<?xml version="1.0"?>
<informationTable xmlns="http://www.sec.gov/edgar/document/thirteenf/informationtable" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>3M CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>88579Y101</cusip><value>186</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1125</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1125</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ABBOTT LABS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>002824100</cusip><value>3313</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>71526</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>47926</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>23600</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ABBVIE INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>00287Y109</cusip><value>1991</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>34000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>19300</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>14700</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ACCENTURE PLC IRELAND</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SHS CLASS A</titleOfClass><cusip>G1151C101</cusip><value>258</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2755</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2755</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ADVANCE AUTO PARTS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>00751Y106</cusip><value>3257</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>21754</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>14654</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>7100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>AGNICO EAGLE MINES LTD</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>008474108</cusip><value>2983</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>106756</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>73756</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>33000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ALLIANT ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>018802108</cusip><value>4264</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>67681</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>43081</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>24600</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN ELEC PWR INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>025537101</cusip><value>2110</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>37500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>21200</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>16300</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN EXPRESS CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>025816109</cusip><value>2514</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>32181</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>21381</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>10800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>AMERICAN INTL GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass><cusip>026874784</cusip><value>2607</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>47573</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>31773</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>15800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>AMGEN INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>031162100</cusip><value>155</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>970</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>970</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ANADARKO PETE CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>032511107</cusip><value>3777</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>45607</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>30807</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>14800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ANHEUSER BUSCH INBEV SA/NV</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass><cusip>03524A108</cusip><value>3501</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>28715</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>17915</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>10800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>APACHE CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>037411105</cusip><value>2089</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>34614</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>23414</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>11200</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>APPLE INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>037833100</cusip><value>5728</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>46036</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>30636</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>15400</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ARES CAP CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>04010L103</cusip><value>3879</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>225900</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>225900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>AT&amp;T INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>00206R102</cusip><value>339</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>10381</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>10381</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BANK AMER CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>7.25%CNV PFD L</titleOfClass><cusip>060505682</cusip><value>10916</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>9435</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>9435</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BANK NEW YORK MELLON CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>064058100</cusip><value>161</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>4000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>4000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BARCLAYS BANK PLC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>ADR PFD SR 5</titleOfClass><cusip>06739H362</cusip><value>525</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>20000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>20000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BARRICK GOLD CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>067901108</cusip><value>679</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>61943</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>44343</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>17600</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BAXTER INTL INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>071813109</cusip><value>83</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1215</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1215</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BB&amp;T CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>054937107</cusip><value>143</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>3665</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>3665</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BECTON DICKINSON &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>075887109</cusip><value>156</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1085</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1085</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BLACKROCK CAPITAL INVESTMENT</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>092533108</cusip><value>3687</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>407000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>407000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BOEING CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>097023105</cusip><value>368</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2450</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2450</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BRISTOL MYERS SQUIBB CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>110122108</cusip><value>1987</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>30800</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>18000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>12800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>BROWN &amp; BROWN INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>115236101</cusip><value>49</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1478</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1478</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CARTER INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>146229109</cusip><value>2264</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>24486</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>16386</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>8100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CHESAPEAKE ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>165167107</cusip><value>2858</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>201855</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>135755</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>66100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CHEVRON CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>166764100</cusip><value>6007</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>57226</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>42526</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>14700</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CISCO SYS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>17275R102</cusip><value>8550</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>310613</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>227413</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>83200</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CLAYMORE EXCHANGE TRD FD TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>GUGG CRP BD 2017</titleOfClass><cusip>18383M548</cusip><value>142</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>6200</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>6200</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CMS ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>125896100</cusip><value>4095</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>117289</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>74589</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>42700</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>COCA COLA CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>191216100</cusip><value>3876</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>95600</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>75300</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>20300</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CONOCOPHILLIPS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>20825C104</cusip><value>7424</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>119246</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>88146</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>31100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CONSOLIDATED EDISON INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>209115104</cusip><value>1430</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>23450</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>13250</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>10200</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>COSTCO WHSL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>22160K105</cusip><value>246</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1625</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1625</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>COTY INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass><cusip>222070203</cusip><value>2042</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>84153</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>55353</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>28800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CROWN CASTLE INTL CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>22822V101</cusip><value>1073</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>13000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>8600</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>4400</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>CVS HEALTH CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>126650100</cusip><value>5476</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>53057</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>36457</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>16600</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DANAHER CORP DEL</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>235851102</cusip><value>166</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1960</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1960</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DARDEN RESTAURANTS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>237194105</cusip><value>2135</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>30800</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>17500</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>13300</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DEVON ENERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>25179M103</cusip><value>1911</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>31684</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>21684</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>10000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DEVRY ED GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>251893103</cusip><value>50</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1494</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>1494</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DIAGEO P L C</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SPON ADR NEW</titleOfClass><cusip>25243Q205</cusip><value>25182</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>227750</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>01 02</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>227750</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DIAGEO P L C</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SPON ADR NEW</titleOfClass><cusip>25243Q205</cusip><value>146</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1320</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1320</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DIAMOND FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>252603105</cusip><value>2927</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>89869</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>55673</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>34196</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DISNEY WALT CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM DISNEY</titleOfClass><cusip>254687106</cusip><value>44</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>415</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>415</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DOMINION RES INC VA NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>25746U109</cusip><value>3217</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>45390</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>27490</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>17900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>DUKE ENERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass><cusip>26441C204</cusip><value>2939</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>38283</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>27183</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>11100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>E M C CORP MASS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>268648102</cusip><value>2691</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>105273</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>70373</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>34900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>EBAY INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>278642103</cusip><value>2552</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>44258</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>29358</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>14900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ENTERGY CORP NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>29364G103</cusip><value>1968</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>25400</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>15800</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>9600</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>EXXON MOBIL CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>30231G102</cusip><value>795</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>9350</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>9350</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>FLOWERS FOODS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>343498101</cusip><value>1566</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>68861</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>45961</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>22900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>GENERAL ELECTRIC CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>369604103</cusip><value>17715</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>714042</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>01 02</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>714042</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>GENERAL ELECTRIC CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>369604103</cusip><value>1112</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>44800</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>32200</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>12600</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>GLAXOSMITHKLINE PLC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass><cusip>37733W105</cusip><value>1717</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>37210</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>23310</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>13900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>GOLDCORP INC NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>380956409</cusip><value>3993</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>220374</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>151074</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>69300</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>38141G104</cusip><value>81027</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>431063</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>01 02</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>431063</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>GOLUB CAP BDC INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>38173M102</cusip><value>4087</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>232876</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>232876</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>HALYARD HEALTH INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>40650V100</cusip><value>10</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>212</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>212</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>HEWLETT PACKARD CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>428236103</cusip><value>6932</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>222471</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>147071</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>75400</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>HOME DEPOT INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>437076102</cusip><value>218</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1915</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1915</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>HONEYWELL INTL INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>438516106</cusip><value>60</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>575</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>575</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>IAMGOLD CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>450913108</cusip><value>360</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>192589</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>133689</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>58900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ILLINOIS TOOL WKS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>452308109</cusip><value>34</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>350</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>350</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>INTEL CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>458140100</cusip><value>56</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1800</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1800</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>459200101</cusip><value>177</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1100</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1100</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>INTERNATIONAL FLAVORS&amp;FRAGRA</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>459506101</cusip><value>182</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1550</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1550</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>IBOXX HI YD ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464288513</cusip><value>7247</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>79975</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>75000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>4975</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>INTERM CR BD ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464288638</cusip><value>521</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>4710</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>4710</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>MSCI CDA ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464286509</cusip><value>22</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>800</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>800</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>MSCI PAC JP ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464286665</cusip><value>23</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>500</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>MSCI SINGAP ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464286673</cusip><value>3925</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>306614</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>177314</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>129300</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>U.S. PFD STK ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464288687</cusip><value>512</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>12752</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>5502</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>7250</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CORE HIGH DV ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>46429B663</cusip><value>969</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>12920</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>4920</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>8000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CORE S&amp;P SCP ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464287804</cusip><value>2925</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>24784</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>24784</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CORE S&amp;P500 ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464287200</cusip><value>3034</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>14600</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>13800</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>MSCI EAFE ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464287465</cusip><value>417</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>6500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>6500</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>MSCI UTD KNGDM</titleOfClass><cusip>46434V548</cusip><value>25</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1400</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1400</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>RUSSELL 3000 ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464287689</cusip><value>456</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>3680</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>3680</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>S&amp;P 100 ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464287101</cusip><value>2121</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>23500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>19500</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>4000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SELECT DIVID ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>464287168</cusip><value>15093</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>193650</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>180100</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>13550</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ISHARES TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>USA MIN VOL ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>46429B697</cusip><value>9077</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>220000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>220000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>JOHNSON &amp; JOHNSON</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>478160104</cusip><value>1936</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>19250</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>12050</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>7200</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>JPMORGAN CHASE &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>46625H100</cusip><value>7737</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>127714</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>81714</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>46000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>KELLOGG CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>487836108</cusip><value>646</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>9786</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>8686</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>1100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>KIMBERLY CLARK CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>494368103</cusip><value>182</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1700</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1700</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>KINDER MORGAN INC DEL</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>49456B101</cusip><value>4181</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>99400</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>78900</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>20500</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>KINROSS GOLD CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM NO PAR</titleOfClass><cusip>496902404</cusip><value>526</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>234605</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>162905</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>71700</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>KOHLS CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>500255104</cusip><value>4400</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>56235</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>37335</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>18900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>KRAFT FOODS GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>50076Q106</cusip><value>8623</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>98983</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>65917</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>33066</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>LILLY ELI &amp; CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>532457108</cusip><value>2332</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>32100</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>18800</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>13300</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>LINEAR TECHNOLOGY CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>535678106</cusip><value>62</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1315</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1315</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>LOCKHEED MARTIN CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>539830109</cusip><value>2334</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>11500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>6800</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>4700</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MARATHON OIL CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>565849106</cusip><value>2060</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>78890</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>53990</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>24900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MARKEL CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>570535104</cusip><value>115</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>150</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>150</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MARKET VECTORS ETF TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>GOLD MINER ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>57060U100</cusip><value>69</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>3800</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>3800</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MARRIOTT INTL INC NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass><cusip>571903202</cusip><value>80</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MCDONALDS CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>580135101</cusip><value>4163</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>42715</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>34715</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>8000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MEAD JOHNSON NUTRITION CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>582839106</cusip><value>5658</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>56285</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>37585</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>18700</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MEDTRONIC PLC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass><cusip>G5960L103</cusip><value>4375</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>56100</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>40400</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>15700</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MERCK &amp; CO INC NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>58933Y105</cusip><value>1908</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>33200</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>19400</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>13800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MICROSOFT CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>594918104</cusip><value>8050</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>198008</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>125108</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>72900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>MONDELEZ INTL INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass><cusip>609207105</cusip><value>2494</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>69102</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>46802</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>22300</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>NEWMONT MINING CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>651639106</cusip><value>245</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>11300</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>3600</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>7700</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>NORDSTROM INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>655664100</cusip><value>173</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2150</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2150</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>NORTHERN TR CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>665859104</cusip><value>192</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2750</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2750</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>NOVARTIS A G</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SPONSORED ADR</titleOfClass><cusip>66987V109</cusip><value>222</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2250</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2250</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>OMNICOM GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>681919106</cusip><value>143</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1840</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1840</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ORACLE CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>68389X105</cusip><value>120</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2770</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2770</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>OUTFRONT MEDIA INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>69007J106</cusip><value>3225</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>107804</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>80585</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>27219</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>PACCAR INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>693718108</cusip><value>139</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2205</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2205</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>PEPSICO INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>713448108</cusip><value>6605</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>69079</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>44879</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>24200</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>PFIZER INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>717081103</cusip><value>5220</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>150055</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>109582</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>40473</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>PG&amp;E CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>69331C108</cusip><value>1940</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>36550</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>22350</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>14200</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>PINNACLE WEST CAP CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>723484101</cusip><value>1855</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>29100</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>16500</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>12600</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>POWERSHARES ETF TR II</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>BUILD AMER ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>73937B407</cusip><value>1366</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>44990</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>44990</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>POWERSHARES ETF TRUST II</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SENIOR LN PORT</titleOfClass><cusip>73936Q769</cusip><value>9651</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>400650</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>135500</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>265150</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>POWERSHARES GLOBAL ETF TRUST</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>AGG PFD PORT</titleOfClass><cusip>73936T565</cusip><value>104</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>6950</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>6950</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>PPL CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>69351T106</cusip><value>2026</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>60200</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>37400</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>22800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>PRAXAIR INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>74005P104</cusip><value>82</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>680</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>680</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>PROCTER &amp; GAMBLE CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>742718109</cusip><value>7589</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>92612</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>60712</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>31900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>PUBLIC SVC ENTERPRISE GROUP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>744573106</cusip><value>1905</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>45450</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>25750</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>19700</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>QUALCOMM INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>747525103</cusip><value>148</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2140</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2140</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ROCKWELL COLLINS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>774341101</cusip><value>108</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1115</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1115</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ROYAL DUTCH SHELL PLC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SPONS ADR A</titleOfClass><cusip>780259206</cusip><value>1819</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>30500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>19400</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>11100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SANOFI</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>RIGHT 12/31/2020</titleOfClass><cusip>80105N113</cusip><value>1</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>2000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SCHLUMBERGER LTD</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>806857108</cusip><value>101</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1205</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1205</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SELECT SECTOR SPDR TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SBI INT-ENERGY</titleOfClass><cusip>81369Y506</cusip><value>1637</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>21100</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>19000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>2100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SEVENTY SEVEN ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>818097107</cusip><value>0</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SOUTHERN CO</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>842587107</cusip><value>5721</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>129218</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>87318</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>41900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SPDR GOLD TRUST</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>GOLD SHS</titleOfClass><cusip>78463V107</cusip><value>3414</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>30037</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>19937</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>10100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SPDR S&amp;P 500 ETF TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>TR UNIT</titleOfClass><cusip>78462F103</cusip><value>56882</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>275552</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>256882</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>18670</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SPDR S&amp;P 500 ETF TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>TR UNIT</titleOfClass><cusip>78462F103</cusip><value>13221</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>64045</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>64045</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SPDR S&amp;P MIDCAP 400 ETF TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>UTSER1 S&amp;PDCRP</titleOfClass><cusip>78467Y107</cusip><value>6095</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>21984</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>21984</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SPDR SERIES TRUST</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>BRC HGH YLD BD</titleOfClass><cusip>78464A417</cusip><value>35</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>900</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SPECTRA ENERGY CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>847560109</cusip><value>3527</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>97500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>75000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>22500</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SYMETRA FINL CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>87151Q106</cusip><value>470347</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>20048879</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>01 02</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>20048879</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>SYSCO CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>871829107</cusip><value>1774</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>47000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>26600</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>20400</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>TARGET CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>87612E106</cusip><value>6315</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>76956</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>50656</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>26300</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>THE ADT CORPORATION</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>00101J106</cusip><value>2985</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>71892</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>48092</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>23800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>TOTAL SYS SVCS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>891906109</cusip><value>1930</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>50588</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>33788</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>16800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>TYCO INTL PLC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SHS</titleOfClass><cusip>G91442106</cusip><value>2641</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>61327</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>38127</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>23200</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>U S G CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass><cusip>903293405</cusip><value>117105</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>4385964</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>01 02</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>4385964</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>UNITED PARCEL SERVICE INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CL B</titleOfClass><cusip>911312106</cusip><value>227</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2340</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2340</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORP</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>913017109</cusip><value>348</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2970</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2970</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>91324P102</cusip><value>142</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1200</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1200</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>US BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass><cusip>902973304</cusip><value>759266</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>17386443</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>01 02</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>17386443</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>US BANCORP DEL</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM NEW</titleOfClass><cusip>902973304</cusip><value>2402</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>55005</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>38605</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>16400</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD BD INDEX FD INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>TOTAL BND MRKT</titleOfClass><cusip>921937835</cusip><value>959</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>11500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>11500</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD INDEX FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>LARGE CAP ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>922908637</cusip><value>999</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>10500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>6600</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>3900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD INDEX FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>MCAP GR IDXVIP</titleOfClass><cusip>922908538</cusip><value>43</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>400</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>400</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD INDEX FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>MCAP VL IDXVIP</titleOfClass><cusip>922908512</cusip><value>37</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>400</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>400</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD INDEX FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SM CP VAL ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>922908611</cusip><value>33</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>300</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>300</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD INDEX FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>SML CP GRW ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>922908595</cusip><value>40</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>300</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>300</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD INDEX FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>TOTAL STK MKT</titleOfClass><cusip>922908769</cusip><value>7325</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>68300</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>68300</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD INDEX FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>VALUE ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>922908744</cusip><value>126</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1500</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1500</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD INTL EQUITY INDEX F</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>FTSE EUROPE ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>922042874</cusip><value>103</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1900</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1900</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD INTL EQUITY INDEX F</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>FTSE PACIFIC ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>922042866</cusip><value>1734</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>28291</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>28291</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD SCOTTSDALE FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>INT-TERM CORP</titleOfClass><cusip>92206C870</cusip><value>717</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>8180</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>8180</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD WORLD FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>ENERGY ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>92204A306</cusip><value>33</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>300</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>300</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VANGUARD WORLD FDS</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>MATERIALS ETF</titleOfClass><cusip>92204A801</cusip><value>43</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>400</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>400</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VARIAN MED SYS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>92220P105</cusip><value>160</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1700</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1700</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VERISK ANALYTICS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass><cusip>92345Y106</cusip><value>2071</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>29000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>29000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VERISK ANALYTICS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass><cusip>92345Y106</cusip><value>210919</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2954050</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>01 02</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>2954050</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>92343V104</cusip><value>3744</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>76991</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>61991</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>15000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VIACOM INC NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass><cusip>92553P102</cusip><value>69</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>1000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>1000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>VISA INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM CL A</titleOfClass><cusip>92826C839</cusip><value>249</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>3800</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>3800</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>WALGREENS BOOTS ALLIANCE INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>931427108</cusip><value>5840</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>68961</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>45861</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>23100</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>WAL-MART STORES INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>931142103</cusip><value>602255</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>7322251</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>01 02</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>7322251</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>WASTE MGMT INC DEL</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>94106L109</cusip><value>108</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>2000</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>2000</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>WELLS FARGO &amp; CO NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>949746101</cusip><value>1322584</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>24312200</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>DFND</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>01 02</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>24312200</Shared><None>0</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>WELLS FARGO &amp; CO NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>949746101</cusip><value>4307</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>79177</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>60277</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>18900</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>WELLS FARGO &amp; CO NEW</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>PERP PFD CNV A</titleOfClass><cusip>949746804</cusip><value>16196</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>13275</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>OTR</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>0</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>13275</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>WISDOMTREE TR</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>EUROPE HEDGED EQ</titleOfClass><cusip>97717X701</cusip><value>11694</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>176809</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>163809</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>13000</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>XCEL ENERGY INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>COM</titleOfClass><cusip>98389B100</cusip><value>1824</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>52400</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>29600</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>22800</None></votingAuthority></infoTable><infoTable><nameOfIssuer>ZOETIS INC</nameOfIssuer><titleOfClass>CL A</titleOfClass><cusip>98978V103</cusip><value>2230</value><shrsOrPrnAmt><sshPrnamt>48173</sshPrnamt><sshPrnamtType>SH</sshPrnamtType></shrsOrPrnAmt><investmentDiscretion>SOLE</investmentDiscretion><otherManager>
		</otherManager><votingAuthority><Sole>31882</Sole><Shared>0</Shared><None>16291</None></votingAuthority></infoTable></informationTable>
