  
46
  Fair values of financial assets and liabilities     F-104  
47
  Measurement basis of financial assets and liabilities     F-112  
48
  Cash and cash equivalents     F-114  
49
  General     F-114  
50
  Related party transactions     F-115  
51
  Principal undertakings     F-121  
52
  Other subsidiaries     F-123  
53
  Life assurance business     F-124  
54
  Directors’ information     F-126  
55
  Summary of relations with the Irish Government     F-135  
56
  Risk management     F-141  
57
  Capital management     F-176  
58
  Post balance sheet events     F-177  
59
  Selected financial information for the nine months ended 31 December 2008 (unaudited)     F-183  
60
  Approval of 20-F     F-183  


F-41


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT
 
1 COMPARATIVE PERIOD
 
On February 17, 2010, the Governor & Company of the Bank of Ireland announced that it was changing its fiscal year end from March 31 to December 31 to align its financial calendar with that of its peer banks.
 
These consolidated financial statements cover the nine month period from April 1, 2009 to December 31, 2009, while the comparative period covers the twelve months from April 1, 2008 to March 31, 2009 and April 1, 2007 to March 31, 2008. As a result, the amounts presented in the financial statements are not entirely comparable.
 
2 OPERATING SEGMENTS
 
The Group has five reportable operating segments as detailed below. As noted in the accounting policies and basis of presentation on pages F-12 to F-35 the Group adopted IFRS 8 during the period and this has not resulted in a change in the Group’s operating segments. These segments reflect the internal financial and management reporting structure and are organised as follows:
 
Retail Republic of Ireland
 
Retail Republic of Ireland includes all the Group’s branch operations in the Republic of Ireland. The branches offer a wide range of financial products and services in addition to the deposit, lending, current account and other money transmission services traditionally offered by banks. It also includes Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank, ICS Building Society, Private Banking, an instalment credit and leasing business, credit card operations, commercial finance/factoring businesses, the domestic and US foreign exchange operations of First Rate Enterprises and direct telephone and online banking services.
 
Bank of Ireland Life (BoI Life)
 
BoI Life offers life assurance, protection, pensions and investment products to customers in Ireland through the extensive branch banking network of Retail Republic of Ireland. The company also operates in the independent intermediary market and through a direct sales force.
 
UK Financial Services
 
UK Financial Services (UKFS) comprises Business Banking in Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the branch network in Northern Ireland, the UK residential mortgage business which, as announced in January 2009 is no longer being sourced through the intermediary channel and the business ventures with the UK Post Office. The business banking unit provides loan facilities to medium and large corporate clients in addition to international banking, working capital financing, leasing and electronic banking services. Offshore deposit taking services are offered in the Isle of Man. The business activities with the UK Post Office are Post Office Financial Services and First Rate Exchange Services, which provide a range of retail financial services.
 
Capital Markets
 
The principal constituents of this division are Corporate Banking and Global Markets in addition to Asset Management Services and IBI Corporate Finance.
 
Corporate Banking provides integrated relationship banking services to a significant number of the major Irish corporations, financial institutions and multinational corporations operating in or out of Ireland. The range of lending products provided includes overdraft and short term loan facilities, term loans, project finance and structured finance. Corporate Banking is also engaged in international lending, with offices located in the UK, France, Germany and the US. Its international lending business includes acquisition finance, project finance, term lending and asset based financing, principally in the UK, Continental Europe and the US.


F-42


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
2 OPERATING SEGMENTS  (Continued)
 
Global Markets is responsible for managing the Group’s interest rate and foreign exchange risks, while also executing the Group’s liquidity and funding requirements. Global Markets trades in a range of market instruments on behalf of the Group itself and the Group’s customers. The trading activities include dealing in inter-bank deposits and loans, foreign exchange spot and forward contracts, options, financial futures, bonds, swaps, forward rate agreements and equity tracker products. Global Markets has offices located in the UK and the US, as well as in the Republic of Ireland.
 
Group Centre
 
Group Centre mainly includes capital management activities, unallocated support costs and the cost of the Irish Government Guarantee Schemes.
 
Other Reconciling Items
 
Other reconciling items represent inter-segment transactions which are eliminated upon consolidation.
 
The analysis of results by operating segment is based on the information used by management to allocate resources and assess performance. Transactions between the business segments are on normal commercial terms and conditions. Internal charges and transfer pricing adjustments have been reflected in the performance of each business. Revenue sharing agreements are used to allocate external customer revenues to a business segment on a reasonable basis.
 
The Group’s management reporting and controlling systems use accounting policies that are the same as those referenced in Accounting Policies on pages F-12 to F-35. The Group measures the performance of its operating segments through a measure of segment profit or loss which is referred to as “Underlying profit” in our internal management reporting systems. Underlying profit or loss is the measure of segment profit or loss used in segment reporting and excludes gross up of policyholder tax in the life business; gain/loss on disposal of business activities; impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets arising from a systemic market event or where the Group is committed to exiting the relevant business; gain on repurchase of subordinated liabilities; investment return on treasury stock held for policyholders; Effective Interest Rate (EIR) adjustment on subordinated debt, the cost of restructuring programmes; hedge ineffectiveness is no longer excluded from underlying for the nine months to December 31, 2009.
 
Capital expenditure comprises additions to property, plant and equipment and intangible assets including additions resulting from acquisitions through business combinations.
 
Gross revenue comprises interest income, net insurance premium income, fee and commission income, net trading expense, life assurance investment income and gains/losses, other operating income, insurance contract liabilities and claims paid and income from associates and joint ventures.
 
There were no revenues deriving from transactions with a single external customer that amounted to 10% or more of the Group’s revenues.
 
Note to table on page F-44
 
(i)  In the current period a revision of estimated cash flows on certain subordinated liabilities has resulted in an income statement credit of €67 million. Of this amount €58 million represents a reduction in interest expense (note 4) while €9 million is report in net trading expense (note 7).
 


F-43


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
2 OPERATING SEGMENTS  (Continued)
 
                                                         
    Retail
      UK
          Other
   
9 Months Ended
  Republic
      Financial
  Capital
  Group
  Reconciling
   
December 31, 2009
  of Ireland   BoI Life   Services   Markets   Centre   items   Group
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Interest income
    3,304       14       2,339       3,438       (513 )     (4,394 )     4,188  
Interest expense
    (2,416 )     (16 )     (1,874 )     (2,733 )     578       4,394       (2,067 )
                                                         
Net interest income
    888       (2 )     465       705       65             2,121  
Other income, net of insurance claims
    112       153       70       83       (102 )           316  
                                                         
Total operating income, net of insurance claims
    1,000       151       535       788       (37 )           2,437  
                                                         
Other operating expenses
    (638 )     (78 )     (277 )     (222 )     (59 )           (1,274 )
Depreciation and amortisation
    (42 )     (4 )     (27 )     (8 )     (26 )           (107 )
                                                         
Operating expenses
    (680 )     (82 )     (304 )     (230 )     (85 )           (1,381 )
Impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets
    (6 )                                   (6 )
                                                         
Operating profit before impairment charges on financial assets
    314       69       231       558       (122 )           1,050  
Impairment charges on loans and advances to customers
    (1,836 )           (1,062 )     (1,157 )                 (4,055 )
Impairment charges on available for sale financial assets
                      (2 )                 (2 )
Share of results of associates and joint ventures
    8             26       1                   35  
                                                         
Underlying (loss)/profit before tax
    (1,514 )     69       (805 )     (600 )     (122 )           (2,972 )
Effective Interest Rate adjustment on subordinated liabilities1
                            67             67  
Gross-up of policyholder tax in the Life business
          64                               64  
Investment return on treasury stock held for policyholders
                            (6 )           (6 )
Loss on disposal of business activities
                      (3 )                 (3 )
Repurchase of subordinated liabilities
                            1,037             1,037  
                                                         
Statutory (loss)/profit before tax
    (1,514 )     133       (805 )     (603 )     976             (1,813 )
                                                         
Capital expenditure
          2       32       6       20             60  
                                                         
Investment in associates and joint ventures
    134             74       9                   217  
                                                         
External assets
    52,999       11,744       53,804       60,101       2,458             181,106  
Inter segment assets
    68,946       1,714       22,202       135,270       47,020       (275,152 )      
                                                         
Total assets
    121,945       13,458       76,006       195,371       49,478       (275,152 )     181,106  
                                                         
External liabilities
    49,109       12,081       18,400       78,562       16,517             174,669  
Inter segment liabilities
    72,401       515       58,298       117,743       26,195       (275,152 )      
                                                         
Total liabilities
    121,510       12,596       76,698       196,305       42,712       (275,152 )     174,669  
                                                         
 
 
1. See note (i) on page number F-43.

F-44


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
2 OPERATING SEGMENTS  (Continued)
 
 
                                                         
    Retail
      UK
      Restated*
  Other
   
Year Ended
  Republic
      Financial
  Capital
  Group
  reconciling
  Restated*
March 31, 2009
  of Ireland   BoI Life   Services   Markets   Centre   items   Group
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Interest income
    7,819       30       4,962       8,650       (2,521 )     (9,223 )     9,717  
Interest expense
    (6,367 )     (37 )     (4,211 )     (7,168 )     2,513       9,223       (6,047 )
                                                         
Net interest income
    1,452       (7 )     751       1,482       (8 )           3,670  
Other income, net of insurance claims
    277       84       139       (237 )     (24 )           239  
                                                         
Total operating income, net of insurance claims
    1,729       77       890       1,245       (32 )           3,909  
                                                         
Other operating expenses
    (858 )     (102 )     (435 )     (366 )     (99 )           (1,860 )
Depreciation and amortisation
    (73 )     (6 )     (37 )     (11 )     (51 )           (178 )
                                                         
Operating expenses
    (931 )     (108 )     (472 )     (377 )     (150 )           (2,038 )
                                                         
Operating profit before impairment charges on financial assets
    798       (31 )     418       868       (182 )           1,871  
Impairment charges on loans and advances to customers
    (708 )           (422 )     (305 )                 (1,435 )
Impairment charges on available for sale financial assets
                      (76 )                 (76 )
Impairment charges on loans and advances to banks
                      (2 )                 (2 )
Share of results of associates and joint ventures
    (70 )           39       (11 )                 (42 )
                                                         
Underlying (loss)/profit before tax
    20       (31 )     35       474       (182 )           316  
Gross-up of policyholder tax in the Life business
          (76 )                             (76 )
Impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets
                      (304 )                 (304 )
Investment return on treasury stock held for policyholders
                            131             131  
Hedge ineffectiveness on transition to IFRS
                            (7 )           (7 )
Cost of restructuring programme
    (9 )           (61 )     (9 )     (4 )           (83 )
                                                         
Statutory (loss)/profit before tax
    11       (107 )     (26 )     161       (62 )           (23 )
                                                         
Capital expenditure
    60       7       59       14       54             194  
                                                         
Investment in associates and joint ventures
    118             46       9                   173  
                                                         
External assets
    55,501       9,697       52,574       71,774       4,570             194,116  
Inter segment assets
    58,879       1,671       12,784       122,534       25,223       (221,091 )      
                                                         
Total assets
    114,380       11,368       65,358       194,308       29,793       (221,091 )     194,116  
                                                         
External liabilities
    54,382       10,058       19,932       92,129       10,702             187,203  
Inter segment liabilities
    56,514       521       46,371       102,577       15,108       (221,091 )      
                                                         
Total liabilities
    110,896       10,579       66,303       194,706       25,810       (221,091 )     187,203  
                                                         
 
 
* The prior periods have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page number F-13.
 


F-45


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
2 OPERATING SEGMENTS  (Continued)
 
                                                         
    Retail
      UK
      Restated*
  Other
   
Year Ended
  Republic
      Financial
  Capital
  Group
  Reconciling
  Restated*
March 31, 2008
  of Ireland   BoI Life   Services   Markets   Centre   Items   Group
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Interest income
    7,452       14       5,484       8,612       (2,792 )     (8,373 )     10,397  
Interest expense
    (6,023 )     (21 )     (4,638 )     (7,582 )     2,757       8,373       (7,134 )
                                                         
Net interest income
    1,429       (7 )     846       1,030       (35 )           3,263  
Other income, net of insurance claims
    417       225       163       89       (43 )           851  
                                                         
Total operating income, net of insurance claims
    1,846       218       1,009       1,119       (78 )           4,114  
                                                         
Other operating expenses
    (909 )     (106 )     (497 )     (405 )     (89 )           (2,006 )
Depreciation and amortisation
    (74 )     (4 )     (36 )     (11 )     (12 )           (137 )
                                                         
Operating expenses
    (983 )     (110 )     (533 )     (416 )     (101 )             (2,143 )
                                                         
Profit on disposal of property
                5       1                   6  
                                                         
Operating profit before impairment charges on financial assets
    863       108       481       704       (179 )     0       1,977  
                                                         
Impairment charges on loans and advances to customers
    (146 )           (33 )     (48 )                 (227 )
Impairment charges on available for sale financial assets
                      (5 )                 (5 )
Share of results of associates and joint ventures
    (1 )           47                           46  
                                                         
Underlying loss/profit before tax
    716       108       495       651       (179 )             1,791  
Profit on disposal of property
    33                                     33  
Gross up for policyholder tax in the Life business
          (60 )                             (60 )
Investment return on treasury stock held for policyholders
                            189             189  
Hedge ineffectiveness on transition to IFRS
                            (6 )           (6 )
Cost of restructuring program
                            (17 )           (17 )
                                                         
Statutory (loss) profit before tax
    749       48       495       651       (13 )     0       1,930  
                                                         
Capital expenditure
    56       15       57       14       10             152  
                                                         
Investment in associates and joint ventures
    31             50       17                   98  
                                                         
External assets
    59,555       13,678       56,690       66,888       623             197,434  
Inter segment assets
    58,295       907       13,973       114,889       40,747       (228,811 )      
                                                         
Total assets
    117,850       14,585       70,663       181,777       41,370       (228,811 )     197,434  
                                                         
External liabilities
    43,237       13,307       28,587       97,336       8,445             190,912  
Inter segment liabilities
    72,065       368       40,761       83,404       32,213       (228,811 )      
                                                         
Total liabilities
    115,302       13,675       69,348       180,740       40,658       (228,811 )     190,912  
                                                         
 
 
* The prior periods have been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.

F-46


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
2 OPERATING SEGMENTS  (Continued)
 
 
Gross Revenue by Business Segments
 
                                                         
    Retail
      UK
               
9 Months Ended
  Republic
      Financial
  Capital
  Group
       
December 31, 2009
  of Ireland   BOI Life   Services   Markets   Centre   Eliminations   Group
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
External customers
    1,458       247       1,814       1,107       1,264             5,890  
Inter-segment revenue
    1,996       15       693       2,474       (734 )     (4,444 )      
                                                         
Total gross revenue
    3,454       262       2,507       3,581       530       (4,444 )     5,890  
                                                         
 
                                                         
    Retail
      UK
               
Year Ended
  Republic
      Financial
  Capital
  Group
       
March 31, 2009
  of Ireland   BOI Life   Services   Markets   Centre   Eliminations   Group
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
External customers
    2,766       7       3,575       4,014       (168 )           10,194  
Inter-segment revenue
    4,981       (10 )     1,629       5,270       (2,626 )     (9,244 )      
                                                         
Total gross revenue
    7,747       (3 )     5,204       9,284       (2,794 )     (9,244 )     10,194  
                                                         
 
                                                         
    Retail
      UK
               
Year Ended
  Republic
      Financial
  Capital
  Group
       
March 31, 2008
  of Ireland   BOI Life   Services   Markets   Centre   Eliminations   Group
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
External customers
    3,232       300       3,982       3,889       164             11,567  
Inter-segment revenue
    4,690       (53 )     1,727       4,846       (2,813 )     (8,397 )      
                                                         
Total gross revenue
    7,922       247       5,709       8,735       (2,649 )     (8,397 )     11,567  
                                                         
 
Geographical Segments
 
                                         
9 Months Ended
      United
  Rest of
       
December 31, 2009
  Ireland   Kingdom   World   Eliminations   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
External revenues
    3,795       2,022       73             5,890  
Inter segment revenue
    1,003       509       226       (1,738 )      
                                         
Gross revenue
    4,798       2,531       299       (1,738 )     5,890  
                                         
(Loss) / profit before taxation
    (1,242 )     (602 )     31             (1,813 )
                                         
Capital expenditure
    27       32       1             60  
                                         
External assets
    116,259       59,089       5,758             181,106  
Inter segment assets
    57,873       26,684       10,731       (95,288 )      
                                         
Total assets
    174,132       85,773       16,489       (95,288 )     181,106  
                                         
External liabilities
    138,292       26,627       9,750             174,669  
Inter segment liabilities
    29,722       59,478       6,089       (95,289 )      
                                         
Total liabilities
    168,014       86,105       15,839       (95,289 )     174,669  
                                         


F-47


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
2 OPERATING SEGMENTS  (Continued)
 
Geographical Segments
 
                                         
Year Ended
  Restated*
  United
  Rest of
      Restated*
March 31, 2009
  Ireland   Kingdom   World   Eliminations   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
External revenues
    6,733       3,304       157             10,194  
Inter segment revenue
    889       2,908       648       (4,445 )      
                                         
Gross revenue
    7,622       6,212       805       (4,445 )     10,194  
                                         
(Loss) / profit before taxation
    154       129       (306 )           (23 )
                                         
Capital expenditure
    134       58       2             194  
                                         
External assets
    128,291       59,791       6,034             194,116  
Inter segment assets
    56,344       33,823       9,280       (99,447 )      
                                         
Total assets
    184,635       93,614       15,314       (99,447 )     194,116  
                                         
External liabilities
    148,094       29,211       9,898             187,203  
Inter segment liabilities
    30,715       63,911       4,821       (99,447 )      
                                         
Total liabilities
    178,809       93,122       14,719       (99,447 )     187,203  
                                         
 
Geographical segments
 
                                         
Year Ended
  Restated*
  United
  Rest of
      Restated*
March 31, 2008
  Ireland   Kingdom   World   Eliminations   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
External revenues
    7,306       4,119       142             11,567  
Inter segment revenue
    1,267       2,341       225       (3,833 )      
                                         
Gross revenue
    8,573       6,460       367       (3,833 )     11,567  
                                         
(Loss) / profit before taxation
    1,409       491       30             1,930  
                                         
Capital expenditure
    93       57       2             152  
                                         
External assets
    133,925       61,471       2,038             197,434  
Inter segment assets
    38,440       33,023       13,296       (84,759 )      
                                         
Total assets
    172,365       94,494       15,334       (84,759 )     197,434  
                                         
External liabilities
    130,490       47,414       13,008             190,912  
Inter segment liabilities
    37,299       45,815       1,645       (84,759 )      
                                         
Total liabilities
    167,789       93,229       14,653       (84,759 )     190,912  
                                         
 
 
* The prior year has been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.


F-48


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
3 INTEREST INCOME
 
                         
    9 months ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Loans and advances to customers
    3,503       7,901       8,213  
Available for sale financial assets
    498       1,335       1,604  
Loans and advances to banks
    48       246       323  
Finance leases
    139       232       251  
Other
          3       6  
                         
Interest income
    4,188       9,717       10,397  
                         
 
Included within interest income is €161 million (March 31, 2009: €110 million; March 31, 2008: €31 million) in respect of impaired loans and advances to customers. Net interest income also includes a debit of €351 million (March 31, 2009: credit of €93 million; March 31, 2008: credit of €185 million) transferred from the cash flow hedge reserve (see page F-7).
 
4 INTEREST EXPENSE
 
                         
    9 months ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Customer accounts
    995       2,773       2,808  
Debt securities in issue
    653       2,297       3,041  
Deposits from banks
    198       554       840  
Subordinated liabilities
    163       423       445  
                         
Interest expense
    2,009       6,047       7,134  
                         
 
Interest expense on financial liabilities (including subordinated liabilities) is recognised using the effective interest rate (EIR) method. In accordance with the EIR method, the carrying value of certain subordinated liabilities has been reduced by €58 million at December 31, 2009 to reflect the Group’s revised estimates of future cashflows on these liabilities. This adjustment has been reflected as a reduction in interest expense in the nine months ended December 31, 2009. For further information see note 58.
 
5 NET INSURANCE PREMIUM INCOME
 
                         
    9 months ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Gross premiums written
    751       1,190       2,101  
Ceded reinsurance premiums
    (91 )     (116 )     (173 )
                         
Net premiums written
    660       1,074       1,928  
Change in provision for unearned premiums
    5       (5 )     12  
                         
Net insurance premium income
    665       1,069       1,940  
                         


F-49


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
6 FEES AND COMMISSION INCOME/EXPENSE
 
                         
    9 months ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
Income
  2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Retail banking customer fees
    268       368       401  
Asset management fees
    66       132       189  
Credit related fees
    41       38       81  
Insurance commissions
    60       75       42  
Brokerage fees
    8       13       23  
Other
    31       91       80  
                         
Fees and commissions income
    474       717       816  
                         
 
For the year ended March 31, 2009, fees amounting to €42 million have been reclassified from retail banking customer fees to insurance commissions for comparative purposes. Included in other fees is an amount of €3 million (March 31, 2009: €4 million, March 31, 2008: €6 million) in trust and other fiduciary fees.
 
                         
    9 months ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
Expenses
  2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Government Guarantee fee (note 55)
    105       66        
Other
    150       166       150  
                         
Fees and commission expense
    255       232       150  
                         
 
The Government Guarantee fee of €105 million (March 31, 2009: €66 million) relates to the fee paid under the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Scheme, which commenced on September 30, 2008.
 
7 NET TRADING EXPENSE
 
                         
    9 months ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Financial assets designated at fair value
    31       (29 )     (6 )
Financial liabilities designated at fair value
    (137 )     55       107  
Related derivatives held for trading
    86       (41 )     (260 )
                         
      (20 )     (15 )     (159 )
Other financial instruments held for trading
    (13 )     (258 )     (79 )
Net fair value hedge ineffectiveness
    7       (27 )     (6 )
Cash flow hedge ineffectiveness
    (2 )     (7 )     (2 )
                         
Net trading expense
    (28 )     (307 )     (246 )
                         


F-50


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
7 NET TRADING EXPENSE  (continued)
 
Net trading expense of €28 million (March 31, 2009: €307 million; March 31, 2008: €246 million) includes the gains and losses on financial instruments held for trading and those designated at fair value through profit or loss (other than unit linked life assurance assets and investment contract liabilities). It includes the gains and losses arising on the purchase and sale of these instruments, the interest income receivable and expense payable and the fair value movement on these instruments, together with the funding cost of the trading instruments. It also includes €20 million (March 31, 2009: €65 million; March 31, 2008: €28 million) in relation to net gains arising from foreign exchange.
 
Net trading expense includes the total fair value movement (including interest receivable and payable) on liabilities that have been designated at fair value through profit or loss. The interest receivable on amortised cost assets which are funded by those liabilities is reported in net interest income. Net trading expense also includes the total fair value movements on derivatives that are economic hedges of assets and liabilities which are measured at amortised cost, the net interest receivable or payable on which is also reported within net interest income. The net amount reported within net interest income relating to these amortised cost instruments was €71 million (March 31, 2009: €578 million; March 31, 2008: €346 million).
 
Net fair value hedge ineffectiveness comprises a net loss from hedging instruments of €97 million (March 31, 2009: net gain of €213 million; March 31, 2008: Net gain of €168 million) offsetting a net gain from hedged items of €104 million (March 31, 2009: net loss of €240 million; March 31, 2008: net loss of €174 million).
 
Net trading expense for March 31, 2009 includes a loss of €39 million arising from the Lehman collapse in September 2008.
 
The net loss from the change in credit spreads relating to the Group’s issued notes designated at fair value through profit or loss was €6 million (March 31, 2009: net gain €64 million; March 31, 2008: €32 million). The cumulative impact from the change in credit spreads at December 31, 2009 is a net gain of €90 million (March 31, 2009: €96 million).
 
Included within net trading expense above is a credit of €9 million in relation to the revised estimates of future cashflows on certain subordinated liabilities. See note 4 for further details.
 
8 LIFE ASSURANCE INVESTMENT INCOME AND GAINS/(LOSSES)
 
                         
    9 months
       
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Gross life assurance investment income and gains/(losses)
    961       (1,635 )     (924 )
Elimination of investment return on treasury stock held for the benefit of policyholders
    (3 )     65       98  
                         
Life assurance investment income and gains/(losses)
    958       (1,570 )     (826 )
                         
 
Life assurance investment income and gains/(losses) comprise the investment return, realised gains and losses, and unrealised gains and losses which accrue to the Group, on all investment assets held by BoI Life, other than those held for the benefit of policyholders whose contracts are considered to be investment contracts.
 
IFRS requires that Bank of Ireland stock held by the Group, including those held by BoI Life for the benefit of policyholders, are reclassified as treasury stock and accounted for as a deduction from equity. Changes in the value of any treasury stock held are recognised in equity at the time of disposal and dividends are not recognised as income or distributions.


F-51


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
8 LIFE ASSURANCE INVESTMENT INCOME AND LOSSES  (continued)
 
The impact on the Group income statement in the nine months to December 31, 2009 of applying this accounting treatment is that life assurance investment income and gains of €961 million have been reduced by €3 million which is the profit on Bank of Ireland stock held under insurance contracts. Other operating income (see note 10) has been reduced by €3 million which is the gain on stock held under investment contracts. The combined adjustment is €6 million. (March 31, 2009 €131 million, March 31, 2008 : €189 million).
 
9 GAIN ON REPURCHASE OF SUBORDINATED LIABILITIES
 
As part of its ongoing capital management activities the Group repurchased certain subordinated liabilities in June 2009. This involved the repurchase for cash of euro, US dollar and sterling subordinated liabilities at a discount to their nominal value.
 
The table below sets out the detail of the instruments purchased, the price paid and the residual amount of each security outstanding at December 31, 2009:
 
                                 
            Price Paid (%
   
    Original
  Principle
  of Principal
  Residual
    Principle
  Amount
  Amount
  Principle
Description   Amount   Repurchased   Repurchased)   Amount
€600 million
7.40% Guaranteed Step-up Callable
Perpetual Preferred Securities
  600m     124m       50 %   476m  
                                 
Stg£350 million
6.25% Guaranteed Callable Perpetual Preferred
Securities
    £350m       £304m       42 %     £46m  
                                 
€600 million
Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting
Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities
  600m     250m       38 %   350m  
                                 
US$800 million
Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting
Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities
  $ 800m     $ 400m       40 %   $ 400m  
                                 
US$400 million
Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting
Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities
  $ 400m     $ 200m       40 %   $ 200m  
                                 
Stg£500 million
Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed
Non-voting Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred
Securities
    £500m       £463m       40 %     £37m  
                                 
 
The net gain after transaction costs on the purchase of the subordinated liabilities amounted to €1,037 million (€1,029 million after taxation) being the difference between of the consideration paid of €683 million and the carrying value of the securities of €1,720 million.
 
Further information on subordinated liabilities is set out in note 39.


F-52


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
10 OTHER OPERATING INCOME
 
                         
    9 months
       
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Profit on disposal available for sale financial assets
    55       5       34  
Other insurance income
    83       23       91  
Other income
    (104 )     (21 )     22  
Elimination of investment return on treasury stock held for the benefit of policyholders
    (3 )     66       91  
                         
Other operating income
    31       73       238  
                         
Included in other income for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 is a charge of €62 million (March 31, 2009: €46 million) for impairment of investment properties and related activities. Also included in other income is a charge of €74 million arising from an unfavourable court ruling in connection with a European property investment.
 
11 INSURANCE CONTRACT LIABILITIES AND CLAIMS PAID
 
                         
    9 months
       
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Gross claims (see analysis below)
    (656 )     (963 )     (1,013 )
Reinsurance
    38       40       27  
                         
Net claims
    (618 )     (923 )     (986 )
                         
Change in liabilities:
                       
Gross
    (1,023 )     1,507       41  
Reinsurance
    179       (47 )     147  
                         
Net changes in liabilities
    (844 )     1,460       188  
                         
Insurance contract liabilities and claims paid
    (1,462 )     537       (798 )
                         
Gross claims are analysed as follows:
                       
Surrenders
    (480 )     (768 )     (851 )
Death and critical illness
    (105 )     (128 )     (113 )
Annuities
    (34 )     (35 )     (32 )
Maturities
    (3 )     (5 )     (3 )
Other
    (34 )     (27 )     (14 )
                         
      (656 )     (963 )     (1,013 )
                         


F-53


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
12 OTHER OPERATING EXPENSES
 
                         
    9 months
  Restated*
  Restated*
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December
  March 31,
  March 31,
    31, 2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Administrative expenses
                       
— Staff costs (see analysis below)
    789       1,197       1,238  
— Other administrative expenses
    479       737       785  
Depreciation
                       
— Intangible assets (note 30)
    75       132       87  
— Property, plant and equipment (note 32)
    32       46       50  
Decline in property below cost
    6       9        
                         
Other operating expenses
    1,381       2,121       2,160  
                         
Staff costs are analysed as follows:
                       
Wages and salaries
    569       849       963  
Social security costs
    61       91       93  
Retirement benefit costs — defined benefit plans (note 43)
    147       173       130  
Retirement benefit costs — defined contribution plans
    2       7       4  
Share based payment schemes (note 45)
          19       16  
Other
    10       58       32  
                         
Staff costs
    789       1,197       1,238  
                         
 
*     The prior year has been restated to reflect the impact of adoption of “Amendment to IFRS2” share based payments vesting conditions and cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page number F-13.
 
Depreciation of intangible assets for the year ended March 31, 2009 included a one off charge of €38 million in relation to accelerated depreciation on software assets as a result of technology consolidation.
 
Included in other administration expenses above is an amount of €49 million (March 31, 2009: €68 million) in relation to operating lease payments.
 
During the year ended March 31, 2009, the Group commenced a process of aligning its structure and cost base to an environment of lower levels of business and activity and a charge of €83 million was included in other operating expenses.


F-54


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
12 OTHER OPERATING EXPENSES  (continued)
 
Staff numbers
 
In the nine months ended December 31, 2009 the average number of staff (full time equivalents) was 14,755 (March 31, 2009: 15,868, March 31, 2008: 16,026) categorised as follows in line with the operating segments as stated in note 2.
 
                         
    9 months
       
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
 
Retail Republic of Ireland
    5,698       5,951       8,467  
BoI Life
    1,071       1,132       1,183  
UK Financial Services
    2,865       3,514       3,599  
Capital Markets
    1,557       1,801       1,737  
Group Centre
    3,564       3,470 *     1,040  
                         
Total
    14,755       15,868       16,026  
                         
 
*     The growth in staff numbers in Group Centre since April 1, 2008 reflects the ongoing centralisation of support functions in order to maximise operating efficiencies.
 
13 AUDITORS’ REMUNERATION
 
                                                 
                9 months
  Year
  Year
                ended
  ended
  ended
                December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    Notes   ROI   Overseas (i)   2009   2009   2008
        €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Audit and assurance services (including VAT)
                                               
Statutory audit (including expenses)
            3.4       1.1       4.5       4.3       4.9  
Other audit and assurance services
    (ii )     4.7       0.5       5.2       5.0       4.8  
                                                 
              8.1       1.6       9.7       9.3       9.7  
Other services (including VAT)
                                               
Taxation services
            0.2       0.2       0.4       0.8       1.1  
                                                 
Auditors remuneration
            8.3       1.8       10.1       10.1       10.8  
                                                 
 
The figures in the above table relate to fees paid to PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC). The Group Audit Committee has reviewed the level of fees and is satisfied that it has not affected the independence of the auditors.
 
(i)  Fees to overseas auditors principally consist of fees to PwC in the UK.
 
(ii)  Other audit and assurance services consist primarily of fees in connection with reporting to regulators, letters of comfort, review of compliance with Government guarantee, reporting on Sarbanes-Oxley, reporting accountants work and accounting matters.
 
It is Group policy to subject all major consultancy assignments to a competitive tender process.


F-55


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
14 IMPAIRMENT CHARGES ON FINANCIAL ASSETS
 
                         
    9 months
       
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Loans and advances to customers (note 25)
    4,055       1,435       227  
Available for sale financial assets (note 24)
    2       76       5  
Loans and advances to banks (note 23)
          2        
                         
      4,057       1,513       232  
                         
 
Of the €4,055 million charge for loans and advances to customers for the nine months to December 31, 2009, €2,231 million relates to loans held for sale to NAMA.
 
15 OPERATING (LOSS)/PROFIT
 
Operating (loss) / profit includes the Group’s earnings from ongoing activities after impairment charges and before share of profit or loss on associates and joint ventures (after tax) and loss on disposal of business activities.
 
16 RESULTS OF ASSOCIATES AND JOINT VENTURES (AFTER TAX)
 
                         
    9 months
       
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
First Rate Exchange Services (note 29)
    27       39       47  
Property unit trust (note 29)
    10       (63 )      
Paul Capital Investment (note 29)
    1       (11 )      
Other joint ventures (note 29)
    (1 )            
Associates (note 28)
    (2 )     (7 )     (1 )
                         
      35       (42 )     46  
                         
 
17 LOSS ON DISPOSAL OF BUSINESS ACTIVITIES
 
                         
    9 months
       
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Iridian Asset Management LLC
    (10 )            
Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC
    7              
                         
Total
    (3 )            
                         


F-56


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
17 LOSS ON DISPOSAL OF BUSINESS ACTIVITIES  (continued)
 
Disposal of Iridian Asset Management LLC
 
During the nine months ended December 31, 2009 the Group disposed of its interest in Iridian Asset Management LLC (Iridian). Iridian was a 100% subsidiary of BIAM US Inc and acted as an Institutional Asset Manager in the US market within the Capital Markets division of the Group. In the Annual Report for the year ended March 31, 2009 the impact of a fall in assets under management in the latter part of that year was highlighted and it was noted that the Group was reviewing its strategic options for this business. The disposal was concluded on June 30, 2009 with a resulting loss on disposal of €10 million.
 
In the year ended March 31, 2009 an impairment charge of €201 million on goodwill relating to Iridian was recognised in the income statement.
 
Disposal of Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC
 
At March 31, 2009, the Group held a 71.5% interest in Guggenheim Alternative Asset Management LLC (Guggenheim). During the nine months ended December 31, 2009, the Group disposed of a 49.5% interest in Guggenheim with the intention of disposing of the remaining interest (22%) in the following year. Guggenheim acted as a US based fund of hedge funds manager within the Capital Markets division of the Group. Similar to Iridian, the significant drop in assets under management in the latter part of the last financial year following the turmoil in global markets prompted the Group to consider its strategic options for this business. The disposal of the 49.5% stake was concluded on August 31, 2009 with a resulting profit on disposal of €7 million. The remaining 22% interest is of negligible value with minimal control or influence.
 
In the year ended March 31, 2009 an impairment charge of €103 million on goodwill and other intangibles relating to Guggenheim was recognised in the income statement.
 
18 TAXATION
 
                         
    9 months
  Restated*
  Restated*
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Current Tax
                       
Irish corporation tax
                       
— current year
    (19 )     (84 )     (236 )
— prior year
    5       7       2  
Double taxation relief
    1             62  
Foreign tax
                       
— current year
    2       3       (140 )
— prior year
    (1 )           (1 )
                         
      (12 )     (74 )     (313 )
Deferred tax
                       
Origination and reversal of temporary differences (note 42)
    356       115       84  
                         
Taxation credit/(charge)
    344       41       (229 )
                         


F-57


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
18 TAXATION  (continued)
 
The reconciliation of tax on (loss) / profit at the standard Irish corporation tax rate to the Group’s actual tax credit/(charge) for the periods ended December 31, 2009, March 31, 2009 and March 31, 2008 is as follows:
 
                         
    9 months
       
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Loss/(profit) before taxation multiplied by the Standard rate of corporate tax in the Republic of Ireland of 12.5% (2008: 12.5%)
    227       1       (242 )
Effects of:
                       
Foreign earnings subject to different rates of tax
    70       81       (86 )
BoI Life — different basis of accounting
    (55 )     58       53  
Income arising on repurchase of subordinated liabilities
    121              
Elimination of investment return on treasury stock held for the benefit of policyholders
    (1 )     16       24  
Tax exempted profits and income at a reduced Irish tax rate
          (4 )     (2 )
Non-deductible goodwill impairment
    (1 )     (110 )      
Non-deductible expenses
    (9 )     (19 )     (7 )
Prior year adjustments
    4       7       1  
Shares of profit of associates and joint ventures shown post tax in income statement
    3       5       6  
Other adjustments for tax purposes
    (15 )     6       24  
                         
Taxation credit/(charge)
    344       41       (229 )
                         
 
The taxation credit for the Group was €344 million for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 compared to a taxation credit of €41 million for the year ended March 31, 2009 primarily due to losses in the period.
 
The effective taxation rate for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 is a credit of 19%. The effective taxation rate for the year ended March 31, 2009 is a credit of 178%1 (March 2008: 11.8%). Excluding the impact of the Life policyholder tax gross up, the elimination of the investment return on treasury shares held by BoI Life for policyholders, hedge ineffectiveness, the gain on the repurchase of subordinated liabilities2 , cost of restructuring, the loss on disposal of business activities, the impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets and the EIR adjustment on the subordinated debt2, the effective taxation rate is 16.1% compared to a rate of 17.7% for the year ended March 31, 2009.
 
The taxation credit for the Group was €41 million for the year ended March 31, 2009 compared to a taxation charge of €229 million for the year ended March 31, 2008. The effective tax rate was a credit of 178%1 for the year ended March 31, 2009, as compared to a charge of 11.8% for the year ended March 31, 2008. The increase in the effective rate is due to the reduction in earnings across the Group and the Life policyholder tax gross-up.
 
 
 1  The prior year has been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page F-13.
 2  These items relate to the nine months ended December 31, 2009 only.


F-58


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
18 TAXATION  (continued)
 
The tax effects relating to each component of other comprehensive income are as follows:
 
                         
    Pre tax
  Tax (charge)/
  Net of tax
Nine Months Ended December 31, 2009
  amount   credit   amount
    €m   €m   €m
 
Changes in revaluation reserve
    (60 )     7       (53 )
                         
Cash flow hedge reserve
                       
Changes in fair value
    (555 )     136       (419 )
Transfer to income statement
    676       (175 )     501  
                         
Net change in reserve
    121       (39 )     82  
                         
Available for sale reserve
                       
Changes in fair value
    1,110       (137 )     973  
Transfer to income statement on asset disposal
    (55 )     6       (49 )
                         
Net change in reserve
    1,055       (131 )     924  
                         
Changes in defined benefit pension funds
    (99 )     25       (74 )
Changes in foreign exchange reserve
    117             117  
                         
Other comprehensive income for the period
    1,134       (138 )     996  
                         
 
                         
    Pre tax
  Tax (charge)/
  Net of
Year Ended March 31, 2009
  amount   credit   tax amount
    €m   €m   €m
 
Changes in revaluation reserve
    (113 )     17       (96 )
                         
Cash flow hedge reserve
                       
Changes in fair value
    121       (102 )     19  
Transfer to income statement
    (765 )     206       (559 )
                         
Net change in reserve
    (644 )     104       (540 )
                         
Available for sale reserve
                       
Changes in fair value
    (1,270 )     162       (1,108 )
Transfer to income statement on asset disposal
    (5 )           (5 )
                         
Net change in reserve
    (1,275 )     162       (1,113 )
                         
Changes in defined benefit pension funds
    (624 )     80       (544 )
Changes in foreign exchange reserve
    (528 )           (528 )
                         
Other comprehensive income for the period
    (3,184 )     363       (2,821 )
                         
 


F-59


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
18 TAXATION  (continued)
 
                         
    Pre tax
  Tax (charge)/
  Net of
Year Ended March 31, 2008
  amount   credit   tax amount
    €m   €m   €m
 
Changes in revaluation reserve
    (78 )     8       (70 )
                         
Cash flow hedge reserve
                       
Changes in fair value
    128       (28 )     100  
Transfer to income statement
    (443 )     96       (347 )
                         
Net change in reserve
    (315 )     68       (247 )
                         
Available for sale reserve
                       
Changes in fair value
    (406 )     50       (356 )
Transfer to income statement on asset disposal
    (34 )     4       (30 )
                         
Net change in reserve
    (440 )     54       (386 )
                         
Changes in defined benefit pension funds
    (245 )     36       (209 )
Changes in foreign exchange reserve
    (712 )           (712 )
                         
Other comprehensive income for the period
    (1,790 )     166       (1,624 )
                         
 
19 EARNINGS PER SHARE
 
The calculation of basic earnings per unit of €0.64 ordinary stock is based on the (loss) / profit attributable to ordinary stockholders divided by the weighted average ordinary stock in issue excluding treasury stock and own stock held for the benefit of life assurance policyholders.
 
                         
    9 Months
  Restated*
  Restated*
    Ended
  Year Ended
  Year Ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Basic
                       
(Loss)/ profit attributable to stockholders as published
    (1,460 )     69       1,699  
Restatement for IFRS 2 amendment
          (16 )     (3 )
                         
(Loss)/profit attributable to stockholders as restated
    (1,460 )     53       1,696  
Dividends on other equity interests
    (4 )     (10 )     (14 )
Dividends on 2009 preference stock
    (210 )     (1 )      
                         
(Loss)/profit attributable to ordinary stockholders
    (1,674 )     42       1,682  
                         
Weighted average number of stock in issue excluding treasury stock and own stock held for the benefit of life assurance policyholders
    993m       988m       965m  
                         
Basic earnings per share (cent)
    (168.6c )     4.3c       174.3c  
                         

F-60


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
19 EARNINGS PER SHARE (continued)
 
Diluted
 
The diluted earnings per share is based on the (loss) / profit attributable to ordinary stockholders divided by the weighted average ordinary stock in issue excluding treasury stock and own stock held for the benefit of life assurance policyholders adjusted for the effect of all dilutive potential ordinary stock.
 
                         
    9 Months
  Restated*
  Restated*
    ended
  Year ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Diluted
                       
(Loss)/ profit attributable to stockholders as published
    (1,460 )     69       1,699  
Restatement for IFRS 2 amendment
          (16 )     (3 )
                         
(Loss)/profit attributable to stockholders as restated
    (1,460 )     53       1,696  
Dividends on other equity interests
    (4 )     (10 )     (14 )
Dividends on 2009 preference stock
    (210 )     (1 )      
                         
(Loss)/profit attributable to ordinary stockholders
    (1,674 )     42       1,682  
                         
Weighted average number of stock in issue excluding treasury stock and own stock held for the benefit of life assurance policyholders
    993m       988m       965m  
Effect of all dilutive potential ordinary stock
                4m  
                         
      993m       988m       969m  
                         
Diluted earnings per share (cent)
    (168.6c )     4.3c       173.6c  
                         
 
*     The prior year has been restated to reflect the impact of the adoption of “Amendments to IFRS 2 Share-based Payment Vesting Conditions and Cancellations”. Further information on this is shown on page number F-13.
 
For the period ending December 31, 2009 there was no difference in the weighted-average number of units of stock used for basic and diluted net loss per share as the effect of all potentially dilutive ordinary units of stock outstanding was anti-dilutive. At March 31, 2009, 158 million warrants issued to the National Pension Reserve Fund Commission (NPRFC) on that date (“the secondary tranche warrants” — see note 55) were dilutive and were included in the calculation of diluted earnings per share, but did not have a significant impact on the weighted average number of shares outstanding. At March 31, 2009 the calculation of diluted earnings per share excluded a weighted average of 20 million units of potential ordinary stock (March 31, 2008: 6 million units).
 
As at December 31, 2009 there were stock options over 12 million units of ordinary units of stock (March 31, 2009: 16 million units of stock), and warrants issued to the NPRFC over 335 million units of stock outstanding (March 31, 2009: 177 million units of stock, “the core tranche warrants” - see note 55), which could potentially have a dilutive impact in the future, but which were anti-dilutive in the period ended December 31, 2009 and year ended March 31, 2009 respectively.
 
EPS above has not been adjusted for the rights issue which completed on June 14, 2010. EPS will be retrospectively adjusted in the financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2010. The adjusted EPS is set out in note 58(i).
 
Dividend on 2009 preference stock
 
Where a dividend on the 2009 preference stock is not paid in either cash or shares, that dividend must subsequently be paid in the form of shares if a subsequent dividend is paid or if any dividend on ordinary stock is paid. The dividend required for the period, although undeclared and not accounted for in these financial statements, has been deducted in the calculation of basic and diluted earnings per share. The dividend due on February 20, 2010 was settled by the issue and allotment of ordinary stock to the NPRFC (see note 58).


F-61


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
20 TRADING SECURITIES
 
                 
    9 months ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Debt securities — listed
    403       125  
                 
Trading securities
    403       125  
                 
 
The Group holds a portfolio of bonds for trading purposes typically taking positions in sovereign, financial and corporate risk with ratings between investment grade AAA and BBB (average rating AA-).
 
21 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
 
The Group’s use, objectives and policies on managing the risks that arise in connection with derivatives, including the policies for hedging, are included in the Risk Management note 56. The notional amounts of certain types of financial instruments do not necessarily indicate the amounts of future cash flows involved or the current fair value of the instruments and, therefore, do not indicate the Group’s exposure to credit risk. The derivative instruments become assets or liabilities as a result of fluctuations in market rates or prices relative to their terms.
 
The fair values and notional amounts of derivative instruments held are set out in the following tables:
 
                         
    Contract /
       
    notional
  Fair values
December 31, 2009
  amount   Assets   Liabilities
    €m   €m   €m
 
Derivatives held for trading
                       
Foreign exchange derivatives
                       
Currency forwards
    33,354       218       454  
Currency swaps
    957       58       20  
Over the counter currency options
    1,191       9       10  
                         
Total foreign exchange derivatives held for trading
    35,502       285       484  
                         
Interest rate derivatives
                       
Interest rate swaps
    182,704       2,078       2,175  
Cross currency interest rate swaps
    14,936       725       818  
Forward rate agreements
    17,643       14       15  
Over the counter interest rate options
    8,732       94       87  
                         
Total interest rate derivatives held for trading
    224,015       2,911       3,095  
                         
Equity and commodity contracts
                       
Equity index linked contracts held
    5,493       148       123  
                         
Credit derivatives
    721              
                         
Total derivative assets/liabilities held for trading
    265,731       3,344       3,702  
                         
Derivatives held for hedging
                       
Derivatives designated as fair value hedges
                       
Interest rate swaps
    28,554       634       595  
Cross currency interest rate swaps
    922       106       3  
                         
Total designated as fair value hedges
    29,476       740       598  
                         
Derivatives designated as cash flow hedges
                       
Interest rate swaps
    63,023       1,155       1,736  
Currency forwards
    28             1  
Currency swaps
    2,270       585        
                         
Total designated as cash flow hedges
    65,321       1,740       1,737  
                         
Total derivative assets/liabilities held for hedging
    94,797       2,480       2,335  
                         
Total derivative assets/liabilities
    360,528       5,824       6,037  
                         


F-62


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
21 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS  (continued)
 
The fair values and notional amounts of derivative instruments held are set out in the following tables:
 
                         
    Contract /
       
    notional
  Fair values
March 31, 2009
  amount   Assets   Liabilities
    €m   €m   €m
 
Derivatives held for trading
                       
Foreign exchange derivatives
                       
Currency forwards
    34,697       571       362  
Currency swaps
    819       34       58  
Over the counter currency options
    1,715       15       16  
                         
Total foreign exchange derivatives held for trading
    37,231       620       436  
                         
Interest rate derivatives
                       
Interest rate swaps
    146,569       2,653       2,546  
Cross currency interest rate swaps
    16,402       1,155       1,123  
Forward rate agreements
    15,544       28       31  
Over the counter interest rate options
    10,582       154       141  
                         
Total interest rate derivatives held for trading
    189,097       3,990       3,841  
                         
Equity and commodity contracts
                       
Equity index linked contracts held
    5,500       141       191  
                         
Total derivative assets/liabilities held for trading
    231,828       4,751       4,468  
                         
Derivatives held for hedging
                       
Derivatives designated as fair value hedges
                       
Interest rate swaps
    20,125       783       609  
Cross currency interest rate swaps
    1,119       119       2  
                         
Total designated as fair value hedges
    21,244       902       611  
                         
Derivatives designated as cash flow hedges
                       
Interest rate swaps
    69,576       1,754       2,357  
Cross currency interest rate swaps
    2,674       10       38  
Currency forwards
    6,628       81       80  
Currency swaps
    2,470       899        
                         
Total designated as cash flow hedges
    81,348       2,744       2,475  
                         
Total derivative assets/liabilities held for hedging
    102,592       3,646       3,086  
                         
Total derivative assets/liabilities
    334,420       8,397       7,554  
                         
 
Derivatives held for trading above comprise derivatives entered into with trading intent as well as derivatives entered into with economic hedging intent to which the Group does not apply hedge accounting.
 
As set out in its risk management policy on pages F-141 to F-175, the Group uses netting arrangements and collateral agreements to reduce its exposure to credit losses. Of the derivative assets of €5.8 billion at December 31, 2009 (March 31, 2009: €8.4 billion), €3.8 billion (March 31, 2009: €5.4 billion) are available for offset against


F-63


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
21 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS  (continued)
 
derivative liabilities under master netting arrangements. These transactions do not meet the criteria under IAS 32 to enable the assets to be presented net of the liabilities.
 
Placements with other banks includes cash collateral of €1.9 billion (March 31, 2009: €1.9 billion) placed with derivative counterparties in respect of the net derivative liability position of €2.2 billion (March 31, 2009: €2.2 billion).
 
Net derivative assets of €2.1 billion (March 31, 2009: €3.0 billion) are not covered by master netting arrangements or relate to counterparties covered by master netting arrangements with whom a net asset position was held at the balance sheet date. At December 31, 2009 cash collateral of €0.5 billion (March 31, 2009: €0.7 billion) was held against these assets and is reported within Deposits from banks (see note 35).
 
The Group designates certain derivatives as hedging instruments in either fair value or cash flow hedge relationships.
 
Fair value hedges
 
Certain interest rate and cross currency interest rate derivatives are designated as hedging instruments. These are primarily used to reduce the interest rate and foreign exchange exposure on the Group’s fixed rate debt held and debt issued portfolios.
 
Cash flow hedges
 
The Group designates certain interest rate and currency derivatives in cash flow hedge relationships in order to hedge the exposure to variability in future cash flows arising from variable assets and liabilities. Movement in the cash flow hedge reserve are shown in the statement of changes in equity (page F-7).
 
The periods in which the hedged cash flows are expected to occur are shown in the table below.
 
                                         
        Between 1 to
  Between 2 to
  More than
   
December 31, 2009
  Up to 1 year   2 years   5 years   5 years   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Forecast receivable cash flows
    153       393       1,215       517       2,278  
                                         
Forecast payable cash flows
    (1,056 )     (1,240 )     (2,457 )     (915 )     (5,668 )
                                         
 
                                         
        Between 1 to
  Between 2 to
  More than
   
March 31, 2009
  Up to 1 year   2 years   5 years   5 years   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Forecast receivable cash flows
    3,470       298       1,021       921       5,710  
                                         
Forecast payable cash flows
    (7,865 )     (2,704 )     (3,681 )     (1,137 )     (15,387 )
                                         
 
The hedged cash flows are expected to impact the income statement in the following periods, excluding any hedge accounting adjustments that may be applied:
 
                                         
        Between 1 to
  Between 2 to
  More than
   
December 31, 2009
  Up to 1 year   2 years   5 years   5 years   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Forecast receivable cash flows
    203       418       1,189       468       2,278  
                                         
Forecast payable cash flows
    (3,159 )     (550 )     (1,104 )     (855 )     (5,668 )
                                         
 


F-64


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
21 DERIVATIVE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS  (continued)
 
                                         
        Between 1 to
  Between 2 to
  More than
   
March 31, 2009
  Up to 1 year   2 years   5 years   5 years   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Forecast receivable cash flows
    3,903       309       1,014       484       5,710  
                                         
Forecast payable cash flows
    (12,920 )     (586 )     (1,168 )     (713 )     (15,387 )
                                         
 
During the year ended March 31, 2009, the Group applied hedge accounting to a forecast future borrowing of €252 million, of which €62 million was no longer expected to occur as at March 31, 2009. During the nine month period to December 31, 2009, the remainder of the forecast transaction was no longer expected to occur, and the remaining portion of the cumulative loss on the hedging instrument was reclassified from other comprehensive income to the income statement.
 
22 OTHER FINANCIAL ASSETS AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH PROFIT OR LOSS
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Equity securities
    6,404       4,397  
Government bonds
    1,605       1,741  
Unit trusts
    1,013       894  
Debt securities
    587       549  
Loans and advances
    70       23  
                 
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
    9,679       7,604  
                 
 
A portion of the Group’s life assurance business takes the legal form of investment contracts, under which legal title to the underlying investment is held by the Group, but the inherent risks and rewards in the investments is borne by the investors. Due to the nature of these contracts, the carrying value of the assets is always the same as the value of the liabilities due to policyholders and any change in the value of the assets results in an equal but opposite change in the value of the amounts due to policyholders.
 
At December 31, 2009, such assets amounted to €9,224 million (March 31, 2009: €7,195 million). The associated liabilities are included in liabilities to customers under investment contracts and insurance contract liabilities on the balance sheet.
 
The remaining €455 million (March 31, 2009: €409 million) relates to other Group businesses.
 
23 LOANS AND ADVANCES TO BANKS
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Placements with other banks
    2,683       4,123  
Mandatory deposit with central banks
    2,107       2,674  
Funds placed with central banks
    223       1,091  
Securities purchased with agreement to resell
    20        
                 
      5,033       7,888  
Less allowance for impairment on loans and advances to banks
    (2 )     (2 )
                 
Loans and advances to banks
    5,031       7,886  
                 

F-65


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
23 LOANS AND ADVANCES TO BANKS  (continued)
 
As set out in its risk management note on pages F-141 to F-175, the Group uses netting arrangements to reduce its exposure to credit losses. Loans and advances with other banks includes money market placements to an international bank counterparty of €nil (March 31, 2009: €0.8 billion), undertaken in the normal course of business, for which a right of set-off in the event of default existed against Deposits from banks of €nil (March 31, 2009: €0.8 billion). In accordance with accounting standards, as there was no intention to settle these balances on a net basis or simultaneously, these balances were recorded as assets and liabilities respectively (see note 34).
 
Placements with other banks includes cash collateral of €1.9 billion (March 31, 2009: €1.9 billion) placed with derivative counterparties in relation to net derivative liability positions (see note 21).
 
For the purposes of disclosure of credit risk exposures, loans and advances to banks are included within Other financial instruments of €36.1 billion (March 31, 2009: €46.9 billion) in the risk management note on pages F-141 to F-175.
 
The Group has entered into transactions to purchase securities with agreement to resell and has accepted collateral that it is permitted to sell or repledge in the absence of default by the owner of the collateral. The fair value of this collateral at December 31, 2009 was €21 million (March 31, 2009: nil).
 
24 AVAILABLE FOR SALE FINANCIAL ASSETS
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Government bonds
    1,055       2,460  
Other debt securities
               
— listed
    18,438       21,728  
— unlisted
    1,391       2,608  
Equity securities
               
— listed
    16       26  
— unlisted
    40       36  
                 
Available for sale financial assets
    20,940       26,858  
                 
 
At December 31, 2009, available for sale financial assets at fair value of €9.8 billion (March 31, 2009: €7.6 billion) had been pledged to third parties in sale and repurchase agreements.
 
The movement on available for sale financial assets is analysed as follows:
 
                 
    9 months
  Year
    ended
  ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
As at the beginning of period
    26,858       29,307  
Revaluation, exchange and other adjustments
    874       (953 )
Additions
    8,587       27,267  
Sales
    (3,385 )     (5,398 )
Redemptions
    (12,004 )     (22,926 )
Amortisation
    12       56  
Impairment charge (note 14)
    (2 )     (76 )
Reclassification
          (419 )
                 
As at end of period
    20,940       26,858  
                 


F-66


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
24 AVAILABLE FOR SALE FINANCIAL ASSETS  (continued)
 
In accordance with the amendment to IAS 39 disclosed in the accounting policies section on page F-33, during the year ended March 31, 2009 the Group reclassified available for sale financial assets with a carrying amount and fair value of €419 million to loans and advances to customers. At the date of this reclassification, the Group had the intention and ability to hold these assets for the foreseeable future or until maturity. The Group did not make any such reclassifications in the nine months ended December 31, 2009.
 
The table below sets out the relevant carrying amounts and fair values:
 
                                 
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    Carrying
  Fair
  Carrying
  Fair
    Amounts   Value   Amounts   Value
    €m   €m   €m   €m
 
AFS financial assets reclassified to loans and advances to customers
    424       432       419       419  
 
Interest income of €11 million and an impairment charge of €22 million have been recognised in the income statement for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 in relation to these assets. If the assets had not been reclassified a fair value gain of €56 million would have been recognised in other comprehensive income and the impairment charge would have been €24 million.
 
25 LOANS AND ADVANCES TO CUSTOMERS
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Loans and advances to customers
    119,926       132,522  
Finance leases and hire purchase receivables (see analysis below)
    2,510       2,999  
                 
      122,436       135,521  
Less allowance for impairment charges on loans and advances to customers (note 27)
    (2,997 )     (1,781 )
                 
Loans and advances to customers
    119,439       133,740  
                 
 
On December 31, 2009, loans and advances to customers of €9,457 million (net of impairment provision of €2,778 million) were reclassified to loans held for sale to NAMA (see note 26). The total loans and advances to customers above exclude these assets.


F-67


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
25 LOANS AND ADVANCES TO CUSTOMERS  (continued)
 
Finance leases and hire purchase receivables
 
Loans and advances to customers include finance leases and hire purchase receivables, which are analysed as follows:
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Gross investment in finance leases:
               
Not later than 1 year
    1,176       1,339  
Later than 1 year and not later than 5 years
    1,553       1,932  
Later than 5 years
    25       36  
                 
      2,754       3,307  
Unearned future finance income on finance leases
    (244 )     (308 )
                 
Net investment in finance leases
    2,510       2,999  
                 
The net investment in finance leases is analysed as follows:
               
Not later than 1 year
    1,072       1,215  
Later than 1 year and not later than 5 years
    1,415       1,751  
Later than 5 years
    23       33  
                 
      2,510       2,999  
                 
 
The Group’s material leasing arrangements include the provision of instalment credit and leasing finance for both consumer and commercial customers.
 
At December 31, 2009, the accumulated allowance for uncollectable minimum lease payments receivable was €62 million.
 
Securitisations
 
Loans and advances to customers include balances that have been securitised but not derecognised, comprising both residential mortgages and commercial loans. In general, the assets, or interests in the assets, are transferred to Special Purposes Entities (SPE’s), which then issue securities to third party investors or to other entities within the Group. All of the Group’s Securitisation SPE’s are consolidated.
 
Refer to note 52 for further details on these SPE’s, including details of entities that have issued liabilities internal to the Group and thus are capable of being pledged to monetary authorities.


F-68


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
26 ASSETS AND LIABILITIES HELD FOR SALE TO NAMA
 
In April 2009, the Minister for Finance announced that NAMA would be established with the purpose of strengthening the Irish financial sector and the NAMA legislation was enacted into law in November 2009.
 
The participation of Bank of Ireland in the NAMA programme was recommended by the Court of Directors in the Circular of December 18, 2009. It was approved by the stockholders at an Extraordinary General Court on January 12, 2010. Bank of Ireland’s application as a participating institution was approved by the Minister for Finance on February 12, 2010.
 
NAMA has the power to acquire from Participating Institutions, Eligible Bank Assets, that is, land and development loans and certain associated loans (which are expected to comprise non-land and non-development related loans to borrowers of land and development related loans, or loans to certain associated entities of borrowers who had provided security in respect of the land or development related loans). The geographic distribution of the loans relates to exposures both within and outside Ireland. The Eligible Bank Assets will also include interest rate derivative contracts sold to borrowers by Participating Institutions that relate to hedging the interest rate exposure on the loans to be acquired.
 
The Eligible Bank Assets are being acquired on a phased basis from April 2010, with the largest systemic exposures to the Irish banking system acquired first. Details of each tranche of assets to be acquired will be set out in the form of an acquisition schedule issued by NAMA prior to each acquisition date. It is expected that all Eligible Assets will have been transferred by December 31, 2010.
 
In acquiring such assets, NAMA will apply a valuation methodology which will take account of the current market value and the long term economic value on a loan by loan basis. As loan quality, geographic distribution and type of loans vary from institution to institution, each loan will be valued individually. As a result the aggregate discount applied to gross loan values in determining the consideration to be paid by NAMA will vary from institution to institution. Participating Institutions are required to accept the valuations set by NAMA, subject only to certain limited rights of objection.
 
As consideration for Eligible Bank Assets transferred, NAMA will issue to financial institutions a combination of Government guaranteed bonds, issued by NAMA (not less than 95% of the consideration) and subordinated bonds (not more than 5% of the consideration). These Government guaranteed bonds will be marketable instruments that are capable of being pledged as funding collateral to debt market investors and to monetary authorities such as the ECB.
 
Payments on the subordinated bonds are subject to the requirement that NAMA has sufficient funds, both annually (in respect of coupon payments) and in order to repay the Government guaranteed bonds and subordinated bonds, based on a measure of financial performance of NAMA in totality (rather than on the financial performance of the Eligible Bank Assets acquired from any particular Participating Institution). The subordinated bonds are not guaranteed by the Irish Government and they are not expected to be marketable, they could have a value less than their nominal face value and the payment of interest and repayment of capital is dependent on the performance of NAMA.
 
At December 31, 2009, the Group considered that the estimated Eligible Bank Assets which were expected to be transferred to NAMA met the criteria for classification as assets held for sale. Thus, the relevant loans and advances to customers, derivatives and accrued interest have been reclassified to assets held for sale as at December 31, 2009. The assets classified as assets held for sale to NAMA continue to be measured on the same basis as prior to their classification as assets held for sale. In particular, loans and advances to customers continue to be measured at amortised cost less any incurred impairment losses. In accordance with accounting standards, de-recognition of these assets held for sale will occur when substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership have been transferred to NAMA. This will only occur on a phased basis as ownership of each tranche is legally transferred to NAMA.


F-69


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
26 ASSETS AND LIABILITIES HELD FOR SALE TO NAMA  (continued)
 
Based on the Eligible Asset Regulations (as contained within the NAMA regulations), internal review work to identify all loans falling within the eligibility criteria and ongoing interaction with NAMA, the Group expects to transfer total land and development and associated loans of approximately gross. €12.2 billion together with related derivatives and accrued interest of €0.2 billion. Net of impairment provisions of €2.8 billion which are held against these loans at December 31, 2009, this estimate would imply a net transfer of €9.6 billion of Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA.
 
         
    December 31,
    2009
    €m
 
Assets held for sale to NAMA
       
Land and development loans
    8,522  
Associated loans
    3,713  
         
      12,235  
Impairment provisions
    (2,778 )
         
      9,457  
Derivatives
    93  
Accrued interest
    31  
         
Total assets held for sale to NAMA
    9,581  
         
Analysed by operating segment
       
Retail Republic of Ireland
    2,470  
UK Financial Services
    2,765  
Capital Markets
    4,346  
         
Total assets held for sale to NAMA
    9,581  
         
 
The fair values and notional amounts of derivative instruments held for sale to NAMA are set out in the table below:
 
                         
    Contract/
       
    notional
  Fair Values
December 31, 2009
  amount   Assets   Liabilities
    €m   €m   €m
 
Derivatives held for trading
                       
Interest rate derivatives
                       
Interest rate swaps
    2,001       88        
Over the counter interest rate options
    348       5       1  
                         
Total derivatives held for trading
    2,349       93       1  
                         
 
As interactions with NAMA and the internal review work are ongoing and the possibility that loans that are expected to transfer may be repaid or refinanced with other banks, there is uncertainty as to the final amount of eligible assets that will transfer.
 
The Group expects to incur a loss on disposal of the Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA arising from the difference between the fair value of the consideration to be received and the carrying value of the Eligible Bank Assets to be disposed of together with the costs of disposal and any provision that may be required under accounting standards due to the ongoing cost of servicing these assets on behalf of NAMA.


F-70


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
26 ASSETS AND LIABILITIES HELD FOR SALE TO NAMA  (continued)
 
The principal determinant of the expected loss on disposal is the difference between the discount applied to the original gross Eligible Bank Asset value in arriving at NAMA’s valuation and the impairment provisions recorded against the Eligible Bank Assets under Accounting Standards. This discount or haircut to original asset value is calculated on a different basis and using a different methodology to the determination of impairment provisions under accounting standards.
 
In accordance with Accounting Standards, the loss on disposal will only be recognised on the actual transfer of each tranche of assets to NAMA. At the same time as recognition of such losses, the Bank will benefit from a reduction in its risk weighted assets for regulatory capital purposes.
 
The loss on disposal of Eligible Bank Assets will be tax deductible. However, the use of such tax losses in future years will be restricted as set out in part 10 of Schedule 3 of the National Asset Management Agency Act 2009 (the “Act”). This inserts a new section 396C into the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997 which limits the utilisation of tax losses carried forward by an institution participating in NAMA. It lengthens the period over which the deferred tax asset created will reverse by restricting the amount of profits against which trading losses can be utilised. The balance is available for indefinite carry forward. There is no time limit on the utilisation of these losses.
 
In addition, the Act provides that, on the later of ten years after the passing of the Act or the dissolution, restructuring or material alteration of NAMA, in the event that the accounts of NAMA disclose an underlying loss, the Minister for Finance may bring forward legislation to impose a special tax by way of surcharge on Participating Institutions to recover such loss.
 
The first tranche of assets transferred to NAMA on April 2, 2010. This tranche comprised €1.9 billion of assets (before impairment provision) for which consideration of €1.2 billion in Government guaranteed bonds and subordinated bonds was received. This resulted in a discount to gross loan value of approximately 36%.
 
These loans (including accrued interest) comprised land and development loans of €0.9 billion and associated loans of €1.0 billion. As at December 31, 2009, the Group held impairment provisions of €0.3 billion against these loans. In addition, the transfer included associated derivatives with a fair value of €15 million.
 
The nominal consideration receivable for these Eligible Bank Assets amounted to €1.2 billion and a loss of €0.4 billion (before the impact of any adjustment required to record the subordinated debt at fair value and any provision that may be required for ongoing servicing costs) will be recognised in the Group’s income statement for the year ending December 31, 2010.
 
The limited number and nature of loans involved in this first tranche mean that it may not be a representative sample of the total portfolio of assets held for sale to NAMA and consequently the loss on sale is not necessarily indicative of the loss that the entire portfolio of Eligible Bank Assets that may ultimately transfer. The loss on sale that is expected to ultimately arise for the Group is a function of the quantum of assets to be transferred, the mix of those assets as between land, development and associated loans and the discount that is applied to the assets transferring on a loan by loan basis. Accordingly the Group is currently unable to accurately quantify the ultimate expected loss on transfer of all of the Bank’s Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA.


F-71


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
27 IMPAIRMENT PROVISIONS
 
The following tables show the movement in the impairment provisions on loans and advances to customers, inclusive of loans and advances reclassified to loans held for sale to NAMA.
 
                                         
        Non-Property
  Property
       
9 Months Ended December 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME &
  and
       
Impairment provisions
  Mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Impaired financial assets
    471       2,806       9,648       426       13,351  
                                         
Provision at the beginning of the period
    144       480       856       301       1,781  
Exchange adjustments
    3       22       22       1       48  
Amounts written off
    (30 )     (42 )           (73 )     (145 )
Recoveries
          1       (1 )     3       3  
Charge against income statement
    237       659       2,993       166       4,055  
Other movements
    5       32       14       (18 )     33  
                                         
Provision at the end of the period
    359       1,152       3,884       380       5,775  
                                         
The provision at December 31, 2009 is split as follows:
                                       
Loans and advances to customers
    359       1,134       1,124       380       2,997  
Loans held for sale to NAMA
          18       2,760             2,778  
                                         
Provision at the end of the period
    359       1,152       3,884       380       5,775  
                                         
 
                                         
        Non-Property
  Property
       
Year Ended March 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME &
  and
       
Impairment provisions
  Mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Impaired financial assets
    229       1,187       3,538       368       5,322  
                                         
Provision at the beginning of the period
    21       280       108       187       596  
Exchange adjustments
    3       (6 )     2       5       4  
Amounts written off
    (9 )     (134 )     (16 )     (85 )     (244 )
Recoveries
    4       1       1       2       8  
Charge against income statement
    127       344       766       198       1,435  
Other movements
    (2 )     (5 )     (5 )     (6 )     (18 )
                                         
Provision at the end of the period
    144       480       856       301       1,781  
                                         
 
28 INTEREST IN ASSOCIATES
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
At the beginning of the period
    22       28  
Share of results after tax (note 16)
    (2 )     (7 )
Increase in investments
    3       2  
Dividend received
          (1 )
                 
At end of period
    23       22  
                 


F-72


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
28  INTEREST IN ASSOCIATES  (continued)
 
In presenting details of the associated undertakings of the Group, the exemption permitted by Regulation 10 of the European Communities (Credit Institutions: Accounts) Regulations, 1992 has been availed of and the Group will annex a full listing of associates to its annual return to the Companies Office.
 
29 INTEREST IN JOINT VENTURES
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
At beginning of period
    151       70  
Reclassifications
          175  
Share of results after tax (note 16):
    37       (35 )
                 
— First Rate Exchange Services
    27       39  
— Property unit trust
    10       (63 )
— Paul Capital Investment
    1       (11 )
— Other
    (1 )      
                 
Dividends received
          (34 )
Exchange adjustments
    6       (25 )
                 
At end of period
    194       151  
                 
 
30 INTANGIBLE ASSETS
 
                                         
                Other
   
        Computer
  Computer
  externally
   
        software
  software
  purchased
   
        externally
  internally
  intangible
   
    Goodwill   purchased   generated   assets   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Cost
                                       
At April 1, 2009
    334       278       828       144       1,250  
Exchange adjustments
    1       3       5       2       10  
Reclassifications
          (8 )     8              
Additions
          11       31       5       47  
Disposals / write offs
    (287 )     (14 )     (39 )     (19 )     (72 )
                                         
At December 31, 2009
    48       270       833       132       1,235  
                                         
Accumulated amortisation
                                       
At April 1, 2009
    (287 )     (231 )     (473 )     (61 )     (765 )
Exchange adjustments
          (1 )     (2 )     1       (2 )
Disposals / write offs
    287       14       39       19       72  
Impairment
                      (6 )     (6 )
Charge for the year (note 12)
          (8 )     (61 )     (6 )     (75 )
                                         
At December 31, 2009
          (226 )     (497 )     (53 )     (776 )
                                         
Net Book Value at December 31, 2009
    48       44       336       79       459  
                                         
 


F-73


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
30 INTANGIBLE ASSETS  (continued)
 
                                         
                Other
   
        Computer
  Computer
  externally
   
        software
  software
  purchased
   
        externally
  internally
  intangible
   
    Goodwill   purchased   generated   assets   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Cost
                                       
At April 1, 2008
    293       267       807       149       1,223  
Exchange adjustments
    41       (12 )     (20 )     (14 )     (46 )
Reclassifications
                2       (19 )     (17 )
Additions
          35       56       28       119  
Disposals / write offs
          (12 )     (17 )           (29 )
                                         
At March 31, 2009
    334       278       828       144       1,250  
                                         
Accumulated amortisation
                                       
At April 1, 2008
          (211 )     (401 )     (41 )     (653 )
Exchange adjustments
          5       6       4       15  
Disposals / write offs
          12       10             22  
Impairment
    (287 )                 (17 )     (17 )
Charge for the year (note 12)
          (37 )     (88 )     (7 )     (132 )
                                         
At March 31, 2009
    (287 )     (231 )     (473 )     (61 )     (765 )
                                         
Net Book Value at March 31, 2009
    47       47       355       83       485  
                                         
 
Impairment Review — Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets
 
Goodwill is reviewed annually for impairment or more frequently if events or circumstances indicate that impairment may have occurred, by comparing the carrying value of goodwill to its recoverable amount. An impairment charge arises if the carrying value exceeds the recoverable amount.
 
The recoverable amount of an asset is the higher of its fair value less costs to sell and its value in use, where the value in use is the present value of the future cash flows expected to be derived from the asset.
 
Impairment testing of goodwill
 
At December 31, 2009 total goodwill on the Group balance sheet was €48 million (March 31, 2009: €47 million), which is outlined in the table below:
 
                         
Goodwill
  Burdale   Other   Total
    €m   €m   €m
 
At April 1, 2009
    41       6       47  
Exchange adjustments
    1             1  
                         
At December 31, 2009
    42       6       48  
                         
 

F-74


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
30 INTANGIBLE ASSETS  (continued)
 
                                         
    Guggenheim   Iridian   Burdale   Other   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
At April 1, 2008
    72       168       48       5       293  
Exchange adjustments
    14       33       (7 )     1       41  
Impairment
    (86 )     (201 )                 (287 )
                                         
At March 31, 2009
                41       6       47  
                                         
 
Goodwill is allocated to cash generating units at a level which represents the smallest identifiable group of assets that generate largely independent cash flows.
 
The calculation of the recoverable amount of goodwill for each of these cash generating units is based upon a value in use calculation that discounts expected pre-tax cash flows at an interest rate appropriate to the cash generating unit. The determination of both require the exercise of judgement. The estimation of pre-tax cash flows is sensitive to the periods for which forecasted cash flows are available and to assumptions underpinning the sustainability of those cash flows. While forecasts are compared with actual performance and external economic data, expected cash flows reflect management’s view of future performance.
 
The values assigned to key assumptions reflect past experience, performance of the business to date and management judgement. The recoverable amount calculations performed for the significant amounts of goodwill are sensitive to changes in the following key assumptions:
 
Cash flow forecasts
 
Cash flow forecasts are based on internal management information for a period of up to five years, after which a growth factor appropriate for the business is applied. Initial cash flows are based on performance in the current year and the next four years’ cash flows are consistent with approved plans for each business.
 
Growth rates
 
Growth rates beyond five years are determined by reference to local economic growth, inflation projections or long term bond yields. The assumed long term growth rate for Burdale is 2.25%.
 
Discount rate
 
The discount rate applied in Burdale is the pre-tax weighted average cost of capital for the Group increased to include a risk premium to reflect the specific risk profile of the cash generating unit to the extent that such risk is not already reflected in the forecast cash flows. A rate of 13.5% has been used in the model.
 
Certain elements within these cash flow forecasts are critical to the performance of the business. The impact of changes in these cash flows, growth rate and discount rate assumptions has been assessed by the Directors in the review. The Directors consider that reasonable changes in key assumptions used to determine the recoverable amount of Burdale, would not result in any impairment of goodwill.
 
No impairment was identified in the periods ended December 31, 2009 or the year ended March 31, 2009 in relation to Burdale.
 
During the year ended March 31, 2009 goodwill in both Iridian and Guggenheim and the other intangibles in Guggenheim were impaired in full resulting in a charge to the income statement of €304 million. During the nine months ended December 31, 2009 these businesses were disposed of. Further information on these disposals is outlined in note 17.

F-75


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
31 INVESTMENT PROPERTIES
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
At beginning of period
    1,413       1,511  
Exchange adjustment
    (17 )      
Revaluation
    (98 )     (512 )
Additions/reclassifications
          414  
Disposals
    (33 )      
                 
At the end of period
    1,265       1,413  
                 
 
Of the €1,265 million (March 31, 2009: €1,413 million) €983 million (March 31, 2009: €1,062 million) is held on behalf of BoI Life policyholders.
 
Investment properties are carried at fair value as determined by external qualified property surveyors appropriate to the variety of properties held. Fair values have been calculated using both current trends in the market and recent transactions for similar properties.
 
During the year ended March 31, 2009 certain other properties were reclassified from assets classified as held for sale to investment properties.
 
Rental income from investment property amounted to €86 million for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 (year ended March 31, 2009: €100 million). Expenses directly attributable to investment property generating rental income amounted to €27 million for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 (year ended March 31, 2009: €28 million). There were no expenses directly attributable to investment property not generating rental income for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 (or the year ended March 31, 2009).


F-76


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
32 PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT
 
                                                 
    Freehold
                   
    land and
              Payments on
   
    buildings
              account and
   
    and long
      Computer
      assets in the
   
    leaseholds
      and other
  Finance
  course of
   
    (at fair
  Adaptations
  equipment
  lease assets
  construction
   
    value)   (at cost)   (at cost)   (at cost)   (at cost)   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Cost or valuation
                                               
At April 1, 2009
    272       146       668       7       23       1,116  
Exchange adjustments
    2       1       4                   7  
Additions
          1       3             7       11  
Disposals
    (1 )     (2 )     (50 )                 (53 )
Revaluation
    (66 )                             (66 )
Reclassifications
          2       17             (19 )      
                                                 
At December 31, 2009
    207       148       642       7       11       1,015  
                                                 
Accumulated depreciation and amortisation
                                               
At April 1, 2009
          (67 )     (550 )     (7 )           (624 )
Exchange adjustments
                (4 )                 (4 )
Disposals
          1       48                   49  
Charge for the year (note 12)
          (11 )     (21 )                 (32 )
Reclassifications
          1       (1 )                  
                                                 
At December 31, 2009
          (76 )     (528 )     (7 )     0       (611 )
                                                 
Net book value at December 31, 2009
    207       72       114             11       404  
                                                 


F-77


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
32 PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT  (continued)
 
The net book value of property, plant and equipment at December 31, 2009 at fair value was €207 million, while that held at amortised cost amounted to €197 million.
 
                                                 
    Freehold
                   
    land and
              Payments on
   
    buildings
              account and
   
    and long
      Computer
      assets in the
   
    leaseholds
      and other
  Finance
  course of
   
    (at fair
  Adaptations
  equipment
  lease assets
  construction
   
    value)   (at cost)   (at cost)   (at cost)   (at cost)   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Cost or valuation
                                               
At April 1, 2008
    380       124       658       7       35       1,204  
Exchange adjustments
    (10 )     (3 )     (19 )           (4 )     (36 )
Additions
    5       8       28             34       75  
Disposals
    (1 )     (1 )     (15 )                 (17 )
Revaluation
    (122 )                             (122 )
Reclassifications
    20       18       16             (42 )     12  
                                                 
At March 31, 2009
    272       146       668       7       23       1,116  
                                                 
Accumulated depreciation and amortisation
                                               
At April 1, 2008
          (55 )     (550 )     (6 )           (611 )
Exchange adjustments
          3       14                   17  
Disposals
                13                   13  
Charge for the year (note 12)
          (15 )     (30 )     (1 )           (46 )
Reclassifications
                3                   3  
                                                 
At March 31, 2009
          (67 )     (550 )     (7 )           (624 )
                                                 
Net book value at March 31, 2009
    272       79       118             23       492  
                                                 
 
The net book value of property, plant and equipment at March 31, 2009 at fair value was €272 million, while that held at cost amounted to €220 million.
 
Property
 
A revaluation of Group property was carried out as at December 31, 2009. All freehold and long leasehold (50 years or more unexpired) commercial properties were valued by Lisneys as external valuers, who also reviewed the valuation of all other property carried out by the Bank’s professionally qualified staff. Valuations were made on the basis of open market value.
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Future capital expenditure
               
— contracted but not provided in the financial statements
    4       17  
— authorised by the Directors but not contracted
    1       81  
                 


F-78


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
32 PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT  (continued)
 
Operating leases
 
The Group leases a number of branch and office premises to carry out its business. The commercial leases typically are 25 to 35 year operating leases with 5 yearly rent reviews. The majority of the rent reviews are on an upwards only basis. Some leases also include break options. The Group also holds a number of short term leases for less than 10 years and a number of long term leases at market rent with less than 110 years unexpired. On expiry of long term leases greater than 5 years the Group has rights of renewal in the majority of the leases.
 
Minimum future rentals are the rentals payable under operating leases up to the next available break option where this exists or to expiry date of the lease. Both the required break option notice period and the amount of any penalty rent have been included in the amounts payable below.
 
Minimum future rentals under non-cancellable operating leases are as follows:
 
                                 
    Payable
  Receivable
  Payable
  Receivable
    December 31,
  December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2009   2009
    €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Not later than 1 year
    65       3       52        
Later than 1 year and not later than 5 years
    219       8       168       3  
Later than 5 years
    442       2       369       2  
                                 
 
The Group has entered into a small number of sub-leases as lessor which represent properties and components of properties surplus to the Group’s own requirements.
 
Included in the operating lease rental receivable is an amount of €11 million in relation to sub-lease rental (March 31, 2009: €12 million).


F-79


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
33 OTHER ASSETS
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Sundry and other debtors
    379       657  
Interest receivable
    503       636  
Value in force of life assurance business (note 53)
    497       468  
Reinsurance asset
    615       437  
Accounts receivable and prepayments
    176       212  
Current tax asset
    134       156  
                 
Other assets
    2,304       2,566  
                 
Other assets are analysed as follows:
               
Within 1 year
    1,192       1,661  
After 1 year
    1,112       905  
                 
      2,304       2,566  
                 
The movement in the reinsurance asset is noted below:
               
At beginning of period
    437       484  
New business
    86       108  
Changes in business
    92       (155 )
                 
At the end of the period
    615       437  
                 
 
34 OTHER ASSETS AND LIABILITIES CLASSIFIED AS HELD FOR SALE
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
Assets
  2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Assets of Guggenheim
          7  
Assets of Iridian
          17  
                 
Assets classified as held for sale
          24  
                 
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
Liabilities
  2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Liabilities of Guggenheim
          4  
Liabilities of Iridian
          10  
                 
Liabilities classified as held for sale
          14  
                 
 
These companies were disposed of during the nine months ended December 31, 2009. Information on the sale of both Guggenheim and Iridian is outlined in note 17.


F-80


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
35 DEPOSITS FROM BANKS
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Deposits from banks
    4,639       9,210  
Securities sold under agreement to repurchase
    12,994       19,508  
Other bank borrowings
    270       96  
                 
Deposits by banks
    17,903       28,814  
                 
 
As set out in the risk management note on pages F-141 to F-175, the Group uses netting arrangements to reduce its exposure to credit losses. Deposits from banks includes money market placements by an international bank counterparty of €nil (March 31, 2009: €0.8 billion, undertaken in the normal course of business, for which a right of set-off in the event of default existed against Loans and Advances to banks of €nil (March 31, 2009: €0.8 billion). In accordance with accounting standards, as there was no intention to settle these balances on a net basis or simultaneously, these balances were recorded as liabilities and assets respectively (see note 34).
 
Deposits from banks includes cash collateral of €0.5 billion (March 31, 2009: €0.7 billion) received from derivative counterparties in relation to net derivative asset positions (see note 21).
 
The Group has developed significant pools of eligible collateral from its balance sheet which are capable of being pledged in the secondary market and through the normal market operations of the Monetary Authorities to provide access to secured funding. At December 31, 2009, the net drawings, from Monetary Authorities, were €8 billion (March 31, 2009: €17 billion).
 
36 CUSTOMER ACCOUNTS
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Term deposits and other products
    35,169       40,437  
Demand deposits
    34,979       28,808  
Current accounts
    14,664       13,874  
                 
Customer accounts
    84,812       83,119  
                 
 
At December 31, 2009, the Group’s largest 20 customer deposits amounted to 11% (March 31, 2009) of total customer accounts. Information on the contractual maturities of customer accounts is set out in note 56 Risk Management.
 
At December 31, 2009 Customer accounts included an amount of €nil (March 31, 2009: €nil) from a global financial institution. The Group had placed net cash with a banking affiliate of the same institution of €nil (March 31, 2009: €nil).
 
37 DEBT SECURITIES IN ISSUE
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Bonds and medium term notes
    25,571       23,986  
Other debt securities in issue
    17,573       21,147  
                 
Debt securities in issue
    43,144       45,133  
                 


F-81


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
38  LIABILITIES TO CUSTOMERS UNDER INVESTMENT AND INSURANCE CONTRACTS
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
Investment contract liabilities
  2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Liabilities to customers under investment contracts at fair value
    5,050       4,084  
                 
 
The movement in gross life insurance contract liabilities can be analysed as follows:
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
Insurance contract liabilities
  2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
At beginning of period
    5,634       7,140  
New business
    710       662  
Changes in business
    314       (2,168 )
                 
At end of period
    6,658       5,634  
                 
 
Bank of Ireland Life (BoI Life) writes the following life assurance contracts that contain insurance risk:
 
Non-unit linked life assurance contracts
 
These contracts provide the policyholder with insurance in the event of death, critical illness or permanent disability (principally mortality and morbidity risk).
 
Non-unit linked annuity contracts
 
These contracts provide the policyholder with an income until death (principally longevity and market risk).
 
Linked insurance contracts
 
These contracts include both policies primarily providing life assurance protection and policies providing investment but with a level of insurance risk deemed to be significant (principally mortality and market risk).
 
Insurance contract liabilities, which consist of both unit linked and non-unit linked liabilities, are calculated in accordance with the Insurance Regulations. Unit linked liabilities reflect the value of the underlying funds in which the policyholder is invested. Non unit-linked liabilities are calculated using either a gross premium or net premium method of valuation.
 
The assumptions are also set out in accordance with the Insurance Regulations and contain a margin for adverse development. The key assumption used in the valuation of insurance contract liabilities are:
 
Interest rate: The interest rates are derived in accordance with the guidelines in the Insurance Regulations. Margins for risk are allowed for in the derived interest rate.
 
Mortality and morbidity: The mortality and morbidity assumptions, which include an allowance for improvements in longevity for annuitants, are set with regard to the Group’s actual experience and/or relevant industry data.
 
Maintenance expenses: Allowance is made for future policy costs and expense inflation explicitly.


F-82


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
38  LIABILITIES TO CUSTOMERS UNDER INVESTMENT AND INSURANCE CONTRACTS  (continued)
 
 
Options and guarantees
 
BoI Life has a very limited range of options and guarantees in its business portfolio as the bulk of the business is unit linked without investment guarantees. Where investment guarantees do exist they are either hedged with an outside party or matched through appropriate investment assets.
 
Uncertainties associated with insurance contract cash flows and risk management activities
 
For life assurance contracts where death is the insured risk, the most significant factors that could adversely affect the frequency and severity of claims are the incidence of disease and general changes in lifestyle. Where the insured risk is longevity, advances in medical care are the key factor that increases longevity. The Group manages its exposures to insurance risks through a combination of applying strict underwriting criteria, asset and liability matching, transferring risk to reinsurers and the establishment of prudent insurance contract liabilities.
 
Credit risk
 
Reinsurance programmes are in place to restrict the amount of cover on any single life. The Group uses a panel of highly rated reinsurance companies to diversify credit risk.
 
Capital Management and Available Resources
 
The Group holds technical reserves to meet its liabilities to policyholders based on prudent actuarial assumptions. In addition, the Financial Regulator requires the Group’s life assurance operation to hold shareholder equity that exceeds a statutory margin, the required minimum regulatory solvency margin. The table below sets out the shareholder equity held by the Group’s life assurance operation compared to the required minimum regulatory margin as at December 31, 2009.
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Minimum regulatory solvency margin
    173       178  
                 
Shareholder equity held for life business
    345       290  
                 


F-83


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
39 SUBORDINATED LIABILITIES
 
                         
        December 31,
  March 31,
    Notes   2009   2009
        €m   €m
 
Undated Loan Capital
                       
Bank of Ireland UK Holdings plc
                       
€600 million 7.40% Guaranteed Step-up Callable Perpetual Preferred Securities
    a, b       499 (1, 2, 4)     637  
Stg£350 million 6.25% Guaranteed Callable Perpetual Preferred Securities
    b, c       52 (1, 2, 4)     381  
BoI Capital Funding (No 1) LP
                       
€600 million Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities
    d, e       342 (1, 2, 4)     592  
BoI Capital Funding (No 2) LP
                       
US$800 million Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities
    e, f,       272 (1, 2, 4)     674  
BoI Capital Funding (No 3) LP
                       
US$400 million Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities
    e, g       139 (1, 2, 4)     345  
BoI Capital Funding (No 4) LP
                       
Stg£500 million Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities
    e, h       40 (1, 2, 4)     587  
Bank of Ireland
                       
Stg£75 million 133/8% Perpetual Subordinated Bonds
    i       140       134  
Bristol & West plc
                       
Stg£32.6 million 81/8% Non-Cumulative Preference Shares
    j       37       35  
                         
              1,521       3,385  
                         
Dated loan capital
                       
€750 million 6.45% Subordinated Bonds 2010
            754       775  
€600 million Subordinated Floating Rate Notes 2013
    k              
Can$400 million Fixed/Floating Rate Subordinated Notes 2015
            229       229  
€600 million Subordinated Floating Rate Notes due 2017
            599 (3)     599  
€750 million Floating Rate Subordinated Notes 2017
            749 (3)     749  
Stg£400 million Fixed/Floating Rate Subordinated Notes 2018
            449 (3)     428  
US $600 million Subordinated Floating Rate Notes due 2018
            416 (3)     450  
Stg£75 million 103/4% Subordinated Bonds 2018
            96       95  
€650 million Fixed/Floating Rate Subordinated Notes 2019
            688 (3)     692  
Stg£450 million dated callable Step-up Fixed/Floating Rate Subordinated Notes September 2020
    l       552       540  
                         
              4,532       4,557  
                         
              6,053       7,942  
                         


F-84


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
39 SUBORDINATED LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
 
(1) In June 2009 the Group repurchased certain amounts of these subordinated liabilities. Information on the repurchase of these subordinated liabilities are shown in note 9.
 
(2) On January 19, 2010, the Group advised the Stock Exchange that the EU Commission had indicated that, in line with its policy and pending its assessment of the Group’s restructuring plan (which is required in compliance with EU State aid rules), that the Group should not make coupon payments on its Tier 1 and Upper Tier 2 capital instruments unless under a binding legal obligation to do so.
 
(3) On February 12, 2010, the Group announced that it had completed an Exchange offer for outstanding notes relating to these five lower Tier 2 securities. For further information see note 58.
 
(4) On April 26, 2010, the Group announced a debt for equity swap on certain of the above securities.
 
Undated loan capital
 
(a) The securities are redeemable in whole or in part at the option of the Issuer subject to the prior consent of the Financial Regulator and of the Bank, at their principal amount together with any outstanding payments on March 7, 2011 or any coupon payment date thereafter. They bear interest at a rate of 7.40% per annum to March 7, 2011 and thereafter at a rate of 3 month Euribor plus 3.26% per annum, reset quarterly.
 
(b) The rights and claims of the holder of the Preferred Securities are subordinated to the claims of the senior creditors of the Issuer or of the Bank (as the case may be) in that no payment in respect of the Preferred Securities or the guarantee in respect of them shall be due and payable except to the extent that the Issuer or the Bank (as applicable) is solvent and could make such payment and still be solvent immediately thereafter. Upon any winding up of the Issuer or the Bank (in respect of claims under the guarantee), the holders of the Preferred Securities will rank pari passu with the holders of the most senior class or classes of preference shares or stock (if any) of the Issuer or of the Bank then in issue and in priority to all other shareholders of the Issuer and of the Bank.
 
(c) The securities are redeemable in whole but not in part at the option of the Issuer subject to the prior consent of the Financial Regulator and of the Bank, at their principal amount together with any outstanding payments on March 7, 2023 or any coupon date thereafter. They bear interest at a rate of 6.25% per annum to March 7, 2023 and thereafter at a rate of 6 month Stg£ Libor plus 1.70% per annum, reset semi annually.
 
(d) The securities are redeemable, subject to the prior approval of the Financial Regulator, on March 3, 2010 or any distribution payment date thereafter, in whole but not in part, at the option of BoI G.P. No. 1 Limited, which is the General Partner of the Issuer, at their principal amount plus any outstanding payments due. They bear interest at a rate of 6.25% per annum to March 3, 2007 and thereafter at a variable rate of interest per annum which is the lesser of (i) the aggregate of 0.10% per annum and the annual spot 10 year EUR fixed versus 6 month Euribor swap rate and (ii) 8% per annum.
 
(e) The issuer will not pay any distributions and the guarantor will not make any payment in respect of distributions under the subordinated guarantee to the extent that such payment would exceed adjusted distributable reserves or even if adjusted distributable reserves are sufficient to the extent that such payment would breach or cause a breach of Capital Adequacy Regulations then applicable to the Group as determined by the Guarantor’s Court of Directors; or to the extent that the Guarantor is not meeting its minimum capital requirements or is not meeting its solvency ratios; or provided a Deemed Declaration Notice has not been delivered, if the Guarantor’s Court of Directors has resolved no distributions should be made; or if the Regulator has instructed the General Partner or the Guarantor not to make such payment.
 
   The Preferred Securities, together with the subordinated guarantee, are intended to provide holders with rights on liquidation equivalent to non-cumulative Stg£1 and €1.27 preference stock of the Guarantor. Claims under the Preferred Securities in respect of any liquidation distributions will rank senior to the rights of the General


F-85


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
39 SUBORDINATED LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
Partner in respect of other partnership interests issued by the Issuer and pari passu with claims of the holders of all other preferred securities issued by the Issuer which rank pari passu with the Preferred Securities.
 
   The rights and claims of the holders of the Preferred Securities rank (i) junior to all liabilities of the Guarantor including subordinated liabilities (in each case other than any liability of the Guarantor which constitutes Tier 1 Capital or which is referred to in (ii) or (iii) below and any other liability expressed to rank pari passu with or junior to the subordinated guarantee), (ii) pari passu with parity securities issued by the Guarantor and any guarantee of the Guarantor ranking pari passu with the subordinated guarantee and (iii) senior to junior share capital.
 
(f) The securities are redeemable, subject to the prior approval of the Financial Regulator, on February 1, 2016 or any distribution payment date thereafter, in whole but not in part, at the option of BoI G.P. No. 1 Limited, which is the General Partner of the Issuer, at the liquidation preference amount plus any additional amounts and outstanding payments due. They bear interest at a rate of 5.571% per annum up to but excluding February 1, 2016 and thereafter at a floating rate of interest of 1.68% per annum above the rate for US$ Libor 3 month US dollar deposits.
 
(g) The securities are redeemable, subject to the prior approval of the Financial Regulator, on February 4, 2016 or on every subsequent tenth anniversary date of February 4, 2016, in whole but not in part, at the option of BoI G.P. No. 1 Limited, which is the General Partner of the Issuer, at the liquidation preference amount plus any additional amounts and outstanding payments due. They bear interest at a rate of 6.107% per annum up to but excluding February 4, 2016 and thereafter at a floating rate of interest of 1.06% per annum above the rate for US$ Libor 3 month US dollar deposits.
 
(h) The securities are redeemable, subject to the prior approval of the Financial Regulator, on April 3, 2017 or any distribution date thereafter, in whole but not in part, at the option of BoI G.P. No. 1 Limited, which is the General Partner of the Issuer, at the liquidation preference amount plus any additional amounts and outstanding payments due. They bear interest at a rate of 6.4295% per annum up to but excluding April 3, 2017 and thereafter at a floating rate of interest of 1.50% per annum above the rate for Stg£ Libor 3 month sterling deposits.
 
(i) The 133/8% Perpetual Subordinated Bonds which have a nominal value of Stg£75 million were revalued as part of the fair value adjustments on the acquisition of Bristol & West plc.
 
(j) These preference shares which are non-redeemable, non-equity shares rank equally amongst themselves as regards participation in profits and in priority to the ordinary shares of Bristol & West plc.
 
   Holders of the Preference Shares are entitled to receive, in priority to the holders of any other class of shares in Bristol & West plc, a non-cumulative preference dividend at a fixed rate per annum payable in equal half yearly instalments in arrears on May 15 and November 15 each year. The preference dividend on the preference shares will only be payable to the extent that payment can be made out of profits available for distribution as at each dividend payment date in accordance with the provisions of the UK Companies Acts.
 
   On October 1, 2007 in connection with the transfer of the business of Bristol & West plc to Bank of Ireland, Bank of Ireland entered into a Guarantee and Capital Maintenance Commitment (the Guarantee) with respect to the preference shares. Under the terms of the Guarantee, the liability of Bristol & West plc in relation to the ongoing payment of dividends and any repayment of capital in relation to the preference shares that remained following the transfer of business would be protected. Under the Guarantee, Bank of Ireland agreed subject to certain conditions to (i) contribute capital to Bristol & West plc to the extent required to ensure that Bristol & West plc has sufficient distributable reserves to pay the dividends on the preference shares and to the extent required, repay the preference share capital and (ii) guarantee Bristol & West plc’s obligations to make repayment of the dividends and preference share capital.


F-86


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
39 SUBORDINATED LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
 
   In this connection the Guarantee contains provisions to the effect that the rights of Bank of Ireland’s creditors under the Guarantee are subordinated to (i) unsubordinated creditors and debtors of Bank of Ireland and (ii) subordinated creditors of Bank of Ireland other than those whose claims rank, or are expressed to rank pari passu or junior to the payments under the Guarantee.
 
Dated loan capital
 
Dated loan capital, which includes bonds and notes, constitute unsecured obligations of the Bank subordinated in right of payments to the claims of depositors and other unsubordinated creditors of the Bank and rank pari passu without any preference among themselves.
 
Interest rates on the floating rate and fixed rate subordinated liabilities (accommodated through swaps) are determined by reference to the relevant currency reference rate.
 
The table on page F-84 provides a description of the dated loan capital, all of which with the exception of the issue marked (l) were issued under the Bank’s Euro Note Programme.
 
•  the currency of the issue;
 
•  if the issue is fixed, floating or a combination of both; and
 
•  maturity.
 
(k) On February 10, 2010 the €750 million 6.45% subordinated bonds were redeemed on reaching their maturity date.
 
(l) On August 7, 2008 the Group issued Stg£450 million dated callable Step-up Fixed / Floating Rate Subordinated Notes due September 2020.
 
40  OTHER LIABILITIES
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Accrued interest payable
    863       929  
Notes in circulation
    715       660  
Sundry creditors
    312       323  
Accruals and deferred income
    217       229  
Current taxation
    121       103  
Other
    671       805  
                 
Other liabilities
    2,899       3,049  
                 
 
Other liabilities at December 31, 2009 and at March 31, 2009 are due within 1 year.
 
The Bank is authorised to issue bank notes in Northern Ireland under the Bankers (Ireland) Act, 1845 and the Bankers (Northern Ireland) Act, 1928.


F-87


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
41  PROVISIONS
 
                                 
        Onerous
       
    Restructuring   Contracts   Legal   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m
 
As at April 1, 2009
    52       12       23       87  
Exchange adjustments
    2       1             3  
Charge to income statement
          1       88       89  
Utilised during the period
    (32 )     (2 )     (2 )     (36 )
Unused amounts reversed during the period
          (1 )           (1 )
                                 
As at December 31, 2009
    22       11       109       142  
                                 
 
                                 
        Onerous
       
    Restructuring   Contracts   Legal   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m
 
As at April 1, 2008
    34       4       9       47  
Exchange adjustments
    (2 )     (1 )           (3 )
Charge to income statement
    44       11       20       75  
Utilised during the period
    (23 )     (1 )     (3 )     (27 )
Unused amounts reversed during the period
    (1 )     (1 )     (3 )     (5 )
                                 
As at March 31, 2009
    52       12       23       87  
                                 
 
Restructuring
 
During the year ended March 31, 2009 the Group commenced the process of aligning its structure and cost base to an environment of lower levels of business and activity. The Group commenced a number of downsizing initiatives with an expected associated cost of €83 million. These initiatives included the cessation of mortgage lending through the intermediary channel in the UK and downsizing of some activities within Capital Markets and in the UK business banking operations.
 
The principal assumptions underlying the provision calculation relate to the timing and cost of executing the initiatives and particularly the number, mix, timing and net cost of associated staff reductions.
 
It is expected that this provision will be used within the next 2 years.
 
Onerous Lease
 
Partly as a result of the Group’s restructuring of its operations, the Group is a lessee in a number of non-cancellable leases over properties that it no longer occupies. The present value of future lease payments on these properties, less any rental income receivable from sub-leasing, has been provided for.
 
Legal
 
This provision includes certain legal claims brought against the Group by third parties. Legal claims are subject to many uncertainties, and their outcome is often difficult to predict both in terms of timing and economic impact.
 
Of the increase in the legal provision €74 million relates to the unfavourable court ruling in connection with a European property investment.


F-88


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
42  DEFERRED TAX
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
The movement on the deferred tax account is as follows:
               
At beginning of period
    (510 )     (14 )
Income statement credit for period (note 18)
    (356 )     (116 )
Available for sale financial assets — charge/(credit) other comprehensive income
    131       (162 )
Cash flow hedges — transferred to other comprehensive income
    39       (104 )
Revaluation/reclassification of property during period
    (7 )     (17 )
Pension
    (25 )     (83 )
Other movements
    (3 )     (14 )
                 
At end of period
    (731 )     (510 )
                 
Deferred tax assets and liabilities are attributable to the following items:
               
Deferred tax liabilities
               
Accelerated capital allowances:
               
— on finance leases
    30       40  
— on equipment used by the Group
    17       20  
Property revaluation surplus
    19       27  
Life companies
    35        
Other temporary differences
    70       10  
                 
Deferred tax liabilities
    171       97  
                 
Deferred tax assets
               
Pensions and other post retirement benefits
    243       211  
Provision for loan impairment
    12       12  
Other provisions
          6  
Cash flow hedge reserve
    80       116  
Available for sale reserve
    86       219  
Life companies
          23  
Unutilised tax losses
    475        
Other temporary differences
    6       20  
                 
Deferred tax assets
    902       607  
                 
Represented on the balance sheet as follows:
               
Deferred tax assets
    (865 )     (560 )
Deferred tax liabilities
    134       50  
                 
      (731 )     (510 )
                 
 
In presenting the deferred tax balances above, under IAS 12, the Group offset deferred tax assets and liabilities where:
 
•  an entity has a legally enforceable right to set off current tax assets against current tax liabilities; and
 
•  the deferred tax assets and the deferred tax liabilities relate to income taxes levied by the same taxation authority on the same taxable entity.


F-89


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
42  DEFERRED TAX (continued)
 
Deferred tax liabilities have not been recognised for tax that may be payable if earnings of certain overseas subsidiaries were remitted to Ireland, as the timing of the reversal of the temporary difference can be controlled and it is probable that the temporary difference will not reverse in the foreseeable future. Unremitted earnings for overseas subsidiaries at December 31, 2009 totalled €1,222 million (March 31, 2009: €1,455 million).
 
The deferred tax asset of €902 million includes an amount of €475 million at December 31, 2009 in respect of operating losses which are available to relieve future profits from tax. This deferred tax asset has been recognised on the basis that it is probable it will be recovered as the Directors are satisfied that it is probable that the Group will have sufficient future taxable profits against which the deferred operating losses can be utilised. Under current Irish and UK tax legislation, there is no time restriction on the utilisation of these losses.
 
Deferred tax assets have not been recognised in respect of US tax credits amounting to €1 million, US tax losses of €83 million and US temporary differences of €3 million. €11 million of the US tax losses expire in the period 2020 to 2028 with €72 million due to expire in 2029. There is no expiration date on the tax credits. Deferred tax assets have not been recognised in respect of these items because it is not probable that future taxable profit will be available against which the Group can utilise the benefits.
 
The deferred tax credit in the income statement comprises the following temporary differences:
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Accelerated tax depreciation
    (17 )     (37 )
Pensions and other retirement benefits
    (6 )     (9 )
Other provisions
    30       (2 )
Life companies
    58       (92 )
Other temporary differences
    43       (2 )
Current period losses
    (466 )      
Prior year adjustment
    2       26  
                 
Total deferred tax
    (356 )     (116 )
                 
 
43  RETIREMENT BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS
 
The Group operates a number of defined benefit and defined contribution schemes in Ireland and overseas. The defined benefit schemes are funded and the assets of the schemes are held in separate trustee administered funds. In determining the level of contributions required to be made to each scheme and the relevant charge to the income statement the Group has been advised by independent actuaries, Towers Watson.
 
The most significant defined benefit scheme in the Group is the Bank of Ireland Staff Pension Fund (BSPF) which accounts for approximately 81% of the pension liability on the consolidated Group balance sheet. The BSPF was closed to new members from October 1, 2006, with the exception of a number of new entry-level employees, (who joined from October 1, 2006 to November 21, 2007), who were offered the one-off option to join the scheme. All new employees in the Group from November 21, 2007 are eligible to become members of the Bank of Ireland Group Pension Fund (“The BIGPF”) or the Bank of Ireland Group UK Pension Fund. The BIGPF is a hybrid scheme which includes elements of both a defined benefit and a defined contribution scheme.
 
Retirement benefits under the BSPF and the other defined benefit plans are calculated by reference to pensionable service and pensionable salary at normal retirement date.


F-90


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
43  RETIREMENT BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS  (continued)
 
The last formal valuation of the BSPF, using the projected unit method, was carried out at March 31, 2007. The projected unit method measures liabilities taking account of the projected future levels of pensionable earnings at the time of commencement of benefits i.e. at normal retirement date.
 
The valuation disclosed that the fair value of scheme assets, after allowing for expected future increases in earnings and pensions, represented 109% of the benefits that had accrued to members. The actuary recommended a contribution rate increase of 0.7% of salaries in the funding programme following the conclusion of the valuation. The next formal valuation is being performed as at March 31, 2010 and will be completed during 2010. The BSPF met the statutory funding standard as at March 31, 2007, however the Fund did not meet the statutory funding standard as at March 31, 2009 and as a result the Trustees and the Bank will be putting a proposal to the Pensions Board to address this deficit. On April 7, 2010 the Group announced that it was proposing to make a number of changes affecting pensions benefits. Further information is outlined in note 58 (g).
 
The actuarial valuations are available for inspection to the members of the schemes but are not available for public inspection. The financial assumptions used in deriving the valuation are set out in the table below.
 
Financial assumptions
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
    % per annum   % per annum
 
Irish Schemes
               
Inflation rate
    2.10       2.00  
Discount rate
    5.60       5.95  
Rate of general increase in salaries
    2.73 *     2.62 *
Rate of increase in pensions in payments
    2.49 *     2.40 *
Rate of increase to deferred pensions
    2.10       2.00  
UK Schemes
               
Inflation rate
    3.50       2.75  
Discount rate
    5.70       6.50  
Rate of general increase in salaries
    4.33 *     3.61 *
Rate of increase in pensions in payments
    3.82 *     3.05 *
Rate of increase to deferred pensions
    3.50       2.75  
*     Weighted average increase across all Group schemes.
 
The discount rates for the Irish and UK schemes are based on the iBoxx over 10 year AA-rated Euro corporate bond index and the iBoxx over 15 year AA-rated Sterling corporate bond index respectively.


F-91


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
43  RETIREMENT BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS  (continued)
 
Mortality assumptions
 
In the last quarter of 2008, the Society of Actuaries in Ireland presented the results of their mortality investigations to the Pensions Board. This included an outline for future improvements in life expectancies. The Bank decided to adopt these assumptions for the purposes of calculating the liabilities of all its Republic of Ireland schemes at March 31, 2009. The table below sets out life expectancies based on these assumptions.
 
Post retirement mortality assumptions (Main Scheme)
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009
  2009
    Years   Years
 
Longevity at age 70 for current pensioners
               
Male
    16.7       16.5  
Female
    18.3       18.1  
Longevity at age 60 for active members currently aged 60 years
               
Male
    26.4       26.2  
Female
    28.1       28.0  
Longevity at age 60 for active members currently aged 40 years
               
Male
    29.2       29.0  
Female
    30.4       30.3  
 
The expected long term rates of return and market value of assets of the material defined benefit plans on a combined basis as at December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2009 were as follows:
 
                                                                 
    December 31, 2009
  March 31, 2009
    Expected long term rate of return   Expected long term rate of return
                Market
              Market
    RoI   UK   Fund   Value   RoI   UK   Fund   Value
    %   %   %   €m   %   %   %   €m
 
Equities
    7.25       8.25       54.8       2,047       7.75       8.5       48.2       1,446  
Debt Securities
    4.6       5.0       36.8       1,373       4.6       5.6       40.3       1,210  
Property
    6.3       6.35       6.8       255       6.0       6.2       9.5       285  
Cash and other
    3.0       4.4       1.6       59       3.0       3.5       2.0       62  
                                                                 
Total market value of schemes assets
                            3,734                               3,003  
Actuarial value of liabilities of funded schemes
                            (5,356 )                             (4,472 )
                                                                 
Aggregate deficit in funded schemes
                            (1,622 )                             (1,469 )
Unfunded schemes
                            (9 )                             (9 )
                                                                 
Net defined benefit pension deficit
                            (1,631 )                             (1,478 )
Defined Contribution schemes
                            (1 )                              
                                                                 
                              (1,632 )                             (1,478 )
                                                                 
This is shown in the balance sheet as:-
                            1,638                               1,485  
Retirement benefit obligations
                            (6 )                             (7 )
                                                                 
Retirement benefit asset
                            1,632                               1,478  
                                                                 


F-92


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
43  RETIREMENT BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS  (continued)
 
Substantially all of the scheme assets have been valued on a bid basis.
 
The expected rate of return on individual asset classes is estimated using current and projected economic and market factors at the measurement date, based on the global asset model employed by the Group actuary. The overall expected return on plan assets is based upon the weighted average of the assumed returns on the major asset classes. The expected long term rate of return on the total of the Group schemes assets as at December 31, 2009 is 6.2% (March 31, 2009: 6.3%).
 
The expected returns on the debt securities is derived from gilt yields and corporate bond yields. This has decreased for the UK schemes mainly due to a reduction in UK corporate bond yields. Approximately 65% of the value of debt securities is held in a liability driven investment portfolio.
 
The retirement benefit scheme assets includes Bank of Ireland stock amounting to €3 million (March 31, 2009: €1 million) and property occupied by Bank of Ireland Group companies to the value of €25 million (March 31, 2009: €28 million).
 
The following table sets out the components of the cost of the defined benefit schemes for the period ended December 31, 2009 and the year ended March 31, 2009.
 
Components of pension expenses
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Current service cost
    91       150  
Past service cost
    2       8  
Curtailments
    (3 )      
Expected return on retirement benefit scheme assets
    (142 )     (262 )
Interest cost on pension scheme liabilities
    199       277  
                 
Cost of providing defined retirement benefits
    147       173  
                 
 
Actual return on scheme assets
 
                 
    9 months ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Expected return on scheme assets
    142       262  
Actuarial gain/(loss) on scheme assets
    574       (1,176 )
                 
Actual return on scheme assets
    716       (914 )
                 


F-93


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
43  RETIREMENT BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS  (continued)
 
Movement in defined benefit obligations during the period
 
                 
    9 months ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Defined benefit obligation at beginning of the period
    4,481       4,762  
Current service cost
    91       150  
Actual member contributions
    11       16  
Past service cost
    2       8  
Interest cost
    199       277  
Actuarial loss/(gain) on scheme liabilities
    643       (470 )
Benefits paid
    (100 )     (137 )
Curtailments
    (3 )      
Currency loss/(gain)
    41       (125 )
                 
Defined benefit obligation at the end of the period
    5,365       4,481  
                 
 
Movement in the fair value of scheme assets during the period
 
                 
    9 months ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Fair value of scheme assets at the beginning of the period
    3,003       3,967  
Expected return
    142       262  
Actual member contributions
    11       16  
Actuarial gain/(loss) on scheme assets
    574       (1,176 )
Contributions by employer
    93       114  
Benefits paid
    (100 )     (137 )
Currency gain/(loss)
    11       (43 )
                 
Fair value of scheme assets at the end of the period
    3,734       3,003  
                 
 
Statement of Other Comprehensive Income
 
                 
    9 months
  Year
    ended
  ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Actuarial gain/(loss) on scheme assets
    574       (1,176 )
Experience gain on scheme liabilities
    33       63  
(Loss)/gain on change of assumptions (financial and demographic)
    (676 )     407  
Currency (loss)/gain
    (30 )     82  
                 
Total loss recognised in Other Comprehensive Income during the period before adjustment of tax
    (99 )     (624 )
                 
Cumulative amount of losses recognised in Other Comprehensive Income to the end of period
    (1,085 )     (986 )
                 


F-94


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
43  RETIREMENT BENEFIT OBLIGATIONS  (continued)
 
History of experience gains and losses
 
                                         
    9 month
  Year
  Year
  Year
  Year
    ended
  ended
  ended
  ended
  ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008   2007   2006
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Actuarial gain/(loss) on scheme assets:
                                       
Amount
    574       (1,176 )     (823 )     144       401  
Percentage of scheme assets
    15.4 %     (39.2 %)     (20.7 %)     3.2 %     9.9 %
Experience gain/(loss) on scheme liabilities:
                                       
Amount
    33       63       (58 )     (126 )     (46 )
Percentage of scheme liabilities
    0.6 %     1.4 %     (1.2 %)     (2.5 %)     (0.9 %)
Total actuarial (loss)/gain recognised in SOCI*
                                       
Amount
    (99 )     (624 )     (244 )     213       131  
Percentage of scheme liabilities
    (1.8 %)     (13.9 %)     (5.1 %)     4.2 %     (2.7 %)
*     Statement of Comprehensive Income.
 
Defined benefit pensions
 
                                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008   2007   2006
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Present value of obligations
    5,365       4,481       4,762       5,092       4,878  
Scheme assets
    3,734       3,003       3,967       4,505       4,070  
                                         
Deficit within schemes
    1,631       1,478       795       587       808  
                                         
 
The deficit above includes a deficit of €1,474 million (March 31, 2009: €1,311 million) relating to the defined benefit schemes in the Bank.
 
Expected employer contributions and expected employee contributions for the year ended December 31, 2010 are €120 million and €15 million respectively.
 
Sensitivity analysis for each of the assumptions used to measure the scheme liabilities at December 31, 2009.
 
         
        BSPF
Factor
  Change in assumption   Impact on actuarial liabilities
 
Discount rate
  Decrease 0.1%   Increase 2.1%
Rate of Inflation
  Increase 0.1%   Increase 2.1%
Rate of salary growth
  Increase 0.1%   Increase 0.7%
Life expectancy
  Increase by 1 year   Increase 2.4%
 
While the table above shows the impact of an individual assumption change, a change in one assumption could impact on other assumptions due to the relationship between assumptions.
 
44  CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND COMMITMENTS
 
The table below gives the contract amounts of contingent liabilities and commitments. The maximum exposure to credit loss under contingent liabilities and commitments is the contractual amount of the instrument in the event of non-performance by the other party where all counter claims, collateral or security prove worthless.


F-95


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
44  CONTINGENT LIABILITIES AND COMMITMENTS  (continued)
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Contingent Liabilities
               
Acceptances and endorsements
    27       19  
Guarantees and irrevocable letters of credit
    1,599       1,879  
Other contingent liabilities
    799       670  
                 
      2,425       2,568  
                 
Commitments
               
Documentary credits and short term trade related transactions
    186       260  
Undrawn note issuance and revolving underwriting facilities
    121       157  
Undrawn formal standby facilities, credit lines and other commitments to lend
               
— revocable or irrevocable with original maturity of 1 year or less
    15,837       17,721  
— irrevocable with original maturity of over 1 year
    8,887       8,781  
                 
      25,031       26,919  
                 
 
In common with other banks, the Group conducts business involving acceptances, performance bonds and indemnities. The majority of these facilities are offset by corresponding obligations of third parties.
 
An acceptance is an undertaking by a bank to pay a bill of exchange drawn on a customer. The Group expects most acceptances to be presented, but reimbursement by the customer is normally immediate. Endorsements are residual liabilities of the Group in respect of bills of exchange, which have been paid and subsequently rediscounted.
 
Guarantees and letters of credit are given as security to support the performance of a customer to third parties. As the Group will only be required to meet these obligations in the event of the customer’s default, the cash requirements of these instruments are expected to be considerably below their nominal amounts.
 
Other contingent liabilities primarily include performance bonds and are generally short term commitments to third parties which are not directly dependent on the customers credit worthiness. The Group is party to legal actions arising out of its normal business operations. The Directors believe that adequate provision has been made in respect of this litigation. The other contingent liabilities disclosed include an amount relating to one matter under litigation. This amount has not been separately disclosed as, in line with the exemption in IAS 37, doing so could be prejudicial to the claim and the Group is satisfied that this litigation is not expected to have a significant adverse effect on its financial position.
 
Documentary credits commit the Group to make payments to third parties, on production of documents, which are usually reimbursed immediately by customers.
 
Commitments to lend are agreements to lend to a customer in the future, subject to certain conditions.


F-96


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
45  CAPITAL STOCK
 
Authorised
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
 
    €m       €m  
2,000 (March 31, 2009: 2,000) million units of €0.64 of ordinary stock
    1,280       1,280  
100 million units of non-cumulative preference stock of €1.27 each
    127       127  
100 million units of undesignated preference stock of €0.25 each
    25       25  
3.5 billion units of non-cumulative preference stock (2009 preference stock) of €0.01 each
    35       35  
Stg£
    £m       £m  
100 million units of non-cumulative preference stock of Stg£1 each
    100       100  
100 million units of undesignated preference stock of Stg£0.25 each
    25       25  
US$
    $m       $m  
8 million units of non-cumulative preference stock of US$25 each
    200       200  
100 million units of undesignated preference stock of US$0.25 each
    25       25  
 
Allotted and fully paid
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
993.0 (March 31, 2009: 994.1) million units of €0.64 of ordinary stock
    636       636  
33.2 (March 31, 2009: 32.1) million units of €0.64 of treasury stock
    21       21  
1.9 million units of non-cumulative preference stock of Stg£1 each
    3       3  
3.0 million units of non-cumulative preference stock of €1.27 each
    4       4  
3.5 billion units of non-cumulative preference stock (2009 preference stock) of €0.01 each
    35       35  
                 
      699       699  
                 
 
Ordinary stock
 
The weighted average ordinary stock in issue at December 31, 2009 used in the earnings per share calculation, excludes the treasury stock which does not represent ordinary stock in issue. Treasury stock does not rank for dividend. While own stock held for the benefit of life assurance policyholders legally rank for dividend, in line with accounting standards this dividend does not accrue in the Group financial statements.


F-97


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
45  CAPITAL STOCK  (continued)
 
Movements in issued Ordinary and treasury stock (units)
 
                                 
    Ordinary   Treasury
    December 31,
  March 31,
  December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2009   2009
 
As at the beginning of period
    994,107,002       980,482,472       32,118,677       45,734,778  
Sharesave scheme
    (1,189 )     8,429       1,189        
Long term incentive plan (LTIP)
    6,733             (6,733 )      
Employee stock issue scheme
          4,157,268             (4,157,268 )
Stock sold /purchased and held for the benefit of life assurance policyholders
    (1,110,682 )     9,458,833       1,110,682       (9,458,833 )
                                 
As at end of period
    993,001,864       994,107,002       32,223,815       32,118,677  
                                 
 
At an Extraordinary General Court of the Bank of Ireland held on March 27, 2009, the authorised ordinary stock was increased from 1,500 million units to 2,000 million units at a par value of €0.64 per unit to facilitate the issue of the warrants as part of the National Pensions Reserve Fund Commission (NPRFC) investment as described in Note 45.
 
During the period ended December 31, 2009 the total ordinary stock in issue decreased from 994,107,002 units of nominal value of €0.64 each to 993,001,864 units of nominal value of €0.64 each as a result of:
 
1,189 units of ordinary stock were redeemed due to a correction in relation to the exercise of options under the terms of the SAYE 2003 Scheme at prices of €7.84.
 
6,733 units of ordinary stock were issued under the 1999 Long term Incentive Plan under the matching stock rule.
 
10,104,443 units of ordinary stock held by the Group’s life assurance company as at March 31, 2009 are categorised as “own shares”. 1,110,682 units of ordinary stock were acquired by the life assurance company during the period ended December 31, 2009. At December 31, 2009 the Group’s life assurance company held 11,215,125 units of ordinary stock as “own shares”.
 
All units of ordinary stock in issue carry the same voting rights. All issued stock is fully paid.
 
Further information on changes to the Ordinary Stock since December 31, 2009 is outlined in note 58.
 
Preference Stock — Stg £1 each and €1.27 each
 
The preference stock is non-redeemable. The holders of preference stock are entitled to receive, at the discretion of the Bank, a non-cumulative preferential dividend, which in the case of the Sterling preference stock will be payable in Sterling, in a gross amount of Stg£1.2625 per unit per annum and in the case of euro preference stock will be payable in euro in a gross amount of €1.523686 per unit per annum, in equal semi-annual instalments, in arrears, on February 20 and August 20 in each year.
 
On a winding up of, or other return of capital by, the Bank (other than on a redemption) the holders of preference stock will be entitled to receive an amount equal to the amount paid up on each unit of the preference stock held (including the premium) out of the surplus assets available for distribution to the holders of ordinary stock.
 
The preference stockholders are not entitled to vote at any General Court except in certain exceptional circumstances when a restricted vote may apply.


F-98


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
45  CAPITAL STOCK  (continued)
 
The Bank has an obligation to increase the cash dividend payable on each unit of preference stock so that the sum of the cash dividend paid or payable together with the associated dividend tax credit shall equal the appropriate gross amounts.
 
As at December 31, 2009 and at March 31, 2009, 1,876,090 units of Sterling preference stock and 3,026,598 units of euro preference stock were in issue.
 
2009 Preference Stock
 
For information on the 2009 Preference stock refer to notes 55 and 58.
 
Use of ordinary stock in employee schemes
 
(a)   Employee Stock Issue Scheme
 
At the 2006 Annual General Court the stockholders approved the establishment of a new Employee Stock Issue Scheme to replace the scheme originally approved by the stockholders in 1997. Under this scheme, which has an Irish and a UK version in order to conform with the relevant Revenue legislation in both jurisdictions, all employees in Ireland and the UK are eligible to participate provided that they have been employed by the Group in one of the schemes’ participating companies for the previous financial year and are still employed by the Group on the date the annual results are announced. Each year the Court may set aside an element of Group profit before taxation for allocation to the trustees of the scheme to enable them to acquire units of ordinary stock on behalf of the scheme participants. As a result there was no award in the nine months ended December 31, 2009.
 
Currently the amount set aside is related to overall Group performance. The maximum award permitted under the scheme is 6% of a participant’s salary. To date, annual distributions under the schemes have ranged between nil and 6% of each participants salary.
 
In addition, if an employee elects for the free stock award, they become eligible to purchase additional stock at market price from gross salary subject to Revenue Commissioners and HM Revenue & Customs rules respectively.
 
(b)   Sharesave Scheme (SAYE Scheme)
 
At the 1999 Annual General Court the stockholders approved the establishment of an SAYE Scheme. Under this scheme, which has an Irish and UK version in order to conform with the relevant Revenue legislation in both jurisdictions, all employees in Ireland and the UK are eligible to participate provided that they are employed by the Group on the invitation to participate date and they are still in the employ of the Group on the date that the options are granted. The table below shows the option price for each year, and what discount this represented of the market price at that time.
 
                     
Grant Dates
      SAYE 2007   SAYE 2006   SAYE 2003
 
Option price
    RoI     € 6.96   €12.28   € 7.84
      UK     € 7.43   €13.09   € 8.37
Discount
    RoI     25%   25%   25%
      UK     20%   20%   20%
 
The difference between Irish and UK option prices reflects the maximum discounts permitted under Revenue Commissioners and HM Revenue & Customs rules respectively.
 
For information on the 2009 Preference stock refer to notes 55 and 58.


F-99


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
45  CAPITAL STOCK  (continued)
 
As at December 31, 2009, there are outstanding options under the scheme over 2,069,925 units of ordinary stock of the issued ordinary capital. These options are ordinarily exercisable, provided the participant’s savings contracts are complete between February 2009 and August 2011.
 
                                                         
    RoI   UK    
    2003
  2006
  2007
  2003
  2006
  2007
   
2009
  5 yr1   3 yr   3 yr   5 yr   3 yr   3 yr   Total
 
Outstanding at beginning of period
    1,643,102       635,057       1,961,474       283,187       154,299       354,616       5,031,735  
Granted
                                         
Exercised*
                                         
Lapsed
    (1,610,504 )     (163,985 )     (686,637 )     (281,559 )     (61,835 )     (157,290 )     (2,961,810 )
                                                         
Outstanding at end of period
    32,598       471,072       1,274,837       1,628       92,464       197,326       2,069,925  
                                                         
Weighted average exercise price
  7.84     12.28     6.96     8.37     13.09     7.43     8.50  
                                                         
 
*     No options were exercised in the period to December 31, 2009. (The weighted average market price on the date the options were exercised in the year ended March 31, 2009 was €8.16).
 
Under the terms of the SAYE schemes an individual may defer payments for a period to a maximum of six months. This extends the maturity date of the scheme for that individual. Upon maturity, individuals have up to six months from maturity date to decide if they wish to exercise their options.
 
1   The 2003 5 year SAYE scheme had a general maturity date of February 1, 2009. The maturity date could be extended to August 1, 2009, with a decision to exercise allowed up to February 1, 2010.
 
(c)   Stock Option Scheme
 
Options to subscribe for units of Ordinary Stock are granted under the terms of the Stock Option Scheme. The scheme was approved by the stockholders at the Annual General Court in 1996 — the “Bank of Ireland Group Stock Option Scheme — 1996”, and its successor scheme, the “Bank of Ireland Group Executive Stock Option Scheme — 2004” which was approved by stockholders at the Annual General Court held in 2004. Key executives may participate in the current scheme at the discretion of the Remuneration Committee. Under the current scheme, the total value of options granted may not exceed 100% of an executive’s salary. The subscription price per unit of stock shall not be less than the market value of the stock at the date of grant.
 
The exercise of options granted between 2004 and 2007 is conditional upon underlying earnings per share achieving a cumulative growth of at least 5% per annum compound above the increase in the Consumer Price Index over the three year performance period, commencing with the period in which the options are granted. If this performance condition is not achieved, the options lapse. For options granted in 2008, 25% will become capable of exercise if the Group’s underlying earnings per share growth is 3% per annum compounded, commencing with the period in which the options are granted. The performance conditions for options granted in 1996 up to and including 2005 have been satisfied. Options may not be transferred or assigned and may be exercised only between the third and tenth anniversaries of their grant.
 


F-100


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
45 CAPITAL STOCK  (continued)
 
                                 
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
        Weighted average
      Weighted average
    Number of options   exercise price (€)   Number of options   exercise price (€)
 
Outstanding at beginning of period
    9,367,967     10.85       7,575,585     12.26  
Granted during period
                2,642,600     7.01  
Exercised during period
                       
Expired during period
    (1,417,922 )   13.65       (850,218 )   11.48  
Outstanding at end of period
    7,950,045     10.35       9,367,967     10.85  
Exercisable at end of period
    4,485,663     11.13       4,714,080     10.94  
 
No options were granted during the period ended December 31, 2009.
 
No options were exercised in the period to December 31, 2009 or in the year to March 31, 2009.
 
For information on the 2009 Preference stock refer to notes 55 and 58.
 
 
         
Exercise Price Range (€)
  Number of options
 
 1.22 - 6.96
    678,250  
 6.97 - 10.65
    2,412,432  
10.66 - 10.77
    2,065,499  
10.78 - 15.45
    2,793,864  
         
Total
    7,950,045  
         
 
Outstanding options under the Stock Option Scheme are exercisable at price ranges above. The weighted average remaining contractual life of the outstanding options under the Stock Option Scheme is 1 year.
 
(d)   Long Term Incentive Plan
 
The “Bank of Ireland Group Long Term Incentive Plan — 2004” (‘LTIP’) was approved by the stockholders at the Annual General Court in July 2004. Its predecessor plan, the “Long Term Performance Stock Plan — 1999” (‘LTPSP’), was approved by the stockholders at the Annual General Court in July 1999. The LTIP links the number of units of stock receivable by participants to the Group’s Total Shareholder Return (“TSR”). TSR represents stock price growth plus dividends.
 
Each year selected senior executives participating in the plan receive a conditional award of a number of units of ordinary stock. The maximum award, for Executive Directors and Group Executive Committee members, cannot exceed 100% (150% for the Group CEO) of their annual salary at the time of the award.
 
Provided the Group’s Return on Equity (“ROE”) over the three year performance period is, on average, at least 20%, then the proportion of these units which actually vest in the executive on the third anniversary of the date of

F-101


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
45  CAPITAL STOCK  (continued)
 
the original award is based on the Group’s TSR growth relative to a comparator group of financial services companies, as follows:
 
       
The Bank’s total shareholder return performance relative to
the Comparator Companies
    % of units of stock subject to an award
which may be issued or transferred
Equal to or better than the company ranked second
    100%
Between the company ranked median and
the company ranked second
    Greater than 35% and less than 100%
(Pro rata based on the Bank’s performance
relative to the Comparator Companies)
Equal to the median
    35%
Below median
    Nil
       
 
If the Group’s ROE over the three year performance period, is on average, below 20%, then the award lapses.
 
Under the LTPSP, a minimum of 80% of the vested stock must be retained for two years from maturity of award. After the two year retention period, an additional award of 20% is made. If the award is retained for an additional five years, a further award of 30% is made.
 
                                 
    December 2009   March 2009
    Number of
  Weighted average
  Number of
  Weighted average
    conditional units   grant price (€)   conditional units   grant price (€)
 
Outstanding at beginning of period
    2,488,162       9.86       1,989,005       13.96  
Granted during period
                1,616,200       6.57  
Vested during period
                       
Expired during period
    (744,442 )     13.27       (1,117,043 )     12.40  
Outstanding at end of period
    1,743,720       8.40       2,488,162       9.86  
 
Outstanding conditional units of stock under the LTIP were awarded at prices ranging between €1.215 to €15.45
 
The weighted average remaining contractual life of the outstanding options under the LTIP Scheme is 1 year (the potential matching awards of 30% on the previous LTPSP schemes are excluded from this calculation).
 
For information on the 2009 Preference stock refer to notes 55 and 58.


F-102


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
45  CAPITAL STOCK  (continued)
 
(e)   Options Pricing Model
 
The binomial lattice option valuation model is used to estimate the value of the options granted. The following table details the assumptions used and the resulting fair values provided by the options pricing model. The volatility assumption has been set with reference to the average volatility (based on monthly price changes) measured over a five year period to the date of grant, and our adopted approach is to round this assumption to the nearest 5%, as it represents a subjective long term view of the stability of the business and therefore should not deviate constantly to reflect market fluctuations.
 
                 
    Stock Option Scheme   LTIP
    Granted During Period   Granted During Period
    March 2009   March 2008   March 2009   March 2008
 
Volatility
  20%   20%   20%   20%
Dividend Yield
  5.7%   3.4%   5.7%   3.4%
Risk free rate
  4.4%   4.6%   N/A   N/A
Implied term
  10 years   9.4 years   3 years   3 years
Fair value
  €0.89   €3.06   €2.76   €6.00
Exercise price
  €7.01   €15.45   Nil   Nil
No. of options (000’s)
  2,642.6   1,151.8   1,616.2   580.4
Vesting period
  3 years   3 years   3 years   3 years
 
                 
    SAYE (ROI)
  SAYE (UK)
    3 Year   3 Year
    2007   2006   2007   2006
 
Volatility
  20%   20%   20%   20%
Dividend Yield
  4.2%   3.3%   4.2%   3.3%
Risk free rate
  4.1%   3.8%   4.1%   3.8%
Implied term
  3 years   3 years   3 years   3 years
Fair value
  €2.94   €5.10   €2.62   €4.55
Exercise price
  €6.96   €12.28   €7.43   €13.09
No. of options (000’s)
  3,967.8   2,311.0   811.3   513.6
Vesting period
  3 years   3 years   3 years   3 years
 
         
    SAYE (ROI)
  SAYE (UK)
    5 Year
  5 Year
    2003   2003
 
Volatility
  30%   30%
Dividend Yield
  3.3%   3.3%
Risk free rate
  3.6%   3.6%
Implied term
  5 years   5 years
Fair value
  €3.54   €3.31
Exercise price
  €7.84   €8.37
No. of options (000’s)
  2,209.2   450.9
Vesting period
  5 years   5 years


F-103


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
45  CAPITAL STOCK  (continued)
 
(f)   Limitations on Employee Stock Issue and Stock Option Schemes
 
All of the above stock issue and stock option schemes are subject to a range of flow rate controls approved by the stockholders and which conform to current institutional investor guidelines.
 
46  FAIR VALUES OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES
 
The Group’s accounting policy on valuation is set out on pages F-18 to F-20, while page F-37 gives details on the critical accounting estimates and judgements made by management in relation to the fair value of financial instruments. The fair value of a financial instrument is defined as the amount for which an asset could be exchanged, or a liability settled, in an arms length transaction between knowledgeable willing parties.
 
Where possible, the Group calculates fair value using observable market prices. Where market prices are not available, fair values are determined using valuation techniques which may include discounted cash flow models or comparisons to instruments with characteristics either identical or similar to those of the instruments held by the Group.
 
These techniques are subjective in nature and involve assumptions which are based upon management’s view of market conditions at period end which may not necessarily be indicative of any subsequent fair value. Furthermore, minor changes in the assumptions used could have a significant impact on the resulting estimated fair values, and, as a result, readers of these financial statements are advised to use caution when using this data to evaluate the Group’s financial position.
 
The concept of fair value assumes realisation of financial instruments by way of a sale. However, in many cases, particularly in respect of loans and advances to customers, the Group intends to realise assets through collection over time. As such the fair values calculated do not represent the value of the Group as a going concern at December 31, 2009 or March 31, 2009.
 
(a)   Financial assets and liabilities recognised and subsequently measured at fair value
 
All financial instruments are initially recognised at fair value. The Group subsequently measures trading securities, other financial assets and liabilities designated at fair value through profit or loss, derivatives and available for sale financial assets at fair value in the balance sheet. These instruments are shown as “at fair value through profit or loss (FVTPL)” or “at fair value through Other Comprehensive Income (OCI)” in note 47 on the measurement basis of financial assets and liabilities. A description of the methods and assumptions used to calculate fair values of these assets and liabilities is set out below.
 
Financial assets held for trading
 
These instruments are valued using observable market prices where available. Trading securities quoted in an active market are valued directly from observable market prices through a recognised pricing source or an independent broker or investment bank.
 
For the small number of trading securities where observable market prices are unavailable, fair value is calculated using discounted cash flow models. Using reasonably possible alternative assumptions would not change the fair value of these securities significantly.
 
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
 
These consist of assets designated at fair value through profit or loss, which are predominantly held for the benefit of unit linked policyholders, with any changes in valuation accruing to the policyholders. These assets consist principally of bonds, equities and unit trusts, which are traded on listed exchanges, are actively traded and have


F-104


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
46  FAIR VALUES OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
readily available prices. The remaining assets are valued using valuation techniques which use observable market data.
 
Derivative financial instruments
 
The Group’s derivative financial instruments are valued using valuation techniques commonly used by market participants. These consist of discounted cash flow and options pricing models, which typically incorporate observable market data, principally interest rates, basis spreads, foreign exchange rates, equity prices and counterparty credit. A small number of derivative financial instruments are valued using non-observable inputs. However, changing one or more assumptions used in the valuation of these derivatives would not have a significant impact as they are entered into to hedge the exposure arising on certain customer accounts (see below), leaving the Group with no net valuation risk due to the non-observable inputs.
 
Assets and liabilities held for sale to NAMA — derivatives
 
In the case of derivatives held for sale to NAMA, counterparty credit is not considered observable and is significant to their valuation. The effect of changing the assumptions in relation to counterparty credit to a range of reasonably possible alternatives would be to increase the fair value of these derivatives by up to €13 million or to decrease their fair value by up to €13 million, with a corresponding impact on the income statement.
 
Debt securities in issue and subordinated liabilities
 
These instruments comprise debt securities in issue and subordinated liabilities with a fair value of €701 million (March 31, 2009: €795 million) which are measured at fair value through profit or loss, the fair value of which is based on valuation techniques incorporating significant unobservable market data. The significant unobservable input is the Group’s credit spread, the estimation of which has become more judgemental in current market circumstances. The Group estimates this spread by reference to recent transactions in the same instrument or in similar instruments issued by the Group.
 
The effect of changing the estimated credit spread on subordinated liabilities to a reasonably possible alternative would be to decrease their fair value by up to €22 million with a corresponding impact on the income statement. The effect of changing the estimated credit spread on the debt securities in issue to a range of reasonably possible alternatives would be to decrease their fair value by up to €13 million or to increase their fair value by up to €6 million, with a corresponding impact on the income statement.
 
Available for sale financial assets
 
For available for sale financial assets for which an active market exists, fair value has been determined directly from observable market prices or yields through a recognised pricing source or an independent broker, price-provider or investment bank.
 
A small number of bonds have been valued using vendor prices, which are not considered to represent observable market data. The effect of using reasonably possible alternative assumptions would be to decrease their fair value by up to €6 million or to increase their fair value by up to €6 million, with a corresponding impact on the statement of other comprehensive income.
 
Customer accounts
 
Customer accounts designated at fair value through profit or loss consist of deposits which contain an embedded derivative (typically an equity option). These instruments are typically valued using valuation techniques which use observable market data. The impact of changes in the Group’s own credit spread is not significant to the fair value of


F-105


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
46  FAIR VALUES OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
these deposits. A small number of customer accounts are valued using non-observable inputs. However, changing one or more assumptions used in the valuation of these customer accounts would not have a significant impact as these customer accounts are hedged with offsetting derivatives (see above), leaving the Group with no net valuation risk due to the non-observable inputs.
 
Liabilities to customers under insurance and investment contracts
 
The accounting policy for these instruments is set out on pages F-30 and F-31. In accordance with the accounting policy, the fair value of liabilities to customers under both insurance and investment unit linked contracts is contractually linked to the fair value of the financial assets within the policyholders’ unit linked funds. The value of the unit linked financial liabilities is determined using current unit prices multiplied by the number of units attributed to the contract holders at the balance sheet date. Their value is never less than the amount payable on surrender, discounted for the required notice period where applicable.
 
(b)   Financial assets and liabilities not subsequently measured at fair value
 
For financial assets and liabilities which are not subsequently measured at fair value on the balance sheet, the Group discloses their fair value in a way that permits them to be compared to their carrying amounts. The methods and assumptions used to calculate the fair values of these assets and liabilities are set out below.
 
Loans and advances to banks
 
The estimated fair value of floating rate placements and overnight placings is their carrying amount. The estimated fair value of fixed interest bearing placements is based on discounted cash flows using prevailing money market interest rates for assets with similar credit risk and remaining maturity.
 
Loans and advances to customers
 
Loans and advances are carried net of provisions for impairment. The fair value of both fixed and variable rate loans and advances to customers is calculated using a valuation technique which involves the discounting of estimated future cash flows at current market rates, incorporating the impact of current credit spreads and margins. The fair value reflects both loan impairments at the balance sheet date and estimates of market participants’ expectations of credit losses over the life of the loans.
 
Assets held for sale to NAMA
 
The assets held for sale to NAMA are measured on the same basis in the balance sheet as prior to their classification as held for sale. On transfer to NAMA, these assets will be valued on a loan-by-loan basis, using the valuation methodology specified in the NAMA Act and in the associated regulations. As set out on page F-61, the Group is currently unable to accurately quantify the ultimate expected loss on the transfer of all the Group’s Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA. The discount to gross loan value that was incurred on the first tranche of loans to transfer to NAMA in early April 2010 is 36%. For the purposes of presenting a fair value of the total portfolio of assets held for sale to NAMA, the Group has applied this 36% discount to all assets. The limited number and nature of the loans involved in this first tranche mean that it may not be a representative sample of the total portfolio of assets held for sale to NAMA and consequently the loss on sale is not necessarily indicative of the loss that is expected to arise on the entire portfolio of Eligible Bank Assets that will ultimately transfer. As the assets held for sale to NAMA are financial instruments, they are carried at amortised cost less impairment provisions.


F-106


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
46  FAIR VALUES OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
Deposits from banks and customer accounts
 
The estimated fair value of deposits with no stated maturity, which includes non-interest bearing deposits, is the amount repayable on demand. The estimated fair value of fixed interest bearing deposits and other borrowings without quoted market prices is based on discounted cash flows using interest rates for new deposits with similar remaining maturity.
 
Debt securities in issue and subordinated liabilities
 
The fair values of these instruments are calculated based on quoted market prices where available. For those notes where quoted market prices are not available, a discounted cash flow model is used based on a current yield curve appropriate to the Group for the remaining term to maturity. The yield curve used incorporates the effect of changes in the Group’s own credit spread.
 
Fair value hierarchy
 
The table below shows, for the Group’s financial assets and liabilities that are recognised and subsequently measured at fair value, their classification within a three-level fair value hierarchy.
 
Level 1 comprises financial assets and liabilities valued using quoted market prices in active markets. An active market is one in which transactions occur with sufficient volume and frequency to provide pricing information on an ongoing basis.
 
Level 2 comprises financial assets and liabilities valued using techniques based significantly on observable market data.
 
Level 3 comprises financial assets and liabilities valued using techniques where the impact of the non-observable market data is significant in determining the fair value of the instrument. Non-observable market data is not readily available in an active market due to market illiquidity or complexity of the product. These inputs are generally determined based on observable inputs of a similar nature, historic observations on the level of the input or analytical techniques.
 


F-107


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
46 FAIR VALUES OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
                                 
December 31, 2009
  Level 1   Level 2   Level 3   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Financial assets held at fair value
                               
Trading securities
    403                   403  
Derivative financial instruments
          5,788       36       5,824  
Assets held for sale to NAMA — derivatives
                93       93  
Other financial assets at FVTPL
    8,987       692             9,679  
AFS financial assets
    18,921       1,687       332       20,940  
                                 
      28,311       8,167       461       36,939  
                                 
As a % of fair value assets
    76.7 %     22.1 %     1.2 %     100 %
                                 
Financial liabilities held at fair value
                               
Deposits from banks
          2             2  
Customer accounts
          1,658       62       1,720  
Derivative financial instruments
          6,017       20       6,037  
Liabilities held for sale to NAMA — derivatives
                1       1  
Liabilities to customers under investment contracts
          5,050             5,050  
Insurance contract liabilities
          6,658             6,658  
Debt securities in issue
                472       472  
Subordinated liabilities
                229       229  
                                 
            19,385       784       20,169  
                                 
As a % of fair value liabilities
          96.1 %     3.9 %     100 %
                                 

F-108


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
46  FAIR VALUES OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
Movements in Level 3 assets
 
                                         
        Derivatives
  Derivates held
  Available for
   
    Trading
  financial
  for sale to
  sale financial
   
December 31, 2009
  securities   instruments   NAMA   assets   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Opening balance
    7       116             403       526  
Total gains or losses in:-
                                       
— Profit or loss
                                       
— Net trading expense
          (27 )                 (27 )
— Other income
                      2       2  
— Other Comprehensive income
                      4       4  
Additions
                      102       102  
Disposals
                      (216 )     (216 )
Redemptions
          (53 )           (31 )     (84 )
Transfer out of level 3
                                       
— from level 3 to level 1
    (7 )                 (14 )     (21 )
— from level 3 to level 2
                      (2 )     (2 )
Transfer into level 3
                                       
— from level 1 to level 3
                             
— from level 2 to level 3
                93       84       177  
                                         
Closing balance
          36       93       332       461  
                                         
Total gains/(losses) for the period included in the profit or loss for assets held in level 3 at the end of the reporting period
          (26 )     (55 )     2       (79 )
                                         
Other transfers
                                       
— from level 1 to level 2
    9                   255       264  
                                         
— from level 2 to level 1
                      152       152  
                                         
 
The above table has been prepared in compliance with IFRS 7 (amended). Consequently, the opening balances of level 3 assets are not directly comparable to the Group’s previously published fair value table.
 
Transfers from level 3 to level 1 resulted from an ability to obtain observable market prices in the current period which were unavailable in the prior year.
 
The transfer of derivatives held for sale to NAMA from level 2 to level 3 resulted from the unobservable inputs becoming significant to their fair value measurement.
 
The transfer of AFS assets from level 2 to level 3 resulted from inputs which were observable at March 31, 2009 becoming unobservable in the current period.


F-109


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
46  FAIR VALUES OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
Movements in Level 3 liabilities
 
                                                 
        Derivatives
  Derivates held
  Debt
       
    Customer
  financial
  for sale to
  securities in
  Subordinated
   
December 31, 2009
  accounts   instruments   NAMA   issue   liabilities   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Opening balance
    69       56             566       229       920  
Total gain or loss in:
                                               
— Profit or loss
                                               
— Net trading expense
    1       (23 )           (28 )     20       (30 )
— Other Comprehensive income
                            (20 )     (20 )
New derivative transactions
          10                         10  
Redemption and maturities
    (8 )     (23 )           (66 )           (97 )
Transfer into level 3
                                               
— from level 2 to level 3
                1                   1  
                                                 
Closing balance
    62       20       1       472       229       784  
                                                 
Total gains/(losses) for the period included in profit or loss for liabilities held at the end of the reporting period
    (1 )     13             (16 )     (20 )     (24 )
                                                 
 
The above table has been prepared in compliance with IFRS 7 (amended). Consequently, the opening balances of level 3 liabilities are not directly comparable to the Group’s previously published fair value table.
 
There were no transfers out of level 3 during the nine months ended December 31, 2009.
 
There were no transfers to level 3 from level 1. The only transfer into level 3 from level 2 was in relation to derivative liabilities held for sale to NAMA.
 
The transfer of derivatives held for sale to NAMA from level 2 to level 3 resulted from the unobservable inputs becoming significant to the fair value measurement.


F-110


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
46  FAIR VALUES OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
The carrying amount and the fair value of the Group’s financial assets and liabilities as at December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2009 are set out in the table below.
 
                                 
    December 2009   March 2009
    Carrying
  Fair
  Carrying
  Fair
    amount   values   amount   values
    €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Financial instruments held for trading
                               
Debt securities(1)
    403       403       125       125  
Derivative financial instruments — trading
                               
Foreign exchange contracts(1)
    (199 )     (199 )     184       184  
Interest rate contracts(1)
    (184 )     (184 )     149       149  
Equity and commodity contracts(1)
    25       25       (50 )     (50 )
Non-trading financial instruments
                               
Assets
                               
Cash and balances at central banks(1)
    4,241       4,241       3,224       3,224  
Items in course of collection from other banks(1)
    400       400       515       515  
Loans and advances to banks
    5,031       5,028       7,886       7,879  
Loans and advances to customers
    119,439       116,846       133,740       128,938  
Assets held for sale to NAMA(2)
    9,581       7,910              
Available for sale financial assets(1)
    20,940       20,940       26,858       26,858  
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss(1)
    9,679       9,679       7,604       7,604  
Liabilities
                               
Deposits from banks
    17,903       17,829       28,814       28,742  
Customer accounts
    84,812       84,680       83,119       83,001  
Items in the course of transmission to other banks(1)
    198       198       238       238  
Debt securities in issue
    43,144       41,419       45,133       44,375  
Liabilities to customers under investment contracts(1)
    5,050       5,050       4,084       4,084  
Insurance contract liabilities(1)
    6,658       6,658       5,634       5,634  
Subordinated liabilities
    6,053       4,585       7,942       4,089  
Liabilities held for sale to NAMA(2)
    1       1              
Derivative financial instruments — hedging
                               
Interest rate contracts and foreign exchange contracts(1)
    (145 )     (145 )     560       560  
 
 
(1) The fair value of these financial instruments is equal to the carrying value. These instruments are either carried at market value or have minimal credit losses and are either short term in nature or repriced frequently.
 
(2) As set out on page F-71, the Group is currently unable to accurately quantify the ultimate expected loss on the transfer of all the Group’s Eligible Bank Assets to NAMA. The discount to gross loan value that will be incurred on the first tranche of loans to transfer to NAMA in early April 2010 is 36%. For the purposes of presenting a fair value of the total portfolio of assets held for sale to NAMA, the Group has applied this 36% discount to the loans held for sale to NAMA. The limited number and nature of the loans involved in this first tranche mean that it may not be a representative sample of the total portfolio of assets held for sale to NAMA and consequently the loss on sale is not necessarily indicative of the loss that is expected to arise on the entire portfolio of Eligible Bank Assets that will ultimately transfer. As the loans held for sale to NAMA are financial instruments, they are carried at amortised cost less impairment provisions. Accounting standards require that additional disclosure is provided of the fair value of such assets at the balance sheet date.


F-111


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
47  MEASUREMENT BASIS OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES
 
The table below analyses the carrying amounts of the financial assets and liabilities by accounting treatment and by balance sheet heading.
 
At December 31, 2009
 
                                                                 
        At fair value through
           
        Other
           
    At fair value through
  Comprehensive
           
    profit or loss   income (OCI)            
    Derivatives
                  Loans and
       
    designated
                  advances/
       
    as fair value
      Designated
      Cash flow
  held at
       
    hedging
  Held for
  upon initial
  Available
  hedge
  amortised
  Insurance
   
    instruments   trading   recognition   for sale   derivatives   cost   contracts   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Financial assets
                                                               
Cash and balances at central banks
                                  4,241             4,241  
Items in the course of collection from other banks
                                  400             400  
Trading securities
          403                                     403  
Derivative financial instruments
    740       3,344                   1,740                   5,824  
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
                9,679                               9,679  
Loans and advances to banks
                                  5,031             5,031  
Available for sale financial assets
                      20,940                         20,940  
Loans and advances to customers
                                  119,439             119,439  
Assets held for sale to NAMA
          93                         9,488             9,581  
                                                                 
Total financial assets
    740       3,840       9,679       20,940       1,740       138,599             175,538  
                                                                 
Financial liabilities
                                                               
Deposits from banks
                2                   17,901             17,903  
Customer accounts
                1,720                   83,092             84,812  
Items in course of transmission to other banks
                                  198             198  
Derivative financial instruments
    598       3,702                   1,737                   6,037  
Liabilities to customers under investment contracts
                5,050                               5,050  
Debt securities in issue
                472                   42,672             43,144  
Insurance contract liabilities
                                        6,658       6,658  
Subordinated liabilities
                229                   5,824             6,053  
Liabilities held for sale to NAMA
          1                                     1  
                                                                 
Total financial liabilities
    598       3,703       7,473             1,737       149,687       6,658       169,856  
                                                                 


F-112


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
47  MEASUREMENT BASIS OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
At March 31, 2009
 
                                                                 
        At fair value through
           
        Other
           
    At fair value through
  Comprehensive
           
    profit or loss   income (OCI)            
    Derivatives
                  Loans and
       
    designated
                  advances/
       
    as fair value
      Designated
      Cash flow
  held at
       
    hedging
  Held for
  upon initial
  Available
  hedge
  amortised
  Insurance
   
    instruments   trading   recognition   for sale   derivatives   cost   contracts   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Financial assets
                                                               
Cash and balances at central banks
                                  3,224             3,224  
Items in the course of collection from other banks
                                  515             515  
Trading securities
          125                                     125  
Derivative financial instruments
    915       4,720       27             2,735                   8,397  
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
                7,604                               7,604  
Loans and advances to banks
                                  7,886             7,886  
Available for sale financial assets
                      26,858                         26,858  
Loans and advances to customers
                                  133,740             133,740  
                                                                 
Total financial assets
    915       4,845       7,631       26,858       2,735       145,365             188,349  
                                                                 
Financial liabilities
                                                               
Deposits from banks
                92                   28,722             28,814  
Customer accounts
                2,006                   81,113             83,119  
Items in course of transmission to other banks
                                  238             238  
Derivative financial instruments
    611       4,468                   2,475                   7,554  
Liabilities to customers under investment contracts
                4,084                               4,084  
Debt securities in issue
                566                   44,567             45,133  
Insurance contract liabilities
                                        5,634       5,634  
Subordinated liabilities
                229                   7,713             7,942  
                                                                 
Total financial liabilities
    611       4,468       6,977             2,475       162,353       5,634       182,518  
                                                                 


F-113


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
47  MEASUREMENT BASIS OF FINANCIAL ASSETS AND LIABILITIES  (continued)
 
The fair value and contractual amount due on maturity of financial liabilities designated at fair value upon initial recognition are shown in the table below.
 
                                 
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
        Contractual
      Contractual
        amount due
      amount due
    Fair values   on maturity   Fair values   on maturity
    €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Deposits from banks
    2       2       92       92  
Customer accounts
    1,720       1,775       2,006       2,085  
Liabilities to customers under investment contracts
    5,050       5,050       4,084       4,084  
Debt securities in issue
    472       494       566       526  
Subordinated liabilities
    229       264       229       240  
                                 
Financial liabilities designated at fair value through profit or loss
    7,473       7,585       6,977       7,027  
                                 
 
For financial assets and liabilities which are recognised and subsequently measured at fair value through profit or loss or through other comprehensive income, a description of the methods and assumptions used to calculate those fair values is set out in note 46.
 
48  CASH AND CASH EQUIVALENTS
 
For the purposes of the cash flow statement, cash and cash equivalents comprises the following balances:
 
                         
    December 31,
  March 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009   2008
    €m   €m   €m
 
Cash and balances at central banks
    4,241       3,224       484  
Loans and advances to banks (with an original maturity of less than 3 months)
    4,946       4,035       7,153  
Central government and other eligible bills
                10  
                         
Cash and cash equivalents
    9,187       7,259       7,647  
                         
 
49  GENERAL
 
(a)   The Bank is domiciled in the Republic of Ireland.
 
(b)   The Bank has given a letter of comfort to the regulatory authority of the Isle of Man in respect of its banking subsidiary Bank of Ireland (IOM) Limited for the protection of the depositors of that subsidiary.
 
(c)   The Bank has provided a guarantee under Section 17 of the Companies (Amendment) Act, 1986 for the following companies: Premier Direct Management Limited, Premier Direct Insurance Services Limited, Tustin Limited, Hill Wilson Secretarial Limited, Bank of Ireland Insurance Services Limited, Bank of Ireland Asset Management (US) Limited, Bank of Ireland Asset Management Limited, Bank of Ireland Car Loans Limited, Bank of Ireland Commercial Finance Limited, Bank of Ireland International Finance Limited, Bank of Ireland Outsourcing Services Limited, Bank of Ireland Unit Trust Managers Limited, Bushfield Leasing Limited, Clonvern Limited, Edendork Leasing Limited, First Rate Enterprises Limited, Florenville Limited, IBI Corporate Finance Limited, Nerling Limited, Nestland Limited.


F-114


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
50  RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
 
The parent company of the Group is the Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland (referred to throughout as the “Bank”), which is a corporation established in Ireland in 1783 under Royal Charter with primary listings on both the Irish and London Stock Exchanges.
 
A number of banking transactions are entered into between the Governor and Company and its subsidiaries in the normal course of business. These include loans, deposits and foreign currency transactions.
 
(a)   Associates and joint ventures
 
The Group provides and receives from its associates and joint ventures certain banking and financial services on similar terms to third party transactions which are not material to the Group. These include loans deposits and foreign currency transactions.
 
(b)   Irish Government
 
During the year ended March 31, 2009, the Irish Government through both the Bank’s participation in the Government Guarantee Scheme and the recapitalisation through the NPRFC became a related party of the Bank. For further details on the Government Guarantee Scheme and on the recapitalisation see note 55.
 
On February 22, 2010 ordinary stock was issued to the NPRFC. Information on this post balance sheet event is shown in note 58.
 
Since March 2010 a number of transactions have occurred relating to the Irish Government. These comprise:-
 
•   conversion of a portion of 2009 preference stock to Ordinary Stock (NPRFC Placing) and associated Rights Issue and
 
•   cancellation of the warrants
 
Further information on these is outlined in note 58 (i).
 
Although there are other arms of the Irish Government with which the Bank has a related party relationship, these are not disclosed as they are in the ordinary course of business, were in place prior to the Irish Government becoming a related party of the Bank and the information is not material on a quantitative or qualitative basis, either separately or in aggregate.
 
National Asset Management Agency (NAMA): please see note 26 for details on NAMA.
 
National Asset Management Agency Investment Limited (NAMAIL)
 
On March 30, 2010, the Group, through its wholly-owned subsidiary New Ireland Assurance Company plc, acquired 17 million B shares in NAMAIL, corresponding to one-third of the 51 million B shares issued by NAMAIL. The balance of the B shares are held in equal proportion by Irish Life Assurance and major pension and institutional clients of AIB Investment Managers. The cost to the Group of acquiring these B shares was €17 million. NAMAIL have also issued the 49 million A shares to NAMA. As a result the Group will hold 17 per cent of the total ordinary share capital of NAMAIL. NAMAIL is expected to be a holding company and its subsidiaries are expected to be the entities to which NAMA Participating Institutions will transfer Eligible Bank Assets.
 
The A shares and B shares generally rank equally, except as otherwise provided in the Articles of Association of NAMAIL. NAMA may appoint up to six directors to the board of NAMAIL. In total, the B shareholders may also jointly appoint up to six directors. As holder of the A shares, NAMA has veto rights in relation to: the declaration of dividends; the appointment or removal of directors; the exercise of voting rights in respect of any subsidiary of


F-115


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
50  RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS  (continued)
 
NAMAIL and the appointment of a Chairman. In addition NAMA can veto any actions by NAMAIL, which NAMA considers in any manner to be inconsistent with its objectives. A holder of the B shares may not sell the shares without the consent of NAMA.
 
A discretionary non-cumulative dividend on the capital invested may be paid on an annual basis and this is limited to the yield on ten year Irish government bonds. On a winding-up, the return on B shares is capped at 110 per cent of the capital invested, (€18.7 million in the case of the Group), and the maximum loss that may be suffered is limited to the original amount invested (€17 million in the case of the Group).
 
The Group had no involvement with NAMAIL prior to March 30, 2010.
 
(c)   Pension funds
 
The Group provides a number of normal banking and financial services to various pension funds operated by the Group for the benefit of its employees (principally for the Bank Staff Pension Fund (“BSPF”)), which are conducted on similar terms to third party transactions and which are not material to the Group. Further details on retirement benefit obligations are set out in note 43.
 
The Group occupies a number of premises owned by the Group’s various pension schemes; the total value of these properties at December 31, 2009 is €25 million (March 31, 2009: €28 million).
 
The total rental income paid to the Group’s pension scheme during the nine months ended December 31, 2009 was €1.6 million (March 31, 2009: €2.5 million, March 31, 2008: €1.9 million).
 
During the nine months ended December 31, 2009, fees of €3.8 million (year ended March 31, 2009: €4.8 million, year ended March 31, 2008: €6.1 million) were paid to the Group by the BSPF.
 
At December 31, 2009 €2,604 million (March 31, 2009: €2,102 million) of the BSPF assets were managed by Bank of Ireland Asset Management Limited.
 
(d)   Transactions with Key Management Personnel
 
The following information is presented in accordance with the Companies Act 1990 (as amended by the Companies (Amendment) Act 2009). For the purposes of the Companies Act disclosures, Directors are the Court of Directors and any past Directors who were Directors during the relevant period. For the purposes of IAS 24 Related Party Disclosures, “key management personnel” (KMP) comprise the Directors of the Court, the members of the Group Executive Committee (GEC), the Group Secretary and the Group Legal Adviser (for part of the relevant period) and any past KMP who was a KMP during the relevant period. In addition to the Executive Directors, the GEC comprises the Group Chief Governance Risk Officer, the Chief Credit and Market Risk Officer, the Head of Group HR and the Head of Group Manufacturing.
 
Directors’ emoluments are set out in the Directors interest note 54 and details of compensation paid to key management personnel are provided below.


F-116


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
50  RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS  (continued)
 
 
Companies Acts disclosure
 
                         
            **†Aggregate maximum
            amount
            outstanding during the
    Balance as at
  (2)Balance as at
  9 months ended
Loans
  April 1, 2009   December 31, 2009   December 31, 2009
    €’000   €’000   €’000
 
Current Directors
                       
R Boucher
                       
Mortgage total
    257       235       257  
Other loans total*
    758       708       758  
Credit cards total
          3       13  
                         
Total
    1,015       946       1,028  
                         
T Considine
                       
Credit cards total
    1       1       4  
                         
Total
    1       1       4  
                         
D Crowley
                       
Mortgage total
    642       614       642  
Other loans total
    25       18       25  
Credit cards total(1)*
    3       14       36  
Current account total(1)
                2  
                         
Total
    670       646       705  
                         
D Donovan
                       
Credit cards total
    2             2  
                         
Total
    2             2  
                         
P Haran
                       
Mortgage total
    131       120       131  
Credit cards total
          2       9  
Current account total
                1  
                         
Total
    131       122       141  
                         
J Kennedy
                       
Mortgage total
    1,299       1,301       1,301  
Other loans total
    135       98       135  
Credit cards total
                4  
Current account total
                2  
                         
Total
    1,434       1,399       1,442  
                         
 
 
Currency converted at April 1, 2009 rate, December 31, 2009 rate and average rate for the nine month period.
 
1. On terms similar to those available to staff generally.
 
2. Balance includes principal and interest.
 
**† Items explained on page F-120.


F-117


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
50  RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS  (continued)
 
 
Companies Acts disclosure
 
                         
            **†Aggregate maximum
            amount
            outstanding during the
    Balance as at
  (2)Balance as at
  9 months ended
Loans
  April 1, 2009   December 31, 2009   December 31, 2009
    €’000   €’000   €’000
 
D McCourt
                       
Mortgage total
    346       348       348  
Other loans total
    44       45       45  
Credit cards total
          3       3  
                         
Total
    390       396       396  
                         
H A McSharry
                       
Mortgage total
    139       120       139  
Credit cards total
    2       5       5  
                         
Total
    141       125       144  
                         
P Molloy
                       
Other loans total
    500       500       500  
Credit cards total(1)
    6       7       7  
                         
Total
    506       507       507  
                         
T Neill
                       
Credit cards total
    1       3       11  
                         
Total
    1       3       11  
                         
J O’ Donovan
                       
Credit cards total(1)
    2       2       4  
                         
Total
    2       2       4  
                         
J Walsh
                       
Credit cards total
    2       1       5  
                         
Total
    2       1       5  
                         
Past Directors
                       
R Burrows
                       
Credit cards total
    5             5  
Current Account total(1)
                14  
                         
Total
    5             19  
                         
G Magan
                       
Other loans total*
    2,149       2,255       2,260  
Credit cards total
    1             4  
                         
Total
    2,150       2,255       2,264  
                         


F-118


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
50  RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS  (continued)
 
Other than as indicated, all loans to Directors are made in the ordinary course of business on substantially the same terms, including interest rates and collateral, as those prevailing at the time for comparable transactions with other persons and do not involve more than the normal risk of collectability or present other unfavourable features.
 
D Dilger, D Holt, R Hynes and P O’Sullivan had no loans with the Group during the nine months ended December 31, 2009.
 
 
Currency converted at April 1, 2009 rate, December 31, 2009 rate and average rate for the nine month period.
 
1. On terms similar to those available to staff generally.
 
2. Balance includes principal and interest.
 
**† Items explained on page F-120.
 
                         
        **†Maximum
   
        amounts outstanding
   
        during the
  Number of persons
    Balance as at
  months ended
  as at December 31,
    December 31, 2009   December 31, 2009   2009
    €’000   €’000    
 
Connected Persons (3) of the following directors:
                       
D Crowley
    3       3       1  
P Molloy
    1       7       2  
 
The above arrangements are on favourable terms similar to those available to staff generally.
 
 
3. Connected persons of Directors are defined by Section 26 of the Companies Act 1990 as the Director’s spouse, parent, brother, sister, child, a trustee where the beneficiaries of the trust are the director, his spouse, children or a company which the Director controls, or a company controlled by the director or a person in partnership within the meaning of the Partnership Act 1890.
 
**† Items explained on page F-120.
 
All Directors have other transactions with the Bank. The nature of these transactions includes investments, pension funds, deposits, life assurance and current accounts with credit balances. The balances on these accounts are included in the aggregate figure for deposits on the following page.
 
Guarantees amounting to €1.14 million at December 31, 2009 (the comparative figure for March 31, 2009 has been adjusted from €0.85 million to €1.14 million) in favour of the Group have been entered into by three Directors and the Group has entered into guarantees in favour of two Directors amounting to €0.08 million at December 31, 2009 (the comparative figure for March 31, 2009 has been adjusted from €0.05 million to €0.13 million). The Group has entered into a guarantee in favour of a) a business entity of one Director amounting to €0.80 million which is backed by collateral in the form of a cash deposit amounting to €0.80 million and b) the connected person of one Director amounting to €0.02 million (the comparative figure for March 31, 2009 has been adjusted from nil to €0.02 million). There were no calls on these guarantees during the period March 31, 2009 and December 31, 2009.
 
There are no provisions in respect of any failure or anticipated failure to repay any of the above loans or interest thereon. There is no interest which having fallen due on the above loans has not been paid.
 
IAS 24 “Related party disclosures”
 
Key management personnel including Directors hold products with Group companies in the ordinary course of business. All loans to Non-Executive Directors are made in the ordinary course of business on substantially the


F-119


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
50  RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS  (continued)
 
same terms (except as indicated by 1 above), including interest rates and collateral, as those prevailing at the time for comparable transactions with other persons, and do not involve more than the normal risk of collectability or present other unfavourable features (except as indicated by 1 above). Loans to key management personnel other than Non-Executive Directors are made on terms similar to those available to staff generally and / or in the ordinary course of business on normal commercial terms.
 
The aggregate amounts outstanding and the number of persons concerned, in respect of all loans, quasi-loans and credit transactions between the Bank and its key management personnel, as defined above, including members of their close families and entities influenced by them together with the disclosure of the year end balances and maximum amounts outstanding during the year are shown in the table on the following page.
 
IAS 24 Disclosure
 
                                         
            **†Maximum
       
            amounts
      Number of
        Balance as at
  outstanding
  Number of
  persons as at
Key Management
  Balance as at
  December 31,
  during the
  persons as at
  December 31,
Personnel
  April 1, 2009   2009   period   April 1, 2009   2009
    €’000   €’000   €’000        
 
Loans
    9,301       10,458       11,551       20       22  
Deposits
    17,991       20,514       32,584       21       26  
 
 
†  These figures include credit card exposures at the maximum statement balance. In all cases key management personnel have not exceeded their approved limits. The maximum approved credit limit on any credit card held by key management personnel is €30,000.
 
** The maximum amount outstanding was calculated using the maximum balance on each account. The single highest maximum outstanding liability during the year ended December 31, 2009 for any member of key management personnel did not exceed €2.3 million. In some cases with credit transactions (i.e. funds based products, life assurance and other policies) the maximum balance amounts were not available and the greater of the balance at the start of the period and the balance at the end of the period has been included as the maximum balance amount. The closing balance includes interest accrued and interest paid, the maximum balance includes interest paid.
 
The comparative figure for loans has been adjusted from €8.327 million to €9.301 million. The comparative figure for deposits has also been adjusted from €14.548 million to €17.991 million. This restatement arises as a result of improvements to the bank’s procedures for identification of balances relating to persons or entities connected to Directors.
 
Included in the above figures are loans to key management personnel (other than Non-Executive Directors) on terms similar to those available to staff generally, amounting to €1.881 million, (March 31, 2009: €1.113 million).
 
There are no provisions in respect of any failure or anticipated failure to repay any of the above loans or interest thereon.


F-120


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
50  RELATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS  (continued)
 
 
(e)   Compensation of key management personnel
 
                 
    9 months ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31
Remuneration
  2009   2009
    €’000   €’000
 
Salaries and other short term benefits.(1)
    5,591       9,951  
Post employment benefits(2)(5)
    2,039       876  
Payment in lieu of notice
    412       1,462  
Equity compensation benefits(3)
          1,973  
                 
Total remuneration before amounts waived
    8,042       14,262  
Amounts waived(4)
    (237 )      
                 
      7,805       14,262  
                 
 
 
(1) Comprises gross salary, fees, bonus, cash in lieu of pension, car allowance and other short term benefits paid in the period. A bonus was paid to only one individual and in line with their contractual position. The individual was not an Executive Director.
 
(2) This comprises Employer contributions to pension funds.
 
(3) This includes the value of awards made under the Group’s executive share option scheme, Save As You Earn schemes, LTIP, Staff Stock Issue in Ireland and Stock Incentive Plan in UK which are described further in note 45.
 
(4) The Executive Directors and members of the GEC who were in office on May 1, 2009 agreed to waive an amount equal to at least 10% of their salary for one year with effect from May 1, 2009. The total amount waived in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 was €236,866.
 
(5) Following his appointment as Group Chief Executive Officer the pension contribution for R Boucher includes a one-off amount paid to the Bank Staff Pension Fund required to cover the contractual option allowing him to retire at age 55 on a pension of approx 59% of salary. This option was waived in April 2010 and the financial impact of the waiver will be included in the next financial statements.
 
51  PRINCIPAL UNDERTAKINGS
 
The principal Group undertakings at December 31, 2009 were:
 
             
        Country of
  Statutory
Name
 
Principal activity
  incorporation   year end
 
Bank of Ireland International Finance Limited*
  International asset financing   Ireland   March 31
Bank of Ireland (IOM) Limited
  Retail banking   Isle of Man   March 31
Bank of Ireland Life Holdings Limited*
  Life assurance and pensions   Ireland   December 31
Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank*
  Mortgage lending and mortgage covered securities   Ireland   March 31
First Rate Enterprises (UK) Limited(1)
  Foreign exchange   England   March 31
ICS Building Society*
  Building society   Ireland   December 31
Midasgrange Limited (t/a Post Office Financial Services, POFS)(2)
  Retail financial Services   England   March 31
 
 
Direct subsidiary of the Governor and Company of Bank of Ireland.


F-121


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
51  PRINCIPAL UNDERTAKINGS  (continued)
 
 
1  This entity is a joint venture with the UK Post Office, in which the Group holds 50% of the equity of the business.
 
2  This is a venture with Post Office Limited in the UK in which the Group holds 50.1% of the equity of the business.
 
All the Group undertakings are included in the consolidated accounts. Unless stated otherwise, the Group owns 100% of the equity of the principal Group undertakings and 100% of the voting shares of all these undertakings and in the case of ICS Building Society, 100% of the investment shares.
 
In presenting details of the principal subsidiary undertakings, the exemption permitted by Regulation 10 of the European Communities (Credit Institutions: Accounts) Regulations, 1992 has been availed of and the Bank will annex a full listing of Group undertakings to its annual return to the Companies Registration Office.
 
Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank (BoIMB)
 
BoIMB’s principal activities are the issuance of Irish residential mortgages and mortgage covered securities in accordance with the Asset Covered Securities Act 2001 and the Asset Covered Securities (Amendment) Act 2007. Such loans may be made directly by the Bank or may be purchased from Bank of Ireland and other members of the Group or third parties.
 
At December 31, 2009, the total amount outstanding in respect of mortgage covered securities issued was €9 billion (March 31, 2009: €10 billion). At December 31, 2009, the total amount of principal outstanding in the mortgage covered pool including mortgage assets and cash was €12.7 billion (March 31, 2009: €12.7 billion).
 
From time to time, BoIMB issues other debt securities comprising the BoIMB’s obligation to the Central Bank and Financial Services Authority of Ireland (CBFSAI) under the terms of the Mortgage Backed Promissory Note (MBPN) programme. At December 31, 2009 there were €3.5 billion such debt securities in issue (March 31, 2009: €3 billion). These obligations had been secured by way of a first floating charge to the CBFSAI over all its right, title, interest and benefit, in a relevant amount of loans and advances to customers. The bank had pledged under the terms of the floating charge to maintain the assets so charged free from any encumbrance and otherwise than in the ordinary course of business not to sell, transfer, lend or otherwise dispose of any part of the charged assets without prior written consent of the CBFSAI. The deed of floating charge was executed by BoIMB and dated July 5, 2004 in favour of the Central Bank and Irish Financial Services Regulatory Authority. The mortgages in the MBPN programme were secured by a floating charge over Irish Residential Mortgage Credit Assets which were not in the covered assets pool.


F-122


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
52  OTHER SUBSIDIARIES
 
The Group has a number of subsidiaries where it does not own more than half of the voting power in the company but which are consolidated. Details of these subsidiaries are listed below.
 
                                       
          December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
              Notes
      Notes
Activity
   
Company
  Gross assets   in issue   Gross assets   in issue
          m   m   m   m
Acquiring mortgage loans and other financial assets and issuing mortgage backed securities. 
    Brunel   £ 3,451     £ 3,354     £ 4,063     £ 3,966  
   
Colston No 1 PLC(1)
  £ 4,093     £ 3,500     £ 4,362     £ 3,756  
   
Colston No 2 PLC(1)
  £ 4,408     £ 3,909     £ 4,721     £ 4,202  
   
Colston No 3 PLC(1)
  £ 4,493     £ 3,863     £ 4,724     £ 4,086  
   
Colston No 4 PLC(1)
  £ 4,276     £ 3,526     £ 4,482     £ 3,716  
      Kildare Securities Limited   1,937     1,892     2,100     2,115  
      Melepard CDO 1 Limited(1)   1,188     1,208     1,203     1,208  
      Morrigan CMBS I Limited(1)   1,757     1,755     1,755     1,755  
      Morrigan CMBS 2 plc(1)   £ 762     £ 776     £ 776     £ 776  
      Pirus Securities Limited(1)   2,020     1,688     2,052     1,721  
Acquiring other financial assets and issuing debt securities. 
    Avondale Securities(3)   829     318     833     377  
Acquiring a pool of acquisition finance loans assets which it has issued a series of loan notes to finance. 
    Partholon CDO 1 plc(2)   371     404     398     408  
 
Under IFRS accounting rules all the assets of these companies are consolidated in the Group’s financial statements and are collateral for the obligations of the companies above. The creditors of these companies have no recourse to the general credit of the Group.
 
 
1.   The Group holds all the notes issued by these companies.
 
2.   The Group holds 25% of the subordinated loan notes. The Group also holds €30 million of AAA rated notes which it intends to hold until maturity. This investment is eliminated on consolidation.
 
3.   The asset backing Avondale Securities’ notes consists of future cash-flows arising from a defined block of unit-linked insurance and investment policies which are held on the balance sheet of a related group company, Bank of Ireland Life. At an interest rate of 1.36%, the present value of the defined block of policies is €829 million at December 31, 2009 and was €833 million at March 31, 2009.
 
                                       
          December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
Activity
   
Company
  Gross assets   Borrowings   Gross assets   Borrowings
          m   m   m   m
Acquiring mortgage loans and other financial assets and guaranteeing mortgage backed securities issued by Bank of Ireland
    Bank of Ireland Covered Bonds LLP   £ 4,615     £ 4,500 (1)   £ 4,951     £ 4,500  
 
 
1. All the borrowings of Bank of Ireland Covered Bonds LLP have been advanced by other Group companies.


F-123


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
53  LIFE ASSURANCE BUSINESS
 
Value of In-Force Life Assurance Business
 
                 
    December 31,
    March 31,
 
    2009     2009  
    €m     €m  
 
At beginning of period
    468       548  
Income statement movement in value of in force (gross of tax)
    29       (80 )
                 
At end of period
    497       468  
                 
 
The Group recognises as an asset the value of in force assurance business in respect of insurance contracts. The value of in force asset has been calculated in accordance with the achieved profits embedded value methodology in the Statement of Recommended Practice issued by the Association of British Insurers which came into force in 2002. The value of in force asset, which is presented gross of attributable tax, represents the present value of future profits expected to arise from these contracts as at the balance sheet date. It is determined by projecting future surpluses and other cash flows arising from insurance contracts and discounting at an appropriate rate. The useful life of the asset is based on the length of the underlying individual policies upon which the asset is calculated. This useful life is expected to be 6.77 years (31 March 2009: 6.83 years).
 
The key economic assumptions used in the calculation of the value of in force business are set out below:
 
                 
    December 31,
    March 31,
 
    2009     2009  
 
Risk Discount Rate
    8.25%       9.0%  
Unit Growth Rate
    6.5%       7.25%  
Shareholder Tax Rate
    12.5%       12.5%  
 
The process used in determining the key economic and experience assumptions is set out below:
 
Risk discount rate:  The risk discount rate is the rate used to discount the surpluses that will arise on insurance business in the long term fund. The rate reflects the yield available on Government bonds of appropriate duration plus a risk margin.
 
Unit growth rate:  The unit growth rate is the assumed rate of return on the Company’s unit linked assets before taxation and management fees in future years. The growth rate reflects the mix of assets held.
 
Shareholder tax rate:  The current rate of corporation tax is assumed to be maintained over the term of the business. Deferred tax is allowed for on the release of retained surplus in the life business.
 
Mortality and morbidity:  Mortality and morbidity assumptions, which include allowances for improvements in longevity for annuitants, are set by reference to the Group’s actual experience and/or relevant industry data.
 
Persistency:  Persistency rates refer to the rate of policy termination for insurance policies. These rates are based on historical experience and management’s views on future experience.
 
Maintenance expenses:  Allowance is made for future policy costs by reference to current and expected future costs. Explicit allowance is made for future expense inflation.


F-124


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
53  LIFE ASSURANCE BUSINESS  (continued)
 
 
Sensitivities
 
The table below indicates the stand alone impact of changes in the key assumptions on profit after tax and shareholder equity.
 
                 
    9 months ended
  Year ended
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
1% increase in risk discount rate
    (27 )     (24 )
1% decrease in risk discount rate
    30       26  
10% improvement in mortality
    10       12  
10% deterioration in persistency
    (18 )     17  
5% improvement in renewal expenses
    6       6  
1% increase in equity markets
    2       2  
 
While the table above shows the impact of an individual assumption change, a change in one assumption could impact on other assumptions due to the relationship between assumptions.


F-125


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
54  DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION
 
Directors’ remuneration for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 (all figures in €000s)
 
                                                                 
                            Amounts
   
                    Pension
  Total 2009
  waived
  Total 2009
    Gross
      Performance
  Other
  funding
  (before
  during the
  (after
    Salary
  Fees
  Bonus
  remuneration
  contributions
  amounts
  period
  amounts
    (1)   (2)   (3)   (4)   (5)   waived)   (6)   waived)
 
Governor
                                                               
R Burrows (retired July 3, 09)
    ** 103                                       103               103  
P Molloy o (appointed to Court on June 10, 2009 and Governor on July 3, 2009)
    ** 194       4                               198               198  
Deputy Governor
                                                               
G M Magan (retired July 3, 2009)
    ** 33                                       33               33  
D Holt (appointed Deputy Governor August 25, 2009)
    ** 45       41                               86               86  
     
     
Executive Directors
                                                               
R Boucher
    508                       43       #1,490       2,041       (45 )     1,996  
D Crowley
    428                       107       (7 )     528       (48 )     480  
D Donovan
    495                       223       (106 )     612       (44 )     568  
J O’Donovan
    412                       151       8       571       (37 )     534  
     
     
Non — Executive Directors
                                                               
T Considine
            60                               60               60  
D Dilger (retired July 3, 2009)
            * 26                               26               26  
P Haran
            67                               67               67  
R Hynes
            + 81                               81               81  
J Kennedy
            + 96                               96               96  
D McCourt
            60                               60               60  
HA McSharry
            65                               65               65  
T Neill
            59                               59               59  
P O’Sullivan (appointed July 3, 2009)
            * 37                               37               37  
J Walsh
            59                               59               59  
     
     
Totals
    2,218       655             524       1,385       4,782       (174 )     4,608  
     
     
Ex-gratia payments paid to former Directors/dependents
                                            248               248  
 
 
# The majority of this amount is a one-off amount paid to the Bank Staff Pensions Fund required to cover the contractual option allowing R Boucher to retire at age 55 on a pension without actuarial reduction. This option was waived in April 2010, and the financial impact of the waiver will be included in the next financial statements.
 
* From date of appointment or to date of retirement as a Director, as indicated.
 
** From date of appointment or to date of retirement as Governor/Deputy Governor, as indicated.
 
+ Includes fees paid in respect of services as Directors of subsidiary companies (R Hynes €18,750, J Kennedy €31,500).
 
o In addition to amounts shown, P Molloy is also in receipt of a pension from the Bank Staff Pensions Fund relating to his previous employment with the Group.


F-126


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
54  DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION  (continued)
 
 
Notes:
 
(1) The Chief Executive Officer, Richie Boucher, has, with effect from May 1, 2009, waived a portion of his salary (€44,667 for the period ended December 31, 2009). The salary shown in the table is the gross amount before that waiver. In addition, the full amount of his pension cash allowance ceased with effect from May 1, 2009.
 
The other Executive Directors have waived payment of at least 10% of their salary with effect from May 1, 2009. The amounts shown in Column (1) are before that waiver. The amounts waived during the nine months ended December 31, 2009 are D Crowley €48,199, D Donovan €44,000 and J O’Donovan €36,667.
 
The Governor and Deputy Governor, as Non-Executive Officers of the Bank, are not paid Court fees but are remunerated by way of non-pensionable salary.
 
(2) Fees are paid only to Non-Executive Directors and a basic fee of €63,000 per annum applies. Additional fees were paid to Committee Chairmen, the Senior Independent Director and for Committee membership. On February 1, 2009, the Governor, Deputy Governor and all Non-Executive Directors agreed to reduce their salary (in the case of the Governor and Deputy Governor) and their fees (in the case of all other Non-Executive Directors) by 25%.
 
All Committee fees were also reduced by 25%.  Where Non-Executive Directors took on additional Committee roles in the period ended December 31, 2009 they received the reduced fee applicable to that role in addition to their basic fee of €63,000 per annum and any other Committee fee they were already receiving.
 
(3) Payments under the performance bonus scheme, are linked to individual performance and overall Group performance versus pre determined targets for the financial year.
 
No bonuses were awarded in respect of the nine months ended December 31, 2009.
 
(4) The figures include car allowances and where applicable a taxable cash allowance in lieu of pension foregone for those Executives whose contractual pension promise would exceed the pensions cap introduced by the Finance Act 2006. No amount is payable in respect of a taxable cash allowance in lieu of pension foregone for R Boucher with effect from May 1, 2009.
 
(5) In the case of D Donovan and D Crowley their pension accrual is now capped at the increase in pension thresholds set out in the Finance Act each year, and as a result, a release back to the fund of previously funded benefits arises on an annual basis.
 
Following his appointment as Group Chief Executive Officer, the pension contribution for R Boucher includes a one-off amount paid to the Bank Staff Pensions Fund required to cover the contractual option allowing him to retire at age 55 on a pension of approx. 59% of salary. This option was waived in April 2010 and the financial impact of the waiver will be included in the next financial statements.
 
All pension amounts at (4) and (5) have been determined by Towers Watson, the Group’s actuary, and approved by the Group Remuneration Committee.
 
(6) Amounts waived are as set out in note (1) above.


F-127


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
54  DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION  (continued)
 
 
Directors’ remuneration for the year ended March 31, 2009 (all figures in €000s)
 
                                                                 
                    Pension
  Payment
       
    Gross
      Performance
  Other
  funding
  in lieu
       
    salary
  Fees
  Bonus
  remuneration
  contributions
  of notice
  Total
   
    (1)   (2)   (3)   (4)   (5)   (6)   2008/09    
 
Governor
                                                               
R Burrows
    503                                               503          
Deputy Governor
                                                               
G M Magan
    161                                               161          
     
     
Executive Directors
                                                               
R Boucher
    580                     284       202             1,066          
D Crowley
    478                     386       (103 )           ++761          
D Donovan
    660                     518       (121 )           1,057          
B J Goggin * (resigned as a Director Feb 25, 2009)
    1,172                     843       (382 )     1,462       3,095          
J O’Donovan
    550                     420       102             1,072          
     
     
Non — Executive Directors
                                                               
T Considine** (appointed Jan 1, 2009)
            19                                       19          
D Dilger
            127                                       127          
P Haran
            119                                       119          
D Holt
            117                                       117          
R Hynes
            +121                                       121          
J Kennedy
            +133                                       133          
D McCourt
            104                                       104          
HA McSharry
            106                                       106          
T Neill
            102                                       102          
J Walsh** (appointed Jan 1, 2009)
            21                                       21          
     
     
Totals
    4,104       969             2,451       (302 )     1,462       8,684          
     
     
Ex-gratia payments paid to former Directors/dependents
                                                    379          
 
 
* Figures in the above table for B J Goggin reflect his employment up to the end of March 2009.
 
** From date of appointment as a Director, as indicated.
 
+ Includes fees paid in respect of services as Directors of subsidiary companies (R Hynes €25,000, J Kennedy €42,000).
 
++ Sterling equivalent 2008/09 — £700,000.
 
Notes:
 
(1) The Governor and Deputy Governor, as Non-Executive Officers of the Bank, are not paid Court fees but are remunerated by way of non-pensionable salary.
 
(2) Fees are paid only to Non-Executive Directors; a basic fee of €84,000 per annum applied up to the end of January 2009. Additional fees were paid to Committee Chairmen, the Senior Independent Director and for


F-128


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
54  DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION  (continued)
 
Committee membership. On February 1, 2009, the Governor, Deputy Governor and all Non-Executive Directors agreed to reduce their salary (in the case of the Governor and Deputy Governor) and their fees (in the case of all other Non-Executive Directors) by 25%.
 
(3) Payments under the performance bonus scheme, are linked to individual performance and overall Group performance versus pre determined targets for the financial year. No bonuses were awarded for the financial year 2008/09.
 
(4) The figures include car allowances and a taxable cash allowance in lieu of pension foregone for those Executives whose contractual pension promise would exceed the pensions cap introduced by the Finance Act 2006 together with the value of awards under the Employee Stock Issue Scheme.
 
(5) In the case of BJ Goggin, D Crowley and D Donovan their pension accrual is now ‘capped’ at the increase in pension thresholds set out in the Finance Act each year, and as a result, a release back to the fund of previously funded benefits arises on an annual basis.
 
All pension amounts at (4) and (5) have been determined by Towers Watson, the Group’s actuary, and approved by the Group Remuneration Committee.
 
(6) B J Goggin resigned as a Director in February 2009 and left the employment of the Group in March 2009. As per his contractual notice period arrangements, he received twelve months pay in lieu of notice.
 
Stock options held by Directors and Secretary
 
(a)   Executive stock options
 
Options Granted between 2006 and 2007
 
The vesting of options granted in 2006 and 2007 is conditional upon underlying earnings per share achieving a cumulative growth of at least 5% per annum compounded above the increase in the Consumer Price Index over the three year performance period.
 
Options granted in 2006 matured on July 4, 2009 and did not vest as the performance conditions were not achieved. This confirms the strong link between returns to stockholders and the remuneration of executives.
 
Options granted in 2007 are due to mature on June 12, 2010, but are likely to lapse as the performance conditions are unlikely to be achieved.
 
Options Granted in 2008
 
For options granted in 2008, 25% will vest if the Group’s underlying earnings per share growth is 3% per annum compounded over the three year performance period covering March 2009 to March 2011. 100% of options granted in 2008 will vest if the Group’s underlying earnings per share growth is 6% compounded over the three year performance period. A scaled level of vesting will occur between these two targets, with options lapsing if the minimum target of underlying earnings per share of 3% per annum compounded is not achieved over the three year performance period.


F-129


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
54  DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION  (continued)
 
 
Options to subscribe for ordinary stock in the Bank granted and exercised during the nine months ended December 31, 2009 are set out in the table below:
 
                                                                     
                    Options at
                   
                    April 1,
                   
                    2009
              Market
   
                    or date of
              price at
  Options at
    Date of
  Earliest
      Exercise
  appointment
  Granted
  Exercised
  Lapsed
  exercise
  December 31,
    grant   exercise date   Expiry date   price   if later   in period   in year   in period   date   2009*
                                     
 
R Boucher
  Jul 26, 2004   Jul 26, 2007   Jul 26, 2014     10.76       26,000                                       26,000  
    Jun 21, 2005   Jun 21, 2008   Jun 21, 2015     12.85       23,000                                       23,000  
    Jul 4, 2006   Jul 4, 2009   Jul 4, 2016     14.00       30,500                       30,500                
    Jun 12, 2007   Jun 12, 2010   Jun 12, 2017     15.45       33,950                                       33,950  
    Jun 3, 2008   Jun 3, 2011   Jun 3, 2018     8.10       71,600                                       71,600  
                                                                     
    Total                     185,050                       30,500               154,550  
                                                                     
D Crowley
  May 21, 2001   May 21, 2004   May 21, 2011     11.05       25,000                                       25,000  
    Jun 24, 2002   Jun 24, 2005   Jun 24, 2012     12.50       25,000                                       25,000  
    Jun 18, 2003   Jun 18, 2006   Jun 18, 2013     10.77       50,000                                       50,000  
    Jul 26, 2004   Jul 26, 2007   Jul 26, 2014     10.76       35,000                                       35,000  
    Jun 21, 2005   Jun 21, 2008   Jun 21, 2015     12.85       32,500                                       32,500  
    Jul 4, 2006   Jul 4, 2009   Jul 4, 2016     14.00       30,500                       30,500                
    Jun 12, 2007   Jun 12, 2010   Jun 12, 2017     15.45       33,950                                       33,950  
    Jun 3, 2008   Jun 3, 2011   Jun 3, 2018     8.10       68,800                                       68,800  
                                                                     
    Total                     300,750                       30,500               270,250  
                                                                     
D Donovan
  Jun 24, 2002   Jun 24, 2005   Jun 24, 2012     12.50       30,000                                       30,000  
    Jun 18, 2003   Jun 18, 2006   Jun 18, 2013     10.77       50,000                                       50,000  
    Jul 26, 2004   Jul 26, 2007   Jul 26, 2014     10.76       35,000                                       35,000  
    Jun 21, 2005   Jun 21, 2008   Jun 21, 2015     12.85       32,500                                       32,500  
    Jul 4, 2006   Jul 4, 2009   Jul 4, 2016     14.00       30,500                       30,500                
    Jun 12, 2007   Jun 12, 2010   Jun 12, 2017     15.45       33,950                                       33,950  
    Jun 3, 2008   Jun 3, 2011   Jun 3, 2018     8.10       81,450                                       81,450  
                                                                     
    Total                     293,400                       30,500               262,900  
                                                                     
J O’Donovan
  Jun 24, 2002   Jun 24, 2005   Jun 24, 2012     12.50       25,000                                       25,000  
    Jun 18, 2003   Jun 18, 2006   Jun 18, 2013     10.77       50,000                                       50,000  
    Jul 26, 2004   Jul 26, 2007   Jul 26, 2014     10.76       35,000                                       35,000  
    Jun 21, 2005   Jun 21, 2008   Jun 21, 2015     12.85       32,500                                       32,500  
    Jul 4, 2006   Jul 4, 2009   Jul 4, 2016     14.00       30,500                       30,500                
    Jun 12, 2007   Jun 12, 2010   Jun 12, 2017     15.45       33,950                                       33,950  
    Jun 3, 2008   Jun 3, 2011   Jun 3, 2018     8.10       67,900                                       67,900  
                                                                     
    Total                     274,850                       30,500               244,350  
                                                                     
Secretary
  May 21, 2001   May 21, 2004   May 21, 2011     11.05       10,000                                       10,000  
H Nolan
  Jun 18, 2003   Jun 18, 2006   Jun 18, 2013     10.77       10,000                                       10,000  
    Jul 26, 2004   Jul 26, 2007   Jul 26, 2014     10.76       12,000                                       12,000  
    Jun 21, 2005   Jun 21, 2008   Jun 21, 2015     12.85       11,000                                       11,000  
    Jul 04, 2006   Jul 4, 2009   Jul 4, 2016     14.00       11,500                       11,500                
    Jun 12, 2007   Jun 12, 2010   Jun 12, 2017     15.45       9,700                                       9,700  
    Jun 3, 2008   Jun 3, 2011   Jun 3, 2018     8.10       16,400                                       16,400  
                                                                     
    Total                     80,600                       11,500               69,100  
                                                                     
 
 
* Information is shown as at December 31, 2009 and before any changes which may be required as a consequence of the Rights Issue.
 
No other Directors have been granted options to subscribe for units of ordinary stock of the Bank or of other Group entities.
 
The official closing price of ordinary stock at December 31, 2009 was €1.325 (March 31, 2009: €0.52).


F-130


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
54  DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION  (continued)
 
 
(b)   Sharesave Scheme Options
 
Under the terms of the Sharesave Schemes offered in 2006 and 2007, options were granted in December of each of those years to all eligible Group employees who elected to participate. Option prices were set at a discount of 25% of the then market price as permitted by the Rules in Ireland and at a discount of 20% of the then market price as permitted by the Rules in the UK. Under the terms of the 2006 and 2007 Sharesave offers, participants could save for three years.
 
The following table summarises the Sharesave Schemes operating in the Group:
 
                             
Sharesave Scheme
  ROI Price   UK Price  
Saving Period
 
Maturity Date
 
2006
  12.28     13.09       3 years     February 2010
2007
  6.96     7.43       3 years     February 2011
 
The options held under the Sharesave schemes by the Directors and Secretary are set out below:
 
                             
                Sharesave
    Sharesave Scheme
  Sharesave options
  Market value at date
  options held at
Name
  date of Grant   granted   of grant   December 31, 2009#
 
Directors:
                           
    2006                        
R Boucher
  December 22, 2006     301     17.33       301  
    2007                        
D Crowley
  December 24, 2007     574     10.11       *
Secretary
                           
H Nolan
  2006                        
    December 22, 2006     301     17.33       301  
    2007                        
    December 24, 2007     531     10.11       531  
 
 
* Des Crowley held 574 options under the 2007 3 Year SAYE Scheme, however, he withdrew from the scheme on June 10, 2009 withdrawing his savings of £1,120 and interest of £27. His options therefore lapsed.
 
# Information is shown as at December 31, 2009, and before any changes which may be required as a consequence of the Rights Issue.
 
(c)   Long Term Incentive Plan (LTIP)
 
Conditional awards of units of ordinary stock are made to Group Senior Executives annually since 2004 under the terms of the LTIP.
 
These awards do not vest in the Executives unless demanding performance criteria are achieved (see description of LTIP in note 45 on page F-101). Prior to the introduction of the LTIP in 2004, conditional awards of units of ordinary stock were made under the Long Term Performance Stock Plan (LTPSP).
 
The performance conditions attached to the award of conditional units of stock made in June 2006 under the LTIP were not met in June 2009 and the awards granted under the scheme lapsed.
 
The Group Remuneration Committee decided that no award was to be made to Executive Directors in June 2009 under the LTIP plan.


F-131


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
54  DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION  (continued)
 
 
The conditional awards of units of ordinary stock made to date to the Executive Directors and the Group Secretary are as follows:
 
                                                                                 
        No. of units
                      Potential
       
        conditionally
      Vested
          Released
  interest
       
        held at
  Conditionally
  and
          from
  in shares at
  Original
   
    Date of
  April 1,
  awarded
  Retained
      Matching
  scheme in
  December 31,
  Maturity
  Maturity
    award   2009   in the year   in Scheme*   Lapsed **   Award*   the year   2009#   date   date*
 
R Boucher
    Jul 4, 2006       30,500                       30,500                             Jul 4, 2009          
      Jun 12, 2007       33,950                                               33,950       Jun 12, 2010          
      Jun 3, 2008       71,600                                               71,600       Jun 3, 2011          
                                                                                 
      Total       136,050                   30,500                   105,550                  
                                                                                 
D Crowley
    Jul 13, 1999                       6,158               1,539       7,697             Jul 13, 2002       Jul 13, 2009  
      May 25, 2000                       13,079               3,269               3,269       May 25, 2003       May 25, 2010  
      May 21, 2001                       9,496               2,373               2,373       May 21, 2004       May 21, 2011  
      Jun 24, 2002                       7,070               1,767               1,767       Jun 24, 2005       Jun 24, 2012  
      Jul 4, 2006       30,500                       30,500                             Jul 4, 2009          
      Jun 12, 2007       33,950                                               33,950       Jun 12, 2010          
      Jun 3, 2008       68,800                                               68,800       Jun 3, 2011          
                                                                                 
      Total       133,250             35,803       30,500       8,948       7,697       110,159                  
                                                                                 
D Donovan
    Jul 13, 1999                       7,544               1,886       9,430             Jul 13, 2002       Jul 13, 2009  
      May 25, 2000                       11,494               2,873               2,873       May 25, 2003       May 25, 2010  
      May 21, 2001                       7,067               1,766               1,766       May 21, 2004       May 21, 2011  
      Jun 24, 2002                       4,714               1,178               1,178       Jun 24, 2005       Jun 24, 2012  
      Jul 4, 2006       30,500                       30,500                             Jul 4, 2009          
      Jun 12, 2007       33,950                                               33,950       Jun 12, 2010          
      Jun 3, 2008       81,450                                               81,450       Jun 3, 2011          
                                                                                 
      Total       145,900             30,819       30,500       7,703       9,430       121,217                  
                                                                                 
J O’Donovan
    Jun 24, 2002                       6,034               1,508             1,508       Jun 24, 2005       Jun 24, 2012  
      Jul 4, 2006       30,500                       30,500                             Jul 4, 2009          
      Jun 12, 2007       33,950                                               33,950       Jun 12, 2010          
      Jun 3, 2008       67,900                                               67,900       Jun 3, 2011          
                                                                                 
      Total       132,350             6,034       30,500       1,508             103,358                  
                                                                                 
Secretary
                                                                               
H Nolan
    Jul 4, 2006       11,500                       11,500                             Jul 4, 2009          
      Jun 12, 2007       6,950                                               6,950       Jun 12, 2010          
      Jun 3, 2008       12,300                                               12,300       Jun 3, 2011          
                                                                                 
      Total       30,750                   11,500                   19,250                  
                                                                                 
 
 
* Only applies to awards made under the LTPSP. A minimum of 80% of the vested stock must be retained for two years from maturity of award. After the two year retention period, an additional award of 20% is made. If the award is retained for an additional five years, a further award of 30% is made. These additional awards are made at the maturity date as per the above table.
 
** This column relates to any conditional grant which may have lapsed during the nine months ended December 31, 2009.
 
# Information is shown as at December 31, 2009, and before any changes which may be required as a consequence of the Rights Issue.


F-132


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
54  DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION  (continued)
 
 
Directors’ pension entitlements
 
Set out below are details of the change in accrued pension benefits for the Directors during the nine months ended December 31, 2009.
 
                         
        (b) Increase /
  (c) Accrued pension
    (a) Additional
  (decrease) in
  entitlement at
Executive Directors
  pension in the period   transfer value   December 31, 2009
       
 
R Boucher
    65,512       1,906,623       276,690  
D Crowley*
          (10,688 )     270,866  
D Donovan*
                268,507  
J O’Donovan
    3,462       25,770       268,903  
 
Column (a) above is the increase in pension during the period. Increases are after adjustment for inflation and comprise allowance for additional pensionable service, increases in pensionable earnings and any agreed adjustment in the individual’s pension accrual.
 
Column (b) is the additional/(reduced) capital value, less each Director’s contributions, of column (a) which would arise if the pension were to be transferred to another pension plan on the Director leaving the Group and is calculated using factors supplied by the actuary in accordance with actuarial guidance notes ASP PEN-2, and is based on leaving service pension benefits becoming payable at normal retirement date, age 60 (or earlier where there is an unfettered right to the payment of the benefit from an earlier age, payable without reduction, on leaving service).
 
During 2009, Richie Boucher’s contractual arrangements were changed to include an option to retire at age 55 on a pension of approx. 59% of his salary. Column (b) above includes an amount in respect of that change in contractual terms. This option was waived by him in April 2010 and the impact of this waiver will be reflected in the next financial statements.
 
Column (c) is the aggregate annual pension entitlement payable at normal retirement age based on each Director’s pensionable service with the Group at December 31, 2009.
 
*Pension entitlements increase annually in line with the increase in fund thresholds announced in the Finance Act each year. In the case of these individuals, the pension earned in 2009 is nil as there were no increases in the statutory revaluation of this threshold in the period from March 31 to December 31 2009.


F-133


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
54  DIRECTORS’ INFORMATION  (continued)
 
 
Directors’ interests in stock
 
In addition to their interests in the ordinary stock through their holding of stock options and the conditional awards of stock under the LTPSP and LTIP as set out above, the interests of the Directors and Secretary in office at December 31, 2009, and of their spouses and minor children, in the stocks issued by the Bank are set out below:
 
                 
    Units of €0.64 of Ordinary Stock
    As at December 31, 2009
  As at April 1, 2009
    Beneficial   Beneficial
 
DIRECTORS
               
R Boucher
    33,127       33,127  
T Considine
    5,000       5,000  
D Crowley
    130,454       128,915  
D Donovan
    185,078       183,192  
P Haran
    8,443       8,443  
D Holt
    16,284       16,284  
R Hynes +
    25,000       25,000  
J Kennedy
    8,062       8,062  
D McCourt
    50,674       50,674  
H A McSharry
    11,354       11,354  
P Molloy
    1,167,333       *1,167,333  
T Neill
    114,461       **114,461  
J O’Donovan
    91,126       108,326  
P O’Sullivan
    10,000       *10,000  
J Walsh
    10,733       10,733  
                 
SECRETARY
               
H Nolan
    21,883       *21,883  
                 
 
 
+ Held as American Depository Receipts (ADRs). One ADR equates to four units of ordinary stock.
 
* As at date of appointment.
 
** The comparative figure is amended to include an additional 161 units of Ordinary Stock taken up under the Stock Alternative Scheme in January 2008.
 
Apart from the interests set out above and in the previous section, the Directors and Secretary and their spouses and minor children had no other interests in the stock / securities of the Bank or its Group undertakings at December 31, 2009.
 
There have been no changes in the stockholdings of the above Directors and Secretary between December 31, 2009 and May 24, 2010, with the exception of D Crowley (133,724 at May 24, 2010) and D Donovan (187,951 at May 24, 2010).


F-134


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
55  SUMMARY OF RELATIONS WITH THE IRISH GOVERNMENT
 
(a)   Guarantee schemes
 
Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Scheme 2008 — (the “2008 Scheme”)
 
On 24 October 2008, four of the Group’s entities elected to participate in the above scheme. Under the scheme the Irish Government has guaranteed relevant deposits and debt securities raised by Irish covered institutions1 until September 29, 2010. The entities participating are the Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland, Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank, ICS Building Society and Bank of Ireland (IOM) Limited.
 
The following are the specific liabilities covered as set out in the Scheme rules:
 
•   all retail and corporate deposits (to the extent not covered by existing deposit protection schemes in Ireland or any other jurisdiction);
 
•   interbank deposits;
 
•   senior unsecured debt;
 
•   covered bonds (including asset covered securities); and
 
•   dated subordinated debt (Lower Tier 2).
 
Any intergroup borrowing and any debt due to the European Central Bank arising from Eurosystem monetary operations is excluded.
 
A number of conditions have been imposed on covered institutions under the Scheme including inter alia, conditions that regulate the commercial conduct of their business, having regard to capital ratios, market share and balance sheet growth. This is in order to minimise any potential competitive distortion that may arise and to avoid any abuse of the guarantee or any use in a manner irreconcilable with the purpose of the guarantee. These conditions are set out in the Scheme.
 
Covered institutions are subject to particular reporting requirements to enable the Financial Regulator and the Minister for Finance to monitor compliance with the Scheme and the achievement of its purposes.
 
A quarterly charge is payable to the Irish Government under the scheme. This amounted to €105 million for the nine months ended December 31, 2009 (€66 million for the six months to March 31, 2009).
 
At December 31, 2009, liabilities of €98.6 billion (March 31, 2009: €105.9 billion) were guaranteed under this scheme.
 
Credit Institutions (Eligible Liabilities Guarantee) Scheme
 
On December 9, 2009 the Credit Institutions (Eligible Liabilities Guarantee) Scheme (the “ELG Scheme”) was introduced. The purpose of the ELG scheme was to update and revise the current bank guarantee under the 2008 Scheme.
 
The ELG Scheme is subject to ongoing six monthly approval by the European Commission in accordance with EU State aid rules. The next review is due for completion by the end of June 2010.
 
Eligible liabilities include:
 
•   deposits to the extent not covered by deposit protection schemes in Ireland (other than the 2008 scheme) or any other jurisdiction;
 
•   senior unsecured certificates of deposit;
 
•   senior unsecured commercial paper;


F-135


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
55  SUMMARY OF RELATIONS WITH THE IRISH GOVERNMENT  (continued)
 
 
•   other senior unsecured bonds and notes; and
 
•   other forms of senior unsecured debt which may be specified by the Minister, consistent with EU State aid rules and the EU Commission’s Banking Communication (2008/C 270/02) and subject to prior consultation with the EU Commission.
 
From the time that a participating institution joins the ELG Scheme, only covered liabilities of that participating institution (as defined in the CIFS Scheme) in existence or contracted for prior to that time will continue to be guaranteed under the CIFS Scheme. All such then-existing covered liabilities will remain guaranteed until September 29, 2010 under the CIFS Scheme. From the time that a participating institution joins the ELG Scheme, any liabilities incurred or contracted for thereafter by that participating institution may be guaranteed under the ELG Scheme only.
 
A fee is payable to the Minister for Finance in respect of each liability guaranteed under the ELG Scheme.
 
On January 11, 2010, the Group became a participating institution under the ELG Scheme.
 
Participating institutions are also required to indemnify the Minister for Finance for any costs and expenses incurred by the Minister and for any payments made by the Minister under the Scheme which relate to the participating institution’s guarantee under the ELG and CIFS Schemes.
 
European Communities (Deposit Guarantee Schemes) Regulations, 1995
 
Under the European Communities (Deposit Guarantee Schemes) Regulations, 1995 (the ’Deposit Protection Scheme’) as amended by the Irish Government on September 20, 2008, deposits of up to €100,000 per depositor per licensed institution regulated by the Irish Financial Regulator are guaranteed.
 
This Scheme covers:
 
•   current accounts;
 
•   demand deposit accounts; and
 
•   term deposit accounts.
 
The level of contribution required from each credit institution is 0.2% per annum of eligible deposits held at all branches of the credit institution.
 
Deposits held in the Isle of Man benefit from the depositor compensation scheme in that jurisdiction which covers the first £50,000 of each deposit.
 
(b)   2009 Preference Stock
 
Against the backdrop of both higher market expectations for capital ratios and the Bank’s revised estimates for loan impairment charges the Government announced on 11 February 2009 its decision to invest in Bank of Ireland. This was achieved by the issue of and subscription by the NPRFC for 3.5 billion units of 2009 preference stock and by the issue of warrants to the NPRFC on March 31, 2009.


F-136


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
55  SUMMARY OF RELATIONS WITH THE IRISH GOVERNMENT  (continued)
 
Application of the €3.5 billion proceeds of 2009 preference stock and warrants was as follows:
 
         
    €m
 
Capital Stock
    35  
Stock Premium
    3,317  
Other equity reserves:
       
Core tranche warrants
    50  
Secondary tranche warrants
    60  
Transaction expenses
    38  
         
      3,500  
         
 
Of the €38 million in transaction expenses €30 million was paid to the NPRFC.
 
The 2009 preference stock is perpetual.
 
The 2009 preference stock entitles the NPRFC to receive a non-cumulative cash dividend at a fixed rate of 8 per cent of the issue price per annum, payable annually in arrears on February 20, at the discretion of the Bank. If a cash dividend is not paid by the Bank, the Bank shall issue units of ordinary stock to the NPRFC.
 
The number of units of ordinary stock that the Bank would be required to issue in the event of non-payment of a cash dividend is calculated by dividing the amount of the unpaid dividend by the Thirty Day Average Price1 . These units will be settled on a day determined by the Bank, in its sole discretion, provided that this must occur no later than the day on which the Bank subsequently redeems or repurchases or pays a dividend on the 2009 preference stock or any class of capital stock.
 
If the dividend on the 2009 preference stock is not paid in any particular year, the Bank is precluded from paying any dividend on ordinary stock until the Bank resumes the payment of dividends on the 2009 preference stock in cash. The Bank will also be precluded from paying any dividend on ordinary stock where the payment of such a dividend would reduce the distributable reserves of the Bank to such an extent that the Bank would be unable to pay the next dividend due for payment on the 2009 preference stock.
 
For information on the February 2010 dividend, refer to note 58.
 
The repayment of the capital paid up (inclusive of premium) on the 2009 preference stock ranks pari passu with the repayment of the paid up nominal value (excluding premium) of the ordinary stock on a winding up or other return of capital of the Bank.
 
The 2009 preference stock ranks ahead of ordinary stock as regards dividends and the repayment of premium on the ordinary stock on a winding up or other return of capital of the Bank. It ranks pari passu as regards dividends with other stock or securities which constitute core tier 1 capital of the Bank (other than ordinary stock and other than dividends to Minority Interests).
 
The 2009 preference stock is transferable in minimum lots of 50,000 units. If transferred to a person who is not a Government Entity2 , it will cease to carry any voting rights or the right to appoint Directors to the Court referred to below.
 
 
 1  Defined on page F-140.
 2  Defined on, page F-140.


F-137


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
55  SUMMARY OF RELATIONS WITH THE IRISH GOVERNMENT  (continued)
 
The 2009 preference stock may be repurchased at the option of the Bank, in whole or in part, at a price per unit equal to the issue price of €1.00 per unit within the first five years from the date of issue and thereafter at a price per unit of €1.25, provided in either case that the consent of the Financial Regulator to the repurchase of the 2009 preference stock is obtained. The 2009 preference stock is not capable of being repurchased if it would breach or cause a breach of Irish banking capital adequacy requirements from time to time applicable to the Bank. It may be repurchased from profits available for distribution or from the proceeds of any issue of stock or securities that constitute core tier 1 capital.
 
While the 2009 preference stock is held by a Government Entity, the Minister for Finance3 will have the right to directly appoint 25 per cent of the Directors of the Bank (such 25 per cent to include any Directors nominated by the Minister for Finance pursuant to the Government Guarantee Scheme3).
 
If the ordinary stock to be issued in the event of non-payment of cash dividends on the 2009 preference stock is not settled on the dividend payment date to which it relates, the NPRFC is entitled to exercise the voting rights of that as yet unissued ordinary stock from the dividend payment date (although such voting rights will have no effect on the Bank’s unfettered discretion in respect of (i) the payment of dividends on the 2009 preference stock or any other securities of the Bank ranking pari passu with, or junior to, the 2009 preference stock or the issuance of ordinary stock in the event of non-payment of cash dividends on the 2009 preference stock; or (ii) the redemption or repurchase of the 2009 preference stock or any other securities of the Bank ranking pari passu with, or junior to, the 2009 preference stock).
 
The 2009 preference stock carries voting rights equivalent to 25 per cent of the total voting rights on any resolution proposed at a General Court of the Bank in relation to the appointment or removal of a Director of the Bank (inclusive of any voting rights that the NPRFC or any Government Entity may have through any holding of ordinary stock obtained through or in relation to the investment by the NPRFC and any voting rights obtained through the as yet unissued ordinary stock (as defined above).
 
The 2009 preference stock carries voting rights equivalent to 25 per cent of the total voting rights in relation to any Control Resolution3 (exclusive of any voting rights that the NPRFC or any Government Entity may have through any holding of ordinary stock obtained through or in relation to the Investment by the NPRFC).
 
While the NPRFC or a Government Entity holds the 2009 preference stock or (if later) until the Warrants are exercised, the implementation of any existing, or the adoption of any proposed, Capital Stock Resolution3 shall be subject to the prior written consent of the Minister for Finance.
 
On May 19, 2010 the NPRFC converted 1,036,000,000 units of 2009 preference stock to units of Ordinary Stock. Please refer to note 58 (i) for further information.
 
In connection with the investment by the NPRFC the Bank has agreed to implement a Banks Customer Package, including:
 
(a)  Increasing Credit Capacity to SME and first-time buyers.
 
(b)  Establishing an Environmental and Clean Energy and Innovation Fund.
 
(c)  Complying with new Codes of Practice in relation to lending to SME and Mortgage Arrears.
 
(d)  Engaging with the Financial Regulator in relation to improving customer communications and financial education.
 
(e)  Participating in an independent review of credit availability.
 
 
 3  Defined on page F-140


F-138


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
55  SUMMARY OF RELATIONS WITH THE IRISH GOVERNMENT  (continued)
 
 
(f)  Working with the IDA, Enterprise Ireland and with State agencies to ensure the supply of appropriate finance to contractors engaged on major projects sponsored by those agencies.
 
(g)  Providing additional funds for venture capital.
 
(h)  Ensuring prompt payment arrangements in future customer contracts.
 
Overview of Banks’ Commitments to SME sector
 
In his speech on March 30, 2010, the Minister for Finance announced a range of additional commitments for banks to support the SME sector. While the detail of these commitments remains to be finalised, they would require the Group to:
 
•  make available for targeted lending not less than €3 billion for new or increased credit facilities to SMEs in both 2010 and 2011, to include funds for working capital for businesses. The Minister stressed that credit should only go to viable businesses;
 
•  make available €20 million for Seed Capital to be provided to Enterprise Ireland supported ventures, building on the programme launched in 2009;
 
•  set-up a new fund of €100 million for Environmental, Clean Energy and Innovation Projects;
 
•  commit resources to work with Enterprise Ireland and the IBF to develop sectoral expertise in the modern growth sectors of the Irish economy;
 
•  explore with Enterprise Ireland and the IBF how best to develop the range of banking services that Irish SMEs trading internationally will need; and
 
•  develop expertise and bring forward new credit products in areas where cashflow, rather than property or assets, is the basis for business lending.
 
The Group is required to submit SME lending plans both by geography and sector for 2010 and 2011 in relation to the €3 billion target within a six week period.
 
Furthermore, as for other Irish banks, the Group will be subject to a Credit Review process whereby borrowers who have had credit refused or withdrawn can apply for an independent review of the Group’s decision. Where the Independent Reviewer recommends that credit should be granted, the Group is required to comply with the recommendation or explain why it will not do so.
 
For further information refer to www.finance.gov.ie
 
The Warrants
 
The Bank also entered into a Warrant Instrument on March 31, 2009 pursuant to which the Bank issued 334,737,148 Warrants to the NPRFC. Under the terms of the Warrants, the NPRFC would have been entitled to subscribe for units of ordinary stock on the basis of one unit of ordinary stock for each individual Warrant.
 
The warrants held by the NPRFC were cancelled in return for a payment of €491 million on May 19, 2010. Please refer to note 58(i) for further information.


F-139


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
55  SUMMARY OF RELATIONS WITH THE IRISH GOVERNMENT  (continued)
 
1Defined terms
 
Capital Stock Resolution
 
Any resolution proposed at a General Court of the Bank to alter the capital stock of the Bank by way of: (a) an increase in the capital stock of the Bank, the reissue of treasury stock or the allotment of any unissued capital stock of the Bank save for the issue of additional preference stock pursuant to the rights attaching to existing preference stock or the issue of capital stock to fund a repurchase or redemption of the 2009 Preference Stock; or (b) the redemption, consolidation, conversion or sub-division of the capital stock of the Bank save for the repurchase or redemption of the 2009 Preference Stock; or (c) any other changes in the capital structure of the Bank;
 
Control Resolution
 
A resolution of those Stockholders who are entitled to so vote for the approval of any agreement or transaction (including a merger) whereby, or in consequence of which, Control of the Bank, or substantially all of the Bank’s business, is or may be acquired by any person or persons (excluding any government concert party) acting in concert and which for the avoidance of doubt shall include any resolution to approve a scheme of arrangement pursuant to section 201 of the Companies Act 1963 pursuant to which a takeover of the Bank (within the meaning of the Irish Takeover Panel Act 1997 Takeover Rules (as amended, replaced or substituted from time to time)) would be effected or approved or a merger or division of the Bank pursuant to European Communities (Mergers And Divisions of Companies) Regulations, 1987 (Statutory Instrument 137 of 1987) or a merger of the Bank pursuant to European Communities (Cross-Border Mergers) Regulations 2008 (Statutory Instrument 157 of 2008);
 
Covered Institution
 
A credit institution or a subsidiary of a credit institution: (a) that stands specified by order by the Minister under section 6(1) of the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Act 2008; and (b) that has joined this Scheme in accordance with paragraph 5 of the Schedule to S.I. No. 411 of 2008.
 
Government
 
The Government of Ireland;
 
Government Entity
 
(i) The NTMA, the NPRFC, the NRPF, the Minister for Finance or any Minister or Department of the Government, in each case holding 2009 Preference Stock, but excludes any other holder of 2009 Preference Stock provided however this shall not include any occupational pension scheme approved by the Revenue Commissioners and registered with the Pension Board; and (ii) any custodian or nominee holding 2009 Preference Stock on behalf of the NPRFC, the Minister for Finance, any Minister or Department of the Government provided however that where such custodian or nominee holds 2009 Preference Stock for any other person, such holding shall be not be taken into account for the purpose of determining the voting rights of the Stockholder;
 
Minister for Finance
 
The Minister for Finance of Ireland;
 
Thirty Day Average Price
 
(i) 100 per cent of the average daily closing price of the Ordinary Stock on the Irish Stock Exchange over the 30 dealing days immediately preceding the original scheduled dividend declaration date, (in the event that the


F-140


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
55  SUMMARY OF RELATIONS WITH THE IRISH GOVERNMENT  (continued)
 
Ordinary Stock issued in the event of non-payment of dividends on the 2009 Preference Stock is settled on the dividend payment date to which it relates); or (ii) 95 per cent of the average daily closing price of the Ordinary Stock on the Irish Stock Exchange over the 30 dealing days immediately preceding the original scheduled dividend declaration date (in the event that the Ordinary Stock, issued in the event of non-payment of dividends on the 2009 Preference Stock, is settled after the dividend payment date to which it relates);
 
(c)   National Asset Management Agency (NAMA)
 
Please refer to note 26 for details on NAMA.
 
(d)   National Asset Management Agency Investment Limited (NAMAIL)
 
Please refer to note 50 for details on NAMAIL.
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT
 
Credit Risk
 
Definition
 
Credit Risk is defined as the risk of loss resulting from a counterparty being unable to meet its contractual obligations to the Group in respect of loans or other financial transactions.
 
Credit risk includes default risk, recovery risk, counterparty risk, the credit risk in securitisation, cross border (or transfer) risk, country risk, credit concentration risk and settlement risk.
 
The nature of the Group’s exposure to credit risk and the manner in which it arises, its policies and processes for managing credit risk and the methods it uses to measure and monitor credit risk are set out below.
 
How Credit Risk Arises
 
The Group’s customer base includes retail customers, financial institutions, sovereigns, state institutions and commercial entities. The Group is exposed to credit risk as a result of the financial transactions it enters into with these customers.
 
The main types of financial transaction the Group enters into and which give rise to credit risk are loans and advances to customers. Credit risk on loans and advances to customers arises as a result of amounts the Group has actually lent and amounts which the Group has committed to lend. Such commitments take a number of forms, the key ones being undrawn loans and overdrafts, guarantees, performance bonds and letters of credit. As regards commitments, the Group could potentially suffer loss to an amount equivalent to its total unused commitments. However, the Group does not expect to incur losses to that extent as most consumer related commitments can be cancelled and non-consumer commitments are entered into subject to the customer continuing to achieve specific credit standards.
 
The Group is also exposed to credit risk through its derivatives, available for sale, and other financial assets. In addition, credit risk arises in Bank of Ireland Life, primarily in relation to its reinsurance activities.
 
Credit Risk Exposures
 
At December 31, 2009, the Group classified those loans and advances to customers which are to transfer to NAMA as assets held for sale to NAMA. See note 26.


F-141


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
The table below represents the maximum exposure to credit risk for financial assets with material credit risk (net of impairment) at December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2009 without taking account of collateral or other credit enhancements held. Exposures are based on the net carrying amounts as reported in the balance sheet for on balance sheet assets.
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Maximum exposure to credit risk (before collateral or other credit enhancements)
               
Loans and advances to banks (note 23)
    5,031       7,886  
Loans and advances to customers (note 25)
    119,439       133,740  
Assets held for sale to NAMA(1) (note 26)
    9,581        
Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
               
- Trading securities (note 20)
    403       125  
- Other financial assets(2)
    3,275       3,207  
Derivative financial instruments (note 21)
    5,824       8,397  
Available for sale financial assets(3) (note 24)
    20,884       26,796  
Other assets(4)
    1,118       1,073  
                 
Total on balance sheet
    165,555       181,224  
Contingent liabilities and commitments (note 44)
    27,456       29,487  
                 
Total maximum exposure
    193,011       210,711  
                 
 
 
(1) Assets held for sale to NAMA include derivatives and accrued interest (see note 26).
 
(2) Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss includes government bonds, unit trusts, debt securities, loans and advances, and excludes equity securities as they are not subject to credit risk (see note 22).
 
(3) Available for sale financial assets excludes equity securities (see note 24).
 
(4) Other assets includes interest receivable and the reinsurance asset.
 
Credit Risk Management
 
The Group’s approach to the management of credit risk is focused on a detailed analysis at origination followed by early intervention and active management of accounts where creditworthiness has deteriorated. Given the changed credit and economic environment over the past two years, and the potential for further deterioration in the financial situation of borrowers, the Group has enhanced its approach to credit management.
 
In May 2009, a new organisational structure was put in place. This structure includes the creation of an enhanced Credit & Market Risk function and the appointment of a Group Chief Credit & Market Risk Officer with responsibility for the management of credit and market risk and overall risk reporting to the Group Executive team, the Court Risk Committee (“CRC”) and the Court.
 
The objectives of the Credit & Market Risk function are to provide strong independent oversight and management of the Group’s credit risk strategy, credit risk management information and credit risk underwriting as well as strategic oversight and the management of certain challenged portfolios.


F-142


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
The Group continues to enhance a range of initiatives to deal with the effects of the continued deterioration in the credit environment and decline in asset quality, such as the following:
 
•  enhancement of collections and recoveries processes;
 
•  the creation and the expansion of existing specialist work out teams to ensure early intervention and resolution;
 
•  more frequent and intensive review cycles for ‘at risk’ exposures and management of excess positions;
 
•  reviews of industry/market sectors considered to be more vulnerable;
 
•  support from central teams in managing ‘at risk/challenged’ portfolios at a business unit level;
 
•  increased centralised control over restructures by Group Credit Committee (“GCC”); and
 
•  tighter/modified lending criteria for specific sectors.
 
The segregation of ‘at risk’ assets and realignment of resources allows remaining portfolio managers to focus on the ‘acceptable quality’ book and to work closely with those customers to help them maintain healthy working capital/cash flow positions.
 
The weakened international financial environment and large bank failures/rescues since September 2008 means that the Group is exposed to increased counterparty risk. The Group has invoked a number of measures to mitigate this increased risk. These include reduced individual bank exposures, enhanced credit risk management procedures for vulnerable exposures, actively managing down these exposures and the application of tighter credit policy criteria where required.
 
Credit policy
 
The core values and principles governing the provision of credit are contained in the Group Credit Policy, which is approved by the Court, on the advice of the CRC and the recommendation of the Group Risk Policy Committee (“GRPC”). Individual business unit credit policies, approved by the GRPC/Head of Risk Strategy, Analysis & Reporting as appropriate, define in greater detail the credit approach appropriate to the units concerned, taking account of the markets in which they operate and the products they provide. In a number of cases, business unit policies are supplemented by sectoral credit policies. Each staff member involved in developing banking relationships and/or in assessing or managing credit is expected to be fully conversant with applicable policies and procedures and has a responsibility to ensure compliance with these policies. Procedures for the approval and monitoring of exceptions to policy are included within the policy documents.
 
Lending authorisation
 
The Group’s credit risk management systems operate through a hierarchy of lending authorities, which are related to internal loan ratings. All exposures above certain levels require approval by the Group Credit Committee (“GCC”). Other exposures are approved according to a system of tiered individual authorities. Individuals are allocated lending limits according to credit competence, proven judgment, experience and the nature and scale of lending in their business unit.
 
Material lending proposals are referred to credit units for independent assessment/approval or formulation of a recommendation and subsequent adjudication by the applicable level of approval authority.


F-143


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
Credit Reporting/Monitoring
 
It is the Group’s policy to ensure that adequate up to date credit management information is available to support the credit management of individual account relationships and the overall loan portfolio. Information is produced on a timely basis and at a frequency interval that reflects the purpose of the report.
 
Credit risk at a Group, divisional and significant operating unit/product type level is reported on a monthly basis to senior management. This monthly reporting includes information and detailed commentary on loan book growth, quality of the loan book (credit grade and Probability of Default (PD) profiles and Risk Weighted Assets), concentrations and loan impairment provisions including individual large impaired exposures. The report and commentaries are consistent across the Group, delivering an assessment of trends in the loan book.
 
On a quarterly basis, the Portfolio Review Committee (“PRC”) considers a credit concentration report, which tracks changes in sectoral and single name concentrations as measured under agreed parameters. This report also details the Group’s largest individual credit exposures.
 
Trends in Economic Capital usage in the Group’s main lending businesses are also reported to the PRC on a quarterly basis. This report acts to highlight changes to risk concentration in the Group’s loan book.
 
Credit risk is also reported monthly in the Court Risk Report. This report is presented to and discussed by the GRPC, the CRC and the Court.
 
Along with the stated suite of monthly and quarterly reporting, ad hoc reports are submitted to senior management and the Court as required.
 
Group Credit Review (“GCR”), an independent function within Group Internal Audit, reviews the quality and management of credit risk assets across the Group and reports to the GRPC on a quarterly basis. The reviews cover lending units in each division and incorporate an examination of adherence to credit policies and credit procedures across the various portfolios. GCR also addresses the timeliness of the annual review process and the quality of credit assessment in each portfolio.
 
Credit related commitments
 
The Group classifies and manages credit related commitments that are not reflected as loans and advances on the balance sheet, as follows:
 
Guarantees and standby letters of credit:  irrevocable commitments by the Group to make payments at a future date in specified circumstances on behalf of a customer. These instruments are assessed on the same basis as loans for credit approval and management.
 
Performance or similar bonds and guarantees:  Group undertakings on behalf of a customer to deliver funds to a third party in specified circumstances should the customer fail in their obligations to the third party. These instruments are assessed on the same basis as loans for credit approval and management.
 
Documentary and commercial letters of credit:  written undertakings by the Group on behalf of a customer authorising a third party to draw drafts or payment instruments on the Group to a stipulated amount under specific terms and conditions. Also, situations where the Group confirms/guarantees to a foreign bank in respect of export letters of credit. These instruments are collateralised by the underlying shipment of goods to which they relate and are assessed on the same basis as loans for credit approval and management.
 
Commitments:  unused elements of authorised credit in the form of loans, guarantees or letters of credit, where the Group is potentially exposed to loss in an amount equal to the total unused commitments. The likely amount of loss is less than the total unused commitments, as most commitments are contingent upon customers maintaining


F-144


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
specific credit and performance standards. These instruments are assessed on the same basis as loans for credit approval and management.
 
Letters of offer:  where the Group has made an irrevocable offer to extend credit to a customer and the customer may or may not have confirmed acceptance of the offer on the terms outlined and within the specified timeframe. The exposure is assessed on the same basis as loans for credit approval and management. The exposure to credit risk is considerably less than the face value of offer letters, as not all offers are accepted.
 
Counterparty Credit Risk arising from derivatives
 
Credit risk exposure arising from derivative instruments (i.e. counterparty credit risk exposure) is managed as part of the overall lending limits with customers and financial institutions.
 
Credit risk exposure on derivative transactions is calculated based on a methodology involving the current value of the contract (mark to market) and an estimate of the maximum cost of rewriting the contract in the event of counterparty default. This credit risk exposure is managed as part of the overall lending limits with customers and financial institutions. The credit process also limits gross derivative positions. Collateral or other security may be required from counterparties.
 
The Group has executed standard internationally recognised documents such as International Swaps and Derivative Association (ISDA) agreements and Credit Support Annexes (CSAs) with its principal interbank derivative counterparties and a very high proportion of its total interbank derivatives book is covered by CSAs and is hence collateralised. The purpose of a CSA is to limit the potential cost of replacing derivative contracts at market prices in the event of default by the original counterparty.
 
Currently all collateral for derivative counterparty risk is in the form of cash.
 
Country Risk
 
The Group is exposed to country risk. Exposures are managed in line with approved policy and country maximum exposure limits.
 
Settlement Risk
 
Settlement risk arises in any situation where a payment in cash, securities or equities is made in expectation of a corresponding receipt in cash, securities or equities. Daily settlement limits are established for each counterparty to cover the aggregate of all settlement risks arising from the Group’s market transactions on any single day.
 
Credit Concentration Risk
 
Credit concentration risk is the risk of loss due to exposures to a single entity or group of entities engaged in similar activities and having similar economic characteristics and/or dependencies that would cause their ability to meet contractual obligations to be similarly affected by changes in economic or other conditions. Undue concentrations could lead to increased volatility in the Group’s expected outcomes. The management of credit concentration risk is governed by the Group’s Credit Concentration Policy as approved by the GRPC.


F-145


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
Loans & advances to customers and loans held for sale to NAMA (Total loans)
 
The following table gives the geographic and industry breakdown of gross loans and advances to customers (before impairment provisions) based on the location of the business unit where the borrowing is booked.
 
                                                 
    Total loans and advances to
  Total loans and advances to
    customers December 31, 2009   customers March 31, 2009
        UK &
          UK &
   
Geographical/industry analysis
  Ireland   other   Total   Ireland   other   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Personal
                                               
- Residential mortgages
    28,196       32,274       60,470       27,647       31,241       58,888  
- Other consumer lending
    2,906       1,434       4,340       3,406       2,231       5,637  
Property and construction
    19,472       16,038       35,510       19,358       14,597       33,955  
Business and other services
    11,983       3,627       15,610       10,782       6,032       16,814  
Manufacturing
    4,511       1,744       6,255       6,049       1,740       7,789  
Distribution
    4,463       525       4,988       3,343       795       4,138  
Transport
    778       618       1,396       935       319       1,254  
Financial
    1,088       1,354       2,442       1,919       349       2,268  
Agriculture
    1,726       388       2,114       1,954       57       2,011  
Energy
    1,438       108       1,546       2,555       212       2,767  
                                                 
Total
    76,561       58,110       134,671       77,948       57,573       135,521  
                                                 
 
The following table gives the geographic and industry breakdown of gross loans held for sale to NAMA (before impairment provisions) based on the location of the underlying property.
 
                                                 
    Loans held for sale to NAMA
  Loans held for sale to NAMA
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
        UK &
          UK &
   
Geographical/industry analysis
  Ireland   other   Total   Ireland   other   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Personal
                                               
- Residential mortgages
    68             68                    
- Other consumer lending
                                   
Property and construction
    7,503       4,453       11,956                    
Business and other services
    188       8       196                    
Manufacturing
    7             7                    
Distribution
                                   
Transport
                                   
Financial
                                   
Agriculture
    8             8                    
Energy
                                   
                                                 
Total
    7,774       4,461       12,235                    
                                                 


F-146


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
The Group’s primary markets are Ireland and the UK and exposures originated and managed in these countries represent a material concentration of credit risk. Similarly, the Group exhibits a material concentration in Residential mortgages and the Property and construction sector. The level of concentration in the Property and construction sector will be reduced following the transfer of loans of circa. €12.2 billion (before impairment provisions) to NAMA.
 
The Group’s Residential mortgage portfolio is widely diversified by individual borrower and amounted to 45% of Total loans at December 31, 2009 (March 31, 2009: 44%). 47% of Residential mortgages related to Ireland and 53% related to the UK (both percentages unchanged from March 31, 2009).
 
The Property and construction sector accounted for 27% or €36 billion of the Group loan book as at December 31, 2009 (March 31, 2009: 25% or €34 billion). This book includes both investment loans and land and development loans. The increase since March 31, 2009 is primarily due to additional loan drawdowns of committed facilities and the impact of movements in exchange rates.
 
Large Exposures
 
The Group’s Credit Concentration Policy and regulatory guidelines set out the maximum exposure limits to a customer or a group of connected customers. The policy and regulatory guidelines cover both bank and non-bank counterparties.
 
The Group limits risk concentration in individual non-bank credit exposures to 10% of total tier 1 capital. This limit is based on aggregate “clean credit commitments”, defined as total credit exposure less any amounts covered by pledged cash, Government Guarantee or acceptable Bank Guarantee. No single customer exposure exceeds regulatory guidelines.
 
At December 31, 2009, the Group’s top 50 non-Bank exposures amounted to €13.6 billion and accounted for 10% (March 31, 2009: €14.9 billion and 11%) of the Group’s loans and advances to customers including loans held for sale to NAMA. Of this amount at December 31, 2009 €3.7 billion relates to loans held for sale to NAMA.
 
Credit Risk Assessment & Measurement
 
All credit transactions are assessed at origination for credit quality and the borrower is assigned a credit grade based on a predefined credit rating scale. The risk, and consequently credit grade, is reassessed periodically as part of the transaction review process.
 
The use of internal credit rating models and scoring tools, which measure the degree of risk inherent in lending to specific counterparties, is central to the credit risk assessment and ongoing management processes within the Group. The primary model measures used are:
 
•  Probability of Default: the probability of a given counterparty defaulting on any of its borrowings from the Group within the next twelve months;
 
•  Exposure at Default: the exposure the Group has to a defaulting borrower at the time of default;
 
•  Loss Given Default: the loss incurred on a specific transaction should the borrower default, expressed as a percentage of Exposure at Default; and
 
•  Maturity: the contractual or estimated time period until an exposure is fully repaid or cancelled.
 
These measures are used to calculate expected loss and are fully embedded in, and form an essential component of, the Group’s operational and strategic credit risk management and credit pricing practices.


F-147


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
For the Group’s retail consumer and smaller business portfolios, which are characterised by a large volume of customers with smaller individual exposures, the credit risk assessment is grounded on application and behavioural scoring tools. For larger commercial and corporate customers, the risk assessment is underpinned by statistical risk rating models which incorporate quantitative information from the customer (e.g. financial accounts) together with a qualitative assessment of non-financial risk factors such as management quality and market/trading outlook.
 
Other financial assets are assigned an internal rating supported by external ratings of the major rating agencies.
 
The credit risk rating systems employed within the Group use statistical analysis combined, where appropriate, with external data and the judgement of professional lenders.
 
An independent unit reporting to Group Internal Audit annually validates internal credit risk models from a performance and compliance perspective. This unit provides reports to the Risk Measurement Committee (RMC).
 
Risk modelling is also applied at a portfolio level in the Group’s credit businesses to guide economic capital allocation and strategic portfolio management.
 
The measures to calculate credit risk referred to above are used to calculate expected loss. A different basis is used to derive the amount of incurred credit losses for financial reporting purposes. For financial reporting purposes, impairment allowances are recognised only with respect to losses that have been incurred at the balance sheet date based on objective evidence of impairment.
 
Credit Risk Mitigation
 
An assessment of the borrower’s ability to service and repay the proposed level of debt is undertaken for credit requests and is a key element in the Group’s approach to mitigating risk. In addition, the Group mitigates credit risk through the adoption of both proactive preventative measures (e.g. controls and limits) and the development and implementation of strategies to assess and reduce the impact of particular risks, should these materialise (e.g. hedging, securitisation and collateralisation).
 
Controls and limits
 
The Group imposes risk control limits and guide points to mitigate significant concentration risk. These limits and guide points are informed by the Group’s loss tolerance guide points and are set in the context of the Group’s risk strategy and risk appetite.
 
The GRPC approves country maximum exposure limits annually based on internal country risk rating models supported by external ratings.
 
Maximum exposure limits for lending to banks are also approved annually by the GRPC for each rating category based on credit risk modelling techniques combined with expert judgement.
 
Risk transfer and financing strategies
 
The objective of risk mitigation/transfer is to limit the risk impact to acceptable (quantitative and qualitative) levels and protect Group income streams.
 
Where the risk review process indicates the possible emergence of undue risk concentrations, appropriate risk transfer and mitigation options are explored and recommended to the Portfolio Review Committee (PRC). These options may include hedging strategies and securitisation programmes.
 
The Group currently makes very limited use of hedging strategies or credit derivatives for risk mitigation purposes. A number of securitisation transactions for residential and commercial mortgages and a collateralised debt


F-148


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
obligation (CDO) vehicle, primarily for leveraged loans, have been undertaken. The primary purpose of these initiatives was for contingent liquidity management.
 
Collateral
 
Credit risk mitigation includes the requirement to obtain collateral, depending on the nature of the product and local market practice, as set out in the Group’s policies and procedures. The nature and level of security required depends on a number of factors, including but not limited to the amount of the exposure, the type of facility provided, the term of the facility, the amount of the borrower’s own cash input and an evaluation of the level of risk or probability of default.
 
A variety of types of collateral are accepted, including property, securities, cash, guarantees and insurance, grouped broadly as follows:
 
•  Financial collateral (lien over deposits, shares, etc.);
 
•  Residential and commercial real estate;
 
•  Physical collateral (plant & machinery, stock, etc.); and
 
•  Other collateral (debtors, guarantees, insurance, etc.).
 
The Group’s requirements around completion, valuation and management requirements for collateral are set out in appropriate Group or business unit policies and procedures. The Group has availed of the option under IFRS 7 not to disclose the fair value of collateral held against past due or impaired financial assets given that it is operationally impracticable.
 
Master Netting Arrangements
 
The Group reduces its exposure to credit losses by entering into master netting arrangements with counterparties with which it undertakes a significant volume of transactions. Master netting arrangements do not generally result in an offset of balance sheet assets and liabilities, as transactions are usually settled on a gross basis. However, the credit risk associated with favourable contracts is reduced by a master netting arrangement to the extent that, if a default occurs, all amounts with the counterparty are terminated and settled on a “net” basis.
 
Loan Loss Provisioning Methodology
 
Through its ongoing credit review processes, the Group seeks to identify deteriorating loans early with a view to taking corrective action to prevent the loan becoming impaired. Typically, loans that are at risk of impairment are managed by dedicated specialist units/debt collection teams focused on “working out” loans.
 
The identification of loans for assessment as impaired is driven by the Group’s credit risk rating systems. It is the Group’s policy to provide for impairment promptly and consistently across the loan book. For those loans that become impaired, the focus is to minimise the loss that the Group will incur from the impairment. This may involve entering into restructuring arrangements or action to enforce security or legal pursuit of individuals who are personally liable for the loan.
 
All credit exposures, either individually or collectively, are regularly reviewed for objective evidence of impairment; where such evidence of impairment exists, the exposure is measured for an impairment provision. The criteria used to determine that there is objective evidence of impairment include:
 
•  delinquency in contractual payments of principal or interest;
 
•  cash flow difficulties;


F-149


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
 
•  breach of loan covenants or conditions;
 
•  deterioration of the borrower’s competitive position;
 
•  deterioration in the value of collateral;
 
•  external rating downgrade below an acceptable level; and
 
•  initiation of bankruptcy proceedings.
 
Where objective evidence of impairment exists, as a result of one or more past events, the Group is required to estimate the recoverable amount of the exposure or group of exposures.
 
For financial reporting purposes, loans on the Balance Sheet that become impaired are written down to their estimated recoverable amount. The amount of this write down is taken as an impairment charge to the income statement.
 
The Group’s impairment provisioning methodologies are compliant with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). International Accounting Standard (IAS) 39 requires that there is objective evidence of impairment and that the loss has been incurred. The standard does not permit the recognition of expected losses, no matter how likely these expected losses may appear.
 
All exposures are assessed for impairment either individually or collectively.
 
Methodology for Individually Assessing Impairment
 
An individual impairment assessment is performed for any exposure for which there is objective evidence of impairment, and where the exposure is above an agreed minimum threshold. The carrying amount of the exposure net of the estimated recoverable amount (and thus the specific provision required) is calculated using a discounted cashflow analysis. This calculates the estimated recoverable amount as the present value of the estimated future cash flows, discounted at the exposure’s original effective interest rate (or the current effective interest rate for variable rate exposures). The estimated future cashflows include forecasted principal and interest payments (not necessarily contractual amounts due) including cash flows, if any, from the realisation of collateral/security held, less realisation costs.
 
In the context of the Group’s impaired land and development property assets, where recovery and/or repayment is likely to be generated from asset sales and/or realisation of the property collateral, estimated cashflows are based on valuations from one or more different methods, in light of the restricted market liquidity that currently exists. These valuation methods include valuations from independent external professionals, estimates based on verbal consultations with external valuers, local market knowledge provided by relevant bank management, and residual value methodologies. The appropriate methodological application depends on the particular circumstances of the loan and underlying collateral, e.g. the degree of liquidity and recent transactional evidence in the relevant market segment, the type, size and location of the property asset and its development potential and marketability.
 
Given the absence of sufficient transactional evidence and market liquidity, up to date, independent and professional valuations in writing are sought in certain circumstances. Whilst less formal than written valuations, verbal consultations with external valuers can help benchmark asset values and provide general information on market developments and trends. The application of local market knowledge occurs typically where the loan and underlying property asset are relatively small and relevant bank management has in-depth knowledge of both the property asset and local market conditions, which may be illiquid. In such cases, estimated valuations of undeveloped sites may be expressed on a ‘per plot’ basis if there is suitable zoning/planning in place, whereas unzoned rural land may be assumed to have only agricultural value. Residual value methodologies are used to estimate the current value of a site or part-completed development based on a detailed appraisal that assesses the


F-150


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
costs (building, funding and other costs) and receipts (forecast sales and/or lettings) associated with bringing a development to completion. This valuation methodology may be applied when a property asset is considered to have realistic development potential given current or anticipated planning status, projected marketability etc.
 
After applying one or more of the above methodologies, the resulting valuations show a wide range of discounts (typically between 40% and 90%) to estimated peak market values for the underlying property collateral assets. Key influencing factors as to the level of discount include the type of property asset (with undeveloped land incurring a relatively high discount), the status of zoning and planning, and the location in terms of both jurisdiction/region and proximate environment, e.g. whether city centre, suburban, provincial town or rural.
 
Methodology for Collectively Assessing Impairment
 
Where exposures fall below the threshold for individual assessment of impairment, such exposures with similar credit risk characteristics (e.g. portfolio of consumer personal loans) are pooled and are collectively assessed for impairment. A provision is then calculated by estimating the future cash flows of a group of exposures that are collectively evaluated for impairment. This estimation considers the expected contractual cash flows of the exposures in a portfolio and the historical loss experience for exposures with credit risk characteristics similar to those in the portfolio being assessed. Assumptions and parameters used to create the portfolio provision, which are based on historical experience (i.e. amount and timing of cashflows/loss given default), are regularly compared against current experience in the loan book and current market conditions.
 
Where there is objective evidence of impairment on a collective basis, this is reported as a specific provision in line with individually assessed loans.
 
Methodology for establishing Incurred but not reported (IBNR) provisions
 
Impairment provisions are also recognised for losses not specifically identified but which, experience and observable data indicate, are present in the portfolio at the date of assessment. These are described as incurred but not reported provisions. Statistical models are used to determine the appropriate level of IBNR provisions. These models estimate latent losses taking into account three observed and/or estimated factors:
 
•  loss emergence rates (based on historic grade migration experience or probability of default);
 
•  the emergence period (historic experience, adjusted to reflect the current conditions and the credit management model); and
 
•  loss given default rates (loss and recovery rates using historical loan loss experience, adjusted where appropriate to reflect current observable data).
 
Account performance is reviewed periodically to confirm that the credit grade or probability of default assigned remains appropriate and to determine if impairment has arisen. For consumer and smaller ticket commercial exposures, the review is largely based on account behaviour and is highly automated. Where there are loan arrears, excesses, dormancy, etc. the account is downgraded to reflect the higher underlying risk. For larger commercial loans, the relationship manager re-assesses the risk at least annually (more frequently if circumstances or grade require) and re-affirms or amends the grade (credit and Probability of Default (“PD”) grade) in light of new information or changes (e.g. up to date financials or changed market outlook). Grade migration and adjusted PD grades are analysed for inclusion in the loss model. Recent data sets are used in order to capture current trends, rather than averaging over a period which might include earlier and less stressed points in the credit cycle.
 
Emergence period is calculated using historical loan loss experience, adjusted to reflect the more intensive credit management model in place, where all vulnerable portfolios are reviewed on a shortened cycle. The range of emergence periods is typically three to nine months.


F-151


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
Loss given default is calculated using historical loan loss experience, adjusted where appropriate to apply management’s credit expertise to reflect current observable data (including assessment of the deterioration in the property sector, discounted collateral values, rising unemployment and reduced repayment prospects, etc).
 
An analysis of the Group’s impairment provisions at December 31, 2009 is set out on pages F-158 and F-159.
 
Other factors taken into consideration in estimating provisions include local and international economic climates, changes in credit management processes and policies, changes in portfolio risk profile and the effect of any external factors such as legal or competition requirements.
 
Whilst provisioning is an ongoing process, all business units formally review and confirm the appropriateness of their provisioning methodologies and the adequacy of their impairment provisions on a half yearly basis. Their conclusions are reviewed by the Credit & Market Risk function and the GRPC.
 
The Group’s provisioning methodology is approved by the GRPC on a half yearly basis.
 
The quantum of the Group’s loan loss charge, impaired loans balances and provisions is also reviewed by the GRPC semi annually, in advance of providing a recommendation to the Group Audit Committee.
 
Asset Quality — Financial Assets
 
The Group classifies financial assets as ‘neither past due nor impaired’, ‘past due but not impaired’ and ‘impaired’ in line with the requirements of IFRS 7.
 
The Group uses internal ratings, based on an assessment of the credit quality of the customer, as part of its credit risk management system. A thirteen point credit grade rating scale is used for more complex, individually managed exposures, including wholesale, corporate and business lending. A seven point credit grade rating scale is used for standard products (including mortgages, personal and small business loans). Both credit scales have a defined relationship with the Group’s Probability of Default (PD) scale.
 
Other financial assets are assigned an internal rating supported by external ratings of the major rating agencies.
 
Loans and advances to customers and loans held for sale to NAMA are assigned an internal credit grade by the Group based on an assessment of the credit quality of the borrower.
 
‘Neither past due nor impaired’ ratings are summarised as set out below:
 
•  high quality ratings apply to highly rated financial obligors, strong corporate and business counterparties and consumer banking borrowers (including residential mortgages) with whom the Group has an excellent repayment experience. High quality ratings are derived from grades 1 to 4 on the thirteen point grade scale, grades 1 and 2 on the seven point grade scale and ratings equivalent to AAA, AA+, AA, AA-, A+, A, A-, BBB+ and BBB for the external major rating agencies;
 
•  satisfactory quality ratings apply to good quality financial assets that are performing as expected, including loans and advances to small and medium sized enterprises, leveraged entities and more recently established businesses. Satisfactory quality ratings also include some element of the Group’s retail portfolios. Satisfactory quality ratings are derived from grades 5 to 7 on the thirteen point grade scale, grade 3 on the seven point grade scale and external ratings equivalent to BBB-, BB+, BB and BB-;
 
•  acceptable quality ratings apply to customers with increased risk profiles that are subject to closer monitoring and scrutiny by lenders with the objective of managing risk and moving accounts to an improved rating category. Acceptable quality ratings are derived from grades 8 and 9 on the thirteen point grade scale, grade 4 outstandings within the seven point scale and external ratings equivalent to B+; and


F-152


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
 
•  the lower quality but not past due nor impaired rating applies to those financial assets that are neither in arrears nor impaired but where the Group requires a work down or work out of the relationship unless an early reduction in risk is achievable. Lower quality ratings are derived from outstandings within rating grades 10 and 11 on the thirteen point grade scale and grade 5 on the seven point grade scale and external ratings equivalent to B or below.
 
‘Past due but not impaired loans’ are defined as follows:
 
•  loans where repayment of interest and/or principal are overdue by at least one day but are not impaired.
 
‘Impaired loans’ are defined as follows:
 
•  loans with a specific impairment provision attaching to them together with loans (excluding residential mortgages) which are more than 90 days in arrears; and
 
•  all assets in grades 12 and 13 on the thirteen point grade scale and grades 6 and 7 on the seven point grade scale are impaired.
 
Asset Quality — loans and advances to customers including loans held for sale to NAMA (Total loans)
 
                                                 
    Gross loans and
  Loans held for
   
December 31, 2009
  advances to customers   sale to NAMA   Total loans
    €m   %   €m   %   €m   %
 
Asset quality
                                               
High quality
    68,654       56.1 %     561       4.6 %     69,215       51.4 %
Satisfactory quality
    27,665       22.6 %     2,014       16.5 %     29,679       22.1 %
Acceptable quality
    11,380       9.3 %     2,266       18.5 %     13,646       10.1 %
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
    2,773       2.3 %     575       4.7 %     3,348       2.5 %
                                                 
Neither past due nor impaired
    110,472       90.2 %     5,416       44.3 %     115,888       86.1 %
Past due but not impaired
    5,177       4.2 %     255       2.1 %     5,432       4.0 %
Impaired
    6,787       5.5 %     6,564       53.6 %     13,351       9.9 %
                                                 
Total loans and advances to customers
    122,436       100.0 %     12,235       100.0 %     134,671       100.0 %
                                                 
 
                                                 
    Gross loans and
  Loans held for
   
March 31, 2009
  advances to customers   sale to NAMA   Total loans
    €m   %   €m   %   €m   %
 
Asset quality
                                               
High quality
    72,465       53.5 %       —         —       72,465       53.5 %
Satisfactory quality
    37,087       27.3 %                 37,087       27.3 %
Acceptable quality
    12,556       9.3 %                 12,556       9.3 %
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
    2,330       1.7 %                 2,330       1.7 %
                                                 
Neither past due nor impaired
    124,438       91.8 %                 124,438       91.8 %
Past due but not impaired
    5,761       4.3 %                 5,761       4.3 %
Impaired
    5,322       3.9 %                 5,322       3.9 %
                                                 
Total loans and advances to customers
    135,521       100.0 %                 135,521       100.0 %
                                                 


F-153


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
On December 31, 2009, the Group classified those loans and advances to customers expected to transfer to NAMA as loans held for sale to NAMA. For ease of comparative purposes the tables and commentary presents the loans and advances to customers of €122 billion and loans held for sale to NAMA of approx. €12 billion, together these are referred to as Total loans.
 
Asset quality continues to deteriorate on a declining loan book. Total loans classified as ‘neither past due nor impaired’ have declined in both volume and percentage terms, with a significant rise in impaired loans in the period from €5.3 billion at March 31, 2009 to €13.4 billion at December 31, 2009. Of the impaired loans at December 31, 2009, 49% or €6.6 billion are expected to transfer to NAMA.
 
Total loans classified as ‘neither past due nor impaired’ accounted for 86.1% of the Group loan book at December 31, 2009 compared to 91.8% at March 31, 2009. The movement is due primarily to the deterioration in the global and Irish economic environments, resulting in continuing low levels of economic activity across our main markets, impacting upon credit quality.
 
In the ‘past due but not impaired’ category, both the quantum and percentage of the Total loans are down from €5.8 billion or 4.3% at March 31, 2009 to €5.4 billion or 4.0% at December 31, 2009. This reduction is mainly due to the movement of exposures into the ‘impaired’ category during the period.
 
‘Impaired’ loans increased from €5.3 billion at March 31, 2009 to €13.4 billion at December 31, 2009, an increase of 151%. This increase in impaired loans reflects the severe deterioration in general economic conditions, weaker consumer sentiment and a sharp slowdown in the Property and construction sector, particularly in the land and development sub-sector. Property and construction accounts for 72% of all impaired loans.
 
The Group currently expects that approx. €12.2 billion of loans may transfer to NAMA (classified as loans held for sale to NAMA). Of these assets of approx. €12.2 billion, 44% or €5.4 billion are classified as ‘neither past due nor impaired’, 2% or €0.3 billion are classified as ‘past due but not impaired’ and 54% or €6.6 billion are classified as impaired. Of the €6.6 billion impaired loans, €6.5 billion or 98% relates to the Property and construction portfolio with €5.2 billion or 80% of this relating to land and development.
 
Asset Quality — Loans and advances to customers & loans held for sale to NAMA (Total loans)
 
The tables and analysis below summarise the Group’s Total loans over the following categories: ‘neither past due nor impaired’, ‘past due but not impaired’ and ‘impaired’. Exposures are based on the gross amount before provisions for impairment.
 
                                         
        Non-Property
           
December 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Loans and advances to customers
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Financial assets neither past due nor impaired
    56,600       30,821       19,390       3,661       110,472  
Financial assets past due but not impaired
    3,331       625       968       253       5,177  
Impaired financial assets
    471       2,694       3,196       426       6,787  
                                         
Total
    60,402       34,140       23,554       4,340       122,436  
                                         
 


F-154


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56 RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
                                         
        Non-Property
           
December 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Loans held for sale to NAMA
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Financial assets neither past due nor impaired
    30       97       5,289             5,416  
Financial assets past due but not impaired
    38       2       215             255  
Impaired financial assets
          112       6,452             6,564  
                                         
Total
    68       211       11,956             12,235  
                                         
 
                                         
        Non-Property
           
December 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Total loans
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Financial assets neither past due nor impaired
    56,630       30,918       24,679       3,661       115,888  
Financial assets past due but not impaired
    3,369       627       1,183       253       5,432  
Impaired financial assets
    471       2,806       9,648       426       13,351  
                                         
Total
    60,470       34,351       35,510       4,340       134,671  
                                         
 
                                         
        Non-Property
           
March 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Total loans
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Financial assets neither past due nor impaired
    55,877       35,081       28,525       4,955       124,438  
Financial assets past due but not impaired
    2,782       773       1,892       314       5,761  
Impaired financial assets
    229       1,187       3,538       368       5,322  
                                         
Total
    58,888       37,041       33,955       5,637       135,521  
                                         
 
Financial Assets ‘neither past due nor impaired’: Loans and advances to customers & loans held for sale to NAMA (Total loans)
 
The tables below provide an analysis of Total loans ‘neither past due nor impaired’ by asset classification based on an assessment of the credit quality of the borrower.
 
                                         
December 31, 2009
      Non-Property
           
Risk profile
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Loans and advances to customers neither past due nor impaired
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
High quality
    56,600       8,298       1,073       2,683       68,654  
Satisfactory quality
          15,712       11,060       893       27,665  
Acceptable quality
          5,098       6,197       85       11,380  
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
          1,713       1,060             2,773  
                                         
Total
    56,600       30,821       19,390       3,661       110,472  
                                         
 

F-155


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56 RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
                                         
December 31, 2009
      Non-Property
           
Risk profile
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Loans held for sale to NAMA neither past due nor impaired
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
High quality
    30       5       526             561  
Satisfactory quality
          40       1,974             2,014  
Acceptable quality
          32       2,234             2,266  
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
          20       555             575  
                                         
Total
    30       97       5,289             5,416  
                                         
 
                                         
December 31, 2009
      Non-Property
           
Risk profile
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Total loans neither past due nor impaired
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
High quality
    56,630       8,303       1,599       2,683       69,215  
Satisfactory quality
          15,752       13,034       893       29,679  
Acceptable quality
          5,130       8,431       85       13,646  
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
          1,733       1,615             3,348  
                                         
Total
    56,630       30,918       24,679       3,661       115,888  
                                         
 
                                         
March 31, 2009
      Non-Property
           
Risk profile
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Total loans and advances to customers neither past due nor impaired
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
High quality
    55,877       10,555       2,370       3,663       72,465  
Satisfactory quality
          18,417       17,613       1,057       37,087  
Acceptable quality
          5,188       7,157       211       12,556  
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
          921       1,385       24       2,330  
                                         
Total
    55,877       35,081       28,525       4,955       124,438  
                                         
 
Financial Assets ‘past due but not impaired’: Loans and advances to customers & loans held for sale to NAMA (Total loans)
 
The tables below provide an aged analysis of financial assets ‘past due but not impaired’ by asset classification. Amounts arising from operational/timing issues that are outside the control of customers are generally excluded.
 
                                         
        Non-Property
           
December 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Loans and advances to customers past due but not impaired
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Past due up to 30 days
    1,159       440       495       132       2,226  
Past due 31 — 60 days
    531       115       324       86       1,056  
Past due 61 — 90 days
    281       70       149       29       529  
Past due more than 90 days
    1,360                   6       1,366  
                                         
Total
    3,331       625       968       253       5,177  
                                         
 

F-156


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56 RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
                                         
        Non-Property
           
December 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Loans held for sale to NAMA past due but not impaired
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Past due up to 30 days
          2       95             97  
Past due 31 — 60 days
                15             15  
Past due 61 — 90 days
    38             105             143  
Past due more than 90 days
                             
                                         
Total
    38       2       215             255  
                                         
 
                                         
        Non-Property
           
December 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Total loans and advances to customers past due but not impaired
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Past due up to 30 days
    1,159       442       590       132       2,323  
Past due 31 — 60 days
    531       115       339       86       1,071  
Past due 61 — 90 days
    319       70       254       29       672  
Past due more than 90 days
    1,360                   6       1,366  
                                         
Total
    3,369       627       1,183       253       5,432  
                                         
 
                                         
        Non-Property
           
March 31, 2009
  Residential
  SME and
  Property and
       
Total loans Past due but not impaired
  mortgages   corporate   construction   Consumer   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Past due up to 30 days
    1,021       389       743       160       2,313  
Past due 31 — 60 days
    510       179       452       110       1,251  
Past due 61 — 90 days
    306       149       630       34       1,119  
Past due more than 90 days
    945       56       67       10       1,078  
                                         
Total
    2,782       773       1,892       314       5,761  
                                         
 
The tables above highlight that the volume of Residential mortgages that are past due but not impaired have increased by 21% from €2.8 billion at March 31, 2009 to €3.4 billion at December 31, 2009. The volume of Residential mortgages that are past due more than 90 days have increased from €0.9 billion at March 31, 2009 to €1.4 billion at December 31, 2009. This reflects the impact on the level of arrears from rising unemployment and lower disposable income.
 
The volume of Property and construction loans that are ‘past due but not impaired’ have fallen from €1.9 billion at March 31, 2009 to €1.2 billion at December 31, 2009. This reflects the increase in impaired loans in this portfolio.

F-157


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
Financial Assets ‘Impaired’: Loans and advances to customers & loans held for sale to NAMA (Total loans)
 
                                         
                    Impairment
            Impaired
      provisions
December 31, 2009
          loans
      as % of
Total loans and advances to customers
      Impaired
  as % of
  Impairment
  impaired
Composition and Impairment
  Advances   loans   advances   provisions   loans
    €m   €m   %   €m   %
 
Residential mortgages
    60,402       471       0.8 %     359       76 %
Non-property SME and corporate
    34,140       2,694       7.9 %     1,134       42 %
Property and construction
    23,554       3,196       13.6 %     1,124       35 %
Consumer
    4,340       426       9.8 %     380       89 %
                                         
Total loans and advances to customers
    122,436       6,787       5.5 %     2,997       44 %
                                         
 
                                         
                    Impairment
            Impaired
      provisions
December 31, 2009
          loans
      as % of
Loans held for sale to NAMA
      Impaired
  as % of
  Impairment
  impaired
Composition and Impairment
  Advances   loans   advances   provisions   loans
    €m   €m   %   €m   %
 
Residential mortgages
    68                          
Non-property SME and corporate
    211       112       53.1 %     18       16 %
Property and construction
    11,956       6,452       54.0 %     2,760       43 %
Consumer
                             
                                         
Total loans and advances to customers
    12,235       6,564       53.6 %     2,778       42 %
                                         
 
                                         
                    Impairment
            Impaired
      provisions
December 31, 2009
          loans
      as % of
Total loans
      Impaired
  as % of
  Impairment
  impaired
Composition and Impairment
  Advances   loans   advances   provisions   loans
    €m   €m   %   €m   %
 
Residential mortgages
    60,470       471       0.8 %     359       76 %
Non-property SME and corporate
    34,351       2,806       8.2 %     1,152       41 %
Property and construction
    35,510       9,648       27.2 %     3,884       40 %
Consumer
    4,340       426       9.8 %     380       89 %
                                         
Total loans and advances to customers
    134,671       13,351       9.9 %     5,775       43 %
                                         
 
                                         
                    Impairment
            Impaired
      provisions
March 31, 2009
          loans
      as % of
Total loans
      Impaired
  as % of
  Impairment
  impaired
Composition and Impairment
  Advances   loans   advances   provisions   loans
    €m   €m   %   €m   %
 
Residential mortgages
    58,888       229       0.4 %     144       63 %
Non-property SME and corporate
    37,041       1,187       3.2 %     480       40 %
Property and construction
    33,955       3,538       10.4 %     856       24 %
Consumer
    5,637       368       6.5 %     301       82 %
                                         
Total loans and advances to customers
    135,521       5,322       3.9 %     1,781       33 %
                                         


F-158


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
Impaired loans increased from €5.3 billion or 3.9% of Total loans at March 31, 2009 to €13.4 billion or 9.9% of Total loans at December 31, 2009. Of the €13.4 billion impaired loans, €11.8 billion have been assessed for impairment on an individual basis with the remaining €1.6 billion assessed collectively. Specific provisions on loans assessed on an individual basis amount to €4 billion. The increase in impaired loans primarily reflects the sharp deterioration in the Property and construction sector, particularly in Ireland, together with a deterioration in general economic conditions and weak consumer sentiment.
 
By portfolio, Residential mortgages accounts for 4% of impaired loans, Non-property SME and corporate accounts for 21% of impaired loans, Property and construction accounts for 72% of impaired loans and Consumer accounts for 3% of impaired loans.
 
The ratio of impaired loans to Total loans in the Residential mortgage portfolio is 0.8%, Non-property SME and corporate is 8.2%, Property and construction is 27.2% and Consumer is 9.8% at December 31, 2009. This ratio has increased for all portfolios since March 31, 2009 with the most significant deterioration in the Property and construction portfolio.
 
Total balance sheet provisions against loans and advances to customers were €5.8 billion at December 31, 2009, a significant increase compared to €1.8 billion at March 31, 2009. The Property and construction portfolio accounts for 76% of the increase in provisions during the period, with the Non-property SME and corporate portfolio and the Residential mortgage portfolio generating most of the balance. The increase in impairment provisions in the Consumer portfolio on a declining loan book was relatively modest. Of the €5.8 billion impairment provisions at December 31, 2009, €2.8 billion relates to assets expected to transfer to NAMA.
 
The increase in provisions reflects the impact of the continued deterioration in general economic conditions, consequent loan grade degradation and continued weakening in the Property and construction sectors, in the Republic of Ireland and to a lesser extent in the UK. Impairment provisions as a percentage of impaired loans (coverage ratio) increased to 43% at December 31, 2009 from 33% at March 31, 2009. Coverage ratios, which vary considerably by portfolio, are influenced by the nature of the loan assets and the extent and quality of underlying collateral held by the Group in support of the loan.
 
The coverage ratio on Residential mortgages increased from 63% at March 31, 2009 to 76% at December 31, 2009. In line with existing market practice, coverage ratios for Residential mortgages are computed on a different basis to other portfolios (i.e. Residential mortgages that are 90 days past due are excluded from impaired loans). If Residential mortgages that are 90 days past due were included in impaired loans, the coverage ratio for Residential mortgages would be 20% at December 31, 2009 (up from 12% at March 31, 2009). The Non-property SME and corporate coverage ratio of 41% at December 31, 2009 compares to 40% at March 31, 2009. The coverage ratio for Property and construction of 40% at December 31, 2009 has increased from 24% at March 31, 2009, reflecting a significant increase in the impairment provision at December 31, 2009. Consumer lending at December 31, 2009 has 89% coverage, up from 82% at March 31, 2009.
 
Of the circa. €12.2 billion of loans held for sale to NAMA, €6.6 billion or 54% were impaired. The impairment provision at December 31, 2009 amounted to €2.8 billion which represents 42% of impaired loans.
 
                         
Loans held for sale to NAMA
      Impairment
  Carrying
Composition by division
  Total loans   provisions   value
    €m   €m   €m
 
Retail Republic of Ireland
    3,525       1,063       2,462  
UK Financial Services
    3,573       817       2,756  
Capital Markets
    5,137       898       4,239  
                         
Total loans held for sale to NAMA
    12,235       2,778       9,457  
                         


F-159


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
The impairment provision on loans held for sale to NAMA of €2.8 billion at December 31, 2009 is made up of €1.1 billion or 38% from Retail Republic of Ireland, €0.8 billion or 29% from UK Financial Services and €0.9 billion or 33% from the Capital Markets division. The ratio of impairment provision to loans held for sale to NAMA is 23%. This ratio differs across the divisions. Retail Republic of Ireland has a ratio of 30% reflecting the impact of the sharp deterioration in the property and construction sector in Ireland. The ratio in UK Financial Services is 23% and the ratio in Capital Markets is 17% reflecting the diversification of property assets across different geographic and less stressed areas with Capital Markets having a higher proportion of assets in the investment element of property assets.
 
Loan Impairment Charge
 
The Group impairment charge for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 amounted to €4,055 million or 3.96% when expressed as an annualised percentage of average loans and advances to customers including loans held for sale to NAMA. The charge of €4,055 million is €2,620 million higher than the charge of €1,435 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This higher charge reflects, in particular, the impact of the sharp deterioration in the property and construction sector particularly in Ireland, with continued weakening in non-property sectors.
 
                                 
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
Total loan impairment charge
  December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    €m   %   €m   %
 
Specific impairment (net of provision write backs)
    3,467       3.39 %     1,058       0.76 %
Incurred but not reported (IBNR)
    591       0.58 %     385       0.27 %
Recoveries
    (3 )     (0.01 )%     (8 )     (0.01 )%
                                 
Total loan impairment charge
    4,055       3.96 %     1,435       1.02 %
                                 
 
The split of the Group impairment charge by portfolio is as follows:
 
                                 
    9 months ended
  12 months ended
Group loan impairment charge
  December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    €m   %   €m   %
 
Residential mortgages
    237       0.52 %     127       0.20 %
Non-property SME and Corporate
    659       2.50 %     344       0.94 %
Property and Construction
    2,993       11.25 %     766       2.11 %
Consumer
    166       4.21 %     198       3.08 %
                                 
Total loan impairment charge
    4,055       3.96 %     1,435       1.02 %
                                 
Analysed as follows:
                               
Loans held for sale to NAMA
    2,231       24.31 %            
Loans and advances to customers
    1,824       1.96 %     1,435       1.02 %
                                 
Total loan impairment charge
    4,055       3.96 %     1,435       1.02 %
                                 
 
The impairment charge on Residential mortgages was €237 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €127 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase is due to the impact on the level of arrears from rising unemployment and lower disposable income together with further declining property prices.


F-160


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
The impairment charge on Non-property SME and corporate was €659 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €344 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. This increase is due to the impact on customers of the slowdown in economic activity and poor consumer sentiment together with the level of business insolvencies.
 
The impairment charge on Property and construction was €2,993 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €766 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The land and development element within the Property and construction portfolio is most significantly impacted by falling property prices, more negative views of asset values, over supply of residential stock in Ireland and the general weak economic conditions, particularly in Ireland and to a lesser extent in the UK.
 
The impairment charge on Consumer loans was €166 million for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 compared to €198 million for the twelve month period ended March 31, 2009. The charge on Consumer loans remains significant due to higher unemployment, high levels of personal indebtedness and lower disposable income.
 
Of the €4,055 million impairment charge on loans and advances to customers for the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, €2,231 million or 55% relates to loans held for sale to NAMA. The impairment charge of €1,824 million on loans and advances to customers represents 45% of the total charge of €4,055 million for the nine months ended December 31, 2009; it represents 1.96% on an annualised basis, on the average loans and advances to customers excluding loans held for sale to NAMA.
 
Financial assets renegotiated that would otherwise be past due or impaired
 
Renegotiated loans are those facilities at December 31, 2009 which if not renegotiated during the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 would have been classified as ‘impaired’ loans or as ‘past due but not impaired’ loans. The carrying value of these loans at December 31, 2009 is €6,390 million (March 31, 2009: €5,950 million) and represents borrowers whose loan terms and conditions have been amended in recognition of a change in the borrowers’ circumstances. Renegotiated loans are primarily included in the ‘Acceptable quality’ and lower quality but not ‘past due nor impaired’ classifications and are not deemed to represent a risk of loss at the reporting date.
 
Loans that have their terms amended but do not meet the requirements for financial assets that are ‘neither past due nor impaired’, continue to be reported as ‘past due but not impaired’ or as ‘impaired’.
 
Repossessed collateral
 
During the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, the Group took possession of collateral held as security, as follows:
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Residential properties
               
Ireland
    6       1  
UK & Other
    66       73  
                 
      72       74  
Other properties
    12        
                 
      84       74  
                 
 
Repossessed properties are sold as soon as practicable, with the proceeds applied against outstanding indebtedness.


F-161


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
Asset quality: Other Financial Instruments
 
Other financial instruments include available for sale financial assets, derivative financial instruments, loans and advances to banks, interest receivable and the reinsurance assets. The table below analyses the Group’s exposure to other financial instruments based on the gross amount before provisions for impairment.
 
                                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
Other financial instruments
  2009   2009
    €m   %   €m   %
 
High quality
    33,633       93 %     41,747       89 %
Satisfactory quality
    2,097       6 %     4,895       11 %
Acceptable quality
    286       1 %     99        
Lower quality but not past due nor impaired
    113             30        
                                 
Neither past due nor impaired
    36,129       100 %     46,771       100 %
Impaired
    12             79        
                                 
Total
    36,141       100 %     46,850       100 %
                                 
 
The total volume of other financial instruments at December 31, 2009 amount to €36.1 billion, a reduction of €10.8 billion from the volume of other financial instruments (€46.9 billion at March 31, 2009). This reduction primarily reflects the lower levels of available for sale financial assets, derivative financial instruments and loans and advances to banks. Virtually all of the Group’s exposure to other financial instruments were classified as ‘neither past due nor impaired’.
 
Liquidity Risk
 
Market environment
 
Liquidity conditions remained somewhat constrained in the early part of the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 but eased from July 2009 onwards. The initial period was characterised by residual weakness in the international liquidity market and by negative sentiment towards Ireland driven by, inter alia, evidence of the depth of the economic downturn and downgrades in sovereign ratings and credit ratings of banks.
 
As the period progressed, funding conditions improved for the Group, reflecting an upturn in the general funding market backdrop and an increased appetite for Irish debt. Investors’ perception of Irish sovereign risk improved from July 2009 based on economic data indicating that the pace of contraction in the Irish economy was moderating, ongoing efforts by the Irish Government to stabilise public finances, measures of support for the Irish banking system (particularly the announcement of NAMA) and, in the latter part of the calendar year the announcement of an extension of the Government liability guarantee.
 
The market’s perception of Irish sovereign risk has also improved in recent months: the 10-year yield spread over Germany has narrowed to under 130 basis points at March 2010 from a recent high of 284 basis points in March 2009.
 
The Group responded to the conditions which existed during the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 by taking a variety of measures:
 
•   in common with other banks, the Group continued to target a reduction in its level of borrowing from wholesale markets by focusing on specific customer deposit gathering initiatives in each division;
 
•   asset growth was controlled and managed in line with current funding capacity;


F-162


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
•   the Group successfully issued term funding during the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 of €9.1 billion;
 
•   the Group successfully issued two benchmark transactions of 3 years and 5 years maturity, beyond the term of the Government Guarantee at that time;
 
•   the Group, through normal market operations, used its contingent liquidity pool to access funding from Monetary Authorities. As at December 31, 2009, the net drawings from Monetary Authorities were €8 billion down from €17 billion at March 31, 2009; and
 
•   during the year, the Group Liquidity Committee (GLC) continued to manage the Group’s Liquidity Position and report to both ALCO and the GRPC.
 
Despite the challenging external environment, the Group remained in compliance with the regulatory liquidity regime in Ireland and in other jurisdictions and maintains a significant buffer above this level.
 
Definition of Liquidity Risk
 
Liquidity risk is the risk that the Group will experience difficulty in financing its assets and/or meeting its contractual payment obligations as they fall due, or will only be able to do so at substantially above the prevailing market cost of funds. Factors that may increase the Group’s cost of funds would be downgrades to credit ratings or other factors which change the market’s willingness to supply funding to the Group, such as market dislocation or major disasters.
 
How Liquidity Risk Arises
 
Liquidity risk arises from differences in timing between cash inflows and outflows. Cash inflows are driven, among other things, by the maturity structure of loans and investments held by the Group, while cash outflows are driven by the term of its debt and the outflows from deposit accounts held “on demand” for customers.
 
Liquidity risk can increase due to the unexpected lengthening of maturities or non-repayment of assets, a sudden withdrawal of deposits, or the inability to refinance maturing debt. The latter are often associated with times of stressed market conditions or adverse events, such as a credit rating downgrade of a financial institution or economic or financial turmoil.
 
Liquidity Risk Management
 
The Group’s exposure to liquidity risk is governed by policy approved by the Court and the Group Risk Policy Committee (GRPC). The operation of this policy is delegated to the Group’s Asset and Liability Committee (ALCO). Group Treasury, on behalf of ALCO, is responsible for monitoring the liquidity risk of the Group and for the development and monitoring of liquidity policy. Bank of Ireland Global Markets is responsible for the day to day execution of the Group’s liquidity position.
 
Liquidity management within the Group consists of two main activities:
 
•   Tactical liquidity management focuses on monitoring current and expected future daily cashflows to ensure that the Group’s liquidity needs can be met. This takes into account the Group’s access to unsecured funding (customer deposits and wholesale funding) and the liquidity characteristics of a portfolio of highly marketable assets and contingent assets that can be converted to liquidity to cover any unforeseen cash outflows.
 
•   Structural liquidity management focuses on assessing the optimal balance sheet structure taking account of the maturity profile of assets and liabilities and the Group’s debt issuance strategy.


F-163


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
 
The Group operates under the regulatory Liquidity Regime introduced by the Irish Financial Regulator in July 2007. This regime requires that banks have sufficient payment resources (cash inflows and marketable assets) to cover 100% of expected cash outflows in the 0 to 8 day time horizon and 90% of expected cash outflows in the 8 day to 30 day time horizon. The Group continues to maintain a significant liquidity buffer in excess of these requirements. The Group also has in place a liquidity contingency plan to assist the Group in managing its liquidity through a period of market dislocation or firm specific liquidity distress. The Group operates within the requirements of local regulators in those jurisdictions in which the liquidity requirements apply to the Group.
 
Liquidity Risk Measurement
 
The Group’s cash flow and liquidity reporting processes, provide to management daily liquidity risk information by designated cash flow categories. These processes capture the cash flows from both on balance sheet and off balance sheet transactions.
 
The tables below summarise the maturity profile of the Group’s financial instrument assets and liabilities, excluding those arising from insurance and participating investment contracts at December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2009 based on the remaining contractual maturity period at the balance sheet date on a discounted basis. Unit linked investment liabilities and unit linked insurance liabilities with a carrying value of €5,050 million and €6,658 million respectively (March 31, 2009: €4,084 million and €5,634 million respectively) are excluded from this analysis as their repayment is linked directly to the financial assets backing these contracts. The Group manages liquidity risk by adjusting the contractual cashflows on the deposit book to reflect its inherent stability and on its mortgage book to reflect early repayment of such loans.


F-164


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
December 31, 2009
 
                                                         
        Up to 3
  3-12
  1-5
  Over 5
       
Maturities of financial assets and liabilities
  Demand   months   months   years   years   Equity Shares   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
ASSETS
                                                       
Cash and balances at central banks
    4,241                                     4,241  
Trading securities
          18       271       84       30             403  
Derivative financial instruments
    1,074       140       505       2,185       1,920             5,824  
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
    903       86       334       510       1,442       6,404       9,679  
Loans and advances to banks
    2,406       2,543       64       16       2             5,031  
Available for sale financial assets
          1,359       4,209       12,418       2,898       56       20,940  
Loans and advances to customers (before impairment provisions)
    895       8,357       8,672       37,499       67,013             122,436  
Assets classified as held for sale to NAMA (before impairment provisions)
    3,616       4,037       1,757       2,036       913             12,359  
                                                         
Total
    13,135       16,540       15,812       54,748       74,218       6,460       180,913  
                                                         
LIABILITIES
                                                       
Deposits from banks
    128       8,365       8,175       1,006       229             17,903  
Customer accounts
    36,795       31,410       12,296       3,966       345             84,812  
Derivative financial instruments
    1,070       445       437       2,289       1,796             6,037  
Debt securities in issue
    11       13,958       10,677       9,330       9,168             43,144  
Subordinated liabilities
          754                   5,299             6,053  
Liabilities classified as held for sale to NAMA (before impairment provisions)
                            1             1  
                                                         
Total
    38,004       54,932       31,585       16,591       16,838             157,950  
                                                         


F-165


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
March 31, 2009
 
                                                         
        Up to 3
  3-12
  1-5
  Over 5
       
Maturities of financial assets and liabilities
  Demand   months   months   years   years   Equity shares   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
ASSETS
                                                       
Cash and balances at central banks
    3,224                                     3,224  
Trading securities
          12       27       70       16             125  
Derivative financial instruments
    922       688       857       2,860       3,070             8,397  
Other financial assets at fair value through profit or loss
    696       169       204       606       1,532       4,397       7,604  
Loans and advances to banks
    4,100       2,990       770       23       3             7,886  
Available for sale financial assets
          1,930       3,555       18,480       2,831       62       26,858  
Loans and advances to customers (before impairment provisions)
    3,799       8,070       14,126       40,876       68,650             135,521  
                                                         
Total
    12,741       13,859       19,539       62,915       76,102       4,459       189,615  
                                                         
LIABILITIES
                                                       
Deposits by banks
    755       25,478       1,560       716       305             28,814  
Customer accounts
    32,823       36,004       11,039       2,904       349             83,119  
Derivative financial instruments
    941       361       541       3,092       2,619             7,554  
Debt securities in issue
    15       15,909       8,214       13,968       7,027             45,133  
Subordinated liabilities
                747             7,195             7,942  
                                                         
Total
    34,534       77,752       22,101       20,680       17,495             172,562  
                                                         
 
Stress testing and scenario analysis
 
The Group performs stress testing and scenario analysis to evaluate the impact of stresses on its liquidity position. These stress tests incorporate Group specific risks and systemic risks and are run at three levels of severity. Tactical actions and strategies available to mitigate the stress scenarios are evaluated as to their appropriateness. Stress test results are reported to ALCO, the GRPC and the Court.
 
Liquidity Risk Mitigation
 
Wholesale Funding diversification
 
The Group’s strategy is to diversify its wholesale funding profile across investor types, regions, instruments and currency of activity. During the nine month period ended December 31, 2009, the Group issued €9.1 billion of debt with an original maturity of greater than one year.


F-166


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
Customer Deposits
 
The Group’s customer deposits increased over the period through the Group’s retail channels, reflecting its increased focus on such deposits as shown in the table below.
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
Divisional profile of deposits
  2009   2009
    €bn   €bn
 
Retail Ireland
    35       33  
UK Financial Services (€bn)
    21       21  
Capital Markets
    29       29  
                 
Total
    85       83  
                 
 
The Group’s funding strategy is focused in particular on growing high quality “sticky” deposits by leveraging the Group’s extensive Retail customer franchise in Ireland and by accessing the UK retail market through the Group’s highly successful joint venture with the UK Post Office. In addition, the Group has extensive and deep Treasury and Corporate Banking customer relationships, in Ireland, the UK and internationally which enable the Group to access a significant pool of high quality corporate customer deposits.
 
The Group will continue to focus on the growth of retail deposits and maximise corporate deposits which arise from the Group’s broader lending and treasury risk management activities with a view to reducing its dependence on wholesale funding and reducing its customer loan to deposit ratio.
 
Contingent Liquidity
 
Contingent Liquidity comprises a pool of internally securitised credit risk assets and a portfolio of liquid or readily marketable assets.
 
Internally Securitised Assets
 
The Group has retained the notes issued from a number of securitisations of balance sheet assets in order to increase its ability to obtain secured funding, if required. The assets comprise Irish and UK residential and commercial mortgages and a corporate loan book securitisation vehicle.
 
Liquid Assets
 
The liquid assets portfolio comprises those securities that can be used to raise liquidity either by sale or through secured funding transactions. This portfolio comprises of bank paper, government debt and asset backed securities. The Group has the ability to access secured funding through the tendering operations of central banks from this pool of assets.
 


F-167


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56 RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
                                 
Funding structure
  December 31, 2009   %   March 31, 2009   %
    €bn       €bn    
 
Senior debt/Asset Covered Securities
    27       16 %     25       13 %
Deposits by banks
    18       11 %     29       16 %
Commercial Paper/Certificate of Deposit
    10       6 %     14       8 %
Securitisation
    6       3 %     6       3 %
                                 
Wholesale Funding
    61       36 %     74       40 %
Customer Deposits
    85       50 %     83       45 %
Subordinated Debt
    6       4 %     8       4 %
Other Liabilities
    11       6 %     12       7 %
Stockholder Equity
    6       4 %     7       4 %
                                 
Total Liabilities (excluding BoI Life liabilities)
    169       100 %     184       100 %
                                 
Customer Deposits
                               
Retail Republic of Ireland
    35       41 %     33       40 %
UKFS (€)
    21       25 %     21       25 %
UKFS (Stg£)
    19               19          
Capital Markets
    29       34 %     29       35 %
                                 
Total
    85       100 %     83       100 %
                                 
Wholesale Funding
                               
Short Term Funding
    41       68 %     54       73 %
Term Funding, > 1 year to maturity
    20       32 %     20       27 %
                                 
Total
    61       100 %     74       100 %
                                 
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
Key Funding Ratios
  2009   2009
 
Contingent liquidity collateral asset
  42bn     49bn  
Net drawings from Monetary Authorities
  8bn     17bn  
Loans and advances to customers — incl. assets held for sale to NAMA/customer deposits
    152 %     161 %
Loans and advances to customers — excl. assets held for sale to NAMA/customer deposits
    141 %      
Wholesale funding/total assets (excluding BOI Life)
    36 %     40 %
Term Funding >1 year, subordinated debt and deposits/loans and advances to customers (incl. loans held for sale to NAMA)
    86 %     83 %
Term Funding >1 year, subordinated debt and deposits/loans and advances to customers (excl. loans held for sale to NAMA)
    93 %      

F-168


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
The tables below summarises the maturity profile of the Group’s financial liabilities (excluding those arising from insurance and investment contracts in BoI Life and those arising on derivative financial instruments) at December 31, 2009 and March 31, 2009 based on contractual undiscounted repayment obligations. Unit linked investment liabilities and unit linked insurance liabilities with a carrying value of €5,050 million and €6,658 million respectively (March 31, 2009: €4,084 million and €5,634 million respectively) are excluded from this analysis as their repayment is linked directly to the financial assets backing these contracts. The Group does not manage liquidity risk on the basis of contractual maturity. Instead the Group manages liquidity risk based on expected cash flows. The balances will not agree directly to the consolidated balance sheet as the table incorporates all cash flows, on an undiscounted basis, related to both principal and interest payments.
 
As at December 31, 2009
 
                                                 
        Up to 3
  3-12
  1-5
  Over 5
   
    Demand   months   months   years   years   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Deposits from banks
    128       8,386       8,205       1,075       241       18,035  
Customer accounts
    36,795       31,484       12,625       4,361       692       85,957  
Debt securities in issue
          14,120       11,043       12,813       10,548       48,524  
Subordinated liabilities
          859       87       839       5,715       7,500  
Contingent liabilities
    2,425                               2,425  
Commitments
    16,144                   8,887             25,031  
                                                 
Total
    55,492       54,849       31,960       27,975       17,196       187,472  
                                                 
 
As at March 31, 2009
 
                                                 
        Up to 3
  3-12
  1-5
  Over 5
   
    Demand   months   months   years   years   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Deposits from banks
    788       25,530       1,590       760       429       29,097  
Customer accounts
    32,849       36,214       11,527       3,415       1,351       85,356  
Debt securities in issue
          16,170       8,709       15,387       13,589       53,855  
Subordinated liabilities
          44       1,103       1,305       8,460       10,912  
Contingent liabilities
    2,568                               2,568  
Commitments
    18,138                   8,781             26,919  
                                                 
Total
    54,343       77,958       22,929       29,648       23,829       208,707  
                                                 
 
As set out in note 21, derivatives held for trading comprise derivatives entered into with trading intent as well as derivatives entered with economic hedging intent to which the Group does not apply hedge accounting. Derivatives held with hedging intent also include all derivatives to which the Group applies hedge accounting.
 
The table below summarises the maturity profile of the Group’s derivative liabilities. The Group manages liquidity risk based on expected cash flows, therefore the undiscounted cash flows payable on derivatives liabilities held with hedging intent are classified according to their contractual maturity, while derivatives held with trading intent have been included at fair value in the ‘demand’ time bucket.


F-169


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
As at December 31, 2009
 
                                                 
        Up to 3
  3-12
  1-5
  Over 5
   
Derivative financial instruments
  Demand   months   months   years   years   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Derivatives held with hedging intent
                                               
Gross settled derivative liabilities — outflows
          3,787       2,316       4,257       854       11,214  
Gross settled derivative liabilities — inflows
          (3,698 )     (2,104 )     (3,766 )     (842 )     (10,410 )
                                                 
Gross settled derivative liabilities — net flows
          89       212       491       12       804  
Net settled derivative liabilities
          554       1,326       1,402       100       3,382  
                                                 
Total derivatives held with hedging intent
          643       1,538       1,893       112       4,186  
Derivative liabilities held with trading intent
    1,795                               1,795  
                                                 
Total derivative cash flows
    1,795       643       1,538       1,893       112       5,981  
                                                 
 
As at March 31, 2009
 
                                                 
        Up to 3
  3-12
  1-5
  Over 5
   
Derivative financial instruments
  Demand   months   months   years   years   Total
    €m   €m   €m   €m   €m   €m
 
Derivatives held with hedging intent
                                               
Gross settled derivative liabilities — outflows
          7,291       4,180       6,230       466       18,167  
Gross settled derivative liabilities — inflows
          (7,246 )     (3,894 )     (5,370 )     (463 )     (16,973 )
                                                 
Gross settled derivative liabilities — net flows
          45       286       860       3       1,194  
Net settled derivative liabilities
          266       1,046       2,003       241       3,556  
                                                 
Total derivatives held with hedging intent
          311       1,332       2,863       244       4,750  
Derivative liabilities held with trading intent
    2,882                               2,882  
                                                 
Total derivative cash flows
    2,882       311       1,332       2,863       244       7,632  
                                                 
 
 
1. The figures above have been restated to align with the enhanced disclosure requirements of IFRS 7 (amended) and are on a consistent basis with those shown for December 31, 2009. As a result, the derivative liabilities held with trading intent are included in the ‘demand’ time bucket.
 
Market Risk
 
Definition
 
Market risk is the risk of loss in the Group’s income or net worth arising from adverse change in interest rates, exchange rates or other market prices.
 
How Market Risk Arises
 
Market risk arises in customer facing banking units mainly on the asset side of the balance sheet through fixed rate lending. These books are hedged with maturity matched funding from Bank of Ireland Global Markets (BoIGM). This exposure is, in turn, substantially eliminated by BoIGM through external hedges.
 
Market risk also arises where variable rate assets and liabilities reprice at different frequencies (monthly, quarterly, semi annually) and where lending reprices with changes in central bank rates but is funded at short dated market


F-170


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
rates. The latter is termed basis risk and, while it has always been a feature of retail and commercial banking, it became more material after mid 2007 as the volatility of spreads between central bank rates and short term market rates increased significantly.
 
Discretionary market risk
 
BoIGM is the sole Group business permitted to take discretionary market risk on behalf of the Group. The Group has never sought to generate a material proportion of its earnings through assuming market risk and it has a low tolerance for earnings volatility arising from this area of risk.
 
Discretionary risk is taken in both the Trading and Banking Books in BoIGM. Positions are allocated to the Trading Book in line with the criterion of ‘intent to trade’ as set out in the EU’s Capital Requirements Directive and are marked to market for financial reporting purposes. Discretionary risk is also taken in the Banking Book in BoIGM. Banking Book risk positions arise from internal hedging transactions which are not fully or immediately eliminated with the market, from wholesale funding in cash and debt markets and from the management of liquidity. While these positions do not arise from an ’intent to trade’, they are actively monitored and exposures can be reduced or eliminated if market conditions warrant.
 
The major part of the Group’s discretionary risk is interest rate risk in the euro, sterling and US dollar markets, assumed in money markets, securities, money and bond futures, swaps and options on futures. The Group’s foreign exchange risk is mainly taken in US dollar/euro, US dollar/Yen and euro/sterling exchange rates.
 
Structural market risk
 
Structural interest rate risk arises from the existence of non-interest bearing assets and liabilities on the balance sheet and structural foreign exchange risk arises from the Group’s net investment in its non-euro based subsidiaries. The measurement and management of structural market risk is discussed separately below.
 
Market Risk Management
 
The management of market risk in the Group is governed by high level principles approved by the Court and a detailed statement of policy approved by the GRPC. Discretionary market risk is subject to strict controls which set out the markets and instruments in which risk can be assumed, the types of positions which can be taken and the limits which must be complied with. The Court approves an overall Value at Risk (VaR) limit, which is a quantification of the Group’s appetite for discretionary market risk. VaR is discussed below. ALCO approves VaR limits for BoIGM, including limits for interest rate, foreign exchange (fx) and credit spread VaR. Market risk limits are rigorously enforced and compliance is monitored by ALCO.
 
Market Risk Measurement
 
Bank of Ireland Global Markets (BoIGM)
 
The Group employs a Value at Risk (VaR) approach to measure, and set limits on, discretionary market risk in BoIGM. This applies to both the Trading and Banking Books. The Group measures VaR for a 1 day horizon at the 99% level of statistical confidence. This means that, for a given set of market risk positions on a given day, the Group believes there is no more than a 1% chance of a gain or loss in excess of the VaR number over the following day. VaR is measured using a variance/covariance matrix approach. Matrices are updated weekly using the Exponentially Weighted Moving Average (EWMA) methodology. This widely used approach gives greater weight to more recent data and, as a consequence, estimates of VaR are more responsive to changes in market conditions.
 
For the nature of the risks assumed by the Group, VaR remains a relatively reliable basis of risk measurement. Nonetheless, management recognises that VaR is subject to certain inherent limitations. The past will not always be


F-171


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
a reliable guide to the future and the statistical assumptions employed may understate the probability of large moves. In addition, there is no presumption that all positions can be closed within the 1 day horizon used to measure risk. For these reasons, VaR limits are supplemented by a range of controls that include position limits and loss tolerances. In addition, scenario based stress tests and long run historic simulations, which measure the effect of past periods of market stress (going back to the early 1990s) on current positions, are used to assess and manage discretionary market risk.
 
The Group’s peak, average and end of period 1 day Trading Book VaR in the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 is summarised in the following table:
 
                 
    9 Months
  12 Months
    Ended
  Ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    €m   €m
 
Interest Rate VaR
               
Peak
    3.4       5.3  
Average
    2.1       2.5  
End period
    1.0       1.2  
Foreign Exchange VaR
               
Peak
    1.0       2.1  
Average
    0.5       0.9  
End period
    1.0       0.9  
 
Banking book risk
 
The Group employs a number of measures to quantify and control market risk in the Banking Book (consisting of all assets, liabilities and derivatives other than those booked with trading intent). Because of the requirement that customer-facing businesses eliminate their interest rate risk with BoIGM, there is negligible interest rate risk in other business units.
 
The impact on the Group’s net interest margin for one year ahead of an immediate and sustained 50 basis points shift up or down in the euro and sterling yield curves applied to the exposures in BoIGM’s wholesale Banking Book is as follows:
 
                 
    9 Months Ended
  12 Months Ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    €m   €m
 
Euro
               
+ 50 basis points
    (5.1 )     (6.5 )
- 50 basis points
    5.1       6.5  
Sterling
               
+ 50 basis points
    (2.5 )     (9.5 )
- 50 basis points
    2.5       9.5  
 
The sensitivities are indicative of the magnitude and direction of exposures but require to be qualified in two respects. First, the results are based on an immediate and sustained shift of the same magnitude in all curves which would represent a very unusual scenario. Second, the scenario implicitly assumes the Group is passive in the face of adverse market movements. In reality, these exposures are continuously monitored and can be substantially eliminated in response to adverse market movements.


F-172


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
The Group also monitors its exposure to basis risk within its consolidated Banking Book. Basis risk arises because the Group, in common with all retail and commercial banks, borrows and lends at a range of different floating rate conventions. It has assets, liabilities and swaps that re-price with changes in central banks rates, as well as 1-, 3- and 6-month interbank rates. The differentials between these floating rates, which was historically quite tight, varied to an unprecedented extent at the height of the recent financial crisis, reflecting liquidity conditions at different terms in money markets. While the exposure of net interest income to changes in basis has subsided considerably as markets have normalised, it remains a feature of the financial environment for all banks. The Group assesses basis risk using scenario analysis at the level of the consolidated balance sheet and it has, from time to time, executed selective basis hedging.
 
Financial Assets Available For Sale
 
At December 31, 2009, the Group held €20.9 billion in debt securities classified as Available for sale financial assets (March 31, 2009: €26.9 billion). These securities are held at fair value on the balance sheet with movements in fair value (apart from impairments) recognised in reserves. Available for sale securities include both floating rate securities and fixed rate securities swapped to a floating rate. A 1 basis point increase in the average spread to Euribor or Libor of the total book at December 31, 2009 would have reduced its value by €4.6 million (March 31, 2009: €6.6 million).
 
Derivatives
 
A derivative is a financial contract whose value is linked to movements in interest rates, exchange rates, equity or commodity prices or, more generally, to any objectively measured variable agreed between the parties. Derivative markets are an efficient mechanism for the transfer of risk and risk mitigation. The Group uses derivatives to manage the market risks that arise naturally in its retail and wholesale banking activities. In addition, it transacts in derivatives with its business and corporate clients for the purpose of assisting these clients in managing their exposure to changes in interest and foreign exchange rates. Finally, the Group takes modest discretionary market risk in derivative markets.
 
The Group also uses credit derivatives, on a very limited basis, within its Trading Book to take exposure to specific and general credit spread movements and in its Banking Book to provide default protection on specific credit exposures.
 
Further details can be found in note 21 and the accounting policy is set out on page F-21.
 
Policy
 
The Group’s participation in derivatives markets is subject to policy approved by the Court and, at a more detailed level, by the GRPC. The Group makes a clear distinction between derivatives which must be transacted on a perfectly hedged basis, and those whose risks can be managed within broader interest rate or foreign exchange books. As these broader books can be structured to assume some degree of discretionary risk, derivative positions held within them will not necessarily be exactly hedged. Market risk can only be assumed in clearly defined categories of derivatives which are traded in well established, liquid markets, supported by industry standard conventions and documentation and valued in accordance with generally accepted methods. BoIGM is the only business unit permitted to take discretionary risk in derivatives such as interest rate futures, bond futures, forward rate agreements, interest rate swaps, credit derivatives, forward foreign exchange and currency swaps. In addition, it is permitted to take exposure in the most widely traded option markets, principally options on futures, caps, floors, swap options (swaptions) and conventional currency options. Transactions in more complex derivatives are typically on a perfectly matched back to back basis.


F-173


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
Collateral agreements
 
The Group has executed Collateral Support Agreements (CSAs) with its principal interbank derivatives counterparties and, as a result, a very high proportion of its total interbank derivatives book is covered by CSAs. The purpose of a CSA is to limit the potential cost of replacing derivative contracts at market prices in the event of default by the original counterparty. Under the terms of a CSA, if the aggregate market value of a set of derivative contracts between the two parties exceeds an agreed threshold figure, the party which would be exposed to loss in the event of default receives a deposit of cash or eligible securities equal to the excess aggregate value over the threshold. In BoIGM’s case, valuations are agreed and collateral is typically exchanged on a daily basis and in some cases weekly.
 
Structural Market Risk
 
Structural interest rate risk arises from the existence of non-interest bearing assets and liabilities on the Group’s balance sheet. These consist mainly of non-interest bearing current accounts plus equity less fixed assets. If these net liabilities were used to fund floating rate assets, the Group’s earnings would fully reflect any variation in interest rates from one reporting period to the next. It is Group policy to invest the major part of these net liabilities in a passively managed portfolio of fixed rate assets with an average life of 4 years and a maximum life of 7 years.
 
Structural foreign exchange (fx) risk is defined as the Group’s non trading net asset position in non-euro currencies. Structural fx risk arises substantially from the Group’s net investment in its sterling based subsidiaries. In considering the most appropriate structural fx position, the Group takes account of the currency composition of its risk weighted assets and the desirability of maintaining a similar currency distribution of capital. This is designed to ensure that capital ratios have a low sensitivity to changes in exchange rates. At December 31, 2009, the Group’s structural fx position was as follows:
 
                 
    9 Months Ended
  12 Months Ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    €m   €m
 
Sterling — net assets
    3,814       3,058  
US dollar — net assets position
    173       73  
                 
Total structural fx
    3,987       3,131  
                 
 
A 10% depreciation of the euro against sterling and the US dollar at December 31, 2009 would have resulted in a gain taken to reserves of €399 million (March 31, 2009: gain of €313 million)
 
Market Risk in Bank of Ireland Life (BoI Life)
 
Market risk arises in the Group’s non-linked life assurance business to the extent that expected duration of cash flows on the liability side differs from the duration of the matching fixed interest assets (comprising Irish and other euro fixed interest government gilts). BoI Life pursues a policy of close asset/liability matching and any difference in the mean duration of assets and liabilities is minimised by buying and selling euro fixed interest government securities. No corporate bonds are held. At December 31, 2009, the sensitivity of the non-linked portfolio to a 50 basis points parallel shift in the yield curve assuming a similar shift in the yield used to discount the liabilities was as follows:
 
                 
    9 Months Ended
  12 Months Ended
    December 31, 2009   March 31, 2009
    €m   €m
 
50 basis points increase
    0.3       (0.6 )
50 basis points decrease
    (0.4 )     0.8  


F-174


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
56  RISK MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
BoI Life does not bear equity risk directly; this is borne by the unit linked policyholders. However, BoI Life is indirectly exposed because the management fees it receives are related to the value of assets under management. A 5% fall in equity and property markets, applied to the book at December 31, 2009, would reduce earnings by €7 million (March 31, 2009: a reduction of €7 million for the same percentage decline).
 
Similarly, the company bears indirect exposure to changes in exchange rates through management fees earned on non-euro unit linked funds under management. A 5% increase in the euro against all other currencies midway through the year would reduce earnings by €5 million (March 31, 2009: a reduction of €4 million for the same percentage decline).
 
Life Insurance Risk
 
Definition
 
Life insurance risk is defined as the volatility in the amount and timing of claims caused by unexpected change in mortality, longevity and morbidity. Mortality risk is the risk that the claim payments incurred by the business due to deaths within the portfolio of assured lives are greater than expected. Longevity risk is the risk that claim payments incurred by the business due to the rates of survival within the portfolio of annuitants are greater than expected. Morbidity risk, primarily critical illness risk, is the risk that claim payments incurred by the business due to critical illness events is greater than expected.
 
Life Insurance Risk Management
 
Life insurance risk is underwritten and managed by BoI Life, a wholly owned subsidiary of the Group. The management of insurance risk is the responsibility of the Board of the life assurance company. The Board sets maximum approved retention risk limits for the business each year. Responsibilities delegated by the Board to the Reinsurance Committee include completing a review of the reinsurance arrangements at least annually and reporting on this review to the Audit Committee of the Board. This includes a review of the panel of reinsurers that may be used and the optimal structure of its reinsurance arrangements. The Reinsurance Committee comprises of senior members of the management team with actuarial and underwriting expertise.
 
Life Insurance Risk Measurement
 
The amount at risk on each life assurance policy is the difference between the sum assured payable on the insured event and the reserve held. Risk experience is monitored monthly. Actual claims experience is compared to the underlying risk assumptions, and risk profits and losses are reported to senior management and reflected in new business pricing and new product design.
 
Life Insurance Risk Mitigation
 
BoI Life mitigates the potential impact of insurance risk through a number of measures. These include reinsurance, underwriting, contract design and diversification.
 
Life Insurance Risk Reporting
 
An update on the status of life insurance risk is included in the Court Risk Report which is presented to the GRPC, the CRC and the Court by the Chief Credit and Market Risk Officer.
 
See also note 53.


F-175


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
57 CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
 
Capital Management Objectives and Policies
 
The objectives of the Group’s capital management policy are to at all times comply with regulatory capital requirements and to ensure that the Group has sufficient capital to cover the risks of its business and support its future development.
 
The capital adequacy requirements set by the Financial Regulator in Ireland which reflect the requirements as set out in the EU Capital Requirements Directive and its preceding directives are used by the Group as the basis for its capital management. These requirements set a floor under which capital levels must not fall. The Group seeks to maintain sufficient capital to ensure that even under stressed conditions these requirements are not breached.
 
The Group also looks at other methodologies of capital measurement including the capital definitions set out by rating agencies. It also calculates economic capital based on its own internal models.
 
The Group meets its objectives in terms of capital management through the maintenance of capital ratios above the minimum levels set by the Financial Regulator and relative to market expectations for banks with its business profile. Market expectations regarding capital ratios for banks have risen following the rise in loss expectations across the international banking industry, driven by exposures to assets vulnerable to the downturn in residential and commercial real estate prices and the deteriorating economic climate. These increased expectations have led to substantial private and government led recapitalisation schemes internationally.
 
Capital Resources
 
The following table sets out the Group’s capital resources.
 
                 
    December 31,
  March 31,
    2009   2009
    €m   €m
 
Stockholders’ funds
               
Equity (including other equity reserves)
    6,345       6,810  
Non-cumulative preference stock
    42       42  
Minority interests — equity
    50       61  
Undated loan capital
    1,521       3,385  
Dated loan capital
    4,532       4,557  
                 
Total capital resources
    12,490       14,855  
                 
 
In the nine month period ended December 31, 2009 the Group’s total capital resources reduced by €2,365 million to €12,490 million. The movement of €2,365 million includes a decrease of €465 million relating to Stockholders’ equity (including other equity reserves) and a decrease of €1,864 million relating to undated loan capital.
 
The movement of €465 million in Stockholders’ funds was mainly driven by the following:
 
•   an after tax loss of €1,460 million which included the impact of the June 2009 tier 1 buyback (increase in Stockholders’ funds of €1,037 million);
 
•   net actuarial loss on pension funds of €74 million; and


F-176


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
57 CAPITAL MANAGEMENT  (continued)
 
 
•   an increase in other reserves (Available for sale reserves of €924 million, cash flow hedging reserve of €82 million) along with a positive movement in foreign exchange reserves of €117 million primarily due to the strengthening of Sterling against euro. Other items gave a negative movement of €54 million.
 
The movement of €1,864 million in undated loan capital primarily relates to the tier 1 buyback in June 2009 together with fair value movements on the remaining securities.
The lower tier 2 subordinated capital exchange which was completed in February 2010 resulted in a reduction of €413 million in dated loan capital. This was offset by an increase of €405 million in Stockholders’ funds. This impact is not included in the table above.
 
As at December 31, 2009, the Group had €1,521 million of undated loan capital and €4,532 million of dated loan capital (including fair value adjustments), a total of €6,053 million of subordinated liabilities. Of the dated loan capital, €3,778 million is repayable in five or more years. The cost and availability of subordinated debt are influenced by credit ratings. A reduction in the ratings assigned to the Group’s securities could increase financing costs and reduce market access. The credit ratings of the Group at June 7, 2010 were as follows:
 
             
        Credit
   
Senior Debt
 
Ratings
 
Date
 
Outlook
 
Standard & Poors
  A-   January 26, 2010   Stable
Moodys
  A1   July 7, 2009   Stable
Fitch
  A-   April 9, 2009   Stable
DBRS
  AA (low)   December 4, 2009   Negative
 
Depending on the degree of subordination, the ratings assigned to loan capital will be one or more notches below the level for senior debt. Credit ratings are not a recommendation to buy, hold or sell any security and each rating should be evaluated independently of every other rating. These ratings are based on current information furnished to the rating agencies by the Group and information obtained by the rating agencies from other sources. The ratings are accurate only as of June 7, 2010 and may be changed, superceded or withdrawn as a result of changes in, or unavailability of, such information.
 
58 POST BALANCE SHEET EVENTS
 
(a)   Discretionary Coupon Payments
 
On January 19, 2010, the Group advised the Stock Exchange that the EU Commission had indicated that, in line with its policy and pending its assessment of the Group’s restructuring plan (which is required in compliance with EU State aid rules), that the Group should not make coupon payments on its Tier 1 and Upper Tier 2 capital instruments unless under a binding legal obligation to do so.
 
Under the terms of BOI Capital Funding (No. 2) LP US$800 million Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-Cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities (‘LP2 Securities’), BOI Capital Funding (No. 3) LP US$400 million Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities (‘LP3 Securities’) and BOI Capital Funding (No. 1) LP €600 million Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities which have the benefits of subordinated guarantees from the Bank it was decided that the non-cumulative distribution on these securities, which would otherwise have been paid on February 1, February 4, and March 3, 2010 respectively would not be paid.


F-177


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
58 POST BALANCE SHEET EVENTS  (continued)
 
The effect of this decision by the Group was to trigger the ‘‘Dividend Stopper’’ provisions of the LP 2 Securities and LP 3 Securities. While this “dividend stopper” remains in force, the Group is precluded for a period of one calender year from and including February 1, and February 4, 2010, from declaring and making any distribution or dividend payment on its Ordinary Stock, the outstanding non-cumulative Euro and Sterling Preference Stock), the Bank of Ireland UK Holdings plc €600 million 7.4% Guaranteed Step-up Callable Perpetual Preferred Securities, the Bank of Ireland UK Holdings plc Stg£350 million 6.25% Guaranteed Callable Perpetual Preferred Securities, and the BOI Capital Funding (No. 4) LP £500 million Fixed Rate/Variable Rate Guaranteed Non-voting Non-cumulative Perpetual Preferred Securities and the Irish Government €3.5 billion preference stock (“the 2009 Preference Stock”) issued to the NPRFC (for further information on the 2009 Preference Stock see (c) below.
 
The Group revised its estimates of future cash flows on these subordinated liabilities during 2009, resulting in an adjustment in interest expense in the nine month ended December 31, 2009.
 
(b)   Exchange of Lower Tier 2 Securities
 
On February 11, 2010, the Group announced that it completed an Exchange Offer for outstanding notes relating to five Lower Tier 2 Securities (three Euro securities and one each in Sterling and US Dollars) with a nominal value equivalent of circa €2.9 billion.
 
The actual securities exchanged had a nominal value equivalent of €1.62 billion. These securities were exchanged at a discount into the following new securities
 
•   €978 million, 10% coupon, maturity February 12, 2020
 
•   £197 million, 10% coupon, maturity February 12, 2020
 
The gain from the Exchange Offer was approximately €405 million after tax.
 
Further information on the Group’s subordinated liabilities is outlined in note 39.
 
(c)   Issue of Ordinary Stock to the NPRFC
 
Following (a) above, on February 22, 2010, the Bank issued the NPRFC 184,394,378 units of Ordinary Stock being the number of units equal to the aggregate cash amount of the dividend due, on the 2009 preference stock, of €250.4 million divided by 100% of the average price per unit of ordinary stock in the 30 trading days prior to and including February 19, 2010. This equated to a share price of €1.3582 per unit of Ordinary Stock.
 
This increased the units of Ordinary Stock of Bank of Ireland in issue to 1,186,611,367. As a result the ownership by the NPRFC increased to 15.73% of the issued Ordinary Stock (excluding the NPRFC Warrant Instrument) at that date. See (i) below for further developments.
 
(d)   Credit Institutions (Eligible Liabilities Guarantee) Scheme — (ELG)
 
On December 9, 2009 the Credit Institutions (Eligible Liabilities Guarantee) Scheme (the “ELG Scheme”) was introduced. The purpose of the ELG scheme was to update and revise the current bank guarantee under the Credit Institutions (Financial Support) Scheme 2008 (the “2008 Scheme”).
 
On January 11, 2010, the Group became a participating institution under the ELG Scheme. For further information on the scheme see note 55.
 
(e)   National Asset Management Agency (NAMA)
 
Please refer to note 26 for details on NAMA.


F-178


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
58 POST BALANCE SHEET EVENTS  (continued)
 
(f)   National Asset Management Agency Investment Limited (NAMAIL)
 
Please refer to note 50 for details on NAMAIL.
 
(g)  Pensions Review
 
The deficit (on an IAS 19 basis) across all of the Group’s defined benefit pension schemes was €1.6 billion at December 31, 2009. In January 2010, the Group launched a pension review to address this deficit. On April 7, 2010, the Group announced that it is proposing to make a number of changes affecting pension benefits. The proposed changes affecting the Group’s pension schemes and the benefits available to members of the schemes require engagement with the trustees and members of these schemes. Extensive discussions have taken place with staff representative bodies and the Group’s proposed approach has been agreed (following its recommendation by an independent third party chairman) with the main bank union, the IBOA, in relation to the main scheme (which accounts for approximately 85% of the total deficit). Full implementation of the amendments to the Group’s pension schemes would eliminate approximately 50% of the December 31, 2009 IAS 19 deficit. If such proposals are implemented, the Group will increase its cash contributions to the schemes so as to eliminate the remaining approximate 50% of the December 31, 2009 IAS 19 deficit over approximately 6 years. The proposed changes would lower the underlying pension costs and would therefore have a positive affect on the income statement of the Group.
 
(h)  EU Restructuring Plan
 
The Group has been involved in detailed negotiations through the Department of Finance with the European Commission in relation to the terms of the EU Restructuring Plan which is required in the context of a review by the European Commission resulting from the State aid which has been received by the Group.
 
On April 16, 2010 the Group provided an update on these negotiations, noting that it was expected that the decision regarding the approval of the proposed measures, including the final terms of the EU Restructuring Plan, would be taken by the European Commission by mid-2010. While the process had not concluded, the Directors believe, based on the status of negotiations with the European Commission, that the final EU Restructuring Plan is likely to include, amongst other actions, the disposal of New Ireland Assurance Company plc, Bank of Ireland Asset Management Limited, ICS Building Society (Irish intermediary sourced mortgage business), Foreign Currency Exchange Corporation (US foreign exchange business), and the Group’s stakes in Paul Capital Top Tier Investments LLC (a US asset management business) and in the Irish Credit Bureau Limited, and the wind-down or disposal of, the Group’s UK intermediary sourced mortgage business and certain discontinued international corporate lending portfolios. It will also include certain behavioural measures, including commitments relating to the non-payment of discretionary coupons and the non-exercise of voluntary call options on hybrid capital securities for a specified period, a commitment relating to the non-payment of dividends on Ordinary Stock for a specified period, a commitment not to make any material acquisitions and measures to facilitate competition in the Irish banking market. The Directors do not expect that the proposed EU Restructuring Plan would be materially detrimental to the long term interests of the Group.
 


F-179


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
58 POST BALANCE SHEET EVENTS  (continued)
 
(i)   Placing of Ordinary Stock, debt for equity offers and rights issue
In April 2010, the Bank announced Proposals to increase its Equity Tier 1 Capital by not less than €2.8 billion by way of an Institutional Placing1(, a NPRFC Placing1, a Rights Issue1 and Debt for Equity Offers. The proceeds of the Institutional Placing1 and the Rights Issue1 were underwritten by Underwriters pursuant to the Underwriting Agreement1. In addition, the Warrants held by the NPRFC were cancelled in return for the payment of €491 million in cash under the Warrant Cancellation1. The Proposals which were approved by Stockholders on May 19, 2010 consisted of:
 
•   Placing:  The Placing, comprising the Institutional Placing1 and the NPRFC Placing1, raised €1,536 million in Equity Tier 1 Capital. The proceeds of the Institutional Placing1 were underwritten pursuant to the Underwriting Agreement1 subject to conditions (which were subsequently satisfied), including Admission of the Placing Stock1 and the approval of the Resolutions at the EGC. This involved the placing of 326,797,386 units of Placing Stock1 at a price of €1.53 per unit of Placing Stock1 issued in the Institutional Placing1 pursuant to the Underwriting Agreement1 The price at which the Placing Stock1 was issued to Placees represented a 15% discount to the Closing Price of €1.80 of the Existing Stock1 on April 23, 2010 (being the last practicable date prior to announcement of the Proposals). Placees were considered Qualifying Stockholders1 for the purposes of the Rights Issue1 in respect of their Placing Stock1 Pursuant to the NPRFC Placing1 the NPRFC agreed to subscribe for 575,555,556 units of Ordinary Stock at a price of €1.80 per unit of Ordinary Stock (being the Closing Price on April 23, 2010). The consideration for the NPRFC’s subscription was the conversion of 1,036,000,000 units of 2009 Preference Stock (at their subscription price of €1.00 per unit of 2009 Preference Stock) to units of Ordinary Stock. The Ordinary Stock to be issued pursuant to the NPRFC Placing1 was eligible for participation in the Rights Issue1 as if such Ordinary Stock was held on the Record Date;
 
•   Rights Issue:  A Rights Issue1 which raised €1,725 million in Equity Tier 1 Capital (a portion of the cash proceeds of which was paid directly to noteholders electing for Ordinary Stock allotted in the Rights Issue1 on their behalf pursuant to the Debt for Equity Offers). The proceeds of the Rights Issue1 of up to €1.2 billion were underwritten pursuant to the Underwriting Agreement1 subject to conditions (which were subsequently satisfied), including Admission of the Rights Issue Stock1 (nil paid) and the approval of the Resolutions at an Extraordinary General Court (‘EGC’). The Rights Issue1 size and Rights Issue Price at which Qualifying Stockholders1 were invited to subscribe for Rights Issue Stock1 were determined by the Bank and the Joint Bookrunners1 in advance of the EGC. Pursuant to the NPRFC Rights Issue Undertaking, the NPRFC agreed, subject to certain terms and conditions, to take up its entitlement of Rights Issue Stock1 in the Rights Issue1 in respect of its holding of the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock and its holding of Ordinary Stock issued as a result of the NPRFC Placing1 (but excluding its other investment holdings in the Bank). The consideration for the take up of its Rights in respect of the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock1 and its holding of Ordinary Stock as a result of the NPRFC Placing1 was the conversion of units of 2009 Preference Stock at their subscription price of €1.00 each to Ordinary Stock at the Rights Issue Price;
 
The average number of units of ordinary stock in issue in the current period and prior years used for the Group’s EPS calculations will be required to be retrospectively adjusted in the Group’s financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2010 by an adjustment factor of 1.586176 arising from the Rights Issue outlined above. The adjusted EPS for the period ended December 31, 2009 and years ended March 31, 2009 and March 31, 2008 will be as follows:
 
                         
    31 December
  31 March
  31 March
    2009   2009   2008
 
Average number of units of ordinary stock in issue (millions)
    1,575       1,567       1,531  
- Basic earnings per share (cent)
    (106.3 )     2.7       109.9  
- Diluted earnings per share (cent)
    (106.3 )     2.7       109.4  
 
 
(1 See defined terms on pages F-182 and F-183.


F-180


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
58 POST BALANCE SHEET EVENTS  (continued)
 
•   Debt for Equity Offers:  Under the Debt for Equity Offers, holders of certain of the Group’s Tier 1 Securities and Upper Tier 2 Securities were given the opportunity to exchange these securities for (a) Allotment Instruments (which automatically convert into Conversion Ordinary Stock on the Conversion Date); or (b) through a settlement procedure, cash proceeds from the allotment of Ordinary Stock in the Rights Issue1 on behalf of such holders; or (c) a combination thereof. The tender prices represented a discount of up to 42% to the nominal value of the existing Tier 1 Securities and Upper Tier 2 Securities exchanged by these security holders and resulted in a capital gain, which increased the Group’s Equity Tier 1 Capital. The increase in Equity Tier 1 Capital resulting from the combination of the Rights Issue and the Debt for Equity Offers amounted to €2,020 million, the actual size of the Rights Issue1( (including the NPRFC Rights Issue Undertaking) having been reduced by the capital gain arising on the Debt for Equity Offers;
 
•   Warrant Cancellation:  The Warrants held by the NPRFC were, simultaneously with the NPRFC Placing, cancelled in return for the payment of €491 million in cash by the Bank to the NPRFC. This reflected the market value of the Warrants, being the difference between the exercise price of the Warrants and the Closing Price of the Ordinary Stock on April 23, 2010, plus a fee of €12 million. Following approval of the Proposals, the NPRFC ceased to hold the Warrants and the subscription rights for Ordinary Stock pursuant to the Warrants; and
 
•   Renominalisation of Ordinary Stock:  Because the Bye-Laws of the Bank precluded the issue units of Ordinary Stock at a discount to their nominal value, the Bank’s ordinary stock was renominalised by Stockholders at the Extraordinary General Court held on May 19, 2010. This resulted in the nominal value of each unit of ordinary stock being reduced from €0.64 per unit to €0.10 per unit. Each existing unit of ordinary stock in existence at the date of renominalisation was subdivided into one unit of Ordinary Stock of €0.10 (“€0.10 Ordinary Stock”) and one unit of deferred stock of €0.54 in the capital of Bank of Ireland (“Deferred Stock”). The purpose of the issue of Deferred Stock is to ensure that the reduction in the nominal value of the Ordinary Stock does not result in a reduction in the capital of Bank of Ireland.
 
Each Ordinary Stockholder’s proportionate interest in the issued Ordinary Stock of Bank of Ireland remained unchanged as a result of the Renominalisation. Aside from the change in nominal value, the rights attaching to €0.10 Ordinary Stock (including voting and dividend rights and rights on a return of capital) are identical in all respects to those of the previous Ordinary Stock.
 
The Deferred Stock created on the Renominalisation has no voting or dividend rights and, on a return of capital on a winding up of Bank of Ireland, will have the right to receive the amount paid up thereon only after Stockholders have received, in aggregate, any amounts paid up thereon plus €10 million per unit of Ordinary Stock, the purpose of which is to ensure that the units of Deferred Stock have no economic value. No stock certificates or documents of title will be issued in respect of the Deferred Stock, nor will CREST accounts of Stockholders be credited in respect of any entitlement to Deferred Stock, nor will they be admitted to the Official Lists or to trading on the Irish Stock Exchange, the London Stock Exchange or any other investment exchange. The Deferred Stock shall not be transferable at any time, other than with the prior written consent of the Directors. At the appropriate time, the Bank may redeem or repurchase the Deferred Stock, make an application to the High Court of Ireland for the Deferred Stock to be cancelled, or acquire or cancel or seek the surrender of the Deferred Stock (in each case for no consideration) using such other lawful means as the Directors may determine.
 
These capital Proposals completed on June 8, 2010, and settled on June 14, 2010.
 
 
(1 See defined terms on pages F-182 and F-183.


F-181


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
58 POST BALANCE SHEET EVENTS  (continued)
 
The net impact of the above Proposals is to increase the Group’s equity tier 1 capital by €2.9 billion, as follows:
 
         
    € m
 
Placing*
    1,536  
Rights Issue
    1,725  
Debt for Equity
    295  
         
      3,556  
Warrant Cancellation
    (491 )
Costs and Fees
    (130 )
         
Total Raised
    2,935  
         
 
 
Institutional placing and NPRFC Placing.
 
Defined terms1
 
Allotment Instruments
 
Each instrument delivered to holders thereof pursuant to the Debt for Equity Offers and issued with the benefit of the Allotment Instrument Deed Poll convertible into Conversion Ordinary Stock, the nominal value of which will not exceed €200,000,000;
 
Closing Price
 
The closing middle-market quotation of a unit of Ordinary Stock as derived from the Daily Official List;
 
Existing Stock
 
The units of Ordinary Stock in issue as at April 26, 2010;
 
Institutional Placing
 
The placing of Ordinary Stock with institutional investors (but excluding the NPRFC);
 
Joint Bookrunners
 
Citi, Credit Suisse, Davy, Deutsche Bank and UBS;
 
NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock
 
184,394,378 units of Ordinary Stock issued to the NPRFC on Monday 22 February 2010 in lieu of the cash dividend otherwise due on the 2009 Preference Stock;
 
NPRFC Placing
 
The proposed conversion by the NPRFC of units of 2009 Preference Stock to units of Ordinary Stock as part of the Placing;
 
Placing Stock
 
The 326,797,386 units of Ordinary Stock to be issued by the Bank pursuant to the Institutional Placing;
 
Rights Issue
 
The offer by way of rights to Qualifying Stockholders to acquire Rights Issue Stock and also includes, where the context so requires, the NPRFC Rights Issue Undertaking;


F-182


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENT  (Continued)
 
58 POST BALANCE SHEET EVENTS  (continued)
 
Rights Issue Stock
 
Up to 18,851,465,603 units of new Ordinary Stock to be allotted and issued by the Bank pursuant to the Rights Issue;
 
Qualifying Stockholders
 
Holders of Ordinary Stock on the Stockholder register of the Bank at the 5pm May 17, 2010 and Placees (excluding the NPRFC in respect of the NPRFC Coupon Ordinary Stock);
 
Underwriting Agreement
 
The underwriting and sponsors’ agreement dated April 26, 2010 between the Bank and the Underwriters relating to the Institutional Placing and the Rights Issue;
 
Warrant Cancellation
 
The cancellation of the Warrants in return for the payment of €491 million by the Bank to the NPRFC;
 
59  SELECTED FINANCIAL INFORMATION FOR THE NINE MONTHS ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2008 (UNAUDITED)
 
The figures below for the nine month period ended December 31, 2008, have not been audited and are presented for comparative purposes only.
 
                 
    9 Months ended
  9 Months ended
    December 31, 2009   December 31, 2008
    €m   €m
 
Total operating income (net of insurance claims)
    3,599       3,079  
                 
Impairment losses on loans and advances to customers
    (4,055 )     (747 )
                 
Impairment of goodwill and other intangible assets
    (6 )     (304 )
(Loss)/Profit before tax
    (1,813 )     372  
Taxation credit/(charge)
    344       (62 )
                 
(Loss)/Profit for the period
    (1,469 )     310  
                 
Earnings per share (cent)
    (168.6c )     32.7c  
 
The cumulative effect of a change in accounting principles would have been a charge of €12 million for the nine months ended December 31, 2008.
 
60 APPROVAL OF 20-F
 
The Court of Directors approved the financial statements for inclusion in Form 20-F on June 14, 2010


F-183


Table of Contents

BANK OF IRELAND GROUP
 
SIGNATURES
 
The Registrant hereby certifies that it meets all of the requirements for filing on Form 20-F and that it has duly caused and authorised the undersigned to sign this annual report on its behalf.
 
The Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland
(Registrant)
 
Date: June 14, 2010
 
  By: 
/s/  Richie Boucher
Name:     Richie Boucher
  Title:  Group Chief Executive
 
  By: 
/s/  John O’Donovan
Name:     John O’Donovan
  Title:  Group Chief Financial Officer


F-184