Subject: File No. S7-14-08
From: Scott McClane

August 14, 2008

I received my CFP designation in 1983 and have been insurance and securities licensed for 20 years. My opinion is that index annuities ABSOLUTELY SHOULD be governed by SEC and/or FINRA. A high percentage of these products are sold by people who do not understand them, do not explain them and are primarily motivated by greed.

I have encourtered numerous situations where clients new to me have purchased a high and long surrender IA and we cannot afford to liquidate, even when financial circumstances require it.

SEC151a should have been passed years ago.

Scott McClane