0001104659-14-029975.txt : 20140424 0001104659-14-029975.hdr.sgml : 20140424 20140424171904 ACCESSION NUMBER: 0001104659-14-029975 CONFORMED SUBMISSION TYPE: SC 13D PUBLIC DOCUMENT COUNT: 3 FILED AS OF DATE: 20140424 DATE AS OF CHANGE: 20140424 GROUP MEMBERS: DAVID H. BATCHELDER GROUP MEMBERS: RALPH V. WHITWORTH GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL COAST PARTNERS, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL FUND PARTNERS, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL INVESTORS IX, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL INVESTORS MID-CAP FUND I, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL INVESTORS MID-CAP FUND II, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL INVESTORS XV, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL INVESTORS XVI, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL INVESTORS XX, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL INVESTORS XXIII, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RELATIONAL INVESTORS XXIV, L.P. GROUP MEMBERS: RH FUND 1, L.P. SUBJECT COMPANY: COMPANY DATA: COMPANY CONFORMED NAME: CLEAN HARBORS INC CENTRAL INDEX KEY: 0000822818 STANDARD INDUSTRIAL CLASSIFICATION: HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT [4955] IRS NUMBER: 042997780 STATE OF INCORPORATION: MA FISCAL YEAR END: 1231 FILING VALUES: FORM TYPE: SC 13D SEC ACT: 1934 Act SEC FILE NUMBER: 005-39179 FILM NUMBER: 14782483 BUSINESS ADDRESS: STREET 1: 42 LONGWATER DRIVE STREET 2: P.O. BOX 9149 CITY: NORWELL STATE: MA ZIP: 02061-9149 BUSINESS PHONE: 781-792-5000 MAIL ADDRESS: STREET 1: 42 LONGWATER DRIVE CITY: NORWELL STATE: MA ZIP: 02061-9149 FILED BY: COMPANY DATA: COMPANY CONFORMED NAME: RELATIONAL INVESTORS LLC CENTRAL INDEX KEY: 0001047644 IRS NUMBER: 330694767 STATE OF INCORPORATION: DE FISCAL YEAR END: 1231 FILING VALUES: FORM TYPE: SC 13D BUSINESS ADDRESS: STREET 1: 12400 HIGH BLUFF DRIVE STREET 2: SUITE 600 CITY: SAN DIEGO STATE: CA ZIP: 92130 BUSINESS PHONE: 858.704.3333 MAIL ADDRESS: STREET 1: 12400 HIGH BLUFF DRIVE STREET 2: SUITE 600 CITY: SAN DIEGO STATE: CA ZIP: 92130 SC 13D 1 a14-10902_1sc13d.htm SC 13D

 

 

UNITED STATES

 

 

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE
COMMISSION

 

 

Washington, D.C. 20549

 

 

 

 

 

SCHEDULE 13D

 


Under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
(Amendment No.    )*

Clean Harbors, Inc.

(Name of Issuer)

 

Common Stock, $0.01 par value

(Title of Class of Securities)

 

436440101

(CUSIP Number)

 

Ralph V. Whitworth
Relational Investors, LLC
12400 High Bluff Drive, Suite 600
San Diego, CA 92130
(858) 704-3333

(Name, Address and Telephone Number of Person
Authorized to Receive Notices and Communications)

 

April 14, 2014

(Date of Event which Requires Filing of this Statement)

If the filing person has previously filed a statement on Schedule 13G to report the acquisition that is the subject of this Schedule 13D, and is filing this schedule because of §§240.13d-1(e), 240.13d-1(f) or 240.13d-1(g), check the following box. o

Note: Schedules filed in paper format shall include a signed original and five copies of the schedule, including all exhibits. See §240.13d-7 for other parties to whom copies are to be sent.

* The remainder of this cover page shall be filled out for a reporting person’s initial filing on this form with respect to the subject class of securities, and for any subsequent amendment containing information which would alter disclosures provided in a prior cover page.

The information required on the remainder of this cover page shall not be deemed to be “filed” for the purpose of Section 18 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (“Act”) or otherwise subject to the liabilities of that section of the Act but shall be subject to all other provisions of the Act (however, see the Notes).

 


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Investors, LLC

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

x

 

 

(b)

o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
OO

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
5,516,622

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
5,516,622

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
5,516,622

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
9.08%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
IA/HC/OO

 

2


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

x

 

 

(b)

o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
1,081,541

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
1,081,541

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
1,081,541

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
1.78%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

3


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
1,478,149

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
1,478,149

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
1,478,149

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
2.43%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

4


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

x

 

 

(b)

o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC/OO

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
17,087

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
17,087

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
17,087

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
0.03%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

5


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

x

 

 

(b)

o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC/OO

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
168,260

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
168,260

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
168,260

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
0.28%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

6


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
218,165

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
218,165

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
218,165

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
0.36%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

7


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
178,914

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
178,914

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
178,914

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
0.29%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

8


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
91,777

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
91,777

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
91,777

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
0.15%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

9


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC/OO

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
160,865

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
160,865

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
160,865

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
0.26%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

10


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC/OO

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
225,349

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
225,349

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
225,349

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
0.37%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

11


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
27,505

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
27,505

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
27,505

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
0.05%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

12


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
WC/OO

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
Delaware

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
149,702

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
-0-

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
149,702

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
-0-

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
149,702

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
0.25%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
PN

 

13


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
Ralph V. Whitworth

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
NA

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
United States

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
-0-

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
5,516,622

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
-0-

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
5,516,622

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
5,516,622

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
9.08%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
IN

 

14


 

 

1.

Names of Reporting Persons.
I.R.S. Identification Nos. of above persons (entities only)
David H. Batchelder

 

 

2.

Check the Appropriate Box if a Member of a Group (See Instructions)

 

 

(a)

 x

 

 

(b)

 o

 

 

3.

SEC Use Only

 

 

4.

Source of Funds (See Instructions)
NA

 

 

5.

Check if Disclosure of Legal Proceedings Is Required Pursuant to Items 2(d) or 2(e)     o

 

 

6.

Citizenship or Place of Organization
United States

 

Number of
Shares
Beneficially
Owned by
Each
Reporting
Person With

7.

Sole Voting Power
-0-

 

8.

Shared Voting Power
5,516,622

 

9.

Sole Dispositive Power
-0-

 

10.

Shared Dispositive Power
5,516,622

 

 

11.

Aggregate Amount Beneficially Owned by Each Reporting Person
5,516,622

 

 

12.

Check if the Aggregate Amount in Row (11) Excludes Certain Shares (See Instructions)   o

 

 

13.

Percent of Class Represented by Amount in Row (11)
9.08%

 

 

14.

Type of Reporting Person (See Instructions)
IN

 

15


 

Item 1.   Security and Issuer

 

This Statement on Schedule 13D (this “Statement”) relates to the common stock, $0.01 par value (the “Shares”) of Clean Harbors, Inc. (the “Issuer” or the “Company”). The Issuer’s principal executive offices are located at 42 Longwater Drive, Norwell, MA 02061.

Item 2.   Identity and Background

This Statement is being filed by and on behalf of Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P. (“MC I”), Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P. (“MC II”), Relational Fund Partners, L.P. (“RFP”), Relational Coast Partners, L.P. (“RCP”), Relational Investors IX, L.P. (“RI IX”), Relational Investors XV, L.P. (“RI XV”), Relational Investors XVI, L.P. (“RI XVI”), Relational Investors XX, L.P. (“RI XX”), Relational Investors XXIII, L.P. (“RI XXIII”), Relational Investors XXIV, L.P. (“RI XXIV”) and RH Fund 1, L.P. (“RHF 1”), collectively, the “Relational LPs.”  Each of the Relational LPs is a Delaware limited partnership.  The principal business of each, is investing in securities.

This Statement is also being filed by Relational Investors, LLC (“RILLC”), a Delaware limited liability company.  The principal business of RILLC is being the sole general partner or sole managing member of the general partner of certain investment partnerships, including the Relational LPs and the investment adviser of certain client managed accounts, the “Managed Accounts”.  The Relational LPs and the Managed Accounts are the beneficial owners of the securities covered by this Statement.  Pursuant to the Limited Partnership Agreement of each of the Relational LPs, and the investment management agreement of the Managed Accounts, RILLC has sole investment discretion and voting authority with respect to the securities covered by this Statement.

This Statement is also being filed by Ralph V. Whitworth and David H. Batchelder.  Messrs. Whitworth and Batchelder are the Principals of RILLC, in which capacity they share voting control and dispositive power over certain securities covered by this Statement.  As such, Messrs. Whitworth and Batchelder may be deemed to have indirect beneficial ownership of such securities, but, each of Mr. Whitworth and Mr. Batchelder disclaim beneficial ownership of the Shares except to the extent of his pecuniary interest therein.  The present principal occupation of each of Messrs. Whitworth and Batchelder is serving as Principals of RILLC (Messrs. Whitworth and Batchelder, together with Relational LPs and RILLC, hereinafter, the “Reporting Persons”).

During the last five years, none of the Reporting Persons has been (i) convicted in a criminal proceeding (excluding traffic violations and similar misdemeanors) or (ii) a party to a civil proceeding of a judicial or administrative body of competent jurisdiction, and as a result of such proceeding, was or is subject to a judgment, decree or final order enjoining future violations of, or prohibiting or mandating activities subject to, federal or state securities laws or finding any violation with respect to such laws.

The business address of each of the Reporting Persons is 12400 High Bluff Drive, Suite 600, San Diego, CA 92130.

Messrs. Whitworth and Batchelder are each citizens of the United States.

Item 3.   Source and Amount of Funds or Other Consideration

RILLC and the Managed Accounts purchased an aggregate of 1,719,308 Shares for a total consideration (including brokerage commissions) of $93.2 million derived from capital of RILLC and the Managed Accounts.

The Relational LPs purchased an aggregate of 3,797,314 Shares for total consideration (including brokerage commissions) of $206.4 million derived from the capital of the Relational LPs and margin borrowings from Credit Suisse Securities (USA) LLC (“CSSU”) for RFP, RCP, RI XX, RI XXIII and RHF 1.

Interest on the margin debt balance of the margin accounts described above is charged at the then Federal Funds Rate plus 50 basis points.  CSSU has a lien on the Shares held by RFP, RCP, RI XX, RI XXIII and RHF 1 to secure repayment of the margin borrowings described above.

 

16


 

Item 4.                                                         Purpose of Transaction

 

The Reporting Persons acquired the Shares covered by this Statement because, in their opinion, such Shares are undervalued, and the current share price does not adequately reflect the potential for significant earnings and cash flow growth.

 

The Reporting Persons believe improvements in a number of areas will further enhance the Company’s equity valuation. Since their initial investment in February 2014, the Reporting Persons have maintained a dialogue with the Company’s management and have presented their views and concerns regarding (i) undervaluation of high return businesses, (ii) portfolio strategic review, (iii) operational improvements, and (iv) capital allocation. The Reporting Persons believe the Company has  and will continue to take actions to improve its performance in these areas.

 

Undervaluation of High Return Businesses

 

The Reporting Persons believe the Company’s dominant position in hazardous waste collection, transportation, and disposal is severely underappreciated. The Company’s legacy Technical Services and Industrial & Field Services businesses, which represent 66% of total company EBITDA, consistently earn a high return on invested capital and benefit from material barriers to entry.  These characteristics warrant a premium valuation relative to the Company’s current trading multiple. The Reporting Persons support the Company’s long-term plan to invest in capacity expansion in these businesses.

 

Portfolio Strategic Review

 

During its fourth quarter earnings call on February 26, 2014, the Company announced a broad strategic review of its operating structure with a focus on driving organic growth and improving its return on invested capital. The Reporting Persons support such actions which may include divestitures or a tax free spin-off of assets that do not earn their cost of capital, do not directly feed waste streams to the Company’s high return disposal assets or lie outside of the Company’s core competency in waste disposal.  The Reporting Persons believe the Company will benefit from a higher Enterprise Value to EBITDA multiple as it refocuses its business mix and improves its return on invested capital.

 

Operational Improvements

 

The Reporting Persons believe that improvements in profit margins and asset utilization will be increasingly important to creating superior equity value. Recent meetings between representatives of the Reporting Persons and the Company’s executive management have increased the Reporting Persons’ confidence that the management team is intently focused on achieving its stated long-term EBITDA margin target of 20%, as announced during the Company’s investor presentation on September 19, 2013. The Reporting Persons are confident that management is focused on SG&A expense reduction, disposal network optimization, asset utilization improvement, profitability improvement of its Oil Re-refining business, and the successful implementation of its recently announced $75 million cost savings initiative.

 

Capital Allocation Discipline

 

The Reporting Persons believe the Company will have substantially completed the investments necessary for its strategic positioning by 2015. Therefore, a larger portion of excess cash flows in future periods will be available for distribution to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. The Reporting Persons believe that the Company’s expected annual future cash flows and potential divestiture proceeds make capital allocation an increasingly important component of equity value creation. The Reporting Persons have been communicating with the Company to help ensure that the Company has capital allocation processes and disciplines in place to ensure that future free cash flows are allocated to the highest and best return alternatives. Based on the Company’s current valuation, the Reporting Persons believe share repurchases represent a low-risk, high-return hurdle against which all alternative uses of capital, particularly acquisitions, must be benchmarked.

 

The Reporting Persons intend to closely monitor the Company’s progress in each of these areas and may modify their plans accordingly.

 

The Reporting Persons may exercise any and all of their respective rights as shareholders of the Company in a manner consistent with their equity interests. The Reporting Persons and their representatives and advisers intend to continue to discuss the Company and its performance with members of the Company’s board and management. In addition, the Reporting Persons may communicate with other shareholders, industry participants, and other interested parties about issues concerning the Company. Although the Reporting Persons do not have any current plans, other than the monitoring and communication program outlined above, the Reporting Persons may in the future decide to seek representation on the Company’s board of directors. Among other factors, the Reporting Persons will consider the Board’s oversight of the execution of operational improvements and capital allocation strategies for maximizing shareholder value as major factors in its decision of whether or not to nominate independent director candidates.

 

The Reporting Persons may from time to time (i) acquire additional Shares (subject to availability at prices deemed favorable) in the open market, in privately negotiated transactions or otherwise, or (ii) dispose of Shares at prices deemed favorable in the open market, in privately negotiated transactions or otherwise. The Reporting Persons may formulate plans or proposals for, and may from time to time explore, or make proposals relating to, transactions or actions which relate to or would result in any of the matters specified in clauses (a) through (j) of Item 4 of Schedule 13D.

17


Item 5.   Interest in Securities of the Issuer

(a)           As of the date of this Statement, the Reporting Persons beneficially owned in the aggregate 5,516,622 Shares, constituting 9.08% of the outstanding Shares.  The percentage of Shares owned is based upon 60,723,422 Shares outstanding on February 26, 2014, as set forth in the Issuer’s Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2013.  The Reporting Persons may be deemed to have direct beneficial ownership of the Shares as follows:

NAME

 

NUMBER OF SHARES

 

% OF OUTSTANDING SHARES

 

VOTING AND DISPOSITIVE POWER

 

RILLC

 

1,719,308

 

2.83

%

Sole

 

MC I

 

1,081,541

 

1.78

%

Sole

 

MC II

 

1,478,149

 

2.43

%

Sole

 

RFP

 

17,087

 

0.03

%

Sole

 

RCP

 

168,260

 

0.28

%

Sole

 

RI IX

 

218,165

 

0.36

%

Sole

 

RI XV

 

178,914

 

0.29

%

Sole

 

RI XVI

 

91,777

 

0.15

%

Sole

 

RI XX

 

160,865

 

0.26

%

Sole

 

RI XXIII

 

225,349

 

0.37

%

Sole

 

RI XXIV

 

27,505

 

0.05

%

Sole

 

RHF 1

 

149,702

 

0.25

%

Sole

 

 

RILLC, individually and in its capacity as an investment adviser, may be deemed to possess direct beneficial ownership of the 1,719,308 Shares that are owned by it and the Managed Accounts.  Additionally, RILLC, as the sole general partner, or sole managing member of the general partner, of each of the Relational LPs may be deemed to beneficially own (as that term is defined in Rule 13d-3 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended) the 3,797,314 Shares beneficially owned by the Relational LPs because the limited partnership agreements of the Relational LPs specify that RILLC has sole investment discretion and voting authority with respect to those Shares.

 

Each of Messrs. Whitworth and Batchelder, as Principals of RILLC, may be deemed to share indirect beneficial ownership of the Shares which RILLC may beneficially own.  Each of Messrs. Whitworth and Batchelder disclaims beneficial ownership of such Shares for all other purposes.

 

To the best of the knowledge of each of the Reporting Persons, other than as set forth above, none of the persons named in Item 2 is the beneficial owner of any Shares.

 

(b)           See item (a) above.

 

(c)           Except as set forth in Exhibit A to this Statement, none of the Reporting Persons has effected any transactions in the Shares during the past sixty days.

 

(d)           No other person is known to have the right to receive or the power to direct the receipt of dividends from, or the proceeds from the sale of, the Shares covered by this Statement, except that dividends from, and proceeds from the sale of, the Shares held by accounts managed by RILLC may be delivered to such accounts.

 

(e)           Not applicable.

 

Item 6.  Contracts, Arrangements, Understandings or Relationships with Respect to Securities of the Issuer

 

Except for the joint filing agreement between and among the Reporting Persons attached hereto as Exhibit B, and except for the investment discretion and voting authority described in Item 2 of this Statement and in the respective partnership agreements and investment management agreements of the Relational LPs and Managed Accounts which each contain provisions whereby RILLC may, after certain adjustments, receive a percentage of realized or unrealized profits, if any, derived from that partnership’s or managed account’s investments, to the best of the knowledge of the Reporting Persons, there are no contracts, arrangements, understandings or relationships (legal or otherwise) among the Reporting Persons or between the Reporting Persons and any other person with respect to any securities of the Issuer, including but not limited to transfer or voting of any of the securities, finder’s fees, joint ventures, loan or option arrangements, puts or calls, guarantees of profits, division of profits or loss, or the giving or withholding of proxies.

 

Item 7.  Material to Be Filed as Exhibits

 

The following Exhibits are filed herewith:

 

Exhibit A – Information concerning transactions in the Shares effected by the Reporting Persons in the last 60 days not previously reported.

 

Exhibit B – Joint Filing Agreement.

 

18


 

Signature

After reasonable inquiry and to the best of my knowledge and belief, I certify that the information set forth in this statement is true, complete and correct.

Dated:  April 24, 2014

RELATIONAL INVESTORS MID-CAP FUND I, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS MID-CAP FUND II, L.P.
RELATIONAL FUND PARTNERS, L.P.
RELATIONAL COAST PARTNERS, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS IX, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XV, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XVI, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XX, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XXIII, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XXIV, L.P.
RH FUND 1, L.P.

By:

RELATIONAL INVESTORS, LLC

 

 

as general partner to each,

 

 

By:

/s/ Ralph V. Whitworth

 

 

 

Ralph V. Whitworth, Principal

 

 

 

RELATIONAL INVESTORS, LLC

 

 

 

 

 

 

By:

/s/ Ralph V. Whitworth

 

 

 

Ralph V. Whitworth, Principal

 

 

 

 

 

 

/s/ Ralph V. Whitworth

 

 

 

Ralph V. Whitworth

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

/s/ David H. Batchelder

 

 

 

David H. Batchelder

 

 

 

 

19

 EX-99.A 2 a14-10902_1ex99da.htm EXHIBIT A

Exhibit A

 

Transactions by Reporting Persons in the last 60 days.

 

Beneficial
Ownership

 

Purchase
or Sale

 

Quantity

 

Transaction
Date

 

 

Price per Share
(including
commission)

 

How
Effected

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,042

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,419

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,307

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

9,996

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

742

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,724

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

75

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

176

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

993

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,613

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

692

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,276

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,924

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,012

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

13,934

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

800

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,858

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

419

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

974

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

715

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,660

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,001

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,325

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

116

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

271

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

665

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,544

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,292

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.70

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

5,319

 

3/6/2014

 

$

50.77

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,780

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,728

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

11,489

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

7,143

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,981

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,232

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

202

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

125

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,649

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,153

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

494

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

11,406

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,092

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

16,011

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,958

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,135

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,328

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,120

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

696

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,908

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,186

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,672

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,661

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

311

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

193

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,775

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,104

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,114

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,801

 

3/7/2014

 

$

52.19

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,222

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

13,334

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,609

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

9,183

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

55,100

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

19,046

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,583

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,503

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,285

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

162

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

972

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

336

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,117

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,895

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,812

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,392

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,117

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

54,704

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

18,909

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

12,798

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

76,759

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

26,535

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,707

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

10,244

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,541

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

895

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,372

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,857

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,525

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,155

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,164

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,136

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

12,816

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,430

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

249

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,496

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

517

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,419

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,515

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,943

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,887

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.66

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

29,323

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

10,136

 

3/10/2014

 

$

52.44

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,408

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,481

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

19

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

14,081

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

18,514

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

81

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,428

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,193

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

14

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

248

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

326

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,247

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,270

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

18

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

13,979

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

18,381

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

80

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

19,617

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

25,791

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

120

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,618

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,442

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

15

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,372

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,805

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,340

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,076

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

13

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,275

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,306

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

18

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

382

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

502

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.88

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,176

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,861

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

12

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

7,493

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

9,852

 

3/11/2014

 

$

52.09

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

43

 

3/11/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

106

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

576

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

576

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,703

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

11,572

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

440

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,373

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,381

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

27,696

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

47,686

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

76

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

409

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

410

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,780

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,225

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

41

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

43

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

491

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

840

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

101

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

547

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

551

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,472

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,917

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,695

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,298

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

437

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,355

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,365

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

27,497

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

47,470

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

615

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,303

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,313

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

38,553

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

66,618

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

81

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

441

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

442

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,152

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,891

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

43

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

231

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

232

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,703

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,646

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

73

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

394

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

395

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,605

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,923

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

105

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

551

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

553

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,442

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

11,092

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

11

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

67

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

64

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

753

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,297

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

68

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

366

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

370

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,282

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,370

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

237

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,262

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.62

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,266

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.42

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

14,739

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

25,377

 

3/12/2014

 

$

51.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

943

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,400

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

5,180

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,888

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

14,009

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

21,345

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

670

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,416

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,682

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

68

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

246

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

376

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

896

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,229

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,920

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,870

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

13,946

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

21,248

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,439

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

19,576

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

29,821

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

724

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,612

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,979

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

378

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,365

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,080

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

646

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,327

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,546

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

904

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,258

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,965

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

105

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

381

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

581

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

600

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,165

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,299

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,069

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.58

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

7,455

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.60

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

11,359

 

3/13/2014

 

$

51.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

13,220

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,976

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,772

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

54,476

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

16,378

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

15,541

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,397

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,825

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,682

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

961

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

289

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

275

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,791

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,767

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,643

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,133

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,584

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

54,226

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

16,305

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

15,471

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

76,074

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

22,874

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

21,704

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

10,157

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,054

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,899

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,311

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,596

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,514

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,054

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,721

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,582

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

12,672

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,810

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,616

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,483

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

446

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

424

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,422

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,531

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,402

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

100

 

3/14/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

28,989

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

8,717

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

8,270

 

3/14/2014

 

$

52.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,705

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

123

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,584

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

28,104

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

515

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

19,216

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,920

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

90

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,364

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

501

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

343

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,390

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

117

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,058

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,311

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

28,341

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

520

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

19,378

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

38,291

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

708

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

26,181

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,143

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

94

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,516

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,695

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

49

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,843

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,699

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

86

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,213

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,584

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

120

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,501

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

716

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

13

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

490

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,361

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

80

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,982

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

15,056

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.28

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

276

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.31

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

10,294

 

3/17/2014

 

$

53.29

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,304

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,039

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

5,467

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

8,549

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

957

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,496

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

97

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

152

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,243

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,360

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

583

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,513

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,621

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,454

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

11,653

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,000

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,564

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

524

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

820

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

914

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,429

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,280

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,002

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

139

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

218

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

848

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,326

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,929

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.67

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,580

 

3/18/2014

 

$

53.68

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,005

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,902

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,042

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

8,403

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

7,971

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

12,749

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,471

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,395

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,232

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

150

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

142

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

227

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,910

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,812

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,899

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,474

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,039

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

12,857

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

11,451

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

10,864

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

17,370

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,538

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,459

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,333

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

806

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

764

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,223

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,405

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,332

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,131

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,968

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,867

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,987

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

214

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

203

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

325

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,304

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,237

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,979

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,501

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.74

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,270

 

3/19/2014

 

$

53.97

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,830

 

3/19/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,914

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

9,605

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

12,215

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

40,257

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,139

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,049

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

218

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

719

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,777

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,154

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

12,318

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

40,596

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

16,642

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

54,825

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,235

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,368

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,172

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,862

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,042

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,732

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,862

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,432

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

311

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,027

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,896

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,249

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,544

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.04

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

21,567

 

3/20/2014

 

$

54.11

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

352

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

11,152

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,475

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

46,735

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

258

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,185

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

26

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

837

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

336

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,439

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,188

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,487

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

47,131

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,008

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

63,626

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

269

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,556

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

142

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,485

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

246

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,817

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

346

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

10,950

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

37

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,196

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

228

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,256

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

790

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.18

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

25,038

 

3/21/2014

 

$

54.33

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,221

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

5,007

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

896

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

90

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,131

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,528

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,801

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

948

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

473

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

852

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,193

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

158

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

794

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,908

 

4/7/2014

 

$

53.41

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

359

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,689

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,553

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,477

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

15,150

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

10,483

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

264

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,710

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,875

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

26

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

273

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

189

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

333

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,421

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,367

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,926

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

19,752

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

13,667

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,603

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

26,636

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

18,432

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

279

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,868

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,984

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

139

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,431

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

990

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

251

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,576

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,782

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

352

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,611

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,498

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

46

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

478

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

331

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

234

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,401

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,661

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

858

 

4/14/2014

 

$

53.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

8,799

 

4/14/2014

 

$

54.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,088

 

4/14/2014

 

$

52.93

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,344

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,150

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

983

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

13,731

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,722

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,038

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,456

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

844

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

722

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

247

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

85

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

72

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,100

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,066

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

638

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

273

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

17,902

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,156

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,264

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

24,143

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,306

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,105

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,599

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

894

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

764

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,297

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

446

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

381

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,335

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

803

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

686

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,272

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,125

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

962

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

433

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

149

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

127

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,176

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

748

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

640

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

7,975

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.08

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,742

 

4/15/2014

 

$

54.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,345

 

4/15/2014

 

$

53.63

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

7,040

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,401

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,989

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

539

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

28,905

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

18,071

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

12,276

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,214

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,172

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,233

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,196

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

396

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

522

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

326

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

221

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

39

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,527

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,081

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,940

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

832

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

349

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

150

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

37,684

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

23,560

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

16,004

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,886

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

50,809

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

31,768

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

21,584

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,899

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,472

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,421

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,324

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

419

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,730

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,707

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,159

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

209

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,915

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,073

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,087

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

376

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,889

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,307

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,926

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

527

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

913

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

571

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

387

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

69

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,581

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,864

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,945

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

350

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

16,787

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.81

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

10,495

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.82

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

7,130

 

4/16/2014

 

$

54.56

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,285

 

4/16/2014

 

$

55.27

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,358

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,571

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,967

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

26,108

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

14,661

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

8,076

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,671

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,623

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,445

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

471

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

264

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

145

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,895

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,311

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,276

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

547

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

34,037

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

19,114

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

10,529

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

45,891

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

25,774

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

14,200

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,943

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,776

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,529

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,466

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,385

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

763

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,440

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,493

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,373

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,222

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,494

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,925

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

825

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

463

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

255

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,138

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,324

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,280

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

15,163

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.10

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

8,515

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.14

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,690

 

4/17/2014

 

$

55.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

393

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,627

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,723

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

8,694

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,615

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

27,208

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

15,288

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

35,698

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

289

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,868

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,735

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,387

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

29

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

491

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

276

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

645

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

364

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,144

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,452

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,643

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,418

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,105

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

35,472

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

19,932

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

46,540

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,844

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

47,824

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

26,876

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

62,745

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

305

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,151

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,894

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,759

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

152

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,570

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,444

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,372

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

274

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,627

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,600

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,071

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

385

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,485

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,644

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,509

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

51

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

860

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

483

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,128

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

256

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

4,313

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,423

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,658

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

938

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.12

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

15,802

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.03

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

8,879

 

4/21/2014

 

$

55.98

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

20,733

 

4/21/2014

 

$

56.01

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,744

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

393

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

11,269

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,615

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,016

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

289

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

203

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

29

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,545

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

255

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.87

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

109

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

14,692

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,105

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

19,812

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,844

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,134

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

305

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,064

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

152

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,916

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

274

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,686

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

385

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

356

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

51

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,786

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

256

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,545

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.86

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

938

 

4/22/2014

 

$

56.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,931

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

1,377

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

107

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

19,672

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

9,557

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

12,036

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

5,653

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

441

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

80,767

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

39,240

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,153

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,011

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

79

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

14,453

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,022

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

217

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

102

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,461

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

709

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,718

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,276

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

99

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

12,768

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,472

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

8,862

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

15,691

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,370

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

576

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

105,296

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

51,158

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

21,156

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,942

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

784

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

141,931

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

68,961

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,279

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,070

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

83

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

15,293

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,430

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,137

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

534

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

41

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,631

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

3,708

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,047

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

961

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

75

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

13,738

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,674

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,868

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,347

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

105

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

19,251

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

9,353

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

380

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

178

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

13

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,554

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,240

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,908

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

896

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

70

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

12,803

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

6,220

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

6,990

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

3,283

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.50

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

256

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

46,910

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.91

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

22,791

 

4/23/2014

 

$

57.94

 

Open Market

 

 


 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,381

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

234

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

983

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

9,777

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

961

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

4,038

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,749

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

171

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Coast Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

722

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

177

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

17

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Fund Partners, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

73

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,208

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

217

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

638

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors IX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

274

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

12,746

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,252

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund I, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

5,264

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

17,184

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,694

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors Mid-Cap Fund II, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

7,103

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,851

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

181

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

764

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

924

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

90

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XVI, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

381

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,663

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

163

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XX, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

686

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

2,330

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

229

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIII, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

962

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

309

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

30

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors XXIV, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

127

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

1,550

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

152

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

RH Fund 1, L.P.

 

Purchase

 

640

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

5,678

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.99

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

558

 

4/24/2014

 

$

58.00

 

Open Market

 

Relational Investors LLC

 

Purchase

 

2,345

 

4/24/2014

 

$

57.88

 

Open Market

 

 

 EX-99.B 3 a14-10902_1ex99db.htm EXHIBIT B

Exhibit B

 

JOINT FILING AGREEMENT

In accordance with Rule 13d-l(k) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, the persons named below agree to the joint filing on behalf of each of them of a statement on Schedule 13D (including amendments thereto) with respect to the common stock, $0.01 par value, of Clean Harbors, Inc. and further agree that this Joint Filing Agreement be included as an Exhibit to such joint filing.  In evidence thereof, the undersigned hereby execute this Agreement this 24th day of April, 2014.

 

RELATIONAL INVESTORS MID-CAP FUND I, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS MID-CAP FUND II, L.P.
RELATIONAL FUND PARTNERS, L.P.
RELATIONAL COAST PARTNERS, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS IX, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XV, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XVI, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XX, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XXIII, L.P.
RELATIONAL INVESTORS XXIV, L.P.

RH FUND 1, L.P.

 

By:

RELATIONAL INVESTORS, LLC

 

as general partner to each,

 

By:

/s/ Ralph V. Whitworth

 

 

 

Ralph V. Whitworth, Principal

 

 

 

 

 

RELATIONAL INVESTORS, LLC

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

By:

/s/ Ralph V. Whitworth

 

 

 

Ralph V. Whitworth, Principal

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

/s/ Ralph V. Whitworth

 

 

 

Ralph V. Whitworth

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

/s/ David H. Batchelder

 

 

 

David H. Batchelder