EX-99.6 13 tm238313d2_ex99-6.htm EXHIBIT 99.6

Exhibit 99.6

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

8804 Mirador Place

McLean, VA 22102

(202) 467-6862

 

  

Peru Federal Savings Bank
Peru, Illinois

  

Conversion Valuation Appraisal Update

Valued as of April 10, 2023

  

Prepared By

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

McLean, Virginia

 

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

8804 Mirador Place

McLean, VA 22102

202-467-6862

 

April 10, 2023

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

1730 Fourth Street 

Peru, Illinois 61354

 

Members of the Board of Directors:

 

At your request, we have completed and hereby provide an independent appraisal (the “Appraisal”) of the estimated pro forma market value of Peru Federal Savings Bank (the “Bank”) as of April 10, 2023 in conjunction with the Bank’s conversion (the “Conversion”) from the mutual to stock form of organization, issuance of all of its capital stock to a newly formed stock holding company known as PFS Bancorp, Inc. (“PFS Bancorp”), and offering for sale of PFS Bancorp’s common stock to eligible depositors of the Bank and the Bank’s employee stock ownership plan (“ESOP”) in a subscription offering. Shares not purchased in the subscription offering will be offered for sale to the general public in a community offering or syndicated community offering. This updated Appraisal is being furnished in connection with the reporting of the Bank’s recent financial results through the period ended March 31, 2023 and a review of current market conditions for bank and thrift common stocks.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc. (“Feldman Financial”) is a financial consulting and advisory firm that specializes in valuations and analyses of business enterprises and securities in the thrift, banking, and mortgage industries. The background of Feldman Financial is presented in Exhibit I. In preparing the Appraisal, we conducted an analysis of the Bank that included discussions with the Bank’s management, the Bank’s legal counsel, Luse Gorman, PC, and the Bank’s independent registered public accounting firm, Wipfli, LLP. In addition, where appropriate, we considered information based on other available published sources that we believe are reliable; however, we cannot guarantee the accuracy and completeness of such information. We also reviewed, among other factors, the economy in the Bank’s primary market area and compared the Bank’s financial condition and operating performance with that of selected publicly traded thrift institutions. We reviewed conditions in the securities markets in general and in the market for thrift institution common stocks in particular. Our original Appraisal as of February 21, 2023 is incorporated and supplemented herein by reference.

 

Our Appraisal is not intended and must not be construed to be a recommendation of any kind as to the advisability of purchasing shares of common stock in the offering. Moreover, because such valuations are necessarily based upon estimates and projections of a number of matters, all of which are subject to change from time to time, no assurance can be given that persons who purchase shares of stock in the offering will thereafter be able to sell such shares at prices related to our estimate of the Bank’s pro forma market value.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 2

 

Recent Financial Performance

 

Table 1 summarizes the Bank’s financial data and ratios as of December 31, 2021 and 2022 and March 31, 2023. Table 2 summarizes the Bank’s recent income statement data and performance ratios for the annual and year-to-date periods. Exhibits 1 to 3 present more detailed balance sheet and income statement data for recent historical periods.

 

Table 1 

Selected Financial Data and Ratios 

As of December 31, 2021 and 2022 and March 31, 2023 

(Dollars in Thousands)

 

   March 31,   December 31, 
   2023   2022   2021 
Selected Balance Sheet Data               
Total assets  $179,066   $174,134   $185,556 
Cash and cash equivalents   17,822    12,561    21,542 
Investment securities   67,189    66,475    74,759 
Federal Home Loan Bank stock   347    347    330 
Total loans, net   83,752    84,916    80,840 
Premises and equipment, net   2,124    2,150    2,159 
Bank-owned life insurance   3,806    3,783    3,696 
Total deposits   157,473    152,707    155,912 
Federal Home Loan Bank advances   -    -    5,000 
Total equity   20,402    20,139    23,440 
                
Capital Ratios               
Total equity to total assets   11.39%   11.57%   12.63%
Tier 1 capital as a % of average assets   13.67%   13.81%   12.55%
Tier 1 capital as a % of risk-weighted assets   28.04%   28.07%   28.14%
Total capital as a % of risk-weighted assets   28.74%   28.71%   28.84%
                
Asset Quality               
Non-performing loans to total loans (1)   2.38%   0.73%   0.96%
Non-performing assets to total assets (1)   1.12%   0.36%   0.42%
Allowance for loan losses to total loans   0.71%   0.64%   0.70%
Allowance for loan losses to non-performing loans (1)   29.99%   87.16%   72.32%

 

(1) Non-performing loans include troubled debt restructurings.        
             
Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank, financial statements and regulatory financial reports.    

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 3

 

The Bank’s total assets increased by $4.9 million or 2.8% to $179.1 million at March 31, 2023 from $174.1 million at December 31, 2022. The increase was due primarily to an increase in cash and cash equivalents that was supported by an increase in total deposits. Cash and cash equivalents increased by $5.2 million from $12.7 million at year-end 2022 to $17.8 million at March 31, 2023. Investment securities increased by $714,000 from $66.5 million at December 31, 2022 to $67.2 million at March 31, 2023. Total cash and securities increased from $79.6 million or 45.7% of total assets at year-end 2022 to $85.4 million or 47.7% of total assets at March 31, 2023. Mainly as a result of normal paydowns, net total loans decreased by $1.2 million or 1.4% to $83.8 million at March 31, 2023 from $84.9 million at December 31, 2022. Net total loans declined from 48.8% of total assets at year-end 2022 to 46.8% of total assets at March 31, 2023.

 

Total deposits increased by $4.8 million or 3.1% to $157.5 million at March 31, 2023 from $152.7 million at December 31, 2022. Certificate of deposit accounts increased by $6.6 million during the quarter ended March 31, 2023, while core deposits (non-certificate accounts) decreased by $1.8 million. The concentration of certificate accounts to total deposits increased from 31.7% at December 31, 2022 to 34.9% at March 31, 2023, while the ratio of core deposits to total deposits declined from 68.3% to 65.1% over the corresponding period.

 

The Bank’s total equity increased by $263,000 or 1.3% to $20.4 million at March 31, 2023 as compared to $20.1 million at December 31, 2022. The increase was primarily due to a $173,000 increase in retained earnings and an increase of $90,000 in accumulated other comprehensive income related to unrealized net unrealized holding losses on available-for-sale securities. Retained earnings increased due to the net income of $213,000 reported for the quarter ended March 31, 2023, offset partially by a negative tax-effected adjustment of $39,000 to reflect the adoption of the Current Expected Credit Losses (“CECL”) accounting standard that resulted in a pre-tax increase of $55,000 to the allowance for loan losses. The ratio of total equity to total assets declined from 11.57% at December 31, 2022 to 11.39% at March 31, 2023 as the rate of asset expansion (2.8%) exceeded the rate of capital formation (1.3%).

 

The Bank’s non-performing assets increased from $623,000 (0.36% of total assets) at December 31, 2022 to $2.0 million (1.12% of total assets) as non-accrual loans increased from $117,000 to $1.5 million. The increase was attributable to two commercial real estate loans with a single borrower that were placed on non-accrual status in February 2023 due to the borrower’s deteriorating financial position. The Bank holds two loans, one with a principal balance of approximately $905,000 representing a 10.3% participation interest, secured by commercial real estate, and one with a principal balance of approximately $396,000 representing a 25% participation interest, secured by commercial real estate. The borrower operates a local hospital and other medical services. The Bank has obtained updated appraisals that indicate the value of the collateral, assuming continued operations as a hospital, exceed the aggregate outstanding loan balances. The local hospital is currently in negotiations with larger health systems as it seeks solutions to keep the hospital in operation. However, in the event of a hospital closure, the Bank may need to take specific reserves or charge-offs in the future on one or both of these loans.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 4

 

Table 2 

Income Statement and Performance Ratios 

For the Years Ended December 31, 2021 and 2022 

And the Three Months Ended March 31, 2022 and 2023 

(Dollars in Thousands)

 

   Three Months Ended   Year Ended 
   March 31,   December 31, 
   2023   2022   2022   2021 
Total interest and dividend income  $1,417   $1,096   $4,803   $4,584 
Total interest expense   317    120    640    611 
Net interest income   1,100    976    4,163    3,973 
Provision (credit) for loan losses   5    37    61    (6)
Net interest income after provision   1,095    939    4,102    3,979 
                     
Total non-interest operating income   149    153    730    660 
Total non-interest expense   984    841    3,625    3,362 
                     
Realized loss on sale of available-for-sale securities   -    -    (221)   - 
                     
Income before income taxes   260    251    986    1,277 
Provision for income taxes   47    45    155    275 
Net income  $213   $206   $831   $1,002 
                     
Selected Performance Ratios (1)                    
Return on average assets   0.47%   0.45%   0.46%   0.56%
Return on average equity   4.20%   3.58%   3.99%   4.29%
Net interest rate spread   2.48%   2.11%   2.35%   2.19%
Net interest margin   2.65%   2.18%   2.42%   2.28%
Total non-interest expense to average assets   2.19%   1.84%   2.00%   1.87%
Efficiency ratio   78.78%   74.49%   74.09%   72.57%

 

(1) Annualized ratios for the quarterly period.

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank, financial data.                

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 5

 

The Bank’s net income increased by $7,000 or 3.4% to $213,000 for the three months ended March 31, 2023, compared to net income of $206,000 for the three months ended March 31, 2022. The moderate increase was primarily due to a $124,000 increase in net interest income and a $32,000 decrease in the provision for loan losses, offset partially by a $143,000 increase in non-interest expense. The Bank’s annualized return on average assets (“ROA”) was 0.47% for the first quarter of 2023 as compared to 0.45% for the first quarter of 2022. The Bank’s annualized return on average equity (“ROE”) was 4.20% for the first quarter of 2023 as compared to 3.58% for the first quarter of 2022.

 

Total interest income for the three months ended March 31, 2023 increased by $320,000 or 29.2% from $1.1 million for the three months ended March 31, 2022 to $1.4 million for the three months ended March 31, 2023. Interest income on cash and securities increased by $247,000, while interest income and fees on loans increased by $73,000 on a quarter-to-quarter basis. The weighted average yield on interest-earning assets increased by 97 basis points from 2.44% to 3.41%. Total interest expense increased by $197,000 or 164.2% from $120,000 to $317,000, reflecting the rising interest rate environment and consumer shift from transactional accounts to higher-cost certificate accounts. The weighted average cost of interest-bearing liabilities increased by 60 basis points from 0.33% to 0.93%. As a result, the Bank’s net interest rate spread increased by 37 basis points from 2.11% in the first quarter of 2022 to 2.48% in the first quarter of 2023.

 

As previously noted, the Bank adopted the CECL accounting standard as of January 1, 2023, which resulted in an increase to the allowance for loan losses of $55,000 that was recorded through retained earnings, net of the income tax effect. For the three months ended March 31, 2023, the provision for loan losses was $5,000 as compared to $37,000 for the three months ended March 31, 2022.

 

Non-interest income for the three months ended March 31, 2023 was $149,000, compared to $153,000 for the three months ended March 31, 2022. Customer service fee income increased $12,000 from the first quarter of 2022 to the first quarter of 2023, while realized gain on loan sales declined by $16,000 over the corresponding period. In relation to average assets, non-interest income increased slightly from 0.33% to 0.34% on an annualized basis.

 

Non-interest expense increased by $142,000 or 16.9% to $983,000 for the three months ended March 31, 2023 from $841,000 for the March 31, 2022, respectively. During the three months ended March 31, 2023 additional professional fees of $50,000 were incurred as a result of the Bank’s audit being completed to meet Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (“PCAOB”) standards, a $25,000 charitable donation made to a local not-for-profit organization, and approximately $20,000 of additional compensation as a result of training related to an employee retirement. The annualized ratio of non-interest expense to average assets increased from 1.84% for the quarter ended March 31, 2022 to 2.19% for the quarter ended March 31, 2023. The Bank’s efficiency ratio measured 78.8% for the recent quarter ended March 31, 2023 as compared to 74.5% for the quarter ended March 31, 2022.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 6

 

Comparative Group: Recent Financial Comparisons

 

Exhibits 4 through 8 summarize recent financial comparisons of the Bank with the Comparative Group for the last twelve months (“LTM”) ended December 31, 2022. Additionally, financial ratios for the Bank for the LTM ended March 31, 2023 are displayed. Such data for the LTM ended March 31, 2023 has not yet been reported by the Comparative Group companies. However, all companies in the Comparative Group are now reporting financial results for the LTM ended December 31, 2022, whereas in the original Appraisal there were only four of 12 companies reporting data for the LTM ended December 31, 2022.

 

Similar to the peer group analysis conducted in our original Appraisal, the Bank continues to be characterized by slightly lower profitability. For the LTM ended December 31, 2022, the Bank’s ROA was 0.46% as compared to the Comparative Group’s median ROA of 0.52%. For the LTM ended March 31, 2023, the Bank’s ROA measured 0.47%. The Bank’s core ROA (which excludes securities gains/losses and other non-recurring items) measured 0.56% for the LTM ended December 31, 2022 and surpassed the Comparative Group’s median core ROA of 0.47%.

 

Relative to the Comparative Group, the Bank’s profitability continues to be characterized by a lower net interest margin and a lower operating expense ratio. The Bank’s lower net interest margin is attributable primarily to its high concentration of cash and securities on the balance sheet and relatively low level of higher-yielding assets in the form of loans receivable. The Bank’s net interest margin measured 2.42% for the LTM ended December 31, 2022 versus the Comparative Group’s median of 3.04%. The Bank net interest margin advanced to 2.55% for the LTM ended March 31, 2023.

 

The Bank’s ratio of non-interest income to average assets was 0.40% for the LTM ended and December 31, 2022 and 0.41% for the LTM ended March 31, 2023, reflecting levels slightly below the Comparative Group’s median ratio of 0.45% for the LTM ended December 31, 2022. The Bank’s ratio of non-interest expense measured 2.00% of average assets for the LTM ended December 31, 2022 and compared favorably to the Comparative Group’s median ratio of 2.57% relative to average assets. The Bank’s ratio of non-interest expense increased to 2.12% for the LTM ended March 31, 2023 as shown in Exhibit 6.

 

The Bank’s ratio of total non-performing assets to total assets at December 31, 2022 was 0.36% and similar to the Comparative Group’s median ratio of 0.39%. However, the Bank’s non-performing assets expanded to 1.12% as of March 31, 2023 due primarily to two commercial real estate participation loans that were placed on non-accrual status in February 2023. The Bank’s ratio of loan loss reserves to total loans (measuring 0.64% at December 31, 2022 and 0.71% at March 31, 2023) remained below the corresponding Comparative Group’s median of 1.14% at December 31, 2022. The Bank’s ratio of tangible equity to assets (before the effect of the Conversion) was 11.57% at December 31, 2022 and 11.39% at March 31, 2023, moderately below the Comparative Group’s median of 12.88%.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 7

 

Comparative Group: Recent Stock Price Performance

 

Since our prior Appraisal as of February 21, 2023, market prices of bank and thrift stocks have plummeted due to widespread turmoil in the banking sector related to the sudden failure of Silicon Valley Bank - Santa Clara, California (“SVB”) and Signature Bank - New York, New York (“SNY”), along with lingering concerns about systemic weakness in the banking industry. The collapses of SVB and SNY represented the second-largest and third-largest, respectively, in the history of U.S. depository institutions. SVB had suffered significant losses in its investment securities portfolio as the value of its bonds declined in the rising interest rate environment. When SVB sold the underwater bonds in an attempt to restructure its portfolio and to raise capital, depositors with uninsured funds at SVB began to withdraw massive amounts of deposits which precipitated a run on SVB’s deposit liabilities.

 

Sensing a heightened risk of contagion, banking regulators took control of SVB and cobbled together programs to provide refuge for other imminently endangered institutions that might need to address liquidity pressures. SVB with assets of approximately $209 billion was seized by regulators on March 10, 2023. Facing a similar liquidity risk spiral, SNY with assets of approximately $110 billion was closed by regulators on March 12, 2023. The banking crisis became a global concern as the Swiss investment bank UBS Group agreed to buy the beleaguered Credit Suisse Group.

 

Investor fears about liquidity pressures, duration risk, underwater bond portfolios, and eroding capital levels spilled over to regional banks and community banks in the U.S. Market prices of bank and thrift stocks declined to one-year or two-year lows as concerns about the soundness and resilience of the U.S banking system focused on issues of unrealized investment losses and levels of uninsured deposits. The Federal Reserve raised the federal funds rate by a quarter point on March 22, 2023, underscoring its commitment to fighting inflation even amid deepening stresses in the banking industry, domestically and globally.

 

Moody’s Investors Service (“Moody’s”) reduced its investment outlook on the U.S. banking industry from stable to negative in March 2023 to reflect the rapid deterioration in the operating environment following the deposit runs at SVB and SNY and the subsequent failures of SVB and SNY. Moody’s noted that banks with substantial unrealized securities losses and with non-retail and uninsured depositors may still be more sensitive to depositor competition or ultimate flight, with adverse effects on funding, liquidity, earnings, and capital. Moody’s further expects pressures to persist and be exacerbated by ongoing monetary tightening with interest rates likely to remain higher for longer until inflation returns to within the Federal Reserve’s targets. Additionally, U.S. banks also now are facing sharply rising deposit costs after years of low funding costs, which will reduce earnings growth at banks, particularly those with a greater proportion of fixed-rate assets.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 8

 

Exhibit 9 summarizes the net change of the Comparative Group’s stock prices and selected market indexes between February 21, 2023 and April 10, 2023. The S&P U.S. Broad Market Index (“BMI”) for all banks and thrifts decreased by 19.5% over this interim period of seven weeks. In sharp contrast, the S&P 500 Stock Index advanced by 2.8% between February 21, 2023 and April 10, 2023. The NASDAQ Bank Index declined by 26.0% over this period. The S&P SmallCap Banks Index and S&P Midwest Banks Index fell by 23.1% and 23.7%, respectively, further evidencing the weakened market pricing for bank and thrift equities.

 

The Comparative Group was not shielded from the severe downturn in bank and thrift stock prices. The Comparative Group an posted an average price decline of 11.1% and median price decline of 12.8% between February 21, 2023 and April 10, 2023. All 12 members of the Comparative Group recorded net stock price declines. The median price-to-book value (“P/B”) ratio for the Comparative Group decreased from 85.0% at February 21, 2023 to 76.9% at April 10, 2023. The median price-to-tangible book value (“P/TB”) ratio for the Comparative Group decreased from 85.0% at February 21, 2023 to 77.1% at April 10, 2023. The median LTM price-to-earnings (“P/E”) ratio for the Comparative Group decreased from 19.2x at February 21, 2023 to 18.5x at April 10, 2023.

 

Valuation Review and Analysis

 

Since our original Appraisal, there has been no material change in the Bank’s operating performance. The Bank reported net income of $838,000 for the LTM ended March 31, 2023, as compared to $831,000 for the LTM ended December 31, 2022. The Bank’s ROA measured 0.47% for the LTM ended March 31, 2023 and 0.46% for the LTM ended December 31, 2022. The Bank’s recent earnings results remained slightly below the overall Comparative Group’s level. The Bank’s non-performing assets increased from 0.36% of total assets at December 31, 2022 to 1.12% at March 31, 2023, above the Comparative Group’s median ratio of 0.39%. The Bank continues to monitor the status of the $1.3 million in commercial real estate loans that were recently placed on non-accrual status.

 

Market conditions for bank and thrift stocks declined sharply as evidenced by the market price changes experienced by the Comparative Group and the various bank stock indexes. The Comparative Group’s stock prices declined by an average of 11.1% and a median of 12.8% between February 21, 2023 and April 10, 2023. The Comparative Group’s average P/B ratio declined by 11.6% from 88.2% to 78.0% and its median P/B ratio declined by 9.5% from 85.0% to 76.9%. In our original Appraisal, we concluded that the Bank’s pro forma market value should be discounted to the Comparative Group’s trading ratios due to factors related to earnings growth and viability, market area, liquidity of the issue, and the new issue discount underlying current stock market conditions. Because of the broad decline in market prices in the banking sector, along with the specific declines of the trading market valuation ratios of the Comparative Group, we believe that a downward adjustment is necessary for the Bank’s current pro forma market value. Based on the aggregate midpoint, including the $400,000 in common stock to be contributed to the Bank’s charitable foundation, we have concluded that the Bank’s estimated pro forma market value should be decreased by $2.0 million or 10.9% from $18.4 million to $16.4 million. Updating for financial data as of March 31, 2023 and the pro forma market value of $16.4 million, we have calculated pro forma P/B and P/TB ratios of 49.7% and 49.7%, respectively, for the Bank as shown below in Table 3.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 9

 

Table 3 

Comparative Pro Forma Market Valuation Ranges 

(Dollars in Thousands)

 

   Original   Current     
   Appraisal   Appraisal   Change 
Pro forma minimum  $15,700   $14,000    -10.8%
Pro forma midpoint   18,400    16,400    -10.9%
Pro forma maximum   21,100    18,800    -10.9%
Pro forma adjusted maximum   24,205    21,560    -10.9%
                
Pro forma minimum P/B   48.9%   45.4%   -7.2%
Pro forma midpoint P/B   53.4%   49.7%   -6.9%
Pro forma maximum P/B   57.3%   53.6%   -6.5%
Pro forma adjusted maximum P/B   61.2%   57.5%   -6.0%

 

 

Employing a range of approximately 15% above and below the updated midpoint, the revised minimum value of $14.0 million reflects a 45.4% P/B ratio and the resulting maximum value of $18.8 million reflects a 53.6% P/B ratio. The adjusted maximum value, computed as an additional 15% above the maximum, is positioned at approximately $21.6 million and a P/B ratio of 57.5%. The Bank’s pro forma P/B and P/TB ratios are equivalent since the Bank had no intangible assets as of March 31, 2023.

 

Table 4 summarizes the relative differences between the Bank’s pro forma valuation ratios and the Comparative Group’s median ratios. As illustrated, the differential levels observed in the original Appraisal are similar to those evident in the current Appraisal. The Bank’s pro forma midpoint P/B and P/TB ratios of 49.7% reflect a discount of 35.4% to the Comparative Group median P/B ratio of 76.9% and a discount of 35.5% to the Comparative Group’s median P/TB ratio of 77.1%. The Bank’s pro forma midpoint P/E ratio of 16.1x is discounted 3.6% to the Comparative Group’s median P/E ratio of 16.7x, and the Bank’s pro forma midpoint core P/E ratio of 13.7x is discounted 25.9% to the Comparative Group’s median core P/E ratio of 18.5x.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 10

 

Table 4 

Comparative Valuation Ratios at the Pro Forma Midpoint Value 

(Dollars in Thousands)

 

   Original Appraisal   Current Appraisal 
   Peru Federal Savings Bank   Peru Federal Savings Bank 
   As of February 21, 2023   As of April 10, 2023 
   Pro Forma   Comp.   Difference   Pro Forma   Comp.   Difference 
   Midpoint   Group   vs. Comp.   Midpoint   Group   vs. Comp. 
   $18,400   Median   Group   $16,400   Median   Group 
Price / book ratio   53.4%   85.0%   -37.2%   49.7%   76.9%   -35.4%
Price / tangible book ratio   53.4%   85.0%   -37.2%   49.7%   77.1%   -35.5%
Price / LTM EPS   17.9x   19.2x   -6.8%   16.1x   16.7x   -3.6%
Price / core EPS   15.2x   19.2x   -20.8%   13.7x   18.5x   -25.9%

 

Valuation Conclusion

 

It is our opinion that, as of April 10, 2023, the estimated pro forma market value of the Bank (inclusive of the $400,000 of common stock to be contributed to the charitable foundation) was within a range of $14,000,000 to $18,800,000 with a midpoint of $16,400,000 (the “Valuation Range”). Pursuant to applicable appraisal guidelines, the Valuation Range was based upon a decrease of approximately 15% decrease from the midpoint value to determine the minimum value and an increase of approximately 15% from the midpoint value to establish the maximum value. Assuming an additional increase of approximately above the maximum value would result in an adjusted maximum of $21,560,000.

 

Based on the Valuation Range, the range of shares to be sold in the stock offering (excluding the shares of common stock to be contributed to the charitable foundation) is as follows: $13,600,000 at the minimum, $16,000,000 at the midpoint, $18,400,000 at the maximum, and $21,160,000 at the adjusted maximum. Based on an initial offering price of $10.00 per share, the number of shares to be sold in the stock offering is as follows: 1,360,000 at the minimum, 1,600,000 at the midpoint, 1,840,000 at the maximum, and 2,116,000 at the adjusted maximum. Exhibit 9 compares the Bank’s pro forma valuation ratios to the market valuation ratios of the Comparative Group.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Board of Directors 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

April 10, 2023 

Page 11

 

Exhibit 10 compares the Bank’s pro forma market valuation ratios to those of the Comparative Group. Exhibit 11 displays the assumptions utilized in calculating the pro forma financial consequences of the stock offering. Exhibit 12 displays pro forma financial data at the minimum, midpoint, maximum, and adjusted maximum levels of the Valuation Range. Exhibit 13 provides more detailed data and calculations at the pro forma midpoint level of the Valuation Range. Exhibit 14 computes the percentage differences of the Bank’s pro forma valuation ratios with the averages and medians reported by the Comparative Group. Exhibit 15 provides supporting data of financial ratios and trading market valuation ratios for all publicly traded thrift institutions.

 

Sincerely,  
   
Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.  
   
   
By: Trent R. Feldman   
  President  
   
   
By: Peter W. L. Williams   
  Principal  

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 1 

Consolidated Balance Sheets 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

As of December 31, 2021 and 2022 and March 31, 2023 

(Dollars in Thousands)

 

   March 31,   December 31, 
   2023   2022   2021 
Assets               
Cash and cash equivalents  $17,822   $12,651   $21,542 
Available-for-sale debt securities   61,348    63,329    71,705 
Held-to-maturity debt securities   5,841    3,146    3,054 
Equity securities   89    88    112 
Federal Home Loan Bank stock   347    347    330 
                
Loans   84,355    85,459    81,407 
Allowance for loan losses   (603)   (543)   (567)
Loans, net   83,752    84,916    80,840 
                
Premises and equipment, net   2,124    2,150    2,159 
Interest receivable   529    592    566 
Bank-owned life insurance   3,806    3,783    3,696 
Other assets   3,406    3,132    1,552 
Total Assets  $179,066   $174,134   $185,556 
                
Liabilities and Equity               
Deposits:               
Demand accounts  $18,080   $17,248   $18,611 
Savings, NOW, and money market accounts   84,477    87,120    90,320 
Certificate of deposit accounts   54,916    48,339    46,981 
Total Deposits   157,473    152,707    155,912 
                
Federal Home Loan Bank advances   -    -    5,000 
Deferred compensation   705    687    635 
Interest payable and other liabilities   485    601    569 
Total Liabilities   158,663    153,995    162,116 
                
Retained earnings   24,001    23,828    22,997 
Accumulated other comprehensive income (loss)   (3,599)   (3,689)   443 
Total Equity   20,402    20,139    23,440 
                
Total Liabilities and Equity  $179,066   $174,134   $185,556 

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank, financial statements.        

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 2
Consolidated Income Statements

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

For the Three Months Ended March 31, 2022 and 2023 

(Dollars in Thousands)

 

   Three Months Ended 
   March 31, 
   2023   2022 
Total interest and dividend income  $1,417   $1,096 
Total interest expense   317    120 
Net interest income   1,100    976 
           
Provision for loan losses   5    37 
Net interest income after provision   1,095    939 
           
Commission income   4    5 
Customer service fees   94    81 
Net realized gain on loan sales   2    18 
Loan servicing fees   19    20 
Realized loss on sale of available-for-sale securities   -    - 
Other income   30    29 
Total non-interest income   149    153 
           
Salaries and employee benefits   521    487 
Occupancy   74    65 
Depreciation   37    37 
Data processing   131    122 
Professional fees   75    24 
Marketing   36    33 
Printing and office supplies   22    15 
Foreclosed assets, net   1    - 
Deposit insurance premiums   35    35 
Other expense   50    24 
Total non-interest expense   984    841 
           
Income before income taxes   260    251 
Provision for income taxes   47    45 
           
Net income  $213   $206 

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank, financial statements.

                   

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 3
Consolidated Income Statements
 

Peru Federal Savings Bank 

For the Years Ended December 31, 2021 and 2022 

(Dollars in Thousands)

 

   Year Ended 
   Decembe 31, 
   2022   2021 
Total interest and dividend income  $4,803   $4,584 
Total interest expense   640    611 
Net interest income   4,163    3,973 
           
Provision for loan losses   61    (6)
Net interest income after provision   4,102    3,979 
           
Commission income   28    28 
Customer service fees   368    339 
Net realized gain on loan sales   140    144 
Loan servicing fees   78    81 
Realized loss on sale of available-for-sale securities   (221)   - 
Other income   116    68 
Total non-interest income   509    660 
           
Salaries and employee benefits   2,002    1,962 
Occupancy   244    232 
Depreciation   145    152 
Data processing   573    434 
Professional fees   152    100 
Marketing   129    124 
Printing and office supplies   69    63 
Foreclosed assets, net   13    - 
Deposit insurance premiums   140    163 
Other expense   158    132 
Total non-interest expense   3,625    3,362 
           
Income before income taxes   986    1,277 
Provision for income taxes   155    275 
           
Net income  $831   $1,002 

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank, financial statements.

         

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 4

General Operating Characteristics

As of December 31, 2022

 

                               Tang. 
                   Total   Total   Total   Common 
            No. of   IPO  Assets   Deposits   Equity   Equity 
   City/State  Ticker  Exchange  Offices   Date  ($000s)   ($000s)   ($000s)   ($000s) 
Peru Federal Savings Bank  Peru, IL  NA  NA   2   NA   174,134    152,707    20,139    20,139 
Peru Federal Savings Bank (1)                    179,066    157,473    20,402    20,402 
                                      
Comparative Group Average                    467,058    360,355    68,504    68,345 
Comparative Group Median                    420,288    306,878    73,226    73,226 
                                      
Comparative Group                                     
1895 Bancorp of Wisconsin, Inc.  Greenfield, WI  BCOW  NASDAQ   6   01/08/19   543,016    387,721    75,362    75,362 
Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.  Opelousas, LA  CLST  NASDAQ   6   10/12/21   263,324    165,094    88,474    88,474 
Cullman Bancorp, Inc.  Cullman, AL  CULL  NASDAQ   4   10/08/09   423,229    292,949    100,182    100,182 
Generations Bancorp NY, Inc.  Seneca Falls, NY  GBNY  NASDAQ   10   07/10/06   386,293    317,678    37,328    35,818 
Home Federal Bancorp, Inc.  Shreveport, LA  HFBL  NASDAQ   11   01/18/05   576,543    518,211    48,689    48,689 
IF Bancorp, Inc.  Watseka, IL  IROQ  NASDAQ   8   07/07/11   823,727    667,337    71,090    71,090 
Magyar Bancorp, Inc.  New Brunswick, NJ  MGYR  NASDAQ   7   01/23/06   821,626    676,083    99,918    99,918 
Mid-Southern Bancorp, Inc.  Salem, IN  MSVB  NASDAQ   3   04/08/98   269,218    206,064    33,322    33,322 
NSTS Bancorp, Inc.  Waukegan, IL  NSTS  NASDAQ   3   01/18/22   264,206    178,714    80,542    80,542 
PB Bankshares, Inc.  Coatesville, PA  PBBK  NASDAQ   4   07/14/21   386,547    289,495    45,987    45,987 
TC Bancshares, Inc.  Thomasville, GA  TCBC  NASDAQ   2   07/20/21   429,618    328,840    85,278    85,278 
Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.  Mineola, TX  TCBS  NASDAQ   6   07/14/21   417,346    296,077    55,870    55,473 

 

(1) As of March 31, 2023.

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank; S&P Global.

                   

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 5

General Financial Performance Ratios

As of or For the Last Twelve Months Ended December 31, 2022

                      

           Total   Tang.   Net                     
   Total   Total   Equity/   Equity/   Interest   Effcy.   LTM   LTM   Core   Core 
   Assets   Deposits   Assets   Assets   Margin   Ratio   ROA   ROE   ROA   ROE 
   ($000s)   ($000s)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%) 
Peru Federal Savings Bank   174,134    152,707    11.57    11.57    2.42    74.09    0.46    3.99    0.56    4.84 
Peru Federal Savings Bank (1)   179,066    157,473    11.39    11.39    2.55    75.15    0.47    4.13    0.57    5.04 
                                                   
Comparative Group Average   467,058    360,355    16.50    16.47    3.18    79.94    0.52    4.15    0.52    4.16 
Comparative Group Median   420,288    306,878    12.88    12.84    3.04    76.18    0.52    4.11    0.47    3.81 
                                                   
All Public Thrift Average   5,129,973    3,703,569    13.39    12.77    3.39    70.59    0.65    5.51    0.76    6.35 
All Public Thrift Median   1,636,381    1,252,412    11.71    10.99    3.14    66.30    0.71    6.26    0.77    6.92 
                                                   
Comparative Group                                                  
1895 Bancorp of Wisconsin, Inc.   543,016    387,721    13.88    13.88    2.88    96.35    (0.03)   (0.19)   0.08    0.52 
Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.   263,324    165,094    33.60    33.60    2.72    99.32    0.06    0.19    0.11    0.33 
Cullman Bancorp, Inc.   423,229    292,949    23.67    23.67    4.19    66.10    1.09    4.21    1.09    4.23 
Generations Bancorp NY, Inc.   386,293    317,678    9.66    9.31    3.42    84.81    0.29    2.69    0.32    2.94 
Home Federal Bancorp, Inc.   576,543    518,211    8.44    8.44    3.65    65.90    0.99    11.45    0.99    11.45 
IF Bancorp, Inc.   823,727    667,337    8.63    8.63    2.98    69.35    0.69    7.51    0.74    8.00 
Magyar Bancorp, Inc.   821,626    676,083    12.16    12.16    3.62    60.21    1.01    8.11    1.01    8.11 
Mid-Southern Bancorp, Inc.   269,218    206,064    12.38    12.38    3.10    72.70    0.71    5.07    0.70    4.99 
NSTS Bancorp, Inc.   264,206    178,714    30.48    30.48    2.15    108.86    0.01    0.03    (0.13)   (0.45)
PB Bankshares, Inc.   386,547    289,495    11.90    11.90    2.97    72.98    0.56    4.65    0.41    3.39 
TC Bancshares, Inc.   429,618    328,840    19.85    19.85    3.65    83.26    0.43    2.05    0.43    2.05 
Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.   417,346    296,077    13.39    13.30    2.88    79.37    0.47    4.01    0.50    4.30 

 

(1) As of or for the last twelve months ended March 31, 2023.

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank; S&P Global.

                     

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 6

Income and Expense Analysis

For the Last Twelve Months Ended December 31, 2022

                       

   As a Percent of Average Assets 
           Net   Other   Gains &   Loan   Gen. &   Intang.       Pre-tax 
   Interest   Interest   Interest   Oper.   Non-rec.   Loss   Admin.   Amort.   Non-rec.   Core 
   Income   Expense   Income   Income   Income   Prov.   Expense   Expense   Expense   Earnings 
Peru Federal Savings Bank   2.66    0.36    2.30    0.40    (0.12)   0.03    2.00    0.00    0.00    0.67 
Peru Federal Savings Bank (1)   2.88    0.47    2.41    0.41    (0.12)   0.02    2.12    0.00    0.00    0.68 
                                                   
Comparative Group Average   3.43    0.43    3.01    0.43    0.01    0.07    2.70    0.00    0.01    0.67 
Comparative Group Median   3.48    0.40    2.97    0.45    (0.00)   0.06    2.57    0.00    0.00    0.61 
                                                   
All Public Thrift Average   3.69    0.49    3.20    0.53    0.01    0.16    2.75    0.02    0.06    1.21 
All Public Thrift Median   3.46    0.41    3.04    0.41    0.00    0.06    2.56    0.00    0.00    1.02 
                                                   
Comparative Group                                                  
1895 Bancorp of Wisconsin, Inc.   3.06    0.37    2.69    0.46    (0.13)   0.04    3.03    0.00    0.00    0.07 
Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.   2.83    0.24    2.59    0.43    (0.02)   (0.13)   3.01    0.00    0.08    0.15 
Cullman Bancorp, Inc.   4.30    0.36    3.95    0.43    (0.01)   0.11    2.89    0.00    0.00    1.38 
Generations Bancorp NY, Inc.   3.55    0.52    3.04    0.58    (0.02)   0.17    3.07    0.02    0.00    0.38 
Home Federal Bancorp, Inc.   3.74    0.36    3.38    0.44    0.00    0.15    2.53    0.00    0.00    1.15 
IF Bancorp, Inc.   3.40    0.51    2.89    0.63    (0.06)   0.10    2.44    0.00    0.00    0.98 
Magyar Bancorp, Inc.   3.88    0.44    3.44    0.32    0.00    0.07    2.27    0.00    0.00    1.43 
Mid-Southern Bancorp, Inc.   3.34    0.42    3.09    0.46    0.01    0.05    2.59    0.00    0.00    0.90 
NSTS Bancorp, Inc.   2.27    0.27    1.99    0.26    0.18    (0.08)   2.45    0.00    0.00    (0.12)
PB Bankshares, Inc.   3.69    0.79    2.90    0.19    0.19    0.32    2.25    0.00    0.00    0.51 
TC Bancshares, Inc.   3.79    0.33    3.46    0.47    0.00    0.03    3.30    0.00    0.00    0.60 
Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.   3.33    0.61    2.73    0.49    (0.01)   0.06    2.55    0.04    0.00    0.62 

 

(1) For the last twelve months ended March 31, 2023.

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank; S&P Global.

                                           

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 7

Balance Sheet Composition

As of December 31, 2022

                     

   As a Percent of Total Assets 
   Cash and   Net   Real   Intang.   Other   Total   Borrowed   Other   Total   Total 
   Securities   Loans   Estate   Assets   Assets   Deposits   Funds   Liabs.   Liabs.   Equity 
Peru Federal Savings Bank   45.69    48.76    0.00    0.00    5.55    87.70    0.00    0.74    88.43    11.57 
Peru Federal Savings Bank (1)   47.72    46.77    0.00    0.00    5.51    87.94    0.00    0.67    88.61    11.39 
                                                   
Comparative Group Average   27.05    67.02    0.03    0.04    5.85    75.44    7.09    0.96    83.50    16.50 
Comparative Group Median   24.54    70.62    0.00    0.00    5.24    75.72    6.40    1.09    87.12    12.88 
                                                   
All Public Thrift Average   21.19    72.93    0.07    0.73    5.00    75.30    9.84    1.21    86.61    13.39 
All Public Thrift Median   18.23    76.55    0.00    0.05    5.02    76.60    8.01    1.14    88.29    11.71 
                                                   
Comparative Group                                                  
1895 Bancorp of Wisconsin, Inc.   27.47    66.24    0.00    0.00    6.28    71.40    13.16    1.56    86.12    13.88 
Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.   41.15    50.05    0.12    0.00    8.68    62.70    3.49    0.21    66.40    33.60 
Cullman Bancorp, Inc.   16.29    77.96    0.01    0.00    5.74    69.22    5.93    1.18    76.33    23.67 
Generations Bancorp NY, Inc.   11.57    78.67    0.00    0.39    9.37    82.24    6.87    1.23    90.34    9.66 
Home Federal Bancorp, Inc.   22.17    73.10    0.05    0.00    4.69    89.88    1.43    0.24    91.56    8.44 
IF Bancorp, Inc.   26.91    68.14    0.00    0.00    4.96    81.01    9.22    1.14    91.37    8.63 
Magyar Bancorp, Inc.   13.37    81.07    0.04    0.00    5.53    82.29    4.04    1.52    87.84    12.16 
Mid-Southern Bancorp, Inc.   41.91    53.63    0.00    0.00    4.46    76.54    10.77    0.31    87.62    12.38 
NSTS Bancorp, Inc.   52.75    39.12    0.00    0.00    8.13    67.64    0.00    1.87    69.52    30.48 
PB Bankshares, Inc.   18.69    77.83    0.00    0.00    3.47    74.89    12.56    0.65    88.10    11.90 
TC Bancshares, Inc.   16.70    78.26    0.16    0.00    4.88    76.54    2.56    1.05    80.15    19.85 
Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.   35.65    60.22    0.00    0.10    4.04    70.94    15.07    0.60    86.61    13.39 

 

(1) As of March 31, 2023.

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank; S&P Global.

                     

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 8

Growth Rates, Credit Risk, and Loan Composition

As of or For the Last Twelve Months Ended December 31, 2022

                     

                       Loan   Loan   Resid.   Other   Non- 
   Asset   Loan   Deposit   NPLs(1)/   NPAs(1)/   Loss   Loss   Real Est.   Real Est.   Real Est. 
   Growth   Growth   Growth   Total   Total   Allow./   Allow./   Loans(2)/   Loans/   Loans/ 
   Rate   Rate   Rate   Loans   Assets   NPLs(1)   Loans   Loans   Loans   Loans 
Peru Federal Savings Bank   (6.16)   5.04    (2.06)   0.73    0.36    87.16    0.64    71.53    22.73    5.74 
Peru Federal Savings Bank (3)   (5.14)   1.83    (2.16)   2.38    1.12    29.99    0.71    71.85    22.30    5.85 
                                                   
Comparative Group Average   5.01    15.03    2.97    0.69    0.49    174.30    1.05    45.70    35.05    19.25 
Comparative Group Median   5.57    14.12    4.15    0.57    0.39    113.59    1.14    41.40    39.55    18.44 
                                                   
All Public Thrift Average   9.01    16.13    4.83    0.71    0.55    221.03    1.04    35.67    41.32    23.01 
All Public Thrift Median   5.25    13.45    2.04    0.45    0.35    182.04    1.00    31.09    50.46    18.44 
                                                   
Comparative Group                                                  
1895 Bancorp of Wisconsin, Inc.   0.63    10.69    0.84    0.31    0.22    284.96    0.88    23.55    58.12    18.32 
Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.   (7.80)   1.52    (6.62)   1.64    1.00    82.44    1.35    65.50    16.94    17.56 
Cullman Bancorp, Inc.   19.32    30.85    26.26    0.77    0.62    111.24    0.85    51.73    29.95    18.32 
Generations Bancorp NY, Inc.   1.94    9.26    1.80    2.24    1.78    36.34    0.82    45.04    5.72    49.23 
Home Federal Bancorp, Inc.   0.92    13.45    1.18    0.01    0.05     NM     1.12    31.36    41.44    27.20 
IF Bancorp, Inc.   6.62    14.13    3.91    0.06    0.04     NM     1.26    26.19    51.40    22.41 
Magyar Bancorp, Inc.   5.25    15.99    4.39    0.05    0.03     NM     1.30    31.90    57.68    10.42 
Mid-Southern Bancorp, Inc.   5.88    17.80    4.66    0.98    0.53    117.99    1.16    42.51    38.93    18.56 
NSTS Bancorp, Inc.   (22.49)   6.95    (37.43)   0.81    0.32    74.37    0.60    90.83    6.70    2.47 
PB Bankshares, Inc.   22.74    20.73    15.28    0.52    0.41    250.44    1.31    36.55    57.08    6.37 
TC Bancshares, Inc.   12.78    24.92    13.66    0.27    0.45    497.36    1.28    40.29    40.18    19.53 
Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.   14.40    14.11    7.69    0.61    0.37    113.59    0.69    62.97    16.42    20.61 

 

(1) Includes accruing troubled debt restructurings.

(2) Includes home equity and second mortgage loans.

(3) As of or for the last twelve months ended March 31, 2023.

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank; S&P Global.                  

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 9

Comparative Group Market Price and Ratio Change

Market Price Data as of February 21, 2023 and April 10, 2023

                                   

   2/21/23   4/10/23       2/21/23   4/10/23       2/21/23   4/10/23       2/21/23   4/10/23     
   Closing   Closing       Price/   Price/       Price/   Price/       Price/   Price/     
   Stock   Stock       LTM   LTM       Book   Book       Tang.   Tang.     
   Price   Price   Change   EPS   EPS   Change   Value   Value   Change   Book   Book   Change 
Company  ($)   ($)   (%)   (x)   (x)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%) 
Comparative Group Average   NA     NA     (11.1)   18.8    18.4    (2.1)   88.2    78.0    (11.6)   88.5    78.2    (11.6)
Comparative Group Median   NA     NA     (12.8)   19.2    18.5    (3.7)   85.0    76.9    (9.5)   85.0    77.1    (9.2)
                                                             
Comparative Group                                                            
1895 Bancorp of Wisconsin, Inc.   9.90    7.92    (20.0)    NA      NA      NA     81.2    64.6    (20.5)   81.2    64.6    (20.5)
Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.   13.00    11.50    (11.5)    NA      NA      NA     76.8    69.1    (10.1)   76.8    69.1    (10.1)
Cullman Bancorp, Inc.   11.71    10.98    (6.3)   22.1    18.5    (16.2)   88.0    81.0    (8.0)   88.0    81.0    (8.0)
Generations Bancorp NY, Inc.   10.98    9.85    (10.3)   15.4    20.1    30.0    69.1    64.7    (6.3)   72.0    67.5    (6.3)
Home Federal Bancorp, Inc.   17.31    17.06    (1.4)   9.9    9.8    (1.3)   111.0    109.5    (1.3)   111.0    109.5    (1.3)
IF Bancorp, Inc.   18.08    15.26    (15.6)   9.7    8.4    (13.7)   84.9    73.2    (13.7)   84.9    73.2    (13.7)
Magyar Bancorp, Inc.   12.60    10.54    (16.3)   10.5    8.8    (16.4)   85.0    71.1    (16.4)   85.0    71.1    (16.4)
Mid-Southern Bancorp, Inc.   13.08    11.40    (12.8)   19.2    16.9    (11.9)   121.8    99.7    (18.1)   121.8    99.7    (18.1)
NSTS Bancorp, Inc.   10.45    9.10    (12.9)    NA      NA      NA     71.3    58.3    (18.2)   71.3    58.3    (18.2)
PB Bankshares, Inc.   13.40    13.25    (1.1)   24.9    22.1    (11.2)   82.3    82.0    (0.4)   82.3    82.0    (0.4)
TC Bancshares, Inc.   16.32    14.02    (14.1)   30.2    38.9    28.9    93.5    81.8    (12.5)   93.5    81.8    (12.5)
Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.   15.73    13.36    (15.1)   27.0    22.0    (18.8)   93.2    80.6    (13.6)   94.0    81.2    (13.6)
                                                             
Index Values                                                            
S&P 500 Stock Index   3,997.3    4,109.1    2.8                                              
S&P Broad Market Index Banks   156.7    126.1    (19.5)                                             
NASDAQ Bank Index   4,195.6    3,105.1    (26.0)                                             
S&P SmallCap Banks   239.5    184.3    (23.1)                                             
S&P Midwest Banks   664.9    507.4    (23.7)                                             

 

Source:  S&P Global.                        

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 10

Comparative Pro Forma Market Valuation Analysis

Computed from Market Price Data as of April 10, 2023

                         

   Current   Total   Price/   Price/   Price/   Price/   Price/   Total   Tang.   Current 
   Stock   Market   LTM   Core   Book   Tang.   Total   Equity/   Equity/   Dividend 
   Price   Value   EPS   EPS   Value   Book   Assets   Assets   Assets   Yield 
Company  ($)   ($Mil.)   (x)   (x)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%) 
PFS Bancorp, Inc. (1)                                                  
Pro Forma Minimum   10.00    14.0    14.1    11.9    45.4    45.4    7.39    16.28    16.28    0.00 
Pro Forma Midpoint   10.00    16.4    16.1    13.7    49.7    49.7    8.56    17.21    17.21    0.00 
Pro Forma Maximum   10.00    18.8    18.2    15.4    53.6    53.6    9.70    18.11    18.11    0.00 
Pro Forma Adj. Maximum   10.00    21.6    20.0    17.2    57.5    57.5    10.99    19.12    19.12    0.00 
                                                   
Comparative Group Average   NA    50.2    18.1    18.4    78.0    78.2    12.24    16.50    16.47    0.92 
Comparative Group Median   NA    49.0    16.7    18.5    76.9    77.1    10.27    12.88    12.84    0.65 
                                                   
All Public Thrift Average (2)   NA    459.6    13.7    13.0    83.2    91.3    10.74    13.39    12.77    1.96 
All Public Thrift Median (2)   NA    136.4    11.2    9.5    81.0    82.7    9.73    11.71    10.99    1.16 
                                                   
Comparative Group                                                  
1895 Bancorp of Wisconsin, Inc.   7.92    48.5     NA      NA     64.6    64.6    8.96    13.88    13.88    0.00 
Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.   11.50    56.2     NA      NA     69.1    69.1    21.35    33.60    33.60    0.00 
Cullman Bancorp, Inc.   10.98    81.0    18.6    18.5    81.0    81.0    19.18    23.67    23.67    1.12 
Generations Bancorp NY, Inc.   9.85    24.1    21.9    20.1    64.7    67.5    6.25    9.66    9.31    0.00 
Home Federal Bancorp, Inc.   17.06    51.2    9.8    9.8    109.5    109.5    9.25    8.44    8.44    2.81 
IF Bancorp, Inc.   15.26    49.5    8.9    8.4    73.2    73.2    6.32    8.63    8.63    2.56 
Magyar Bancorp, Inc.   10.54    71.0    8.8    8.8    71.1    71.1    8.64    12.16    12.16    1.14 
Mid-Southern Bancorp, Inc.   11.40    31.5    16.7    16.9    99.7    99.7    12.35    12.38    12.38    2.08 
NSTS Bancorp, Inc.   9.10    47.0     NA      NA     58.3    58.3    17.77    30.48    30.48    0.00 
PB Bankshares, Inc.   13.25    34.6    16.2    22.1    82.0    82.0    9.75    11.90    11.90    0.00 
TC Bancshares, Inc.   14.02    64.8    38.9    38.9    81.8    81.8    16.23    19.85    19.85    0.71 
Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.   13.36    42.9    23.6    22.0    80.6    81.2    10.79    13.39    13.30    0.59 

 

(1)Pro forma ratios assume an estimated pro forma market value of $14.0 million at the minimum, $16.4 million at the midpoint, $18.8 million at the maximum, and $21.6 million at the adjusted maximum (inclusive of the shares of common stock issued to the Foundation).
(2)All public thrifts traded on a major exchange, excluding mutual holding companies and companies being acquired in announced merger transactions.

 

Source:  Peru Federal Savings Bank; S&P Global.                  

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 11

 

Pro Forma Assumptions for the Conversion Stock Offering

 

1.The total amount of the net offering proceeds was fully invested at the beginning of the applicable period.

 

2.The net offering proceeds are invested to yield a return of 3.99%, which represented the yield on five-year U.S. Treasury securities at December 31, 2022. The effective income tax rate was assumed to be 28.5%, resulting in a net after-tax yield of 2.85%.

 

3.It is assumed that a contribution of $100,000 in cash and 40,000 shares of common stock (aggregate value of $400,000) will be issued to the charitable foundation in connection with the Conversion and stock offering.

 

4.It is assumed that 8.0% of the total shares of common stock to be issued in the Conversion (including shares issued to the charitable foundation) will be acquired by the Bank’s employee stock ownership plan (“ESOP”). Pro forma adjustments have been made to earnings and equity to reflect the impact of the ESOP. The annual expense is estimated based on a 25-year loan to the ESOP from the Bank. No re-investment is assumed on proceeds used to fund the ESOP.

 

5.It is assumed that that the Bank’s restricted stock plan (“RSP”) will purchase in the open market a number of shares equal to 4.0% of the total shares issued in the Conversion (including shares issued to the charitable foundation). Also, it is assumed that these shares are acquired at the initial public offering price of $10.00 per share. Pro forma adjustments have been made to earnings and equity to reflect the impact of the RSP. The annual expense is estimated based on a five-year vesting period. No re-investment is assumed on proceeds used to fund the RSP.

 

6.It is assumed that an additional 10.0% of the total shares sold in the stock offering will be reserved for issuance by the Bank’s stock option plan. The pro forma net income has been adjusted to reflect the expense associated with the granting of options at an assumed options value of $4.07 per option. It is further assumed that options for all shares reserved under the plan were granted to plan participants at the beginning of the period and 25.0% were non-qualified options for income tax purposes, the options would vest at a rate of 20.0% per year, and compensation expense will be recognized on a straight-line basis over the five-year vesting period

 

7.The fair value of stock options has been estimated at $4.07 per option using the Black-Scholes option pricing model with the following assumptions: a grant-date share price and option exercise price of $10.00; dividend yield of 0.00%; an expected option life of 10 years; a risk-free interest rate of 3.88%; and a volatility rate of 20.27% based a selected bank stock index.

 

8.Total offering expenses are estimated at $1,500,000.

 

9.No effect has been given to withdrawals from deposit accounts for the purpose of purchasing common stock in the stock offering.

 

10.No effect has been given in the pro forma equity calculation for the assumed earnings on the net proceeds.

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 12

Peru Federal Savings Bank

Pro Forma Conversion Valuation Range

Historical Financial Data as of March 31, 2023

(Dollars in Thousands, Except Per Share Data)

 

   MINIMUM   MIDPOINT   MAXIMUM   ADJ. MAX. 
Total shares outstanding   1,400,000    1,640,000    1,880,000    2,156,000 
Shares sold in the offering   1,360,000    1,600,000    1,840,000    2,116,000 
Shares issued to charitable foundation   40,000    40,000    40,000    40,000 
Offering price  $10.00   $10.00   $10.00   $10.00 
Pro forma market value  $14,000   $16,400   $18,800   $21,560 
                     
Gross offering proceeds  $13,600   $16,000   $18,400   $21,160 
Less:estimated offering expenses   (1,500)   (1,500)   (1,500)   (1,500)
Net offering proceeds   12,100    14,500    16,900    19,660 
Less:cash contribution to foundation   (100)   (100)   (100)   (100)
Less:ESOP purchase   (1,120)   (1,312)   (1,504)   (1,725)
Less:RSP purchase   (560)   (656)   (752)   (862)
Net investable proceeds  $10,320   $12,432   $14,544   $16,973 
                     
Net income - LTM ended 3/31/23  $838   $838   $838   $838 
Pro forma income on net proceeds   294    355    415    484 
Pro forma ESOP adjustment   (32)   (38)   (43)   (49)
Pro forma RSP adjustment   (80)   (94)   (108)   (123)
Pro forma option adjustment   (106)   (124)   (142)   (163)
Pro forma net income  $914   $937   $960   $987 
Pro forma earnings per share  $0.71   $0.62   $0.55   $0.50 
Core earnings - LTM ended 3/31/23  $1,013   $1,013   $1,013   $1,013 
Pro forma income on net proceeds   294    355    415    484 
Pro forma ESOP adjustment   (32)   (38)   (43)   (49)
Pro forma RSP adjustment   (80)   (94)   (108)   (123)
Pro forma option adjustment   (106)   (124)   (142)   (163)
Pro forma core earnings  $1,089   $1,112   $1,135   $1,162 
Pro forma core earnings per share  $0.84   $0.73   $0.65   $0.58 
Total equity - 3/31/23  $20,402   $20,402   $20,402   $20,402 
Net offering proceeds   12,100    14,500    16,900    19,660 
Plus:common stock issued to foundation   400    400    400    400 
Less:charitable contribution expense   (358)   (358)   (358)   (358)
Less:ESOP purchase   (1,120)   (1,312)   (1,504)   (1,725)
Less:RSP purchase   (560)   (656)   (752)   (862)
Pro forma total equity  $30,864   $32,976   $35,088   $37,517 
Pro forma book value  $22.05   $20.11   $18.66   $17.40 
Tangible equity - 3/31/23  $20,402   $20,402   $20,402   $20,402 
Net offering proceeds   12,100    14,500    16,900    19,660 
Plus:common stock issued to foundation   400    400    400    400 
Less:charitable contribution expense   (358)   (358)   (358)   (358)
Less:ESOP purchase   (1,120)   (1,312)   (1,504)   (1,725)
Less:RSP purchase   (560)   (656)   (752)   (862)
Pro forma tangible equity  $30,864   $32,976   $35,088   $37,517 
Pro forma tangible book value  $22.05   $20.11   $18.66   $17.40 
Total assets - 3/31/23  $179,066   $179,066   $179,066   $179,066 
Net offering proceeds   12,100    14,500    16,900    19,660 
Plus:common stock issued to foundation   400    400    400    400 
Less:charitable contribution expense, net   (358)   (358)   (358)   (358)
Less:ESOP purchase   (1,120)   (1,312)   (1,504)   (1,725)
Less:RSP purchase   (560)   (656)   (752)   (862)
Pro forma total assets  $189,528   $191,640   $193,752   $196,181 
Pro Forma Ratios:                    
Price / LTM EPS   14.1x   16.1x   18.2x   20.0x
Price / Core EPS   11.9x   13.7x   15.4x   17.2x
Price / Book Value   45.35%   49.73%   53.59%   57.47%
Price / Tangible Book Value   45.35%   49.73%   53.59%   57.47%
Price / Total Assets   7.39%   8.56%   9.70%   10.99%
Total Equity / Assets   16.28%   17.21%   18.11%   19.12%
Tangible Equity / Assets   16.28%   17.21%   18.11%   19.12%

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 13

Pro Forma Conversion Analysis at the Midpoint Value

Peru Federal Savings Bank

Historical Financial Data as of March 31, 2023

 

Valuation Parameters  Symbol  Data 
Net income -- LTM  Y  $838,000 
Core earnings -- LTM  Y   1,013,000 
Net worth  B   20,402,000 
Tangible net worth  B   20,402,000 
Total assets  A   179,066,000 
Expenses in conversion  X   1,500,000 
Other proceeds not reinvested  O   2,468,000 
ESOP purchase  E   1,312,000 
ESOP expense (pre-tax)  F   53,147 
RSP purchase  M   656,000 
RSP expense (pre-tax)  N   131,469 
Stock option expense (pre-tax)  Q   133,496 
Cash contribution to foundation  C   100,000 
Stock contribution to foundation  K   400,000 
Option expense tax-deductible  D   25.00%
Re-investment rate (after-tax)  R   2.85%
Tax rate  T   28.50%
Shares for EPS  S   92.32%
         
Pro Forma Valuation Ratios at Midpoint Value        
Price / LTM EPS  P/E   16.13x
Price / Core EPS  P/E   13.70x
Price / Book Value  P/B   49.7%
Price / Tangible Book  P/TB   49.7%
Price / Assets  P/A   8.56%

 

Pro Forma Calculation at Midpoint Value     Based on
         
V    =   (P/E / S)*((Y-R*(O+X)-(F+N)*(1-T)-(Q-Q*D*T))) = $16,400,000 [LTM earnings]
  1 - (P/E / S) * R      
         
V    =   (P/E / S)*((Y-R*(O+X)-(F+N)*(1-T)-(Q-Q*D*T)) = $16,400,000 [Core earnings]
  1 - (P/E / S) * R      
         
V    =   P/B * (B - X - E - M - (C+K)*(1-T))) = $16,400,000 [Book value]
  1 - P/B      
         
V    =   P/TB * (B - X - E - M - (C+K)*(1-T))) = $16,400,000 [Tangible book]
  1 - P/TB      
         
V    =   P/A * (A - X - E - M - (C+K)*(1-T)) = $16,400,000 [Total assets]
  1 - P/A      

 

Pro Forma           Valuation   Offering   Foundation 
Valuation Range             Range   Range   Shares 
Minimum=  $16,400,000   x  0.8533  =  $14,000,000   $13,600,000   $400,000 
Midpoint=  $16,400,000   x  1.0000  =  $16,400,000   $16,000,000   $400,000 
Maximum=  $16,400,000   x  1.1467  =  $18,800,000   $18,400,000   $400,000 
Adj. Max. =  $18,800,000   x  1.1493  =  $21,560,000   $21,160,000   $400,000 

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 14

Comparative Valuation Ratio Analysis

Pro Forma Conversion Valuation

Computed from Market Price Data as of April 10, 2023

 

      Peru                
      Federal  Comparative   All Public 
Valuation     Savings  Group   Thrifts (1) 
Ratio  Symbol  Bank  Average   Median   Average   Median 
Price / LTM EPS  P/E      18.1    16.7    13.7    11.2 
Minimum  (x)  14.1   -22.1%   -15.6%   3.1%   26.0%
Midpoint     16.1   -11.0%   -3.6%   17.7%   43.9%
Maximum     18.2   0.6%   9.0%   33.0%   62.6%
Adjusted Maximum     20.0   10.5%   19.8%   46.2%   78.7%
                           
Price / Core EPS  P/E      18.4    18.5    13.0    9.5 
Minimum  (x)  11.9   -35.3%   -35.7%   -8.5%   25.1%
Midpoint     13.7   -25.5%   -25.9%   5.3%   44.0%
Maximum     15.4   -16.3%   -16.8%   18.4%   61.8%
Adjusted Maximum     17.2   -6.5%   -7.0%   32.2%   80.8%
                           
Price / Book Value  P/B      78.0    76.9    83.2    81.0 
Minimum  (%)  45.4   -41.8%   -41.0%   -45.5%   -44.0%
Midpoint     49.7   -36.3%   -35.4%   -40.3%   -38.6%
Maximum     53.6   -31.3%   -30.3%   -35.6%   -33.8%
Adjusted Maximum     57.5   -26.3%   -25.2%   -30.9%   -29.0%
                           
Price / Tangible Book  P/TB      78.2    77.1    91.3    82.7 
Minimum  (%)  45.4   -41.9%   -41.1%   -50.3%   -45.1%
Midpoint     49.7   -36.4%   -35.5%   -45.6%   -39.9%
Maximum     53.6   -31.5%   -30.5%   -41.3%   -35.2%
Adjusted Maximum     57.5   -26.5%   -25.4%   -37.0%   -30.5%
                           
Price / Total Assets  P/A      12.24    10.27    10.74    9.73 
Minimum  (%)  7.39   -39.6%   -28.0%   -31.2%   -24.1%
Midpoint     8.56   -30.1%   -16.7%   -20.3%   -12.1%
Maximum     9.70   -20.8%   -5.6%   -9.7%   -0.3%
Adjusted Maximum     10.99   -10.2%   7.0%   2.3%   12.9%

 

(1) Excludes companies subject to mutual holding company ownership or pending acquisition.    

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

  

Exhibit 15

Financial and Market Data for All Public Thrifts

                               

             Total   Tang.           Closing   Total   Price/   Price/   Price/   Price/   Price/     
         Total   Equity/   Equity/   LTM   LTM   Price   Market   LTM   Core   Book   Tang.   Total   Div. 
         Assets   Assets   Assets   ROA   ROE   4/10/23   Value   EPS   EPS   Value   Book   Assets   Yield 
Company  State  Ticker  ($Mil.)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   ($)   ($Mil.)   (x)   (x)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%) 
All Public Thrifts (1)                                                                       
1895 Bancorp of Wisconsin, Inc.  WI  BCOW   543    13.88    13.88    (0.03)   (0.19)   7.92    48.5     NM      NM     64.6    64.6    8.96    0.00 
Affinity Bancshares, Inc.  GA  AFBI   791    14.80    12.75    0.93    6.05    14.55    96.2    13.8    12.6    82.3    97.8    12.18    0.00 
Axos Financial, Inc.  NV  AX   18,741    9.54    8.77    1.52    15.69    37.22    2,225.4    8.6    7.5    124.5    136.5    11.87    0.00 
Blue Foundry Bancorp  NJ  BLFY   2,043    19.27    19.24    0.12    0.58    9.59    243.8     NM      NM     67.0    67.2    12.92    0.00 
Broadway Financial Corporation  CA  BYFC   1,184     NA      NA     0.50    2.55    1.04    50.1    13.0     NA     59.1    75.7     NA     0.00 
Capitol Federal Financial, Inc.  KS  CFFN   9,930    10.62    10.52    0.67    6.83    6.74    895.6    11.6    11.5    86.9    87.8    9.23    5.05 
Carver Bancorp, Inc.  NY  CARV   712    6.34    6.34    (0.39)   (5.38)   4.02    17.0     NM      NM     87.4    87.4    2.51    0.00 
Catalyst Bancorp, Inc.  LA  CLST   263    33.60    33.60    0.06    0.19    11.50    56.2     NA      NA     69.1    69.1    23.20    0.00 
Cullman Bancorp, Inc.  AL  CULL   423    23.67    23.67    1.09    4.21    10.98    81.0    18.6    18.5    81.0    81.0    19.18    1.12 
ECB Bancorp, Inc.  MA  ECBK   1,064    15.29    15.29    0.35    2.37    13.02    120.6    41.1    24.4    74.1    74.1    11.33    0.00 
ESSA Bancorp, Inc.  PA  ESSA   1,927    11.22    10.57    1.09    9.48    15.91    153.5    7.6    7.5    76.1    81.4    8.53    3.80 
First Northwest Bancorp  WA  FNWB   2,042    7.75    7.70    0.68    7.84    12.06    108.0    7.1    6.7    73.1    73.6    5.77    2.30 
First Seacoast Bancorp, Inc.  NH  FSEA   537    9.18    9.13    (0.11)   (1.05)   8.62    44.3     NM      NM     89.6    90.1    8.22    0.00 
FS Bancorp, Inc.  WA  FSBW   2,633    8.80    8.60    1.22    11.66    28.57    221.0    7.8    7.6    96.8    99.3    8.52    3.45 
Generations Bancorp NY, Inc.  NY  GBNY   386    9.66    9.31    0.29    2.69    9.85    24.1    21.9    20.1    64.7    67.5    6.25    0.00 
HarborOne Bancorp, Inc.  MA  HONE   5,360    11.51    10.31    0.95    7.14    12.21    554.0    12.7    12.3    97.5    110.4    11.23    2.44 
Hingham Institution for Savings  MA  HIFS   4,194    9.20    9.20    0.98    10.01    219.18    466.0    12.7    8.7    120.7    120.7    11.11    1.16 
HMN Financial, Inc.  MN  HMNF   1,096    8.88    8.81    0.75    7.03    18.65    81.1    10.2    10.2    85.8    86.5    7.62    1.29 
Home Federal Bancorp, Inc.  LA  HFBL   577    8.44    8.44    0.99    11.45    17.06    51.2    9.8    9.8    109.5    109.5    9.25    2.81 
IF Bancorp, Inc.  IL  IROQ   824    8.63    8.63    0.69    7.51    15.26    49.5    8.9    8.4    73.2    73.2    6.32    2.56 
Kearny Financial Corp.  NJ  KRNY   8,289    10.53    8.16    0.62    5.19    8.14    525.2    11.6    9.3    62.5    82.7    6.58    5.44 
Magyar Bancorp, Inc.  NJ  MGYR   822    12.16    12.16    1.01    8.11    10.54    71.0    8.8    8.8    71.1    71.1    8.64    1.14 
Mid-Southern Bancorp, Inc.  IN  MSVB   269    12.38    12.38    0.71    5.07    11.40    31.5    16.7    16.9    99.7    99.7    12.35    2.08 
New York Community Bancorp, Inc.  NY  NYCB   90,144    9.79    6.99    1.01    9.18    8.79    6,016.4    7.0    7.8    72.1    107.0    6.70    7.72 
Northeast Community Bancorp, Inc.  NY  NECB   1,425    18.39    18.37    1.95    9.60    13.37    196.1    8.4    7.9    81.4    81.5    14.97    1.81 
Northfield Bancorp, Inc.  NJ  NFBK   5,601    12.52    11.87    1.09    8.57    11.42    537.3    8.7    8.7    77.6    82.4    9.71    4.53 
NSTS Bancorp, Inc.  IL  NSTS   264    30.48    30.48    0.01    0.03    9.10    47.0     NM      NM     58.3    58.3    17.77    0.00 
PB Bankshares, Inc.  PA  PBBK   387    11.90    11.90    0.56    4.65    13.25    34.6    16.2    22.1    82.0    82.0    9.75    0.00 
Ponce Financial Group, Inc.  NY  PDLB   2,312    21.31    21.31    (1.55)   (7.47)   7.67    177.7     NM      NA     70.9    70.9    9.09    0.00 
Provident Bancorp, Inc.  MA  PVBC   1,636    12.68    12.68    (1.24)   (9.26)   6.61    116.6     NM      NM     57.2    57.2    7.26    0.00 
Provident Financial Holdings, Inc.  CA  PROV   1,271    10.17    10.17    0.71    6.69    13.50    95.7    11.3    11.3    74.4    74.4    7.57    4.15 

 

Feldman Financial Advisors, Inc.

 

Exhibit 15 (continued)

Financial and Market Data for All Public Thrifts

                               

             Total   Tang.           Closing   Total   Price/   Price/   Price/   Price/   Price/     
         Total   Equity/   Equity/   LTM   LTM   Price   Market   LTM   Core   Book   Tang.   Total   Div. 
         Assets   Assets   Assets   ROA   ROE   4/10/23   Value   EPS   EPS   Value   Book   Assets   Yield 
Company  State  Ticker  ($Mil.)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%)   ($)   ($Mil.)   (x)   (x)   (%)   (%)   (%)   (%) 
Provident Financial Services, Inc.  NJ  PFS   13,783    11.59    8.54    1.29    10.86    18.58    1,373.5    7.8    7.6    86.5    121.5    10.02    5.22 
Riverview Bancorp, Inc.  WA  RVSB   1,599    9.51    7.93    1.13    12.29    5.24    115.0    6.1    6.1    75.6    92.3    7.19    4.49 
Sterling Bancorp, Inc.  MI  SBT   2,445    12.79    12.79    (0.54)   (4.19)   5.50    280.5     NM      NM     90.3    90.3    11.55    0.00 
TC Bancshares, Inc.  GA  TCBC   430    19.85    19.85    0.43    2.05    14.02    64.8    38.9    38.9    81.8    81.8    16.23    0.71 
Territorial Bancorp Inc.  HI  TBNK   2,170    11.82    11.82    0.75    6.26    19.56    174.5    11.0    11.6    70.3    70.3    8.31    4.63 
Texas Community Bancshares, Inc.  TX  TCBS   417    13.39    13.30    0.47    4.01    13.36    42.9    23.6    22.0    80.6    81.2    10.79    0.59 
Third Coast Bancshares, Inc.  TX  TCBX   3,773    10.12    9.66    0.58    5.76    14.66    199.1    11.7     NA     62.9    66.9    5.35    0.00 
Timberland Bancorp, Inc.  WA  TSBK   1,836    12.18    11.41    1.38    11.92    27.00    220.8    8.7    8.7    98.9    106.5    12.04    3.43 
Triumph Financial, Inc.  TX  TFIN   5,334    16.67    12.30    1.79    11.46    56.59    1,286.2    14.1    16.4    158.8    231.8    25.34    0.00 
TrustCo Bank Corp NY  NY  TRST   6,000    10.00    9.99    1.22    12.60    31.12    588.0    7.9    7.9    98.0    98.1    9.80    4.66 
Waterstone Financial, Inc.  WI  WSBF   2,032    18.24    18.21    0.96    4.91    14.81    323.2    16.6    16.8    88.2    88.4    16.09    5.43 
Western New England Bancorp, Inc.  MA  WNEB   2,553    8.94    8.41    1.02    11.85    7.96    174.1    6.8    7.3    78.5    83.9    7.01    3.47 
William Penn Bancorporation  PA  WMPN   871    20.58    20.08    0.46    2.05    10.78    136.4    34.8    32.2    82.3    84.9    16.94    1.15 
WSFS Financial Corporation  DE  WSFS   19,915    11.06    6.32    1.09    9.29    37.33    2,267.6    10.6    8.3    103.2    189.8    11.43    1.62 
                                                                        
Average         5,130    13.39    12.77    0.65    5.51     NA    459.6    13.7    13.0    83.2    91.3    10.74    1.96 
Median         1,636    11.71    10.99    0.71    6.26     NA    136.4    11.2    9.5    81.0    82.7    9.73    1.16 

 

(1) Public thrifts traded on NYSE, NYSE American, and NASDAQ stock markets; excludes companies subject to pending acquisitions or mutual holding company ownership.                                                                                                                

 

Source:  S&P Global.